UnGovr Transcript
iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.0:00 – 0:034 turns
Before I call the roll, I'd like to note for the record that Supervisor Anderson is participating via teleconference. As such all votes will be handled by a roll call vote. At this time Supervisor Anderson will make a statement about participating remotely and disclose whether anyone over the age of 18 is in the room with them as well as their relationship to the supervisor
First, pursuant to government code 54953 under the provision set forth in the assembly bill 2449 and 2022. I will be participating remotely in this October. 8th or 7th 2026 Board of Supervisors meeting session during due to just cause for the following reason. Contagious illness that prevents member from attending in person
Roll call, called by that Supervisor Anderson is
Show transcript
Okay before we begin the business before our board today, we recess to complete closed session. We estimate the remaining items for closed session will take 45-60 minutes So we will not reconvene before 9.45 AM, that's our estimated reconvening is 9. 45 but we will return after closed session is complete. When we return, we will begin with item 15 from yesterday's session first and then we continue with the land use agenda. We now recess to close session thanks.
Board will now recess into closed session to consider those matters listed under item 16 on yesterday's agenda Okay, we're all good. Yeah.
0:06 – 0:082 turns
You. We now proceed with the closed session report. Council is to report from closed session today.
Thank you, Chair Lawson-Reamer. The Board of Supervisors met in closed session on October 6th, 2026 from 422 p.m. to 506 p. m., and on October 7th, 2026 from 906 a.m.. to 1041 a. m. Four board members were present for both sessions. Supervisor Anderson was absent for both sessions. The board took the following reportable actions. On item 16E by a vote of 4-0, the board authorized county council to initiate litigation. Particulars about the litigation will be disclosed to any person upon inquiry after litigation has formally commenced.
On item 16, I by a vote of 3 to 1 with Supervisor Desmond voting no the board authorized County Council to initiate litigation. Particulars about the litigation will be disclosed to any person upon inquiry after litigation has formally commenced
0:08 – 0:136 turns
Okay, thank you so much. So we now can move ahead to item 15 from yesterday and that was an item that's introduced by Supervisor Desmond and Supervisor Anderson if either of you have any comments and then we'll go to public comments. Okay sorry your hand is up I see it. Thank You Supervisor Anderson
I would just like to start off by thanking Supervisor Desmond for bringing this late docket item forward with me today. Although the county has been on record in opposing the placement of sexually violent predators in our communities, it's important for us to ratchet up our opposition and express our growing concerns to the Superior Court There have been a lot of activities related to the placement of sexually violent predators in San Diego County recently.
I'd like to start by making, when we initiated it because it was a late docketed orb letter We neglected to add John Phillips. He's a sexually violent predator whose placement in Borrego is also being considered in our letter to the Superior Court, so I'd like to make that amendment in the motion moving forward to pass this to include him. While the court is expected to decide as early as October 15th on the proposed placement of two more sexually violent predators in San Diego County, no one knows where other sexually violent predator Earl Wakefield is right now.
That should be extremely concerning, not just to the residents of rural communities where these sexually violent predators continue to be dumped by the state and their contractor Liberty Healthcare but by all county residents. Once these individuals are no longer supervised they can go anywhere in the region. In the case of Murrow Wakefield This sexually violent predator was convicted of lewd or lascivious acts with a child under 14 years old and raped by force.
Because he removed his GPA, I think it's supposed to be a GPS monitor while working in Rancho Bernardo, he can no longer be tracked and is still at large. It should be unconscionable to place more of these individuals who have committed some of the most heinous crimes, while our law enforcement agencies are engaged in a manhunt to find the sexually violent predator forced on us by the state.
It's also important to know that the state and its contractor do when escapes from the supervision occur How they plan to change their process and ensure these incidents don't occur in the future. I would also like to thank the Chair for recognizing the importance of bringing this issue forward today and allowing the Board to weigh in with the Superior Court before October 15th placement hearing by allowing this late docketed item. I respectfully ask my colleagues to support the recommendations that we've brought forward, and that's my motion.
Thank you.
Okay, thank you very much Supervisor Desmond
I'll just go ahead and second the motion. And thank you very much Supervisor Anderson for bringing me on board on this board letter, and I concur that it would be in recommendation number two to include John Phillips in that along with the Michael Poulsen and Rinaldo D'Alessario to include John Phillips who's going to be placed or proposed to be placed in Borrego Springs. So did we give you the language on that? Okay, I don't know if you want to put that up but we just want to add that because Mr. Phillips hearing was the day before although it wasn't decided but his hearing was a day before Wakefield escaped And so we just wanted to add his name to that recommendation number two. So I appreciate the Supervisor Anderson, yes and we do not want any more of these sexually violent predators placed in San Diego County until Wakefield is caught and measures are taken to make sure this doesn't happen again.
So, I'll second the motion and thank you very much.
Okay, thank you. We'll go to public comment?
Thank you chair Lawson-Reamer. We do have 11 total requests to speak, 4 individuals in person and 7 requesting to speak by phone. Also like to note for the record we did receive 5 e-call months on this item all five were in favor For those that requested to speak by phone, if you could please dial into the conference line now. We'll go ahead and begin with those in-person speakers. As your name is called, please come forward and stand on the arrows until it is your turn to speak at the podium. You will then have one minute to address the board. If you could please begin by stating your name for the audio record. I'd like to invite forward the first three individuals.
Allegedly Audra, Mary Davis, and Corbin Winters.
0:14 – 0:197 turns
It's funny that you have authority to micromanage drug dealers, but you have no authority over sexually violent predators. But you do have authority who you contract with. Why are you guys contracting with Liberty Healthcare if they're doing this in our county? Wouldn't that make you want to look at that contract and say hmmm... Are you who we should be contracting with for jail-based services if you are the ones that are ensuring through the state that this gets put into our communities? You guys always act like there's nothing you can do. You can look at that contract and you can say, we're not going to contract with them anymore if they're going to do this.
You're just giving them more money. They're getting plenty of money to house these people. It's very lucrative at the cost of our communities. So when are you willing to look at who you contract with? Don't shame them and then contract with them. And that's what you guys do. You can have the best of both worlds, if you actually care, then you should do that and cancel that contract.
Next speaker is Mary Davis, Corbin Winters, Jeffrey Osborne, and Tonya, I believe it's Ayu. May come forward in any order
Good morning, Supervisors. My name is Corbin Winters and I'm a resident of Jacomba. There are currently three sexually violent predators in my immediate neighborhood of less than 200 houses. That's not to mention the SVPs that live on the outskirts of our community I was recently made aware of a supposed rehabilitated sexually violent predator who lives two doors down from me. We were given zero notification although he is supposedly rehabilitated on the Megan's Law website, he has been given a risk assessment of five which means an above average chance of reoffending This man was determined that he has two counts of lewd or lascivious acts against children under 14. I just don't think this is someone who can be rehabilitated or ever left to live in front of a children's bus stop, which is where he is.
Thank you.
Thank you. Next speaker may come forward in any order
Good morning. My name is Tanya Ayau, A-I-A-U and I'm a co-manager at the Hicumba Community Center where we serve lunch and breakfast to both the youth and the older people and the middle people of Hicumba. And I would like to know what that money that he is earning at that job goes to? Is it like being paid to people here or is the health care, Liberty Health getting that money back? Why are they working in jobs? Would you want your Your cousin, nephew, niece that's 20 something working with one of those people at your job and not knowing that there's a risk with that person because they have a history of doing stuff. What about Wakefield? Did he pick up some poor little kid on his way out wherever he's at now? Because he knows the back country because he lives out there.
I've personally called for the sheriffs at the community center one day when I had two seniors physically having a blowout and it took them 1 hour and 20 minutes. One hour and 20 minutes response That's plenty of time to do an awful lot of damage to anybody. Everybody up there is aware that these people are out there, there's nothing we can do. Thank you and help us.
Good morning Supervisors, my name is Jeff Osborne. I'm the Chair of the Acomba Community Sponsor Group. I am the President of the Highland Senior Center and on the Community Services Board. I want to speak on this topic because I've pretty much spent all my time trying to uplift the Mountain Empire communities And the placement of these predators goes well beyond just the rights that they may have. It affects our community's psychological ability to operate, all of our parents talk about it nonstop. They're constantly concerned about these people and their neighborhoods down the street from them. Anyone we look to hire asks us what's the deal with the sexually violent predators? I talked to our superintendent of the school district he says every new teacher wants to know are they gonna move out to our communities while I don't know There's sexually violent predators there.
I don't want my family there, but they'll drive up from the other communities to teach in our schools. I think the effects of these people being placed in our communities goes well beyond what we often think of. I hope you consider more action on this. Thank you.
And then one final call for Mary Davis, not seeing Mary Davis in the chamber. We'll now go to our phone speakers. When it is your turn to speak you will be unmuted. You will hear a recording that will tell you to begin your comments and we'll go ahead and begin with our first caller.
0:19 – 0:2511 turns
Hello? Can you hear me?
Yes, we can. Hello
Ryan. Okay thanks. Unincorporated areas have fewer resources, fewer police, fewer deputies and fewer hospitals and ambulances. And therefore inadequate response time for emergencies so SVPs should not be placed there Actually, SVPs should put in a comfy house but on prison grounds until they're not violent and not predators. I agree with Otter by the way. Liberty Healthcare should be kicked out of this county!
This is safety issue and I hope you don't give East County the short end of the stick again Between you and Sandag, they have ample grounds for a hefty lawsuit. And...
Thank you your time is up we'll go ahead and go to our next speaker
Good morning, my name is Becky Rapp and I strongly support this item. And also want to address the discussion about limiting public comment based on where someone lives or how often they're allowed to speak. This item involving the placement of SVPs in our county is exactly why the public needs full access to public comment. This impacts all of us. Wakefield was housed in the unincorporated area of the county, but he removed his ankle monitor and escaped while working at Rancho Bernardo. He remains at large and could potentially be anywhere in San Diego County. So which district gets priority to speak about Wakefield? The answer should be everyone!
We are one county. Public safety threats do not stop at district lines, and neither do the consequences of decisions made by this board. Where you live should not determine when you get to speak and what you get to speak about. Please protect meaningful public participation even when you may not agree with what the public has to say. Thank you.
Thank you we'll go to our next caller
It's true, that was well said. Terror-delayed an item about sexually violent predators. San Diego County definitely knows what an unpatriotic authoritarian looks like alright. The policy beliefs of these three wannabe queens who treat perpetrators better than they do victims and ironically hate women are why the SCPs are here. Merle Waitfield, Michael Polson, Renato Del Rosario and John Phillips are a reflection of their sick minds and policies. That is why Waitfield was allowed to just walk away. The toxic criminal first agenda thinking is why they're politically allied judges are releasing SCP's into our neighborhoods. Judge Theodore Weathers is also a pro-criminal progressive and should be held personally criminally liable for his decisions as should all other California judges.
This board, the Consumer Protection Unit and the DA need to sue Theodore Weathers, the State Hospitals, Liberty Health, New Stump, Scott Wiener and anyone else who has advocated for or enabled the release of violent criminals. I wonder if Ebony signing a letter she'll use the auto pen on will mean anything at all coming from this corrupt board? Down with Liberty Healthcare and down with Tara Lawson Reamer.
And Chair Lawson Reamer not seeing any other callers in the call-in queue that will conclude public comment on this item
Okay, I turn it over to Supervisor Desmond. Thank
you Madam Chair
appreciate it just for clarification because I heard quite a few comments the county we do not contract with Liberty Healthcare we don't it is the Department of State Hospitals so this is all state driven this is and there's an election coming up if you want to change some state representatives but this is the Department of State Hospitals contracts with Liberty Healthcare And because of that, these sexually violent predators are now patients.
So they're patients and they have HIPAA protections. So I think it's totally unacceptable. It actually took two hours. Liberty Healthcare is the one that monitors the ankle bracelets. So it took two hours for Liberty Healthcare to notify the Sheriff's Department and law enforcement after this guy cut off his ankle monitor. It took two hours from Liberty Healthcare to do that. The sheriff also had to jump through many hoops in order to get a warrant for Wakefield's arrest because this guy is not under police or law enforcement supervision, he's under Liberty Healthcare's, under the State Department of Hospitals. And so we've asked many times the questions of, are they going to get a job? Or can they get a car? I mean, I was shocked to hear this guy was actually working a job and had a car.
So we've always asked the questions Is this person gonna be able to go to the mailbox? Is this person gonna be able to go to the grocery store? Is this person gonna be able to be let out? And we're always told, we can't tell you because of HIPAA violations. These people have more protections than the rest of us do. The state of California runs these, shoves these guys down our throats and quite frankly even the judges that I've been to many hearings have also said their hands are tied by the state as long as a house meets certain parameters then they can place them there And it's really unfortunate, but it's not the County of San Diego. We don't contract with Liberty Healthcare. It's Department of State Hospitals and I wish we had that authority, but we don't so thank you very much for letting me make those clarifications.
0:25 – 0:3110 turns
Okay, thank you so much. We have a motion on the floor in the second. Seeing no other request or comment please vote.
Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 motion on the floor in the second. Seeing no other request or comment please vote. And it will be roll call
Show transcript
and that motion passes unanimously with all supervisors being present and voting aye.
Okay thank you so much Thank you. I think we're done, right? Oh yeah. Do we have any non-agenda public comment? Okay sorry. We'll do the remainder of non-agenda Tuesday public comment and then we'll roll to the
Wednesday session. No, no. We just have a Wednesday land use for public
comment. We don't have it. We're done.
That's
what I thought we were. Yes, done with Tuesday land uses. Great that's what I thought okay so I was uh yeah so we're now moving over to Wednesday Okay, so go ahead. We'll begin with knowledge and a public comment for Wednesday.
Thank you chair. Lots of rumor we do have 11 total requests to speak three individuals in person eight requesting to speak by phone for those that have requested to speak by phone if you could please dial into the conference line now we will go ahead and begin with in-person speakers and again as your name is called if you could please come forward and stand on the arrows until it is your turn to speak at the podium. You then have two minutes to address the board and if you can please begin by stating your name for the audio record like to invite forward Thomas Wall Robert Gurman and allegedly Audra
Good morning Supervisors. While I'm here in front of you, Joel we got an invite out to you to come to Town Hall and Boulevard. We really would love to have you out there. Hopefully y'all remember me. I'm Thomas Wall. You remember our powerful community from the Starlight Project last month? I just want to take a moment to really share how proud, first of all, I am of our town. I'm glad you're all kind of looking at me right now. I really appreciate that.
We worked really, really hard. We organized. You saw videos. I think you saw a difference in how we showed up. I want to share one really stark point that I think is important for all of you to hear You know, at the Commissioner's meeting I really felt like they advocated for us. They listened, they pushed back against a permit applicant and unfortunately we did not feel that from any of you. You really just kind of aligned with the permit applicant when we needed two really important things. We needed those batteries moved because that made the project safer and you kind of lined with the permit applicant to just make it more about money because they didn't want to spend that money and then the county didn't want to do the EIR And the other point was like you didn't advocate for that Community Benefits Impact Fund.
You know, like you did that in JVR. You could have really pushed that forward so it was really, really disappointing. So my question for you all and I'd love one of you to answer this is how come you didn't advocate for us? I have 26 seconds left, 25. I'd love to hear from one of you please. It's really sad.
Okay, this is going to be another learning experience. I apologize... Robert Gurman. I apologize, I can't get the sidebar out of it so... Starts out with California jet owners delinquent on aircraft property taxes. LA has collected Millions of dollars in back taxes from jet owners who didn't even know that California had property tax on their jets and other aircraft. Hopefully our tax assessor is on top of this better than LA since we're in a budget shortfall, it just always seems like the rich fall through the cracks for paying taxes. I don't know good lawyers Maybe they can't find them in other countries, I really don't know.
The next one is maybe with that property tax money which goes in the general fund we could get some fire trucks for the airports. Do you see any fire truck in there? Although this lady is courageously running down the airport or the runway with her partner filming her and they get to the plane do you still see any fire truck? And by the way, that black smoke is leaded abgas. So it should be classified as a hazmat problem. Not a word mentioned on any TV station.
I think it's disgusting that we can have... We had Cajon Speedway had its own little pickup with fire crew on it. Four people died in 40 years at the Cajons Speedway but yet at our airports that we have 16 of them We have what, one fire crew at Lindbergh? Maybe a fire crew at Carlsbad. But none of the other airports who are extremely busy in Southern California because we have out-of-state aircraft that fly constantly in our airspace and train foreign students who actually, the person that perished in this fire was from a foreign country. How would you like to tell your parents?
Seems like always aviation is exempt from everything. No accountability, thank you.
0:31 – 0:386 turns
All right Jim don't get it twisted I didn't say that you were contracting with Liberty Healthcare for the SVPs you contract them for jail-based services for mental health and competency so that is a contract that you could stop if you really were against them being placed and having them do business like that You could, you're just not willing to. You'll sit here and oppose this but you won't really go where it matters so don't twist what I'm saying and make it seem like I'm saying that you guys contracted with them for this. I know that's the state and I even mentioned that. And it's just sad to see that people from Boulevard... It's good actually because people need to see how you guys are but that you can sit there and stay silent when you've been asked why you didn't advocate That's proof in the pudding you guys are so encroaching upon people's lives, micromanaging them.
Saying that you want to hear from them and then doing something like that where people will come in fill the rooms in a town and you dismiss everything they say but then you blame me for reasons why the meetings are toxic or you can't even get your business done or that people don't want to come in. They come in, you disregard them Right? But as long as you paint a picture that it's other people, it's like... You made a blood oath yesterday to go to the Padres game so you couldn't even do the business that you needed to do to get it done.
And you had to trail it over to today! And you didn't even- you said you were gonna spend an hour and a half on closed session, that you should get it done, and then you come in here and make all these people wait?! ! You're lucky that these people have these sexually violent predators being placed in their community so that they could talk about it today. But there were people that wanted to talk about it yesterday, that you disenfranchised. So don't twist things and make it seem like the people are the enemy when you're the enemy of the people.
And you choose to be that. You guys are hypocrites and you invert everything. You sit here and you virtue signal like what you want is the best for the community Then prove it instead of just totally ignoring the communities that you claim to represent.
Now we will hear from those that requested to speak by phone and again in accordance with the board's rules, we'll be hearing from the first five callers. Remaining callers will be heard at the conclusion of today's session. When it is your turn to speak you'll be unmuted and you will hear a recording that will tell you to begin your comments and we'll go ahead and begin with our first caller.
First caller is Consuelo. Your device might be muted.
Thank you so much for that. Gosh, and that's so true they don't advocate for the people they sell us out to the highest bidder. They don't care about the county they're willing to sacrifice it to become the next Los Angeles right Paloma? Right? Yeah, that's all they do. It's all about money. That's it and climbing up that political ladder So yesterday's meeting was a direct result of people not participating. This board, especially the three supervisors who claim to want public engagement yet the people who can't consistently show up because they give a shit right? That's what your video had me saying right Tara that's what our tax dollars are going after TikTok videos.
How do you twist things and lie about people who don't even come it's years long ago footage and you like show it as if its current You're so evil and I just can't say enough about that. But anyways, the people who come because they have been asked to come are the only ones that you pay attention to. It was repeatedly said yesterday if you want respect, you give it by bit. They're taking every bit of freedom from the people and I want to tell the people directly what you don't use, you lose. This is where we're at. So much is changing within our county so fast Are more consumed with things like Padre thing. This board actually had the nerve to sit up there talking about how we are the ones causing meetings to be delayed and prolonged, yet they rush through a meeting like Audra just mentioned to go to accommodate a game before the people's business.
A game while people are suffering, a game while people can't even afford to feed their families yeah. And then here's the hypocrisy more hypocrisy mentioning How they don't want participation from other cities and other districts. And then they have, I mean the people from Los Angeles coming down to take precedence within our...
Your time is up we will go to our next speaker. Next speaker is Barbara Gordon. You need to mute your device.
Okay, okay. Thank you. The San Diego Climate Week is October 1st through 8th we need to protect our environment the rapidly increasing amount of toxic secondhand smoke in the air from vaping and marijuana and cigarettes it continues to rise It's practically everywhere in places like parks, outdoor events and sidewalks. The problem is only getting worse in large part to the rise of vaping and marijuana in California. According to the California Adult Tobacco Survey, e-cigarette secondhand exposure increased more than 65% in two years and marijuana secondhand smoke nearly doubled. There is no safe level exposure to secondhand smoke. I urge the board to enact now and strict free policies in public spaces.
I believe everyone has the right to breathe clean air, yet I find myself constantly exposed to toxic secondhand smoke. Any exposure can be harmful especially to children older adults and people with disabilities. The consequences of secondhand smoke exposure are severe and can lead to health issues such as cancer, stroke, serious respiratory illnesses and heart disease. The public is asking for your leadership in addressing the rise of secondhand smoke. Limiting the number of places where people are allowed to smoke would make San Diego a healthier, more enjoyable place to call home. Thank you very much.
And one more chance, we can't hear you.
Okay and we'll come back to you.
0:39 – 0:446 turns
Hi, Natalie Rashti. I just wanted to comment again about leadership and yesterday our top tier leadership and what showing it's frustrating when we come to this level of government and kind of gas lit with what the public is doing and seeing at the top tier It is specifically our right and your job to hear what we have to say, regardless if you like it or the way they say it. I'm not saying it excuses foul language but that's the feelings that people have and you chose that position.
I was reading Aristotle's Ethics and I think that everybody should read that book And the first paragraph says, since moral goodness is concerned with feelings and actions. And those that are voluntary receive praise and blame whereas those that are involuntary receive pardon and sometimes pity too. Students of morale goodness must presumably determine the limits of their voluntary and involuntary. Such a course is useful also for the legislators with a view to prescribing honors and punishments You guys are given that responsibility to hear your people.
And when our top tier leadership shows chaos, disruption, division... That is what you're there for! Thank you.
Thank you. We'll go to our next caller.
Good morning, my name is Andrew Lawson. I'm running for the 79th Assembly District. I just want to remind everybody that when your government becomes tyrannical it becomes a duty of the people to replace that government so don't forget to register to vote even though our government is tyrannical in California and they limit public comment at meetings and they've hijacked our election system and made it legal for people to commit fraud in this state I just want to remind everybody too that Pete Hegseth has directed the military to monitor our elections. So, I really hope that San Diego County is doing something to secure our election systems because I would hate for it to come back on November 4th and find out that there was fraud in our election and this county decided not to do a damn thing about it.
But I would like you guys to take some action before Election Day and secure our elections here in San Diego County. We have reports from the CIA that suggest That our systems have been vulnerable for the past 25 years. Gee, imagine that. Democrats in California having super majority power for over 16 years and it's just a fraud? You guys are ridiculous. I hope you guys do something.
By the way, Prop 1 might have a nice little ballot title of veteran housing but it only provides 11% of funding for the veterans. Furthermore I wonder if this board is ever going to recognize the Trump administration and their efforts to clean up the Tijuana River Valley. Or are you guys just gonna keep lying to the people and tell us that you need more of our tax money or squander away?
Thanks, you guys have a great day.
Thank you and we'll go to our fifth call. We'll go back to Ian for our fifth caller in the morning
Good morning Board of Supervisors, this is Anne Riddle speaking. I called in today like many others because we read the UT article this morning about the changes to the speaking procedures at Board of Supervisors. I felt the article was overdrawn and overblown and it didn't fully recognize or Give credence to the people who speak, who are sometimes very frustrated. This morning is a perfect example of a meeting that was supposed to start at 9 o'clock and didn't get underway until closer to 11. For those of us who call in from the workplace this is really difficult and we make special arrangements to speak to you at nine and then when the meeting's delayed that creates a sort of frustration. And I think we need to look at the role of both sides of this dialogue, both the callers and the Board of Supervisors regarding disability we meet here at Board of Supervisors.
We ask that you'll be more sensitive to your constituents, particularly those of us who live in the unincorporated area. We can't drive down there easily and being able to call in is about the only way we can communicate with you. You don't have commissions that can attend like the cities around us do.
I'm going to pause your time you have there's another device in the background and maybe you may be listening to the meeting. But there is a lot of audio frequency coming through so you do need to mute that
0:44 – 0:5123 turns
Okay, what I'll do is call back in a few minutes.
Well this is you're the fifth and final speaker so we're going to move on. You have 40
seconds left. There might be somebody in
an adjoining room perhaps there.
Well,
hello
again. There
you are. I think that
someone's listening to a meeting in one of the adjoining rooms to my workspace and they're rushing to turn off their device. Oh, I'm sorry. Give it another shot another day.
Okay thank you in. And her loss and reamer that concludes public comment for a non agenda public communication this morning and again all remaining speakers will be heard at the conclusion of today's session.
Okay, thank you so much. We now proceed with the formation of the consent agenda audits are on consent or routine only be acted upon with one motion says items 1 through 3 do any my colleagues have
No comments, no need to pull any items. I will move the consent agenda.
Chair Pro Tem Aguirre? None, I'll second.
Okay Supervisor Anderson?
None at
this time.
Supervisor Desmond? None, thank you. Okay we have a motion and second please go to public comment.
Thank you Chair Loftin-Reamer. We do have seven individuals that have requested to speak one individual person six requesting to speak by phone for those that are requested to speak by phone please dial into the conference line. Go ahead and begin with that in-person speaker I'd like to invite forward allegedly Audra you'll have two minutes to address the board and if you could please begin uh by identifying which consent items agenda items
I'll start with one, just the way that you guys word things when you say that there's no new information of substantial importance. Makes you wonder what it is because you guys always like to brush things under the rug and say that it's not substantially increased in severity and that's just your determination when again it's like talking about the Tijuana River Valley at number three This has been going on since the 1930s.
And every time we have to help them quit shitting in our yard, it's very interesting because it's like the first time we helped them make a pipeline in 1938 so that it could go out to the sea which that itself is horrific to think about cause I thought you guys cared about the ocean but why are we the ones that are always constantly having to pay to fix their problem? You know, in the 30s when this started it was like 14,000 people. Now there's a couple of million people and bunch more sewage is coming into our yard and we're planning on making plants when they've never even been able to be sustained because they're overwhelmed by the amount of sewage and with the amount of increasing people going there it's like you guys are unwilling to do what you need to with Mexico just like with Liberty Healthcare.
It's like, you know, Mexico, it's not their problem because they're putting it into our yard If it was their problem, their federal government would give them money for it. That's why we should turn off the water that they're getting from the Colorado River. Because I understand there's a treaty, but when they were not giving Texas water it got shut off and immediately they course corrected. Now if they don't have water to ship back in our yard they're gonna probably course correct and get the money themselves instead of it coming from us. You guys keep going like why isn't anybody doing anything? Why aren't you doing what you need to? You contract and do business with Mexico all the time we're giving them tolls It's like, at what point are we gonna really do what it matters?
Because people are suffering and they have been for decades. More than 30 years since the 1930s. Thank
you. We will now hear from those that are requested to speak by phone again when it's your turn to speak you'll be unmuted. You will hear a recording that will tell you to begin your comments and we'll go ahead and begin with our first caller
The TJ River pollution thing has gone on since 1933. Government action since 1944, look at that! The crisis is now spreading kind of wide and now the San Luis Ray has its own pollution crisis. This is more than a crisis, more than an emergency but your response has been mostly to seek external money or resources for it's sake. We need local action, which would be quicker. It's affecting people daily lives. People are getting sicker worse daily.
You mentioned the paragraph we need to action now not in the future, not when Congress or the state can find the money to act. We're getting tired of air purifiers that don't work, of repeated studies which find the same thing. Of people getting sick from the pollution, of money being thrown at so many things that just haven't worked. Time for a new approach. Maybe local action like I keep saying. I have previously mentioned several possible solutions, the main one being handheld pollution monitors to zero in on the buildings and find out exactly where the pollution is coming from. Look at that!
But I can't support the continuation of what is essentially an industry based on promoting the emergency rather than fixing it. Items 1 & 2 are good But let's have a moment of silence from People's Boulevard when you're about to poison or incinerate with inadequate backgrounds. All of the kids who get murdered, raped or stolen with near impunity in county foster or adoptive care
please rise.
Thank you move on to our next speaker.
0:51 – 0:566 turns
Amen. Yeah, that was excellent Paul and Audra. Yeah and giving Mexico our toll revenue is not helping totally amen to that people have to wake up to know that this issue has not been resolved for decades because it's lucrative and let's not dismiss The blame game, the factor of the blame game of administration dropping the ball does the job too. It just keeps the people further divided, further fighting, struggling and it's just a domino effect you know when the people struggle they need things like these air purifiers and keeps the doctors and big pharma In business, it all is conducive to the system and it all continues because people are not able to pay attention. And like I said, the ones who are paying attention are being penalized for it and the ones who are calling out, the ones that are not necessarily pulling the strings but the puppets, calling out the puppets are being entirely...
What's the word? Uh, shit. What's the word? I can't even think of the words. Um, anyways, uh, our reputations are being tarnished. There you go. It's not, that's not the word I was looking for. But anyways, the point is that people who are paying attention or we see it all and that's a shame that others aren't seeing just how politics are a game of politics and how the system provides off of ignorant And a docile public that thinks voting is gonna do the job and it actually perpetuates it.
I'm done.
Thank you, we'll go to our next caller
So item two, and really this is a general question. Cara does consent count as one item or how many agenda items are within the consent? Not that it matters after a court ruling but you know just curious. So item two adding Enrico Fermi Drive in Sampra Viva Road to the county's responsibility. I'm wondering how did it come to be that the county is responsible for freeway maintenance because last I checked that is the job of Caltrans This is what Caltrans should be paying for, the state.
I guess it doesn't matter if the people affected by Mexico's sewage pay for the roads that benefit Mexico, right? Manuela Paloma Aguirre, that's the only country you're loyal to or ever will be loyal to and I don't even think it's a country, it's not the people because you're not interested in making it better for them to live. That's for sure because they also suffer from the sewage. You're only interested in giving The cartel and the unions more money so they can buy more some complexes to donate back to the corrupt parasitic politicians, the profits that is.
Item three emergency declaration number 100 still no effect and we all remember well at least those of us who were there Imperial Beach April 2025 Manuela Paloma voted against solutions By 2025, I said Manuela would keep up Nora's useless studies and air purifier band-aids. And sure enough that's what she's been doing. April 2026 Sandbag meeting she said she doesn't care what Mexico does with their future toll revenue of the border crossing we are paying for. She does not support water or border shutdowns nor commercial restrictions. She's a betrayed fascist. She only supports more tax scams to benefit These corrupt wannabe queens, aka Measure A. Go on that crap. Imperial Beach has to take all of this issue into their own hands in collaboration with the federal government.
That is the only real solution there will ever be. Certainly never gonna be Manuela Paloma Gaye, never.
Thank you your time is up and Chair Lawson-Reamer that concludes public comment on the items on the consent agenda.
Okay thank you so much. We have a motion and a second please vote
Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 motion and a second please vote
Show transcript
And that motion passes unanimously with all supervisors being present and voting aye.
0:56 – 1:028 turns
Okay great um we now move on to discussion item four strengthening community revitalization and economic development in Jacomba by chair Pro Tem Aguirre and Supervisor Anderson
I'd like to go ahead and make a statement if I may.
Yes, I just recognize you both.
Despite the excitement of my voice, I am very excited to bring this board letter forward today on behalf of my constituents in Hocumba. And I'm grateful to Chair Pro Tem McGeary for her partnership and for joining me on a tour of my district in meeting with Hocumba residents who explained why this effort is so important. Tacoma is a small but mighty town in the far east of our county, which has a poverty rate two and a half times higher than the county average.
It has one sexually violent predator for every 100 residents. However, the community has experienced a much-needed economic revival thanks to the continual restoration of the Halkoma Hot Springs Hotel and community benefit that were provided thanks to this board on part of the JVR solar project. Today's action will help continue and strengthen Cucumber's community revitalization and economic development opportunities by beginning the zoning amendment process to align the general plan with zoning that meets the community's vision.
For far too long Okumbwa has been left behind and today is a big step towards providing them the much-needed opportunities they deserve. Again I'd like to thank Chair Pro Tem Akiri for her partnership in supporting this item and I'm respectfully asking my colleagues for their support as well, and that is my motion. And just For clarity, this item will have staff outreach to Hukumbo learn the residents vision for their community and align the zoning code to meet their vision. It does not allow for a general plan amendment.
Thank
you. Supervisor, sorry Chair Pro Tem. Thank You Madam
Chair Earlier this year, Supervisor Anderson and I toured each other's districts and I heard directly from residents community leaders and business owners. Our communities are different but people want many of the same things good jobs close to home opportunities for local businesses in a county government that listens and follows through During my visit to District 2, I saw the history, natural beauty and community pride that makes places like Hacomba special.
I also heard about the challenges facing these communities. Hacomba residents deserve the same attention and commitment from their county as the communities I represent in my district. That's why I'm pleased to support and partner with Supervisor Anderson on this effort. We have different political perspectives, but we share a responsibility to find practical solutions that improve people's lives.
Listening to what communities need gives us a place to start. Today's action begins a community-driven process to bring Hakamba zoning and development standards into better alignment with the county's general plan and the community's vision. This work can help address barriers to revitalizing Jacomba and its economy over time generating additional tax revenue to help support schools and other public needs.
Any proposed changes will be driven by community input and remain within the housing capacity already allowed by the existing general plan and community plan. Hacumba may be a small community, but this work can make a meaningful difference for the people who call it home. I am proud to support this first step and I'm proud to work with Supervisor Anderson to turn what we heard from residents into action. And with that, I'd like to second the motion. Thank you.
Okay we will go to public comment, thanks.
Thank you Chair Lawson-Rumer. We do have 14 total requests to speak 7 individuals in person, 7 requesting to speak by phone also like to note for the record we did receive one e-comment on this item that was in favor. For those that requested to speak by phone if you could please dial into the conference line. We will go ahead and begin with the in-person speakers as your name is called if you could please come stand on the arrows until it is your turn to speak at the podium. You'll then have 1 minute to address I will be calling individuals in groups of three, so please listen for your name. And the first three individuals are Thomas Wall, Allegedly Audra and Andrew Malik.
Okay if you all recall, I really value kindness respect and dignity. I know it's been a lot of heat in here tonight. I just want to tell you really quick Something's happening in Hacomba. It's really positive, okay? And so you all have an opportunity here to really support that these are really incredible people. The first time I met Melissa, I asked her like what do you guys plan on doing with the community? I thought she was going to talk about pools and hotels and all that. You know what she said to me? She looked me right in the eye and she said We're here to build our community and they live there. So really please, I just talked to you about advocation. You guys would not respond to me in that but please respond by voting for this. It's a really, really great thing.
You can feel good about it. I know you've been in the Hiccumba. Please come on and visit. You don't have to come as a politician. You can come in disguise. You can hang out on the pool or you can hang out on the water but something magical is happening and it's a positive thing so please vote yes for that. Thank you.
1:02 – 1:088 turns
And then again, if you could please line up on the arrows.
Talk about weaponizing free speech. You guys bought them off. Don't sit here and act like you brought in this money. You bought them off so that they consented not to SVPs nor JRBR. But yet it's in there and you're saying you want to listen to the people. Listen to what the community needs. Turn what heard into action. It's interesting because they said they don't want it and the reason why these zoning ordinances are changing is the catalyst is this JVR and the fire station that's needed. So, don't try and spin it and virtue signal like you guys are doing people a favor like you actually fought for this money for the community. No! You work with the developers to get this money because you knew you were going to do what the community didn't want.
So don't buy them off and then sit here and act like you did something great. That's what's so disgusting about what you do because you are the one that weaponizes free speech, and you guys weaponize money and everything you do against the people and it is just appalling but good for them to see it.
Next couple speakers Corbin Winters and Howard Blackson
Hi good morning, my name is Andrew Malick. I am the chapter president of the San Diego Council of Infill Builders and I am speaking in support of item 4. For decades, Hocomba has suffered from systematic neglect and disinvestment. That trajectory changed when a creative group of friends took a massive leap of faith putting real capital and vision into restoring the historic Hocomba Hot Springs Hotel.
Private investors shouldn't have to fight 1980s zoning rules to save the town core. The county needs to back community-led revitalization with modern planning tools. Currently, Jocumbo's general plan rural village designation is directly at odds with outdated zoning like rural residential along Old Highway 80. Item 4 fixes this mismatch. It aligns with the county's climate action plan. It focuses walkable commercial activity within the village footprint protecting backcountry open space without expanding sprawl. This board has an opportunity to support a community. Please vote in support. Thank you.
Corbin Winters, I'm a resident of Hacumba and a mother to a young son. I volunteer at our local community center serving breakfast on the weekends. I love my community and we are in need of help. My son attended our local public school, Clover Flat Elementary for almost two years. The bus picks up and drops off right by our home and this convenience allowed both me and my husband to go to work. My husband is a longshoreman at the ports here in San Diego.
As parents we were disappointed with the conditions at Clover Flat and decided it was not an environment where we could leave our son in good conscience. We are now driving him 45 minutes each way to a charter school, two days a week and we trade off homeschooling him the other three. One look at our local playground in Jacomba and you can see we've been forgotten or worse, we have been a dumping ground. It's our community where the SVPs are placed.
And now our landscape is overrun with hundreds of acres of solar panels that support the energy needs of other San Diego communities but not ours. Supervisors give us a chance.
Thank you Board of Supervisors. Thank you Supervisor Anderson for putting this forward, thank you Chair Pro Tem Aguirre for supporting this. I also want to thank Supervisor Anderson's aide Dollin Young for putting this together, Vince Nicoletti for helping us and even Davia Lynch for her leadership because I know that we worked on this together many many years ago during the general plan update and doing the Hakamba sponsor group community plant update years ago.
Dan Silver couldn't be here today from the Environmental Endangered Habitat League, but he wanted me to relay his support for the recommended limited items such as village regulations which would foster tourist-oriented development And if you could just state your name for the audio record, please. I'm sorry? Oh, you'd state your name for the audio record. Howard Blackson, Urban Designer.
And then final two in-person speakers, Jeffrey Osborne and Tonya Ayew.
Good morning Supervisors, Jeff Osborne again. I am one of the co-owners of the Hukumba Hot Springs Hotel. I'm also the chair of the Hukumba Community Sponsor Group that put this request forward over two years ago. I just really wanted to thank personally Supervisor Paloma Aguirre and Supervisor Joel Anderson for visiting us. We're a very small town and we often find it challenging to get the attention so we really appreciate that. And we appreciate that you listened and are really trying to take some action today to help us in any way that you actually can. So thank you for that, and thank you for Vince and the PDS staff for working with the supervisor's staff on this. It's really appreciated. I'm going to go back in time a little bit. Thank you Tara.
Four years ago, actually maybe five. You put forward the community benefit on JVR and I'm proud to say we just this month finally released a small piece of that for a community needs assessment and we're going to be using that community needs assessment to determine the grants we want to propose for our community So thank you for that, and thank you Jim for supporting that motion at that time. We appreciate your guys' support for our tiny community. This item today will give our community a chance to realign with our history and with the vision of our future determined by us in our community. The item is one step in the right direction, a step towards revitalization of Acumba and the Mountain Empire. Thank you, and we hope you support this today.
Thank you. And final speaker?
1:08 – 1:159 turns
Hi, my name is Tanya Ayau, A-I-A-U. My father moved up to Acomba in the 70s and I spent every other weekend up there and it's my community. And I've come back now that I no longer have a full time job and my full time job now is working at the community center and providing for our neediest people that are out there. We don't have a good bus system. A lot of people don't have phones that work We need to encourage any businesses that are putting back money into our community to help our people now while we have an opportunity with people that are there with a plan that has been very successful. They have cleaned up the town, they've cleaned up all of the old needles and trash that's been around, and the Hicamba Community Center We're going to hear from those that requested speak by phone again when it's your turn to speak you'll be unmuted
It's insulting that Recommendation 3 is to return in 12 months with findings on the project from 2011. When the board letter says on page 2, this action is both urgent and a benefit. Nothing like the residents follow through with Paloma mentioned and get their sexually violent predators out of her combat. The residents have enough to do There are low incomes in solar fuel generating dust and pollution. It sounds like you'd rather rezone to Tacoma to allow more development than actually do it, and that almost sounds like you want to isolate them further. The board letter says that vehicle trips are captured within the rural village by allowing for a wider mix of uses that enable walking and biking to access everyday needs,
which translated means people stay. Thank you your time is up we'll go to our next speaker
Yeah, amen. And Consuelo here so they don't have... I wanted to just answer the guy talking about come in disguise. They don't have to come in disguise to Hicamba quite frankly because no one knows hardly anyone knows who the hell these people are and that this board even exists. So hence why they buy communities off And it's so unfortunate that people aren't seeing through the smoke and mirrors, but there are those of us who do.
And good luck, Hakumba with all the sexually violent predators that the county dumps on you and all of the electric storage vehicles, the battery storage, just yeah, it's a shame. East County has become the garbage can of our county I got to say.
Your time is up, we will go to our next caller.
It's true for the record this is the daytime not the nighttime. Manuela finally visited an unincorporated town outside of Spring Valley She said they deserve equal attention and representation that this board gives to the city of San Diego. So yeah, you're never going to get that. Same for Joel. I love that he bragged about a community benefit bribe that does not represent what the community wanted or should be entitled to for the damage this board has done to their community, let alone what she's done on the boulevard. All this is about is building stacking packs in a combo. Unions like the Building Construction Trades Council or the San Diego Council of Infill Development profit off these giant apartment complexes. Hotels would be better because tourism is guaranteed revenue for the locals, not the special interest.
The 1,356-acre wide JBR Energy Park sold as a fire station basically benefits another special interest, the unionized corporate solar panel developers like Hammond Climate Solutions. Out-of-date regulations is the double speak back door for selling out a Cumba to corporate developers from bunch of fascist fakes. That's what this board
is. Your time is up and Chair Lawson-Reamer that concludes public comment on this item
Okay, thank you. Um I'm happy to support and I just want to say to our community members coming out from come by a really appreciate the fierceness of your leadership for your community and, um. The constructive way that you engage in kind of looking at all sorts of options and opportunities. And Thank you for your work, because it's hard to be responsive if we don't know what folks want. So we definitely know what you all want. So thank you for that. Appreciate it. Supervisor Geary?
Thank you. I just want to add that, you know, we heard it from some of the comments made today but I certainly heard from an array of people while I was visiting there and I think one of the speakers brought it up how challenging the conditions of the schools are and the community in general is quite admirable and all they want is a chance. And I think this is a great first step in giving them that, and giving themselves that ability to grow, to be better, to beautify their community, and to have a steady source of resources that will continue to self-sustain. So that's why I was very happy to support this item And just lastly, I do want to acknowledge one of the commenters that was asking us to respond to your question. Just for procedural purposes because of the Brown Act we cannot directly respond to you during a comment.
That's why nobody responded so just for your awareness. But I thank you for your feedback. Whether it's criticism or complimentary, we are here to hear that. So I appreciate you sharing that with us and with that, you know, I already motioned so Supervisor Anderson.
1:15 – 1:1911 turns
I just want to thank the community for stepping up. It's a long drive, so I appreciate the sacrifice you made. I think today is a new day for East County and I'm grateful to my colleague for touring my district In being open to seeing all the needs throughout the county, not just in her district. And by the way, it's ditto I understood the board letter yesterday at the movie industry having met with the movie industry and her district while I toured her district. And I would encourage all our colleagues if you have a chance to tour somebody else's district, let's set up appointments. Let's do it for everybody. I think we all gain when we know more about the county entirely not just what we read in the newspaper. Thank you Madam Chair.
Thank you. I just want to echo your comments, Supervisor Anderson and I do agree it's so incredibly valuable if we all can better understand each other's districts and I do think, you know, I just know personally, you know, I think I've lived in lots of districts in this county and so there's something that feels helpful. Gone to school in lots of districts and lived in lots I agree, I think that's a great idea. I think it's the more we have a personal first-hand experience with our whole county and not just our district because at the end of the day, we run the entire county and our votes impact everybody. We don't just vote on things that impact our district, we can vote on things that impact everyone. So perhaps we could all work together and get some tours scheduled but I think We are in my district, thank you for coming.
Thank you for joining us in my district. Okay with that we have a motion and second please vote.
Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 motion and second please vote. Thank you
Show transcript
That motion passes unanimously with all supervisors being present and voting aye.
Thank you all so Yeah, I want to make sure you all get it. So let me pull the room. So the next item will probably take 75 minutes or so because we have a lot of speakers and there's a staff presentation. So we would be done maybe 115, 130 at the latest and then we have to do non-agenda public comment or we take a break for lunch and we come back. And do it after lunch. So Supervisor Anderson, would you rather power through another 75 minutes or so? Or would you rather break for lunch and come back?
I will defer to my colleagues. I'm remote, so I don't have the same...
Constraints.
I have easier access to a restroom.
Got it. Okay. And a refrigerator. Okay. Chair Pro Tem! I am hungry. Why am I not surprised? Okay, so I think that we'll most likely break for lunch unless Supervisor Anderson or the Vice Chair of the Strong Program... How about 30 minutes
for lunch?
30 minutes for lunch? I will do my best. I have a medical reason why that might not be sufficient time. So I will try. Why don't we do 30 minutes for lunch and if there's an issue of us starting on time, I'll pass it to the vice chair. Okay great thank you.
Board is in recess for 30 minutes for lunch be back at 12 32.
1:19 – 1:2515 turns
Good afternoon, everybody. We are reconvening our Board of Supervisors land use session. We will begin with discussion on item number five receiving the housing workshop presentation adopt the county's Housing for All initiative receive an update on the Innovative Housing Trust Fund and authorize a competitive solicitation for tenant legal services and fair housing program and I will hand the floor over to the county team for presentation
Okay, good afternoon Vice Chair Montgomery Stepp and members of the board. Last year the Board received the Housing Forward presentation with updates on housing policy and production in the unincorporated area and expressed a strong interest in continued updates on the countywide approach to housing. Under your leadership, the county has significantly expanded its impact on affordable housing in the region.
In fact last fiscal year was a record year for grand openings and groundbreakings for new county funded homes for families, seniors, veterans and people exiting homelessness. With the housing blueprint as a foundation, we have evolved to a broader Housing for All effort. Today we'll highlight some of that progress especially with the Innovative Housing Trust Fund and ask for the board's adoption of Housing For All We are also seeking authorization to release a competitive solicitation for the Tenant Legal Services and Fair Housing Program. I'm joined today by David Estrella and Kelly Sammons from Housing and Community Development Services, and Vince Nicoletti from the Department of Planning and Development Services. Before I hand the floor over to David, I would like to share a quick video.
All right.
This surplus land strategy has been a game changer for meeting our region's housing goals and reflects the county's commitment to housing as a foundation for health and safety. And I'm a new resident here at Mirasol Meadows
A new affordable housing development with apartments set aside for seniors exiting homelessness
The reimagined Villa Serena community highlights the power of collaboration and unwavering commitment to affordable housing
We officially moved in a week ago
Welcome to my new place.
I'm just extremely overwhelmed with gratitude and perfect. I used to dream about having a place like
this.
Here, I'm safe. I am secure. I
have all of my amenities. This is my sanctuary! I just knew that this was the place for me. I am overwhelmed with appreciation. Overwhelmed with blessings. You know something told me that my blessings are going to start coming. They're gonna be overwhelming. They're here.
Thank you Jamie and good afternoon. During today's presentation, we will discuss the current housing landscape and major housing strategy milestones. From there, we'll introduce the Housing for All initiative and the county's housing accomplishments under Housing for All. And finally, we'll close with a look ahead. In recent years, the county has strengthened its approach to housing.
A major milestone occurred in December of 2022 when the board held the Let's Talk Housing workshop that resulted in the adoption of the housing blueprint and it's five policy goals known as The Five P's. In 2024 staff returned to the board with an update on operationalizing priority blueprint actions followed by a memo on progress in 2025 Most recently at the November 2025 housing forward workshop, the board and stakeholders emphasized the need for zoning amendments that reduce regulatory barriers and support housing production in villages.
And other preferred areas near jobs services and transit. Today's Housing For All presentation builds on that conversation. The housing blueprints 5 peas and strategies provide a foundation for understanding the range of actions. The county can take to address our housing challenges. The 5 peas which are promote equity inclusion sustainability produce housing for all preserve vulnerable housing protect tenants and prevent displacement represent Building on the work reflected in the housing blueprint, the county is moving forward with a comprehensive plan known as the Housing for All initiative. The initiative is not a new approach but rather a consolidation of our existing housing initiatives, frameworks and strategies under one cohesive identity.
I'll now pass the presentation over to Kelly Solomons to highlight the county's housing accomplishments.
Thank you, David. The county continues to support the development and preservation of affordable housing through the administration of local state and federal funding programs. The county has invested $398 million for the creation and preservation of 123 developments including 12 county- Just put
the mic a little bit closer to you just so we can make sure we pick
1:25 – 1:363 turns
The county has invested $398 million for the creation and preservation of 123 developments, including 12 county-owned sites with 9,423 units throughout the region. These funds have leveraged over 3.2 billion in other local state and federal funding. These efforts will enhance the quality of life for over 90,000 households over the span of the affordability period and have a positive economic impact such as creating employment for San Diegans.
The Innovative Housing Trust Fund or IHTF was established by the Board of Supervisors in 2017 to increase the regional supply of affordable housing. Prior to 2017, county investment in affordable housing totaled about $55 million over the span of 35 years. Since the creation of the Innovative Housing Trust Fund in 2017, less than 10 years, HHSA has committed over $343 million in local state and federal sources supporting affordable housing across San Diego County.
To date, the board has approved $129 million into the IHTF over seven funding allocations that include the most recent allocation of 22 million. IHTF supported the construction of 38 developments with 3,396 deed-restricted housing units funded with IHTF. The reimagining of county owned land has been a game changer for helping the county meet its region's housing goals.
The county currently has 12 sites in various stages that will bring approximately 1,800 new affordable housing units to the region supported with over $52.8 million. Modica and Terramena are two of the four developments at the former County Crime Lab site in District 4, shown here. Goodwin-on-Glacier, currently a county owned parking lot in District 2 will be transformed to provide 131 homes for seniors.
Staff also continue to explore other future sites. The county and city formalized a joint commitment to support building 10,000 affordable units on publicly owned land As of March 2026, these shared efforts support nearly 7000 units across the region with continued progress underway towards a 2030 goal. This includes 1855 units funded in part by the county.
Homekey Plus partnerships have also been vital and accelerating projects in District 1, 4 & 5. These collective efforts strengthen the collaboration in alignment with Housing for All. Another key partnership under the Housing for All initiative is supporting affordable housing on faith-based land. Changes to state laws have made it easier to develop on faith based land, creating an opportunity to expand affordable housing in our communities.
The county has funded three such developments to date which will create 220 affordable homes. Examples include Nestor Senior Village and the Haven on Palm partnerships with the United Methodist Church. Staff also continue to engage in cross-sector meetings and forums focused on financing, funding opportunities and collaboration including the Regional Housing Finance Agency Advisory Board.
Through the Housing for All initiative, the county has launched the Housing for All Hub, a centralized place for community members to access information on housing services, resources and data. We've improved the county restricted affordable housing map and launched the San Diego County Housing Legislation Map, a tool that makes it easier to see exactly where in the unincorporated area you can build using state laws designed to streamline housing development.
In addition, we have implemented a new Housing Authority case management system to modernize operations and enhance the overall experience for participants and landlords. The county also continues to support residents in the unincorporated areas through both preservation and access to home ownership. The home repair program provides necessary health and safety repairs, helping eligible low-income participants maintain safe and stable homes.
The county also offers first time home buyer programs, helping low and moderate income households attain homeownership through low interest deferred payment loans. Finally, the county continues to commission studies to better understand and promote the community land trust model throughout the region and identify opportunities to use this innovative approach to preserve long-term affordability and expand home ownership opportunities.
Next, advancing the five P's in strategies requires a county of one approach. And now I would like to introduce Fitz Nicoletti.
Within the unincorporated area, the county is advancing a variety of land use and housing policy initiatives to support housing production and address the region's housing needs. While there is no single action that can solve the housing shortage, the county has several policy levers that can be used to facilitate housing development, increase housing constructed, and improve affordability.
The housing levers generally fall into four categories. Planning for housing involves ensuring that the county's long-range plans allow for future housing growth in appropriate locations, particularly in areas near transit services, jobs and existing infrastructure. Removing regulatory barriers focuses on reducing regulations and increasing flexibility to make it easier to build housing.
Simplifying processes focuses on creating quicker, more efficient and predictable permitting pathways for approving housing projects. And expanding housing opportunities focuses on supporting a wider variety of housing choices and ownership opportunities. Several recent and ongoing initiatives demonstrate how these policy levers are being used to support housing production now.
Under Planning for Housing, the Sustainable Land Use Framework will help guide future land use decisions in the unincorporated area including the next housing element update. It also builds on last year's Housing Forward Workshop by exploring ways to support housing in the right location including villages, areas closer to jobs, services and transits. Under removing regulatory barriers, the Housing Unlocked Zoning Ordinance amendment is anticipated for consideration this fall and would increase development flexibility for housing.
The County's zoning ordinance cleanup also scheduled for this fall will improve clarity and align local requirements with changes in state law. The simplifying processes lever includes updates to the grading ordinance to create clearer and more predictable paths for housing development while continuing to protect important environmental resources. Finally under expanding opportunities, the county's regulations allowing for the separate sale of accessory dwelling units or ADUs create home ownership opportunities and the recently adopted inclusionary housing ordinance increases the supply of affordable homes for lower income households. These homeownership opportunities are augmented with first time home buyer programs available. I'll now hand it back to David.
Thank you Vince. The County's Tenant Legal Services and Fair Housing Program plays a key role in protecting tenants. These provide critical legal assistance to tenants who are facing housing challenges. Through a combination of legal counseling, outreach, education and eviction prevention services the program focuses on reaching vulnerable and underserved populations.
In calendar year 2025, the program served over 2,300 clients supported by a county investment of $3 million. This investment reflects the County's commitment to stabilizing residents in their homes, preventing homelessness and protecting the rights of community members. The programs and initiatives we have discussed today reflect our ongoing commitment to increasing housing opportunities The final section highlights some of the priorities that will guide our efforts moving forward.
Up next for the Innovative Housing Trust Fund, $13 million of the recent $22 million allocation was awarded to affordable housing developments on county property in Grantville and Escondido. Staff anticipate awarding the balance of the IHTF funding to development partners through an open notice of funding availability or NOFA. The NOFA includes $9 million in IHTF and other state and federal funding sources. And we'll close this November with awards issued in early 2027.
Following award of IHTF funding, construction may begin at the development sites within the next two to four years. Lastly, funding is the foundation of every successful housing initiative. Good morning, everyone. As you can see, continued funding is essential to maintaining momentum and ensuring that effective housing solutions remain available to those who need the most.
A key organizational priority is identifying a dedicated revenue stream for the innovative housing trust fund to strengthen the long-term sustainability of affordable housing development since 2017 along with Once funding commitments from the current open offer awarded, no other local or state funding sources will be available. This chart illustrates the level of investment the county can realistically provide for affordable housing development in the coming years if no additional dedicated ongoing resources are allocated to the IHTF. The $22 million recently allocated By pairing a sustainable local investment with advocacy at the federal and state levels, the county can maximize external resources, accelerate affordable housing development and help address the region's long-term housing needs.
Looking ahead, strengthening partnerships will continue to be an important part of how we advance our housing goals. As previously discussed, we have already begun building relationships across the public, private, nonprofit, faith-based and community sectors. The next step is to deepen those partnerships and turn collaboration into tangible opportunities by leveraging public and faith based land, supporting affordable housing development or working together on innovative housing solutions.
As we conclude the actions presented today reflect the county's continued commitment to addressing the housing needs of our communities. The work we have highlighted demonstrates that Housing for All is not a new direction, but rather unification of our existing housing initiatives, frameworks and strategies under one cohesive identity. Today's actions request the board to find the actions today are exempt from CEQA, receive a housing workshop presentation and adopt the county's Housing for All initiative as the county's overarching housing framework.
We're happy to answer any questions you may have. Thank you.
1:36 – 1:4327 turns
Thank you very much for the presentation, David. Can you go back to the slide where you had the Innovative Housing Trust Fund? I just wanted clarity on the notice of
funding
availability, NOFA. Can you just walk me through the two projects that were... can somebody pull up that slide? Thank you. The two projects that were mentioned there, were those separate from the NOFA that's currently open or was that in addition to? I just want to get an idea of what the balance is right now.
Thank you for your question Chair Pro Tem. So the initial allocation was $22 million for the Innovative Housing Trust Fund I'll call on Kelly to give us some of the specifics.
One development that was funded was the Joel, which is in the Grantville area. It's 206 units for individuals and families and they received an award of $7 million. And the other property is in Escondido. I'm sorry, Valley Creek, which is in Escondido serving seniors and also permanent supportive housing for veterans. And that will create 136 units and they receive an award of $6 million.
So that's $13 million? Correct. So then the NOFA, the currently open one, it's page 18 please. Thank you. The current NOFA, how much is that being made available? The balance or how much?
It's the balance
and additional funding sources. Correct we have additional federal funding sources through the HOME Program, Home Investment Partnerships as well as Community Development Block Grant and a little bit through some state programs. Got it okay
thank you so much that's very helpful
Supervisor Desmond.
Thank you, Vice Chair. A couple of questions. Where is the housing hub? County Housing for All Hub?
It's on the county website and I'd be happy to send you a link
to that. Is it in what community? At the COC or where is this hub?
Oh, I'm sorry, it's an online web page. It's a webpage.
That's what you said the first time, all right. I
was
looking for an address but I guess that's it. Yeah, yeah, www address go ahead.
And Supervisor, the beauty of the hub is it's all the information is available on County Housing Community Development Services our webpage and along with it goes a map I guess going on to
with the Valley Creek. I didn't know it had a name, Valley Creek now. The one in Escondido which is great. So where does that put both of these projects? We got $7 million for the Grantville project and $6 million for the Escondido project. So are those projects then... I guess what's the next steps to get any of them built?
Yes we expect both those projects to apply for tax credits in early 2027 and then break ground shortly thereafter
All right, well great. Well it's good to hear that and I guess I didn't quite catch then out of the 22 million this is 13 million where's the balance? Or is that still in the IHT? Because it says on the slide 18...I was looking at it We just
recently released a NOFA with the remaining $9 million in innovative housing trust fund paired with about another 5 to 6 million in federal and state funding. So there's a current NOFA
out. That's still part of the future NOFA, okay well thank you very much great to see this We're moving forward and there's anything we can do to help the Escondido entity. I know that it's been developed around there, that's where the old hospital was right across the street. That hospital is now housing which is very good and I think the senior housing in there is really going to complement that area where that old hospital was so thank you.
Okay, thank you all any other questions or comments? Okay we'll go to public comment
Thank you chair Lawson-Reamer. We do have 21 total requests to speak, 10 individuals in person and 11 requesting to speak by phone and two group presentations. Also like to note for the record we did not receive any comments on this item. For those that have requested to speak by phone please dial into the conference line now. We will go ahead and begin with our group presentations I'll be calling the first group forward. You will have 10 minutes to address the board, all members of the group must speak during that 10 minutes. Please self-regulate your time with a timer on the podium. I'd like to invite forward the first group which consists of Peter Armstrong, Paige Eves, Randy Slavers and Dante Golden. You can go ahead and approach the podium And then just as a reminder, each person in the group may speak for no more than four minutes.
As you come forward if you could please state your name and then do you have the rest of your group? There's two of us that are missing right now I don't know if it makes sense to wait or... Yeah, the board rules you have to have three minimum. Okay So we can call the other group forward while you coordinate the other group members coming.
Cool thank
you. Okay, no problem All right so we'll call the other group forward I'd like to invite forward Gilberto Vera, Joanne Franksis and Emilio Romero. And then same rules apply 10 minutes no one person can speak more than four minutes and each person in the group must speak.
1:43 – 1:506 turns
I also brought copies of our presentation.
Wonderful if you hand them to the deputy clerk behind you she can distribute
One second, let me just queue up our presentation. Thank you for your patience
Wonderful, and then if everyone can just introduce themselves as they come up to speak.
Good morning my name is Joanne Franciscus I'm the Executive Director of the Legal Aid Society of San Diego we run the Tenant Legal Services Program and today i'd like to share with you some of the program's recent data and accomplishments The TLS provides a one-stop shop of free legal services to low income tenants in the County of San Diego including outreach education clinic services legal representation case management and emergency financial assistance all designed to prevent addictions and homelessness From January of 2025 through August of 2026, we've answered over 3,800 housing calls. We've served 39, sorry, 3,970 unduplicated clients with legal services and case management. We've helped more than 4,400 clinic participants and assisted 109 households with emergency financial assistance.
A total of 10,650 households have benefited from the program. We've also served as a coordinating agency for the Housing Justice Collaborative maintaining the HJC website organizing committee and network partner meetings and conducting more than 74 outreach and education events. The Tenant Legal Services Program is an effective and efficient tool for preventing homelessness and ensuring housing for all In the last 20 months, 84.6% of TLS clients were able to remain in their same home and an additional 8.1 were successfully able to move into a new unit meaning TLS services prevented homelessness in at least 92.7% of cases.
Addressing homelessness after it occurs costs the government approximately $50,000 per year per individual. By comparison, the cost of the TLS services averaged out to just $1140 per case But the TLS does more than just make fiscal sense, it furthers equity. 50% of our clients are disabled, 26% are aged 60 or above, 70% earn less than 30% of the area median income.
TLS ensures that vulnerable people have access to courts and lawyers so that tenants with meritorious defenses can prevail. It ensures that our most vulnerable residents don't have to suffer the lasting trauma that eviction and homelessness cause when it is preventable. Before I turn it over to my colleagues, I'd like to share some stories of clients served in the TLS program.
Cori was a disabled mother of four actively fleeing domestic violence when she came to Legal Aid. Her abusers stopped paying rent as a form of financial abuse, triggering an unlawful detainer and termination of their Section 8 voucher. Through the TLS program Legal aid settled the unlawful detainer, had the abuser removed from the Section 8 voucher and the voucher reinstated and reassigned to Corey. Corey was provided with case management services to help her find new housing and financial assistance to cut our moving costs. As a result, Corey and her four children were able to escape abuse and find new stable housing.
Pedro and his family Faced eviction for non-payment of rent after his wife and son experienced medical emergencies, rendering them unable to work. Pedro found a higher paying job and could pay all the family's expenses moving forward but could not cover the arrears. Through the TLS program, Legal Aid intervened with legal assistance and emergency financial assistance. As a result, the family was able to come current in their rent, avoid eviction and homelessness, and is now stable and can pay their rent going forward. When it comes to the TLS, every dollar is money well spent because this program works.
Hi, good afternoon. My name is Amalia Romero and I'm the Managing Attorney for the Fair Housing team at Legal Aid. I'm here to speak in support of continued funding for tenant legal services and in particular the importance of pairing that with fair housing services as well. At Legal Aid we are very well aware that projects are most effective when they address issues in a holistic manner. We really embrace that approach as an agency providing services through more than a dozen different practice areas And for housing specifically, we have an internal housing task force that allows for cross-team collaboration to identify emerging trends and more effectively respond to changing community needs. So when someone comes to us with an eviction which is an issue that just rarely exists in isolation, we can also help with their other legal issues.
We can help with their public benefits, their health access to healthcare domestic violence issues or housing discrimination issues. Having fair housing attorneys within our organization allows us to address the root causes of housing instability and not just the immediate crisis of an eviction. Fair housing work helps people access housing, maintain it, and prevent conflict before it escalates. For example, a very common example, reasonable accommodation requests can resolve a dispute between a tenant with a disability and their landlord before it escalates to an eviction and possible homelessness.
Another important aspect of fair housing law is that it provides both administrative and legal remedies, and our team helps people who've experienced discrimination through a range of legal services including court representation as may be appropriate for fair housing violations. And lastly, I really want to emphasize the importance of maintaining local funding for Fair Housing Services. While federal funding remains very important it increasingly comes with restrictions on the types of issues that can be addressed using that funding. Some of the areas that have been limited include issues like for example tenant credit screening and junk fees issues that disproportionately impact vulnerable populations including people of color, people with disabilities.
It's impacted our ability to provide language access and translated information as well as the ability to enforce state and local fair housing protections like laws that protect Section 8 voucher holders. We've had to turn away clients with legitimate state claims due to these funding restrictions So at a time when housing stability is more important than ever, continued local investment in tenant and fair housing services it's incredibly important to residents being able to obtain housing keep it and seek meaningful justice when discrimination occurs. Thank you
1:50 – 1:563 turns
Good afternoon, chair and supervisors. My name is Gil Vara. I'm the director of the Housing Justice Collaborative and Legal Aid. First, I want to begin by thanking the board for its leadership and vision and also staff in addressing our region's housing crisis. First, the county has made important investments in the tenant legal services program that helps families stay housed, avoid eviction, and prevent homelessness before it starts.
We're very grateful for this continued partnership with the county. Also, the county has expanded affordable housing production as we just saw The city of Sioux Falls has And lastly, earlier this year the creation of the County Consumers Protection Unit also demonstrates a commitment to ensuring tenant rights are protected and enforced. These accomplishments deserve recognition but as we celebrate this progress, we should also continue to build by sharing and learning from best practices around the country. For example, cities like Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Philadelphia are three of 28 jurisdictions that have invested in right-to-counsel programs to provide free legal representation to tenants facing eviction These programs not only keep families housed, but have been proven to be a cost-effective homelessness prevention strategy.
A study conducted by the Philadelphia Bar Association on the Right to Counsel project found that a relatively modest investment in legal services 3.5 annually generates substantial public savings of 45 million dollars annually by preventing displacement and reducing homelessness. This is almost a 13 to 1 return on investment Tenant legal services are most effective when paired with strong tenant protections. For example, just cause eviction protections, local rent stabilization measures and innovative policies like the City of Los Angeles Eviction Rent Threshold give families additional safeguards during times of financial hardship and provide opportunities to connect with legal assistance and access rental support before a housing crisis pushes families into homelessness.
These policies are rooted in a simple belief. No family should lose their home because they can't afford an attorney, experience a temporary setback or fell behind on a relatively low amount of rent. Also as we move forward I encourage the county to continue thinking regionally. Housing instability does not stop at our artificial city borders when families in Chula Vista, Oceanside Escondido, Vista and El Cajon lose their housing the consequences impact all of us We would encourage the county to explore partnerships with these cities to expand 10 illegal services and homelessness prevention programs. A countywide housing safety net should be a shared regional responsibility by leveraging resources from cities throughout San Diego County, we can expand access to legal representation and reach more households before eviction and homelessness occurs.
Finally, I would urge the county to prioritize data collection with the development of a rent or eviction registry. We can't solve what we do not measure. Better data will help us identify where the displacement is happening, how to target the homelessness prevention resources we have, inform future housing and zoning decisions, and ensure that public investments reach the communities with the greatest need.
And in closing, thank you for your leadership and your continued support in ensuring every person in San Diego County a safe, stable and affordable place to call home. Thank you all.
Thank you. And then my understanding is the rest of the group members have came from Group 1 so I'd like to invite forward Peter Armstrong, Paige Eves, Randy Slobbers and Dante Golden may come forward to the podium please. And then just as a reminder, you have 10 minutes to address the board. All members of the group must speak during that 10 minutes and no one person can speak longer than four minutes. And then as you come up and you start your speaking if you could just introduce yourself.
Good afternoon. Good afternoon. I wanted that good afternoon chair loss and remember some don't take hold in senior director of policy at City Housing Federation we have been the voice for those who support build and finance for housing in San Diego since 1990. I want to start by saying thank you this board has shown what real commitment to affordable housing looks like The 22 million made available in 2026, 2027 fiscal year continues that momentum and the sector is grateful for it. The county is also led by example on surplus land 2012 surplus county properties are in the pipeline expected to produce approximately 1800 affordable homes proof that public assets when put to work intentionally can make a real difference we have been actively engaged at the state level to strengthen the Surplus Lands Act and close loopholes so more California jurisdictions follow San Diego's lead And the results are showing up where it counts.
The county's investments have helped put thousands of San Diego's into stable affordable homes, seniors, veterans, families and people moving out of homelessness but the California Housing Partnerships 2026 San Diego County housing needs report reminds us of how much further we have to go to see progress. The need is deep and it is not slowing down Every county dollar this board invests leverages state and private capital through HDFC, HCD, SIDLAC, TCAC and a range of other state funding programs.
With Prop 1 on the November ballot yes vote would bring in a substantial increase in state affordable housing resources but only jurisdictions with local investments to match will be positioned to compete for them. The Innovative Housing Trust Fund is exactly that tool to help us out. If time permits I think it does. The pro-housing designation Thank you very much. Thank you very much for the opportunity to be here with you today. We're going to talk a little bit about what's coming up in the next couple of weeks and then we'll get into some of the details as we go through the rest of the meeting. But first, I want to thank you all for joining us this evening. As you can see on the screen right now, we are in the middle of an extremely busy time right now.
We've got a lot of work ahead of us. Your partnership with the sector matters now more than as ever. Thank you.
1:56 – 2:046 turns
Good afternoon chair members and the board my name is Randy slavers and I'm assistant vice president development with National Corps in support of item 5. And the county's housing of all initiatives, I've been with National Corps for about 7 years we've already went through a lot of the numbers of of the development so I'm not going to bore you with that but The I see commitments close critical gaps as many know and strengthen our ability to secure tax credits.
This is a partnership that resulted in a ground lease with the church. And it just demonstrated why the blueprints emphasis on faith-based partnerships matter with diverse rights support community land could become. It's actually a cornerstone of the success of development. We're now building on this approach for Valley Creek, which was mentioned we were We're very pleased to be here. And are very thankful for the award for the surplus land and for the I H T F funding. I am very pleased to say that we're already 4 weeks in the plan check.
It's just a beautiful senior center that's going to have 136 because of my mom's love The combination of land and funding is extremely powerful. It gives us the site and financial foundation from which to pursue remaining sources needed to deliver these homes. As you consider housing for all, I encourage continued IHTF investment, access to county surplus land, and these committed partnerships These help us deliver housing. This is our shared goal, and this is a wonderful, wonderful initiative. So thank you to the board and the staff for your commitment and your collaboration.
National Corps looks forward to continuing to build more affordable housing homes with you, and thank you for listening.
Good afternoon, my name is Peter Armstrong. I'm a Vice President of Real Estate Development with Wakeland Housing. Wakeland is a non-profit affordable housing developer and we've been working in San Diego since 1998 and to date we've created 70 affordable housing communities and almost 9,000 affordable homes And since our inception, we've really value our work with residents of the county.
With our housing and with our services, we've touched the lives of more than 50,000 county residents as part of our work. Over the past 10 years, Wakeland has had the great pleasure to have a lot of collaboration with the County of San Diego. A big part of that has been your innovative housing trust fund. Wakeland has received three awards to date and these are communities that are really transforming the neighborhoods and the county at large.
First project I'd like to highlight is called City Heights Place in City Heights, San Diego. And the IHTF gave us $3 million and with that we were able to develop and bring to fruition 60 affordable homes for families And that was a part of the ongoing revitalization of the City Heights Urban Village. There's been a dramatic transformation of City Heights since the mid-90s.
A lot of that work has been in partnership with Price Philanthropies, and Price continues to go. And so that project was completed in 2023. We also had another project, and I don't want to be remiss, Supervisorial District 4 is the City Heights Project. The second project I'd like to highlight is called Casa Anita, that's in District 1 in Chula Vista. That project we also received $3 million from the IHTF. In addition we received $5 million in your No Place Like Home funds And that's a 96 unit project for large families with 24 of the units set aside for residents exiting homelessness.
And as I said, that was completed in 2023 and that's a partnership with the City of Chula Vista. And finally, I just want to highlight a project we recently received an award on called The Jewel located in Supervisorial District 2 in Grantville And that's also on a county surplus land site. And that will be 210 units for families, and there's kind of a sister project directly across the street called Goodwin-on-Glacier that we're set to start construction on in January. And that one will provide 131 homes for low income seniors.
And as I said, that's also a surplus land site. That project was really fortunate to receive an award from the state of $35 million through its MHP program And I think what I'd like to, you know leave you with is that we're hoping that we're going to have an opportunity with the passage of Proposition 1 in a few weeks. That will provide billions of dollars for new affordable housing and so Your work on the surplus county land sites and your work with the Innovative Housing Trust Fund and your other sources will really be a benefit as we try to bring as many of those, you know, the $10 billion to San Diego County. And so having the support... I'm going to pause your time.
You're passed for four minutes. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Your final member can come speak. You have 40 seconds left.
You're telling the preacher she has 40 seconds?
I'm so sorry.
I'm Reverend Paige Eaves, I work in the Bishop's Office of the United Methodist Church. We cover Southern California, Hawaii and Guam. In recent years we've worked with developer partners to transform a number of our properties. We have a pretty significant portfolio including the Nestor Senior Village and just recently County staff Wakeland and Supervisor Geary and I were there in Imperial Beach to celebrate a ground Thank you so much. All right, so now we will begin with the in person speakers
2:04 – 2:0910 turns
As your name is called, if you could please come forward and stand on the arrows until it's your turn to speak at the podium. You'll then have one minute to address the board. Please begin by stating your name for the audio record and I'd like to invite forward allegedly Audra Muhammad Umar and Ansemero Estrada AJ.
It's interesting how much developers benefit from these projects. Of course, people want to make money but just sad. And I feel like this shows how left behind the unincorporated areas really are because the cities all have their own incorporation to go in and provide different things to them and it just shows how These projects are more in the cities and not out in the rural area because there aren't transit hubs. And they won't meet the requirements to be able to go and get that funding, to have things be built in the unincorporated areas. So it's like look at Jacomba and Boulevard for example I mean the only way they get money to come into their community is if you flood them with solar panels against their consent, then they get money to spend on their community.
But it should be that there's money that's going to them naturally. It shouldn't be that they have to fight for it while the cities thrive and they're just trying to survive.
Good afternoon, my name is Mohamed Omar. I'm with the Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans here today as a member of the Coalition for Equitable Development advocating for policies and public investment that support environmentally sustainable equitable development in socio-economically and culturally diverse communities We support county efforts to provide critical gap financing through the innovative housing trust fund, develop access county land with affordable homes, unlock land for development and provide rental assistance.
And we appreciate the county efforts to address the coalition concerns related to the county budget inclusion in housing ordinance and the basic needs of our most at-risk residents. However, the board's delay in acting decisively to protect renters causing And then just one final call
Okay, not seeing AJ in the board chamber. We will go ahead and go on to our callers again. When it's your turn to speak you'll be unmuted and you'll hear a recording that will tell you to begin your comments and we will go ahead and begin with our first caller.
Hello, innovative housing trust fund is neither innovative nor trustworthy. It does give away to developers Maybe three of the five Ps are piss off poor people. When the landlord collects a wide range of incomes for their affordable rents like under 60% period, it's a scam that allows them to pick and choose. I'm sure it will be the guy who can pay the rent rather than give them piece of paper or as it is usually called a voucher.
So that's why so many people can't get into housing. It looks like the legal services are mostly educational, so I'd suggest combining the expiring Legal Aid Society contract with the CSA San Diego contract mentioned in the board letter and save us all that money to renew your estimate and recommendation.
Your time is up we'll go to our next speaker.
Before you start my time, Ryan, what do we have on it? Two minutes or one minute.
It's one minute.
Okay and I just also wanted to add that there are people in the queue. You didn't call me for closed session and I was on the phone waiting so anyways I just wanted to address that with the calling system. Okay, but here goes my speech. Okay another band-aid on our dime once again never getting to the source of the problem government continues to be wasteful with our money just more temporary fixes but no real solid solutions.
The system itself is the source of the problem Government creates the problems then swoops in as if it's the savior, the hero that's come to save the day. Anyone who believes government is here to help please look up Stockholm Syndrome. Thank you.
Thank you we'll go to our next caller
2:10 – 2:159 turns
Hi, good afternoon Chair, Vice-Chair and Board of Supervisors. This is Jesse Schmidte State Policy Manager for Alliance San Diego and here on behalf of the Coalition for Equitable Development a local housing coalition that advocates for policies and public investments that support environmentally sustainable equitable development in socioeconomically and culturally diverse communities through San Diego. We support county efforts to provide critical gap funding through the Innovative Housing Trust Fund to develop excess county land with affordable homes and unlocking land for development We are appreciative of county efforts to address the coalition's concerns related to the county budget, inclusionary housing ordinance and the everyday essentials of our most at-risk residents.
However this board's delay in acting decisively on expanded tenant protections has caused household stress and continues to force families to make tradeoffs Thank you. Your time is up. We will go to our next speaker.
It's true. The housing in the video, uh, the sack attack, it was like Mount Etna that just flooded and nobody cared about the seniors there or like the ones in East Village with all the drug addicts or like Union Grant building with all the shootings. You know this item is a great example of paid speakers who monopolize my time and really we don't need to waste time on their repetitive comments But you know, it's because the unions who funded the three wannabe Queens campaigns like AJ and the Building Construction Trades Council. And there are some conflicts in National City legal aid who barely help anybody. And of course, the communist terrorist group, ACE, who funded corrupt politicians, Alison Snowman, Wallace Loma. Those are conflicts of interest that need to be disclosed.
How much parking will be insured? None, right. What about fire EMS and law enforcement funding? None. Junk box housing for as long as you don't have money and don't want to actually own anything. County owned land, county owned unlocked profit. Wouldn't want to give the land back to we the people would you? So greedy won't even give it back to my American Indian people racist fascists.
Fantastic again.
Thank you time is up. We'll go to our next speaker
I'm glad they're collecting more information on all these guys that rent these places. Because we just had a terrorist attack, Ali Aqba on an airplane! We need to go through these Muslim guys that are occupying these buildings, especially the Somalis. Those guys are pirates man. They're scammers.
These comments are off topic? This is your first warning? Thank you.
Inspect all these units they said more data one guy mentioned data we gotta collect all the data Let's start collecting all these data on these people. Because a lot of them are really shifty, man. A lot of those smiling guys occupying and building these places. They're not on the up-and-up. The builders are smiling all the way to the bank, man! They know it's a scam. But they're in on it. But any guy that lives there... You guys are supposed to watch out for us, man! Protect us from these
Allah Akbar types in the world. That could be one... Thank you your time is up we'll go to our next speaker
Hi, Natalie Rushdie. I do want to highlight that I was able to access legal aid a couple of years ago and they did prevent me from being wrongfully evicted. I would like to Thank you. Go to our next speaker. Good afternoon, my name is Emma Navarro and I'm a recent term policy advocate with the Center on Policy Initiatives. I'd like to thank District 1 for their efforts involving community organizations to work on sustainable housing solutions. It is important to engage housing advocates. We also ask for continued community collaboration and to include outreach to individuals that will be directly benefiting from the upcoming housing development across the county. CPI believes that the best way to ensure that housing is created and functions equitably, if IC can be advised are working class people most hit by the lack of housing affordability and the highest risk of falling into homelessness.
The UCLA Center for the Transformation of Schools recently released a report on the housing crisis for students experiencing homelessness across the state and San Diego was listed as the fourth county with the highest count of students experiencing homelessness Taking this into consideration, we'd like to specifically highlight the high needs to seek collaboration with and elevate the voice of the parents, school district leadership and CDRs working with these groups. Thank you for your ongoing effort.
Thank you. Your time is up. We'll go to our next speaker.
2:16 – 2:229 turns
Hi, Guadalupe Rojas.
Hello Supervisors, my name is Juanita Rojas from MidCityCAN, a member of the Coalition for Equitable Development advocating for policies and public investments to support the diverse communities we represent. We appreciate the work the county has done to address our concerns including the inclusionary housing ordinance and basic needs for our residents. Yet we believe that there's a delay in acting decisively to protect renters from predatory landlords and strong enforcement like eliminating junkies and investment Tenant legal services are key in preventing displacement. As advocates, we keep hearing stories of tenants being asked to pay outrageous prices for utilities and others that live in infested homes because landlords are not often livable in safe spaces Many of our members feel retaliation and feel like they have no choice.
That is why we respectfully ask that you focus on doing more to protect renters. Thank you all for your time and
for your work.
Thank you, your time is up. And Chair Lawson-Reidman not seeing any other callers in the call in queue that will conclude public comment on this item.
Okay thank you very much Chair Pro Tem Mungiri
I have a question for one of the presenters um for Gilbert A couple questions actually First, thank you for being here and to the group for the presentation. My pleasure. I appreciate all of your work. Can you just expand a little bit more on the concept you mentioned regarding partnering with other jurisdictions with the right to legal counsel? You mentioned there are 28 jurisdictions in America that have that type of program. And I was just wondering if you can elaborate a little bit more on what the structure would look like. Would it be an MOU with different cities or how would that work?
So like the right to counsel would be like a such like an ordinance you would pass that would essentially create like it would essentially kind of codify the 10 legal services program subject to the annual appropriations. And in the context of, you know, and that program can look, you know looks very differently in this 20 jurisdictions right? You can create priorities of what You know essentially who is the population that would be entitled to these representations based on income household size composition or like some cities have done it.
Regionally based on like on zip codes right based on the data they get on where the evictions are happening also you get a lot of data from the sentence about the populations which has more risk of becoming homelessness, it's also part of your housing element So it can look very differently depending on how you as a legislative body prioritize, you know the groups you want to serve. And then the context of kind of we're looking at it regionally for example that the city and county of LA working regionally they each have their own right to counsel but they help The city of San Diego has a program called the eviction prevention program. It's essentially the 2 programs, the city one focuses on I think that's a great question. I don't know what the answer to that is but the idea being that of you know other cities specially larger ones in our County might have the resources to add to to the funds, the county has so that we can get we can help amplify the services.
We're currently offering I think that currently you know I think over the last couple grant years we have been up by We've had to shift some in order to make those We're not going to be able to fund that. We haven't funded any of that with County funds June of last year and that is because we were going to spend down the funds too quickly and so luckily earlier this year a partnership with private philanthropy allowed us to reopen our emergency rental systems and then we also were able to find philanthropy that would You know if you have a regional approach and other cities are contributing then then you know they're those resources and how we're spending on the funds might be able to not just last a 12 month period, but help more people.
And that would be complemented by a database on evictions that you were mentioning right the data where the need is greatest right?
Yeah so I think for example I think that's a really good question. I mean the city has in their local 10 protection ordinance have established like either I think right now focus on eviction and eviction notice registry where landlord has to file an eviction notice with the city And so that can give you a lot of valuable data about where the evictions in your city are happening to who they're happening, who is doing the evictions and what is the reason for the eviction right. Right now that the way eviction data works is that their state laws that limit access to eviction lawsuits and that is to protect consumers right. The people named in the eviction lawsuits because before these laws were in effect essentially credit reporting companies would go down to The court and Rick even then say give me all the names of all the defendants and then you would get you would be reported as having a picture on your record regardless of the outcome of the actual case like you could have won in your names on this registry.
So the currently the way the law works is that those cases don't become public unless the tenant loses the eviction case, then it becomes public and then it can affect their credit So but the double edge of that is that it that because access is limited, it's very difficult to get data about evictions and so that is why you know taking a making local investments and efforts to collect ideas really important. And then the rent registry portion also gives you idea of like what are And so that gives you like real time data
2:23 – 2:319 turns
Thank you. I appreciate that. I appreciate the data points of the 92% of people who were assisted or prevented from falling into homelessness and their return on investment, right? 1100, I think you mentioned per person that you invest with legal services versus the cost on the other end I'm going to go ahead and start.
And yeah that you know we've we've been I think tracking those outcomes for about the last couple of years and they pretty much stayed within that like 89 to 92% level, the same for these city equivalent program division protection program. We do the same reporting we do the county we due to that program and and generate kind of this it's the same outcomes were getting in both in both grants
Thank you. I appreciate that and I think that behooves us tremendously as a public health authority of the county right where we're spending all this money trying to place people into in housing in address homelessness well, we are not talking enough about homelessness prevention right and this is I'm going to continue some prepared remarks. For too many families in District 1, payday means deciding which bills can wait.
Nearly half of households are housing insecure meaning they spend at least 30% of their income keeping a roof over their heads. This leaves too little for groceries, child care or an unexpected car repair. During a town hall in my district residents raised issues related to their housing concerns. 27% said home ownership feels out of reach 28% said rent stretches budgets to the breaking point and 26% said one missed paycheck or medical emergency can put a family's home at risk Good morning. My belief is simple everyone deserves a safe affordable place to call home the opportunity to start here grow here and stay here that is the promise of housing for all and I appreciate the progress shared today.
First firing homeowners down payment assistance in the ability to buy an 80 you separately offer more attainable I want us to advance this work with urgency For those struggling to afford housing, I fought for increased funding for the Innovative Housing Trust Fund which has already delivered as was heard earlier 2217 affordable homes with 318 more under construction and another 519 expected to be built or rehabilitated over the next one to four years through 2030.
Additionally, I fought for continued funding for a shallow rent subsidy program which has provided cash assistance for hundreds of seniors helping keep them safely housed as well as supported our inclusionary housing ordinance. We've delivered nearly 1900 affordable homes in District 1 with hundreds more underway or planned Thank you. Thank you very much. Developments like ocean view in Logan Heights on Sunday and sunny Cedro and the Haven on palm in Imperial Beach will help families put down roots seniors age with dignity and residents connect to community services for neighbors facing the loss of their home investments in rental assistance, legal support Looking ahead, I support expanding options for early intervention to avoid a crisis leading to homelessness.
I'm encouraged to see our planning and housing departments working toward one shared goal, getting homes built and helping people afford and keep them. Residents should be able to turn to the county for help and find a coordinated response. Let's turn today's progress into lasting opportunity, a chance to own rent people can manage in a secure future in the communities they call home.
That concludes my remarks and I want to thank all of you for all the great work that you've been doing. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I appreciate the staff for the presentation and it's encouraging to see all the work that's being done and the numbers of projects coming forward. I'm going to be supportive of the item today but I do have questions particularly on the tenant legal services portion. Yeah, I remember we initiated this in 2021. This is when COVID was going strong and it had an end date on it of 2028. I'm a little confused in the recommendation number five because, but I got a couple questions first. One of which is the tenant legal aid primarily at services primarily in the unincorporated areas? I think I heard that speaker say it was, but I'm just wondering if Is it limited to the unincorporated areas or anywhere in the county?
No, the program's available throughout the county. However as Gil had mentioned, the City of San Diego has a complimentary program so those folks will typically be served by that contract.
Okay, so recommendation number five is going out for successful negotiations and determination of a fair reasonable price to award contracts for maximum geographical coverage I'm just wondering, the city of San Diego has their own but are we paying for other cities? What I'm looking at is maybe this regional approach where the county shouldn't have to be picking this up for all the other cities as well.
So what's your maximum geographical coverage? That's just anywhere in the county that we possibly can. But are we looking for partnerships in other cities or things like that, for them to maybe pony up for these efforts instead of having to have the county bear all of that weight?
Thank you for the question through the chair. Currently, the county does provide the services regionwide. We don't currently turn anyone away based on where they live within the county.
Yeah, I guess my only thing is and I get the value of the legal services and things like that. We don't want people kicked out into the street but this was a COVID program that is now growing and expanding in the county's taking on more and more and more of the burden I'm not sure that we should be doing that. And it seems like once we let this, we just keep taking out and the cities will just say well, the county is gonna do that and pay for it. So that precedent to me is a slippery slope especially since this only came into effect during the COVID years and here we're expanding it. So you know, I'm gonna register my opposition I guess just to the growing of the legal... I wanna get the name right here For the tenant legal services, I just don't think we should be going countywide with all those services and bearing the brunt for other cities.
Why would the City of San Diego even continue doing theirs? They're looking for money if the County is just gonna take that over. To me this is kind of a slippery slope so I'm in opposition to growing that program for everyone everywhere and in the county, but a very much appreciative of all the efforts is going on the loose staff. Especially I appreciate all the work for bringing changes to the zoning ordinances for better alignment with our general plan looking forward to seeing the housing unlocked item hopefully being brought back that to the board within the next month And also for all the work you put into allowing for the separate sale of the ADUs. That was a lot of work going into there, and so I appreciate all of those efforts. I think those are steps in the right direction.
I just don't want to see this program growing beyond the unincorporated means. Thanks.
Thank you. The chairperson had not completely completed her comments. I failed to make the motion, so I move. Yes, she wanted to make the motion.
2:31 – 2:433 turns
Thank you so much. Really, before the presentation I know that I think the board has kind of been asking for this operational comprehensive framework coming before us and it's now being put kind of... The strategies being talked about under one operational framework is important for the departments to continue to work together on our goals. So I really do appreciate that approach.
You know, the idea of the tenant legal assistance being region-wide I think it's important for a lot of reasons, morally. But as part of stepping back and looking at what we're really facing as a region, it's important to have these different buckets for our tenants and for our residents. What do I mean by that? Of course, we have to build. Using our land in order to do that adds to our inventory region-wide. That's super, super important. It takes 7 to 10 years to build, right? In the meantime People are in their homes, they need assistance. So I think just a bucket of tenant assistance of the subsidies that we are providing this concept bringing forward of continuing tenant legal services all of those keep people in their homes And they're a part of housing for all.
They're a part of this system that we are looking to create. I think they go hand in hand, and so that's why I think it's important. The other thing the folks from Legal Aid in the presentation of a one-stop homelessness prevention model, right? This is the reason why we have to help people. When we don't help folks stay in their home, guess where they come back to?
They come back to us for additional rental assistance. They come back to apply to be on CalFresh. They come back to apply to be on Medi-Cal. These are the things that happens when we're not using preventative measures, and that's why I think it's important for us to invest region-wide because folks are going to need help if they get kicked out of their homes.
And we are charged as a public health agency to help them right? And so I think that's just a part of the conversation we have to talk about there There are folks talking right now as we're on this dais about, you know how homelessness is mainly a behavioral health and mental health issue. I don't agree with that. I think that if you are facing homelessness and then, you know, you're not able to feed your children and you end up walking outside on the hot sidewalk with no shoes on and you're going through all of these things, that's going to break any person down And so we can do so much with investing into these preventative measures. So anyway, thank you for the work that you're doing and appreciate And working to fulfill the city and county joint resolution of getting to those 10,000 units.
That's very important. Tenant legal services extremely important looking forward I'd like to see more on community land trust especially when it comes to for sale side did the force affordable for sale housing we've seen some models It's already that we can go, we can look toward to model our ordinances after. And so thank you for all of the work. Appreciate the conversation and I second the motion.
Thank you all so much. So just a couple comments first of all this is incredibly helpful to see in one place all the work that we have been doing on housing and all the different ways that we are tackling our housing crisis because make no mistake it absolutely This is a crisis for people across San Diego County. And this is very, very useful to say we're really trying to get at It's been a. Thunderstorm of directives from the board going in all sorts of different directions on tackling the housing crisis and I think this framework and this hasn't for all framework helps us. We really see it helps the public really see how all specific of this challenge and leveraging different tools, right? Like the Innovative Housing Trust Fund is getting at this from a different angle than our surplus land but they're all bringing different tools to bear.
So I think it's really helpful to put this all in one place and see the way that our regulatory changes I'm going to turn it over to I just want to say on that note to my colleagues and to really this whole board. We don't agree on everything that's definitely true, but I think on this front, I really appreciated the partnership of everyone on tackling our housing crisis and knowing that it's worth making progress on even if we don't get to count for arena right I just want to make a couple comments about a I think that's really helpful to bring this together. I do think this tenant legal services piece and the prevention is really critical. This was an initiative that I had initially brought forward a number of years ago, and I'm pleased to see that this is now being kind of mainstreamed So that we could see how it worked.
And I think it worked really well, so really excited to see the pilot that I brought forward has his born fruit and appreciate the incredible leadership of Legal Aid on actually doing the work to make it work for folks. And I just on this, I do want to...I just think I was really moved by a number of the stories that you all included some of them were just so compelling of why legal services can be such a shortcut to doing the right thing and keeping people housed.
So, the one that really struck me was this story about Corey, the mother who is fleeing domestic violence whose abuser stopped paying rent as financial abuse which then triggered termination of the Family Section 8 voucher and her imminent eviction. And the work y'all did to make sure she could find new housing and settle the unlawful detainer, and allow that voucher to be reinstated is just exactly the kind of reason we need legal services and why it's so important. So thank you for that.
Thank you. I want to make sure that that is included in how we talk about The diversion so when we come back next year, it'd be great to include the statistics on that. I think it's important to note that we are tracking a cost of an average cost about $1300. A person to prevent homelessness which as my colleague rightly fight rightfully pointed out less than $50,000 which is what costs an average to get someone back in their home that them that didn't might not be the most up-to-date but I do think just including the work on diversion already doing It continues to be as promising, impactful as it has been last year. Then that's something we should certainly look at scaling up if it's you know having So I think that's something that we should be looking at.
The huge returns for the lower cost, which is always the goal. So I think that that's just wanted to note. I also think it would be I don't know how we include this or don't include this. But I know that the treasurer tax collector starting to do some work looking The work that they're looking at it within this strategic framework and make sure it's reported out and it's. Coordinated.
So those are my my thoughts and my comments, but overall this is really helpful I think The housing crisis by any stretch of the imagination. But it is incredibly important to just see the diligence and the focus, um, of the work and that we have made a dent that would not have happened but for. The commitment and dedication. Um that everyone here has brought You want to buy did you want to bifurcate the vote Jim was that your request or just you're noting, you're chatting noting you don't like the legal services program.
I'll support that I can I like the housing stuff it's just I think this one program is growing a little too far too fast for okay so we are going to support
2:43 – 2:455 turns
Okay, now we resume with non-agenda public comments.
Ryan please call any remaining speakers.
Thank you, Chair Lawson-Reamer we do have three requests remaining for non agenda public communication all the request is coming via phone so we will give those phone callers a moment to call in. So now uh any member of the public that has requested to speak by phone it is now time your uh to call in to give your comments All right, we have our first speaker so we will go ahead and unmute.
And you have two minutes to address the board. First caller is Hector. Hector, your device may be muted. You may need to unmute. Okay. Hector has hung up. I do not see any other callers in the call-in queue, Chair Lawson-Reamer so that is going to conclude public comment on non-agenda communication this afternoon.
Okay great, thank you so much. So seeing no further requests for comments on agenda this meeting is now adjourned.
Next regular meeting of the board will take place on October 27th.