UnGovr Transcript
iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.0:05 – 0:114 turns
Roll call — called by Mayor
Show transcript
Okay, my button keeps bouncing off and on. Is it on? No, okay. Because I didn't touch it and it came on that's why I'm wondering. City Attorney Mr. Watson could you please give the closed session report?
Yes Madam Mayor with respect to item 3A the properties APN 121-224-037 instructions were provided to the agency's negotiators to take back to the other party
Thank you. We will now present a proclamation honoring the life and service of Joseph Glenn Alexander, and I feel very honored and privileged to be presenting this tonight. Whereas Joseph Glenn Alexander honorably served the community as an engineer with the Santa Maria Fire Department, demonstrating dedication and professionalism in an unwavering commitment to public safety.
And whereas on January 22nd 1969 while actively operating a fire engine at a structure fire in the area of College Drive and Mariposa Drive Engineer Alex suffered Alexander suffered a fatal heart attack in the line of duty, whereas Joseph Glenn Alexander is recognized as the first line-of-duty death in the history of the Santa Maria Fire Department. A solemn distinction that underscores the inherent risk faced daily by firefighters and whose sacrifice stands as a lasting reminder of the courage Selflessness and devotion require those who answer the call to protect life and property, often at great personal risk. And whereas the City of Santa Maria remains forever grateful for Engineers Alexander's service and honors his memory as an integral part of the department history and legacy Now therefore I, Alice M.
Patino, Mayor of the City of Santa Maria do hereby proclaim that the city of Santa Maria recognizes and honors the life service and ultimate sacrifice of Joseph Glenn Alexander and commemorates January 22nd 1969 his last alarm with profound respect and gratitude Yet therefore proclaim that this proclamation ensures engineer Alexander's name, service and sacrifice are forever remembered. And that his legacy continues to inspire current and future members of the Santa Maria Fire Department as well as the community they proudly served.
Witness thereof, I'm here to have set my hand and cause the seal of the city of Santa Maria to be affixed this third day of February of 2026. And here to receive this except this is his daughter Wanda Acquistapache.
Thank you everyone. Good evening honorable mayor, council members and city staff thank you all for taking the time to recognize a true local hero Joseph Glenn Alexander and his family beside me is his lovely daughter Wanda Just like every person in our fire department, Joe was an extraordinary person that loved to help others. Countless times he would rush out the door when the alarm rang putting other's lives and property before his own.
On January 22nd 1969, Joe Alexander was driving a fire engine to a house fire near Hancock College. When the crew arrived others jumped off to combat the fire while Joe was struck with a sudden heart attack still behind the steering wheel. A passing firefighter noticed Joe's state and pulled him out to perform life-saving measures. He never made it home to his wife and daughter.
Back then, heart attacks in the fire service were not recognized as line duty deaths. Historically speaking, heart attacks and strokes account for almost 50% of firefighter deaths. It wasn't until December 15th of 2003 with the passage of the Hometown Hero Survivors Benefits Act that Heart Disease in the Fire Service was officially recognized as a long time contributor of firefighter deaths.
Since the tragic loss of Joe his fellow firefighters and the Santa Maria Fire Department have made many changes to better care for their firefighters. Shortly after Joe and Alvin Newton's passings, his brothers in the department founded the Firefighters Union Local 2020 to help advocate for firefighter health well-being and overall job satisfaction. The Santa Maria Fire Department also took large steps to assist in firefighter fitness to include health on site Fitness equipment, annual health exams and partnering with 1805 to care for firefighters mental health after tough calls and the loss of life of fellow firefighters.
This evening we honor engineer Joseph Alexander and his entire family for their sacrifice and dedication to the fire service and our city. We stand by you now and always thank you
0:11 – 0:1818 turns
Thank you very much and thank you for being here, Wanda. Appreciate it. All of you firefighters are welcome to stay for the whole meeting.
The next item is a public comment period. Madam Clerk could you please read the criteria?
Speakers may provide public comment on any matter within the subject matter jurisdiction of the City Council. Excuse me, each speaker will be limited to three minutes maximum 15 minutes for public comment period unless majority of the council objects the mayor may provide speakers more or less time to speak all comments or queries shall be addressed to the council as a body and not to any specific member thereof pursuant to government code 54954282 The Ralph M. Brown Act, no action or discussion by the City Council shall be undertaken on any item not appearing on the posted agenda except to briefly provide information, ask for clarification, provide direction to staff, or schedule a matter for a future meeting.
Okay did you have any others that are public comment and or that are 12A Madam Clerk?
Agenda Discussionitems moved / continued / pulled — click to expand
Public comment is for anything that's not on the agenda. If you want to speak on 12A, then that is separate. So I'm assuming some of you are here to speak on 12A and not
public comment. Okay, I will start then. I know Mr. Hall wants to speak at public comment for sure. So Mr. Hall?
Am I really that predictable Mayor?
Ah yes.
Thank you and good evening Madam Mayor, council members, staff and the citizens of Santa Maria, my name is Gary Hall. I am a resident of Rancho Buena Vista Mobile Estates at 2135 North Railroad Avenue here in Santa Maria. I represent the North Santa Barbara County Manufactured Homeowners Team or NESBIT. Nesbitt's primary goal remains to provide protection to all Santa Maria mobile home residents presently living in an unregulated rental market.
We are simply asking for the City of Santa Maria to stand with us maintaining affordable housing. Affordable mobile home housing is vanishing here in Santa Maria and all across the state. I have repeatedly reminded you that on June 7th, 2022 nearly four years ago this council passed a motion with the intention of improving the 2020 model lease or replacing it.
It has done neither. We believe now is the time to take action to replace the model lease with a uniform, mandatory, enforceable mobile home rent stabilization program much like those in our neighboring city and county jurisdictions. Santa Maria Mobile Home Seniors also continue to live with the ongoing threat that their senior mobile home park could be converted into an all-age park as was attempted at Del Cielo Senior Park in Orchid.
I brought this to the council's attention August 20th, 2024. Now 18 months later we remain hopeful the draft senior mobile home park zoning overlay ordinance being developed by Santa Maria Community Development personnel and now in internal review will soon be completed and adopted It's past time to add both mobile home rent stabilization and senior mobile home park conversion prevention to a near-term future meetings agenda.
And now I have a personal note, I have found the ongoing ice abuse of power Both locally and nationally, appalling. Immigrants documented or not are human beings and should be treated humanely. The Constitution and due process should be enforced, not ignored. We must find appropriate ways to address immigration. After all, all of us have ancestors who were once immigrants.
Tonight's resolution Is a good first step. Thank you.
Thank you. OK I have 20 requests to speak and this is from FLA invisible San Maria my cop cause but I'm assuming you really want to speak on 12 a is that accurate Could you come up here, Mr.
Solomon? Okay
just come to the okay
so would you clarify for us if we're here and we're going to talk about the ad hoc committee is it public comment Or is it 12 a okay
and that's what we are going to be speaking on the resolution tonight. That's what's on the agenda if you choose to speak on another item, you can do so
again. Several sessions ago, we were chastised because we were told that we needed to speak on public comment when in fact we were speaking later. So just to clarify I am going to be commenting on the ad hoc committee so should and we've got other people who are asking the same question. Should we be speaking now or should we be speaking And at 12 on 12 a
okay. Mr. Watson either one
know with respect to the ad hoc committee or anything other than 12 a specifically they should speak now
now, okay? Okay So if you choose to then I will call your names and if you choose to speak Now you may do so if you choose to speak on the resolution then you can just say for the resolution Thank
You very much
0:19 – 0:2422 turns
So I will start with Sophia Navarro. I'm sorry, can you? Madeli Aguirre. Followed by Elvia Salazar, followed by Braden Lopez.
Good evening, Mayor and City Council members. My name is Maydaly Aguirre and I am a young resident of Santa Maria and future leaders of America student council president. I am here to represent and respectfully request city council agendize the discussion of establishing in ad hoc committee on immigration for future council meetings while this committee would be temporarily And concerns it would be addressed are ongoing and deeply impacting many families in our community. As a young person growing up in Santa Maria, I have seen how immigration issues affect people in real life and personal ways. Friends and classmates live with constant fear and uncertainty. Fear of family separation, fear of speaking and seeking for medical help when they need it.
When families are afraid, trust in our City Council is weakened. And that affects the safety and well-being of the entire city. If agendized this discussion can explore how an ad hoc committee might improve transparency Trust in our community topics such as include requesting formal communications regarding immigration related arrest within the city limits allocating city owned spaces and nonprofit organizations providing immigrant support services and examining ice free zones in our city.
This committee could also review Complaints competency within existing state laws, including California's Value Act and Sensitive Location Act. And California's Truth Act. And as a young resident I want to live in the city where families are safe and heard protected and agendized this item would be important for our first steps towards thoughtful and transparency conversations. I respectfully ask the City Council to place this item in the future agendas. Thank you for your time.
Raiden Lopez. Good afternoon mayor and council members.
My name is
Elvia Salazar. Desempeño el rol de organizadora de padres en futuros líderes de América.
Future leaders of America, I represent the parents.
Yo soy una orgullosa residente de la Ciudad de Santa Maria por más de 26 años.
For more than 26 years, I'm a very proud resident of Santa Maria.
Hoy estoy aquí para instar encarecidamente a este consejo a que establezca formalmente un comité ad hoc.
I'm here today pleading to the council to establish formally a committee for ad hoc.
De inmigración y para solicitar que este punto se incluya en la agenda de la próxima reunión del consejo.
For immigration and to solicit, to make a note to include in the agenda on the next reunion of the next meeting council meeting.
Sabemos como las recientes acciones de ICE, de aplicación de la ley de inmigración han creado miedo, aislamiento y separación familiar en nuestra comunidad.
As residents we can see have seen the action and the application of the law of immigration and how ICE has been scaring people in isolating them to separate families in the community
As an organizer of FLA, it is very sad to receive the call from my parents letting us know. Ms. Salazar, could you please take me to my dentist appointment? Senora Salazar, el dia de hoy por favor puede llevar a mi estudiante a su escuela?
Ms. Alsar could you please today take my student to school?
Senora Salazar, por favor puede traer alimentos a la puerta de mi casa?
Ms Alsar could you please bring some food to my doorstep?
Esto es muy triste recibir estas llamadas todos los dias
It's very sad to receive these type of calls every day.
How many Ms Salazar do families need everyday for support? Our immigrant families are suffering.
For this reason?
0:25 – 0:3224 turns
I plead that you hear our petition to help and assist with immigration laws.
And please adopt a firm posture against the arrest, the racist and unconstitutional arrests that happen in the city.
Y adopten una postura firme y basada en principios.
Also adopt a posture of principle
Tal como lo han hecho las ciudades vecinas de Guadalupe
As our neighbor cities, Guadalupe have established
Carpinteria and Goleta
as well.
En apoyo de sus residentes indocumentados.
In support of the undocumented residents.
Por favor, basta de ignorar el miedo.
Please enough of ignoring fear.
De seguir creando aislamiento y la separación de familias.
To keep people Isolated and separating from their families.
En nuestra comunidad inmigrante.
In our immigrant community.
Muchas gracias.
Thank you.
Gracias.
Brayden Lopez followed by Nan Hageland, followed by Danny Mogg.
Okay, good evening council members. I'm here today to urge you to create an ad hoc committee focused on immigration and community safety. Right now many families in our community are living with uncertainty and fear because they've done nothing wrong but because they don't know how local policies or enforcement practices might affect them or their loved ones.
This fear doesn't just impact individuals. It affects schools, workplaces and overall trust in people who are in local government. An ad hoc committee would give this council the opportunity to gather accurate information, listen to residents and develop thoughtful policies that protect both safety and dignity. Transparency matters. Our community deserves to know how law enforcement interacts with federal immigration agencies, how data and surveillance tools are being said and used and whether our city spaces remain safe and accessible for everyone.
Especially in sensitive places like school, clinics and places of worship. This committee could also help ensure our city is following state laws and protect due process and privacy while still supporting lawful and effective public space practices. When people feel safe reporting crimes, accessing services and participating in civic life the entire community grows stronger.
I ask you to take a proactive and principled step by forming this committee and adding this item to the agenda for our next City Council meeting, listening to impacted voices and working toward policies that build trust instead of fear. Thank you all again for your time and your commitment to serving this community.
Nan Hagelman followed by Danny Mogg.
Greetings everyone. My name is Nan Helgeland. I have been in this room one other time, November 18th 2025. The session opened with a comprehensive overview from the Chamber of Commerce. They detail their efforts past present and future to attract visitors and outside dollars to Santa Maria. I found myself thinking about that presentation and eventually realized I could offer perspective that would be unique to this assemblage.
I live in Los Angeles and the 805, and divide my time equally between the two. Stopping in Santa Barbara for an errand or coffee with a friend. I've done some research on my own that you should hear. People in Los Angeles either have not heard of Santa Maria, or they think it's in Northern California. They are not coming. People in Santa Barbara are aware of Santa Maria, but still not coming.
People in Los Alamos are up here daily, but as a community of 1,300 we are not going to move your needle even on a good day. I did a personal inventory of my visits to Santa Maria and they tally to about four visits per year all to one place, Birch Toll. However, in the 18th year of owning my ranch I found myself in Santa Maria almost 30 times. Why the jump?
I was up here participating in protests, attending meetings, joining banner drops on your freeway overpasses. I attended a vigil on your front lawn! And sadly, I have been up here numerous times delivering food to the various wonderful organizations working to provide sustenance to the women and children whose breadwinners have been kidnapped off of your streets.
And in that year, I learned something about Santa Maria. Santa Maria is full of gold. Santa Maria is full of gold! There is gold everywhere you look and what is this gold? It's your Latino community. 79% of Santa Maria is Latino. These are the people putting the coins in your coffers, people who are spending money here day in and day out. People looking to provide the best possible lives for their families, the best possible futures for their children.
And you do not see this! It occurred to me after a year that you do not see this You do not see this gold, you do not appreciate this gold. You do not protect this gold and you do not deserve this gold.
Thank you.
0:32 – 0:384 turns
Good evening Mayor, Council Members. My name is Danny Mogg and I'm on the leadership team of the public advocacy group Indivisible. I am also a proud resident of Santa Maria in Santa Barbara County. I'm here today to strongly urge this council to formally establish an immigration ad hoc committee to address our community's concern on increasing ICE activity within Santa Maria.
This committee can discuss potential action items and resolutions, such as sending FOIA requests to ICE director after any arrests are made within the Santa Maria City limits. Allocating city buildings to non-profits leading immigration support services for low rent or no rent. They could model the city of Los Angeles by monitoring an order... By motioning an ordinance to establish ice free zones Requesting information from our police chief Chris Williams regarding actions toward educating officers on the new state laws that are now in effect and their involvement specifically with ICE.
Personal story, I have a grandson who happens to be Latino he's 16 years old he attends Pioneer Valley High School here in Santa Maria He is a high functioning autistic teenager. He walks 30 minutes to school and 30 minutes home each day. My family, and any family for that matter should not have to fear that their children will be racially profiled and abducted on their way home from school.
This literally describes life today in Donald Trump's America. Your community continues to bear the impact of these racist and unconstitutional enforcement tactics, leaving many in fear and with little to no trust in their local government. Outside these chambers are immigrants' parents living in fear of leaving their homes or speaking our languages due to the risk of separation from their families. Our youth who we have an obligation to protect are being used as bait to lure and kidnap their immigrant parents Legal observers and community members are standing up to these injustices, are being violently attacked and even killed by untrained agents all while the world watches.
It's up to you to take action and protect a community that has given so much to this city. I've stood at this lectern and presented moral rationale why these policies do not comport with American values. I've explained the legal argument, the language of the Constitution which I am sworn to defend. I have presented economic facts as to why these barbaric acts are detrimental to the financial health of our city.
I'm here tonight to ask the fundamental question that I often ask myself and one that all city officials should ask themselves. Are we meeting this moment in history? Thank you.
Cliff Solomon followed by Raul Oliveira.
Mr. Solomon, followed by Raoul Oliveira, followed by Maricela Orquiz.
Thank you for the clarification. Good evening, Mayor Patino and City Council members. My name is Cliff Solomon and I am here once again to request that you establish an Immigration Ad Hoc Committee. At the last city council meeting, I highlighted many of the local cities that are taking action in recognizing the serious need of our immigrant community These communities include Carpinteria, Goleta, Santa Barbara, Oxnard, Santa Paula, Thousand Oaks, Ventura and Camarillo.
I appreciate that City Council is addressing the issue by placing resolution on the agenda that supports all Santa Maria residents. However as a member of the Santa Maria City Council Immigration Coalition Indivisible Santa Maria again requests that the City Council form an ad hoc immigration committee to explore additional legal actions the city can undertake. These actions may include renting out city buildings to nonprofits, providing immigrant support services at low or no cost, establishing ice-free zones across city-owned and city-owned controlled properties with clear signage.
And asking Police Chief, Chief Williams for updates on efforts to educate officers about the new state laws now in effect and to prohibit involvement with ICE. It is crucial that the ad hoc committee include members, both members of the public and City Council members. By forming this committee the Santa Maria City Council will take tangible action that can make a meaningful difference and demonstrate that it's listening to the community.
And I also have, I have a gift for everyone. We had a protest here a couple days ago. A local artist put together this wonderful display of monarch butterflies that represent some of the people who are, the immigrants who have been taken And I would like to give you one of these, a portion of this display. So I have five of these pieces of art. Is there someone who could take these?
Thank you very much and thank you for your time.
0:39 – 0:4425 turns
Followed by Maricela Ortiz, followed by Teresa Suarez.
What was that? Raul Oliveira.
Good afternoon, Mayor and City Council members. My name is Raul Oliveira. I'm an organizer with Proyecto Mixteco Indígena Community Organizing Project and member of the 805 Immigrant Coalition in Santa Barbara County. Mass men have come to our community terrorizing our community. I am here to ask you to stand with our community not with words but with action.
They say they were arresting criminals. My friend was arrested and did everything legally. This is not a coincidence, Santa Maria, it's a community of immigrants. It is the one that has been most impacted in our county. This is not what we hear, this is what we know. We need our leaders to take action again, not with words but with action. Our community needs you to stand for what's right.
We need you to talk about what is harming us and for you to make a decision that will benefit our community as a whole. We are a community of immigrants, our indigenous and farm working community who has been most impacted is asking for you too Establish an immigration ad hoc committee to respond to the impact of immigration enforcement and provide recommendations that holistically address inequality ties, racial injustice, economy hardship, social strength, and mental health challenges.
This committee shall include key stakeholders in community based organizations working directly with those most impacted such as farm workers General domestic workers, landscaper, indigenous leaders and the most impacted on vulnerable in jobs sector. We're looking forward to you standing in solidarity with us. Thank you.
Maricela Ortiz, followed by Teresa Suarez, followed by Guinevere Cannon.
Buenas tardes. Alcaldesa Patiño y Honorable Concejales. Mi nombre es Maricela Ortiz, navegadora de robo de salario con el Proyecto Mixteco Indígena
Good afternoon, Mayor Patino and council members. My name is Maricela Ortiz. I work with the Fed Salary Project, Mixteco Indígena.
Comparezco hoy para solicitar la creación de un comité EADHAC de inmigración con el fin de proteger el bienestar de nuestra comunidad y garantizar el respeto a sus derechos constitucionales
I'm here today to request the creation of a committee of immigration ad hoc with the goal to protect the well-being of our community and to guarantee the respect and constitutional rights against all the negative actions and inhumane actions from ICE.
Hoy vemos familias separadas, padres y madres arrancados de sus hogares y niños que quedan solos
Today we see separated families, fathers and mothers ripping away from their homes and kids left alone.
¿Qué crimen han cometido estos niños? Ninguno. La comunidad agrícola no es criminal.
What crimes have these kids committed? None. The agricultural community is not a criminal.
Su único delito ha sido trabajar arduamente bajo condiciones extremas
The only crime has been working really hard under extreme conditions.
Para que haya comida en nuestras mesas y sostener la economía de esta ciudad y país,
so that we can put food on our tables and to sustain the economy of this city and the country.
Todos los seres humanos merecen dignidad y respeto.
All human beings deserve respect and dignity.
Criminalizar a comunidad por su origen es injusto e inacceptable.
To criminalize a community because of their origin is unfair and unacceptable.
Les pedimos que actúen con urgencia y conciencia, y se coloquen del lado correcto de la historia, el de la justicia y la humanidad.
We ask that you act with urgency and conscience and to be at the right side of history which is justice and being human.
Muchos gracias.
Thank
you.
0:44 – 0:505 turns
Good evening Mayor.
I'm here to respectfully request your support in establishing an immigration ad hoc committee. Through this committee, our community can come together To thoughtfully discuss and develop local resolutions that protect undocumented residents from unconstitutional enforcement practices currently being used by ICE. Potential actions could include establishing ice-free zones in city owned and city controlled properties, requiring clear and visible signage on city facilities and more. These measures would mirror ordinances already approved by cities such as Los Angeles.
The urgency of this matter cannot be overstated. Now more than ever, we must come together to protect our community. Continued postponements places families and children at risk and safety should never be delayed. Let's not feed into the narrative that immigration enforcements only targets criminals because we know this is not true. Our communities have experienced firsthand that these actions go far beyond that and are deeply rooted into racial profiling and harmful stereotypes.
These practices impact entire families, especially children creating fear, trauma and long-term harm into their well being. When fears normalized the whole community suffers. It is also important to acknowledge that this land was taken through colonization and that many who continue to benefit from that history have never been held accountable. The real threat to public safety is not immigration residents who live We must be clear, continuing down this path risks further divisions and chaos. Something we are already witnessing in other parts of the country and even here in Santa Maria. Santa Maria can and must do better. Our community deserves safety rooted in dignity justice and care for all families. Thank you
Thank you. Guinevere Cannon followed by Patricio Solario, followed by Sergio Castillo.
Hi my name is Guinevere Cannon and I'm quite sure that the mayor knows me by now. I'm looking at this adoption of resolution expressing support for immigrant residents in Santa Maria. I would like to pose that why don't we do an adoption for a resolution expressing support for ICE The police department, the fire department and the first responder. I never hear anything about expressing support for the gentlemen and the women that goes out risk their life may not come home. The family may not see them again but yet what I hear daily and I have a rhetoric about racist.
I heard every day about I'm not being respected You know, this is what the Bible said. The Bible says if you walk around in fear, the fear of the Lord is to begin with wisdom. So if you walk around in fear that means that you have something to hide. I walk in this city in freedom and I'm really here to speak on behalf... If you're a district attorney in this place?
A judge in this place? The reason why we see what we see is because of the fact that we do not do our job. If there's a criminal, like I work every day and I go and I see the highway patrol here it's seven in the morning someone's walking the line because they're probably drunk he doesn't get them out of their car because hey I have nothing else to do They're drunk. And if they're drunk at 7 in the morning, they're drunkers.
And my question is how many of these drunkers are still in our streets because they're not persecuted? They go to jail. They get right out of jail and then we're asked to say be nice. No I am not nice about someone that's out to kill someone. I may kill my family or kill me on the way home. I'm absolutely not nice about that. And those who have this real ugly, ugly for the ICE officer. I do not.
They're here to serve our country. They're here doing what they are supposed to do. That's arrest a criminal. So if you're a criminal, you're supposed to be arrested. If you have nothing to hide, you can walk around in freedom. But I will stand. I will come in here and stand for the authorities That takes care of us and our family. I will not downgrade them, and I think it's time for America to stand up.
And I pray for you city council members every day because I believe that God is in charge. And there is nothing that God does not see. He sees the evil and he sees the good. And God is a just god. He's a merciful god. But he's merciful when you call on him and say, I need your help. And those that are in this room here, you sit and you say my kids are afraid. My kids are afraid. If you know that you are not legal...
Thank you Ms. Cannon. Patricio Solario followed by Sergio Castillo.
0:50 – 0:5715 turns
Thank you. Statistically, criminals are U.S. citizens at a higher rate than undocumented folks just for the record. So good evening Mayor City Council. My name is Patricia and I'm Deputy Director of the Fund for Santa Barbara. I'm here to urge you to vote to form an immigration ad hoc committee so the Council can engage in deeper and more intentional discussions about what the City of Santa Maria can do to address activity in our community.
Many of you have been very vocal about what you can't do. At this moment, our community needs leadership that is willing to focus on solutions. Forming an ad hoc committee is not a radical step. It is the absolute least you all can do to grapple seriously with the fear and harm our community is experiencing. The City of Santa Maria, as you know, is a majority Latino city made up of many immigrants and first-gen citizens like myself.
These residents are the backbone of our local economy. They are workers, parents, business owners, professionals and taxpayers. And they're deeply disappointed by the city's lack of a strong visible show of support An ad hoc committee would create a space for education, dialogue, accountability. It would signal that this City Council is willing to listen, learn and lead rather than remain silent.
I urge you to be more vocal, more intentional in standing with our immigrant community. This is the opportunity to do the minimum that leadership requires and to stand on the right side of history.
Good evening mayor and council member. My name is Sergio Castillo, I am a community organizer with MICO and member of the 875 Immigrant Coalition. I'm here today because for us protecting our families and children must be a priority especially in this moment so Cuando guardamos silencio, el miedo se normaliza. Alzar la voz permite visibilizar el impacto real de las redadas migratorias.
When we stay quiet fear normalizes. We raise our voice the impact, the real impact of this immigration raids become real and the kids are with anxiety constant anxiety
Children become fearful that their parents might not come back home and the families are forced to plan emergency until a possible separation. Hablar de esta realidad es una forma de proteger su bienestar emocional y su derecho a una infancia segura.
When we speak, this reality is a way to protect their well-being, emotional well being and their right to have an upbringing or a childhood secure for them.
Today I become part of this community that is undocumented in Santa Maria and I ask the council to also take a stand, a clear stand. Por esta razón, solicitamos que se establezca un comité ad hoc de inmigración con el propósito de evaluar y proponer resoluciones locales.
For this reason I request that an immigration ad hoc committee be formed with a purpose to evaluate and to propose resolutions, local resolutions, to protect the residents undocumented
En Santa Maria, las recientes acciones del control negatorio han sembrado miedo.
In Santa Maria the recent actions have created quite fear.
Padres que salen a trabajar sin saber si volverán a casa. Uno se despide cada mañana con el temor de no volver a ver a sus familias completas
Parents go out to work with the fear of not coming home. Kids say goodbye every morning with a fear that maybe not see their families again.
Homes that before were full of life and joy, today they live with anxiety and quietness. No community should live through this pain. Como comunidad, tenemos la responsabilidad de alzar labores por quienes no pueden hacerlo. Proteger a nuestras familias, garantizar los derechos de todos y vivir sin miedo es un compromiso que nos fortalece.
As a community we have the responsibility to raise our voice for those who cannot speak. To protect our families, to guarantee everybody's rights without fear is a compromise that unites us.
When we act with solidarity and compassion, we remember that dignity and family unity have to always be on top of everything. Thank you so
much.
0:57 – 1:0321 turns
Followed by Armando Santiago, followed by Reynaldo Rodriguez.
Good evening, Mayor and Council Members. My name is Anna Nguyen and I am the Program Director for MICOP in Santa Barbara County. I am also a voting resident in the City of Santa Maria. I am here today because as a member of the immigrant community of our region we need all of us to speak up and advocate for our protection. I stand with the undocumented community of Santa Maria and ask that our council take a stand as well.
I come today to ask you to please establish an immigration ad hoc committee to discuss potential local resolutions that protect undocumented residents from the unconstitutional tactics currently being used by ICE. When established, this committee must discuss the high rates of arrests and ICE activity taking place in our city. At our office, we are constantly receiving families seeking support because their loved one has been arrested or deported.
Sometimes it's debt that is taken and being the primary financial provider in the home, our office supports mom and children with long-term assistance which could be figuring out how to pay rent, get food, child care et cetera. At other times, it's mom that is arrested and deported. And when that happens we scramble to figure out how to support the babies in the home.
It's an even bigger challenge supporting children when both parents have been deported. More support is needed. As City Council you can do more to support. This ad hoc committee is a good start and we appreciate the resolution, and we also need action. Thank you. Thank you.
Armando Santiago followed
by Rinaldo Rodriguez followed by Fernando Martinez.
Hello
Mayor Patino and
council members, almost evening. I hope you're doing well My name is Armando Santiago. I am a community organizer with the Mixteco Indigenous Project, MiCOP.
I am here to ask in the most attentive way that action be taken against the Ad Hoc Committee which is fundamental and can
be established in the city.
I'm here to, as a kindest manner, to take action and to form the community for ad hoc which is fundamental to establishing the community of Santa Maria. to discuss possible resolutions, local resolutions to protect to the residents, undocumented residents from the tactics and constitutional tactics that ICE is using. As they're using those tactics to establish and to protect the well-being of the citizens, of the inhabitants of Santa Maria.
Que la gran mayoría de los habitantes son trabajadores agrícolas que solo buscan salir adelante de la manera más honrada posible.
Which a majority of the people are workers, farm workers that they're only looking forward to work in their most honest manner
Es injusto ver como las leyes están protegiendo más a los agentes de ICE que a las propias personas.
It is unfair to see how the laws are protecting more ICE agents than the same people.
Es inhumano porque por solo defenderse o defender a sus familiares puedan quitarles la vida.
It's inhumane that only because they're defending themselves or defending their relatives, they could lose their life.
¿Acaso el simple hecho de tener un color de piel diferente, una estatura diferente o un lenguaje diferente te hace ser menos persona?
Is it simply because of having a different color skin, having a different height or speak a different language makes you a less person?
Solo me gustaría terminar diciendo que las leyes son para proteger y cuidar de cada habitante de este país.
I'd just like to finish by saying that the laws are to protect and take care of every citizen of this country. For this reason, gratefully I'd like you to take these words into consideration in this petition that not only involves me but it's also for our community and everyone else.
I would like to add that we're all humans, we all live on this planet and we all have the same rights. Thank you.
1:04 – 1:0923 turns
Reynaldo Rodriguez, followed by Fernando Martinez.
Followed by Lorena Martinez Cruz.
Good afternoon
Mayor
Patino and council members.
My name is Reynaldo Rodriguez, an organizer from the community of Micop here in Santa Maria.
Estoy aquí en solidaridad con nuestra comunidad trabajadora y en apoyo a la propuesta de establecer un comité ad hoc de inmigrantes que fue puesto sobre la mesa por la concejal Soto.
I'm here as part of the solidarity with our community, the working community to support the proposal to establish a committee ad hoc for immigration that was brought to the table by Council Soto. To see what's happening is not enough. And the suggestion is to take action, a concrete action to help the community. I have faith and trust that this committee is going to be great support to oversee and take care of the voice of protection for families, to residents that live in the city regardless of their migratory status. The
application of immigration law has escalated to a level that was never imagined. Today ICE has the order to kill anyone who opposes it. I ask myself, is this democracy or freedom that stands out so much in this country?
The application, the way ICE is applying has escalated to a level that we have never imagined. ICE has the order to kill any person that is in front of them or is opposed to them. I ask myself, is this the democracy or the freedom that this country offers?
Lamentablemente, las políticas racistas e injustas de nuestro gobierno federal han impactado negativamente a nuestra comunidad su seguridad, mi seguridad y el bienestar general de nuestra comunidad.
Sadly the racist and unjust and unfair politics from our federal government have impacted negatively our community, our safety, the safety and well-being of our community in general.
I believe that we all agree that if someone has broken the law, to have a due process and not just to try everyone the same like criminals is not fair for anyone. Los recientes operativos federales han generado temor e inestabilidad para todos los residentes que vivimos en esta ciudad. Esta acción genera mucho miedo en las familias al momento de ir a trabajar o llevar a los hijos a la escuela.
All the activity, the feral activity has taken a lot of fear and instability to the citizens of this city Do action, it creates a lot of fear and the families at the time to go into work or taking their kids to school.
The thing that we're thinking the most is that at any time they can stop us or even worse be killed by an ICE agent.
It's not fair for a human being to live in fear.
If I live with this fear, with these thoughts as an adult, I cannot imagine how the kids are dealing with this trauma. And what kind of generation are
we expecting or hoping for?
Con la intención de formar este comité, la Ciudad de Santa Maria podrá mantenerse mejor informada e involucrada con nuestra comunidad inmigrante.
With the forming of this committee, the City of Santa Maria will actually be very well informed and be involved with immigrant community.
Cabe resaltar que es justo lo que merece nuestra comunidad trabajadora.
Please note that it's fair and just. This is what the community deserves.
Your support and attention as backup, as council members.
1:09 – 1:166 turns
Followed by Lorena Martinez-Cruz, followed by Isaac Gill.
Good evening, Mayor Patino and fellow council members. My name is Fernando Martinez. I'm a community organizer with MICOP and resident of Santa Maria for over 25 years. I am here today to strongly urge the Council to formally establish the Immigration Ad Hoc Committee to address the recent concerns in our community related to the increase of ICE activity in Santa Maria.
Council Member Soto uplifted the need of an ad hoc committee back in September, October but was pushed back. And I really hope that pushback time allowed each of you to think about what you can do to better protect our community. If established this ad hoc committee could thoughtfully examine community impacts, identify concrete actions resolutions the city can take to better protect our immigrant community.
I know we often hear that cities cannot enforce or change federal laws, but we can often take actions to help, to serve, to provide resources. For example this is one of the many options that can be done for example as part of an ad hoc committee The city can submit a FOIA requesting information to Immigration and Customs Enforcement following any arrest made within city limits, a practice that is already being used in the City of Santana.
The city could also allow municipal facilities for community members to gather, hold meetings for nonprofit organizations are providing legal and immigration services for education, emergency support These are one of the many examples that are being created within different city councils across California. So I really hope, you know, you as our representatives...I'm in District 3 so I really hope my District 3 representative can take action to support our community.
Proactive leadership from City Council is essential. That's why you were elected this action will help ensure our immigrant community feel safer informed and respected in the city they call home unfortunately Community members have been arrested by ICE, many who have no prior conviction. Many who have not been to jail or have not been cited for any arrest or anything.
We respectfully urge you as a city council to move forward with an ad hoc committee And I repeat, I know you cannot change federal laws but you can definitely take action like other city councils have done to better serve our community. So I really hope you take the action that is needed. Thank you.
Lorena Martinez followed by Isaac Gill followed by
Michelle Ambrise
Good evening, City Council members. My name is Lorena and I'm a student at a local high school. I am here today to urge you to vote in favor of forming an immigration ad hoc committee to address the increased fears our community is facing. It's honestly so disappointing that youth like myself have to come to a city council meeting to ask for something so basic such as safety Such as the safety, understanding and compassion for the people you oversee. You at City Council should have taken a stance a year ago when students walked out of school, rallied and showed up to a city council meeting asking for protection for immigrant families and immigrant students. As youth, we should be focusing on our education future and our families not pleading our local leaders to protect the very community that keeps the city running.
This isn't just affecting adults but also youth when we see our families neighbors and friends living in constant fear we feel that fear too if you don't set a date for this motion and vote in honor of it the mistrust for our local leaders will only continue to grow We're here because we still have hope, hope that our leaders will finally listen and take action to protect their community. Thank you.
Good evening Councilmembers and Mayor Patino. My name is Isaac Yeo, I'm a local student at Pioneer Valley and tonight I am here with cause but more importantly because I'm tired of seeing my community hurt. I'm here because injustice is happening to a huge part of our community, our immigrants. These are street vendors, our essential workers, our daily laborers, our parents, our neighbors and our family members.
They are contributors to the Santa Maria Valley in every sense. And yet today we've reached a point where people are afraid to go to work, afraid to take their kids to school, afraid to seek medical care when they need it. Now I want to share a story of a friend of mine who recently her father was kidnapped despite what some sources like to say he was not a criminal but even beyond that label what is still what happened afterward is truly what matters My friend, who is already working one job had to take on a second job to care for her family and her father.
Overnight she became responsible for burdens no young person should have to carry. That story is not rare, she wasn't the first student this happened to and nor will she be the last unless this city council decides to take action. But what we're seeing right now is fear becoming normalized and human decency being pushed aside and that should scare all of us.
This is a terrifying time for our community and it's important that you truly see, not just hear it but feel it. We're watching what's happening across our country right now and the question I keep asking myself is what makes us think we're immune? What makes us think Santa Maria's next or not? That's why it's so important that you as our elected officials Take action. As a community we're not asking for anything extreme, rather asking for the bare minimum.
Furthermore, Council Member Flores I live in District 2 and four months ago this conversation was tabled because you needed more information. Since then actions since then you've heard the community's outcry and at this point actions matter more than waiting our community safety should not come second to discussions about more dog parks while our families are living in constant fear This is why I urge you, the committee to support the Immigration Ad Hoc Committee and finally set a date to vote on this motion. Please take action. Our lives, our families and our futures depend on it. And Gloria Flores can you please stay off of your phone while people are giving public comments? Thank you.
1:17 – 1:237 turns
All right, good evening mayor and council members. My name is Michelle Embreez. I'm a policy advocate for CAUSE, volunteer for 805 Rapid Response Network, Santa Maria resident specifically in District 1. I am here today because Santa Maria continues to be heavily impacted by the increasing ICE activity like many of you know. And like many of the people in this room, I've been here at every meeting since September And yeah, back in October. You guys over three months ago actually this council decided to table the motion to establish an immigration ad hoc committee until February.
Now, February is here. The discussion item has not been agendized and yeah we need this ad hoc committee as a direct way or direct action you can take to support the city. And so today I'm here to request for you to establish an immigration ad hoc committee discuss potential local policies that can protect undocumented residents within that committee and requests of this item be agendized for the next council meeting Or as soon as possible. We've waited long enough.
If established, this committee could potentially discuss sending FOIA requests for immigration or for ICE after any arrests made within Santa Maria City limits, allocating city buildings to nonprofits, leading immigrant support services for low rents or no rent Motion to establish ice-free zones across city owned, city controlled properties that require clear signage on those properties. Establish permit processes for civil enforcement operations and preserve lawful criminal law enforcement and the execution of valid judicial warrants similar to an ordinance already passed in Los Angeles.
Also, in this committee you can discuss requesting any information from SMPD's Chief Williams regarding any actions towards educating police officers on state laws related to immigration. This includes the California Values Act limits states and local law enforcement cooperation with federal immigration, the sensitive location SB 81 which strengthens protections for sensitive locations like hospitals clinics and health centers and complying with the California Truth Act.
As of today, there have been 1,571 confirmed kidnappings throughout the region with 401 of those right here in Santa Maria. That is 28 more since the last time I was here. That is 28 more families that have been impacted and are hurting due to loss of a family member Today you've heard how volunteers, community organizations and even our youth have had to step up to support their neighbors because our council continues to fall short in that. So yeah, our communities cannot afford for you to wait. We need direction. We need direct action and support now.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. Just a quick question Michelle and I believe you submitted one of the letters right? In that part it says permit process for civil enforcement operation. What does that... Can you give me some more clarification what does that mean? It's a point number three that you sent this motion to establish a free zone cross and then establishing a permit process for civil enforcement operations.
Excuse me, could you please come to vote because we have to record this?
And so you're talking about the permit process for civil enforcement operations? Correct. So yeah, I think this can go back to like the FOIA requests and asking for if there are going to be any raids arrests within Santa Maria making sure that Santa Maria is alerted beforehand or alerted first so that we can keep our community safe back in last year November A car collision happened due to an ICE arrest happening. So just making sure that we're being able to protect any community members in the area during any arrests or raids, alerting the city first beforehand.
Does that answer your question? Thank
you.
Sofia Navarro.
Hello. Good evening, Council. I'm here to voice my disdain of how federal agents are violating our rights here in our community and across the nation. I am hoping this City Council will do everything in its power to prevent further collusion over law enforcement and Sheriff's Department with this disgraceful agency. Please establish concrete policies to stop further collusion with this federal agency.
It's honestly disgraceful how they're just blatantly disregarding all our rights, the way they do the arrests. I mean is video evidence not enough for you guys to see how disrespectful these agents are being? Please follow our county supervisor's dictum in Santa Barbara and holding the sheriff accountable for colluding with ICE. Thank you, that's all I have for today.
1:23 – 1:309 turns
And I wanted to make a comment to the gentleman in my district. I was on my phone taking notes for the radio station that I go to tomorrow morning, so that's why it was on my phone. Thank you.
OK. Should I have? Nope, that's it. OK thank you very much for being here. I'm sorry, Mary. Oh that's for 12A. Oh, is that Gohan? Okay. Yes come up here. Usually after what happens after an item starts then nobody's the other slips don't get turned in so yeah go ahead.
Hello City Council. I just, I want to talk about have you ever heard the saying if your friend jumps off a bridge will you? Think about think about it Trump is leading USA off a bridge are you gonna let your community jump off that bridge too? I am done thank you
Okay, that completes. Now Mr Valenzuela did you wish to speak now or on item 12a?
Thank you honorable mayor and esteemed city council members, staff. My name is Esteban Valenzuela and I'm a lawyer in Santa Maria. I am also the commander of the American GI Forum Hispanic Veterans Family Organization that's established in Santa Maria for about 50 years has worked very hard in the community for all these years to support students and Hispanic families in education primarily, and continue to integrate into our society as productive citizens.
And I want to compliment the city council on preparing an ad hoc committee to deal with the immigration issues that have become so violent with the tactics by ICE that have put our children in fear or families in fear There have been many abuses that we as veterans are attempting to confront. There's been deportation of Hispanic veterans that have been decorated in Vietnam War, for sure we know that.
And their families have given great commitment and service to this country. And we appreciate that this city is going to be prepared to deal with any type of invasion that we're seeing in other cities on the television, in Minnesota, Los Angeles. Other cities that are being subjected to this brutality, people being pulled from their vehicles, veterans being arrested just for driving up to the scene.
So whatever participation the American GI Forum can give this effort to develop with the city a policy that hopefully can be established by ordinance So that there is some legal standing to resist abuses to our community. We fully support and thank the City Council for their work. Thank you very much.
Thank you. That concludes all of the public comment period. Chief Williams, did you wish to make a remark now or just wait till 12A?
It's
up to you. You can do it now if you'd like.
Good evening Madam Mayor, council members and community. I as your police chief feel it's important that you all know and understand that the Santa Maria Police Department values and enforces all the state laws. And as has been well established, as I've mentioned before in previous council members as well as putting out social media posts and speaking at community groups that the Santa Maria Police Department does not collaborate, work or enforce any immigration laws.
Nor do we ask anyone that we make contact with what their immigration status is. The Santa Maria Police Department is committed to serving our community with honor And we want everyone to know that they can contact the Santa Maria Police Department and seek assistance if they're a victim of a crime. If they need our assistance, we will be there for them. We have taken many, many steps to try to build a bridge with our community including going out to the fields and engaging with the community, partnering with local Mexican radio stations Going to community events, welcoming community members to our national night out and demonstrating time and time again that we support our community.
And we do not care what their status is whether they're legal or illegal in the United States. Thank you.
1:30 – 1:3518 turns
Okay, we will now move on to the consent calendar. Does anyone have any
items? Madam Mayor, I just need to announce the one written comment that was received and it was from Michelle
Abreu. Thank you. We will now move on to the consent calendar. Does anyone have items they wish to pull for discussion?
If not, Madam Mayor,
I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Hearing none, Madam Clerk can you please call the roll?
Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 motion and a second. Any further discussion? Hearing none, Madam Clerk can you please call the roll?
Show transcript
Next is a regular business item. Madam Clerk can you please read the title?
Adoption of a resolution expressing support for immigrant residents of Santa Maria.
And the report will be given by City Manager David Rollins
Thank you, Madam Mayor and City Council. Tonight we brought forward a resolution for your consideration tonight. This was at the request of City Council at our last city council meeting to bring us back for adoption. It addresses the support for the immigration community and also law enforcement basically echoing what Chief Williams just explained in the community so I'll turn it over to you.
Any comments from the council at all? Questions. Yes.
This is more around policy clarity beyond SB 54 do we currently have a written citywide policy on how staff should respond if ICE requests any information or access?
We don't have any written policies, no.
What type of guidance are staff currently given if I swerve to enter any of our city premises?
But fortunately, they have not done that. Our staff would treat them as any resident in the community would come to our facility. We're not gonna be interfering and blocking. They're gonna carry out their duties just like we do with the police department. If there was an issue, we'd contact our police department to come down and assist our staff if we need to.
What kind of relationships does the city currently have formal or informal with some of the community-based organizations that are providing rapid response efforts or legal assistance to immigrant communities?
We don't have any specific written agreements with any of the groups. It's more accorded efforts talking with individuals that come to our city council meetings, we've had some meetings with some of the other groups who are doing some of the protest work they met with our staff and with our police department. We ensure them that we are there to make sure they're protected.
They have also been doing a courtesy in notifying city staff prior to any protests where or aware to make sure we keep any protesters safe while they're out there Protesting, protesting or demonstrating their rights.
When there's any type of ICE enforcement activity in the city is there any line of communication between federal agents and our local police department?
Madam Mayor, Council, specifically Councilmember Soto. There have been times in the past when I first started back in late April of 2025 periodically the Department of Homeland Security would call if they were going to do a surveillance They would not give us specific locations, just notifying us that they would be in the area to conduct non-enforcement activities.
What we were told so we wouldn't have any blue on blue or law enforcement and law enforcement engagement where we would, if we for instance got a call for service of a suspicious vehicle in the area and we showed up to mitigate any hostile action with our officers and the federal agents. After a couple of months while being the police chief, that communication has ceased and we no longer have any communication with federal enforcement officers.
I don't know exactly why that is. I would presume because they fear that we could potentially compromise their safety by relaying that information to the public.
1:35 – 1:4318 turns
Chief Williams, what kind of training or how are our officers being updated on the new state laws that have been passed by the state legislator? For instance... I saw ICE agents not being, you know one of those laws being that they don't wear masks or face coverings. That's just an example so do our officers by any chance get trained on the current state laws that are coming out to protect immigrant communities?
Yes, they are. Unfortunately the mask law that you're referring to is not enforceable by us towards the ICE agents. They are federal law enforcement officers and have...they're basically not impacted by our state laws and don't have to follow our state laws. So our officers if we were to see ICE agents that are masked there's nothing that we can do about it as local law enforcement.
In regards to the Values Act, SB 54. Our officers are well versed. It's not a new law. It's been around for I don't know off the top of my head but at least two to three years and our officers have continued training whether it be briefing training, legal update training on all laws that are applicable that they're required to enforce
Those are all the questions I have. Thank you, Madam Mayor.
I think at the last meeting there was a question about like prior two weeks prior to our last meeting where there was an incident on South Broadway and I think we were asked to get information on that.
Yes, we have sent in the information And we have a further request of information to the ISAs through their channels. One through the original, we got from Councilor Soto. Sent that back in and then they sent it back in and said it's the wrong department so we sent it into another department and we have not heard back yet at this point in time.
And you're talking about the FOIA requests that we made? Correct. And that was three weeks ago? Approximately three weeks ago yes.
And we're still waiting.
And we're still waiting.
And Chief Williams, do you have any information at all on that incident?
The incident on Broadway.
Yes.
Yes, Madam Mayor. I was told through our field supervisors that responded to the call we were not contacted by ICE. We were contacted through our 911 communication center because it was an airbag deployment, a traffic collision So our officers responded as a call for service thinking it was an injury traffic collision. When our officers were on scene, they obviously noted that it was involving a federal law enforcement officer that their vehicle had been rammed They, being the Federal Law Enforcement Agency had taken that person into custody.
And we simply just stood around to ensure that the public was safe because there was a crowd starting to gather and we didn't want there to be any further violence or issues. Our officers did not take any enforcement action and just maintained the peace and took their traffic collision report because it was in our jurisdiction.
You said federal law enforcement, so it was not ICE or who was that?
I believe from my recollection Madam Mayor it was both Department of Homeland Security and ICE officers. They were doing a federal criminal investigation.
Okay thank you. Any other questions? No. Okay. Madam Clerk, are there any requests to speak or written comments? I think I have one.
I just provide you with one of them but we did receive written comment and I should've said this during consent. We received for item 11C1 from Jeffrey Wheeler. We have three written for this item right now. Hunter Jamison, Joyce Lipman and Sarah McDonald.
Thank you. So I have Christina Wood
Thank you, good evening Mayor Patino, city council members. Sorry I need cataract surgery so this is gonna be a little tough. My name is Christina Wood. I'm a proud member of Santa Maria Indivisible 805 Immigrant Rapid Response Network and a resident of Santa Maria and a voter. I am the granddaughter of immigrants, a defender of the US Constitution granddaughter of a World War I veteran, daughter of a World War II veteran.
And I appreciate the sacrifices that they made to defend America from fascism and now I'm taking up the fight. I'm requesting the formation of an ad hoc committee to address our community's concerns regarding ICE activity and abuses, to consider potential responses like sending Freedom of Information Act requests to the ICE director following the abduction of anyone within the city limits. We've had people taken and their families haven't known what's happened to them because they've been denied The telephone call that they're entitled to and communication with an attorney. So sometimes the families don't know where they are until they pop up on a Facebook page in Tijuana.
And that lack of transparency is very, very harmful obviously. I can imagine kids coming home and not knowing where their parents are and not having access to finding out and ICE not responding when they easily could. So if the ad hoc committee could work towards getting transparency, I think that's minimal respect that everyone deserves And I just wanted to share.
something that happened on December 28th during the ICE raids. I was driving around on the east side of, or west side of town and saw two high school girls standing on the corner looking rather upset. I'm a 34-year veteran teacher and so I pulled over to see if they were okay And they had witnessed a man, a neighbor being chased down the street, tackled and zip tied.
And then they showed me the video. He was also kicked in the face numerous times. A man who's zip tied facedown no threat and that happened in our city And I'm just so sick of the abuses. Just wanted you to know that. Thank you.
1:44 – 1:496 turns
So do I have any, any motion? Do I have any comments on the resolution?
I have comments. Madam Mayor, um, I want to thank staff at first. I wanted to think council member Aguilera for, for bringing this resolution forward and I also want to thank staff who took a jab at drafting this resolution. Extremely underwhelmed by what I read. In reading the resolution, it lacks Showcasing the fear and the instability that ICE has caused in our community.
It doesn't state anywhere on this resolution That we as a council are prohibiting any type of city resources, staffing or facilities from being used for ICE enforcement. Nowhere on here does it talk about training on constitutional rights or just know your rights training. And these are things that other cities have done, LA, San Francisco, Oakland, Richmond.
On here there is nothing about partnering with non-profit organizations who are conducting on the ground rapid response efforts. Cities like San Jose and Santana have done that in their own resolutions. Emmerville is another great example where, in their own resolution they also talk about making sure that their city does what it can to Get information as much as possible by asking the city manager to provide a report to the City Council detailing any type of request that may come from immigration authorities within their city and what the response is from city officials so that accountability and transparency is lacking in this resolution, as well as like I mentioned earlier just acknowledging the fear, trauma, the family separation and the real harm and economic disruption that is being caused by ICE.
No where on here are these things really stated in this resolution. And so I wanted to bring that forward because the questions that I asked at the start of this discussion were really to get a sense of, you know, the efforts that are being conducted by the city at this moment which are very minimal as well as seeing how we could tie the areas that are visibly lacking into this resolution.
I think if the police chief has stated that our officers are being trained in state laws and that we are not using our resources, then I would say that should be And the resolution because it's already happening. So we're already not cooperating with ICE, we're not helping them and we are training on officers as the chief of police said so I would say that we should add to that because Santa Maria is already doing those things.
And it goes beyond right beyond collaboration with law enforcement because there are because we know what State laws and so yes, definitely including that language on here. But going beyond that and making sure that no city resources, no staff time outside of PD, no facilities, no parking lots city owned are that those are prohibited for any type of enforcement. And so making sure that is clearly outlined in this resolution is going to be important in my opinion.
I can email My suggested edits. Or I can read them line item by item if the council wishes.
Well, I think we could email them to the city manager
and then have the resolution be brought forward again.
1:49 – 2:011 turns
We can do either whatever the pleasure is. Tonight, hearing some of the testimony of people that came forward and accusations that were made that I don't know are valid or not but if you could put that into some kind of a letter and ask that question, the questions that we had. It gets very disturbing when I hear people say that ICE is killing people And we know people have died.
We know that we've seen a lot of the protests, and to me I think so many of them were violent protests. But let me tell you something. Those ICE officers, our police officers, our firefighters go to work every day and they deserve to come home at night to their loved ones. They really do. I am, let me tell you something. Some of you may not be aware of this.
Do you know Santos Melendez? Does that name ring a bell? Morales Suarez. Aaron Hernandez Sanchez. Ulysses Garcia Mendez. Abraham Rojas, Eric Martinez, Miguel Castillo, Jorge Alfaro and there's other names so back in 2013 And it went on for three years. We had killings in Santa Maria, people were killed and MS-13 came in Santa Maria and set up shop. We had people coming in here and saying to us at the council well if they weren't this color of skin maybe you guys would do something about it And that really hurts when you're up here and you are helpless.
One night coming up at the dais, Ms. Zuniga said to me, well nobody got killed this weekend. I was thinking it, I just never said it. And I think it's really sad when you see a community being taken hostage by a gang and that's what happened to us. And it is a very tragic and very, very sad. And then you have a young kid get shot and killed on our streets. These are kids too. I mean they have parents, they have sisters, they have brothers.
And this young man, this kid gets killed on our streets. I can't imagine what his mother went through And then the kid that was with him that survived what his mother went through also. But all the victims in Santa Maria, not just the ones that were killed. Then one day another story two young men they were cousins went out to Guadalupe and they were playing soccer out there are police officers On those burner phones, got messages that the MS-13 was heading out to Guadalupe to kill these two.
Our officers beat them to it. Found one of the wing young men standing next to the car watching the soccer game going on And our police officer said, where is so-and-so? He said he's out there playing soccer. He said get him right now. We're getting the two of you out of here and save the lives of those two young men. Our police officers along with Homeland Security, ATF, County of Santa Barbara Sheriff, County of San Luis Obispo, probably Ventura Saved a lot of lives.
And then there was. The name you might remember Marilyn Ferris. She was brutally, brutally murdered, raped, murdered in her home. This man had been, the police were, sheriffs were aware of him. He had tried to rape another woman before. He had a rap sheet. He should not have been in this country and yet he murdered this woman. Those men, MS-13 that murdered all these people they should not have been here.
And it's really, really sad when you see this happen in your community. Parents did not want their kids playing out in their front yard. They didn't take them to the parks. It was so completely, it was so dismal and I said we, the father of this young man came here to the podium. The family of this young man that was murdered on our streets came here asking us to do something about it The MS-13 gang members that were picked up on, I'll never forget it was March 3rd.
I went down to the police station and I saw these people. Each one individually were held in a car in the Sally Port in the back of the police department with their hands handcuffed. We went in on March 3rd, not me, our police officers went into Homes in Santa Maria went to another home in Bakersfield, another one in Columbus, Ohio. That was at 6 o'clock in the morning. It was 3 o'clock in the morning.
You can't imagine I'm thinking I don't want any of our police officers hurt in this. This was a dangerous, dangerous thing that they were doing and none of them got hurt. And you know what? I am praying because I don�t want any of them hurt. We've already had all these murders in Santa Now the people in that MS-13 gang, they worked out in the fields. They had a work ethic. They got up every morning and went to work. They had families.
Can you imagine toddlers, young kids in these homes? I can't imagine. And a lot of the kids, of course, had to be placed in homes with nearest relatives. So I had to live through that so my perspective You know, on that is probably much different than some of your perspective on it. And this is really difficult and I kept saying to our police chief at the time when is this going to end?
When are we going to be able to do something? And finally it happened on that March 3rd or just about coming up on March 3rd. I can't begin to tell you the horrific things that man did this woman that he brutally murdered in her home. A lot wasn't even in the newspaper. And then I sit on a board fighting back Santa Maria Valley. And one day, I'm taking this young boy home to his house. He lives on the west side of town and we're talking And I'm talking about things he wants to do. He's probably a sophomore in high school. He's telling me that his brother wants to be a police officer, but he can't be a police officer here because he's here illegally so he's going to have to go back to Mexico to be a police officer and I'm thinking that shouldn't be you know these kids have whatever age he was when he came here they're Americans they've gone to our schools they pledged allegiance they sing our songs there are Americans they've been raised here And I have a Mayor's Youth Task Force.
I take these kids to the universities, I take them to museums, I take them to anything that I think is enrichment for them so they're exposed to things. I don't ask them for their status and I know...I think it was not Back in Trump's first administration, he tried to get something passed through on DACA. These kids that have been here all their lives and have come here as children, you know, as far as I'm concerned they're Americans. And so you're coming here, you're asking us to do something that we have Little or no authority to do, we can do all these things but that's like putting a band-aid on a huge surgical wound.
I have no problem talking to our congressman and saying hey, we really need to do something. This is at the crisis it really is. We had people out here protesting when MS 13 was murdering people in Santa Maria and we were doing nothing about it And it's like I said, it's such a helpless feeling when you have that and you have to make a decision on something. We can make decisions on all kinds of things that will not ultimately affect your life.
But I think this is bigger than this little Band-Aid. I think it's really sad when I see people out there yelling and screaming, we're not the bad guys. We really are not the bad guys. When I saw millions of people coming across the border through the last administration they were never abetted and I'm thinking oh my gosh what is that going to mean to all of us?
There's no way to quantify all of this. We can have all the ad hoc committees and we can talk about different things here in our community. But this takes really action from our leaders at the federal level, and I have no problem talking to our congressmen and say hey, but let's be reasonable because we're talking, and I get it, we need to come to the middle.
And we don't need to lose any more lives getting there But this is, like I said, what I have been through and seeing what's happened to Santa Maria. And people will say to me we would like to have Santa Maria back where it was in 1955 or something when it was a small lazy little town. And I have no reason to believe that all of you aren't being honest when you come up here to speak. I question some of the numbers, there's a few things I question and I've asked Mr. Rollins to find out but I just think it's really sad and I'm not making excuses, I'm just telling you what we are able to do is very limited as a city I will not, I do not want Santa Maria as a sanctuary city. I do not want to protect criminals in the City of Santa Maria.
I do not. I think that has hurt Santa Maria. Some of the state laws that we have seen whether it was Prop 47 or others have hurt California and that hurts all of you out there. That hurts all of you.
2:01 – 2:089 turns
Does this council agree with the tactics that ICE is currently using? Is that something we can at least agree
on? You know what, when you say tactics I have no idea.
Not following the constitution, killing people in broad daylight, using excessive force Detaining people without due
process? You know, in the state of California if those jails were allowed to give the criminals over to the federal government then we would be getting these people out of here. And I don't want the criminals because when they're released from that jail you know where they go? They don't go to Santa Barbara or they don't go to L.A., they come into Santa Maria so they're releasing people out there out of the jails.
When we have Our police don't ask what their immigration status is. They're not allowed to ask. We have, and remember you brought the Ford. There was that family that was killed over on Blosser, drunk driver. We have drunk drivers all over this city all the time. They go down Railroad Street and they're running into walls and that's a straight, straight street.
So this is a huge, huge problem. It's not just today, it's not just ICE and I really have no idea what they're actually doing here in Santa Maria other than what communications our police chief or our city manager can have with ICE.
I believe that there's a lot of people who share the sentiment We don't agree with the way ICE is carrying out their protections. And my intent was to have a resolution where we made it clear that the city of Santa Maria stands with the immigrants, and that's why we are here today. I think it's important to look at the language. I think it's important to look at the suggestions and because Santa Maria is a city that's very rich, and we have a lot of immigrants as I stated at the last council meeting my parents are immigrants. I picked strawberries as a child.
It is a difficult life And the immigrants come here looking for a better life. And we are a rich country because of the immigrants and the different types of immigrants that have come to America over the years, have enriched our country and that's why we are melting pot. So my intent was to make it clear to the entire community that that's where Santa Maria stands and that's what the resolution is about.
It is not about creating division or creating more hate, and it's not us versus them. It is about our neighbors, our community working together to help each other. A lot of people are volunteering to take kids to school because the parents are undocumented. I volunteer to take kids to school when the parents are scared, and as a community we can't rely on the government The federal government to come save us, we have to come together and we have to stop creating division and help each other. We have to take food to our neighbors.
We have to give each other rides. We have to help each other. And that was my intent, to bring unity to our community. And that's where I would like to move forward with this resolution.
Is that a motion? Okay, I have a motion.
What's the motion?
To move forward with the resolution. Oh did you have some...
I do. Do you want me to read them? Yeah. Okay so some additions that need to be added to the whereas Whereas immigrant residents of Santa Maria contribute significantly to the city's workforce, economy, schools and civic life. And many families have deep multi-generational roots in the community. And whereas recent federal immigration enforcement activity has caused fear, trauma and disruption for families, workers and students in Santa Maria undermining community trust and public safety Whereas local governance requires not only compliance with state law but clear policies, staff training, transparency and coordination to ensure all residents can safely access city services without fear.
In the sections that are outlined Revising them. Section 1, the City Council deeply affirms its support for our residents in the city of Santa Maria regardless of immigration status and commits to fostering a city where our residents can safely access services and engage with local government. Section 2 We need more clarification there. All City of Santa Maria policies and procedures are in compliance with California state laws that protect undocumented individuals, including Senate Bill 54.
Santa Maria Police Department does not ask about, collect or retain information regarding immigration status of individuals encountered in the course of its duties. And then adding a third section No city funds, personnel equipment, facilities, databases or other resources shall be used to assist any federal immigration enforcement activities. Adding an additional section, the city manager is directed to ensure that all city departments including non-law enforcement departments that regularly interact with the public receive periodic training on SB 54 and related state protections for undocumented residents.
Constitutional rights, inappropriate responses to federal immigration enforcement requests or presence within city facilities.
2:08 – 2:1334 turns
So I think it covers that the police department is trained in the Values Act SB 54 or any state laws, that we are not using city resources, facilities.
Databases, personnel, or any resources to assist federal immigration enforcements and to ensure that city departments are trained regularly especially those that interface with the public
So training regularly, follow state law. And what we are doing already is not use...
Okay I think you know the rest of the council needs to be privy to all this information before a decision is made at least that's my opinion because it's a lot of addition to that
I have a question maybe for the city attorneys. That part when, now we're talking about more like a policy than from what I understand of now we're moving from
this
resolution to more like a policy because now I listen to training for everybody actually everybody in the city and is that what it's been trying to do? Just get lost into, if I understand correctly also about the not permitting the facilities to host any parking of an ICE agent and so on and so forth. Are we doing that?
Sounds like your question is what's the difference between two policy in a resolution?
Yeah, in that regards because you know everything You know, it starts sounding more like a policy than an actual resolution.
Just for clarification first of all the maker of the motion has not amended her motion. The second has not amended her second that was a suggestion and until its adopted its neither however the clear direction provided is a policy that would be enforced and enforceable by the city manager and that appeared to be at least the intent of the amendment Am I correct?
Okay. Then that is exactly what, you were correct. However procedurally it still has not come either from the maker of the motion
or the second. Because we have a motion and a second on the
table. On the original
resolution. So would you like to withdraw your second? Okay, I don't know how legal this even is and so this has to go back to the attorney.
I'm going to make sure it's legal.
Yeah, I know that but I mean it has to
go
back...
But first of all again you have to move it forward or it dies anyway. So the question is first for Ms. Aguilera whether or not you accept those amendments and are we going to move them over to the second?
I think that's the first question. I think that was the inquiry from Council Member Escobedo, is that he wanted to see the language whether it's a policy or resolution.
No just for clarification from you guys since there has been... Yeah what exactly is that in this resolution wants to be added as per request from Council Member Soto?
Because the language changes. It totally changes so we have to decide what we're doing and I'm not even clear now because now it's the language that you brought up, Soto, with the training and everything else that goes with it. We have to decide how we're going to do this, how we're going to move forward. We need clear direction.
Do we give the language to
the city manager? Wait a minute, before we get to the language. Do you want to take back your second at that point? No. Okay. So your motion was made on this resolution, is that correct? My
motion was that the city bring a resolution forward
But I'm saying right now your motion was made on this resolution. Yeah,
that's what was in the
notice
to
the second was
made on and that was a language that we. That we gave it to the public that we noticed right were required by law to give notice to the public right?
OK,
but we can also amend and not accept what was presented.
OK so then Miss Soto put in in what she wanted in
And now it would be a matter of council member Hernandez to decide if she accept the amendment and you keep this second. Okay, right?
2:13 – 2:1921 turns
Is the motion with the resolution as stated
or with
changes?
No, it's right now. So
let's go through the voting process
to move forward. The motion is as stated here and the second is as stated unless they want to withdraw the motion in a second. Or
modify their motion.
Any further discussion? Madam Clerk, can you please call the roll?
Roll-call vote Passed 4–1 motion. Any further discussion? Madam Clerk, can you please call the roll?
Show transcript
Motion carries So
the next item on the agenda will be a report by City Manager Mr. Rowlands
Thank you, Madam Mayor and Council. Our next city council meeting we will be having the Chamber of Commerce doing their quarterly report for us. We will also be looking at some disposition of several buses and equipment and looking to do a generator purchase so we're also working on a couple other items that aren't on the current upcoming agenda list. So that's all I have for tonight thank you
They will proceed them with three oral reports from council members who wants to begin.
I will thank you Madam Mayor. I went January 21st of the 23rd to the city's mayor and City Council Academy in Sacramento and then Did I say May? I meant January. January 27th, I went to the Boys and Girls Club standing with the youth and then also in the evening I went to the police council and then the 29th I went to CATA board meeting. Mr. Escobedo
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I also attended the 16th anniversary of the Boisingers Club looking forward for this year and it's really close to my as a former board member it's a really close organization to me and the work they do is phenomenal and fantastic particularly since they are in the heart of my district so shout out to to the Boisingers club team and everybody and that's it
Thank you. This is Aguilar Hernandez.
Yes, so I did. I also attended the Boys and Girls Club sending with the youth breakfast. I went to a Caltrans meeting on the 21st on the 26th there was an econ Alliance board meeting On the 27th, I attended the Police Council Mixer and I attended the Board of Supervisors meeting. On the 28th,I attended the Investment Committee meeting and I also attended a county meeting regarding street vendors and the restaurants that are being affected by that And then on the 30th, I attended the ribbon cutting for the it's called Las Mujeres Park in Guadalupe.
And that is all.
Thank you. Ms. Soto?
On Wednesday, January 21st. Was that the last one? I attended the city of Santa Maria and airport meeting. Let's see what else. I attended a budget ad hoc committee on Monday the 26th. I attended a meeting on homelessness on January 29th I attended on the 28th, I forgot to mention it. I think it was the 28th standing with youth and on the 30th I also attended the meeting with Joan Hartman on their new ordinance on street vendors and that is all I have to report.
Thank you. On January 20th I did the Ben Hayes show which tomorrow morning Council Member Flores will be doing On the 22nd and 23rd, I attended the League of California Cities Policy Committee on Housing. And from that budget—from the budget as it stands right now, we're not going to see any extra money for low-income housing. We're not going to see any money for homeless coming into our area.
On the 26th, I attended the Budget Ad Hoc Committee. On the 27th, attended the Police Council Membership Social. On the 28th, attended 3CE Policy Board Meeting of Directors Special Meeting and the Marion Foundation Board meeting. On the 29th, attended the Leadership Santa Maria Valley and on the 30th, the CalCOG board meeting.
Madam Mayor, before we adjourn I would like to end the meeting in honor and to recognize those who have died due to ICE actions in 2026 or in their custody. Keith Porter, Geraldo Lunas Campos, Luis Gustavo Nunez Careses, Luis Beltran Ines Cruz, Renee Good, Prady Law, Victor Manuel Diaz, Herbert Sanchez-Dominguez and Alex Preti.
Thank you this meeting is adjourned