BodyBoard of Supervisors
MeetingRegular Meeting
Date📅 July 7, 2026

UnGovr Transcript

iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.
  1. PendingQueued for transcription.
  2. AIYou are hereAuto-transcribed and summarized; not yet human-verified.
  3. VerifiedReviewed and corrected by a person.

0:01 – 0:098 turns

Pledge of Allegianceceremonial · click to expand
UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role0:02

One, two, three. Okay good morning everyone and welcome back from 4th of July holiday we want to welcome you to our regularly scheduled meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors today as you know is Tuesday July the 7th 2026 and we take note that a quorum of the board is present the chief executive officer county council executive officer and the sergeant at arms are all here to assist We will now start the county's land acknowledgement.

The County of Los Angeles recognizes that we occupy land originally and still inhabited and cared for by the Tongva, to Taviam, Serrano, Quiche and Chumash peoples. We honor and pay respect to their elders and descendants past present and emerging as they continue their stewardship of these lands and waters we acknowledge that settler colonization resulted in land seizure disease subjugation slavery relocation broken promises genocide and multi-generational trauma this acknowledgement demonstrates our responsibility and commitment to truth healing and reconciliation, and to elevating the stories culture and community of the original inhabitants of Los Angeles County. We are grateful to have the opportunity to live and work on these ancestral lands We are dedicated to growing and sustaining

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role1:32

relationships with Native peoples and local tribal governments, including in no particular order. Fernandeno Tataviam Band of Mission Indians, Gabrielino Tongva Indians of California Tribal Council, Gabrioleno Tongva San Gabriel Band of Mission Indians, Gabrielenio Band of Mission Indians Kish Nation, To learn more about the First Peoples of Los Angeles County, please visit the Los Angeles City-County Native American Indian Commission website at lanaic.lacounty.gov Thank you. And with that, this morning's invocation will be led by our very own Nicole Lee from the Executive Office followed by the Pledge of Allegiance which will be led by Arturo Garcia Ayala former E-Force Specialist United States Army from the 4th District. If you are able please join us and stand.

not transcribed≈18s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role2:48

Good morning. Our Heavenly Father, we ask your blessing upon this Board of Supervisors today. We pray that all of the many decisions made today are with your guidance and blessing. We pray that a greater understanding of the problems of county government by the citizens of this county will result from this meeting. We ask these things in thy name. Amen.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role3:09

Thank you. Pledge of Allegiance.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed3:14

Good morning. Please face the flag. Place your right hand over your heart. If you're a veteran, you may render a hand salute and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance.

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed4:00

Thank you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure for me today to welcome and honor and thank Arturo Garcia Ayala, a United States Army veteran for leading us in the Pledge of Allegiance this morning. Please give him another round of applause. I missed it. Did they thank you? Did they applaud? Okay, okay. I missed it. Arturo proudly served our nation from 2002 to 2009 as an infantry rifleman with the 4th Brigade, 10th Mountain Division and completed deployments in both Afghanistan and Iraq. During his service, Arturo earned numerous military honors including the Combat Infantry Badge, the Army Achievement Medal, the Army Good Conduct Medal And campaign medals for both Afghanistan and Iraq. Look at the medals that he is displaying on his jacket, very impressive.

And today Arturo continues to serve our community as a professional photographer. He has documented countless events and celebrations throughout San Pedro preserving the stories and memories that make our community so special. Arturo is also an ambassador for our San Pedro Chamber of Commerce and serves as the Veterans Liaison for the Korean Bell of Friendship, continuing his lifelong commitment to bringing people together and serving our community. Thank you, Arturo, for your service to our country, your continued dedication to the Harbor Area, and for joining us today to lead us in our Pledge of Allegiance. We are grateful for all that you do And on behalf of my colleagues here in the board, we wanted to give you this County of Los Angeles Certificate of Appreciation for joining us today.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed6:13

All right, today June gloom is over and the dog days of summer are here. I want you all to meet Dinky a 10-month old Cane Corso boxer mix who was transferred from Palmdale to Agora in May and whereas Dinky is not dinky so you will He's coming, but believe me he will not. He's not dinky. But while he's walking in I just want to remind people I mean the Palmdale and Antelope Valley Lancaster seem to be where we're getting a lot of the dogs from and I'm really focused on spay and neuter But this is Dinky. He is very, very playful do not let his size fool you and do not be intimidated by him because he actually doesn't realize just how big he is and is the sweetest dog sits will shake hands And he is a helper dog at the shelter. He's a dog that they use to determine the temperament of other dogs that are brought in, and he gets along with everybody.

When he's not romping around the play yard, he's contempt cuddling by your side. He thinks he is a lapdog but he is definitely a keeper for someone Yeah, but he does get along with other dogs and again is the helper dog at Agoura right now. So when they have new dogs, he kind of figures out their temperament and welcomes them to the shelter. If you want to adopt Dinky, you can call the Agoura Care Center at 818-991-0071 to make Dinky yours. And again, sweetest, sweetest dog with a great temperament So please, if you will know this one really all of them but this one especially and then his coloring is tortoise shell. He's just absolutely a beautiful dog And now, please turn your attention to the screen for our pet from Palmdale.

Meet Blackie. He's half German Shepherd, half Alaskan Husky and 100% the social butterfly up in the Antelope Valley. This two-year-old pup has a great personality and really enjoys meeting new people. He loves playtime, the outdoors and most of all getting attention. Call the Palmdale Care Center at 661-575-2888 to make Blackie one of your new best friends. And there is a promotion still going on. The Dog Days of Summer Promotion is happening until July 31st.

Adoption fees are waived for all dogs at all seven care centers. Visit animalcare.lacounty.gov to find the one for you. Thank you, Madam Chair. And thank you, Dinky.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role9:00

All right. Thank you. Yeah. Executive Officer, please call the agenda.

0:09 – 0:154 turns

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction9:07

Good morning Madam Chair, members of the board. Today's agenda will begin on page 2 consent calendar Board of Supervisors items 1 through 8. On item 4 supervisor Solis requests that this item be held also this includes a revision as indicated on the supplemental agenda. On item 6 this includes a revision as indicated on the supplemental agenda. On item 7 supervisor Mitchell request that this item be held. On Item 8 supervisor Horvath would like to revise her motion to add supervisor Barger as co-author On page 10, administrative matters items 9 through 44. On item nine, Supervisor Mitchell requests that this item be revised to remove recommendation numbers 4 and 5. On items 23 and 24 on the motion to approve these items the board finds that the amendments further the purposes of chapter 2.190 of the Los Angeles County Code.

On page 32 special district agenda this is the agenda for the meeting of the Los Angeles County Development Authority items 1D through 3D On page 35, notice is a closed session item CS1 through CS5. On item CS1 this item was taken off calendar as indicated on the supplemental agenda. On item CS2 County Council requests that one case be continued one week to July 14th 2026 also this includes a revision as indicated on the supplemental agenda. On item CS5 this is an addition as indicated on the supplemental agenda On page 38, items continued from previous meetings for further discussion and action by the board. Item A1. On item A1, Supervisor Solis requests that this item be held.

The request for continuance revisions and items taken off calendar through A1 are before you. That completes the reading of the agenda Madam Chair.

Roll-call vote Moved by Lindsey P. Horvath · Seconded by Holly J. Mitchell
Show transcript
Thank you. Moved by Supervisor Horvath, seconded by Supervisor Mitchell to approve the items. That will be the order. Executive Officer, play the Code of Conduct please.
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed10:55

Ladies and gentlemen, may I please have your attention. The meeting of the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors is about to commence. A code of conduct will now be read and we request that you comply with it to ensure the efficient administration of the meeting. Members of the public, it is your right to participate in today's board hearing and the Board encourages such participation. However, the right of the public to address the Board must be balanced with the need to ensure that public comment does not interfere with the orderly course of the Board's business.

All are reminded to abide by the following rules. Speakers must cease speaking immediately when their time has ended. Public comment on agenda items must relate to the subject matter of that item. General public comment is limited to subjects within the jurisdiction of the board. Public comment does not include the right to engage in a dialogue with board members or staff.

Please remain respectful of the forum and refrain from uttering, writing or displaying profane, personal, threatening, derogatory, demeaning or other abusive statements toward the board, any member thereof, staff or any other person. Members of the audience should be respectful of the views expressed by speakers, staff and board members and may not clap, cheer, whistle or otherwise disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting.

Any person engaging in conduct that disrupts the meeting is subject to being removed from the board meeting. And finally, if you witness conduct or behavior by other members of the public that disrupts your ability to remain engaged or participate in this meeting, please notify the sergeant at arms or other county staff. Thank you for your cooperation.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role12:58

And with that, today's meeting order will be the following. Public comment on items not held for discussion by the board including closed session matters followed by items four and seven then item A1 followed by general public comment and finishing up with closed session. Before we begin executive officer call please read the calling information and explain the speaking rules thank you

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction13:22

Good morning members of the public. If you wish to participate in public comment, you may do so in person or remotely. To participate remotely please visit our website at www.bos.lacounty.gov. To register and join the meeting or you may call 213-306-3065 and use access code 25342241284 and meeting password 2672026 You will have the opportunity to address the board throughout the meeting. For items not held by the board, you will receive one minute for one item and up to two minutes for two or more items. For items held by supervisors, you will have one minute to address the board and one minute to address the board on general public comment for a total of up to six minutes. When it is your turn to speak if registered on a computer or device, you will hear a beep and your name will be called.

Or, if joining by telephone you will hear your line is unmuted. Your area code and the last two digits of your phone number will be called. To ensure we hear from both in-person and remote speakers we will alternate between the two speaking cues. Members of the public who are in attendance when you hear or see your name displayed on the screen please come down to the front of the boardroom and staff will assist you. Please do not approach the podium until directed to do so. Also, for members of the public in attendance please note that we have a constituent assistance team that includes representatives from the Department of Mental Health, Public Social Services, Children and Family Services, LA Homeless Services Authority and Parks and Recreation in the audience should you need assistance from them.

At this time, we will hear from members of the public wishing to address the board on all items not held for discussion by supervisors including closed session matters. The consent items will be acted upon with one motion. For members of the public joining us remotely, to comment on these items please use the raise hand feature if you're online or press star 3 if on a telephone. Please indicate the agenda item numbers that you wish to address in the beginning of your comment for us to allocate the appropriate amount of time.

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

0:15 – 0:2015 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed15:22

We will now call in-person speakers and while they are coming forward we will take remote speakers. This will be for all items not held by the board for discussion and closed session items. Cipriano Belser, Dana Coffey, Victor Tobar, Alcalina Soriano Verosa, Zachary Belsky, Cynthia Ayala, Brianna Maldona, Traz Koh please come forward. Arturo Garcia TNC your line is now unmuted please begin

PresenterArturo Garcianature Conservancy Thank you for the opportunity to express support for the motiProposedself-stated15:53

Good morning. Can you hear me?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed15:55

Yes, please begin

PresenterArturo Garcianature Conservancy Thank you for the opportunity to express support for the motiProposedself-stated15:57

excellent dear cherished Lisa numbers the board. My name is Arturo Garcia and on behalf of the nature Conservancy Thank you for the opportunity to express support for the motion proclaiming July 2026 as parks make life better month as an organization dedicated to conserving the lands and waters upon which all life depends we see every day how parks provide far more than recreation.

Parks connect people with nature, improve community health and well-being, strengthen climate resilience and service critical gathering spaces during times of need. This motion appropriately recognizes the extraordinary role LA County Parks play in supporting residents not only through outdoor recreation and environmental stewardship but also through emergency response youth programming food assistance and community recovery efforts These services are especially important in ensuring that all residents regardless of zip code have access to safe welcoming public spaces.

We commend Chair Solis and the Department of Park and Recreation for highlighting the essential role parks play in both the good times and the hard times, and for their continued commitment to Los Angeles County communities. Thank you for your leadership.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed16:55

Thank you. Elizabeth Decarteret your line is unmuted please begin. Hi, yes can you hear me? Yes please begin.

CommentElizabeth Dicartere ThankProposedself-stated17:03

Okay thank you good morning Chair and Supervisors I'm speaking in opposition of item number four my name is Elizabeth Dicartere

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed17:11

Item 4 is being held for discussion you can get back in queue and have public comment when that item's discussed

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed17:19

Thank You Ben Reynoso your line is unmuted please begin

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed17:25

Hi, and thank you board for bringing forward item number 6. This is to permanently or secure funding for permanently funding the public health councils program as many of you know in some of the audience who may not. The public health councils program was created in partnership with the Department of Public Health and certified worker organizations back at the height of the pandemic in order to respond to the COVID-19 emergency.

Um, it has gone way beyond that. Now we started off with 5 industries being represented frontline essential grocery restaurants etcetera warehousing people who didn't get the opportunity to take work off and now fast forward we have 12 organizations 12 unique or not totalizations but on 12 unique sectors that are being served. And all of our friends and colleagues are here in the audience today, but I just wanted to thank the board for bringing this item forward. The infrastructure that's been created in partnership with Department of Public Health through the Office of Worker Health and Safety in partnership with the CWOs across LA County is invaluable and honestly a shining star for LA County and worker health and safety.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed18:27

Thank you David Diaz your line isn't muted please begin.

PresenterDavid DiazActive San Gabriel ValleyProposedself-stated18:33

Hi, good morning. My name is David Diaz. I'm the Executive Director of Active San Gabriel Valley. We're an environmental justice and public health non-profit headquartered in East Johnston County. We're calling to thank Supervisor Solis for putting forward the motion proclaiming July as Parks Make Life Better Month at LA County. As Executive Director of Active San Gabriel Valley, volunteer coach, and a parent of two kids under seven years old, I couldn't agree more that parks make life better and play such a vital role in well-being connection I want to give a big shout out to all the folks working at the Los Angeles County Parks and Recreation Department, and to Director Norma Garcia-Gonzalez for her leadership. Thank you again to Supervisors Feliz for putting this motion forward.

Thank you for your time and attention. Have a great week!

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed19:19

Thank you. Roy Humphries, your line is unmuted. Please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed19:25

Yes just a short and sweet here that the I believe it's item 8 on the child issues in your, the county's endeavors and expenditure on the child trafficking etc is abysmal and disgraceful disgusting. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed19:47

Thank You Claudia Cuadrino your line is unmuted please begin

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed19:55

Hi, good morning. My name is Claudia, Program Manager at the Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust. Our role as a non-profit is creating and stewarding parks and green spaces across LA County. So on behalf of LANLT we want to thank Supervisor Solis for introducing motion number three to recognize parks as essential public infrastructure not just amenities. Our parks are climate infrastructure cooling neighborhoods that face the worst heat Thank you.

not transcribed≈26s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

0:20 – 0:2813 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed20:50

Romeo Hebron, your line is unmuted. Please state the items you're speaking on and begin.

PresenterRomeo Hebronwith the Filipino Migrant Center based in Long BeachProposedself-stated20:57

Good morning board I'm speaking on item six my name is Romeo Hebron executive director with the Filipino Migrant Center based in Long Beach. The Public Health Council's program has had an immense impact in being able to reach workers early on during the pandemic as well as beyond in recent years Most recently, we've been able to help residential care facility workers, caregivers fight a 2.3 and get and win a $2.3 million citation against their employer who was stealing their wages. We've also been helping trafficked caregivers as well in Lancaster, which ultimately led to the shutdown of the recruitment agency. And then most importantly or lastly this program has also helped us not just build other connections with worker centers but also build stronger and deeper relationships with LA County Department of Public Health and other county departments.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed21:55

Thank you. Mary Nguyen, please state your name and the items you're speaking on and begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed22:03

Hi, this is Mary Nguyen. I'm from the California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative and I am the Policy and Research Manager at the California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative which works with the Vietnamese licensed manicurists across California to support their safety health and livelihood in the workforce and their community. I am speaking on agenda item number six I would like to take a moment and ask the Board of Supervisors to continue Public Health Council program because it has supported our workers through COVID-19 and through the wildfires that happened in past year. We have been able to provide educational workshops and outreach as well as PPE for our members, especially in language So that they are aware of their rights and know how to advocate for themselves.

And also be protected and supported in the community, thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed23:00

Thank you. Speaker with phone number 3233 ending in 42, please state your name and the agenda item you're speaking on and begin.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated23:12

Hi good morning my name is Amy I'm speaking on Item 6. I'm representing Edevska, a local worker center organization that works with day laborers and domestic workers. I'm also here in support of Supervisor Solis' request to find sustainable funding for the Public Health Council program which is led by L.A County's Public Health. So for Edevska this program has allowed us to have continued educational program and direct health services at our several day labor centers that are Throughout the city of L.A., through this program, we've also been able to provide pertinent health education to domestic workers on a monthly basis and this approach has allowed local CBO's to continue to partner with the local public health department to continue providing timely education and resources for these workers like vaccine clinics and outreach in burn zones.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed24:04

Thank you. Daisy Gonzalez your line is unmuted please state the agenda item you're speaking on and begin Hi, can you hear me? Yes. Please begin.

PresenterDaisy Gonzalez I'mGarment Workers CenterProposedself-stated24:14

Hi my name is Daisy Gonzalez I'm with the Garment Workers Center. GWC organizes LA's apparel workers in an industry of over 30,000 workers and it's also an industry known for high rates of public health violations We're a proud participant in the PHC program, and the PHC program is an innovative model for enforcement. It empowers low-wage workers recognizing them as subjects matter experts to identify and address workplace hazards and violations through training, uh, to be able to form worker councils for peer support and to file complaints with environment.

Through this program, GDBC reached over 406 factories and formed 22 public health councils This is an infrastructure and frontline that has been applied during COVID wildfires and federal enforcement in immigrant communities. The PHC program has been addressing enforcement gaps and helping employers come into compliance, and we urge the board to approve the two.

Near the program

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed25:14

thank you Madam Chair there are no other remote speakers to address the board or remote participation for these items is now concluded. We will go to in person speakers please begin

PresenterCipriano Belserthe Southern California Coalition for Occupational Safety and HealthProposedself-stated25:23

good morning esteemed My name is Cipriano Belser. I'm the co-executive director of the Southern California Coalition for Occupational Safety and Health, and I'm here to speak to item six. I first want to thank Supervisor Solis' office for putting this motion forward. Um...I'm here to support the continued and permanent funding for the L.A. County Public Health Council's program. I've worked on this program since its inception, and have seen something truly unique and powerful develop over these last five years, um, that being the partnership between frontline workers, worker advocates, These relationships are unheard of elsewhere.

And they've enabled fast, effective responses to protect our county from many threats that have happened to public health. It would be a devastating blow for the county's ability to support hard-to-reach working people if this program is allowed to sunset. So we urge the supervisors to identify funding to keep this program alive. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed26:17

Thank you. Next speaker please?

PresenterVictor TobarWorker Empowerment Community NetworkProposedself-stated26:19

Hello, good morning Supervisors. My name is Victor Tobar and I'm here to speak on behalf of the Worker Empowerment Community Network. Item 6 as you guys have all heard we're all advocating here for permanent funding on the PHC program. You've heard it from all different industries. We serve the restaurant industry but the PHC program has been able to connect a full network to all frontline workers, not just the restaurant workers that we've been able to provide in time resources and much needed help to those communities that were not able to take breaks during pandemics and during the wildfires. So we do ask that you consider permanently funding the program to allow us to continue to bring this support to those communities in need. Thank you.

PresenterDana Coffey I'mLOSH that's the Labor Occupational Safety and Health Program UCLAProposedself-stated27:09

Thank you, next speaker please. Good morning my name is Dana Coffey I'm associate director of LOSH that's the Labor Occupational Safety and Health Program UCLA. I'm here to comment on item six that's permanent funding for the public health councils since the Public Health Councils inception LOSH has served as a training and technical assistance provider to support the DPH and the community worker organizations We've seen the evolution of the program from the response to COVID-19 to a wide range of public health issues in the workplace.

And in addition to its many accomplishments, the Public Health Council's program has become well known among public health practitioners nationwide. It is the gold standard for how to do meaningful engagement between public health departments and workers and community based orgs. I commend the Board of Supervisors for seeing the vision and investing in this program for several years. And, I simply wanted to offer this context and perspective as you consider future funding. Thank you.

0:28 – 0:3821 turns

PresenterAkilina Soriano-Versosthe Filipino Workers CenterProposedself-stated28:13

Hi, my name is Akilina Soriano-Versos. I'm the Executive Director of the Filipino Workers Center. Good morning and thank you. I am speaking on Item 6 in support of the Public Health Council's further funding. The Filipino Workers Center has been a part of the Public Health Council since the beginning of the program. It's really established critical infrastructure that both gets More quickly and effectively the resources from the county to essential workers, but also has really informed the Department of Public Health about things that are happening on the ground. And it's really important. The health of the workers is also really critical for the health of the public. because they also have critical experiences that are helping to keep everyone safe.

For example, in the restaurants and in food packing and in residential care facilities those are the industries that PwC had been reaching out to and we have been able to vaccinate so many more people to keep everyone.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed29:14

Thank you next speaker please

CommentCynthia AyalaProposedself-stated29:16

Good morning esteemed board members. My name is Cynthia Ayala, I will be speaking on item six today this morning. I would like to thank you for giving us the opportunity to speak today and also to our organizations and our colleagues on this matter basically what we spoke on last couple weeks ago it's very important for us to continue the PHC program it's flourished immensely from the beginning from COVID And as we see right now with the wildfires and what's going on with factories burning down and folks getting in the midst of their lungs being affected, I believe in this program immensely how we talk to workers one-on-one daily. I'm an organizer that goes into these stores and folks that are from undocumented families and they do not know their rights from the workplace or in the state of California as well so we inform them every day.

We go in With our hearts full and our minds full as well to speak on for them and help them out in these events. And so we really hope you take this in consideration to continue the funding for this wonderful

PresenterBrianna MaldonadoLos Angeles Alliance for a New Economy and I am here today to strongly support sProposedself-stated30:18

Thank you, next speaker please. Good morning my name is Brianna Maldonado and I'm a community organizer with the Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy and I am here today to strongly support sustainable and permanent funding for the PHC or Public Health Council's program. I come today as an organizer but I was here five years ago drawing stick figures outside of this office because I myself knew as a worker that this was essential for people like us Every day our team is on the ground talking to non-union grocery and retail workers throughout LA County. Through our conversations it is clear that low wage and essential workers bear the heaviest burdens, not just from unfair labor practices but from the severe public health and environmental hazards Whether it's navigating workplace violence due to immigration raids, harassment from employers, cuts from federal funding impacting their Medi-Cal, respiratory threats or even the recent Boyle Heights fire.

These workers are on the front lines. I urge you to permanently secure funding to protect our essential workforce. Thank you.

PresenterZachary BilskiNorth Hollywood Neighborhood CouncilProposedself-stated31:21

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Zachary Bilski here today on behalf of the North Hollywood Neighborhood Council. I just want to thank you all for this opportunity. I do want to stand in agreement with Ms. Salas regarding item number three, parks absolutely make life better. That's what I'm here to discuss today regarding the Alexandria Park Tiny Home Village. I know y'all can't see this but it is located within North Hollywood's Valley Plaza The initiative is known as Hope of the Wall. It is a beautification project.

What we would like to see, we want to propose a beautification project for the area including the residents of the tiny home villages. We want to start with litter cleanup and by doing that we would launch litter removal days so how do we get the residents involved in something like that? Throughout the year, you guys know that there are special holidays like World Heart Day, International Overdose Awareness Day. These are great days to take advantage of and get the residents to be a part of something along with the community. Then we clean up and we commemorate the day with what you're looking at here.

PresenterTraz KoAPAITProposedself-stated32:23

Thank you. Next

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed32:24

speaker

PresenterTraz KoAPAITProposedself-stated32:25

please. Hi everyone, my name is Traz Ko. I am representing APAIT, a non-profit organization based in Los Angeles. Thank you so much Supervisor Solis for putting this on the agenda and I appreciate Department of Health for all the support that we've been getting. As a frontline outreach worker, we've been providing essential services for community members of different backgrounds from providing immigration relief and legal aid to distributing hygiene kits in food and water for unhoused people of LA. We need this funding to be able to sustain our services. My outreach specifically are for Chinese massage parlor workers the discrimination aggression and violence that they face is concerning to say the least and horrifying at most Our service have been able to find them resources such as therapy, health care, food resources and more.

Now more than ever we need the support of this board by way of advocating for our continued funding to be able to continue these vital resources for the most vulnerable. Thank you next speaker please

PresenterLisa Futhe California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative and I'm also here to speak aboutProposedself-stated33:29

Hi, good morning. My name is Lisa Fu. I'm Executive Director of the California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative and I'm also here to speak about the promise and importance of the Public Health Council Program. We work with the Vietnamese nail salon workforce in LA County who are 80% immigrant and refugee women and low-wage workers And LA County has the highest number of nail salons and nail salon workers in the whole entire country. And throughout Public Health Council program, we've actually developed a unique model of working with nail salons as hubs. And so they reach out and re-share out the information that we're sharing with them. So reaching hundreds of workers and nail salon owners throughout every month During the height of the pandemic we were the only organization in the state, in the country providing in-language support and information specifically for nail salons in Vietnamese.

We were the trusted point of information and contact through the work that we've done with PHC with COVID.

PresenterSally GarciaSan Gabriel and Lower Los Angeles Rivers & Mounds Conservancy or RMCProposedself-stated34:31

Thank

PresenterLisa Futhe California Healthy Nail Salon Collaborative and I'm also here to speak aboutProposedself-stated34:31

you next speaker

PresenterSally GarciaSan Gabriel and Lower Los Angeles Rivers & Mounds Conservancy or RMCProposedself-stated34:32

please Good morning Supervisors. My name is Sally Garcia, Deputy Executive Officer with the San Gabriel and Lower Los Angeles Rivers & Mounds Conservancy or RMC. And we strongly support item 3 designating July 2026 as Parks Make Lives Better Month As an agency dedicated to expanding open space, watershed health and low-impact recreation across Los Angeles County we know firsthand that parks are not just amenities.

They are essential public infrastructure for health climate resilience and community well-being. We thank the board for its continued leadership in prioritizing equitable access to nature, and we look forward to working alongside county to ensure all of our communities can thrive in safe, vibrant outdoor spaces this July and all year long. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed35:22

Thank you.

PresenterSally GarciaSan Gabriel and Lower Los Angeles Rivers & Mounds Conservancy or RMCProposedself-stated35:23

Next

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed35:23

speaker please?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed35:25

Good morning, Chichi Navarro from the TransLatina Coalition. I will be speaking on items six, five, and 13. So on item six, the program protects low-wage workers in garment warehouse food and restaurant industries by training them to monitor workplace health and safety and shielding them from retaliation. I'm raising this because transgender gender nonconforming and intersex workers are disproportionately pushed into precisely these low wage precarious industries due to well documented employment discrimination many TGI workers can't safely report unsafe conditions through formal HR channels Because doing so risks exposing their identity to a hostile employer or losing a job that they can't easily replace.

A worker-led model with strong anti-retaliation protections is exactly the type As you identify the 2.3 million in ongoing funding, I'm asking that the board to ensure public health council trainings include explicit guidance on protecting LGBTQ plus and TGI workers from retaliation tied to their identity, not just their health and safety reports. Transgender, gender non-conforming and intersex people experience intimate partner violence at significantly higher rates than the general population. Yet we are consistently underserved by mainstream systems, turned away from shelters, misgendered by providers or met with the services that simply weren't designed with us in mind. As you expand prevention efforts and reconsider how the Domestic Violence Council is structured, I'm asking the board to explicitly ensure that TGI survivors are named, counted and served.

That means TGI inclusive data collection, culturally competent training for providers and safe appropriate shelter access. Item 13 in particular removes a formerly recognized oversight body as DPH develops a new model please make sure that whatever replaces it does not lose the thread on TGI specific needs thank you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed37:15

Thank you. Next speaker, please.

PresenterLee Wallachlittle organization in PalmsProposedself-stated37:18

Hello. I could not more enthusiastically endorse July as Parks Month. I'm Lee Wallach. I am the director of a little organization in Palms, California. It's wonderful, wonderful little area and in large part to little things that you folks have done. We manage our farmers market, our community gardens. Pick up the trash, all kinds of programs. Because of this body we have a community garden. We have a garden at local school. We have all kinds of gardens around Palms. It changes our lives since before COVID which seems so long ago, we only had little Woodbine Park. You folks really changed that for us. I encourage you to do more, more creativity push LA as USD to have co-sponsored parks in our city

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed38:20

Thank you. Thank you. That concludes our time for public comment on these items.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role38:27

I do want to thank the folks that came out today to speak on behalf of Park. So, I see you we hear you and thank you and also those that came out to speak on behalf of the Public Health Councils it's vitally important that the work continues and I appreciate you coming down today. That's all.

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction38:45

Madam Chair and members of the board, the following items are before you. 1 through 3, 5 and 6, 8 as revised, 9 as revised 10 through 41, 1D through 3D these items are before you

0:38 – 0:5713 turns

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role38:58

Thank you. Moved by Supervisor Hahn, seconded by Supervisor Barger to approve the items with the exceptions noted by the executive officer. Executive Officer please call the roll.

Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 Moved by Janice Hahn · Seconded by Barger Moved by Supervisor Hahn, seconded by Supervisor Barger to approve the items with the exceptions noted by the executive officer. Executive O
Show transcript
Supervisor Mitchell? Aye. Supervisor Mitchell aye. Supervisor Horfath? Aye Supervisor Horfath aye. Supervisor Hahn? Aye Supervisor Hahn aye. Supervisor Barker? Aye Supervisor Barker aye.
CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction39:19

Supervisors Solis? Aye Supervisors Solis? Aye Motion carries we will now

move on to item four advancing a We are pleased to announce that the board of Supervisors is offering a community opportunity to purchase act program for unincorporated Los Angeles County, which was held by supervisor Solis. For members of the public joining us remotely to comment on this item please use Director of Consumer and Business Affairs, Manuel Ruiz. Chief Policy Division Department of Consumer and Business Affairs and Emilio Salas, Executive Director of the Los Angeles County Development Authority are available for questions. For the departmental speakers please state your name and title for the record when you address the board

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role40:01

Thank you, and first of all I want to thank Supervisor Ollie Mitchell for joining me on this very important effort before us. You know advancing a Community Opportunity to Purchase Act known as COPA for the unincorporated Los Angeles County is, I think a sensible approach for a potential also tenant opportunity to purchase act known as TOPA for our future. I want to thank DCBA Director Rafael Carbajal and LACTA director Emilio Salas and all of your teams and county council for helping us move forward with this motion.

I also want to thank other related departments, including our Chief Executive Office and Assessor's office who will be helping us with this important effort. Colleagues we all know That there's a big effort going on right now and an important one in our communities. And that what they're asking us to do is help them secure housing, affordable housing. Just take a look at some of the slides that you'll see before us today.

Colleagues I wanna bring your attention to some slides that were displayed as examples at eight sites across the county of Los Angeles that were purchased through the 2020 Los Angeles County Community Land Trust Partnership. By mission driven entities where affordability is preserved in perpetuity and properties are stewarded by tenants and community. takes it up a notch.

Back in 2021, when the board adopted my first motion to begin exploring ATOPA or COPA, the housing affordability crisis was very intense and we see it continuing today. Unfortunately conditions haven't changed that much or improved since that time housing affordability and in fact that's one of the main discussion items back in DC right now as well as here at our state. The county, as you know is facing rising displacement pressures as rents outpace incomes more than half of renters are rent burdened and you've heard the statistics 38% of homes are renter occupied and Including 9,000 mobile home spaces that are especially vulnerable. With residents representing our African American and Latino households which are most impacted.

Corporate ownership has increased post 2020. I'm sorry, 2008 with larger owners driving higher sale prices, aggressive rent increases and eviction practices. We need to fight and we need to have tools to keep people in their homes. COPA provides a mission driven organization including community land trust and non-profit developers to have a fair chance to buy buildings when they go up for sale. Preserving affordability in perpetuity, preventing that displacement and homelessness and promoting housing stability.

TOPA, if pursued in a future phase would build on the COPA framework by providing tenants and tenant groups with an opportunity to purchase their buildings either directly or in partnership with a qualified nonprofit or community-based housing partner. Back in 2023 DCBA and HRNA advisors released their report with recommendations for a hybrid TOPA and COPA framework Today's motion before us is advancing certain recommendations from that report.

Although a combined TOPA and COPA would be a strong complementary strategy for addressing displacement pressures in the unincorporated areas, my motion also recognizes the county's current budgetary challenges. Colleagues, the idea is to start small. My motion moves forward a thoughtful phased approach starting with an ordinance to implement COPA for unincorporated areas before implementing the TOPA program. And it also starts with the smaller universe of rental properties, specifically properties with five units or more in unincorporated areas. Where we typically see 30 to 130 sale transactions annually. And recognizes that not all transactions will result in COPA purchase, only those that are financially feasible.

The phased approach also allows us to establish foundational systems before evaluating whether and how to add TOPA in the future. A COPA would help households stabilize, prevent displacement and homelessness We've talked about that even before the pandemic. And now I see it as something even more essential with all the fires and displacements happening in the county as well as what we just experienced in East Los Angeles, where people were impacted even in their apartments and housing units because of the Boyle Heights fire. But before finishing my remarks and before I turn to my co-author, I did wanna ask some questions considering some of the comments that my office have received regarding this item. So my first question is for Director Carbajal.

Thank you for being here on your staff. Can you please describe the engagement on the initial study and how you plan to build on that, and what we are now asking you to do today.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed45:41

Good morning Madam Chair and Board of Supervisors. Rafael Carbajal, Director of the Department of Consumer Business Affairs appreciate being part of this conversation as this discussion I'm going to ask Manuel Ruiz my colleague to take the first crack at the question he's been leading his effort since the onset of the initial evaluation

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed45:59

So good morning Supervisors. Manny Ruiz, Chief of the Public Policy Division at the Department of Consumer Business Affairs. As part of our 2023 TOPA assessment report we conducted a very extensive and robust engagement process Collected feedback from stakeholder groups to inform the recommendations that went into the framework. And so this extensive engagement that we conducted really targeted three key stakeholder groups, which included tenant leaders, tenant organizers, community land trusts, nonprofit, community-based organizations, property owners, real estate representatives.

That included also the apartment associations at the state and local level. In addition to affordable housing developers in the region, inclusive again of for profit and non-profit housing developers. And so we invited over 158 representatives from all these stakeholder groups that attended one of five virtual stakeholder sessions where we held two for the tenant advocates. Two for the property owner groups and real estate professionals, and one for the affordable housing developers. And so as part of that engagement process we saw representatives from over 35 different organizations attending which included the California Apartment Association, the Apartment Association of the Greater Los Angeles Area, The Los Angeles Realtor Association, the Marina del Rey Lassiz.

In addition to various community-based organizations such as the LA Tenants Union, Inquilinos Unidos, Trust South LA, Eastside Leeds and community land trusts like the Beverly Vermont Community Land Trusts. Genesis LA, the Coalition for Responsible Community Development Partners etc. So we plan to build on that very robust engagement process that we conducted three or four years ago.

We want to build on the strategies that were outlined in the report from three years ago while really focusing and emphasizing a COPA strategy. So, really focusing on how we will operationalize a COPA for the Los Angeles County region while also looking at other jurisdictions so that we could try to minimize any potential delays to the existing sale process.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed48:17

And I think what we could see is that we undertook a pretty robust process and what we're learning now, and this motion actually acknowledges, is this is an ongoing conversation. Conversations that have happened after the release of the original report, conversations that happened at cluster, conversations that are happening today. This is all information we're going to take back and include as part of the reassessment process.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role48:38

So Rafael, I mentioned earlier the challenges we face budgetarily. What can we leverage? What other sources of funding can we leverage for example La Casa or even the proposed housing bond that's on the November ballot before us? Can you respond to that?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed48:55

Yeah, no thank you for that question. And that's a very important consideration because the real purpose around COPPA is providing a true opportunity to purchase and it's only meaningful if they have the resources to actually act on that opportunity and I think what we're looking at is striking while the opportunity exists in particular where The dollars from Measure A including La Casa, the investments that the county is already making in this space and the interest from philanthropic community to advance some of these efforts. So the reality is when entities come into this opportunity they're already leveraging existing resources and market products that already exist to bring a purchase such as this to fruition We already see that on a regular basis when we see our developers applying for our NOFAs, our affordable housing production opportunities.

Some of the examples that you shared with the CLTs. So this is already an existing resource that's out there and we're just trying to create an opportunity for them to take advantage of trying to purchase some of these properties.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role49:51

Great thank you. And I want to ask Dr. Director Salas but I see as a doctor you're very very Well known in your area. I want to ask you, given that we plan to establish pre-qualified lists of mission driven purchasers what do you see is important to help us in evaluating and selecting those purchases? Thank

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed50:17

you for the question Supervisor Madam Chair. Emilio Salas Executive Director of Los Angeles County Development Authority So we initially want to develop a bench of potential purchasers who we would pre-qualify through an open solicitation. These entities would be nonprofits whose activity centers around preservation and development of affordable housing, and we think it's important that this bench be pre-qualified to make sure that these transactions are successful We will be looking at things like demonstrated experience in the field of affordable housing, their financial capacity to be able to make these transactions, the fact that they're mission-driven and that they have the staffing available to complete these transactions.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role51:03

Thank you. I just want to say that overall the motion has four directives and if I can, I'd like to express them. It directs DCBA and relevant departments to report back in 180 days with a COPA program ordinance including a public education and outreach strategy which I know you're fully aware of, to provide advance notice of any COPA ordinance requirements and compliance. And it directs DCBA and relevant departments to report back in 120 days with the reassessment of the 2023 DCBA and HRNA advisors' report considering certain parameters And it directs our CEO to report back in 180 days on potential funding sources for implementation of the COPA program, and grants delegated authority to DCBA to contract with consultants to carry out those directives.

And colleagues, I would just say in closing as we continue to contend with the housing affordability crisis, COPA is one of those tools in our tool chest that I know will help us decrease the cost of housing and provide relief for some of our most vulnerable residents that we know are here today with us and that we represent in our respective districts. So I would like to ask for your aye vote and let us lift up those low-income renters who in many cases have been living in these dwellings for maybe 30 or even longer years, intergenerational and now may have an opportunity to own the property and create their own assets and wealth. So with that I will turn it over to my co-author. Supervisor Mitchell, thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 15Proposed52:44

Thank you very much Madam Chair and I appreciate you bringing the motion forward and allowing me to co-author it. Thank you for the images in the pictures. For me, I often talk about being a product of Leimert Park. Grew up in a nine unit apartment building ended up at Leimert Park because my parents were redlined out of the jungle And so when I walk around that community or drive through the community today, it's not unincorporated. It's L.A. City. But when I walk through the jungle, a large planned apartment community in the 50s, I am struck by the number of signs that reflect corporate ownership because that was not the case when I was growing up. They were small units often 10, 12 and fewer That were mom and pop owned. Owned in many instances by people of color, and again in my district one of the last significant communities of affordable housing so I appreciate the imaging because that triggered for me my own lived experience.

Again this motion represents a meaningful step in expanding the county's toolbox for housing stability and creating innovative strategies for pathways to ownership. It provides an important tool to combat displacement and housing insecurity for renters in our unincorporated communities. The most important feature of the Community Opportunities to Purchase Act, COPA, the ordinance is the regulatory change that ensures tenants and mission-driven organizations receive notice when a property is offered for voluntary sale.

I'll repeat that, offered for voluntary sale. This notice gives mission-driven organizations the opportunity to purchase rental properties, helping tenants remain in their homes, preserving stability, preventing displacement and keeping residents rooted in their community. So I appreciate both the strong support from renters and tenant advocates for this motion and the serious concern raised by property owners.

This motion is not about taking property, forcing a sale or preventing a sale. It's about creating a fair and transparent process for when an owner chooses to sell while also building the financing and implementation structure needed to make that process work effectively. Our responsibility is to balance housing stability The concerns from property owners regarding the speed of transactions and whether organizations or tenants can move quickly enough are fair.

And that's why I think you've talked about a DCBA along with our county departments and working with the new kid on the block, La Casa who is moving at The speed of light, which is a great thing. That you all are developing the acquisition fund to support community land trust and naturally occurring affordable housing. So this fund will help ensure accessible capital is available to facilitate timely purchases.

In DC and San Francisco, it was the pairing of housing financing tools with COPA policies that gave organizations the speed and certainty they needed to compete. And there are lots of really good examples in those two areas. And so again today's motion proposes building that infrastructure here in our unincorporated communities. TOPA and COPA programs also support aging mom-and-pop landlords who've long maintained affordable rents in our communities, and who would very likely prefer not to have to sell the corporate buyers. These programs create an alternative pathway where they can sell at market rate and keep units affordable and retire if they no longer choose to be property owners.

I've heard two specific issues from property owners and the apartment associations that I would love to see included in the report back. And they include an option where properties are co-listed on the open market while tenants and mission driven organizations simultaneously receive notice of sale And an option where the county is included as one of the eligible purchasing entities. If those options could be looked into and included in report back, I'd appreciate that.

With that, thank you very much for the vision around this motion and bringing COPA to LA County's Unincorporated Communities Supervisor Solis and I'm proud to join you in this motion. Thank you.

0:57 – 1:1223 turns

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role57:44

Thank you, you know the credit goes to the community. To be honest those groups that helped us form this several years ago and I want to thank them and really the trust of the county too for helping us do these piloted programs. And what I have seen personally firsthand from the families has just been incredible because a sense of ownership living in a dwelling that perhaps your family you were born there even can potentially be passed along to your family is something great. That is still part of the American dream, I believe for many of our families. So thank you Supervisor for your comments. Let me go to our other members that want to speak on the item we have Supervisor Barger.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed58:31

Thank you and thank you Supervisors Solis and Supervisor Mitchell for bringing this motion forward. I agree. The goal is I mean we talked about this when we had concerns regarding I am very cognizant of the fact that rent forbearance and all, as it relates to corporate buyout. And it impacts disproportionately the mom-and-pop apartment owners that can't survive on the rent that's coming in because we put caps on it. So I'm very cognizant of the fact that I would rather see us put together a program Non-profits that COPA is looking at. You know, I had a question for you just to get some clarification in terms of mission driven affordable housing organization or entities.

Could you define exactly what that is?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed59:34

Yeah, so thank you for the question Supervisor. And this is something that we'll clarify in the reassessment and refine but like Emilio mentioned earlier generally when we're referring our mission-driven affordable housing organizations we're talking about organizations whose primary purpose is to develop acquire or rehabilitate and are committed to the long term preservation of affordable housing rather than maximizing profits These are typical nonprofit affordable housing developers, community land trusts, mission-oriented providers or other organizations for profit or nonprofit that reinvest their resources in preserving these properties. So these are the folks that we want to make sure have an opportunity a true opportunity to try to attain some of these properties

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:00:18

So I mean, I think it's an opportunity especially as you pointed out with La Casa just starting to get the Measure A monies and releasing funding programs. It's an opportunity to move that forward. I know DCBA is actively running our emergency rent relief programs in utilizing La Casa dollars for prevention services So I want to make sure that we're not competing or undermining other programs. And I know LACDA and DCBA are both involved in fifth district programs for Altena residents, where we're supporting residents and rebuilding after the Eaton fire.

That there's clarity in terms of the monies that are going to be allocated. And it sounds to me like you've already thought that through?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:00:59

So absolutely, and we've actually met with a number of groups who are trying to organize around some of the purchasing opportunities that are happening in Altadena, particularly in response to corporations coming in and trying to buy that up. There's been some natural work happening there, and this will only help support that and advance some of them.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:01:16

Fantastic and Ralph, thank you to you and your team for the support that you've given to the Altadena residents. You continue to show up and it is not lost on me how much your staff has invested in Altadena and so I appreciate that. In terms of other models, I know, and I don't know if you can talk about this but in Washington D.C., they implemented the TOPA regulations more than 40 years ago And last year they moved to scale the program back, citing there were delays and complications that the critics have raised. Can you talk about that?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:01:57

Sure, so I think what you're seeing here in this motion with the recommendation move forward, COPA is a response to what we've learned both from the research that was happening on the ground and made some adjustments. And that's why we're moving in this direction. Actually, I can ask my colleague Manny to briefly describe some of the work in San Francisco. That would be great. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:02:14

Yeah, so in San Francisco what we see with their COPPA is they have a very truncated process for providing qualified purchasers with the opportunity to purchase. And so in their model they're offering five days to these qualified purchasers to respond with a letter of interest and then they only have 20 days after that to fully assess the feasibility of purchasing and to provide an offer. So it is a very short timeline, it's very aggressive and it does impact smaller non-profits.

But it is something that we are definitely going to look at and include as part of our reassessment report so that we can propose a framework that minimizes the delays in the market.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:02:56

So Manny thank you. So when Supervisor Mitchell brought in or wanted to add something as it relates to parallel tracks would that address Yes, yes it would. I like that and I want to make it clear this is not about eminent domain. This is about leveling the playing field for individuals or entities that want to purchase that can't compete with the corporate people that are coming in and buying out most of our rental market correct?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:03:29

Yes, we definitely want to propose a framework that takes a look at all the options and really tries to maximize the goal of affordable housing preservation while minimizing the impacts to the open market.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:03:42

Thank you. And if I may, I think it's worth saying that we recognize the real estate transactions are timing around that matters to both the sellers and the buyers. So when we go back and make this reassessment, the intent is to come back with a framework that really balances that while still preserving a meaningful opportunity to purchase some of these properties.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:03:59

And you've got the appraised value for properties. I mean, which happens quite often unfortunately. These bidding wars go on. How will that work out as it relates to the appraisal of the property versus the actual purchase price? Or does that come into play?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:04:21

Yeah so this doesn't limit the purchase price. This only creates an opportunity to purchase a property at market rate. At market. So we're not capping the value of the property whatsoever.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:04:33

I think that's important, because I know we got letters from the Department of Association and all. And actually, I'm really torn on this because on one hand they come and testify about the fact that we're pushing mom-and-pops out and incorporations in, and actually what this would do if I Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And it's a report back in 180 days. But there are still some unanswered questions, Manny and you said that y'all are gonna be looking into like what San Francisco did and then lessons learned from Washington DC as it relates to timeframe requirements. Can you provide the board with a regular report back prior to the 180 day when it's gonna be put into an ordinance?

Maybe like every 60 days or so with an update on the progress and indicator What will be included in the ordinance so that we get a better understanding in terms of where you are and how you're proceeding?

not transcribed≈21s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:05:50

Yeah, we'd be happy to provide verbal updates. I think the housing cluster would probably be the best opportunity for us to do that every 60 days.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:05:58

Perfect because we're getting a report but it's also being a report put into an ordinance which is something we would act on. So I think it's important to have input and better understanding as it relates to the final ordinance. All right, thank you and thank you again for bringing this forward. I'm intrigued by it and I think it's... It's

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed1:06:18

provocative.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:06:19

It's an opportunity for us to put our money where our mouth is as it relates to protecting the mom-and-pops and protecting those people that want affordable housing in LA County. Thank you.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role1:06:29

Thank you. Supervisor Hahn?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:06:31

Thank you Madam Chair. And first, I really do wanna thank you as well as Supervisor Mitchell for bringing this motion forward Preserving affordable housing is one of the most effective ways we can prevent displacement and maintain stable communities and address our homelessness crisis. Every apartment building we preserve for affordable housing is one less building we have to replace, and every family that can remain in their home is a family that has a better chance to thrive.

As I reviewed this motion, I also spent some time along with Ivan looking at San Francisco's experience with its Community Opportunity to Purchase Act. And one of the biggest lessons I took away from this type of program is that they're most successful when they are built on communication, strong partnerships And San Francisco definitely had a strong financing infrastructure built in before I think they introduced their ordinance.

And so I appreciate that that's going to be a part of what we're looking at. And I appreciate the authors accepting my amendment directing DCBA to develop and implement a public education and outreach strategy with specific efforts to engage our landlords. Our landlords are essential partners in this conversation and whether they own one rental property or many, they deserve to understand how this program works, what their responsibilities are and who they can turn to when they have questions.

And I would also like to see realtors included in the stakeholder engagement. They weren't specifically called out. I think they have a huge role to play if this is going to be successful going forward. And you can include that in the report back how we could do that. Building that trust early will make implementation smoother, in my opinion and help avoid unnecessary confusion down the road.

I'm very excited about the implementation of this very bold and provocative as a chair said initiative. I really believe it's the right thing for us to do, I think Los Angeles County will again be on the forefront of doing everything we can to preserve housing for those who have come But we're going to need landlords, we're going to need realtors, we're gonna need everybody to understand why this is important to the county.

If we're gonna create a program that preserves affordable housing for the long term it needs to be one that people understand and one that's predictable and one that's built through collaboration From the amount of some of my emails that I got over the weekend, it was clear there was a lot of misunderstanding maybe a little anxiety and fear. And I think we can assuage that as we go forward.

Appreciate my colleagues for bringing this thoughtful proposal forward and I plan to support it all the way to its end. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 17Proposed1:09:58

Thank you, Supervisor Horvath. Thank you Madam Chair I want to thank you and Supervisor Mitchell for bringing forward this motion today as we know LA County's affordability crisis drives gentrification family and community instability in our homelessness crisis while we need more housing now we also need more tools and guardrails that protect affordability of existing housing for working Angelenos When a building is put up for sale, tenants can be coerced into taking buyouts subjected to legal and illegal rent increases and displaced altogether if the building gets taken off the rental market.

Tenant and Community Opportunity to Purchase Act programs are tools that can help stem the tide of displacement by creating an opportunity to maintain those tenancies and to preserve existing naturally occurring affordable housing This motion is a good first step to establish a right of first offer and a right of first refusal for qualified nonprofit and mission-driven organizations. These organizations must commit to keeping rents affordable, and explore tenant ownership where feasible.

By first focusing only on larger buildings of five units or more and mobile home parks, and by working with pre-qualified organizations, LA County can show proof of concept including a minimal disruption for sales timeline. Long-term, we can work to expand tenant organization ownership opportunities and to serve as an example for other jurisdictions. I look forward to updated report after additional stakeholder engagement that will include more detail on notification and transaction timelines and the certification process for mission driven organizations. With the voter support of Measure A, the LA County Affordable Housing Solutions Agency has preservation funds that could be available to support organizations that would utilize COPA which makes this program unique.

I hope that additionally we can work with philanthropic partners who are interested in keeping LA affordable for tenants and increasing home ownership to assist qualified organization purchasers. LA County can be a leader once again in protecting tenants and innovation in the housing space. Thank you.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role1:12:16

Thank you all, my colleagues for your comments at this time executive officer let's go to public comment

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:12:24

Will the following individuals please come forward and staff will assist you. Andre Donado, Bianca Estrada, Dushane Cantley, Eva Garcia, Jamie Penn, Casey Ventura, Margarita Quintanilla, Mariella Saba, Matthew Vo, As a final reminder for participants to be placed in the speaking queue to address item 4, if you have not already done so use the raise hand feature on your device or press star 3 on your telephone now. We will go to in-person speakers first.

not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:13 – 1:1921 turns

PresenterAndrea DonadoLIBREProposedself-stated1:13:12

Good morning, Board of Supervisors. My name is Andrea Donado and I'm the Executive Director of LIBRE, a tenant rights and housing justice organization serving residents across the fourth supervisorial district. And I'm here in strong support of the Tenant and Community Opportunity Purchase Act Every day we work with tenants facing evictions, rising rents and the fear of losing the communities they have called home for years. We help families stay housed but we also know that we cannot solve the housing crisis one eviction case at a time. We need policies that prevent displacement before it happens. T-COPA is one of those policies. It gives tenants community land trust And mission driven non-profits a fair opportunity to preserve affordable housing before it purchased by speculative investors.

Preserving existing affordable homes is one of the smartest, most cost effective investments we can make. Importantly this policy will also help protect

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:14:14

residents. Thank you. Next speaker please.

CommentCasey VenturaProposedself-stated1:14:19

Good morning, Supervisors. My name is Casey Ventura but I'll actually be reading Dijanae Cantley's comment who just had to leave right now. My name is Dijanae Cantley. I'm a South Central resident living in unincorporated Westmont in District 2 and a public board member with BBCLT. I want to thank Supervisor Holly Mitchell for co-authoring this motion and for recognizing the importance of preserving affordable housing and creating pathways for community ownership. A few years ago my apartment building was sold during COVID, my neighbors and i didn't know what would happen next so we came together from the tenant association to figure out how to protect our homes in our community as we organized i realized i wanted the opportunity to purchase our We purchased our building with a community land trust so we can preserve our homes and create community ownership, but we were never given the chance.

That's why TCOPA is so important. It gives tenants a fair opportunity to purchase, to fight outside investors. It creates pathway for permanent affordability, community ownership, and today she's continuing organizing because she believes tenants deserve more than just the right to stay.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:15:20

Thank you. Next speaker please.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:15:24

Buenos dias Supervisoras. Good

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:15:30

morning Supervisors, my name is Margarita Quintanilla. I'm

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:15:33

a resident of North Hollywood District 3.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:15:43

And I'm a member of the Board of Directors.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:15:45

As

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:15:49

a resident of BVCLT.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:15:51

And I am here to express my support for item four on the agenda, to advance TCOPA.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:16:08

When BVCLT bought our building,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:16:13

they didn't just

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:16:14

preserve our housing. They

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:16:16

worked with us as well to be able to keep up the maintenance and they listened to our concerns and

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:16:20

they met with us

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:16:32

To be

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:16:35

able to talk about how we could care for and steward our building together. I had the good fortune that with BVCLT and with the money from you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 18Proposed1:16:50

all, I was able to buy my building. And I know firsthand how transformative that experience can be. All renters deserve that same opportunity Before their housing falls into the hands of corporate's interests. TCOPA gives community land trusts. Thank you, next speaker please.

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMia Shaw RobinsonProposedself-stated1:17:29

Good day esteemed board members. I am Mia Shaw Robinson, resident of SD4 and a member of Long Beach CLT. Thank you for giving us the time to speak today in support of COPPA. For too long tenants communities have had little say in the future of buildings we call home. For me, I was living in my home for 19 years when my building was sold Thank you. Good morning, everyone. I would like to take this opportunity to thank the board of Supervisors for allowing me to be a part of this meeting today. I want to start by saying thank you so much to all of the board members and staff who have worked tirelessly to make sure that we are able Far from us.

The moment is bigger than one building.

not transcribed≈15s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
PresenterJessica MelendezTrasatele and the LACLT coalitionProposedself-stated1:18:31

Thank you, next speaker please. Hi my name is Jessica Melendez good morning I'm here with Trasatele and the LACLT coalition. I grew up in Supervisory District 2 a fourplex not too far away from the office I currently work at. I lived there till I was about 18 years old. My dad and his family had settled in South Central from Mexico and had been in that home for over 20 years That home held over 20 years of history and community, and when I was 15 our landlord passed away. And I learned very quickly how competitive buying our home would be. We struggled, and too many times I heard my grandma say it'd be better if I just lived under the bridge, the freeway bridge.

It was stressful, we struggled, and eventually we moved out in 2010. My family and I could have benefited directly from a policy like COPA. COPA gives neighbors the chance to buy into their neighborhoods and create a permanently affordable housing that is run and owned by the people who live in LA rather than some out-of-state investor. COPA does not force owners to sell or to sell below market, it only asks sellers to consider their tenants as potential buyers and give them an opportunity to make a fair market bet. Thank you next speaker please

1:19 – 1:2714 turns

PresenterKareli De La CruzTrust South LA and the Los Angeles Community Land Trust CoalitionProposedself-stated1:19:39

Good morning, Supervisors. My name is Kareli De La Cruz. I'm a constituent of SD2. I am here with Trust South LA and the Los Angeles Community Land Trust Coalition. Through my work, I have met many tenants who have been displaced after their buildings were sold to corporate investors. Families lose not only their homes but also their schools, jobs, support system and the communities where they have built their lives. Many wanted the opportunity to purchase a building but they were outbid by cash investors and pushed out through rent increases and evictions. TCOPA creates a fair opportunity for tenants to organize, connect with a community land trust and make a fair market offer before their homes are sold. It does not take away property rights or require anyone to sell below market rate.

It simply gives tenants a chance to stay in the community they call home As a constituent of SD2, I respectfully ask you to vote yes on item four and support TCOPA. Thank you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 19Proposed1:20:33

Thank you, next speaker please. Good morning, Vanessa Gonzalez here. I'm with Fiego Municipio Comunitaria Tierra Libre and the Los Angeles Community Land Trust Coalition. I am here to strongly urge the Board of Directors to please vote yes on item four in advancing the Community Opportunity for Purchase Act Our organization Stewards 700 Simmons, a building that was purchased through the county pilot program. And I just wanted to highlight one of our tenants. Her name is Berta. She's been living at our building for over 50 years.

And that is your home. And this is a reality that we see with a lot of our community members. So COPA, it is a proven policy to prevent displacement and it also like provides security stability and this is what our community needs so I do urge for your support. Thank you next speaker please.

CommentMichelle RomoProposedself-stated1:21:38

Good morning supervisors my name is Michelle Romo I am a constituent of SD4 and I'm here today with Long Beach CLT and the Los Angeles Community Land Trust Coalition in support of TCOPA. For many families, home is more than just a place to live it's where we raise our children care for our elders and build friendships and create community Yet in Los Angeles, tenants can spend decades living in their neighborhoods and can lose everything when their building is sold.

My family has lived in their building for over 25 years and so have many of my neighbors. Together we have spent years paying rent, caring for our homes, and helping build a stable community. If our landlord ever decides to sell, we deserve the opportunity to make a fair market offer Before an outsider investors by our building and puts our home at risk. We cannot solve the housing crisis by building Alone, we must also preserve the affordable homes that have already existed to protect the communities To make Los Angeles County strong as a constituent of sd4 I respectfully ask that you vote yes on item for

PresenterChristina BoyerPublic Council and the LACLT Coalition in support of TCOPAProposedself-stated1:22:40

speaker, please Good morning, Supervisors. My name is Christina Boyer. I'm a constituent of Supervisor Horvath and here with Public Council and the LACLT Coalition in support of TCOPA. Thank you, Supervisors Solis and Mitchell for putting forward this policy that will preserve our affordable housing, prevent displacement and keep communities together. We are at risk of losing half of our unsubsidized affordable housing in this county, which is already in a dire housing crisis. What's being proposed today as an effective tool to combat that crisis, a targeted application of TCOPA on mobile home parks and buildings with five or more units. That's the universe of only 30 to 130 transactions a year that affordable housing preservationists can align with existing funding to make TCOPA actionable immediately.

TOPA and COPA ordinances have existed across the country for 50 years, withstanding every major legal challenge, succeeding in protecting valuable affordable housing and proliferating across more and more jurisdictions. What's being proposed today doesn't force anyone to sell and has been a successful model across the country to give community groups a seat at the table when making housing decisions.

I urge your aye vote. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:23:42

Thank you. Next speaker please.

PresenterNazira Beniswith the Long Beach CLT and a member of the LACLT Coalition Supporting communityProposedself-stated1:23:44

Good morning Supervisors. I'm Nazira Benis, Executive Director with the Long Beach CLT and a member of the LACLT Coalition Supporting community ownership opportunities across SD4. I'm here today in strong support of COPA, and thank you for bringing this item forward. I want to share one example of how COPA could transform lives. A group of tenants came to us when they learned their six-unit building was being sold.

We quickly identified a development partner, assembled pre-development funds and identified existing long term funding opportunities through La Casa and other philanthropic sources. We were ready to make a fair market offer but the property owner unfortunately would not consider an offer in support of the residents. These families have lived together for over 10 years. They've built a beautiful community together, they share meals, organize events, participate in their community together, care for one another's children and they dream of collectively owning the place they call home building long-term stability but if this building is sold on the market they will very likely be displaced to be replaced with tenants paying higher rents.

There are many communities facing similar experiences across SD4 and LA County and I urge the board today

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:24:46

Thank you. We will now go to remote speakers, Elizabeth DeCarteret your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentElizabeth Dicartere ThankProposedself-stated1:24:53

Thank you. My name is Elizabeth DeCartere, I am the Government Affairs Director for Southland Regional Association of Realtors. I respectfully urge you to oppose this motion for item 4 directing the development of a COPA or any future TOPA ordinance. While preserving affordable housing is an important goal that we all share, this proposal moves in the wrong direction by adding another layer of regulation and taxpayer expense without creating any new housing units. The real solution to our housing affordability challenge is increasing housing supply by reducing barriers to development, streamlining approvals and encouraging investment. Not making it more difficult for property owners to sell their property. This proposal relies on recommendations that were developed using data conducted several years ago.

Since then interest rates, construction costs, financing conditions and housing market conditions have changed dramatically. In addition, it creates uncertainty delays and uncertain and unnecessary delays. According to the county's own analysis transactions could be delayed for months while designated purchasers.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:25:54

Thank you. Oscar Sarate your line is unmuted please begin.

PresenterOscar Sarate I'mExternal Affairs at CHIRLA the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights I just wantProposedself-stated1:25:58

Good morning supervisors my name is Oscar Sarate I'm a constituent of Supervisor Mitchell and the Director of External Affairs at CHIRLA the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights I just want to thank the board and the leadership of Supervisor Solis and Mitchell for bringing forward this TOPA COPA ordinance. CHRLA proudly supports this measure, we believe it will Result in affordable housing for immigrant communities. On a personal note, I was recently able to purchase my childhood home in unincorporated Willowbrook from the corporate owners who acquired it after my landlord passed away. I did so to ensure stable affordable housing for my parents. That opportunity should not be the exception. It should be available to every family in Los Angeles County.

Please vote yes on item four. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:26:52

Thank you Oscar Monge your line is unmuted please begin.

PresenterOscar MonqueTristata Lake and a member of the LA Community Land Trust Coalition I respectfulProposedself-stated1:26:57

Hi, can you hear me?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:26:59

Yes please begin. Okay

PresenterOscar MonqueTristata Lake and a member of the LA Community Land Trust Coalition I respectfulProposedself-stated1:27:01

thank you hi everyone good morning LA County Board members my name is Oscar Monque executive director of Tristata Lake and a member of the LA Community Land Trust Coalition I respectfully urge your support for item four advancing tenant and community over training to purchase thank you to all of our community members and TLT coalition leaders for advocating for this and making it out through the meeting in person today For more than 20 years, we have worked to acquire affordable housing. Our expertise has shown that we cannot build our way out of the housing crisis alone and we must preserve the affordable homes that we already have. Item 4 does not require property owners to sell below market value or force owners Thank you. Laquisha

not transcribed≈26s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:28 – 1:3720 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 20Proposed1:28:09

Yes, thank you so much. Supervisors my name is the founder and principal strategist of example strategies global public policy consulting firm dedicated to advancing equitable evidence based solutions that strengthen our communities. I am here today in strong support of item number four, and to thank Supervisor Mitchell as well as Supervisor Salas who I'm a constituent.

Housing stability is the foundation of economic mobility, community health and generational wealth yet too many longtime residents particularly black and Latino families continue to face displacement as housing costs outpace income. This motion is thoughtful that reality. By directing the county to develop this ordinance and identify sustainable funding strategies, you're creating pathways for tenants and mission-driven organizations to preserve affordable housing. Thank you again so much that you are creating a

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:29:11

smart... Thank you. Siris Barrios your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentCidis BarriosProposedself-stated1:29:16

Good morning, my name is Cidis Barrios. I'm Deputy Director at Trust LA and a resident of Watts. During the pandemic organization process more than 1,000 California Emergency Rental Assistance application given us first-hand insight into the housing challenges facing both tenants and landlords in the Florence Farrington community three families who had lived in their homes for 10 to 26 years were displaced after their landlord passed away one tenant offered to purchase the property so they could remain in the community The property was ultimately resold three times while the family's enduring long, painful eviction process. Trust LA was ready to work with both of the heirs and the tenants to preserve these homes but there was no path to make it happen.

GCOPA provides that pathway. It gives opportunity. Thank you. Thank you.

not transcribed≈21s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 21Proposed1:30:25

Good morning, Supervisors. Gerard Wright, Governor and First Rector of the Greater Los Angeles Realtors. Strong concerns with TOPA and COPA because there's again this addresses a lot of the affordability issues but the bigger concern is where is NHS in this conversation? Where is the conversation around how folks can actually get educated on financial vehicles so that they can purchase their homes and purchase property There's a lot of things that are missing from this conversation, and I feel it's just as scratching the surface. This is still a way of taking one to the other. We're replacing one corporation and turning into a nonprofit corporation in the process. So this is just a lot of concerns our members are having with this particular measure and what this is proposing to do for an ordinance.

Those are our comments at this moment in time. Thank you for your time and attention.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:31:28

Tim Shaw, your line is unmuted. Please begin.

CommentTim ShawProposedself-stated1:31:31

Thank you, good morning. My name is Tim Shaw. I'm the Government Affairs Director for both the Tri-Counties and Pacific West Association of Realtors. We have longstanding policy opposing TOPA and COPA. These are well intentioned policies that ultimately do more harm than good as they disrupt the free market in real estate. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the board. I'm here to speak on behalf of the Board of Supervisors in support of housing affordability. Topa and Copa proved to add significant delays and government disruption in what should be the free market in real estate so we would urge that your board respectfully look for other ways to address the housing affordability problem which we agree there is significant problems with our

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:32:30

Thank you. Roy Humphreys, your line is unmuted please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:32:34

It's a thank you. It is a damn time as the corporate vultures have been circling from day one of the Los Angeles City burndown, from which Bass and Company should be in alligator Alcatraz. Additionally, the gang of four Democrat board members of this board continue to support the Biden illegals, which has exacerbated this issue and a slap in Legacy illegals. You can look forward to my Senator Boxer's message to me on these illegals, thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:33:16

Thank you Philip Crispino your line is unmuted please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 22Proposed1:33:21

Thank you very much, Supervisors. Housing affordability challenges will not be solved by restricting property transfers or creating new obstacles to real estate transactions. The most effective long-term solutions are policies that increase housing supply, encourage investment, streamline development approvals and expand opportunities for home ownership. Nothing prevents tenants, tenant groups, non-profit organizations or affordable housing developers from purchasing properties today through the open market. Granting preferential purchasing rights to selected groups creates an uneven playing field and may discourage future investment in rental housing. For these reasons I respectfully urge you to oppose development and adoption of a TOPA of a TCOPA ordinance and instead focus on policies that expand housing opportunities while preserving private property rights and maintaining a fair, competitive and transparent real estate market.

Thank you for your consideration and my name is Philip Crispino, REALTOR® and board member of Southland Regional Association of REALTORS®. Thank you so much!

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:34:19

Thank You Melissa Morgan your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentMelissa MorganProposedself-stated1:34:23

Hello I'm Melissa Morgan with Black Lives Matter Grassroots Long Beach our black neighborhood tenant council and a member of the Long Beach community Land Trust in strong support of COPA. From a Black housing justice perspective, black families know what it means to be pushed out, priced out over police and locked out of ownership as a result of generations of redlining discrimination, classism and now corporate speculation. In our county, black renters are the most rent burdened especially us black women holding families and communities together We carry the weight of the housing crisis every day. 65% of black renters are rent burdened, we face the highest eviction rates in L.A., these pressures fuel homelessness and we're only 9% of the population but 31% of houselessness.

COPA gives tenants and CLTs a fair chance to preserve housing Before displacement and instead of letting wealthy corporations decide who gets to stay. So Supervisor Janice Hunt, please vote yes. If we don't act now black families will be displaced our communities lost let's preserve affordable housing.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:35:25

Thank you. Will the following individuals please come forward and staff will assist you? Roberto Garcia, Kimberly Sun, Ivelia Montano, Sureus Hernandez, Anna Hernandez, Antonio Hernandez, Matthew Buck, Sandra McNeil, Jeff Fowler, Victor Ricks, Magdalena Cazares, Miguel Montero, Scott Kurzban, Brenda Toffia. We will continue with in-person speakers. Please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 23Proposed1:35:53

Good morning to you.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:36:02

My name is Evelia Montano and I'm a member of the Community Power Collective and Fideicomiso Comunitario Tierra Libre.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 23Proposed1:36:11

Estoy aquí por inquilina, como inquilina he vivido el acoso y la amenaza constante de perder mi hogar. And

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:36:23

I'm here as a renter. As a renter, I have faced constant threats and harassment and the threat of losing my home. And so I ask you to approve T-COPA.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 23Proposed1:36:33

This law will allow us the opportunity to be able to be the first to buy the buildings where we live and to participate in making decisions about our housing. We want communities that are free from harassment. And we also want it to be free from evictions

not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:37:05

and speculation.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 23Proposed1:37:06

Housing is a human right, it's not a business. Every family deserves to live with security and dignity. So I ask you therefore to vote in favor of the Ticopa law. Please put the community first, thank you. Thank you next speaker please

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:37 – 1:4310 turns

PresenterRoberto Garcia CeballosFideicomiso Comunitario Tierra LibreProposedself-stated1:37:39

Good morning everyone, my name is Roberto Garcia Ceballos. I'm here with Fideicomiso Comunitario Tierra Libre, the first community land trust in East LA and one of the main reasons we started a community land trust was because we understood the conditions in which naturally occurring affordable housing was in unincorporated East LA. We knew a lot of tenants were in need for their buildings to be rehabilitated and the health conditions that people were suffering because of mold, because of unsealed windows and the variety of things that housing needs. Through the CLT pilot program that we had, we were really successful at changing people's lives.

And unfortunately, we still doorknock at people's homes in unincorporated East L.A., and we find people who need community organization to come and rehabilitate and work with them to create permanent affordability and healthy living conditions. And so T-COPA is a solution for that, so thank you.

CommentKimberly Sun I'mProposedself-stated1:38:41

Thank you next speaker please. My name is Kimberly Sun I'm a member of Tierra of Colectivo Poder Comunitario and Tierra Libre Community Land Trust. I respectfully urge you to support T-COPA as it gives tenants Family is the opportunity to have the first chance to purchase the buildings where they live and helps keep our community stable. For years, many families have faced harassment, evictions and displacements because of large investors buying their homes without caring about the people who live there. With T-COPA, tenants can organize alongside community organizations to protect their homes and build long term stability.

The housing should never be treated as a commodity. Housing is a human right and it is essential for life and every family deserves to live without the constant fear of losing their home. We urge you to vote for T-COPA and give our communities opportunity to protect their homes, strengthen our neighborhoods, and to put our people before profit. Thank you. Thank you, next speaker please.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 24Proposed1:39:46

Hi my name is Rosario and I'm here with my son Joaquin and we are constituents of Isla Solis' district. I have a story of me growing up and getting displaced in a time where Topa or Ticopa was not around. We got displaced and moved three times. We are now in a time Where communities are coming together, community land trusts are in the game that can actually help this from happening to other families. While there's a lot of fears and holdbacks from folks I think at the end of the day we have to realize that our children suffer displacement it affects their studies and we're supposed to be investing in our future If we want leaders that can truly stay community grounded but also advocate for everybody, then we should be putting our money towards our children.

And that means making sure that affordable housing stays affordable because my son should have the ability to own a home Thank you, next speaker please.

CommentMeg SullivanProposedself-stated1:40:50

My name is Meg Sullivan as a mom and pop housing provider in District 2 I came here to urge you to oppose the disastrous idea of lengthy delays at sale To address the region's housing crisis, you need more people like me and my husband to step up and invest in the high risk and low rewards business of providing rental housing. But no private party in their right mind is going to invest in a market that looks like the equivalent of the Hotel California song where investors can check-in but it's not clear that they can ever leave Or on what timeline? If you go forward with this, private capital will continue to flow to less restrictive markets. Delays in timeline at sale is an investment killer. Capital chases liquidity.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:41:51

Thank you. Next speaker please.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 25Proposed1:41:54

Joseph Ramos for the Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles. We urge you to oppose this proposal in its current form, the county simply cannot afford to create another expensive bureaucracy. Even the outdated HRNA advisor's report estimated this program would cost at least $2 million every year and require 15 full-time employees plus additional outreach costs. Those costs will undoubtedly be much higher today. If you want to move forward with any policy limited to the far less expensive mobile home resident opportunity to purchase model used in Alameda County Alternatively, use Colorado's ordinance for the county to be the sole purchaser to bridge the gap between small owners with 20 or few units who must sell quickly due to urgent needs and non-profit organizations that want time to assemble financing.

Colorado's ordinance also excludes all profits with fewer than 15 units. Neither policy was considered by HRNA. Please reject this proposal until more practical and affordable alternatives are fully researched. The county's cost for this new program would be far better spent closing Men's Central Jail. Thank you for your time.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:42:49

Thank you. Next speaker

CommentEva GarciaProposedself-stated1:42:50

please? Very good afternoon to you. My name is Eva Garcia, and I am an organizer with Community Power Collective. I'm also the co-founder of the Community Land Trust. As a organizer, every single day I see harassment that is taking place by landlords toward tenants. It is

not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:43:29

very sad to see families being evicted every day. I

CommentEva GarciaProposedself-stated1:43:32

see the Seymour building, for example as a co-founder of the Community Land Trust, I see people living with peace there.

not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:43 – 1:4916 turns

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:43:52

That's why we need the Ticopa law to be accepted. We need more tenants to be living at peace, where they would be able to know how to govern their building and take housing off the market. Because housing is not a business. It's essential, it's vital housing is. How can we stop this taking the

CommentEva GarciaProposedself-stated1:44:21

housing off the market? So we have this hope through TECOPA

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:44:36

Because housing should be for those who are inhabiting the home.

CommentEva GarciaProposedself-stated1:44:42

And

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:44:43

not a market as if it was just a business. So

CommentEva GarciaProposedself-stated1:44:45

please, I ask for your support for TECOPA. That's the

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated1:44:48

community's hope.

PresenterBianca Estradamy son Octavio he's four years old we're here to motion or be here in support ofProposedself-stated1:44:53

Thank you, next speaker please. Hi good morning supervisors my name is Bianca Estrada and I'm here with my son Octavio he's four years old we're here to motion or be here in support of item 4 I am an advocate for all Good morning. My name is Yvonne. I am a Boyle Heights resident all my life. I want to make sure that families in my community are housed. We have a lot of unhoused people that are currently displaced and they fear displacement currently in their own homes, and it would be great if we have We're here to defy all odds with poverty, with all kinds of educational barriers. We're just trying to make sure that our children have a place to stay and that our community stays with the people that care for it and are willing to do anything for it.

That's all. Thank you so much.

CommentMariela SabaProposedself-stated1:45:52

Thank you. Next speaker please? Good morning, my name is Mariela Saba and all I wanna say is do the right thing today. I know you have a lot of decisions on your plate every day yet in the moral compass shaped by genocide of indigenous people on these stolen lands and genocide of so many people on lands overseas Lebanon, Sudan, Palestine and more as we speak Your decisions can either contribute to further displacement, which is a key ingredient of genocide disguised by such language as a free market. Or you can help us all stop these 250 year old plus trends to push people continuously out of their homes through policies and police.

I am here with my daughter and more families with the El Sereno Community Land Trust, and the LACLT coalition. And we are all united here in support of Ticopa. Thank you next speaker please.

PresenterLily PiedraLACLT coalition in support of TicopaProposedself-stated1:47:00

Hello, my name is Lily Piedra. I'm with Long Beach Residents Empowered here in solidarity with the LACLT coalition in support of Ticopa. At Long Beach Residence Empowered, we see all too often when housing is sold the floodgates are open to everything from tenant harassment to the abuse of eviction protection loopholes. We've spoken to many groups of tenants all together facing the pressure to sign oppressive new lease agreements or refuse needed repairs in their units who are all of a sudden told that their homes need to be substantially remodeled.

The goal of these new landlords is to turn over these 10, 15, 20-year leases so that rents can be doubled or sometimes even tripled. TCOPA is a tool to prevent displacement and I urge the board to vote in support. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:47:59

Thank you. We will now go back to remote speakers. Araceli Palafox your line is unmuted please begin.

PresenterAraceli PalafoxEnterprise Community Partners to offer our support of Item 4 to advance a CommunProposedself-stated1:48:05

Good morning, Board of Supervisors. My name is Araceli Palafox and I'm calling on behalf of Enterprise Community Partners to offer our support of Item 4 to advance a Community Opportunity Purchase Act program for unincorporated LA County. We know from our work across the state and across the country that opportunity purchase acts are critical tools for affordable housing preservation, and we believe that a TCOPA program would be catalytic in LA County. Allowing mission driven affordable housing organizations like CLTs and nonprofit affordable housing developers to acquire and preserve properties when tenants are not able to do so.

We also know that supporting mission-driven affordable housing organizations to do this is especially critical in high cost areas like our county. We're grateful to Supervisor Solis and Supervisor Mitchell for your leadership on this, and urge you to vote yes on item four. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:48:56

Thank you. Callers starting with phone number 818 ending in 73. Your line is unmuted, please state your name and begin. Please begin.

CommentAlan ZamanProposedself-stated1:49:08

Hi, are you speaking with me?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:49:13

Yes, please begin.

CommentAlan ZamanProposedself-stated1:49:15

Yes hi good morning my name is Alan Zaman I am a realtor and real estate advocate in Los Angeles County. I am calling today to voice my concern and opposition with item four I respectfully urge you to vote no on item 4. While I do support the goal of expanding affordable housing and creating stable communities, I do not believe that this ordinance is the right approach and requiring rental property owners Thank you for your time.

not transcribed≈26s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:50 – 1:5723 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:50:12

Thank you. Callers starting with phone number 626, ending in 69. Your line is unmuted please state your name and begin.

PresenterAdriana BautistaAltadena Earthseed Community Land Trust I'm calling because our community has beProposedself-stated1:50:19

Hi my name is Adriana Bautista with the Altadena Earthseed Community Land Trust I'm calling because our community has been impacted by the Eaton's fire which Decimated our community's affordable housing and changed our community forever. I stand in solidarity with the folks in the room at the Board of Supervisors who have been advancing the important work of community life, which creates permanently affordable housing for communities to steward for a generation. Our community has a thriving powerful beautiful black community which in the 80s was about 48 percent of Altadena's population before the fire, 18 percent and now is projected...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:51:24

Thank you caller starting with phone number 626 ending in 59 your line is unmuted please begin Thank you. Caller please begin. Hello

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 26Proposed1:51:38

can

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:51:38

you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 26Proposed1:51:38

hear me

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:51:39

yes please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 26Proposed1:51:42

Oh I'm sorry hi my name is Florence- calling for out to Dina and- so encouraged to see what the supervisors are doing and- and totaling support Looks a little bleak right now. And this opportunity would afford them, especially the rental community, would afford them the hope that they may be able to get in. Residents like 403, Figueroa and all of the rest. I really do hope that you... It's messy but it is a solution that has an outcome that brings families together and puts roof over people's heads. And as the lady said does not leave somebody thinking that they would have to sleep under a bridge. So I really do hope on behalf of Pasadena's Organizing for Progress and Dina Rise Up.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:52:40

Thank you. Sadiq Kamushi your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentEmily ZamoraProposedself-stated1:52:46

Hi,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:52:48

please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed1:52:48

We'll

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:52:52

go to the next caller Anastasia Komoroske your line is unmuted please begin. Anastasia please begin we will go to the next caller Byron your line is unmuted please begin

CommentAnastasia KomoroskeProposed1:53:11

Good morning, Board Chair Byron with the Trans-Latina Coalition. Thank you to Supervisor Mitchell and your board's leadership for advancing this motion. I hope you continue to listen and uplift through your votes and through your policies and three priorities where the communities are asking for communities throughout the county and not just failed Thank you. Caller with phone numbers starting in 323, ending in 05. Your line is unmuted please state your name and begin.

not transcribed≈14s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated1:54:03

We support ownership, however we think the motion has to be enhanced. There is no beneficial owner registry for affordable housing units in LA County. Developers hide under the cloak of non-profit status. Nonprofits and foundations don't have to disclose who their donors are. When sunset clauses are up, affordable housing units are sold off. SB 1000 protects red light communities that are underserved and suffer from environmental risk.

I have been speaking directly with EPA due to the legacy pollution sites in East L.A., and due to the two recent environmental catastrophes, it is one thing to talk about existing housing units and those yet to be built To continue building units that cost $500,000. It's unacceptable and it's a form of poverty pimping at the expense of the public purse and at the exploitation of renters.

Thank you. The family is

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:55:04

the most direct. Your line is unmuted please begin. Okay next caller Anthony Arenas your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentAnthony ArenasProposedself-stated1:55:15

Hi, my name is Anthony Arenas. I'm a lifelong resident of District 3 with Dignity and Power Now in the Justice LA Coalition. And I want to speak in favor of this item. I heard a speaker earlier have the gall to say that we should instead of investing in affordable housing that we should invest in closing down Central Jail. I'll tell you right now, you will not close the jail if you don't have community affordable housing. And you all heard from the jail closure implementation team last week. Many of you have reaffirmed your commitment to close the jail and if you vote no on this item, I don't think you're taking your commitment to closing the jail and investing in care for a serious You really cannot keep breaking your promises with the community.

You have all of these families here speaking in support of community affordable housing, less than 10 developers came to tell you to vote no on this. You are the only ones in the way of advocating for community affordable housing.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:56:17

Thank you caller with phone number 818 ending in 00. Your line is unmuted please state your name and begin. Caller, please begin. Okay we'll get to the next caller. Jan Missingle your line is unmuted please begin. Next caller Anastasia Komoroske your line is unmuted please begin.

PresenterAnn KomoroscUnited StatesProposedself-stated1:56:42

Hello can you hear me?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:56:47

Yes please begin.

PresenterAnn KomoroscUnited StatesProposedself-stated1:56:48

Hello my name is Ann Komorosc I am a non Partisan candidate for president of the United States, and I do not support any more mail-in ballots for elections in LA

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:57:04

County. Ma'am you are off topic we're taking public comment on item number four you can get back in queue for general public comment

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:57:14

Thank you. Madam Chair, there are no other remote speakers to address the board. Remote participation for item four is now concluded. We will go to in-person speakers. Please begin.

1:57 – 2:0513 turns

PresenterMatthew VuBeverly Vermont Community Land Trust and an organizer with the Los Angeles CommuProposedself-stated1:57:29

Good morning, Board of Supervisors. My name is Matthew Vu. I'm the board president of the Beverly Vermont Community Land Trust and an organizer with the Los Angeles Community Land Trust Coalition. I want to thank supervisors Mitchell and Solis for their leadership on Tenant and Community Opportunity Purchase Act. Since 2021 when this was first brought up by the board, the circumstances requiring have only exacerbated. We know that corporations are 60% of the purchasers in Post Fire Altadena, and that number continues to exacerbate. I hear the real estate lobby talking about market pressure. That's what it looks like. It looks like the disinvestment of black communities and a transfer of wealth from black ownership to their hands. And please forgive me if I take what they said with a grain of salt.

We're talking about the cabal that brought to you redlining and racial covenants. I don't know what market interventions they are opposed to, but those ones they're cool with. This one is about putting people ahead of corporations. Please vote yes.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:58:31

Thank you next speaker please

GuestJamie PennTreasurerProposedself-stated1:58:33

Good morning, supervisors. I'm Jamie Penn. I am a District 5 resident and the treasurer of the Beverly Vermont Community Land Trust and I'm here to support agenda item number four, TCOPA. And I do wanna give a special thanks to Supervisors Solis and Mitchell for bringing this business. So I've seen firsthand what this model brings. One of our properties, Urban Soil Tiara Urbana in Koreatown known to many as the Los Angeles Eco-Village came out of the 1992 uprisings It sat nearly half vacant for years before we brought it back. Today, it's fully occupied in full compliance with the housing department with tenant managed gardens and native landscaping that helps cool the block. And over a decade later, we've displaced almost nobody. Residents who lived there when we acquired it still live there today.

That's the difference between speculative ownership and community ownership. TCOPA gives tenants and land trusts the first opportunity to buy, and before that difference disappears.

CommentSua Iris HernandezProposedself-stated1:59:37

My name is Sua Iris Hernandez, and I just wanted to congratulate the supervisors for actually coming in and looking at this question. These small shifts in information flows are exactly what we need. I want to remind you that the real estate teams were the ones that were after red zoning was discouraged and actually made illegal They were the bodies that continued redlining throughout and continue the effects of it today. Many places are still being unfairly treated, many families being diverted to neighborhoods through the real estate agencies. They continue to need a lot of education on how to actually market to our people This is a small shift in information flows. It has no construction costs, as some of the folks that have opposed have come up.

There's nothing here. It's a small shift in information flows that is a very powerful one. It allows tenants to consider actually purchasing. It doesn't have a cost on building. Thank you. Next

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 27Proposed2:00:40

speaker

CommentSua Iris HernandezProposedself-stated2:00:40

please?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 27Proposed2:00:42

Good morning, everybody. My name is Claudia. This is my first time being heard here and I'm excited. I'm learning. I am here representing my trans community and first of all, I want to thank Hilda Solis for recognizing the rent burden that our communities You know, go through. I also want to thank Holly Mitchell for supporting the trans community and I mean, I remember you visiting the Trans Latina Coalition.

Putting that aside, I just want to mention, I heard the lady talking about San Francisco. You know trying to make Los Angeles you know put their foot forward comparing to Trans-Francisco. San Francisco is one of the cities that support the LGBT community especially the trans community. I don't hear you supporting a trans community. Elderly trans suffer you know a lot and most of us We are here by ourselves. Thank you, next speaker please.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:01:50

Hello everybody, Chichi Navarro with the Transatina Coalition. TGI people and Angelenos in general across the city and the county are facing a housing crisis. You all are aware of that. That is pushing too many working people, seniors, and vulnerable tenants out of their homes. In Los Angeles for-profit realtors and developers keep advancing policies that prioritize ≫ Good morning, everyone. My name is Jordan. I'm the vice president for housing and development at COPA. We are a multi-family housing company that is committed to providing affordable housing for real people. That's not a housing solution. That is displacement dressed up as progress. COPA is exactly the kind of structural tool we need to keep As DCBA develops this ordinance, I ask you to please center tenant stability, protect vulnerable communities such as TGI and low-income communities and make sure this effort strengthens long term housing affordability for Angelenos who are most at risk.

Thank you.

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
PresenterBrenda TafoyaEl Sereno Community Land Trust and part of the LACLT CoalitionProposedself-stated2:02:49

Thank you next speaker please Hello, my name is Brenda Tafoya, Executive Director of El Sereno Community Land Trust and part of the LACLT Coalition. Our urge is to support TCOPA as a practical solution to our housing crisis. As practitioners we work with the real estate market Because we understand it, and we try to bring that information back to our communities. We focus on natural occurring housing and specialize in minimizing the barriers of ownership through education advocacy while still serving the community as professional affordable housing developers guided by community because they know what's best for them. With T-COPA, we can partner with willing sellers and tenants to acquire properties ensuring smooth transactions while preserving permanently affordable housing, stabilizing neighborhoods and ensuring that public investments benefits generations of residents.

I urge you to support T-COPA as smart investments in housing stability affordability and long term community. Thank you next speaker please

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 28Proposed2:03:54

Jeff Fowler, president of the Apartment Owners Association. The largest group of apartment owners in the state. Many of our owners are members actually own corporations. It's called an LLC and I'd ask that you distinguish the difference between an LLC and a corporate Wall Street type of investor. Private investors versus corporate. Please make the distinction when you do your research.

Non-profits are already purchasing. You've heard good testimonies already, so I want data. How is this not fair? Give us real data. If you wanna help renters build a legacy through ownership, create a resource that walks them through the process of how to get funding, how to evaluate, how to purchase. Do that. Help them leave a legacy. What does Berkeley, East Palo Alto and Redwood City all have in common?

Two things, they rejected COPA because they did their research. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 29Proposed2:04:55

Thank you, next speaker please. Good morning

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:05:02

Supervisors and everyone else who's here my name is Ana Hernandez.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 29Proposed2:05:05

I am a member of Community Power Collective and also the Free Land Community Trust and I'm here in support of item four. I'm here in support of the TCOPA law. Those of us who are renters in our community deserve the first opportunity to be buyers.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈18s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

2:05 – 2:1114 turns

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:05:46

Throughout many years as renters we have suffered from harassment and eviction, mistreatment from owners that are only looking for their own interests.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 29Proposed2:05:57

And through TCOPA, we are able to take ownership of where we live. We can be able to manage our own dwelling and be able to take charge of our own decision

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:06:04

making.

not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 29Proposed2:06:18

The community should be able to have control of their own housing and land, because housing is a right. It's not a luxury.

not transcribed≈15s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:06:41

Enough is enough. We cannot continue to let the corporations to decide our family's futures. Please approve the teacupa. Thank

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 29Proposed2:06:49

you.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:06:50

Have a wonderful day.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:06:52

Thank you. Next speaker, please.

CommentVictor RicksProposedself-stated2:06:55

My name is Victor Ricks. We just celebrated the Fourth of July, which was monumental on choice fight for what you believe in. You deserve what you do. It's your freedom of choice It is paramount of an owner to have that choice, to choose to whom he wants to sell this property to regardless of race, gender, religion or marital status. Owning an apartment building is a very tough job. Fourth of July I was replacing sewer lines that busted underneath the building. It's a very difficult job it's not just as glamorous thing you just own apartment building and the rents go from hand to pocket and never goes out Thank you. Next speaker, please?

not transcribed≈13s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentVictor RicksProposed2:07:57

Good morning, Madam Chair and members. Sandra McNeil here in support of item four. I'm a 26-year resident of SD2 and a policy advisor to the LACLT coalition. I applaud the board's vision for sensible policy which will enhance tenant stability throughout unincorporated neighborhoods by starting with a pilot version of the five plus unit buildings We, HRNA has assessed we'll only cover between 30 and 130 transactions annually.

And we'll be able to together have the opportunity to test and refine implementation. Importantly this can include coordination with acquisition resources newly available through La Casa CLT PPO and home ownership programs as well as hopefully a new bond funded 500 million state community anti-displacement preservation program. We realize this policy is making an ask of property owners to place a slight pause on their transactions, but we have found many landlords interested in selling. Thank you next speaker please

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 30Proposed2:09:00

Hi, Matthew Buck, Vice President of Public Affairs for the California Apartment Association. Anyone can already purchase property. COPA would go beyond that by creating a government-managed process that gives preferential treatment to certain entities and could add delays to property sales. Delays would create uncertainty for owners, buyers, lenders and residents. COPA does not create any new housing. It only changes timelines for those who may purchase existing housing.

The proposal would require even more bureaucracy which would increase costs and make rental housing investment less predictable. To avoid these costs, the county could simply hire a realtor to source sales. If the board chooses to move forward please work to preserve open market competition, minimize transaction delays and administrative costs, avoid unnecessary barriers to buying and selling rental housing and ensure strict capital and operational requirements are met. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:09:55

Thank you next speaker please.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 31Proposed2:09:59

Good morning Supervisors and staff. My name is Antonio with Strategic Actions for a Just Economy and constituent of Supervisor Mitchell. Community members and partners have already shared the TOPA COPA details, and yeah just here to also state that we're here to find creative and structural opportunities for long-standing community residents to steward their homes and neighborhoods. Also I've heard that there is this hesitance or this unclear aspect of the process where we need to find ways to incentivize property owners and including smaller residential owners, to seriously consider selling to trusted community organizations and tenants instead of being outbid by corporations and housing speculators especially in historically redlined neighborhoods.

We understand that corporations and housing speculators are not housing providers just to simply provide accessible housing rights so that is clear. Yeah let's just continue to partner up with community-based organizations for Topo Copa. Thank you,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 32Proposed2:11:00

next speaker please.

2:11 – 2:2230 turns

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:11:08

Very good morning to you. My name is Magdalena Cáceres and I'm a member of the Community Transformation Collective in East

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 32Proposed2:11:16

Los Angeles. Thank you, Ms. Solis for this motion because in recent years rents in the Los Angeles community have increased They are

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:11:38

very high rents, and so we are facing instability in our communities around housing. In the unincorporated areas.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 32Proposed2:11:48

These rent increases make us predisposed to evictions.

not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:12:10

So we would like to ask that you would support TCOPA, we are also in support of it so that those of us who are renters would have the first option to be able to buy our homes. and or also having the priority when there is a rented property that is put up for

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 32Proposed2:12:33

sale.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:12:40

In this way, as renters will be able to have an affordable housing option and being able to buy our own housing. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:12:51

Thank you. Next speaker please.

CommentMiguel MonteroProposedself-stated2:12:53

Hi, good morning County Board of Supervisors. My name is Miguel Montero. I'm a constituent of ST2 Holly Mitchell and today I'm here to speak on Topocopa and ask for the county board of supervisors to support this motion I'm also part of SAGE, Strategic Actions for a Just Economy and our research has shown that corporations which include LOCs are amassing these large portfolios of housing and this has led to a lot People being harassed in their units. Also, we've noticed a lot of evictions and eviction threats coming from these landlords and just big real estate players. So what we're asking for with Topocopa is for the playing field to be leveled out and to give tenants an opportunity to go ahead and also buy up these properties for their well-being and...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:13:54

Thank you, next speaker please?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 33Proposed2:13:57

Hi, Scott Kurzban. I am against Item 4 and you know we've heard a lot of comments here about horrible landlords. We already have laws in the books that absolutely should be utilized to combat horrible landlords but the answer isn't to layer on really crappy policy and we all want to preserve affordable housing and reduce displacement, but good intentions don't always produce good policy. Policies like this might save 11 units, but they disincentivize thousands of units from being built. The only answer to L.A.'s housing crisis is more units. It's not to strangle the owners that have the only units on the market. It is literally insanity. Supervisor Barger even just admitted that your own policies hurt small landlords yet you want to double down on bad policy and in the end not solve the actual problem.

So I urge you to vote no reconsider this stop layering on bad policy additional commissions more employment for government employees to form lists and surveil transactions.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:14:58

Thank you

CommentShannon OxProposedself-stated2:14:58

next speaker please. Hello board, my name is Shannon Ox. I'm a proud out transgender woman. I support voting yes on the agenda item four because protecting affordable housing is essential to keeping our community diverse, stable and accessible for working families, seniors, veterans and young people and trans women. What we have heard one after another today was another spoiled white man who works in real estate who probably cheats on their wives saying protecting the most vulnerable is wrong Preserving and expanding affordable housing helps ensure that residents can continue to live where they work, raise their families and contribute to our local economy. A yes vote reflects a commitment to housing stability, economic opportunity and a strong future for Los Angeles and everyone in our community.

Protect trans women and protect housing.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:15:53

Thank you next speaker please

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 34Proposed2:15:55

Good morning. Claudia Hernandez, DWC DPSS. I believe that more units is an answer. COPA could be a remedy but realistically we need fair wages paid. What we make, the wages that we make it should take us there to be able to pay for affordable housing that is quality of life We need fair pay wages. We need to look at that because here in L.A., we pay a lot of taxes, we pay a lot of money for housing and everything so we have to look at how is it that our work is paid and how we can increase that, do something with that because there's going to be units but we're not going to be able to afford it for it because we don't have the jobs and all that. So, it is connected so I think COPA is a remedy and then... Thank you next speaker please.

not transcribed≈7s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentDr. Critical Rahel Desire-TruthbayProposedself-stated2:17:01

Greetings my name is Dr. Critical Rahel Desire-Truthbay first and foremost want to say Emilio Salas thank you for being here thank you for your service with LACTA truly appreciate it so Unidos Podemos! It's very important that we have the goal of preserving affordable housing and preventing displacement for everyday working citizens, taxpayers and families who have experienced homeless for years.

As a policy analyst I've seen over and over again good people in organizations that lose property due to pay-to-play and corruption TCOPA is an opportunity to develop the county and ensure community-based organizations, righteous people, and just everyday citizens have a way to have a meaningful opportunity to purchase property and not to be displaced. We also recommend financial program to teach and give loan grants for those families and organizations who want to do so. So thank you, Hilda Solis and Mitchell for this initiative.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:18:03

Thank you. We will now go back to remote speakers. Jayan Masangli, your line is unmuted. Please begin. That caller dropped. Nathan Nunez, your line is unmuted. Please begin.

PresenterNathan Francisco NunezSan Brandon Luturista Community Land TrustProposedself-stated2:18:14

Hello, can you hear me?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:18:18

Yes, please begin.

PresenterNathan Francisco NunezSan Brandon Luturista Community Land TrustProposedself-stated2:18:21

Hello everyone my name is Nathan Francisco Nunez, constituent of Ward District 4 speaking on behalf of San Brandon Luturista Community Land Trust, a rising community land trust I'm here to speak in support of agenda item four. Being a heavily rented area, Southeast LA and a lifetime resident of Southeast LA, cities like Cudahy are a super majority of renters and approving an item like this goes to support them finding a living situation That is sustainable, which is very important within these upcoming crises in the upcoming times.

Especially with the heavy amount of rent burden that exists I myself have lived in the same household for 27 years and many of my neighbors are, and within that time we would have been able to purchase this housing with the amount of being able to pay off a whole mortgage. So approving an item like this would do so much to the rent-burdened, the majority of rent-paying living situation that exists in Southeast LA, and I support this item. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:19:33

Thank you. Jean Massongli? Your line is unmuted. Please begin. It looks like that caller dropped. Madam Chair, members of the Board, that concludes public comment on this item.

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction2:19:45

Madam

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 15Proposed2:19:46

Chair, Item 4 is

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:19:46

before you. Hold on. Supervisor Mitchell?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 15Proposed2:19:49

Thank you very much Madam Chair I just wanted to quickly thank all those who came to speak. And we were asked to do some research and collect some data, so I'm gonna return the favor. Often when we have these conversations around housing and tenants' rights, we hear from kind of the polar opposites. And oftentimes people come, you offer your testimony then they leave or after this item is voted on they leave. I would ask of you that those who represent land trust organizations before you leave Out in the foyer, have a conversation with the realtor.

I would ask that one of the tenants' rights representatives before you leave have a conversation with that real property owner. I think it's important that as you come here and you advocate from your perspective that you also spend some time hearing from the other person. You know, I will say that I believe that housing is a right I also understand that the construction of housing, the provision of housing is indeed a business. And that's why I'm encouraging people to have the conversation. Lastly, Madam Chair, I would ask you know, I wasn't here in 2020. I wasn't serving on the board yet when the board voted to close Men's Central Jail and I was surprised by the comment and so if any of you can remember If AGLA took a position on the closure of Men's Central Jail, because it sounds as if based on testimony today they are in support of it.

But I just wondered if they took a position on the closure when the motion came forward? We don't seem to remember. Thank you very much for the opportunity.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:21:27

Thank you. Before we go on to the vote, I do want to thank the folks that came in today. I know this is rough weather out there for a lot of reasons but I want to thank you. Quiero agradecer toda la gente que han llegado hoy día para dar sus testimonios y yo sé que es un día pues con mucho esperanza y esperamos que todo salga bien. Thank you let's go. Madam

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction2:21:52

Chair item four is before you

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:21:54

Okay, I will move the item seconded by Supervisor Mitchell to approve. Executive Officer please call the roll.

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction2:22:00

Supervisor Mitchell?

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:22:01

Aye.

Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 move the item seconded by Supervisor Mitchell to approve. Executive Officer please call the roll.
Show transcript
Supervisor Mitchell aye. Supervisor Horfath? Aye Supervisor Horfath aye. Supervisor Hahn? Aye Supervisor Hahn aye. Supervisor Barger? Aye Supervisor Barger aye.

2:22 – 2:276 turns

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction2:22:11

Supervisors Solis?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed2:22:12

Aye

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction2:22:12

Supervisors Solis aye. Motion carries. We will now

move on to Item 7 Restoring the Will of Los Angeles County. Voters at the ballot box, which was held by Supervisor Mitchell. For members of the public joining us remotely to comment on this item please use the raise hand feature if you're online or press star 3 if on a telephone.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:22:34

Thank You supervisor Mitchell

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 15Proposed2:22:37

Thank you very much Madam Chair. I held this item today because of the depth of public concern regarding the fate of Measure J following the passage of Measure G and because the people who fought for Measure J really deserve to hear directly, I believe from this board regarding our intentions I really want to acknowledge many of the advocates and community members, some of whom were here today about a hundred or so who showed up at Cluster. Many of whom spent years organizing to make Measure J a reality. And in 2020 in the middle of a pandemic and a national reckoning on racial justice 57% of LA County voters made a historic commitment to invest directly in our communities in care first and jails last And now we face the potential undermining of that historic commitment, not because of a policy choice by this board or the voters but frankly because of a clerical and an administrative failure.

The idea that this commitment could be undone even potentially without the knowledge of the people of LA County is unacceptable to me and I have heard and share your frustration. Rushed drafting error cannot be allowed to wipe out years of work on justice reinvestment. And while I wasn't responsible for that error that led to the repeal of Measure J, I am clear that I have a responsibility to do everything within my power to correct it and ensure that the will of the voters is upheld.

So I am really relieved and glad that we have a path forward to clarify the continued implementation of Measure J within our new governance structure following the adoption of Measure G. However, this situation is a wake-up call. We shouldn't have to fix this after the fact. Charter updates must be governed by clear timelines, quality controls and accountability so that nothing like this happens again.

Just as importantly, we must recognize that this is what happens when we rush big things. I've consistently raised concerns about the consequences of the speed and unprecedented scale of the governance changes that Measure G would advance. And the drafting oversight that undermined Measure J that we're trying to fix today is a painful example of just that. The elected county executive represents a fundamental and massive restructuring of county government.

We are only beginning to digest and uncover the practical implications of this change for how the county operates. Therefore, I believe we have got to be careful to ensure that all of the county's obligations including Measure J are upheld in this new governance structure. We already have a proposed charter amendment underway to ensure that the new Ethics Commission and Ethics Compliance Office have the independence voters were promised under Measure G.

This upcoming charter amendment is also the appropriate vehicle to fix the administrative error that occurred when Measure G was adopted. This motion is straightforward. It directs County Council to fold two protections into the charter amendment already underway on the Ethics Commission. First, it moves Measure J to a new section of the charter so that it's no longer subject to potential repeal in 2028 under Measure G.

Second, it makes explicit that the elected county executive must follow Measure J. Including not being able to veto the measure J set aside through the budget process. The status of Measure J should not be up for debate. Again, the voters spoke in 2020. So today, this board has an obligation to uphold the will of the voters. And I'd like to thank Supervisor Horvath for her desire to co-author this important motion and I ask our colleagues for your support. Thank you Madam Chair.

2:27 – 2:367 turns

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:27:13

Supervisor Horvath.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 17Proposed2:27:14

Thank you, Madam Chair and thank you Supervisor Mitchell for this motion for your consistent advocacy and commitment to justice reform and for welcoming me as a co-author on the motion in 2020 Los Angeles County voters made their values unmistakably clear by passing Measure J they recognize what we know to be true investing in prevention care and opportunity makes our communities safer stronger and more resilient Since that time, the county's efforts to build out alternatives to incarceration and a system of prevention and care have saved countless dollars and lives. It was the right decision then, and it is still the right decision today.

Then nearly two years ago voters spoke again by passing Measure G calling for a county government that is more transparent accountable and responsive to the people we serve. We absolutely have a responsibility to honor both of those mandates and I couldn't agree with you more, Supervisor Mitchell. With today's motion we are fulfilling that commitment and making sure the will of the voters is truly reflected in our county charter. I'm grateful to the friends advocates and community leaders and voters who have continued to show up and organize reminding us all what is at stake Our residents deserve care, dignity and a justice system that delivers for them in their communities. And I look forward to continuing to build out that system of care while also creating a county government that is responsive to our residents who need it most.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:28:46

Thank you, Supervisor Barger. You're recognized.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:28:50

Thank you and thank you, Supervisor Mitchell, for bringing this forward. And there's no question in my mind That had the voters known that Measure J had been taken out of the ballot measure before the voters, it would have changed a lot as it relates to that election. But that was not known because I think the comment was made when it was brought up, the concerns that we could fix it and this is how we're going to fix it is bringing it back to the voters.

And I do appreciate your efforts to address the oversight created by the approval of Measure G. I oppose Measure G as you know When it came before the board because I thought it lacked sufficient stakeholder engagement, true transparency and ample review and input. It is ironic that in quickly moving forward with Measure G and the governance reform the county overrode a previously voter approved initiative.

And it's incredibly disconcerting that the government officials can put anything Before the voters that repeals their previous wishes without even knowing that they are doing so. And I think that is what I'm hearing from a lot of opponents of Measure J who fought hard to get it across the finish line originally. Today's motion, while codifying the will of the voters from November 20 of 20 can also be construed as vague without full disclosure The county created by Measure G and the rectification of Measure J. While I support the Ethics Commission, and again, I believe that we could do this without a voter initiative but to make it truly independent, I think it's important for us to bring it to the voters. But I am concerned about adding this language to the Ethics Commission ballot measure without full disclosure to the voters about the error.

This is setting a concerning president to try to fix a mistake without being fully transparent to the voters. I don't know if it would change the outcome, but again, um, the fact that we have to go back to the voters to reinstate something that I'm sure they spent millions to bring across the finish line should be concerning to all voters as it relates to things put before them and I would encourage people to read the propositions before they vote on them. Although I don't think this would have been caught because It was completely deleted from the ballot measure as it relates to Measure G.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:31:14

Well, thank you Madam Chair. And as we're all talking about whether or not we supported Measure G or not I was a big supporter of Measure G and was happy to co-author the ballot measure with Supervisor Horvath and the voters clearly supported it. It was overwhelming that the voters felt like it was time to reform county government in Some, you know very large ways.

And while yeah certainly we talked a lot about transparency and accountability and efficiency this really wasn't it was a terrible unintended consequence no one saw that was happening wasn't it I'm going to pass it over to you, Commissioner. I'm going to start with measure J, because the voters were pretty clear also in 2020 with measure J that they wanted to see more county dollars going towards community investments.

To make sure that we have more alternatives to incarceration and if we're ever gonna close Men's Central Jail which I think we are all committed to doing. We have to have more investments in the community So even after the judge declared Measure J unconstitutional, this board again really doubled down and listened to the will of the voters and fully supported Measure J implementation by codifying it into the county's Care First Community Investment Policy. So Measure J is now the law of the land and it must continue to be so even when Measure G goes into effect in 2028. We cannot let this technical error invalidate the will of the voters, so appreciate Supervisor Mitchell and Horvath bringing this forward to preserve Measure J by asking our voters to support the charter amendment that will be on this November ballot and ensure that Measure J is not repealed Once Measure G goes into effect in 2028.

The Charter Amendment will also make sure that both the Board of Supervisors and the County Executive are responsible for the CARE First Community Investment implementation. I also appreciate that because at one point it was going to give the county executive the ability to veto You know, the board's recommendations for that. So this will make sure that that still falls within the Board of Supervisors as well as the county executive.

So I think that's also a really important piece of this ballot measure So I'm committed to upholding Measure J, so I will definitely be supporting this motion and I'm pretty sure our voters are sophisticated enough and educated enough to understand what it is they're voting on this November. Thank you.

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role2:34:31

Thank you. I just want to say thanks to Supervisor Mitchell and Horvath for bringing the motion forward. The motion makes the necessary correction to the administrative oversight that put Measure J at risk, and I want to say that I'm proud that I was a co-author of the initial motion to place Measure J on the 2020 ballot and also very supportive of obviously the Measure G to help reform our government. I believe that there's going to be a continuance of our effort to continually look at ourselves and how we provide care first, and jails last. And as we move to reaffirm that commitment, that's what our vote will be today whatever reflective that might be. But I continue to see that there is so much important work ahead of us especially to advance the essential Government reforms that voters approved with Measure G.

With that, I will ask our EO to go to public comment.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:35:34

Will the following individuals please come forward and staff will assist you? Kehlani Brown, Joy Richardson, Alonzo Hill, Adriana Urjano, Felicia Carbajal, Claudia Bondes, Akelina Soriano-Varosa, Pamela Moyada, Chelsea Velez, Jared James, Alex Bass, Jose Catalan, Sabra Williams, Deanna Pimpman, Angela Arroyo, Major Buntin, Chichi Navarro, Megan Castillo, Trasko, Paloma Baustos. As a final reminder to remote participants to be placed in the speaking queue to address item seven if you have not already done so use the raise hand feature on your device or press star three on your telephone now we will begin with in-person speakers please begin

2:36 – 2:428 turns

CommentKaylani BrownProposedself-stated2:36:21

Good morning, my name is Kaylani Brown and I'm here today because I believe Measure J represents something bigger than a budget line. Growing up, my father was and still is incarcerated. These experiences shape how I move through this work today. I work behind the scenes helping community organizations keep these programs running I can tell you these aren't abstract dollars. They become case management, legal services, mental health support, re-entry services and opportunities that people depend on. Stable funding allows organizations to focus on serving people instead of worrying whether they'll exist next year.

When funding becomes unstable, of course organizations suffer but it's the people and families who lose access to the support they've come to rely on that are most impacted. Public safety isn't only about responding after harm has happened. It's about creating the conditions where people have housing, mental health support, employment opportunities and somewhere to turn before a crisis becomes irreversible. Measure J was approved because voters believed in investing in people. I ask you to honor that decision and protect both- Thank you next speaker please

PresenterJoy RichardsonStProposedself-stated2:37:22

Good afternoon, members of the Board of Supervisors. My name is Joy Richardson and I'm here today on behalf of St. Joseph Center. We respectfully urge the board to support item 7 and restore the will of Los Angeles County voters by ensuring that the commitments established through Measure J remain permanently reflected in the county charter. Every day, St. Joseph Center stands alongside individuals and families experiencing homelessness, behavioral health challenges, and economic hardship We know from the work in our community throughout Los Angeles County that investments in housing, mental health services, workforce development and supportive programs are not only compassionate. They are essential strategies that create pathways to stability and strengthen our community.

The Care First approach recognizes the true public safety and public When individuals have access to resources that are necessary to thrive. I want to thank Supervisor Mitchell and Supervisor Horvath for your leadership.

CommentMegan Castillo I'mProposedself-stated2:38:24

Thank you, next speaker please. Good afternoon Supervisors my name is Megan Castillo I'm a resident of District 2 and I'm with La Defensa and the Reimagine LA Coalition. I want to thank Supervisor Holly Mitchell and Lizzie Horvath for bringing this motion forward to protect community investment in honor the will of Los Angeles County voters. Measure J funds life saving services that address the root causes of instability these investments support housing mental health care youth programs Violence prevention programs and for many families these services are the difference between stability and falling into crisis. And so supporting this motion will help to ensure that this county provides the stability that CBO's need, some of whom are present today with and without that certainty organizations face layoffs service reductions or even close their doors.

An administrative error should never override the clear intent of the voters. We need all of your help to protect these critical investments, preserve Measure J and vote yes on this motion. And while I'm here, close MidCentral Jail, free the 50 girls, Black Lives Matters and remember dreams do not have borders. Thank you.

PresenterAlonzo HillDowntown Women's CenterProposedself-stated2:39:29

Hi, my name's Alonzo Hill representing Downtown Women's Center. For nearly 50 years DWC has led women and survivor-centered housing solutions in Los Angeles and we are proud to receive CFCI funding through Measure J. These funds support benefits employment mental health services for 600 people annually building independence and providing alternatives to our incarceration. Measure J funding also supports our mobile employment specialist mental health clinicians Committee health workers and peer support specialists. These staff members have been essential in reaching more just-involved people than ever before. If Measure J ends, hundreds of women and survivors who receive services from DWC alone could lose access to resources that prevent criminalization or recidivism.

We respectfully urge the Board of Supervisors to vote yes on Supervisor Mitchell and Solis' motion to preserve and protect Measure J funding. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:40:27

Thank you, next speaker please. I'm Felicia Carvajal,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 35Proposed2:40:30

Executive Director of the Slate Impact Center, a resident of District 3 and a proud member of Reimagine L.A. Coalition. Madam Chair and Supervisors good afternoon. I rise today in support of agenda item number seven. Thank you Supervisor Mitchell and Horvath. I can tell you ladies exactly what care first investments have made possible through CFCI funding we built an expungement program rooted in a simple belief Our communities are not the problem, they are the solution. We leverage that investment to secure additional funding, expand our services and create opportunities led by people with lived experience. One of those peoples is Chantelle, a formerly incarcerated black queer single mother of two. She came to us for an expungement to remove barriers to employment.

After receiving that second chance she came back, not for more services but to serve. She participated in our leadership and wellness fellowships, and today she's employed serving our unhoused population and volunteering with us. That's what CFCI does. Thank you next

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:41:30

speaker please

PresenterJose CadalanNew Way of LifeProposedself-stated2:41:32

My name is Jose Cadalan. I'm a community organizer with the New Way of Life. First, I want to thank Supervisor Mitchell for taking the leadership on this. So we strongly urge the county to restore Measure J and to fully fund CareFirst Community Investments. Los Angeles County voters made their voices clear when they chose to invest housing, mental health care, re-entry services, youth development and other community based programs I'd like to start by thanking the Board of Supervisors for Thanks to community-based programs, I myself am no longer in a prison but here before you as a taxpayer and supporting my community. For that, I urge your aye vote on agenda item seven. Thank you.

not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

2:42 – 2:4912 turns

CommentJared JamesProposedself-stated2:42:34

Good morning chair and members of the board. My name is Jared James, a community organizer with new way of life and we urge the county to protect major J measure J from repeal and fully fund care first community investments. Voters gave a clear mandate invest in housing, mental health youth development and reentry services. True public safety means investing in our communities and expanding alternatives to incarceration not turning back the clock on other voters and fully fund our future. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:43:05

Thank you. Next speaker, please.

CommentPamela MolledaProposedself-stated2:43:07

Good morning to the Board of Supervisors. My name is Pamela Molleda. I advocate for TGI housing. Housing is necessary to all Angelenos because of team resource such as mental health care, food and housing has become more difficult every day. In the past, due to health problems I almost lost my apartment. But Los Angeles LGBT Center helped me so I didn't lose my apartment. The TGI community often face violence exclusion from employment and education.

Now, I'm worried because we have surgeries at the end of the month and thinking about By health problems, I have been at risk to lose my apartment again. And I don't want to be homeless. Supervisors please consider my TGI community to give us a safe place-

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:44:08

Thank you next speaker please.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 27Proposed2:44:11

It's me again Claudia Bundis. Bon Appetit. Buen Provecho. So back in 1999 2000 I was incarcerated When I came out, I lost my apartment. I had to start from zero. So I'm here for you to support, make sure Jake at first, jail last. As you know the trans community is a small percentage of the community but we're being attacked Even by President Trump. Why? I don't understand. We're a small community, so I urge you to keep us in mind, support our trans community Thank you. Next speaker, please?

not transcribed≈14s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentChelsea VelezProposedself-stated2:45:14

Hi, I'm Chelsea Velez. I'm here as the policy coordinator with Trans Latina Coalition and I'm also a proud coalition member of Reimagine LA. I am also a resident of District 1 so I'm here in support of Agenda Item One. LA voters have overwhelmingly approved Measure J and established a permanent commitment to community investment alternatives to incarceration and to the county's Care First vision As you've heard, the transgender gender nonconforming and intersex community is twice as likely to be incarcerated compared to the general population. Our community is four times more likely to experience houselessness and poverty. We are directly impacted by policing violence and the decisions y'all make here. We have demanded reform and transparency.

We've demanded resources, funding and investment in our communities. We provided you with creative solutions that are community-led. Solutions like Trans Latinas Coalition's TGI Housing Initiative, youth programming, reentry services, affordable housing and many other ways for y'all to implement Care First priorities.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:46:16

Thank you. We will now go to remote speakers. Cierra J. C-Y-F-C, your line is unmuted. Please begin.

PresenterCierra Jaswick CollegeLydia Sinclair Templeton Esquire Executive Director of Children Youth and FamiProposedself-stated2:46:24

Thank you for the opportunity to speak on Measure J. I'm Cierra Jaswick College and Data Manager with Children Youth and Family Collaborative. I am representing Lydia Sinclair Templeton Esquire Executive Director of Children Youth and Family Collaborative, an agency and project of Holman United Methodist Church. We are in favor of Measure J as not only an employee of a youth program that serves all youth with a focus on fostering and at-risk youth I am also a testament to the importance of having these programs in place especially to address systemic racism historical inequities and to reallocate funds directly to marginalized communities As a former foster youth myself, if it wasn't for these programs in place I wouldn't be where I am today holding a bachelor's in human services and an MBA degree as well as leaping into a doctorate program in education.

A business owner community advocate for foster youth and parents. Measure J would continue to provide important community youth development programs like ours the opportunity to continue to make a positive impact and grant you the chance to plug yourselves into something.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:47:26

Thank You. Brooklyn Carter your line is unmuted please begin

PresenterBrooklyn CarterReimagined LA CoalitionProposedself-stated2:47:33

Good afternoon. My name is Brooklyn Carter and I'm a resident of SD2 and an intern with the Reimagined LA Coalition. I am here today in support of Agenda Item 7, and I would like to thank Supervisor Mitchell for putting this motion forward. As a young black woman living in unincorporated Los Angeles where the city of Compton is literally my backyard, I am no stranger to the inequities affecting my black and brown low-income community members. I'm from a home where my mother and father work extremely hard to provide for my family, despite the systematic pushback they receive as black citizens of LA County. Measure J allows not only my family but my community to have a lifeline to fall back on in times of need and suffering. Without it our community will suffer.

Our people will be laid off, turned away from jobs, and ultimately be pushed in the direction of failure as it goes uncared for and unsupported. Supervisor Barger, Pond and Solis. Supporting my community is up to you. Choose to protect Measure J. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:48:27

Thank You. Kaitlyn Player your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentKaitlyn PlayerProposedself-stated2:48:32

Hello, my name is Kaitlyn Player. I'm an intern for La Defensa and I am speaking today in strong support for Item 7, Restoring the Will of Los Angeles County Voters and the Ballot Box to Protect Measure J. Measure J was passed by more than 2 million voters who demanded a permanent structural commitment to public safety through prevention, care, and opportunity, not incarceration. An administrative or technical error should never override the democratic will of the people.

Measure J funds crucial everyday infrastructure, affordable housing, mental health crisis support, youth development and community-based diversion. These programs tackle the root causes of instability before people end up in jails, hospitals or experiencing homelessness. True safety means investing in care first. Protecting measure J is the first step Good afternoon. Thank you, Board of Supervisors for

not transcribed≈24s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

2:49 – 2:5616 turns

CommentJosh BrenneckeProposedself-stated2:49:45

Agenda item today, and thank you Supervisor Mitchell for your support. My name is Josh Brennecke. I'm a housing coordinator with Burling Corners and a member of Brown Game LA. Measure J represented a promise that county budgeting would begin to address long-standing racial and economic inequities affecting black, brown, low income, disabled, and some impacted communities.

Measure J funds life saving services that communities depend on Including programs, investments including affordable housing and homeless prevention programs. Mental health services and crisis support programs. Violence prevention and healing programs and youth development programs. Programs like these prevent the likelihood of people re-entering jail and being incarcerated and help protect our communities. Thank you for your support in supporting Measure J.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:50:40

Thank you. Freddy Pusa your line is unmuted please begin.

PresenterHardi Poozamyself today and speaking in strong support of the motion to permanently preservProposedself-stated2:50:45

Good morning, my name is Hardi Pooza. I'm the mayor of Culver City but i'm representing myself today and speaking in strong support of the motion to permanently preserve Measure J in LA County's charter as we transition to the new governance structure. Thank you to Supervisor Mitchell for authoring this motion and Supervisor Horvath for co-authoring it. The voters overwhelmingly approved Measure J because they understood that investing in people is fundamental to building safer, stronger, healthier communities. In Culver City we've seen the value of a care first approach investments in mental health response homelessness services violence prevention youth programs and community based organizations help people before they reach a point of crisis These investments don't just change individual lives, they make our entire region stronger and reduce long-term costs for taxpayers.

Please ensure Measure J remains a permanent commitment by protecting it within the Charter. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:51:38

Thank you. Janet Asante your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentJanet AsanteProposedself-stated2:51:42

Hi my name is Janet Asante resident of District 2 in Campaigns for Dignity and Power Now on the Justice LA Coalition. There have been so many incredible voices here advocating for Measure J to be protected And rightfully so, it's a disgrace that Measure J was even necessary given that these investments are common sense and evidence-based. So many people have fought and died for Measure J to exist, and we're still fighting for the community care health and safety and the ATI dollars that are rightfully community led.

And as we know, we finally do have a plan with budgetary recommendations to close Men's Central Jail. And now that we are protecting Measure J, that's exactly where a lot of these dollars should be going To make all of us safer and better taken care of. And to end this harmful mass incarceration system that we have in LA County. Thank you to Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for authoring this motion, um, and I strongly urge the rest of the board to vote in favor. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:52:40

Thank you. Byron your line is unmuted. Please begin.

CommentAnastasia KomoroskeProposed2:52:45

Good afternoon Board Byron with the Tlalocanac Coalition and Reimagine LA. Thank you, Supervisor Mitchell and all your deputies and team for engaging various stakeholders as part of the process but also throughout Cluster. A lot more voters voted for Measure J than Measure G and the Court of Appeals actually upheld that Measure J is constitutional so let's make sure we're not misrepresenting the facts to the public. And speaking of informing the voters and the public Let's really talk about who was at fault here. Who is, who created the administrative error instead of talking about and let's also talk about how much money the county council and the CEO spend with A-Labs and probation officers to oppose Measure J and appeal it in the courts so move forward we're committing to care first jails last as we move forward to upholding the will of the voters then make sure we close Metro Central Jail today

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:53:43

Thank you. Jessica Ferris, your line is unmuted. Please begin.

PresenterJess FerrisACLU of Southern California as well as a member of the Reimagine LProposedself-stated2:53:47

Hi, I'm Jess Ferris. I'm a resident of District 4 and a Senior Policy Counsel with the ACLU of Southern California as well as a member of the Reimagine L.A. Coalition. We want to thank Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for this motion. We fully support it and it sounds from all your discussion like all of supervisors supported so thank you to all of you. Given that support to protect Measure J we urge you also to honor it more fully by giving more dollars to Care First Investments To stop funding the failed policies of law enforcement, to close MCJ.

We firmly believe that when you protect and honor Measure J, you protect and honor Angeleno's. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:54:25

Thank you. Anthony Arenas your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentAnthony ArenasProposedself-stated2:54:30

Thank you, Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for your efforts. If any of the supervisors today continue to delay funding, you're complicit in denying the will The people need care, not cages. Just last week you all heard from the jail closure implementation team and if you're serious about care first, if you're serious about promises made, promises kept, you will vote yes to fully fund Measure J. You're the only ones in the way of this. Where is the opposition today? Fighting to deny And ask and demand that you keep your promises made. You're the only ones in the way.

not transcribed≈22s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:55:32

Thank

CommentAnthony ArenasProposedself-stated2:55:32

you. No more delay.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:55:34

Iba Alley, your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentIba AlleyProposedself-stated2:55:38

Thank you my name is Iba Alley. I'm with Whole Systems Learning and we receive funding from CSCI. This funding hasn't just affected the people that participate it has affected thousands of people family members And other community members. What Supervisor Hahn said really spoke everything that I could ever speak, but I will say that this is also in my 30 years Of working in LA County, that there has ever been a program that has provided the kind of appropriate services that actually help the people that need help. Thank you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:56:34

Thank you. Will the following individuals please come forward and staff will assist you? Bebe Alvarez, Rene Ocampo, Joshua Brenneke, Lupita C., Shannon Axe, Cassidy Modano, Evelyn Espinal, Iro Dykes, Reeve Melendrez, and Cynthia Mesa. We will now continue with in-person speakers. Please begin.

2:57 – 3:0316 turns

CommentAdriana ArjonaProposedself-stated2:57:00

Good afternoon Supervisors, my name is Adriana Arjona. I'm a

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:57:20

survivor of having lived on the street and I have not had a way to get affordable housing.

CommentAdriana ArjonaProposedself-stated2:57:26

These 20 years that I went through, I was raped, I was beat up, I was discriminated

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:57:33

against

CommentAdriana ArjonaProposedself-stated2:57:41

It is necessary for us to be taken into account. Trans women must be taken into account.

not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:58:05

Because we are not included, we face a lot of racism and discrimination. I don't want to go through the same thing that I went through 20 years ago because I lived on the street for 20 years.

CommentAdriana ArjonaProposedself-stated2:58:25

And it is painful because there's not anybody to help us or direct us.

not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated2:58:45

I just make ends meet by selling rosaries and scapula and different parts or

CommentAdriana ArjonaProposedself-stated2:58:54

accessories for cars. That's the only way. I have a disability, and that doesn't allow me to work. Thank you. Next speaker please?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:59:05

Good afternoon. Chichi Navarro with the Transatina Coalition, part of Reimagine Los Angeles. First and foremost, shout out to Supervisor Holly J. Mitchell and Lindsay Horvath y'all for making this happen! I hope that you will continue to investigate this matter though, and to ensure that an error like this does not continue to happen because this was massive.

I want to also uplift the importance of the safeguards introduced in this motion to ensure that our future Board of Supervisors as well as the County Executive adhere to Measure J and the will of the people. As our federal government continues to heighten its attacks on TGI, immigrants, low-income workers, the disabled and old people who are not wealthy white cis men And as our economy continues to be pulverized by a madman who embodies the worst of white supremacy, restoring Measure J is not just a necessary tool to counteract these continuous attacks but reaffirms the best in humanity that all people can do good when provided with the proper pathways. So thank you for reaffirming your belief in Care First, but most importantly-

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:00:07

Thank you. Next speaker please.

PresenterAkilina Soriano-Versosthe Filipino Workers CenterProposedself-stated3:00:10

Hi, I'm Akilina Soriano-Versosa with the Filipino Workers Center. Thank you for bringing this motion and you may have saw we had more members here to speak but unfortunately they couldn't wait because they had to get back to work as caregivers but we were all speaking in favor of this item seven and how important it is for our whole county that we are able to preserve measure J, care not incarceration Thank you. Next speaker please.

not transcribed≈23s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentAlex BassProposedself-stated3:00:59

Good morning, representatives. I'll be speaking on Item 7. My name is Alex Bass. I'm a proud trans resident of District 3 and the Policy Associate for Trans Latina Coalition. I am here in support of Measure J. This measure could correct the racial injustices seen in the traditional carceral system by shifting financial resources away from these systems and into community care For example, towards supportive housing. Vulnerable communities like the transgender, gender expansive, the intersex community, the disabled, the elderly, the system impacted and the immigrant community experience homelessness violence and a lack of access to essential services at a higher rate than any other community. The TGI Housing Initiative would prioritize housing stability.

We are asking the county to invest in a two-year program, $20 million homelessness prevention program which would fund and provide rental assistance, flexible financial assistance, housing navigation and tenant rights education. Investing in TGI High is a crucial step for the county in continuing to advance equity. Thank

CommentSabra WilliamsProposedself-stated3:02:00

you, next speaker

CommentAlex BassProposedself-stated3:02:01

please.

CommentSabra WilliamsProposedself-stated3:02:02

Hi I'm Sabra Williams from Creative Acts teaching artist thank you to Supervisor Mitchell and Horvath. I want to speak briefly about public safety. I think we need to start to really think about who is the public and what is the safety? I have been working inside prisons for more than 20 years now, so I've experienced what it was like when we only had three programs across the state. Prisons were three times overcrowded and violence and recidivism were off the charts. Today California has historically low crime rates and youth arrest rates. Data on what happens when we fund in-prison programs is clear. Transitional age youth, in particular, show enhanced mental health outcomes, lowering of violence, less likelihood of gang activity and return home prepared and resourced to transform their lives.

I missed a World Cup match here to come and speak here today. That's how important it is to me. I hope it's more important to you. Thank you.

3:03 – 3:1830 turns

PresenterMajor BuntonProgramming for Creative ActsProposedself-stated3:03:04

Hi, my name is Major Bunton. I am the Director of Programming for Creative Acts. We are ready to rise in CFCI grantees. Thank you Holly Mitchell for this moment. There's currently a push to take funding away from prison youth programs. At the same moment as our youth are in the short and a probation crisis, programs for transitional age youth have proven critical for lowering violence and gang involvement supporting improving mental health outcomes and keeping them in school and employed.

Now is not the time to remove this funding but to expand it that is a real public safety thank you

PresenterDeanna PittmanYoung Women's Freedom CenterProposedself-stated3:03:45

Thank you, next speaker please. Hello my name is Deanna Pittman and I'm a resident of SD2 and I'm here on behalf of the Young Women's Freedom Center. We're also a CFCI grantee. Measure J is the will of LA County voters They're voters who knew that it was time to address the historical injustices and move away from continuing to fund carceral solutions. At the Young Women's Freedom Center, we work towards building up the leadership of formerly incarcerated girls, gender expansive youth and trans youth. The Care First community investments truly make this work possible and it scares me to think of a future of what our work would look like without it.

This funding has allowed us to host weekly youth circles, a young mom support group, an entrepreneurship program and weekly one-on-one mentorship with youth. Let's not jeopardize this over an error. Protect Measure J and make it permanent. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:04:40

Next speaker please.

PresenterPaloma BustosSunita Jane Anti-Trafficking Initiative at Loyola Law School and the Reimagine LProposedself-stated3:04:41

Hello, my name is Paloma Bustos with the Sunita Jane Anti-Trafficking Initiative at Loyola Law School and the Reimagine LA Coalition. Thank you Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for bringing the motion to protect Measure J. The county has repeatedly said that it is committed to a public health approach when talking about issues related to homelessness, violence prevention, youth development, human trafficking, mental health, and alternatives to incarceration but a public health approach has to be backed by real investments That means investing in prevention and community-based care, including housing and support services. And not relying on punishment as a main response to complex social issues. This matters because when people do not have the support they become more vulnerable to harm at SJI.

We see this often in human trafficking and exploitation cases. Protecting Measure J is how the county follows through on its work to take a public health approach to support communities. So I urge you to pass this motion. Thank you.

CommentAngela ArroyoProposedself-stated3:05:39

Thank you, next speaker please. Good afternoon my name is Angela Arroyo I am a resident of District 2 and a member of the Young Women's Freedom Center. I'm here today to speak on agenda item 7 as a formerly incarcerated youth myself alternative programs for youth decarceration like the Young Woman's Freedom Center and Beloved helped me achieve my goals like getting my high school diploma employment and new ways of healing and that's not speaking on all the youth they help out individually and work with to prevent us from reoffending Never in the five years I was in and out of juvenile hall did I receive these opportunities. Instead, I felt helpless, oppressed by the people who should have helped me instead of punishing and releasing me to the same environment with no guidance.

Programs like the Young Women's Freedom Center and Beloved should continue to be funded through the CFCI so youth like myself can strive and be guided towards success and not oppression. Opportunity and second chances protect Mexico City. Thank you. Thank you. Next speaker please.

CommentZinnia MorenoProposedself-stated3:06:34

My name is Zinnia Moreno and I am a resident of SD3 and UCLA graduate student here today with La Defensa. I am also one of the 2.1 million voters that voted for Measure J because I understand that nobody can get well in a cell, and our cycles of criminalization perpetuate harm rather than healing. I have also worked inside, oh, I'm sorry. Like programs such as the Young Women's Freedom Center where I used to work. I've also worked inside the rightfully closed down Camp Joseph Scott and Challenger Memorial Youth Center, as well as the illegally operating Los Padrinos Juvenile Hall, all cesspools of violence against minors that funnels them straight into the adult prison system I oppose the continuous shuffling of people and dollars from one facility to another when there are transformative programs we could fund instead.

I ask that you not just restore my will as a voter, but prioritize the well-being of all those who cannot attend today because instead of receiving services they're locked in cages. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:07:34

Thank you. We will now go back to remote speakers. Veronica Lewis your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentVeronica LewisProposedself-stated3:07:40

Good morning my name is Veronica Lewis. I'm the current and inaugural chair of Measure J. And CFCI Advisory Committee, thank you Supervisor Mitchell and Supervisor Corbat for co-authoring. As a person who's been here literally from the beginning of Measure J I'm extremely proud of the tens of thousands of lives that have been saved and changed because of it. The 150 plus grassroots organization many of which were founded by people who are system impacted that have funding for the first time to really be beacons of light in their community. And then Measure J CFCI pushed the county to create a unique way to incorporate meaningful community led And driven budgeting and resource allocation. And with that said, while we appreciate the board's willingness to create the CFCI budget policy in 2021, as each of the Board of Supervisors have said, the will of the voters to codify a deep and sustained investment into alternatives to incarceration and direct community investment in the county charter is fully necessary.

So thank you for your leadership and affirmative vote today to reinstate Measure J.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:08:39

Thank you. Maya Hendricks? Your line is unmuted. Please begin.

CommentMaya HendricksProposedself-stated3:08:44

Good afternoon, Board of Supervisors. My name is Maya Hendricks. I'm a resident of SD3 and a member of the Reimagined LA Coalition. I am here today in support of Agenda Item 7. Thank you to Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for addressing this issue. Measure J was one of the clearest expressions of public demand for budget transformation in Los Angeles County history. More than 2.1 million voters voted in favor because they understand that public safety cannot be achieved through incarceration. For the past four years, a big part of my job has been advocating for the full implementation of Measure J. Through that experience I have seen firsthand how beneficial Measure J has been for our communities. Community-based organizations have been able to expand their programs, pay their staff and provide vital frontline services for community members.

Supervisors Solis, Hahn and Barger it's up to you to vote yes on this motion and take the next step to restore the county from its stake, preserve trust and save lives. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:09:42

Thank you. Anthony Robles, your line is unmuted. Please begin. Anthony, please begin. We'll go to the next caller. James Takamatsu, your lines are muted. Please begin.

CommentJames TakamatsuProposedself-stated3:09:59

Hi, my name is James Takamatsu with Dignity Empower Now and the Justice LA Coalition calling in support of Item 7. I want to thank Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for putting this motion forward correcting an extreme oversight by the county. In 2020, LA County residents overwhelmingly voted This past Measure J to create a fund to transform LA County into the care first vision our communities desperately want to see. Measure J is vital to the county's commitment to close Men's Central Jail without a replacement and building out a continuum of care and services our community members need. Many programs in the jail closure implementation team's plan to close MCJ rely on funding from Measure J and CFCI. Losing this funding would be a devastating blow to our communities.

Disposing the will of the people because of an oversight by those in power would be an injustice to the residents of LA County. Make this right, protect Measure J now and in the future. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:10:50

Thank you. Caller with phone number starting at 8183 ending in 00 your line is unmuted please state your name and begin. Caller please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 36Proposed3:11:03

Yes yes can you hear me? Thank you. Thank you, John. Yes, thank you. Thank you. This is Sir in Alta Vena District 5. Thank you all the families there and everyone calling on the line. You know mistakes happen and opposition is real but to God be the glory right? It sounds to me like yeah this I know you guys are going to affirm that now you're gonna pass it but not only message a but the expansion to measure G never we share the song Justice shall return to right and the upright will follow it. This is the upright following the right will of the people what was called for regardless of the lawsuits, regardless of the shim-sham.

Yes yes and let it expand if that's what I heard to the new district and everyone has to honor care first community initiative we keep us safe yeah job space Michael four and four

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:12:03

Thank you. Caller with phone number starting in 7142 ending in 96, your line is unmuted please state your name and begin. Hi caller please begin. Hello

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated3:12:16

can you hear me?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:12:18

Yes please begin.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated3:12:19

My name is Trav Co I urge you to listen to the people that spoke here today And voters that have already voted on this. The funding is for the people. I also work for the Social Impact Center and our expansion of services are essential for communities of color who disproportionately face incarceration, violence in the justice system. It is the board's responsibility and duty to uphold and preserve Measure J, the way that the people intended their votes to do. It is a life-and-death situation for some of us as we know that the prisons only do harm and deliver more pain to our black and brown brothers and sisters. To our queer and trans Angelenos that you serve on this board Chair first, jails last. It's not only an initiative that works but it should be an ethos for all of us here.

Compassion goes a long way and your vote here is your compassion in action. 9000 cops in Los Angeles and they get 24% of the general.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:13:18

Thank you. Lauren Scott and your line is unmuted please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 37Proposed3:13:24

Well thank you for bringing this motion. Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath You know, all these folks have already said so much more than I could really say. I'm a resident ST3 by the way. I just think this is just such a ridiculous miscarriage of justice and I think calling it an administrative error while sure it might be an error. It's either you know grossly negligent Or intentional.

I strongly urge the board to pursue other measures to investigate what happened, how this happened and why we now need to you know pending approval of this motion. We need to go and vote again to protect this measure that shouldn't have to happen in the first place. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:14:15

Thank you does our holiday your line is unmuted please begin

PresenterGiselle HollidayYouth Justice CoalitionProposedself-stated3:14:19

again.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:14:20

Can you hear me? Yes, please

PresenterGiselle HollidayYouth Justice CoalitionProposedself-stated3:14:23

My name is Giselle Holliday with the Youth Justice Coalition. I'm in support of Measure J because I was a youth who needed support. I've always had some forms of support, like access to a job. I work for WOCAC Workforce Center which gave me the opportunity to provide for myself and feel accomplished. Affordable housing is something that I've also struggled with, something that the whole California needs. Even the people who live in houses can't afford rent and the cost of living because rent is sky high. And some people are a paycheck away and a job lost away from being homeless. I'm in support of Measure J because it represents a promise that county budgeting will begin to address long-standing racial and economic inequities affecting black, brown, and low income disabled and system impacted communities.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:15:10

Thank you. Your line is unmuted, please begin. Hi,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 38Proposed3:15:16

I'm Napoleon. I work for brilliant corners and I am also a member of united the union there. I'm calling in support of measure J. We have invested too long in prison as a solution and we should be investing in our communities instead. We have a program called Breaking Barriers where we support justice impacted folks, and we have seen that investment in their health and in their homes and in their pursuit of careers.

It provides dividends to the community and allows them to be a cornerstone for other people in their communities to rely on, as well as giving them safety to pursue their own lives to the best of their own desires and respecting and honoring their humanity. We would really love to see this type of opportunity continue to exist in Los Angeles, as that is the wilder people. We know that people deserve their right to pursue the best

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:16:16

Thank you. Call with phone number starting in 7189 ending in 42 your line is unmuted please state your name and begin. Caller please begin.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated3:16:28

Good afternoon Supervisors, Evette Allais-Ferlito Executive Director of LABESADS part of the Reimagine L.A. Coalition and resident of District 1 I want to thank Supervisor Mitchell for your ongoing leadership and Supervisor Horvath are being in solidarity with community members that are in support of Measure J. I was part of the initial organizing team that came up with the idea for Measure J, and came to you, to this board, to put Measure J on the ballot. And thanks to the solidarity between the community and this board we got Measure J on the ballot and we got it passed with over two million votes. This is a win for the community but it was also a win for this board and it's faffling to me how over the years The board hasn't treated Measure J like the win that it should have been treated and continues to be in the community.

We have heard from so many community members today who have been directly supported by Measure J funding. It is saving lives, and it's also supporting the council...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:17:30

Thank you Yasmin Shouki your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentYasmin ShokaProposedself-stated3:17:36

Hi, good morning Supervisors. My name is Yasmin Shoka and I am a member of the Reimagine LA Coalition and a Community Engagement and Policy Intern with Law Defensa. I urge you to support Supervisor Holly Mitchell's motion to protect Measure J. More than 2.1 million Los Angeles County voters approved Measure J because they wanted our county to invest in people not just punishment. Measure J represents a commitment to care first investments that help prevent incarceration by funding housing, mental health services, youth programs, violence prevention and other community based resources. These investments make our communities safer by addressing the root causes of harm. Weakening or appealing measure J would ignore the will of the voters and put these critical investments at risk.

I urge you to honor the public's vote protect measure J and ensure care for spending remains a priority for Los Angeles County. Thank you.

3:18 – 3:2529 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:18:28

Thank you. Will the following individuals please come forward and staff will assist you? Elizabeth Sanchez, Coco Cornspan, Vanessa Melendrez, Dr. Critical Truthpayh, Eleonora Olden, Carolyn Oropes, Lolita De La Cruz, Faye Omondock, Aurora Recento, Josephine Dupre, Josephine Bickler, Karina Reyo, Claudia Jerez, Amy Stubblefield, Juana Lambert, Isaac Gonzalez, and Sean Hugh. We will continue with in-person speakers, please begin.

CommentSean HuffProposedself-stated3:19:00

Good morning my name is Sean Huff with Californians for Safety and Justice I want to start by thanking Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for authorizing authoring this motion CJCJ just released a report based on statistics released by DOJ which shares that California experienced a 13 percent drop in crime rates in 2025 bringing crime to its lowest numbers in recorded history This is the type of increase in community safety, which is a direct result of the type of community safety investments that more than two million voters intended when we originally voted to pass Measure J. Therefore I ask all supervisors to support Agenda Item 7 to protect Measure J as voted on by the people of Los Angeles. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:19:46

Thank you next speaker please

CommentBebe OlivaresProposedself-stated3:19:54

Hi, good afternoon. My name is Bebe Olivares and I live in Los Angeles.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:20:01

I'm here to support my TGI community and to support the Trans Latina Coalition And I am calling to whom it may concern, to support us with community funds. To be able to cover the need for affordable housing and also for mental health

not transcribed≈20s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentBebe OlivaresProposedself-stated3:20:43

which is indispensable Ya que nuestra comunidad ha sufrido violencia y discriminación.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:20:51

Because of the fact that our community has suffered violence and discrimination.

CommentBebe OlivaresProposedself-stated3:20:55

Cuando solicitan esos servicios.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:20:57

When we ask for these services.

CommentBebe OlivaresProposedself-stated3:20:59

Y a través de la Organización Trans-Latina Coalition.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:21:02

And through the Organization Trans-Latina Coalition.

CommentBebe OlivaresProposedself-stated3:21:05

Se nos facilita ese proceso.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:21:07

They help facilitate this process.

CommentBebe OlivaresProposedself-stated3:21:10

Gracias.

PresenterErrol DykesAngels of Change and the Trans Latina Coalition speaking on item sevenProposedself-stated3:21:10

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:21:12

Thank you, next speaker please?

PresenterErrol DykesAngels of Change and the Trans Latina Coalition speaking on item sevenProposedself-stated3:21:14

Good afternoon, my name is Errol Dykes. I'm here representing Angels of Change and the Trans Latina Coalition speaking on item seven. The people have voted in protecting the voice of the community should be the top priority. Where was the transparency? And how are you going to make that right concerning measure seven? The cost, mental health and long-term result of crisis prevention models speak volumes in comparison to the negative impact of the incarceration model. How do we lessen the traumatic impact of incarceration on TGI citizens? Many times our victims of domestic violence are in need of stable housing and paths to self empowerment.

Services that align with Measure J like education, healthcare and housing navigation help me personally with keeping an essential positive mindset. We need so much more of this. The repeal of Measure J threatens the trust of the people.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:22:16

Thank you next

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:22:17

speaker please. Good afternoon my name is Renee Ocampo.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 39Proposed3:22:24

And I reside in District 10 of the city

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:22:36

I would like to express my concern for the growing housing

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 39Proposed3:22:39

crisis,

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:22:42

and that affects many working families.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 39Proposed3:22:45

So this situation affects the economic stability of families

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated3:22:57

And it limits opportunities for those who are seeking an opportune housing situation. I ask you to improve the housing and living situation for all marginalized communities. Thank you, Supervisors.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 40Proposed3:23:19

Thank you. Next speaker please? Good afternoon, Supervisors. My name is Lupita and I am here with the Young Women's Freedom Center urging you to protect Measure J funding. Measure J is an investment in people not punishment. It funds community-based organizations that address the root cause of harm by providing housing, mental health support, violence prevention, reentry services, and alternatives to incarceration. At the Young Women's Freedom Center, these investments allow us to do more than provide services. We help young women and gender expansive youth reclaim their power, build self-determination and create futures on their own terms. We walk alongside young people as they heal from trauma, access opportunities, strengthen their leadership and break cycles of incarceration and poverty.

The board has committed to divesting from incarceration and investing in community Protect Measure J means keeping the promise. When you invest in organizations like ours, you're investing in healing leadership and safer communities for all. I urge you to protect Measure J funding. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:24:19

Thank you. Next speaker please.

CommentCynthia MesaProposedself-stated3:24:22

Hello my name is Cynthia Mesa. I am a credible messenger with Young Women's Freedom Center. I'm here to speak on item 7, Let's Protect Measure LA County probation has had over a hundred twenty three years of causing harm to the city of Los Angeles. Measure J needs more than just six years if we even want to begin to try to touch all the harm that's been caused by you guys protecting measure J, you guys will be ensuring that we can keep on doing the work to give the community alternatives to healing from all their harm and from the county from all the harm that's been caused by LA County probation and the jail institutions that we have Thank

CommentCassidy MalonadoProposedself-stated3:25:03

you. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon. My name is Cassidy Malonado. I'm part of District 1. I've been affected by the system since I was 15 years old and I'm here today to ask you to please fix the mistake in taking consideration that little help we got from you guys is to help our kids grow and heal. Like Freedom Circle, help me and the young people to socialize and leave the hate behind. Young Mothers United helped me and the young moms know that we are not alone and we have The Village. Please protect Measure J and free the 50 girls. Thank you.

3:25 – 3:3211 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 41Proposed3:25:44

Good afternoon, my name is Evelyn and I am a fellow at the Young Women's Freedom Center. I'm here today to speak on Item 7. Without funding our programs may be reduced or eliminated leaving fewer opportunities for young girls and gender expansive youth to stay engaged receive mentorship and prepare for future success in schools and their communities. Our youth programs provide safe spaces to learn new skills build self-confidence develop healthy relationships participate in positive Activities and Hill. I currently facilitate a young mothers program in this amazing feeling to see our young moms enjoy and give their full attention to every session. Let's continue this good work by protecting Measure J. Thank you for your time.

Thank you, next speaker please.

PresenterIsaac GonzalezCreative ActsProposedself-stated3:26:27

Good afternoon, my name is Isaac Gonzalez and I'm the Executive Director of Creative Acts. I am here urging you to support the motion to enshrine Measure J in the new county governance structure and the difference these investments make on the ground. Creative Acts is a ready-to-rise NCFCI grantee and has been able to significantly expand our work inside juvenile halls and camps. Our Art Attacks program is a civic engagement program using the arts to help Transitional age youth to understand their own power and the tool of voting to transform their communities. When we started in 2018, the voting rate was 35%. After our program it was 100%, not magic but proof that the arts are the most effective vehicle for people to be able to receive and retain information and inspire them to act on it.

I should know, I was once in those very prisons. Thank you.

PresenterVanessa MelendrezFilipino Workers CenterProposedself-stated3:27:27

Good afternoon, board. My name is Vanessa Melendrez and I am with the Filipino Workers Center. And we also are in SD1 and I live in SD3. I ask you to vote to approve item seven. L.A. County is one of the most diverse counties in America. That is why voters voted to approve Measure J, a measure that invests in restorative justice instead of punitive justice. As we know, the punitive justice system disproportionately affects black and brown communities. That is why it is essential that we vote with our values as LA County and vote yes on item 7 to preserve Measure J. Thank you so much.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:28:11

We will now go back to remote speakers. Caller with phone number 2138 ending in 50, your line is unmuted. Please state your name and begin. Caller please begin. We'll go to the next caller, Anthony Robles. Your line is unmuted please begin.

PresenterAnthony Robles I'mDignity Empowered Now and the Justice LA and Care First California coalitions inProposedself-stated3:28:29

Hello my name is Anthony Robles I'm a resident of District 1 representing Dignity Empowered Now and the Justice LA and Care First California coalitions in 2020 LA County voters passed Measure J with 57 percent of the vote. A clear democratic mandate for community investment over incarceration and now because of an administrative error the public is being forced to fight for it again and that is not how democracy works. Voters should not have to rewind a mandate they already earned So we need to ask, how did this happen? Who was responsible for ensuring voter approved charter provisions carried forward into the new governance structure. Who failed to catch this and when did the board find out? Are there backdoor dealings happening to create situations like this?

A second battle for Measure J exposes a settled question to new political conditions that did not exist in 2020. The error was the counties and the cost should not fall back on the community. I agree with the previous comment that this is grossly negligent or criminally intentional, both which require accountability for the responsible parties so the board must answer what systemic safeguards we put in place to ensure no voter approved charter provision is ever lost again in a structural transition and what does accountability look like for the parties?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:29:32

Thank you Roy Humphreys your line is unmuted please begin

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed3:29:37

Jails last is a good idea, but jails are essential and in all cases done right. As Sheriff Leroy Baca and Tanaka can tell you yes if you do the crime as decided by jury of your peers, you get to do the time. The historical failure to fund this system commensurate with the mission and separate the jails from the sheriff is a self fulfilling prophecy Would tell you.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:30:09

Thank you, Emily Zamora. Your line is unmuted please begin.

CommentEmily ZamoraProposedself-stated3:30:15

Hi, my name is Emily Zamora resident of District 2. I'm the policy and campaigns coordinator with Youth Justice Coalition and I'm calling in support of Holly J Mitchell's A motion to protect Measure J as one of the strongest public demands with over 2.1 million L.A. County voters that voted in support, which made a clear move towards care and not cops. Measure J is a critical component of our fight towards supporting our beloved community getting essential resources including affordable housing, mental health resources, re-entry support for those coming back home Youth development and job pathways for our most vulnerable communities. All of these supports invest in safer, healthier life outcomes for our community that is still recovering from a pandemic growing inflation prices increased policing of our black and brown youth extreme levels of housing crisis and rampant ICE attacks throughout our neighborhoods.

Measure J acts as an accountability marker upholding a shift in county budgeting to dismantle historical, racial and economic disparities affecting low-income black and brown communities of people with disabilities and our system's most impacted.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:31:16

Thank you. Tahita Shakur your line is unmuted please begin. Tahita please begin. Hi can y'all hear me? Yes please begin

CommentTasha CoreProposedself-stated3:31:29

Hold on, okay. Good morning my name is Tasha Core with you just close and I'm here in support of Measure J the 4th of July just passed and while many people celebrate it, I believe our values are measured by how we invest in our communities not by fireworks. As Fannie Lou Hamer said, nobody's free until everybody is free. Measure J invests in the things that actually keep people safe and healthy. Affordable housing, mental health services, violence prevention and healing, and youth justice, re-entry support, and community based separation programs. These are life saving investments that address the root causes of instability, harm, and criminalization. They help keep families housed, support young people, and give people the resources Good morning.

not transcribed≈19s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

3:32 – 3:3817 turns

PresenterDerek StillsSocial Justice Learning Institute and also a member of the Los Angeles County GoProposedself-stated3:32:35

Actually, good afternoon. My name is Derek Stills, Executive Director of Social Justice Learning Institute and also a member of the Los Angeles County Governance Reform Task Force. I want to express my strong support for item seven and thank Supervisor Holly Mitchell for her leadership and Supervisor Lindsay Horwath for bringing this forward. Nearly six years, Measure J has represented the will of Los Angeles County and was approved by the people upheld by the courts and through the Care First Community Investment Framework As already directed hundreds of millions of dollars into housing, youth development and mental health reentry violence prevention and community based organizations that have positively impacted hundreds of thousands of Angelenos.

Today we have the opportunity to finally complete that work by enshrining Measure J in permanently making sure that it is a part of the charter at a time when federal funding cuts and growing economic uncertainty is happening these community investments are more important than ever about taking this action today You are protecting voter intent, strengthening public trust and ensuring that this commitment in the communities continues for generations to come.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:33:35

Thank you. Caller with phone number 6264 ending in 9-3 your line is unmuted please state your name and begin. Caller please begin we will go to the next caller Collar starting with three two three six ending in nine nine your line is unmuted please state your name and begin.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated3:34:01

Hear me

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:34:05

yes we can hear you please begin.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated3:34:09

Good afternoon, my name is Gabriela Vasquez. I'm the Deputy Director at La Defensa and a lifelong resident of Supervisorial District 1. I want to thank Supervisor Holly Mitchell for not only just having the bravery but looking at what our government actually needs to create for our communities and rectifying this wrong. Thank you to Supervisor Horvath for joining in on this motion. My message today is that I would like unanimous support of this motion Angeleno's are tired of having to be part Thank you caller with phone

not transcribed≈27s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:35:12

number 2 1 3 8 ending in 5 0 your line is unmuted please state your name and begin.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated3:35:21

Good afternoon my name is Alexandra Morales and a resident of C1 on behalf of the Member Defenders Law Center we urge the county to continue advancing the process to restore Measure J. The county must continue to honor the commitment made through Measure J as first adopted by thousands of voters Care First investments funded by Measure J remain critical to supporting vulnerable populations across the county, divesting from incarceration and detention and investing in the well-being and stability of our communities. It has also become critical in responding to the evolving needs of a historically marginalized community. As the County moves forward with restoring Measure J we want to underscore that these commitments were always meant to be the floor and not the fielding in Care First's amendments.

Thank you and please vote on the motion.

not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:36:24

Yes, we can hear you. Please begin.

PresenterAnn KomoroscUnited StatesProposedself-stated3:36:26

Oh, so my name is Ann Comaraz nonpartisan president of the United States 2026. Oh 2028. How are you doing?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:36:41

Please continue.

PresenterAnn KomoroscUnited StatesProposedself-stated3:36:44

So I am nonpartisan president candidate for 2028. So President Trump has issued that no more mail-in ballots in LA County and I support...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed3:37:00

Ma'am, this is agenda item 7 you can get back in queue for general public comment

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:37:07

Thank you next caller starting with phone number 6 to 6. Ending in 9, 3, your line is unmuted please state your name and begin. I

CommentVictoria GomezProposedself-stated3:37:18

can hear me

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:37:19

yes we can hear you please begin.

CommentVictoria GomezProposedself-stated3:37:22

Hi, my name is Victoria Gomez. I use she they pronouns and I am a lifelong Angeleno and resident of Janice Hans District. I urge y'all to support item 7 and restore Measure J. I have seen firsthand how Measure J has supported and changed the lives of youth especially girls and trans youth in LA County. In addition it's been a lifeline for local nonprofits and community organizations who are doing hard work every day I know you guys are going to do the right thing in passing this, so I urge you after that to fully implement Measure J and make sure that all of the money is actually used and going to where it's needed.

Making sure that all Measure J funds are accessible to community providers, transparent to the public, protected from bureaucratic delays, and fully funded every year because as we know every year Measure J spends millions of unspent dollars So I urge you to do the right thing and after the fact, make sure there's full implementation. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:38:16

Thank you George Garcia. Your line is unmuted please begin.

3:38 – 3:4416 turns

PresenterGeorge GarciaYouth Justice Coalition and I am here for public commentProposedself-stated3:38:24

Can you guys hear me?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:38:26

Yes, please begin.

PresenterGeorge GarciaYouth Justice Coalition and I am here for public commentProposedself-stated3:38:28

Hello, my name is George Garcia and I'm here with the Youth Justice Coalition and I am here for public comment. And I'm also here to support Measure J being restored. Why? Because Measure J helps a lot of people in South Central to continue to exist and survive with the help that they offer. They offer many resources especially for our youth whether it's jobs, mental health crisis help or any other resources like affordable housing We need to restore it so that people won't be displaced because I am even affected. So please keep funding Measure J, because without it, I would have been jobless. Because of Measure J, I was able to get a job in high school at Chucos Justice Center and it gave me stability and helped a lot.

I was able to pay my rent and I was able to pay my bills. It gave me a lot of stability and help. Please support Measure J. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:39:17

Thank you. Caller with phone number starting at 9514 ending in 64 your line is unmuted please state your name and begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 42Proposed3:39:25

Thank you California Assemblymember Isaac Bryan I want to thank Supervisors Mitchell and Horvath for item 7 enshrining Measure J in the state or in the county charter is something that the voters We have to protect measure J.

not transcribed≈26s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:40:09

Thank you. Kimberly Renee, your line is unmuted please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 43Proposed3:40:17

Good afternoon, my name is Kimberly and I'm a member of the Youth Justice Coalition and in support of the Reimagine LA coalition. I'm here in strong support of agenda item seven. In 2020 we overwhelmingly voted Measure JM because we wanted lasting investment in our communities alternatives to incarceration and a care first approach As the county continues implementing Measure G, it's critical that this commitment is protected not weakened or lost because it changes in government. Voters have already made their choice and the board's responsibility is to honor the voters' choice Protecting Measure J means protecting the communities that rely on connections to job, therapy, diversion programs and other resources. And ensuring future county leaders remain accountable.

I owe you to vote yes on this motion and uphold the will of the voters. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:41:15

Thank you. Caller with phone number starting in 3107 ending in 68 your line is unmuted please state your name and begin

CommentLisa Gordon KaneProposedself-stated3:41:25

Hello this is 9 to 6 8 the line is open.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:41:29

Yes please begin.

CommentLisa Gordon KaneProposedself-stated3:41:31

OK my name is Lisa Gordon Kane and I work why I'm a woman. And I'm calling in because I find it almost incredulous that we are even being posed with this question because of an error that the people did not make. In addition to that, I'm going to say that this is why we need people with lived experience to participate and be on these boards, because I'm sure they would be much more arduous and purposeful in making sure these kinds of mistakes did not occur. With 2.1 million people voting for this, the fact that people are even being asked to do this again especially in this climate I think you all must be aware. Thank you for your time and thank you Holly.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:42:13

Thank you caller with phone number starting in 3233 ending in 105 please state your name and begin. Caller please begin Okay, the caller has dropped Madam Chair. There are no other remote speakers to address the board. Remote participation for item 7 is now concluded we will go back to in-person speakers please begin Good afternoon

CommentKarina RayoProposedself-stated3:42:43

supervisors My name is Karina Rayo, an LGBTQ plus resident of South Los Angeles District 2 and student at El Camino College. I'm speaking today in strong and unwavering support of fully restoring and implementing Measure J. When LA County voters passed this measure we made a clear mandate to reinvest at least 10% of our locally generated unrestricted funds into community care youth development affordable housing and mental health services. We voted to move away from punitive custodial systems and toward healing and economic opportunity for our most impacted neighbors.

The recent administrative oversight that put Major Jay in jeopardy cannot be allowed to derail this critical promise. I urge this board to use every administrative tool, legislative and legal at your disposal to permanently enshrine and enforce these protections. Please correct the charter, secure this funding and honor the will of the voters. Our communities cannot wait any longer for these vital investments. Thank you.

CommentElizabeth Sanchez-SheherProposedself-stated3:43:34

Thank you next speaker please. Good afternoon. My name is Elizabeth Sanchez-Sheher, a resident of SD2 and the program manager at the Young Women's Freedom Center. I'm here to protect Measure J. For many, Measure J funds are the difference between stability and crisis. At YWFC we see this in our healing circles, our support groups, affirming care for gender expansive and trans youth And the staffing of our incredible self-determined coordinators and credible messengers who make daily visits inside juvenile halls to work directly with our youth inside Camp Kilpatrick, as well as outside in our reentry programs. From staffing, creating curriculum and running programs, to building trust within our community, Measure J is imperative to the preventative measures and reducing recrimination to the young women and the gender expansive youth we serve.

Please restore Measure J. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:44:22

Thank you. Next speaker please?

CommentCoco CornspanProposedself-stated3:44:25

Hi, my name is Coco Cornspan. I am the Southern California Regional Director for Young Women's Freedom Center and Beloved Village. I'm here to speak in favor of Measure J. The CFCI funding that Measure J provides to Young Women's Freedom Center and Beloved Village is very important to our mission of supporting girls and gender expansive youth in their re-entry from incarceration and back into their community.

It has allowed us to support youth and families with various services such as safe housing, mental health services Thank you. Next speaker, please?

not transcribed≈17s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

3:45 – 3:509 turns

CommentAmy StubblefieldProposedself-stated3:45:14

Hello, my name is Amy Stubblefield and I live in Santa Clarita and I work in the city of San Fernando. I voted for Measure J and I was so proud of my fellow Angelenos when it overwhelmingly passed. I was at the same time highly skeptical of the permanent nature of the funding based on previous experience with government funding. Then measure G passed and here we are, exactly where I predicted we would be eventually.

After hearing the supervisor's comments at the beginning of the discussion of this agenda item and your positive comments about measure J, I realized happily that most of us didn't likely need to be here to talk in support however since I drove all the way and paid $24 for parking, I decided to stay. I represent a small nonprofit organization that has received CFCI funding for the past 10 years. We've been able to provide mental health services to help people live violence-free. Please vote to keep this funding available for our community and for the nonprofit. Thank you, next speaker please.

PresenterCarlina RopezLos Angeles Boys and GirlProposedself-stated3:46:17

Hello, my name is Carlina Ropez. I'm a resident of Catherine Barger's district, Altadena and I'm wearing my Altadena hat today. I am speaking though on behalf of the Los Angeles Boys and Girls Club located in Hilda Solis' district. We urge you to protect Measure J. Measure J funding has transformed what's possible for us to do to support teens of Northeast Los Angeles through our boys and girls club We've been able to help over 300 teens explore and develop their passions and turn those passions into jobs, small and micro businesses, and help keep those young people out of the justice system.

We ask you to protect Measure J and keep support for our organization and many, many other important organizations that are making a difference through Measure J. Please vote yes on item number seven. And we invite you to come visit us and the many organizations out there doing the work Come by any time. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:47:19

Thank you, next speaker

PresenterJuana LambertProposedself-stated3:47:20

please. Yes my name is Juana Lambert and I am also from the Los Angeles Boys & Girls Club and I'm the Executive Director. I live in District 5 and I am representing here our club which is just below Dodger Stadium in District 1 with Hilda Solis. So I'm speaking to you today because this measure really works. It is critical to our communities, where kids are in jeopardy of becoming gang members every day from the influence of multi-generational families and the community that still has a problem and lures kids.

to the gang and crimes side of life. But our club has a beautiful space that we've drawn through this grant, that offers a maker space and a recording studio and it is filled with teens right now as we speak. And that's what makes the difference. Thank you next speaker please.

CommentDr. Critical Rahel Desire-TruthbayProposedself-stated3:48:25

Yes I support, I mean we all support this motion particularly. For Measure J I want you to focus on the oversight for the Los Angeles County Probation Department as Measure J has been a very important measure there are still abuses especially with the long-term mental effect causing from probation officers so You have still sexual misconduct. You still have those who are being talked down to, abused. Some of these probation officers' asses need to be whipped on a severe measure. But since we don't promote violence children that we definitely need to have some oversight on pre-training probation officers. So as you preserve Measure J, to continue to put in alternatives For the youth, it goes a long way. So when they come out they don't come out worse off than when they went in so let's not be hypocritical and continue to be on this motion.

So thank you for supporting Measure J.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 34Proposed3:49:26

Thank you next speaker please I have to say oversight is good, but I want to say this. It's important to know that once Measure J gets in place that you make an assessment of the measurements of the items that are delineated on Measure J that are set for recovery like I know the oversight is good. Because of the abuses and everything, but I think it's important that you understand that the community has to also have a responsibility To put forth a commitment to these programs For them to work.

not transcribed≈17s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed3:50:30

Thank You madam chair members of the board that concludes public comment on this item

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role3:50:34

Madam Chair item 7 is before you

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role3:50:37

Thank you. Moved by Supervisor Mitchell, seconded by Supervisor Horvath to approve the item. Executive Officer call the roll.

Roll-call vote Passed 4–0 Moved by Holly J. Mitchell · Seconded by Lindsey P. Horvath Moved by Supervisor Mitchell, seconded by Supervisor Horvath to approve the item. Executive Officer call the roll.
Show transcript
Supervisor Mitchell? Aye. Supervisor Mitchell aye. Supervisor Horvath? Aye. Supervisor Horvath aye. Supervisor Hahn? Aye Supervisor Hahn aye. Supervisor Barger? Abstain. Super Supervisor Barger abstention. Supervision Solis? Aye

3:50 – 3:577 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role3:50:58

Supervision Solis aye that measure passes with four votes yes one vote with an abstention We will now

move on to Item 9, implementation of Measure E.R., the Essential Services Restoration Act for Los Angeles County. We will now

move on to item A1, Proclaimed Local Emergency Boyle Heights Commercial Building Fire which was held by Supervisor Solis. For members of the public joining us remotely to comment on this item please use the raise hand feature if you are online or press star three F on a telephone. Anthony Maroney, fire chief John O'Brien, Chief Deputy Emergency Operations Mario Treseras, Chief Health Hazardous Materials Fire Department Dr. Barbara Ferrer, Director of Public Health Dr. Muntu Davis, Medical Director Department of Public Health Mark Pastrea, Director of Public Works. Kevin McGowan, Director of the Office of Emergency Management and Scott Kuhn, Assistant County Counselor available for questions. For the departmental speakers please state your name and title for the record when you address the board.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role3:52:05

Okay thank you. Colleagues, I'm holding this item again A1 for an update on the Boyle Heights East LA fire emergency. And I want to thank all of you here for your continued support especially our county representatives and your departments in AQMD and others that have been on top of as much as we can in the past almost three weeks. I especially want to recognize the residents of the unincorporated East Los Angeles area that I represent in the first district, the community and the coverage area was the largest impacted population while we hear that it's the Boyle Heights yes the facility is located in the city of Los Angeles but the majority of people residents who live alongside that facility represent about 118,000 folks. And we know that the impact went even far beyond our boundaries.

We had calls from Monterey Park, from Commerce, Montebello and other neighboring communities. Although the bulk of the main fire has been put out, that's my understanding and I hope someone will verify that. The impacted communities continue to deal with the fallout from the incident and significant amounts of debris as we know remain in a facility that needs to be removed, cleared including the rotting meat and other food byproducts.

And this presents both a nuisance and a potential public health risk to surrounding communities. And must be disposed of quickly but safely and appropriately. However, as you all may have seen in the media reports over the weekend there has been a troubling rise in finger pointing among involved parties including Leenage and their various contractors. This has slowed down the cleanup, but I understand just now that they have resumed cleanup and maybe someone can clarify that for us as well.

And the recovery process in communities however I believe are still suffering. In fact residents community leaders and businesses elected officials from across Boyle Heights East LA San Gabriel Valley in the southeast We as a county in my belief should continue to stand with and support the impacted residents, especially those in the unincorporated communities that are looking directly to us for assistance. And I want to thank you, the panel and the departments for joining us again.

Being here today is very important, and I would like to ask a few questions for a status update and to uplift those community concerns. So I want to begin by asking Kevin McGowan our Director for OEM, Office of Emergency Management. If he can provide us with the latest status update for the response including the cleanup and debris removal.

not transcribed≈17s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
PresenterKim McGowanOffice of Emergency ManagementProposedself-stated3:55:24

Good afternoon, Supervisor. For the record, Kim McGowan, Director of the Office of Emergency Management. A quick update and then my partners and colleagues up here from the various departments can provide some specifics. The update we were provided yesterday afternoon and into the evening from LA City was that Transition of the facility has been fully moved to lineage. So up until last night, LA City Fire and the broader city were still heavily engaged in a partnership with controlling the facility because of the fire and the ongoing smoldering. And then that has now completely transitioned over to the facility.

In addition to that, Lineage's subcontractor that is focused on remediation and debris removal and stabilizing the facility has brought in an incident management team to go through a structured response and recovery effort in relationship to the debris removal operations. And hosts daily workshops with all of the different governmental entities that have either a regulatory or an operational It was reported that there was a period of a pause, but the latest update we got this morning was that there were operations related to debris removal that were starting to go back into operations which was welcoming news.

And that there's a balance with the incident management team and then the governmental agencies to make sure, as you said it Supervisor that it's done expeditiously but in a safe and responsible manner consistent with the regulations. And that the plans that they're making are pre-approved by the different regulatory groups.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role3:57:17

And who are some of those regulatory groups just so the public is aware?

PresenterKim McGowanOffice of Emergency ManagementProposedself-stated3:57:22

Our Department of Public Works, our Department of Public Health play critical roles in reviewing their plans. Our fire department is also engaged as the primary group and they can express their specifics in what roles they're playing.

3:57 – 4:1422 turns

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role3:57:40

Okay, I wanted to note for the public that we have stood up with your help OEM and with the assistance of many volunteers and disaster workers. The distribution since it started approximately over 9000 purifiers including boxes of food cases of water and 96 masks Having federally qualified clinics including our own DHS mobile unit, health mobile unit situated at the Civic Center. I can't tell you how many people have come through but I know that many were visited by our nurses and our physicians and folks that were there. Now keep in mind, most of those clinics are not receiving any compensation. And many have put in long hours and the list kind of goes on. But I also want to point out to the public as well as to our departments and I wanna particularly thank the assistance of the disaster service workers because they also helped us distribute things but they were more importantly also representing departments inside the largest recovery center, which is at East L.A.

Library and joining us also in recent days has been AQMD, which I am very happy to see since we last saw Director Wayne Nastry here at our last meeting. But the disaster workers, we had about 74 of them that were deployed and assisted in helping our community recover and I hope that they continue to be accessible because my understanding is that we are supposed to be coming to an end by Wednesday and that to me is kind of an artificial date.

Maybe you could talk a little bit about that Kevin?

PresenterKim McGowanOffice of Emergency ManagementProposedself-stated3:59:32

Yes, thanks Supervisor. One just a big shout out to your team has been really at the forefront at this site and doing a great job at supporting and leading the efforts there along with the disaster service workers who get this is Something that the county has really matured since the COVID period of time where we've utilized disaster service workers from a variety of departments to go out and support our communities.

Our continued work with your staff is to determine what will be like the duration of that time. So I know initially Wednesday, I think we're going further than Wednesday and we're just working out the details of what that exact timeline's gonna be.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:00:18

Good, I'm not clear but I hope to get that information because we

PresenterKim McGowanOffice of Emergency ManagementProposedself-stated4:00:21

obviously... We'll report back to you with a specific date.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:00:24

Is that, pardon me?

PresenterKim McGowanOffice of Emergency ManagementProposedself-stated4:00:25

We will be able to find a specific date with your team.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:00:27

Okay good and I do want to thank my team because they've just been involved around the clock 24 hours weekends and what have you and have really worked also with community-based organizations who are doing the volunteer work whether it was even Youth at Work Park students I want to give them a shout out who were at the Belvedere site and other sites helping us with distribution and helping to set up, and talking to people as they were coming in and directing them. I also want to thank the various CBOs and also the church, Victoria that opened up their church right, which is adjacent very close to this facility and most of the impacted families that we saw there and you were there that day as well as our CEO could see the type of folks that were impacted that were coming in and expressing their concerns about exposure to smoke and issues with respiratory ailments that they were having or experiencing.

And I think that's when we knew further that we had to do more on a larger scale. We opened up then, we ended up having about three different sites but the largest one at the East LA Civic Center and it still remains so I wanna continue that and I want assurances too from AQMD because I really appreciate when Wayne Nastry was here that he talked about not just examining the levels of smoke and particulate matter But other things that can also be found in our atmosphere, or in households or businesses. And how to provide assistance to families and owners that maybe have had their homes or their businesses impacted by smoke and it's still there. So could you briefly go over that? I do wanna say this though publicly. AQMD and also one of our board members that sits on AQMd were at a meeting last week.

I think it was held last Friday, and there was a committee meeting and a vote to provide assistance to impacted residents for this particular purpose, and I believe there was an allocation dollars is what I was told and we did send a letter in it to affirm that and to urge members of that AQMD board to vote for that. And as a result, we're now going to be receiving about anywhere from four to five thousand purifiers and they came. They came immediately and you also had staff there. I visited, I saw them yesterday and they were there doing intake and more than just intake. They were actually talking to people And I was very impressed with how organized they were, but also wanting to know how long we could count on them and that support. So can you please go over some of the things that you're responsible for?

CommentJason LoweProposedself-stated4:03:23

Absolutely. So for the record, Jason Lowe, Deputy Executive Officer for the Monitoring Analysis Division at South Coast AQMD. First I want to thank you Supervisors Leis and Supervisor Mitchell for supporting the Air Filtration Initiative. As you mentioned yesterday that initiative began to distribute out the air filters out to the community members We were able to distribute over 240 air filters to community members, and reports at today's distribution at the East Los Angeles Library is indicating that the demand is still very high.

Right now we have a plan to distribute through tomorrow at that location and will continue to do outreach in terms of how to distribute the other for air filtration devices, but I want to thank you for all that support to help the indoor side. But as you know we are more specialty at least on the monitoring analysis side of things for outdoor air. So I think one of the indicators that we look at is within our purview is number of complaints so we have our inspectors responding to each of the different complaints through our 1-800 cut smog number and they do reply back to make sure that they contact each individual who calls that line On the science front for air monitoring, we are taking a primary role for oversight over the contractor data that has been hired by Lineage.

So they are producing data on a daily basis. We've worked with Department of Public Health in collaboration to have more effective communication of that data. One of the barriers to access is that this is a lot of highly technical information with a lot of different pollutants so trying to get that information so it's I'd like to start by saying thank you very much.

assessment of the community error as well as oversight over the contractor data. So we review the data, the data provided by the contractor every single day to see if there's anything that we would consider suspicious or out of line with what we're observing. And then also last week, we did mobile measurements so we drove a mobile laboratory street by street through the neighborhood similar to what we did during active fire incident but this time we were looking for the main components of concern which was volatile organic compounds. During that active fire, we were looking at metals, we were looking at other things that fill in the gaps for the incident command But this time, knowing that the concern is these volatile organic compounds. Some of them are air toxics.

Some of them produce odors. So that's what this mobile platform was looking at on a street-by-street basis to make sure our results were consistent with what the contractor has been doing. Did you

not transcribed≈20s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:06:16

find anything?

CommentJason LoweProposedself-stated4:06:17

So what we found was that for air toxics, what we found was very typical of what we've done in other of our monitoring efforts in this community We do other air monitoring in the East Isla Boyle Heights area under AB 617. So we compared those results to our earlier efforts before the fire, before all this remediation effort. So what we found is at least for air toxics they're pretty similar to what we observed. Any of the components that we saw that were slightly elevated were due to vehicular emissions and then also when we looked at the odors so when we did look at some odor compounds And we can only look at the odor compounds qualitatively, so how much of a difference is that from what we normally see? So we did see up to 25 times higher of some of these odor compounds.

One of them was on the monitor here, methamphetamine, and that's a sulfur-containing compound, and that's a compound that we as human beings can smell very well at very low concentrations. So we did see the elevated levels of these odor compounds And of course, you know, we worked to kind of make sure that hey, you know, with public health, our odor compounds considered what kind of impacts they potentially could have. But at least overall the measurements and levels do indicate what we expect and are consistent the contractor measurements were at the time. And so

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:07:41

there's no reason to be alarmed or is that what you're saying?

CommentJason LoweProposedself-stated4:07:45

Well, I mean, I think there is an impact of odors right? As far as air toxics perspective and air pollutants that directly affect the health and that have known health standards for direct inhalation for those pollutants are pretty typical. However, there is an odor component we've heard Dr. Davis last week indicate that there are potential effects and responses that humans have in response to odors and maybe Dr. Ferreira can expand upon that, but there is the presence of those compounds that we did find in our studies.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:08:20

Are you planning on continuing to have your mobile units in the area for some period of time?

CommentJason LoweProposedself-stated4:08:25

So what I can say is that we're committing to measurements and a lot of us verify what the contractor is seeing. So whether it be a mobile form or may consider other types kind of longer term type of items are things that we're looking to as the contractor finalizes their community air monitoring plan.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:08:43

And you have some say-so in that plan?

CommentJason LoweProposedself-stated4:08:45

Yes, yes, we absolutely do.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:08:47

Because it isn't just the contractor having, you know, the ability to decide what they're going to pay for or what they believe is necessary and it's based on what science?

CommentJason LoweProposedself-stated4:08:58

Yes and basically our practices for doing air monitoring with our extensive experience doing community air monitoring, for doing incident monitoring. We have a vast experience in terms of doing what types of methodologies? What types of coverage in terms of around the fence line or in the community would be appropriate for this type of effort and concern with the community?

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:09:22

Do you do any property inspections or anything like that, or is that not in your purview?

CommentJason LoweProposedself-stated4:09:28

The only thing I can say is that if it involves asbestos, that's something our compliance division would be able to talk to. But that, as far as my knowledge, would be our jurisdiction at that point.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:09:43

Okay, so Dr. Ferrer maybe that's a good segue to talk to us about what the exposure is and the big question is why were we not putting forward an evacuation order? And whose authority is that? And if you could run through that protocol so the public understands.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 44Proposed4:10:03

Yeah, thank you so much. And I wanted to start, Supervisor, by acknowledging your exemplary leadership and how you've brought together the county family so quickly. And i'm grateful to you and your team for all you're doing to support the residents that are affected by this devastating event because it is a devastating event. I know that we're sitting here with the science and we're going to tell you That the numbers particularly on air toxics are not alarming, but smoke is dangerous. Everybody knows that smoke is dangerous for some households that were close to where the fire was they've had smoke damage in their house that needs to be remediated And there's a continuing problem obviously associated with what's called nuisance odors, but are odors that actually can impact the health and well-being of residents in the nearby areas.

And you know we've had residents complaining of nauseousness, of nosebleeds, of irritation in their throat and their eyes. And this is commonly associated with what's called nuisance odors And the best way to address these, what are short term impacts of nuisance odors is to obviously avoid being in an area where those odors are going to impact your health and well-being.

In some cases you can stay in a home. You can use air monitors I mean air filters that actually have activated charcoal in them that will help filter out those odors. But for some residents, the solution is really going to be a relocation, a temporary relocation. You know that we've issued a directive to Lineage. We issued that back in June. I think it was June 29th.

Directing them to implement a community mitigation plan, which includes taking steps to mitigate the impact of both smoke associated damage and nuisance odors. Including coming up with a plan for making sure that people who need to be relocated can be relocated. Lineage was asked to give us their preliminary documents starting yesterday and their final plan is due on the 16th And our team, similar to AQMD, is reviewing those plans to make sure that—and when I say reviewing we're giving them feedback and saying you should include this. You need to include this. We're looking for this so that the plans are complete.

and then fully implemented. I think the goal here is for the responsible party to take full responsibility for mitigating the conditions that are affecting, in very detrimental ways, the residents. Today either today or tomorrow we'll also be issuing local health advisory to all of our providers. We've done this before reminding them of the impact Both of illnesses related to exposure to smoke and illnesses related to nuisance odors.

A course, a short online course that they can take to familiarize themselves with medical and clinical practice associated with diagnosing and responding to those complaints. But again we're sending something out to all providers reminding them that people associated with the event in Boyle Heights in East LA but also people are complaining about Smoke, smoke exposure associated with the fireworks and we're in fire season so we want to do a good reminder to providers to be alert to this.

In terms of your question on you know how our decisions made to evacuate I want to note that all of us who are pretty much sitting here have members that are in what's called incident command Whenever there is a dangerous incident that happens in the communities and an incident command, we share information that we have. from each of our areas. And that allows the incident commander to go ahead and make decisions about what are the safety protocols that need to be put in place?

So, that did happen with this event. Evacuation orders need to be issued by law enforcement. That's really how it happens but it happens when everybody is working together and sharing information to make sure that there are not risks to the public's safety. And I know that Kevin has a lot of experience with this also, so I don't know if he wants to add to...

4:14 – 4:3030 turns

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:14:42

I would just ask who is the final decision maker? Is it a group process or is there one individual? You're saying commander, so who is that?

PresenterKim McGowanOffice of Emergency ManagementProposedself-stated4:14:52

And this incident, Incident Command was comprised of LA City Fire and Los Angeles Police Department. And they were the ones who in that structure, L.A. County had different representation from Public Health, County Fire, Office of Emergency Management, the Sheriff's Department And as different subject matter experts were weighing in and evaluating the information that was being provided by different air monitoring and sensors, decisions were made by those incident commanders which in this case again was LA City Fire and LA Police Department to implement them.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:15:28

And I think there's some confusion out in the public because they, some people may believe that we have the sole authority but because this incident occurred in the boundaries of the city of Los Angeles, what heights is in the city that that's the lead agency or the lead relief. We want to use that word or leadership. Is that correct?

PresenterKim McGowanOffice of Emergency ManagementProposedself-stated4:15:56

It's correct that as it related to the structure fire and then the incident itself, LA City Fire and LAPD were in unified command and incident command and the county was an assisting agency

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:16:09

And I understand that we also had our fire teams there, our fire department chief Moroni and I know we had the hazmat team out there because I actually saw them in action showing me detailed information on screens monitoring levels of smoke. And other things that actually, I guess you have some new equipment where you have drones that can actually go in spaces that you don't want to send human beings into. That can actually record a lot of information and data so do you want to say anything about that?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 45Proposed4:16:44

Yes, certainly Madam Chair. Thank you Anthony Moroney Fire Chief County of Los Angeles Fire Department that is correct the L.A. County Fire Department was an assisting agency to the City of Los Angeles. The City of Los Angeles was the authority having jurisdiction but we did bring personnel from LA County fire not only to help fight the fire but we had our health hazardous materials personnel there to monitor the air quality of the surrounding areas

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:17:10

And that's Mario Tresieras. Fire, yeah. Can you add anything there that you saw? Any cautionary notes there? Obviously at the beginning of the fire there was some ammonia leak and did that permeate the community in any way or the first two blocks? What happened? How is that handled?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 46Proposed4:17:32

Yeah, good afternoon Madam Chair and Supervisors. So our health hazmat teams were dispatched immediately on that fire and plugged in with LAFD being the lead there was an initial concern with the refrigerant with the anhydrous ammonia that had that been breached or released That could have been catastrophic and extremely dangerous. And I believe that is why the reason that the shelter in place order was basically issued there for that location, for the safety. Once that particular issue was mitigated and no longer a hazard along with the lithium ion battery concerns they could have liberated hydrogen fluoride gas. That's when the advisories were sent out and that became more of a commercial industrial type fire.

My team continued to do monitoring and as I expressed two weeks ago, we're utilizing handheld monitors. So we're monitoring the air more for acute hazards right? And so that's where the determination at that point in the advisories were given to LAFD at that point for any decision making processes at that time.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:18:31

Is there anything that you're doing right now with respect to the debris that is still contained in the storage facility? Is there any monitoring that you all do from your department?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 46Proposed4:18:42

So once again, I did go there this morning in person. I actually interviewed one of the contractors there and it's really nice to see that they're buttoning up that facility with some plastic covers that should really minimize some of those odors. And on top of that what I observed were those misters too, right? To help offset those odors. So, as far as my last team member was there last Thursday. They were requested by the Joint Hazard Assessment Team from LAFD regarding concerns for methane gas.

Methane gas is lighter than air. We did send our subject matter expert out there to support the effort and they were extremely low if any concentrations, right? Five percent or 50,000 parts per million for that to be an explosivity hazard. And it was there was no levels of concern for that but we have not had staff per LAFD they said they would continue to do the monitoring and no longer needed health hazmat as of last Thursday.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:19:32

And I wanted to ask about the they used some deodorant to suppress the odors can you tell me what that was? And is it still being used and is it effective?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 46Proposed4:19:45

You know what, I obtained actually a safety data sheet from that. They were using a particular product now it's basically a product that I reviewed the safety data sheet and when you look at the concentration of a chemical there of course you have to provide some particular hazards but they do have statements in item number three of the SDS when it's highly diluted they're indicating there are no health concerns to the public on that safety data sheet

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:20:09

Okay, I wanted to also ask our Department of Public Works what role are you playing in the debris removal? And you've been on the scene since the get-go because obviously the amount of water being used and the flow of that water. We heard different stories about where some of the debris is ending up storm system or water system or LA River. Can you go over some of that with us and then also talk about the infrastructure, the fact that while we look at the planning of getting the debris out of the area what that looks like for the community that's already impacted there?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 47Proposed4:20:52

Yeah, good afternoon Supervisor Luis Ramirez. I'm a Deputy Director at LA County Public Works. So yes, Public Works has been present at the incident as soon as it was safe to do so. We were at the scene as you mentioned to make sure that we were protecting the water quality in the LA River and that is done through making sure that best management practices are established and implemented in all the storm drains surrounding the facility That to minimize the amount of solid particles that would be going into the storm drains. So our teams at Public Works worked with LA County, I mean, LA City Sanitation to make sure that storm drains were being protected. We also at the outlet in the LA River we put in some boons to catch anything that may have gone through those BMPs just to make sure that the water quality downstream was free of those solids.

We have also, Supervisor, been doing some water quality testing at the LA River. The responsible party has also carried out some testing and I think earlier you had asked if we had any initial results and what we have found is that during the incident there were really low pH levels in the water as well as oxygen concentration. You recall that there we found some dead fish in the river at the time While we don't know that that is the reason why the fish died, it often is a reason why there are those die-offs when you have low pH and low oxygen concentration.

We've continued to do some testing. We've gotten some raw data that is still being analyzed so we don''t have any conclusive evidence to really indicate whether there were actually any long term contamination of the river.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:22:44

When will you get that information?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 47Proposed4:22:47

So we should be getting it, my understanding is within the upcoming week.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:22:52

So we'll be able to post that publicize it and just going can you talk quickly about the infrastructure? The fact that

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 47Proposed4:22:59

absolutely are

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:22:59

involved in the debris planning of the removal.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 47Proposed4:23:02

Yes part of our role is to make sure that we review the responsible parties waste management plan and what that entails is how the debris that will be removed would be segregated so you're looking at segregating for example the metals Food waste, the insulation foam that was essentially covering the exterior of the building as well as the liquid. Part of one of the mitigations that they implemented to prevent water from going into the Yellow River was to have vector trucks that were essentially vacuuming any water that was spilling out of a building to prevent it from going into the storm drains prior to the city rerouting that into the sanitary waste system within the city. So all of that waste has to be segregated and there are specific facilities that will take each of the different types of waste.

So the Waste Management Plan indicates how that's going to be done, and we take part in the review of that plan. Another thing that we're doing is making sure that we're reviewing the haul routes that are being proposed. And we do that to make sure that we are reducing traffic impacts to the community, minimizing the number of heavy trucks that are going through residential areas.

As you know some streets are rated to take a specific amount of weight and so we want to make sure that these trucks that are hauling the waste are not going down streets that were not designed to take that waste. Part of what we also look at is how the waste is going to be disposed, so in this case when the contractor begins to remove the food that is inside the freezer that has yet to be opened which will be decomposing. We'll make sure that it's wrapped properly part of what they're proposing is to put a layer of material inside the trucks and to prevent them from leaking down the roadways, but also wrapping the exterior to mitigate odors as well as putting some foam on top of the trucks that are being removed. So we look at that. We also look at the frequency in which the trucks are leaving the facility to make sure that we don't have trucks leaving so frequently that it leads to unintended traffic impacts to the surrounding community.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:25:12

So you're able to work with a community there? I mean, are they informed about what those routes will be like

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 47Proposed4:25:19

Correct, so we've gone through about three different iterations of the haul routes and we are making them public as they get approved. And that aligns also Supervisor with Mayor Bass's order that the contractor publish and get those haul routes approved. So we're making sure that you know that those the intent of that order is implemented.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:25:41

And some of that debris has already reached some landfills I'm told?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 47Proposed4:25:44

Correct. So the first thing they did, Supervisor, was to try to clear the debris around the building to be able to make it safe for people to go in there and assess the condition of the structure. So some of that debris which included metal, it included some of that insulation foam. It also included some Some food bread that was being stored in one of their loading docks, that has already been removed and disposed. However the fire debris that is still within this site, they started segregating that yesterday.

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:26:24

I know maybe I missed asking this of Dr. Ferrer, when we talked about odors we had heard a while back and I'm not sure if it's correct or not that there was mold that was now growing in the warehouse and you mentioned you visited yesterday can you talk about that?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 44Proposed4:26:42

Yeah, our team visited yesterday and there was no obvious sign of mold. Obviously we'll continue working with the folks that are cleaning up at the site to make sure that there's no mold or that if there is mold that's noticed it's remediated immediately. Again getting inside the full structure is not possible yet so...

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:27:03

When do you think that's going to be possible? Any guesstimate here from anyone? OEM? No? Well, they have to retrieve something has to work to get all that debris out. So I mean, I would assume there's still probably a hazard with respect to sending in crews for safety purposes.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 47Proposed4:27:27

So Supervisor, I know that the LA City building official has required the contractor to provide on how they're going to make sure that the structure that burned is safe, right? To include some shoring potentially so that people can safely go in there and start removing the debris.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:27:45

So it's still there is what we know. Yes. Which is very unfortunate, particularly because on days like this where heat in the last couple of days has been really extremely high. The odor just permeates and what do people do about that Dr. Ferrer? What can they do if they become nauseous? What do you recommend to the public?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 44Proposed4:28:11

I mean, the only really effective way to address not getting sick from nuisance odors is to avoid being around nuisance odors. This is particularly true for people who are most vulnerable, very young people, very old people and that's hard to do in this situation for people who live in that neighborhood. You know, we have advised both before and in other incidences where people are experiencing noxious odors that making sure you're staying indoors with all your windows closed, that you're not bringing in air from the outside into your house if you're running your HVAC system Using an air purifier that has an activated charcoal filter in it.

You know we do recommend for people who are able to Leave the area during the day and go to one of our county facilities, our libraries etc. You know get to get out of the areas is something useful now obviously for all of this you know this is not possible for everyone and that's why we have been very direct with lineage that a relocation party The board of supervisors meeting You know, nuisance odors affect people differently.

There's no there's no threshold by which we can say you know don't worry about it if it's not at this threshold because it has an individualized impact on people For some people this can really be have a detrimental impact short-term impact but impact nonetheless on their health and well-being And they really should avoid the area and and the responsible party should take responsibility for making that possible

not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

4:30 – 4:4322 turns

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:30:08

if they don't you're

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 44Proposed4:30:09

prepared

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:30:10

to

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 44Proposed4:30:12

We've issued a directive and we're obviously working with County Council about what the options are.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:30:17

Okay, for DEO Jessica Kim thanks for being here. I've heard repeatedly that people have lost a lot of wealth and I don't want to even say well their business they have not been able to get back on their feet because of the closures and the smoke and all of that so a lot of damages economic as well as homes businesses property owners People are asking what kind of relief can they expect and what does that look like, given that we've been through so many other similar circumstances? What process is made available to the

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 48Proposed4:30:59

public? Sure. One of the areas in which we're unlocking is the SBA Economic Injury Disaster Loan. It is one of the low interest loans at 4% that businesses can offer We've been canvassing and working with businesses directly, and have already completed eight applications of which five are needed to submit to SBA in order to unlock it. And so we are expeditiously working with the Office of Emergency Management, SBA, Cal OES, and the City of LA as we coordinate that, and so we are hoping to get those in this week.

I'm going to start by saying thank you to the California Community Foundation for And then we also work to unlock $2 million in additional assistance and workforce funds that both supports the workers and the businesses. And so, we've been working with the California Employment Development Department and look forward to hearing back from them in 10 days that it's approved and that we can start implementing but that will provide job training, wraparound supportive services, transitional subsidized employment. We know getting money into people's pockets as they, whether this transition is critical. And so those funds will support our ability to quickly respond.

not transcribed≈18s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:32:33

So as long as we keep our resource centers open the one the largest one in East Los Angeles your office can help staff that correct? Yes and help them with the applications because you literally have to walk people through it and what about those people that are not eligible for an SBA loan because it's federal

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 48Proposed4:32:51

That's where we'll continue to pursue opportunities to unlock funding that can support the businesses. So, we're continuously talking with our philanthropic partners as well. We know the California Community Foundation in the next few weeks is going to release a next tranche of funding to support the longer economic recovery and so we will continuously pursue-

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:33:13

And you are working

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 48Proposed4:33:14

in tandem

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:33:14

with them? Correct. I'm just wondering for Obviously, we need to go back to the responsible party because I'm sure the damages are going to be astronomical. And four, if people have to declare bankruptcy and all of these things that go along with losing your business or you just can't go back at all because your place has been damaged, who's liable?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 48Proposed4:33:44

That's the push that we will be doing with county council, the city and once we determine that to be able then to support our community to pursue the claims process. We want to ensure that technical assistance as they make their claims that they have A great application, a complete application going in and that assistance is available in multiple languages too so that folks can navigate that. We're doing something similar for the East LA oil spill and we'll continuously push for a claims process as soon as possible so that then we can support the community as they apply. And do you have staff out in the field? I know last. We do so we have staff out canvassing the businesses, we don't want to take a wait and see approach that were we have staff out visiting our businesses where we're gaining that on-the-ground intelligence and then we also have staff at both of the assistance centers providing those services.

So you have teams

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:34:39

Yes. Both in Boyle Heights and East LA going door to door to businesses, and how many have you contacted so far?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 48Proposed4:34:47

Over 50 in the canvassing we split with the City of LA so that we can cover more ground. And of which we already know a third have been impacted by smoke damage. A third has had workforce impacts about a third has not been able to fully operate and it has had their supply chains disrupted And so as we understand the impacts greater and greater, then it's an opportunity for us to then respond with resources and to develop and push for those.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:35:16

I think it would be helpful at some point if we can publish that so people understand and will open up and hopefully contact us but also continuing the outreach because that I think is persistent. And there are a lot of including street vendors Thank you. Thank you very much. And to work

not transcribed≈19s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 48Proposed4:35:57

with our businesses, there's a WorkShare program too. So any business that is reducing hours as a result, there's a way in which we can leverage our resources and grants in order to support them for the workers to earn their full wages while they have reduced hours. And so we're deploying every resource that we can to ensure folks are continuously earning and having money in their pockets. Great. And

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:36:20

then for our county council, what are the next steps for us? If you can give us a sense of what we're doing

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 49Proposed4:36:29

right now. Thank you, Supervisor. Scott Kuhn, Assistant County Counselor. So in terms of next steps, we are working with an expert to determine the cause of the fire and to have a definitive list of responsible parties down the road at the appropriate time We could begin the process of trying to recover all of the county's costs, the different county families. Everyone here at the dais, all their departments have incurred a lot of expense and it would be a similar process to what we've done in other situations like Chiquita Canyon Landfill, Dominguez Channel odor incident, Eaton Fire against Edison.

That process will really come towards the end of this process. The focus right now, of course, is on responding to community needs, recovery cleanup, removal of the odors and things like that but then after all those costs are gathered up then that would be the time for County Council to go in and do our best to recover those costs for the county.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:37:27

One thing that enters my mind is where can people call? Where do they go to make a claim? Do we even have a hotline to do that?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 49Proposed4:37:37

Well again, that would be a better question for others on the panel. The County Council we can only really represent the county or the people of State of California not individuals for their individual claims so I'd refer it to others.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 48Proposed4:37:50

Not at this time there is no claims process established yet and so that is something that we will continuously monitor

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:37:59

But we're going to need to do that, and I'm going to read in a motion to kind of hopefully start that process because obviously we're getting a lot of concerns for that. So if I might members and the panel, my colleagues, I want to thank you again for being here This is obviously going to be a long process for many of us, but it is very clear to me that we need to continue to stand with our residents and to ensure that we have appropriate responses. And we have to continue to ensure that we have the support from lineage, the responsible party for their contracted partners to help us sustain this operation, because it can't all come from just the county or even my own funds that I have. We really have gone through a lot in the last three weeks and that includes funding for the recovery as well as monitoring for ongoing health and environmental risks to help inform DPH's decision.

So, to that end I have a read in motion today to help ensure that we can sustain these operations moving forward. So I'm gonna try to run through this quickly. The directors will read as follows. I therefore move that the Board of Supervisors send a five signature letter drafted by County Council to lineage requesting response and writing within 48 hours addressing the county's request and concerns to ensure Ongoing support for impacted residents, but not limited to.

Commitments for ongoing resources and financial support to sustain critical county community response centers including but not limited to food water N95 masks and air purifiers in addition to resources and services from the county departments to support locations at the Los Angeles County Community Resiliency Center The Our Lady of Victory Church in Salazar Park. Support for essential community responses, including immediate temporary housing for Boyle Heights and East Los Angeles residents impacted by the recent fire. Long-term housing assistance for impacted residents and their pets. And service animals for the duration of the remediation efforts. A smoke and toxin remediation program at no cost to renters or homeowners and business owners.

Funding for community health clinics and county health services involved in the ongoing community response. Financial support for community-based organizations supporting residents and local businesses, creating a dedicated multilingual hotline and claim center, and participation in community meetings to directly inform and receive feedback from impacted residents and businesses. Comprehensive plans to address the following material removal schedule with phase milestones for further interior clearance, a daily manifest of all materials to be removed including proposed disposal destination and decontamination plans Odor and vector control plans that mitigate public health impacts to surrounding neighborhoods. Firewater runoff management, including testing results published daily.

Air quality monitoring during demolition and hauling operations with real time data reported by the South Coast Air Quality Management District published and analyzed daily. Removal of hazardous materials including but not limited to asbestos, lithium batteries, and mold. Identification of certified waste haulers, biohazard disposal contractors and environmental radiation firms. Retention of a certified industrial hygienist or licensed environmental professional of record responsible for site oversight and publishing of designated operating hours and daily number of truck hauls that minimize impacts on the surrounding community with advanced notification of any significant changes.

I want to thank all of you again for being here and sharing information, but I know that this is just the beginning and we still have a long way to go and above all coordination. And I think what comes for me to mind is that the responsible party parties are Have to respect our community and have to respect the ability for us to do our job here at the county as well as the city. And with having no partnership or communication, we're going nowhere and that can't happen. So we're gonna continue to lift up the voices of our residents and the concerns that you all have on the cooperation. And I know that's gonna carry us through as it has in many other ways. But I don't want to see East LA or Boyle Heights left in the same manner that we saw almost three weeks ago.

Something has to be done and the time and action is now, so thank you. Do my colleagues have any comments? None. Okay very good then with that let's go to public comment, executive office.

4:43 – 4:5414 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed4:43:14

Will the following individuals please come forward and staff will assist you. Claudia Jerez, Lisa Contreras, Roxanne Nazario, Alma Marquez, Jerry Guzman, Cindy Bourbon, Irene Gonzalez, Jose Mateo, Claudette Contreras, Humberta Larios, Virgin Zarate, E. Olvera, Salma Perez, Michelsida Herrera, Lizette Duarte, Roy Humphreys, your line is unmuted. Please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed4:43:53

Thank you. Given credit to all where credit is due in the present, it brings questions as to this counties and cities there in preparation for future disaster potentials associated with data centers with best slash city of industry and lessons learned from the Moss Landing Data Center failure The Orange County chemical disaster is a mini-view of disaster potential. Yes, we realize City of Los Angeles Wilshire Building Foresight Data Center Complex is three campuses allegedly with the two gig best station. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed4:44:36

Thank You. Caller your line is unmuted please begin Caller, please begin. Caller? Madam Chair, there are no other remote speakers to address the board. Remote participation for item A1 is now concluded. We will go into in-person speakers. Please begin.

CommentJerry GuzmanProposedself-stated4:45:22

Good afternoon, Supervisors and staff. My name is Jerry Guzman. I live 3.5 miles from the Leonard's Warehouse toxic fire in the city of Montebello where I've lived all my life. However, my son who was 42 and another son who was 44 live in Boyle Heights and have for several years. We are represented today as I also represent 30 organizations and their leadership And we all want the same thing. We want evacuation of the residents with help to move now, not a reimbursement months later. I'm sure most of you and not all of you know that's impossible for many of our residents to have the money to front up the cost.

The only thing that will stop the gas Is distance. Declare our homes unsafe, dated back to June 17th so that our insurance and mortgage relief finally can be unlocked. Tell us what has burned and please name the chemicals. Thank

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:46:26

you. You want to submit your statement? You can okay and then they'll make copies thank you Jerry appreciate it

CommentLisa ContrerasProposedself-stated4:46:33

Hello, my name is Lisa Contreras and I am a resident of El Sereno. I am here to ask the Board of Supervisors and Dr. Davis to please use your authority to provide full transparency to our community and surrounding communities regarding this toxic fire that is still smoldering in the Leenage building. As well as providing thorough and extensive testing of air, soil, businesses and homes in the impacted areas. We are asking for an urgent meeting to further discuss this crisis We also need a plan shared publicly on how the waste is safely being removed. It was mentioned here today, but it's 20 days in and we need answers faster.

Do not pacify us with air purifiers and masks although helpful for particulate matter they don't protect us against gases. Our supervisor Ila Solis mentioned that 9,000 air purifiers have been distributed in the community. But we have 750,000 residents so that- Thank you next speaker.

PresenterRoxanne NazarioPolicy and Legislative Affairs for HPP Cares which has been on the ground helpinProposedself-stated4:47:40

Hi, my name is Roxanne Nazario. I am the Director of Policy and Legislative Affairs for HPP Cares which has been on the ground helping rebuild in Altadena. Thank you to Supervisor Barger for all of her support. I'm here to help advocate for this group of people who's not getting the same support that other impacted communities have gotten because it's not visible. Just because we can't see it doesn't mean it's not toxic, doesn't mean it's not affecting and hurting families.

It absolutely is so just like previous people said distance is the only thing that's going to help and we're demanding a health local emergency be declared so people can be evacuated out of the area Also want to mention that we can't just depend on lineage to do the right thing. Their CEO made $69.3 million in 2024, I doubt that they're going to want to give up any of that funds including the money that they've lost by this tragedy to help people in the community there.

Thank you,

PresenterCindy Bourbonmy elderly family and many residents in LA County District 4Proposedself-stated4:48:43

next speaker. Good afternoon my name is Cindy Bourbon and I'm here representing my elderly family and many residents in LA County District 4. My family was forced to self-evacuate at their own expense because they experienced severe health symptoms during and after the fire we have repeatedly been told that the air is safe but we don't believe that. The science does not support making a conclusion without with complete testing Today I'm asking for Dr. Davis to use his authority to recommend a mandatory evacuation for all impacted residents with financial assistance, declare affected homes unsafe until they can be properly assessed, conduct testing for all hazardous gases and contaminants Publicly disclose what's exactly burned and what communities are exposed to.

And provide clear guidance to physicians so they can know how to evaluate and treat exposed patients. Supervisors, this is a public health emergency. Please convene an emergency meeting this week and act with urgency. Thank you next speaker.

CommentClaudette Contreras I'mProposedself-stated4:49:47

Hi my name is Claudette Contreras I'm a resident of El Sereno and I'm part of El Sereno Neighbors. We're here because we have obviously all the real questions, questions like is our home safe to live in? And what does reentry require? What cleaning verified by who? Is the food in our homes safe to eat? In our refrigerators, in our cabinets, in our gardens or was it contaminated and contaminating our bodies?

Are our medications and vitamins safe Do we consume them? Do we throw them away? We have real questions that we ask around the kitchen table. Are our clothes, our children's beddings, are our furniture safe when there's homes that don't have proper ventilation which a lot of the homes I live in an older home in East LA you can't open your windows, you can't ventilate properly.

What does that mean for us and who's gonna answer those questions in real time? Thank you. Next speaker?

CommentMiki TsleredaProposedself-stated4:50:50

Hello, my name is Miki Tslereda and I'm here today because we need a mandatory evacuation as a result of this fire. I live behind East Los Angeles College and am asthmatic. As I stand here in front of you all today, I'm left with ongoing lung and back pain, headaches, nosebleeds, and the question on why this isn't being treated like an emergency. The exposure to these gases and ammonia have left us with questions on why the air purifiers that are being distributed can only do so much and can't filter out these gases. I experienced that firsthand as I went to the Red Cross in need of fresh air.

These N95, N100 masks don't support in removing these gases. We need resources long term. Dr. Davis please unlock these resources and we're asking for utility relief, for renter's relief, for mortgage relief. This is a crisis we need support now. Thank

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed4:51:55

you next speaker.

CommentSalma PerezProposedself-stated4:51:57

Hello, good afternoon. My name is Salma Perez. I am a resident of El Sereno. I also provide caretaking to my grandfather who is 94-95 and I'm here to advocate on his behalf who spends a lot of his time in the resident in El Sereno This is, we demand that there's an evacuation order for all the residents in the surrounding areas. We also are here to advocate for free blood lead testing and health surveillance. I personally have seen someone on social media who is pregnant who lives right down the street from the warehouse. And so those are the kind of folks that I'm thinking about. We also ask that everything is given in three languages or more. I believe if there's more than 20 families In a specific language, we should be providing advisory notices, monitoring releases, claims documents issued in English, Spanish and Mandarin but any other languages as well.

We're also here to say that we need utility relief and we need to recover funds- Thank you. Next speaker?

CommentEzequiel OlveraProposedself-stated4:53:01

Hi, my name is Ezequiel Olvera with El Sereno Neighbors. Thank you for having this discussion and for asking these members to address our concerns by asking these agencies the tough questions we have in mind. Dr. Ferrer said it best, don't be around these odors, avoid this area, make this matter urgent and evacuate the area now. We should not be living in these conditions Supervisor, you just read from a letter Mayor Bass sent over 48 hours ago to Leenage. So this just bought them, Leenage, 48 more hours.

This is what we mean by needing unified command. This is just gave lineage 48 hours and for Dr. Davis, we asked that you call the senescence odors. We ask that you be clear with the plume path where it's traveling to and where the wind blows because it's going all the way to El Sereno. The higher you are, the more you feel it.

CommentIrene GonzalezProposedself-stated4:54:03

Thank you. Next speaker. Hello, good afternoon my name is Irene Gonzalez and I'm here to express my concern. I live half a mile from the toxic fire. Ever since the 17th of June, my family and I have begun to experience

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

4:54 – 5:0012 turns

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated4:54:42

Symptoms such as headaches and stomach pain, eye irritation, unbearable pain. And it's something that we should not have to experience. We

CommentIrene GonzalezProposedself-stated4:54:56

are experiencing

not transcribed≈13s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated4:55:12

Because we are breathing the air when the windows are open, we're experiencing difficulty breathing. We're asking for an immediate evacuation. We ask that you would use your authority right now to be able to declare our homes uninhabitable and to be able to make us safe through evacuation.

CommentIrene GonzalezProposedself-stated4:55:41

So please analyze honestly what these gases are really all about and call right now a meeting on an emergency basis. And please act with a state of emergency. Thank you, next speaker?

not transcribed≈17s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentLisette DuarteProposedself-stated4:56:10

Good afternoon, Supervisors. My name is Lisette Duarte. I'm a constituent of Supervisor Hilda Solis but I am a longtime community advocate for over two decades for people with developmental disabilities and I'm here today because I am actually somebody who was impacted By this tragedy, I unfortunately am recently diagnosed with end-stage kidney failure and I'm a long COVID survivor. I self identified to my supervisor's office and I asked for support help resources humidifier and the response from my three touch points with the office was we'll get back to you will put your name on the list. Unfortunately, I wasn't able because of my health conditions to go out and stand in long lines in heat With my health condition, I was forced to self evacuate with my family and my pets.

My daughter and I have been feeling these symptoms of nausea, headaches, just not feeling well. My daughter has had a cough since the fire started, and I'm a parent of two children- Thank you, next speaker?

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role4:57:15

Somebody

CommentVirgen ZarateProposedself-stated4:57:15

on my staff will assist you now. Hello, good afternoon. My name is Virgen Zarate and I live in East Los Angeles close to where the fire occurred starting on June 17th. Ever since that time, we have been dealing with a horrible situation and the smell is unbearable. We are not able to go out. We're not able to go out for walks outside of our home. This smell is really

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated4:57:54

bad. I also have four children and now that we're on vacation, I just have them enclosed at home. We are not able to go out and so honestly we need you to evacuate

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentVirgen ZarateProposedself-stated4:58:15

us already. We are not able to open the windows either. It's such a horrible smell, it smells as if it was a dead animal and we don't have the desire to cook or to eat

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated4:58:28

either And honestly, the air filters don't help a lot. The smell just keeps getting stronger and that's it. Thank you. Thank you. Next speaker.

not transcribed≈18s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentAlma MarquezProposedself-stated4:59:01

Hello, my name is Alma Marquez. I'm a resident of Monterey Park and a proud partner of all of the leaders who've spoken to you in addition to the 30 other organizations and civic and civil rights leaders who signed on to the letter that we sent Dr. Davis and that we provided to all of you and your offices as of yesterday asking for an immediate emergency I'm so excited to be here at this important meeting to actually have more than a minute to discuss what's happened. And I hope you feel as indignant about what is happening in our country and our county under your watch, Without a mandatory evacuation order, we are unable to access the insurance that we've covered and we've paid because they won't allow us to get ALE coverage. So we ask you, we plead if I have to beg, I will beg for you to issue a mandatory evacuation order today and- Thank you next speaker.

We have emergency needs that we can have our due. One minute is not

CommentBerta LariosProposedself-stated5:00:09

enough

5:00 – 5:0410 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:00:13

Next speaker. Hi,

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:00:17

good

CommentBerta LariosProposedself-stated5:00:20

afternoon my name is Berta Larios and I'm here because I live in East Los Angeles right in front of where the fire was on June 17th. So I am concerned about my children's health. I have four kids. I am worried about their well-being, about my family. We need to be evacuated. You need to help us already. It's not possible for us to continue living there. My children are suffering with headache, pain, nausea and it is not fair for them to be living this.

We do have the air purifiers on, but that doesn't help because the smell is very strong. So this smell it is so strong it enters in through the windows, it goes into the living room and the

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈18s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated5:01:41

bathrooms all of the rooms

not transcribed≈20s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentBerta LariosProposedself-stated5:02:03

We need a solution now. We need to be evacuated because we have children, we have adults, we have people with asthma and others with health conditions. And that's it. Thank you next speaker

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentDr. Critical Rahel Desire-TruthbayProposedself-stated5:02:30

Alright, so just in short it would have been more effective had you had all of the experts still sitting here listening to the people that would testify. You see? As ProtectLA.com That you tried so hard for me not to put up while they were speaking. You got to take these testimonies seriously. There's too much tragedy that's been happening with these fires and slow responses, very slow response. Some people came here for the very first time and some people already know the incompetency of the response time when it comes to LA County and LA City tragedies. I'm just saying if you're going to have a panel of experts especially Barbara Ferrer They need to sit here and look into the eyes of every person, and really even pretend for a minute that they care before they walk off to the back having lunch somewhere.

So let's hopefully that everybody can get help because I trust the county very well.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:03:32

Madam Chair and members of the board, that concludes public comment on this item.

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction5:03:36

Madam Chair, Item A1 is before you.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:03:39

Okay, I will move seconded by Supervisor Hahn to approve the item. Executive Officer call the roll.

Roll-call vote Passed 6–0 move seconded by Supervisor Hahn to approve the item. Executive Officer call the roll.
Show transcript
Supervisor Mitchell? Aye. Supervisor Mitchell, aye. Supervisor Horfath? Aye Supervisor Horfath, aye. Supervisor Hahn? Aye Supervisor Hahn, aye. Supervisor Barger? Aye Supervisor Barger, aye Supervisor Solis? Aye Supervisor Solis, aye
CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction5:03:58

Motion carries We will now move on to general public comment At this time, we will hear from members of the public wishing to address the board on general public comment. This is an opportunity for the public to address the board on subject matters within the Board's jurisdiction but not on items on the meeting agenda. For members of the public joining us remotely, please use the raise hand feature if you are online or press star 3 if on a telephone.

5:04 – 5:1212 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:04:30

We will now call in-person speakers and while they're coming forward, we will take remote speakers. Manuel Alejandro Polanca, Raymond Garcia, Humberto Larios, Virgen Zarate, Irene Gonzalez, Roxanne Nazario, Mequizila Herrera, Salma Perez, Cindy Bourbon, Dr. Critical Truthbay, E. Olvera, Claudette Contreras, Sineta Fairley, Shereen McFall, Alberto Vasquez, We will now go to remote callers. Roy Humphreys, your line is unmuted please begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed5:05:14

Thank you. I have sent to all members of this board, the San Gabriel Valley Tribune article noting the pathetic and criminal negligence of the four Democrat board members' criminal efforts to close Men's Central Jail while cutting funding to the district attorney and the county courts in failure to expand the courts and DA to enable them to timely process all those under-the-law As is your sworn duty, criminal obstruction of justice. Yes all of these acts of criminal negligence have been repeatedly brought to this board and yes it was myself. I will be asking the feds to step in the states because Calderon and Archuleta have been complicitous in this police criminal acts you have money to expand your board to nine members but not to do take care The criminal enterprise and see justice as the done in America, the American way.

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:06:20

Caller with phone number starting in 323 and ending in 06 please begin. Please begin. Hello.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated5:06:39

Can

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:06:39

you hear me?

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated5:06:39

Yes, please begin. My name is Sofia Quinones. I'm with the East L.A. Boyle Heights Coalition. I am calling because I am very concerned regarding the gross negligence by the L. A County Board of Supervisors in dealing with the legacy sites of contamination on the east side and also to deal with the two environmental catastrophes that recently happened, the 25,000-gallon oil spill Under the new cold storage facility ongoing fire.

To begin with, none of the hospitals in LA County are addressing in a uniform way the respiratory distress that our residents are dealing with. The simple blood tests that you've been asking us to take for years are a lie. We need bone scanning machines, and there are none of them in the state of California, to properly and adequately measure the amount of lead in our body. But we do have our dialysis centers all around LA County. Why? Because when the lead leaches into your bones it takes out your kidneys and other organs.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:07:47

Caller, your line is unmuted. Please state your name and begin.

PresenterAmy I'mEdevskaProposedself-stated5:07:56

Hi good afternoon my name is Christy Hernandez and I'm a resident of unincorporated East Los Angeles. I live within a mile of the lineage warehouse toxic fire and this environmental breach has been designated as a state of emergency however the sense of urgency is far from that of state of emergency. LA County you must do better and do right by the community, by us Air purifiers, food, water are temporary fixes. When we asked for purifiers, we were referred to Supervisor Solis' office and were asked to call between 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday through Friday. The community was experiencing emergency toxic fumes 24-7 for eight days and yet residents had to work around your business hours. That is unacceptable. Again this is not being treated as state of emergency and it's the clear example of environmental racism.

We need long term solutions for item seven and general comments.

not transcribed≈23s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 51Proposed5:09:16

I just wanted to commend the Board of Supervisors. I think it was a really good addition to add the list of the CAC, the constituents that are there to help. I think that was a really nice touch. Secondly, Madam Chair, I respectfully ask if you're going to...if anybody on the ice is going to speak in a foreign language that you at least translate it? I think it's professionally inappropriate and And it's unfair for those who do not speak foreign languages. If you blurt out something is, you know other people don't know what's being said and then the last thing is although 4th of July has passed we talk about air quality and air quality in district 2 I'm sure in other districts.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:10:03

Madam Chair there are no other remote speakers to address the board. Remote participation for general public comment is now concluded. We will go to in-person speakers please begin

PresenterSunetta FarleyEast Rancho Dominguez Neighborhood AssociationProposedself-stated5:10:14

Good afternoon. My name is Sunetta Farley, I'm president of East Rancho Dominguez Neighborhood Association. We're here today to represent our community. Thank you Supervisor Mitchell for the improvement of the parking enforcement it has really helped our community but today we're here for another issue. Some time ago you as the board approved an ordinance And that gave the Department of Economic Opportunity, the responsibility for enforcing vendors.

We are here today to ask you to add additional funding so that those officers can really do a good job. The information that we are receiving is that they do not have sufficient funds to do our job for our community and other communities.

CommentShirin McFallProposedself-stated5:11:18

Good afternoon, my name is Shirin McFall. I serve on the Board of Directors for the East Rancho Dominguez Neighborhood Association. One of the most immediate public safety concerns is unauthorized parking associated with street vending. Vehicles often park in red zones block fire hydrants, park on the sidewalk and even stop in the center median along Atlantic Avenue. These actions create unsafe streets and congestion reduce visibility for drivers and place pedestrians at risk. Parking enforcement officers work really hard, but they simply do not have enough resources for the volume of violations occurring in the evening. Again this is simply not an enforcement issue it's a funding issue. The county must allocate adequate resources to enforce the ordinance that it had adopted we need to come up with a solution where everyone wins thank you.

Thank you next speaker.

5:12 – 5:1816 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 52Proposed5:12:12

Mi nombre es Alberto Vasquez y soy propietario de una barberia aquí en Rancho Dominguez.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated5:12:18

Good afternoon, Supervisors. My name is Alberto Dominguez. I'm Alberto and I am a owner of a barbershop here in Rancho Dominguez.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 52Proposed5:12:27

A la vuelta de mi negocio regularmente se instala un puesto de venta ambulante, la cual cierra completamente la banqueta.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated5:12:35

Right next to my business, there is a street vendor that regularly closes off the sidewalk area. I

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 52Proposed5:12:44

do respect that people have a right to earn a living but the traffic that this has generated and the way it's affecting the neighborhood is really interfering with people's way of life. A la gente le cuesta encontrar dónde estacionarse. El tráfico se acumula, el área se vuelve difícil de transitar. Esto no solo afecta a mi barbería sino a toda la comunidad.

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated5:13:14

People have a very hard time finding parking the whole area gets congested this doesn't just affect my barbershop it affects the whole entire community.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 52Proposed5:13:23

Le pido a la supervisora que escuche a los propietarios de pequeños negocios y nos ayuden a encontrar una solución para esta situación

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated5:13:30

I would ask the supervisor to please listen to owners of small businesses and please find a solution for us.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 52Proposed5:13:37

I ask that you would please find a solution for us so that all of us will be able to benefit from it, thank you so much. Thank you next

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated5:13:43

speaker.

PresenterRoxanne NazarioPolicy and Legislative Affairs for HPP Cares which has been on the ground helpinProposedself-stated5:13:51

Hello again, my name is Roxanne Nazario. I do live in Supervisor Horvath's district in the city of Sylmar which is a very high impacted fire community but I want to talk about the community that's being directly affected with the Lineage Fire. For example there are 750,000 residents within five miles So when we talk about evacuating, it's not just who's across the street. This includes 15 different cities, neighborhoods, East LA, Southgate, Boyle Heights, Montebello, Monterey Park, Bell Gardens, Bell, Maywood, Cudahy, Commerce, Vernon, Monterey Park again, El Sereno, Lincoln Heights and downtown LA. All of these areas are within a five mile radius of the fire, just because these houses didn't burn down again doesn't mean that there's not toxic destructive trauma being caused to these families.

These kids can enjoy their summer being locked inside their houses all summer. Thank you. Thank you next speaker.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 53Proposed5:14:54

Raymond E. Garcia, living man, in order to reconcile the past and present states I as author of my story am moved by one, the scientific method, two firsthand experience knowledge and three sound mind and memory of the whole truth of the matter to personally compose this peaceable paleographic memoir to declare once and for all that one is all present and accounted for from fertilization to last breath, never to be presumed at war over a violently contrived particular end. One's unique genesis known scientifically as fertilization religiously as creation is the point where Darwin meets God an act of God origin of the species and extraterritorial merit incognito nativity resulting in a perfect quintessential Noah's Ark membership progressing without sunder alpha to omega wholly in accordance with nature seamless evolutionary due process ab Thank you.

Next speaker.

not transcribed≈15s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentManuel Alejandro PolancoProposedself-stated5:16:00

Saludos, estimada Junta Supervisora de Los Angeles, Supervisor Holly Lindsey, Janice Catherine and Chair Hilda. Estimados empleados públicos, Edward, Nicole, ciudadanos del Condado de Los Angeles.

CommentMargarita QuintanillaProposedself-stated5:16:17

So greetings esteemed Board of Supervisors, Supervisor Holly and Lindsey, Janice, Catherine and Chair Hilda and public employees. Edgar and all of the residents of the county of Los Angeles.

CommentManuel Alejandro PolancoProposedself-stated5:16:32

You truly representing the leadership of this LA County. I would love to ask one minute more of time today chair Hilda Solis is possible? My name is Manuel Alejandro Polanco. I am a lawyer on political scientists See us in the group. I am originally from Venezuela. I would love to truly say thank you for the people from my country, Venezuela. From saying the firefighters to my country and as well, I would love to thank you for the dignity of the humanity. For you are truly leaders and this is thousands of people in my country die and your firefighters save thousands, hundreds lives support the peoples of my country.

27 years ago we live in a dictatorship This dictatorship moving thousands, millions of people from my country. And this for that reason we receive people in LA County but not only us. We received people from Ukraine, Armenia and Russia and Mexico. And we having a declaration that was a couple years ago on the 4th April 2023 I have the opportunity to speak here in this Board of Supervisors.

I truly want to request a meeting with every single one of you to speak about the future of the youth, immigrants and first generation Americans in this county. To provide tools. Now I have an organization that we are working with the community college district.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:18:01

Thank you next speaker. Next speaker please.

5:18 – 5:2110 turns

CommentDr. Critical Rahel Desire-TruthbayProposedself-stated5:18:19

Okay this is on. Oh now it's on, okay thank you. So I want to talk to LA HOPP. When I spoke to you about the defunding of LASA staff it wasn't to melee on someone right? So Ms. Janice Hahn I know you got really defensive that day and say I'm not going to let that happen well this is what happens When you contact LAHOP and you put the request in for a homeless person, this is their response. The first outreach attempt will occur a few days after the request is received. On average, LAHOP requests are completed within seven days but may take longer. This is a problem. Why would you call somebody to get help for someone who's homeless and it will come a few days later? But what I do want to give, only got a few seconds left. You have Salvador, Abel and Cesar that are sitting there.

And I want to say thank you for at least starting something new. And training them in the way that they can be effective. Right? If I can get 10

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed5:19:16

seconds. Madam Chair and members of the board, that concludes our time for general public

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction5:19:20

comment. We will now proceed with adjournment.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:19:30

Dawn, Executive Officer.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 17Proposed5:19:32

Madam Chair I just wanted to acknowledge that one of the speakers acknowledged our LA County USAR team and USA2. I was able to greet them as they came home last night and it was a truly moving evening. I just wanted to thank him for that acknowledgement and we'll make sure that our team is meeting with him and I know you have a plan for our board.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:19:53

We'll be recognizing them here on the board at the next meeting. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed5:19:59

I was going to say something earlier. We're so proud of them. To think there are two international search and rescue teams, two! And we're one of them. It's quite amazing. It was very nice to hear the comments about Venezuela and them going over there. They made some amazing rescues. Thank you for being there last night when they came home. That's wonderful.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:20:23

Executive Officer?

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction5:20:24

Madam Chair, we have adjournments next.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:20:26

We'll go to adjournments, one, two, three, four and five. So I will go first. I have one members. I move that when we adjourned today, we do so in the memory of Maria de Lara, a beloved community member of the greater San Gabriel Valley. Maria grew up in Mexicali Mexico where she picked cotton in the fields from age six to 11. She later immigrated to Los Angeles by herself with her three daughters. Determined and hardworking, Maria supported her family through jobs like construction and house cleaning She continued her journey by attending East LA College and entering the real estate field. She earned many awards while helping first-time homebuyers purchase a home, but she built a legacy of resilience service and perseverance. But above all Maria was proud to raise three successful daughters Jennifer who's a manager for the police department Stephanie is a retired police officer and Jessica who was a doctor in research in the medical field Maria became an example of strength and love for her family.

She's survived by her three daughters and five grandchildren, may she rest in peace. Supervisor Mitchell?

5:21 – 5:395 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 15Proposed5:21:31

Appreciate that Madam Chair thank you very much. Colleagues when we adjourn today I ask that we adjourn in the memory of two very young cherished community members whose lives were tragically taken in a yet another senseless act of gun violence Eric Washington and Mia Bordenave Jenkins. Their passing on the 4th of July holiday has left a profound void felt deeply by their families, friends and the broader Los Angeles County community.

Eric, a beloved young man, devoted son, brother and friend was killed at the age of 37. He earned an associate's degree in political science from El Camino College in 2011 followed by a bachelor's degree in poli sci with a concentration in constitutional law from the University of North Texas in 2014 and a master's degree in public administration from Grambling State University in 2018 His graduate study strengthened the leadership and policy skills he carried into his public service.

While at Grambling, he became a proud member of Alpha Phi Alpha Fraternity Incorporated. Eric dedicated his life to serving and uplifting his community. He joined the office of then California State Assembly Member Mike Gibson as a field representative He was also an active member of the Watts Gang Task Force, centering his work on community engagement and violence intervention.

His service placed him directly where he believed he was most needed working faithfully in the neighborhoods he sought to protect. Most recently, Eric served as a Community Engagement Manager for HACLA, the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles where he created opportunities for youth and families including through his leadership of HACLA's World Cup Youth Tournament.

Eric's legacy lives on in the countless lives he touched through his service, his compassion and unwavering commitment to his community. He will be deeply missed and forever cherished by his mother, Tina Johnson, his family, his fraternity brothers, his friends, and the many communities he devoted his life to supporting. We also honor the life of Mia Bourdain Jenkins Mia was a very young woman whose life reflected promise, purpose and a deep commitment to the future she was building.

She was 19 years old. She was a sophomore at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas studying to become a nurse with a neonatal focus. She wanted to be a travel nurse so she could see the world. A path that spoke to her compassion and the care she hoped to extend to others. She was here for the holiday weekend to visit her grandmother. Her family described her as full of life, very compassionate in the church. Very giving someone who would help anyone in need."

These words shared by her mother Ebony and her loved ones reflect the warmth Mia carried and the meaningful connections she built in her very short 19 years. Although her passing occurred amid a broader tragedy that shook the community, today we hold close the light Mia brought. The hopes she pursued and the profound loss felt by all who knew and loved her.

She leaves behind a legacy rooted in love and the future she was so determined to create for herself. So as we honor both Eric and Mia, we extend our deepest condolences to their families and friends and all who are grieving these heartbreaking losses. We also want to acknowledge a second tragic gun shooting that happened again in the city of Compton, same weekend at 132nd and Grandee.

And the loss of 28 year old Thaddeus Clark, a resident of Rialto California. In the pursuit of healing and justice, we ask that anyone with information related to the incidents is encouraged, is urged to contact the LA County Sheriff's Department, the Homicide Bureau at 323-890-5500. Those wishing to remain anonymous may call Crime Stoppers at 800-222-TIPS.

And in that vein, I think it was very striking to hear Eric's mother in the At the height of her deep shock and sorrow, made comments at a vigil yesterday where she talked about we don't get to choose when we show up for each other in community. That when our own families are impacted, we want others to show up for us and we have a responsibility as community to show up for others in all ways all the time.

I thank you all for allowing me to acknowledge the second district residents, and I ask that you join me in their adjournments. Thank you.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:27:20

Supervisor Horvath?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 17Proposed5:27:22

Thank you very much. I move that when we adjourn today, we adjourn in memory of Clive Davis, a legendary music executive and visionary whose influence shaped generations of artists. Clive Davis passed away on June 22nd at the age of 94. Over a career spanning more than six decades, Davis discovered and championed some of the most iconic voices in music. His remarkable ability to recognize talent transformed the music industry and helped to launch countless careers.

Both in New York, born in New York Davis shared a longstanding connection to Los Angeles through the entertainment industry that defines so much of our region. For decades he was a familiar presence at the annual pre-Grammy gala and Beverly Hills bringing together artists producers and music leaders from around the world to celebrate the creative spirit that thrives in Los Angeles County.

He has survived by his partner Greg Schreif Schreifer, his four children Fred, Doug, Mitchell and Lauren, eight grandchildren and two great-grandchildren. His loss is deeply felt by his family the music community and the countless artists whose lives and careers were forever changed by his vision I also move that when we adjourn today, we adjourn in memory of Tony Melia.

A dedicated community leader, businessman and longtime resident of West Hollywood, Anthony Tony F. Melia passed away at the age of 92. After moving to Los Angeles in 1957, Tony built a successful career in the insurance industry founding the National Business Insurance Agency in 1968 His impact extended far beyond business as he became a driving force in shaping West Hollywood through decades of civic leadership.

He served twice as president of the West Hollywood Chamber of Commerce, helped to lead the community's successful cityhood effort and was a founding member of the West Hollywood Convention and Visitors Bureau, now known as VisitWestHollywood. Friends and colleagues remember him as a generous mentor, a thoughtful leader, and a steadfast advocate whose vision helped to shape the city into the vibrant community it is today.

He has survived by his many nieces and nephews, extended family and countless friends whose lives he touched through his kindness, leadership and unwavering commitment to the community. His loss is deeply felt throughout West Hollywood and beyond. And you can read more of his story in the recently published WeHo Stories book. Thank you.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:30:09

Thank you Supervisor Hahn.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed5:30:12

Thank you Madam Chair and thank you Supervisor Mitchell for those two adjournments. I also knew Eric who also worked for Council District 15 as part of his career but what a great outgoing really dedicated to service And then I move when we adjourn today, we adjourned in memory of Charles Chuck Hanchett. He passed away recently, he was 87. He was a proud veteran and dedicated community leader whose decades of service left a lasting impact on the harbor area. Chuck served honorably in the United States Navy from 1958 to 1960 before building successful careers in the jewelry and real estate industries. He was perhaps best known for his extraordinary 40-year commitment to community service through Rotary International. Chuck held numerous leadership roles with Rotary Club, including serving as president of the Torrance Del Amo, the Palos Verdes Sunset and the San Pedro Rotary Clubs.

He also served as assistant governor for Rotary District 5280 and helped foster international goodwill through Rotary's group study exchange program. His dedication to the community also included leadership roles with the YMCA of San Pedro, Harbor Interfaith Services and the San Pedro Peninsula Hospital. He's pre-deceased by his first wife, Claudia. And he survived by his current wife Angela, his children Catherine, Teresa, Lisa and Charles. His brother James 14 grandchildren and 14 great grandchildren. I felt honored to know Chuck and Claudia in my early years in San Pedro. He really has left a legacy.

And then I move when we adjourn today. We turn in our memory of Frank Thompson, Jr.. Frank is the father of my dear friend Jake Thompson. Frank was born July 4th 1947 and passed away on June 29th just days short of his birthday this year. He honorably served his country in the U.S. Army from 1969 to 1971, where he was awarded numerous commendations including the Bronze Star Medal and the Purple Heart.

Frank was an active member of the First Baptist Church of Eatonton, where he served as a deacon. He was a member of the First Leadership Putnam Class, a former member of Eaton and Kiwanis Club, a volunteer coach, board member for Putnam County Recreation Department and a supporter of Gatewood Schools in more ways than could possibly be recounted. Frank's greatest treasure in life was his family and nothing brought him more joy than being a grandpa. As a devoted husband, father and grandfather he was fiercely protective, nurturing and loving.

Frank is survived by his wife Laura, their children Jake Thompson and husband Pete Settlemire. Katie Hanks and husband Edwin and Ben Thompson and wife Melanie and grandchildren Amelia, Caroline, Addie, Lulu and Walt. I was honored to get to meet Frank when he came and visited Jake and Pete and He was just such a southern gentleman and I enjoyed his company so much, and I know he'll be missed.

I also move that when we adjourn today, we adjourn in the memory of Maria de Jesus Mendoza who is affectionately known to everyone as La Chuchana. She was born on February 24th, 1935 in Mexico and passed away peacefully on July 1st in Bakersfield, California. Did I say that right? Or hope I didn't have a derogatory word. It's Chuchana. But here's what we wanna know is Maria was the mother of Tony Mendoza Who was a former state senator of the 32nd district and who's our Artesia Cemetery District General Manager.

And Maria was the heart and soul of her family, a loving mother, grandmother, great-grandmother, great-great-grandmother, sister, aunt, and friend. More than anything she was a hero, a rock, and the foundation that held generations together as a devoted single mother Maria worked tirelessly and sacrificed endlessly to provide for and raise her 10 children. Through determination, strength, and unconditional love she built a family rooted in faith, resilience, and compassion. Maria had a spirit unlike any other. She was funny, she was joyful, loving, and truly one of a kind. She loved to make food and feed everyone always bringing people together through her cooking and generosity. Her warm smile, infectious laughter, kind heart and unwavering strength touched everyone who had the privilege of knowing her.

No matter the challenges she faced, she met them with courage and grace earning the admiration of all who knew her. She was a true warrior whose love knew no limits. Maria is survived by seven of her 10 children, 39 grandchildren And I also move that when we adjourn Spot Helfer. Paul was 93 when he passed away, he was a longtime resident of La Habra Heights and together with his wife Claire devoted more than 20 years to running music in the park.

Over the years the concert series grew into beloved community tradition drawing between 2,000 and 3,000 attendees to each performance and bringing neighbors and visitors from all over LA County together in celebration of music Paul was raised in Willowbrook by his German parents Carl and Frieda who instilled in him the values of hard work, resilience and craftsmanship. He proudly served in the U.S. Navy traveling to places such as Hawaii, Okinawa and Alaska, an experience that deepened his sense of duty and shaped the course of his life.

After his military service, Paul attended Compton College before beginning a long and successful career in construction. In 1958 he met Claire and the two later married in a church Paul helped to build. In 1982, Paul, Claire, and their children Heidi and Darren moved to LeHabra Heights settling on a beautiful property that reflected their love of animals and the outdoors. Paul and Claire soon became active members of the community, serving with the Le Havre Heights Improvement Association.

Paul also served on the Planning Commission and used his construction skills to build the gazebo at the park, which is now the iconic grandstand for Music in the Park concerts and a lasting part of his legacy. Those who knew Paul will remember his warmth, his humility, and the way he made others feel valued simply by being himself. Paul was preceded in death by his beloved wife Claire. He survived by his daughter Heidi, his son Darren, and his daughter-in-law Christine.

And my last one, Madam Chair is I ask that when we adjourn today, we adjourn in the memory of Yolanda Espinoza Correa who passed away on June 9th. She was born in 1968 in Mexico City and was the youngest of four children. She grew up in South Los Angeles and eventually settled in La Mirada where she built a loving home and many cherished memories. Yolanda met Sammy Correa in seventh grade and their friendship blossomed into a lifelong partnership. Yolanda spent 26 years teaching at Daniel Webster Elementary School where she made her classroom a welcoming place and helped every student feel seen, valued, and capable of great things. She loved to travel and capture special moments with her camera Yolanda is survived by her husband Samuel, her daughters Emma and Tanya.

Her mother Guadalupe Espinoza. Her mother-in-law Alida Correa. Her sister-in law Diana. Her sisters Gloria and Angela. And her brother Thomas Espinoza. And her niece Monique Diaz.

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈17s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈21s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

5:39 – 5:444 turns

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:39:22

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed5:39:23

Thank you Supervisor Barger.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed5:39:25

Thank you Madam Chair I move that we adjourn today. We do so in memory of Kevin O'Malley A devoted baseball executive and beloved member of the O'Malley family who passed away on June 30th at the age of 50. Born and raised in Los Angeles, O'Malley played baseball at Harvard Westlake and later at the University of Pennsylvania where he also earned an MBA from Wharton in 2004.

In the late 1990s he worked for the Dodgers organization in Great Falls Montana and at Dodger Town in Vero Beach Florida. He co-founded Top of the Third, Inc., which operated the Stockton Mudville Nine and the Visalia Rawhide minor league teams in Central California. In 2012, Kevin joined the Seidler and O'Malley families as a part owner of the San Diego Padres. Kevin's baseball roots run deep. His grandfather who worked with your father, Supervisor Hahn, Walter O'Malley owned the Dodgers from 1944 to 1979 And was credited with bringing the Dodgers to the Los Angeles from Brooklyn. Walter was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Kevin's father, Peter led the Los Angeles Dodgers as president from 1970 to 1998.

Kevin honored his family's legacy through steady work and heartfelt commitment. Baseball was important to him, his father said. Family came first but baseball was a close second. He is survived by his wife Allison, his children Grace, Brendan, Brooke and Margaret. His father Peter, his sister Catherine, his brother Brian and several nieces and nephews. He was preceded in death by his mother Annette.

Also that we adjourn in memory of Dale Harold Hetzel a long time resident of Santa Clarita who passed away at the age of 90 Dale was born February 17th, 1936 in Illinois and moved to California at the age of 10. In 1956 he married Alma Vickers and together they raised four children with their marriage lasting nearly 69 years until Alma's passing in 2025. Dale served our country as an army reservist during the early years of his marriage. He also had a long career in the grocery industry where he was known for his dependability leadership and his character.

Outside of work, he enjoyed reading and love spending time in his garden. Dale loved watching sports proudly cheering on the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Pittsburgh Steelers. Dale survived by his three children, 10 grandchildren, 17 great-grandchildren and many others who will forever cherish his legacy. Also we adjourn a memory of Frederick David Henry Williams, a resident of Claremont who passed away at the age of 100 Frederick was born in New York and spent his early years in England. During World War II, in 1946 he began serving in the U.S. Army where he was assigned to the 3071st Mobile Refrigeration Unit and was later honorably discharged in 1949.

After the war, he returned to America and worked as a truck driver in Cleveland, Ohio where he met his wife of 73 years, Gloria. They eventually settled in Los Angeles and raised their children David and Laura Lee. Frederick was preceded in death by his wife, Gloria, who died at the age of 97. He moved to Claremont Manor where he enjoyed participating in current event talks. In 2025, his community came together to hold a party to commemorate his 100th birthday. Frederick is survived by his son, David Williams, and daughter-in-law Susan Williams, daughter Laura Lee, and son-in law John Rimpow, three grandchildren Great-grandchildren.

Also, I move that we adjourn in memory of the following individuals who are identified as indigent veterans by the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner and were subsequently buried with dignity and honor at Riverside National Cemetery in the last month. Luis Alfonso Garcia Army, Willard Arthur Weeks Army, Melvin Laverne Taylor Navy, John David Boggs Army, Harvey D. McLeven Army, Brendan John Merholtz Navy, Henry Raymond Devedal Army, Jerry Martin Hornstein Army, David Lawrence Dodson Air Force, Larry Edwin Salisbury Marines, Roderick Rennell Breckenridge Army and Robert Charles Peterson Navy. May their contributions and sacrifices in service to our country never be forgotten. Thank you, Madam Chair.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role5:44:13

Thank you. And thank you. We'll take all these motions as seconded. There's no objection until we announce this vote. That will be the order.

5:44 – 5:5111 turns

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction5:44:23

Please read us into closed session. Members of the public, the board will now be going into closed session. While the board is in closed session we will be showing a video presentation. Supervisor Solis has a video presentation recognizing the Youth at Work Parks and Recreation Program. In accordance with Brown Act requirements notices hereby given that the Board of Supervisors will convene in closed session to discuss item number CS2 conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation one case Item number CS3, public employment consideration of candidates for appointment to the position of interim director of the Department of Children and Family Services. Item number CS4 conference with labor negotiators Joseph M Nikita and designated staff.

And item number CS5 conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation one case as indicated on the posted in supplemental agendas

PresenterMatthew VuBeverly Vermont Community Land Trust and an organizer with the Los Angeles CommuProposedself-stated5:45:17

So it all started. Our school ran down, my friend told us to come here.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 54Proposed5:45:23

Yes, so we walked in. Abby wasn't sure she didn't want to come check out the camp and I said let's just go see and then we'll go the rest of our day will go to the park or something and she walked in and said I'm staying. I've seen the parents just the

CommentMeasure JProposed · by introduction5:45:37

relief by how much praise they give us how thankful grateful they are for us to be coming here and knowing my kids are safe for the day while I'm figuring out how to get through this situation for the next week month year however long it takes.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 55Proposed5:45:49

It's really been a huge support for all of us parents who are trying to figure out what to do next.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 56Proposed5:45:58

So the Youth at Work program is a program for youth and young adults ages 14-24 where youth can gain work experience and build life lessons, get mentorship at one of our local parks.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 57Proposed5:46:10

It's been really great, a nice experience for me. I've been getting to work while I'm still at school. Nice experience. Get to build my resume and stuff while still pursuing education.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 58Proposed5:46:22

Our senior program has this wonderful partnership with Human Services Association that essentially provides meals to our elderly 55 and above. We have a hot meal program that's served Monday through Friday from 11 A.M. till 1 P.M..

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 59Proposed5:46:38

In partnership with the Department of Probation during the government shutdown that impacted the Supplemental Nutrition Program, a 43-day period greatly impacted our park families who turned to parks to help provide access to food security. During the difficult ice enforcement raids, LA County Parks came together with our frontline park staff to see what we could do together to ensure that families and seniors and children could continue to safely access our after-school programs, summer activities events, and our senior congregate meal and other programs.

Park staff worked with community seniors and we came up with a senior shuttle program. In addition, we worked with our park staff to create an ambassador program. This ambassador program provided extra oversight and support

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 60Proposed5:47:31

Today we currently have a food distribution going on along with an air purifier distribution going on in our basketball dome, along with shelter for anyone who is experiencing any endangerment when it comes to the fires and just trying to give them shelter and along with food as well. It feels great, you know we're able to help out the community in any way that we're able to. We're able to open up our doors to them allow them to spend nights here along give them shelter give them food just so that way they can feel comfortable they can feel safe and also keeping all the kids in a great environment by giving him board games TV foosball tables and just allowing him to be here at the park

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed5:48:18

Good morning. Yeah. You.

5:52 – 9:222 turns

CommentIba AlleyProposedself-stated5:52:40

you Hi, everyone.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed5:54:17

You. I'm Yeah. Okay. Okay. Okay. Thank you. You. Thank you. You. ♪ Yeah. ♪ ♪ Good morning, everyone. Good morning, everyone. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Good morning. Yeah. ♪ Yeah. Yeah. You. ♪ You. Yeah. Good morning. Good morning. Yeah. Yeah. Good morning, everyone. ♪ ♪ Good morning, everyone. you ♪ Good morning. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you.

Yeah. . . Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. ♪ Yeah. Good morning, everyone. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Hi. Thank you. Yeah. ♪ ♪♪ ♪ ♪ Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah. . . Thank you. you Good morning. Good morning. Yeah. Yeah. Good morning, everyone. Thank you. Good morning, everyone. Good morning. Good morning. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Good morning, everyone.

Yeah. ♪ Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. ♪ Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah. Good morning, everyone. ♪ Thank you. Music playing you Thank you. Yeah. This is a test. Thank you. Yeah. Music Yeah. The. Hi, everyone. Yeah. Good morning. You. Yeah. Yeah. Hello, everyone. Hi. Yeah. Yeah. Hey. Hi, everyone. you Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. Yeah.

you Yeah. Hi, everyone. Yeah. ♪ Good morning, everyone. Hi, everybody. Thank you. Yeah. you Yeah. ♪ Yeah. . . you Hi. So. Yeah. Welcome to the board meeting. You Oh, Yeah. Yeah. You. ♪ ♪ Yeah. Yeah. Good morning, everyone. ♪ Yeah. You.

9:23 – 9:262 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 50Proposed9:23:58

♪ Hi, everyone. You didn't want to stay here.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role9:26:33

Right, we are now back in open session. Executive Officer please read the report of action.

9:26 – 9:272 turns

CommentExecutive OfficerProposed · by introduction9:26:40

The following is a report of action taken in closed session on July 7th 2026 item number CS2 conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation no reportable action was taken. Item number CS3 public employment consideration of candidates for appointment to the position of interim director of the department of children and family services No reportable action was taken. On item number CS4, conference with labor negotiators Joseph M. Nikita and designated staff no reportable action was taken. Item number CS5, conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation one case no reportable action was taken.

UnidentifiedChairProposed · by role9:27:16

Okay that concludes today's board meeting the next regular meeting will be held on July 14th 2026 at 9 30 am we are adjourned thank you you