BodyBoard of Supervisors
MeetingRegular Meeting
Date📅 October 3, 2023

UnGovr Transcript

iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.
  1. PendingQueued for transcription.
  2. AIYou are hereAuto-transcribed and summarized; not yet human-verified.
  3. VerifiedReviewed and corrected by a person.

0:00 – 0:036 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.970:18

Good morning. I will call to order the October 3rd, 2023 meeting of the Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors to order. Madam Clerk please call the roll.

Roll call, called by Clerk of the Board
Show transcript
Supervisor Katz. Here. Supervisor Nelson. Here. Supervisor Lavinino. Here, Supervisor Hartman here and Chair Williams here
Pledge of Allegianceceremonial · click to expand · ≈22s recited, not transcribed
ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.970:35

at this time please join us in pledging allegiance to our flag

Next item of business is the minutes from the September 19th meeting. Is there a motion?

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:06

Move approval.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:08

Is there second? Second. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Opposed? Thank you. CEO's report

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:16

Chairman Williams, I do have one brief announcement from the Office of Emergency Management. There will be a nationwide test of the emergency alert system and wireless emergency alert system tomorrow Wednesday October 4th at 1120 in the morning. The alert is conducted by FEMA and the FCC. Emergency Alert System messages are transmitted on all local radio and television stations with an alert tone or scrolling text across the bottom of the screen Wireless emergency alert messages are transmitted to cell phones and look like text messages that are accompanied by a distinct attention tone and vibration to all cell phones that are on and within range of a cell tower. The Office of Emergency Management has posted information about this test on ReadySBC.org in English and in Spanish.

Information was also shared via press release on multiple county social media accounts, and that concludes the CO report.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.972:11

Thank you and I also have one addition. On Sunday, I had the pleasure to award Santa Barbara or to present a Santa Barbara Beautiful Award to Dignity Moves for our project that we partnered with them at 1016 Santa Barbara Street or Garden Street And of course, I thought this was amazing in that it's one of the first times. It is definitely the first time that Santa Barbara Beautiful has ever given an award usually presented to the nicest looking house in town to a transitional homeless housing. So I'll pass it around.

But great partnership and of course not possible without Good Samaritan. Madam Clerk, are there any announcements or changes to our agenda today?

0:03 – 0:0713 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role3:13

Chair Williams and members of the board, I do have a few quick announcements this morning. We received a withdrawal request from the department for departmental item number three. Departmental item number three is from the planning and development department. It is a hearing to consider recommendations regarding an appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of revision to permit condition number 38 MM Bio 16 Golden Ego Take Permit for the Straus Wind Energy Project case number 23 RBP 31.

This is in the third and fourth districts. The applicant has withdrawn their appeal, and as such the department has revised their recommended actions requesting that the board accept the applicants withdrawal. Lastly for the Board of Supervisors methods of public participation and to provide public comment on general public comment or an item on the boards agenda please see page two of the agenda Individuals that would like to provide verbal public comment may do so via zoom by registering in advance via the link available on page 2. If you have any questions please contact the clerk of the board's office at 805-568-2240 That concludes my announcements for today

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.974:20

Would any board members like to pull any items from the administrative agenda?

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.854:26

A6 please

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.974:27

Thank you. Can I get a motion on the balance of the consent agenda?

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.854:34

So moved. Second.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.974:35

All those in favor please say aye. Aye. Opposed? E6.

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role4:45

Chair Williams and members of the Board, Administrative Item 6 is from the County Executive Office. It is to consider recommendations regarding a nomination to name Refugio Road Pedestrian Trail in honor of Karina DeVelasquez. This project is located within the 3rd District. This item requires a unanimous vote.

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.855:08

At 6.55 p.m., on Thursday, March 26th 2015, 15-year-old Karina Velazquez was on her way home from school when she stepped out into the crosswalk at the intersection of Herfufio and Highway 246 and was hit by a car. She died a few hours later one day before her 16th birthday. It's eight and a half years later, but the community still remembers the girl who often stayed late to help put away books and straighten up papers. The girl with the inquisitive mind who was a very hard worker. And the girl who loved animals especially cats whose motto was never forget to smile.

Her father describes her as a girl who had been a little shy around new people and situations, and was just beginning to blossom and come out of her shell. Her father helped us build the demonstration part of the path including a small footbridge We would like to place a boulder with the plaque there. The Santa Ynez High School Board approved placing the marker on school property next to the path which is placed in the county right-of-way. Karina's father, Jose Velasquez Jr., wrote to the high school board in support of this saying it has been eight plus years since we've lost our daughter and we've been missing a piece of our hearts every day. My hope is that the path will be a safe place for people to walk and ride bikes away from traffic And that no other families have to suffer the loss of a family member in this way.

We would like to have Karina's name on the path so that she is not forgotten. Hopefully putting her name on it will increase awareness of the hazards of walking on the road and will make it more real as to what can happen in a flash if you let your guard down. I very much hope this board will join the high school board in unanimous support to name the trail in Karina memory. Thank you.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.977:02

Thank you, Supervisor Hartman. Can we get a motion on A6?

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.857:08

So moved.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.977:09

Second?

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.857:10

Second.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.977:11

All those in favor please say aye. Aye. It's unanimous. Let's go to administrative item number 22

0:07 – 0:123 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role7:26

Chair Williams and members of the board, Administrative Item 22 is sponsored by Supervisor Williams. It is to adopt a Resolution of Commendation retroactively honoring Kerry Gallagher of the District Attorney's Office as July 2023 Employee of the Month of Santa Barbara County. Joining us here in person we have Kerry Gallagher, District Attorney John Savernock and Chief Deputy District Attorney Anne Knutson. Please make your way to the podium and I will read the resolution into the record.

Whereas Kerry Gallagher exemplifies the county's organizational values of accountability, customer focus, equity and inclusion, innovation, trust and ethics. And whereas Kerry models the transformative behaviors of collaborative problem-solving alignment with the county's vision risk taking data driven decision making And whereas, juvenile justice is an important component of the criminal justice system. Carrie's responsible for the prosecution of all juvenile cases in North County from the time of filing through sentencing. All of which she handles with exceptional care, judgment and conscientiousness while protecting public safety. Addressing the concerns of victims, protecting the rights of juveniles and upholding the highest ethical standards.

And whereas, Cary actively engages in our community and supports our juveniles in public safety by working with probation, the courts, the defense bar, local law enforcement, school districts, community-based service organizations, child welfare services. The diversion of treatment programs to ensure that the juveniles in our community are getting the appropriate support, services and rehabilitation to protect public safety and to ensure justice.

And whereas, Cary facilitates communications through workflows through all of the county's criminal justice partners including providing training keeping up to date with new areas of law and working to continue to grow and develop special intervention programs like Heart Court. Now therefore be it hereby ordered a resolve that this Board of Supervisors recognizes Cary Gallagher as employee of the month for July 2023 passed and adopted today

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed9:47

Chair Williams, members of the board just a few brief comments. One with me today is actually Chief Deputy Sonia Baeste but about Carrie many years ago Carrie was actually a mentee of my predecessor Joyce Dudley I'm sure Joyce would tell you all that she imparted a large part of Carrie's sense of justice in her but I think Carrie had that innately After establishing an already well-established career, Carrie came to us with a passion for juvenile justice.

And juvenile justice is a different function than general adult prosecutions. There is a significant effort on rehabilitation education changing behaviors Combined that, there are also some very serious crimes which demand a public safety response. And one of the many beauties of Carrie is that she can switch between those roles so easily. She identifies the young individuals that need help, need a helping hand, have grown up in difficult circumstances and have an absolute ability to change.

And in that, she is such a wonderful collaborator which speaks to what we are doing as a county. The goal of our county is to work together with all systems, all entities, all the organizations inside and outside the county family that come into play in any field. What our focus is on collaboration and Carrie is phenomenal at that Of working with service providers, working with probation who has such an important role a critical role in juvenile justice. Working with police agencies and working with defense counsel so I've got to say when Kerry came to us with a passion for juvenile justice we were a very lucky office thank you Kerry

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9712:18

We thank you so much for your work. A23.

0:12 – 0:153 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role12:23

Chair Williams and members of the board, Administrative Item 23 is sponsored by Supervisor Williams. It is to adopt a resolution of commendation honoring Adrian Garcia of the General Services Department as October 2023 Employee of the Month in Santa Barbara County. Joining us here we have Adrian. If you'll please make your way to the podium I will read the resolution into the record.

Whereas Adrian Garcia, Building Maintenance Worker exemplifies the county's organizational values of accountability, customer focus, equity and inclusion, innovation, trust and ethics. And whereas Adrian models the transformative behaviors of collaborative problem-solving alignment with the county's vision risk taking data driven decision making And strategic thinking. And whereas, his career started in the Parks Department in July of 2018 working in the Santa Barbara Veterans Building as an extra help employee. He was then promoted to the General Services Department in March of 2019 working at the Santa Barbara Main Jail. He was then moved to the downtown campus to train with a long-term maintenance employee known as Legend and Adrian quickly earned the nickname Little Legend.

And whereas, Adrian is responsible for 11 downtown county-owned buildings consisting of approximately 370,000 square feet of building space. And he takes great pride in managing these facilities. Adrian successfully responds to an average of 1,700 work requests with a smile and exceptional professionalism. He displays incredible dedication to the organization, and Adrian is usually the first person on scene to respond Building Maintenance Emergencies.

And whereas, during the recent local emergencies in January and February he provided extremely loyal service to the county and community working long hours protecting all of the downtown facilities from damaging heavy rainfall and flooding. Throughout these emergencies, Adrian made tremendous personal sacrifices to be away from his family and ensure the county facilities avoided any major flood damages.

And now therefore be it hereby ordered a resolve that this Board of Supervisors recognizes Adrian Garcia as employee of the month of October 2023 passed and adopted today.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed14:54

Chair Williams, Supervisors thank you very much for this recognition for Adrian. I know he's pretty humble and didn't really want to be up here but appreciate it and I also want to recognize the rest of the folks you see in the back in the blue shirts the rest of the facilities maintenance team and on a day-in and day-out basis who take care of all our county facilities and after hours weekends holidays they're there to respond and so my hats off to all them as well thank you

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9715:27

They sure wanted you up there, Adrian. Administrative item number 24.

0:15 – 0:182 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role15:36

Chair Williams and members of the board, administrative item 24 is sponsored by Supervisor Williams and Supervisor Hurtman. It is to adopt a resolution proclaiming the month of October 2023 as National Domestic Violence Awareness Month in Santa Barbara County. Joining us here in person we have Domestic Violence Solutions and Veronica Cubillo. Please join us at the podium and I will now read the resolution into the record.

Whereas domestic violence is a pervasive issue that affects individuals and families across our nation regardless of age, gender, race and social economic status. And whereas National Domestic Violence Awareness Month observed in October provides an opportunity to raise public awareness about domestic violence and its devastating impacts on survivors and communities.

And whereas survivors of domestic violence often face physical emotional It is crucial to provide support and resources to help them rebuild their lives. And whereas promoting awareness and education about domestic violence is essential in preventing future instances of abuse, and fostering a society that values respect, empathy, and healthy relationships. And whereas here in Santa Barbara County Domestic Violence Solution, a premier not-for-profit organization that provides safety shelter and support countywide for individuals and families affected by domestic violence. And collaborates with community partners to raise awareness regarding the cause prevalence and impact of domestic violence will be organizing a series of community events and encourages all to take part in raising awareness about domestic violence And the ways that all of us can contribute towards its prevention.

Now therefore be it hereby ordered and resolved that this Board of Supervisors officially recognizes the month of October as National Domestic Violence Awareness Month, and pledges to work together as a community to raise awareness, support survivors, and promote efforts to eradicate domestic violence from our society past and adopted today.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed17:41

Thank you everybody. I just wanted to take the chance to plug in that we do have our vigil this Thursday here in Santa Maria for any locals that would like to attend it's going to be held at the Machado Plaza, I believe begins at 530 so we'll love to have anybody that can join us join us to continue to bring awareness to the topic. So thank you guys

0:18 – 0:215 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9718:12

Number 25.

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role18:13

Chair Williams and members of the board, Administrative Item 25 is sponsored by Supervisor Capps and Supervisor Hartman. It is to adopt a resolution proclaiming the month of October 2023 as Breast Cancer Awareness Month in Santa Barbara County. Joining us here in person we have Director Hamami and via Zoom we have June English. Director Hamami if you will make your way to the podium I will now read the resolution into the record Whereas in the U.S., one in eight women will be diagnosed with breast cancer in their lifetime, and when breast cancer is detected early in a localized stage, the five-year survival rate is 98% as a result.

Women should work with their medical providers to establish a plan to detect the disease in the early stages which includes regular mammograms, clinical breast exams and self-breast exams. And whereas, health care plans cover preventative services such as breast exams. The public health department Every Woman Counts program provides support for breast cancer screening and diagnostic services for low-income women who do not have the resources for this important service.

And whereas in the past fiscal year Santa Barbara County every woman's count health educators provided 1,350 tri-county individuals with breast cancer education and referrals to free screenings In addition, providers whom partnered with Every Woman Counts conducted free breast cancer screening and diagnostic services for 6,882 Tri-County individuals. And whereas in the past fiscal year Santa Barbara County Every Woman Counts has provided 124 Tri-County women with patient navigation services from the program's nursing staff to support patient compliance and eliminate barriers to timely screening.

Completion of diagnostic testing and facilitating referral for treatment. And whereas we are in support of Santa Barbara County's Every Woman Counts prevention efforts, now therefore be it hereby ordered and resolved that this Board of Supervisors does proclaim the month of October 2023 as Breast Cancer Awareness Month to promote the health of all residents in the county of Santa Barbara passed and adopted today.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed20:23

Thank you Thank you very much for the resolution. And as we heard, although we are seeing an increase in the diagnosis of breast cancer rates, we are also seeing a decrease in death from that cancer and this highlights the importance of early detection and screening. And this is what this program's all about. I don't know if Miss English June, if you are with us on Zoom, if you want to say a few words?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed20:54

Thank you very much. We are very happy to be out in the community this month, and this is our biggest month for outreach actually. So please encourage anyone you know who wants the information about our services for the uninsured or under-insured to please contact our office and also let us know if you have any suggestions for further outreach We very much value our collaboration with all the community partners that we have. And it's been a wonderful service to be able to reach women in our communities and steer them towards the care that they deserve to have. Thank you very much.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed21:39

Thank you.

0:21 – 0:266 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9721:45

Administrative item number 26.

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role21:48

Chair Williams and members of the board, Administrative Item 26 is sponsored by Supervisor Hartman. It is to adopt a resolution proclaiming October 4th 2023 as National Bike and Walk to School Day in Santa Barbara County. Joining us here in person we have Ken Dahmen from MOVE! Santa Barbara County. Will you please make your way to the podium and I will read the resolution into the record?

Whereas promoting active and sustainable modes of transportation is essential for health and well-being of our youth. And whereas National Bike & Walk to School Day encourages students to engage in physical activity, and reduce their carbon footprint by walking or biking to school. And whereas the Safe Routes to School Program, as established by the U.S. Department of Transportation, plays a pivotal role in creating safe environments for students to walk and bike to school by providing infrastructure improvements, educational programs and community engagement.

And whereas the benefits of walking and biking to school include improved physical fitness, reduced traffic congestion and increased community connectedness. And whereas National Bike & Walk To School Day fosters a sense of independence responsibility in students as they navigate their neighborhood safely. And whereas celebrating National Bike & Walk To School Day on October 4th 2023 aligns with our commitment to creating a more sustainable and active future for our youth Now therefore be it hereby ordered and resolved that this Board of Supervisors supports the designation of October 4th, 2023 as National Bike and Walk to School Day. And encourages schools parents and communities to participate in this meaningful event to promote the health and well-being of our students and the environment passed and adopted today

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed23:32

Thank you council so much for this resolution. I think it's really important to highlight the active transportation capabilities of our communities and working with Move Santa Barbara County, I've been doing that for the last seven and a half years thank you guys so much for the opportunity just wanted to introduce one of my co-workers Terry Bircher he's taking our North North County education program from five schools to all 20 in Santa Maria Bonita School District also working from Lompoc and San Diego Valley as well so it's an honor to do this work thank you guys so much

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9724:06

Supervisor

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.8524:06

Hartman. Thank you there was an image up of me my first day of school, first grade riding my bike so I'm a passionate advocate for getting kids out of cars walking and biking to school Gina Fisher did that without my permission but But you can see that I started young and I was really impatient to be off. I'd taken my bike safety classes and was ready to ride, but only later I learned my father had followed me the whole two miles in his car to make sure that I actually did it the way I had been taught But my bike meant freedom, it meant independence and as a kinetic kid the ride was good way for me to burn off some energy before I settled down in the classroom. So tomorrow I'm going to be at Solvang Elementary School with the CHP to mark National Bike and Walk to School Day and encouraging kids to arrive on bike and foot.

We plan to start organizing now for next year because we'd like to see throughout the valley and I'd like to see throughout the county Where we have walking school buses and riding bike trains, and really allowing every kid to have the kind of freedom that I enjoyed when I was a youngster. I consider it to be a birthright really the ability to get outside stand on their own two feet and propel themselves to school so MOVE is working with South County schools, one by one identifying obstacles that are barriers that are making it hard for kids to get to school. And as you heard from Ken they're very active in North County but I think this is really important for kids health and well being so anyway celebrate walk to school day bike to school day.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9725:58

Well, Yashin and Kaya are big supporters of your efforts. And we'll be enacting it on Wednesday as well. Okay, administer of item number 27.

0:26 – 0:314 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role26:11

Chair Williams and members of the board, Administrative Item 27 is sponsored by Supervisor Williams. It is to adopt a resolution proclaiming October 3rd 2023 as Seasonal Flu Kickoff Day in Santa Barbara County. Joining us here in person we have Director Hamameh and Anne Carlisle. If you'll please make your way to the podium I will read the resolution into the record.

Whereas the County of Santa Barbara wants all county residents to be healthy and protected from illness. Whereas Santa Barbara County is joining the Centers for Disease Control in their seasonal flu kickoff day, to highlight the importance of flu vaccination during flu season. And whereas the Centers for Disease Control recommends a yearly flu vaccine for everyone six months of age and older as the first and most important step in protecting against the influenza disease.

And whereas individuals who receive the flu vaccine may also protect people around them, including those who are more vulnerable to serious flu illness like babies and young children, older people and people with certain chronic health conditions. And whereas flu vaccines are safe and effective with hundreds of millions of Americans receiving flu vaccines over the past 50 years.

Now therefore it is hereby ordered and resolved that this Board of Supervisors of Santa Barbara County does hereby proclaim October 3rd as Seasonal Flu Kickoff Day, passed and adopted today.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed27:35

So thank you for the resolution Mr. Chair and my understanding that this is a tradition where you get the VIP treatment, we get you the shots to the podium but today we're doing also an extra where we brought 100 doses and anybody that is here that would love or would want a shot then all they can, all they need to do is just walk to our station over there. We have the best team members with us. They have the magic touch you will not feel anything it's free. All you have to do is fill a very short form and you can get your vaccine we're here till noon so anytime between now till noon just make sure that you get yours and as we have our team members giving the shot for our supervisors I'm going to join It

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9728:22

looks like you're going to really test how tough those general services staff are.

CommentMadam ClerkProposed · by introduction29:05

Oh, whoa. Now I'm pretty impressed with that. There was excitement last time. Thank you. Yeah. Okay.

0:31 – 0:366 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed31:38

Thank you.

CommentMadam ClerkProposed · by introduction32:15

We did. A lot of

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed32:50

really interesting

CommentMadam ClerkProposed · by introduction32:52

stuff going on here.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed33:13

In my mind. Okay, thank you. Okay. No, no they don't make it.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9735:50

Well, we're getting a lot of flu shots done but we do need to reconvene the meeting. Now is the time for members of the public to speak on items that are not on the agenda. Madam Clerk, are there any requests to speak on general public comment?

0:36 – 0:393 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role36:06

Chair Williams and members of the board we have one request to speak. George Alvarez here in Santa Maria.

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role36:23

Good morning Board of Supervisors. I want to thank you for the assistance in the dredging of our river over there, fantastic job. Of course again Being Guadalupe and we waited 20 years, not by your fault. Government has different priorities when it comes to the little people of our communities on that. I'm not too excited about our local congressperson didn't do a damn thing for us in Guadalupe. I invested in this little town okay? Mr Hart another person has to be called out and not doing anything.

When we need it as a community, from that perspective. One concern some of the ranchers have on the aspect of completing the project is government has a tendency of being over the top when it comes to environmental issues and throws a human element outside. Critters are more important than human elements, okay? This is probably what we're having because how it ends up dredging down to a point On the fence north side of the river.

It seems to be totally narrow and they have a fear, farmers have a fear that when you get that completed in the water comes in there hits the bank curves it'll eat up any road levy eventually if it's not taken into consideration I'm not an engineer this is a concern farmers have and we're spending a lot of tortillas on this issue okay and It's not becoming of intelligence to do something knowing the end result. It might be disastrous, we waited 23 years fine. Now on another note, we need the county Santa Barbara is one of the only few counties where police officers cannot make a judgment call on someone who might have mental issues on the 72 hour puff situation as they call it in the medical profession.

We should have access, police officers with their training should have the ability to make that call. I've been involved lately where it would involve someone who had an epileptic seizure in downtown Guadalupe and we called 911, we called paramedics, police department. And at a time when the person fell to the ground, I was there, he turned, he had a gun in his post right here.

Loaded 930 in the morning. Gun issue, yes but mental health issue. We didn't have the ability to call mental health to get that situated one on one to make an analysis where this guy coming from nine o'clock, 930 in the morning carrying a gun? These are issues that important in public safety where county the city should have the intertwining communications of the experts to help if not let the police officers handle that from that perspective. All right thank you for your time.

Have a good day.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9739:41

Thank you. Departmental item number one winter storm preparation

0:39 – 0:484 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role39:49

Chair Williams and members of the board, departmental item number one is from the Fire Department and Public Works Department. It is a hearing to consider recommendations regarding the 2023 through 2024 winter storm preparation

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed40:22

This morning we'll provide a presentation here on preparations for the coming storm season, winter storm season. When I talk to National Weather Service it's rare that you hear high percentage likelihood chances from weather service right? And they're saying, talked to a couple different offices and they say plus 90% on chances of There we go, sorry about that. We are in an El Nino pattern whether it will be wet or dry is still kind of an unknown but they think there's a high likelihood of a wet pattern for our area and so as a county were looking to prepare for that And we're going to go through some county preparations, infrastructure. We'll talk a little bit about some of our waterways response coordination, private property creek permitting and we'll talk about what the community can also do to prepare as well at this point I'll turn it over to Walter and he can provide updates on public works.

Hold on. You

CommentWalter RubicabaProposedself-stated41:37

got it? Good morning Chair Williams, members of the board. I'm Walter Rubicaba with Public Works and I'll be providing an update on our preparation for the 23-24 storms. I do want to note that although we're expecting an El Nino this year whether it's a dry year or wet season our department goes through the same preparation every year so we're not caught off guard.

Next slide please So this is a summary of our current sites and status update, starting with transportation there's approximately 169 locations or sites. We had about $56 million worth of damage and 50 of those sites have been reopened. On the flood control side, we actually have 15 basins that have been cleared and then we have three basins are currently ongoing up here in the North County.

We've also finished five dredging operations and our debris sorting site which is off of Cathedral Oaks up above the Emergency Operations Center was sorted as of last week and will begin off hauling efforts starting this week. And I'll give an update on the Santa Maria River in a few more slides next slide please So looking at our reservoir and releases, I'll start with Kachuma. Kachuma is about 90% full in comparison to last year at this time it was about 30% full so we'll begin discussions with the Bureau starting soon Bureau reclamation soon regarding any potential releases this year Just so you're aware that the county provides feedback based on our knowledge and our modeling but we are not the ultimate decision maker on those releases.

If we get to the point where we feel releases are going to be of concern to any downstream communities or stakeholders, we will work with emergency management to communicate that and make sure that those stakeholders are notified and we'll work through the Office of Emergency Management on that. Next slide please. On the Twitchell Reservoir, it's about 20% full right now.

The Santa Maria Water Conservation District continues to release 250-300 CFS continuously. They will continue to do that until the reservoir is empty and we're currently expecting that to happen sometime in December. Now, what's different about the Twitchell Reservoir as I mentioned on Kachuma is the Bureau of Reclamation. They're involved on the Twitchell Reservoir as well but the decision makers are the Bureau, Army Corps, the San Antonio Water Conservation District and the county in that situation plays the same role. We're not the decision maker but we have a place at the table and we provide input based on our knowledge and modeling.

Now, there is an ongoing effort to change the release protocol. Supervisor Nelson's office and Lavinino's office have already begun those discussions and Public Works will continue to support those efforts and try to change some of those protocols. And then similar to Kachuma, if the releases at Twitchell plus the flows that are coming down Sisquack. If they get to the point of concern we will again work with our emergency management team to get proper notifications and generally for the community of Guadalupe in this case.

Next slide please So this is a, this is an update on the Santa Maria River. Work continues to progress. I'll start with transportation. There's three sites on West Main Street. The first site is just prior to the kiosk that was completed already and then there's another one that's about 1,000 feet past the kiosk. That work should be done by the end of October. And then there's a third site over near closer to the Pacific Ocean That site should be done by the end of December.

On the flood control side, there are two projects that we're working on. There's a pilot channel that is upstream of State Route 1 downstream of Bonita School Road. That's going to be a pilot channel project and the purpose of that project is there's water that is impeding on the levee at a sharp angle right now so we're gonna try to redirect that flow Straight down the river.

And then the second project is the product that we Discussed on the 12th, that is the debris removal project That's from State Route 1 down to the Pacific Ocean that is currently about 40% complete and We still have, we still plan to complete that work by November 1st. However, we're gonna continually go after an extension for the executive order has a deadline of November 1st, we're gonna ask for a 30 day extension and the reason we're gonna do that is it gives us some flexibility on how we're doing this project right now we are working 24 hours a day six days a week And the burn rate is high.

If we were to get an extension of 30 days, we could consider backing off some of those overtime hours to try and save some some of those tax dollars. Now I do want to highlight it says coordinated work with county fire. County fire started on September 11th doing vegetation removal and it was very dense vegetation out there. They did great work, they've been extremely helpful I also want to mention that the farmers the adjacent property owners have been providing labor equipment to help our efforts. The city of Guadalupe their wastewater treatment plant operators have Have been helping to find us irrigation for the restoration project. And I should have mentioned, the farmers have done that as well.

The city of Guadalupe, the mayor, we couldn't ask for more. This coordination effort has been so great and it's been so helpful and it's really helping us meet that November 1st deadline. And with that, I'll pass it over to Kelly.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed48:00

So just as an update with our coordination with the state, we were denied assistance from the state for construction. However, we are working with the State Department of Water Resources Flood Fight Division to work on pre-identification of what resources may be needed if some of the work that Public Works is doing Is not enough to contain if we have significantly high flows, we still want to have a plan in place. So we're pre-scripting, pre-identifying those resources working with the state to do that.

0:48 – 0:542 turns

CommentWalter RubicabaProposedself-stated48:38

Okay and just for the sake of time, I've covered most of these bullets already. What I'll highlight on this is there's a lot of good educational information regarding flood preparation on the county websites both at the Office of Emergency Management website and Flood Control. We encourage the community to visit those sites if they have any challenges finding that information please reach out to our offices and we'll help guide them to that information.

And with that I will pass it over to Lisa

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed49:09

Good morning Mr. Chair, members of the board. I'm here today to talk a little bit about what will happen if there are floods and how we can work with the community to get them through the process particularly those properties that live along creeks. Next slide please So this is very tiny print and I'm not expecting you to read it, but this is just our flow chart of how we work through this process. We actually established this for the 2023 storms in January because we had a number of applicants coming in because they had damage when they lived along creeks.

And essentially it lays out what happens in the inland areas and when you don't need a permit and when you do need a permit As well as the coastal zone areas which almost always require a permit for things. But essentially if you're inland, you have some damage along a creek If you want to come back in, stack some rocks, put some willows in to secure that bank. That's no permit and we help guide them through that process. If you're going to construct a wall or you're going to put grout in, that becomes a structure and then you need a building permit. So this just lays out that process for us. It's great that we have this already established in the event that we see a lot of damage from storms.

Next slide please. There's also damage that occurs to structures, right? So sometimes you'll have water damage to your drywall. You might have damage to the integrity of your structural supports or something done to your foundation through debris flow or whatnot. So this is the type of work that you'll do with our building and safety department. So next slide please.

So the steps that we will work with applicants on is if they are concerned about whether or not their structure is safe to enter, they need to call building and safety and schedule an inspection. And they will come out and determine whether or not they do a rough assessment about whether or no you can enter the building or not enter the building. But what they, it's a safety assessment essentially. Then they need to move on to hire a professional that will assess the actual damage to the structure and come up with a plan to make the repairs. And then they'll submit a building permit application online.

Next slide. If people have questions or concerns, we have office hours where people can set up appointments either virtually or on the phone or in person. There are walk-in hours so we recommend people take advantage of those if they do have questions and of course we'll be conducting outreach if we do see storms coming online. Next slide please So I want to move on to the concept of the ombudsman.

This was an issue that came up during budget hearings and the board had decided to provide some funding and create sort of this part-time position that could assist during storms. And initially the planning and development was not the department that was identified. But as we worked through it with the CEO's office, it seemed that we were really poised to manage that position.

Next slide please. So essentially this ombudsman role becomes a central point of contact for property owners that have to make repairs along creeks. Confusing and involved process for people as we've seen we even had our own staff in P&D who lived on creeks that had some Damage, and it's really struggled with state and federal agencies and trying to figure out how to navigate it Then this individual would serve as a liaison between the property owners and the other governmental agencies that are involved will coordinate communication and then provide some guidance on the permitting of to the property owners that are seeking these creek repairs.

The reason I think P&D is in a good position to do this is because we do a lot of work with those agencies already and so we have established relationships, and I think our goal is obviously to provide the smoothest path forward for people who have suffered some of these damages. Next slide please. So what we're doing in terms of preparing for the El Nino storms We're establishing a recovery team that will assist with permitting within P&D. We're developing a contact list of all of the agencies, either internal and state and federal. And then we're going to develop and put together a kickoff meeting prior to the rainy season with all of these agencies so that we can all be on the same page If it does indeed start to rain, large volumes.

And then as they work through the process we will coordinate with the various agencies internal and external to help the applicants navigate it. I'm happy to answer any questions

0:54 – 1:0514 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed54:28

So I'll talk through some of that. Do you want to stop for questions or do you want me to continue presentation?

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9754:33

Sure, Supervisor Hartman

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.8554:35

has it. As I interpret what you presented it's kind of after the fact once there is damage a lot of people I'm talking to now are trying to figure out how to prevent damage and several are in really deeply incised creeks With a lot of vegetation growing along the side and then vegetation comes down the creek and blocks, and then things go bad in a hurry. So could you talk about what somebody in that situation should be doing now?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed55:12

Sure, Supervisor Hartman through the chair. So if they have concerns about the stability of their bank currently I think it would be a good idea for them to start the process of looking at ways to stabilize it and that could include adding boulders and putting in more vegetation now It's maybe even a little bit late You know because we are approaching the rainy season because you want those plants to take root But we're happy to work with anybody who has questions or concerns and kind of give them some guidance on what they might want to do Sure

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed55:48

sure

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9755:49

Supervisor now,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed55:50

yes. Thank you chair Williams. I Remember this discussion. I think it was supervisor Hartman had brought it up about the ombudsman and I'm big supporter of that concept What's the mechanism that is being funded by? Was that in the budget last year? Maybe this is for the CEO

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed56:06

Chair, Supervisor Nelson through the chair yes there was $50,000 put away in the current year budget.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed56:13

Okay thank you some more comments about that later

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.9756:16

And while we're at it, it's just important to indicate that in some cases this is not possible. But generally flood control's preference is for wider channel because increased channelization and stabilization hardening the banks That will exacerbate channelization, increases velocity for downstream users. So what we want to do is always try to slow down the water when possible so wider banks, V-shaped banks as opposed to vertical banks is what we're hoping for.

Please proceed.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed57:07

Thank you. If I can have the presentation back up? Great, thank you. All right so I'll talk a little bit about what we're doing as a county to prepare and have our agencies and our staff ready to respond and then I'll talk a little bit about what the community can do to prepare as well. So as a county we've hosted multiple concepts moving forward. We've already hosted a multi-agency, multi-department county tabletop exercise where we sat down and talked through what are the potential scenarios concerns?

We're also having some coordination meetings moving forward talking to flood control public works national National Weather Service fire law All of our partner agencies, our cities to talk through all of those considerations. Walter mentioned earlier the downstream agencies for the two major reservoirs that we have. We are having pre-meetings with those agencies so we're having a lot of pre meetings to talk through our considerations and when we should be recommending public protective actions and when it's a consideration of discussion sharing of resources activations those types of considerations We're also doing some EOC training and considerations here. OEM, Sheriff and the Fire Department have hosted some all hazards evacuation training where we've met with deputies and firefighters and OEM and we've talked about the process of determining those protective actions.

How do we do notifications? How do those concepts work and get implemented? We're rolling out phased implementation of state and federal online trainings for all county employees. And we have EOC training scheduled between now and December to support all staff in trainings, to make sure that they're ready to respond to the Emergency Operations Center. The EOC itself as a facility, the Emergency Operations Center.

We're working on refining our alerting and community information on our website how we do our emergency alerts, refining our language now making sure we have it translated. We have an EOC activation plan for during construction just for your awareness I know many of the board and community members are aware of construction there so we're making sure we know how we're going to activate that facility And then we also have an alternate EOC plans for the North County. This was a leadership project, just graduated this group and they did a review and looked at how do we set up a north EOC? It's actually in this room, this facility if we were needing to activate this North County concept. And then OEM has a grab-and-go plan essentially what do we need a grab from South County if possible to bring it up here or what would we need to establish here if we cannot grab those items from South County Community preparedness, this is what I really wanted to highlight.

What can our community members do? And so I just want to talk through or remind the community about emergency protective actions. Some of the ones you might see in a flood type event, evacuation warnings and orders will typically come before the rain starts. We want community members to leave or evacuate prior to rain if possible because we don't want to have them necessarily driving in hazardous conditions once it is significant. If there's significant rainfall flash flood warning Maybe we start to have some roads that are flooded. Then residents might see a shelter in place where we ask them to stay in their homes, go to higher ground and generally find an area in their home or their household that might be safer than trying to travel through roads that are flooded.

These are all terms that you may see and we highly encourage residents to be aware and familiar with these they are also up on our website I will always encourage our residents to register for ReadySBC alerts. Countywide, we have 14% registration. 14% of our residents are registered. So, we have landlines that are automatically in our system. Not many people have landlines anymore so that's not as helpful as it used to be.

So, we encourage residents to go to ReadySBC.org to register. They can register up to five addresses within the county. Must register at least one contact method and one physical address. I know it sounds weird that I'm saying that but sometimes people going to put their address and then they don't necessarily complete it with a full phone number email address. Highly encouraged for residents to have at least one phone number in there for text messages or phone calls not just email since most people their emails don't Actively ring on their phones, right? So we want that phone number in there if possible text message. We do reverse calls to landlines and cell phones email and does have accessibility accommodations for anyone who may have issues with the deaf or hard of hearing and needed that accessibility.

We will use either ourselves or National Weather Service. So for flooding, often the National Weather Service is the lead for wireless emergency alerts just so the community understands that. National Weather Service does that automatically through their systems and so we won't always repeat a wireless emergency alert but we will use those other reverse notifications door-to-door notification by local law enforcement or public safety officials and EAS is those ones that you'll get over the radio or TV Lots of places to get incident information. One of the things that disaster social science tells us is that people will look for three places to confirm what they're supposed to do before they take that action. It doesn't matter that I notify them that they should evacuate, there's still going to look for at least two other places to verify that that's what they should be doing and so we want to encourage and make sure people understand where else they can get that official information.

And so these are just a few of those channels and opportunities to look for that information. I won't go through all Individual preparedness at ReadySBC. You can just go to readysbc.org if you want the more direct link to storm readiness, it's up on the screen there. Now is the time as Lisa mentioned to take action to protect your home. Where did you have flooding? Did you have water back up at your back door? Where should you be putting sandbags? Sometimes it's hard to think of those things ahead of time before it starts raining so think back to this last season what were the issues or concerns that you had at your house? What can you do now?

Through that link and also on the flood on Public Works website there's a great manual about how to protect your home from floods. A little guide, do you have an emergency plan? Do you know your local roads if one always floods, do you know another way out of your community or if you don't if there's only one road and that one always floods should you consider either one evacuating proactively so you can get to and from work or take your kids to school Or two, should you consider additional supplies at home? Buy some extra groceries. Have some flashlights and batteries. Those kinds of readiness considerations before the rain comes. That comes to your emergency kit. And please, please, please get to know your neighbors if there's an elderly resident nearby or somebody maybe my daughter was a latchkey kid meaning she was 12 years old and at home before and after school and I knew my neighbors were looking out for her so be aware of your neighbors know who else might need help in these situations, please.

And with that, and I apologize. I did not put the recommendations from the board letter but the recommendations are to receive and file a report on county preparations for possible strong storm season resulting from predicted El Nino conditions and determine the above action is not a project under CEQA. If there's any questions we're here to answer those.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:04:57

Further questions from the Board? Supervisor Hartman

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:05:01

Are we at risk of debris flows? I mean, I think the rule of thumb is five years for the watershed to heal and then it's less likely. But could you comment on that?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed1:05:12

So I'll make a supervisor through the chair, I'll make an initial comment and then I don't know if Walter wants to add to that. National Weather Service is officially not monitoring any areas in our county anymore so we are past any official monitoring areas associated with fire burn scars. So we do the Cave Fire, Alice Hall, the Montecito area all of those are out of any official monitoring. Now anytime we end up with significant ongoing concepts of saturation then some of those conditions change and some of those recommendations might change.

1:05 – 1:1315 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:05:55

Supervisor Caps?

ElectedLaura CappsSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:05:57

Thank you, Director Hubbard and everyone. You certainly have given us a challenge with that 14% signups to ReadySBC. I'm actually astounded that it's that low so we've got our work cut out for us to get everybody signed up especially at all that we've been through as a community I will do my best. But, I wanted to ask for me growing up here El Nino signified like was meant before when I was a kid scary hot winds can you speak about the dry what could happen and how we should be preparing for a dry El Nino with debris and fire potential etc?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed1:06:36

Supervisor through the chair, I not having the background fully in weather and some of our National Weather Service partners. We did ask some questions around the expectations of storms and whether they would be warm or cold so with those storms there is the expectation of higher winds Warmer storms you're so higher snow level not necessarily having that snow level on the 154 like we did this past year But we did not I did not specifically ask questions to the impacts if it was dry So I'd have to get back to you with additional considerations on that

ElectedLaura CappsSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:07:14

Thank you, and I fully understand that our concern as of late for sure has been wet and flooding and our basins and all that. So I understand that but I imagine it's similar to just fire preparation in general with branches etc., but something to be on the lookout for. Thank you

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:07:36

I don't know whether this year was categorized as a dry or wet El Nino, but we had an El Nino a few years back in which we had almost no rain because the storm systems were farther out to sea. We definitely had waves, but we didn't have a whole lot of rain. Is that what you would call a dry El Nino?

CommentWalter RubicabaProposedself-stated1:08:04

Supervisor Williams, the flood control district doesn't really focus on El Nino years and non-El Nino years. We just approach it every year as if it's going to be the worst storm we've ever seen and we do that just so we stay vigilant. This last storm season had more rain than what we had expected but again we were prepared to deal with that.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:08:28

Makes perfect sense okay can I get a motion?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:08:33

Sorry I thought

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:08:34

no supervisor.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:08:36

No I was waiting for public comment.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:08:38

Is there a public comment?

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role1:08:39

Chair Williams and members of the board we have no request to speak

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:08:42

All right. Can I have a couple quick comments, I think? So

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:08:49

I appreciate your honesty. I have questions that are really common.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:08:52

Yeah. You know, a couple of things I just want to get out there is getting back to the Santa Maria River and the work that's being done out there. I just really want to echo the appreciation for the city of Guadalupe and the farmers as well as our county staff public works staff after it. I mean it's a Herculean effort. We're even getting compliments from George Alvarez which means we're doing something right, I guess? That's pretty high bar so I really just want to thank everybody that's been involved in that project and continues to the contractors R.W. Scott and Vince Lopez & Sons and so I can't let this item go by without thanking all of them for their work On the Twitchell issue, you know that's in my district now Post redistricting and I've got a chance to really dig in deep and it's something that I'm really looking forward to Getting after.

You know, I think the public needs understand that some of the damage that was done in Guadalupe was because of those releases which was part of a Rule that was set up in the 50s when the Twitchell was originally built that has not been updated to reflect current meteorological Standards or technology. And so those releases are happening to the detriment of downstream properties and specifically that ultimately in fact impacted the Guadalupe Eastern or sorry, the Western Santa Maria Valley. So that's a really important thing for us as well as the ground groundwater recharge. So Twitchell is releasing water right now And all that water actually stops and goes underground and begins to recharge our groundwater basin about Benita School Road.

For perspective for everybody, we released over 70,000 acre feet of water from Twitchell that could have been held back to be released at this time of year so that we could get additional recharge. And again, to put that perspective when we talk about the state water project We had gotten 100% delivery of water to our county that only been 45,000 acre feet. I think we've got about 10%, so that's 140 times amount of state delivery that we could have held back for recharge the Santa Maria Valley which is as we know is by 80% of our groundwater or water supply for counties so it is you know the most acute need obviously is dealing with I just wanted to make sure that the public understands that's what we're after. I know Supervisor Lavagnino, myself and Public Works staff will be making some additional logging efforts to get that done.

And the last maybe comment is I am concerned about the ombudsman. I know that planning and development, you know, thank you guys for taking it on but I know there's a lot of other challenges in your department and That concerns me, to be honest. I know that staffing issues in long range and building and other places continue to be a challenge so I know that you guys don't say no when you're asked but I just want maybe for the CEO's office making sure that is fully staffed in a way that can get accomplished You know, I would absolutely love planning to have that in the future but I just don't know if it's the right time. That's why I wanted to make sure I put that out there because getting these dollars deployed this year is really important and Lisa and her team have a lot on their plate right now so I'm just alerting that as a concern of at least one supervisor to you making sure that's operationalized in the future.

I think it's a good idea And I'd like to see it piloted this year and maybe be considered in the future for ongoing funding, especially as Mr. Rubicola talks about that we have to prepare every year like it's going to potentially be the worst year. We have storms like we did last year and not El Nino years. And we have impacts of wildfires like we did with the Thomas fire debris flow. So I think we always have to be vigilant in Santa Barbara County and having a mechanism to help private property owners Navigate the regulatory hurdles that are out there is really important to what we do here in the county. So much of our property is privately owned, especially in some of these waterways it's necessary that us the experts and a lot of this and have the relationship with these agencies are able to help the general public navigate that so I'm big fan of that.

I want to thank Supervisor Hartman for highlighting that last year because I think it's good use of our resources. Thank you.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:13 – 1:286 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:13:17

Okay seeing no public comment and no lights on, can we get a motion?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:13:25

Motion to resume file.

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:13:27

Second.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:13:28

All those in favor please say aye. Aye. Opposed? Thank you. D2

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role1:13:44

Chair Williams and members of the board, departmental item number two is from the Public Works Department Board of Directors Water Agency. It is a hearing to consider recommendations regarding the Santa Barbara County water resources update 2023 groundwater basin summary.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:14:03

Chair Williams, members of the board, Happy New Year! October 1st was the start of a new state and federal water year. This presentation is an annual update on the state of water supplies countywide, an overview of what the County Water Agency and its partner agencies are doing to ensure reliable sustainable supplies into the future. I think you already had a little bit of a preview of some of the things we'll talk about here from that last item but we'll try not to be too redundant Water year 2023 was the wettest in the last 25 years since the record-setting 1998.

Our climate in Santa Barbara County and California more generally have extremely high interannual variability. We can have wet years with more than double the average precipitation like last year, and dry years with a third of the average. We also have persistent trends that can last a decade. For example, the 1990s were quite wetter than average and the 2010's significantly drier.

Here's a longer look at the data going back 100 years. The black line shows a moving 10-year average of annual precipitation at Gibraltar Dam in the middle of the county. You can see we were recently at the lowest ten year average in recorded history. This chart further shows the interannual variability with multi-year trends of low and high precipitation as you see the black line moving up and down for significant periods of time.

Under a warming climate, current science predicts that this variability will be exacerbated with more precipitation falling in fewer years with longer dry spells in between. I want to touch briefly on precipitation forecasts for this winter and Chair Williams this might be relevant to your question from the last item. You've probably heard news reports that this winter will be a strong El Nino. A common misperception is that every strong El Nino results in a higher than average precipitation year.

It's true that many of our wettest years, such as 1983 and 1998 have been strong El Ninos indicated by the dark red bars on the graph. However, some strong El Nino years have been significantly drier than normal such as 1988 and 2016. This last year actually had weak La Nina conditions we had an extremely wet year as previously mentioned in the Water Resources Division both at the Water Agency and Flood Control we plan every year as if it may be an extremely wet year or the start of an extended drought Over the next few slides, I'd like to discuss the impact of this last wet year on the various parts of the overall water portfolio in the county.

This graph shows water supplies used by public water systems within the county over time. As a whole, the county relies most on groundwater which is blue, Lake Kachuma in orange and state water in gray which is imported from Northern California. However, the specific mix varies widely over time depending on climatic conditions and available supplies. So while we're evaluating overall county water, excuse me, depending on climatic conditions please note that this chart does not include groundwater used by agriculture, mutual water companies, small water systems and domestic wells. Groundwater is roughly 80% of the total water used countywide if you include not just public systems.

Most residents in the county are served by one of a network of purveyors shown on this map, each of which has invested in its own unique portfolio of water supplies. So while we're evaluating overall county water supplies, the particular supply situation of a given resident depends on where they live and if it's specific water portfolio held by their purveyor.

Now we'll walk through the status of each of the major sources of supply. Groundwater is the largest source in the county, currently making up roughly 80% of its supplies. It's relied on most heavily by North County purveyors, agriculture, small water systems and domestic well owners. Groundwater is typically a smaller portion of the portfolios of South County purveyor with some exceptions.

The Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, or SGMA, has started to take effect and groundwater sustainability agencies are slowly beginning to manage groundwater in their basins. Included in the board package for this item is our annual Groundwater Basin Summary Report which details overall water level status for the major alluvial basins in the county. In the recent drought, some portions of most basins in the county were at or near historical low levels. This last wet winter has started the process of recharging most of these basins especially in the portions near rivers and streams. However, in most cases it takes multiple years of above average rainfall to bring water levels up significantly This map shows the major alluvial groundwater basins in the county.

Kiyama has submitted a Groundwater Sustainability Plan, or GSP, that was ultimately approved by the Department of Water Resources, or DWR. The Kiyama GSA has begun implementing the GSP, including the first phase of a series of pumping reductions in the central portion of the basin. Major pumpers in the valley have initiated an adjudication process which will proceed in parallel with the GSP implementation, but does not remove the need for the GSA to continue to manage the basin.

GSAs in the San Antonio Creek and Santa Nez River Valleys basins have submitted plans in January 2022 and DWR is required to provide a review by this upcoming January. Montecito submitted a GSP in May of this year and Carpinteria will soon be submitting their own. The Santa Maria and Goleta basins have been adjudicated and are not subject to SGMA. The next major water supply is surface water from the San Ines River. There are three major reservoirs, Kachuma, Gibraltar, and Jameson. We'll focus today on the largest of these, Kachuma.

Kachuma is currently 93% full. Originally built in 1954 by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, storage has decreased over time to the current 192,978 acre feet. The annual yield has decreased over time as well due to sedimentation and federal biological opinions mandating fish flow releases. It's important to note that unlike many other reservoirs in California, Kachuma has no space dedicated to flood control.

However, a protocol called Modified Storm Operations allows Reclamation and County Flood Control to flexibly manage storage in the reservoir to allow for some downstream protection while still maximizing water supply benefits. We anticipate that the modified storm ops will be implemented this winter as well due to the high starting water levels of the lake.

As the contractor with the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, the Water Agency just last week executed a three-year contract extension to provide water from the lake to five member units. Once some fisheries issues are resolved through a new federal biological opinion we will be negotiating a new long term water supply contract. For a little bit of context, here's the historical record of Kachuma storage. Since it last spilled in 2011, Kachuma was in a period of extremely low storage with a brief respite coming from wet years and water years 2017 and 2019. Of course this last winter filled the lake to capacity and Kachuma was in a state of spill from the end of January through the end of June.

This allowed surplus water to be made available at no cost to the five member units. And one of the member units, Goleta Water District was able to inject 814 acre feet into their groundwater basin to replenish their supplies of that free surplus water. Twitchell Reservoir on the Cuyama River in North County is another Bureau of Reclamation reservoir. It stores Cuyama River floodwaters for release to recharge the Santa Maria Groundwater Basin and is operated by the Santa Maria Valley Water Conservation District. There's no direct use of this water.

Unlike Kachuma, roughly half the reservoir space is reserved for flood control storage with releases overseen by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The Water Agency is working with the Army Corps Bureau of Reclamation and local partners on exploring ways to modify the water control manual governing flood releases to both enhance water conservation and better manage flood releases.

Twitchell is currently releasing stored water from last winter to recharge the groundwater basin and should be mostly empty by the time significant inflows begin this winter. This graph shows how Twitchell fills up sporadically, then lies empty until the next wet year. The next major source of supply is imported water from the State Water Project. Water is brought in from Northern California via the coastal branch aqueduct and supplies several purveyors in North County before terminating in Lake Kachuma for conveyance to the South Coast.

Bringing in more than 45,000 acre feet of state water to the county was approved by the voters in 1991. However this is a variable amount and in recent years allocations have ranged from as low as 5% up to 100% just this year. The state water system in our county is operated by the Central Coast Water Authority although the County Flood Control and Water Conservation District remains the contractor.

State water was a valuable supplement during the 2011-2018 drought with some purveyors nearly entirely reliant upon it. Desalination is a growing part of the overall portfolio. The only major desal plant in the county is currently the City of Santa Barbara's, which originally opened in 1991 was subsequently decommissioned during the very wet 1990s then reactivated in 2016.

This is a local drought-resistant supply of 3,125 acre feet per year. It also has regional benefits beyond the city with an agreement last year or several years ago to provide about 1,400 acre feet per year to Montecito over a 50-year period The plan is permitted to produce up to 10,000 acre feet per year so it could be significantly expanded as needed in the future. The Water Agency is working with San Luis Obispo County on exploring options for a regional plant that could provide water for both counties and Vandenberg is continuing to evaluate desalination options on the base.

Another local drought resistant supply is recycled water. Currently, local purveyors produce recycled water for direct non-potable reuse primarily for landscaping. Indirect potable reuse is where wastewater is treated and injected into a groundwater basin for future use. Carbonary Valley Water District's Advanced Purification Project is intended to serve this purpose.

Finally, direct potable reuse is where treated wastewater is delivered directly to customers. The Water Agency recently partnered with Laguna Sanitation District to study the potential for indirect potable reuse from this county facility. The report, released in August, identified two very promising potential options for injecting treated wastewater into the groundwater basin.

A follow-on study and legal analysis are currently in process. We also partnered with all of the wastewater treatment agencies in the county to do a countywide indirect potable reuse evaluation. That report is expected to be finalized later this fall, it will include a high level overview of all the agencies county wide as well as a deeper dive onto three different agencies that volunteered and requested that we do so including the cities of Solvang and Buelton and Summerland Sanitary District.

So that's a summary of where we are. I'd like to briefly talk about the Water Agency's role in managing supplies and responding to drought. Our primary role is partnership and collaboration. In everything we do, we're partnering with other agencies in trying to maintain a regional countywide perspective. We coordinate regional programs such as the Integrated Regional Water Management Planning Program, the Regional Water Efficiency Partnership, and Sustainable Groundwater Management.

We have a long-standing existing program with nine other agencies for precipitation enhancement, commonly known as cloud seeding in the Kachuma and Twitchell areas. Finally through our work with GSAs in doing stormwater planning we are working to facilitate projects to recharge groundwater with urban storm water and flood flows. We also participate in a countywide drought task force with Environmental Health and the Office of Emergency Management.

I just want to highlight quickly our Regional Water Efficiency Program, which is our water conservation program. We coordinate this program with 15 water purveyors in the county. Our web helps ensure consistent conservation messaging, provides public reference information, educates landscape professionals, works with local schools and conducts water audits for the green business program. All this helps to contribute to sustainable water use when the supplies are limited.

The Water Agency also funds a mobile irrigation lab in partnership with the Kachuma Resource Conservation District that assists agriculture and large landscapes with water efficiency projects. I'd like to highlight a grant that our conservation staff pursued and won in partnership with several local purveyors. They won a $500,000 Bureau of Reclamation Landscape Rebate Grant which will rebate homeowners who replace the lawn with water-wise landscaping.

While the Water Agency is the grantee, programs will be implemented by each purveyor to their specific customers. With all of the work put into conservation messaging, we are glad to report that countywide residential water use is roughly 25% lower than it was 10 years ago prior to the start of the drought. The solid lines on this chart show Santa Barbara County conservation versus statewide conservation in the dashed lines. These data are collected by the State Water Resources Control Board and show the significant progress that county residents have made to reducing their reliance on our supplies.

With that, staff recommends that your board receive and file both this report and the Groundwater Basin Summary Report and determine if these actions are exempt from CEQA. Thank you very much.

1:28 – 1:338 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:28:39

We have some questions and comments. Supervisor Nelson?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:28:43

Yes, thank you Chair Williams. Thank you Mr. Young for your presentation. I'm really interested in some of the water efficiency programs that your agency is going to be championing. You talked about this project where there will be reimbursement or grants to homeowners. Can you go a little further on that? I think it's something the public would be interested with.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:29:02

Yeah, absolutely. So in partnership with a number of the water purveyors who were interested in accounting we pursued a Water Smart grant from the Bureau of Reclamation and so what will happen is each city or water district will implement it slightly differently they'll develop their own parameters for what a water efficient landscape looks like But in general, residents who are looking to replace their lawns and reduce their water bills will be able to get a portion of that project refunded by their city or water district. So the city or water district will set up the program then they will submit invoices to the county. The county will submit invoices to the bureau and then everything will get paid for. So typically reimbursement rates range from 25% to 50%, depending on the type of project and how it's set up by the particular city or water district.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:29:49

That's great. Thank you for that. I'm also curious about other bigger projects, you know we were exploring I know with the Parks Department some of our play fields soccer fields baseball fields about converting those from current uses of natural grass to maybe artificial grass are there other grant programs out there? Are there other ways that we can incentivize for our own organization to move in that direction or other municipalities That my own fields that they want to go ahead and make those conversions to

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:30:24

Yeah Supervisor Nelson through the chair You may recall that several years ago We brought to your board the countywide integrated stormwater resources plan And that was a plan that was mandated by the State Water Resources Control Board in order to be eligible for Prop one grant funding for stormwater projects, and these are the types of projects where you take urban runoff and And you might take a park or soccer field and find a way to store flood stormwater flows on that field during the winter, let them percolate into the groundwater basin.

And then it dries out and you have a nice park later. So, a number of projects were identified throughout the county through that program. And my understanding is that one or two of those have begun going forward, but implementation has been very slow. So we continue to have discussions with our partners to find ways to incentivize those programs. I know Supervisor Hartman is very interested in this. She's been talking about ways that we can find as the water agency to help incentivize these programs. So it's certainly something we'll be looking forward to doing more of in the future.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:31:26

Great, I wanted to throw out there for you that the 4th District is also very interested in some of those projects. Let's dust that off for our office and take a look at what some of the opportunities that might be for my constituents. The other about the recycled water projects I know we're moving forward maybe with Laguna Sanitation exploring that can you go in a little bit more depth about what that might look like for providing additional water supply in the Santa Maria Valley?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:31:52

Absolutely Supervisor Harmon, Supervisor Nelson through the chair. So, our consultant Corolla engineers identified two potential projects for Laguna Sanitation District one is a smaller quicker cheaper half million gallon per day project and another would be a much more expensive more involved but 1.7 million gallon per day project that water would be treated to a very very high standard potable drinking water standard That injected into the groundwater basin, and then pulled back out. Typically there's a state requirement that it's in the groundwater basin for 60 days before you pull it out at a minimum, and they could be then served as a potable drinking water supply.

So, in addition to further engineering studies as you know the Santa Maria Groundwater Basin is adjudicated so there will be some legal issues in figuring out how to store that water and be able to purvey it. The County Water Agency is working with county council and the Laguna Sanitation District to explore what those legal avenues are going to be in order to be able to purvey that water

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:33:03

That's really exciting for the Santa Maria Valley. For so long we only had two options, State Water Project which is owned and operated by the Central Coast Water Agency and Groundwater. I just think it's really important for our board to prioritize other options and get them legally recognized whether that's recycled options like this or potable direct Potable Yes, yes or recycled options or conservation options. I think those are all things that we should explore to not only You know satisfy the needs of growth in our community but also create some independence and opportunities for Some of our constituents so thank you for other work you're doing there

1:33 – 1:387 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:33:47

Supervisor Harp

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:33:48

Thank you. A couple of points. Has the state rules on direct potable reuse gone final yet?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:33:56

Supervisor Hartman through the chair. Yes, they recently did come out and they are fairly strenuous and so direct potable reuse projects will be quite expensive it's something that we looked at in this indirect reuse evaluation countywide that will be coming out later this month because we wanted to make sure hey you know it doesn't make more sense to do direct potable versus indirect potable and because of the way the requirements are written And rightly so, we're taking treated wastewater and serving it as drinking water. They're very strenuous and so those projects are going to be extremely expensive. And so in most cases at least in our county we're looking primarily at indirect versus direct.

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:34:39

And when that study is finished for Solvang, Buellton & Summerlin will you bring that back to the board? I would hope to see it maybe even as a D item if that's possible.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:34:49

Certainly the Water Agency would be happy to bring that back to the Board.

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:34:53

And then we'd like to talk a little bit more about stormwater capture. You know, earlier in the previous presentation we were talking about flood control and much of our system for water has been designed to shunt water often polluted to the ocean as quickly as possible so we've designed a whole infrastructure to do just that And now we recognize that it's an invaluable resource and so how do we redesign to capture the stormwater, to slow the flows, to get more infiltration into the groundwater basins.

Our county has done a really good study but talking to Matt just before this it doesn't pencil out if you're looking at just one benefit for recharge But if we can get triple bottom line where it's cleaning water, it's recharging water and perhaps it's for athletic fields or swales or some other benefit maybe we can have a plan that we actually implement. And so I was delighted to hear that Supervisor Nelson is keenly interested in this because I'd like to bring that study back I know we've been working on the housing element. We're working on a recreation master plan, but we tend to be looking at those in different silos and what are our highest value recharge areas and how do we protect those? How do we enhance their capacity for recharge?

And so that's the question I have and I'd really like To be able to take that study further because whether it's a wet or dry year, we know over time we're going to have more dry years and we want to recapture this water. So that might be some direction we could offer. One final point I'd like to make and that is That Matt has been the leader in the general the groundwater sustainability agencies. That's really been a pioneering and very sensitive delicate Negotiation wherever people are talking about water groundwater rights, and what's groundwater? What's surface water?

And you've just done it masterfully and we're all appreciative of that So thank you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:37:18

Can I piggyback? Sure. Sorry, I just wanted to go about the stormwater recharge you know talking about the Santa Maria Valley it wasn't only Twitchell that where there's a lot of lost opportunity we have something called Guadalupe Lake which is actually a water area that brings water through you know orchid area that comes into some agricultural areas and with Santa Maria by Tanglewood And eventually goes out Solomon Creek, which connects to the Santa Maria River right about the entrance to the Guadalupe Dunes. And so that's another opportunity there where that water instead of going out to the Pacific Ocean should be we should be exploring some areas for that to get back into our groundwater system. I know there's a clay lens there in that area and that's why it doesn't percolate and so we need to find a way to get it out to some of the sandy soils so that we can get it back into our system.

So I know that you met with some of the farmers in my area to look at that during the stormy times. But we may not see rains like this for another decade, but the planning starts today, right? So we need to have that forethought because when those times come, you always wish that somebody would have thought about this in the past. But you know obviously we talked about conservation and desalinization, other priorities. And during the droughts but as soon as the rains comes at the end of the political will starts to erode, pun intended. And so I think it's time for us to make sure that we stay vigilant on this so that we can put the infrastructure in place to have a sustainable community moving forward.

1:38 – 1:4510 turns

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:38:53

Supervisor Capston, we do have one public comment.

ElectedLaura CappsSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:38:55

Yeah, thank you to my colleagues and thank you. I just wanted to double down on this recharge That's the you made the point in questions that I was going to To bring up as well And I have two directly because I know we all felt with these storms in January and February at this like this feeling of like how you know How are we capturing this? And there was quite a bit in the press about different communities, different counties. I believe LA County and also Inland was rethinking their levy system etc. So I'm just very interested in how it does pencil out and I just want to understand if there's a study that's coming back or there's a study that was produced? Help me out there.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:39:34

Supervisor Capps for the Chair, there are two studies that we've been referencing. The first is the 2021 Santa Barbara County-wide integrated stormwater resources plan. That one is done and it identifies a number of the best areas in the county to do storm water projects where you're taking urban primarily urban runoff capturing it and finding ways to infiltrate it to a groundwater basin.

The study that Supervisor Hartman asked to come back is a countywide indirect potable reuse study that should be completed this month. It's looking at taking treated wastewater and finding ways to put that in the groundwater basins.

ElectedLaura CappsSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:40:10

Right, there was sort of a lively meeting last fall I believe on that topic. So that's, that report is forthcoming I understand.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:40:19

That's correct.

ElectedLaura CappsSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:40:20

And I just want to appreciate this your work because it's you have a big job and this kind of all of the above approach when it comes to water and we can see it here with this presentation I just want to say thanks.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:40:35

Let's go to public comment.

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role1:40:38

Chair Williams and members of the board we have one request to speak. We'll move to Roberta Jefe via Zoom

CommentRoberta Jaffe I'mProposedself-stated1:40:48

Good morning. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Thanks. Good morning my name is Roberta Jaffe I'm a farmer and resident in the Cuyama Valley and so have been really involved with our GSA. I've been a standing advisory committee member since the inception of that committee. So I've had the opportunity to work with Matt Young and Water Agency, and I want to both express a lot of gratitude on behalf of the Cuyama Valley, our residents for first of all for the current report which summarizes very complicated situations I think in a very both efficient and clear transparent way I remember when the Board of Supervisors approved the joint powers, the JPA setting up the Cuyama GSA. I think it was seven to eight years ago and I remember my public comment at that time was asking the board to be very aware that you are the direct we have no local representation in the Cuyama Valley that you would be our representatives in the GSA process and really asked you to take that into consideration.

And I'm really happy and pleased to be able to say seven to eight years later, I really feel that you have represented us very well thanks to both Supervisor Williams and Loving New Year's offices and their commitment. And a special thanks to Matt Young and the CWA team who've had ongoing participation In all of the everything from tech advisory meetings to helping educate me and others on.

on the Standing Advisory Committee as to what a hydrograph was, to start off with. And now I feel like I'm almost able to get a degree in hydrogeology so and a lot of that is thanks to the work of your team. I really appreciate that. I do have one question and I'm just wondering if there are any plans to update Santa Barbara County's Environmental threshold for groundwater. The last time it was updated was 1992, so over 30 years ago and it's very outdated.

And, you know, Cuyama Basin for example has a lot of current data that would be available I assume for revision to this threshold. And since this is such an important threshold and used in consideration of new projects, I hope that it can somehow get on a priority list. Thank you very much and thanks for your continued work with the Cuyama Basin.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:43:47

Mr. Young, did you want to say anything about that? And I also want to thank the active members of the Koyama community and it should note that my understanding is A wet year last year really did nothing to change the basic problem we have out there. It was a little blip on the radar screen, if anything and that with residents are increasingly feeling Pressure before they were feeling the pressure of possibly losing water sources and now they're feeling the pressure of having to retain attorneys because of the adjudication initiated by Bolthouse and Grimway. And you should all know that the residents have called for a carrot boycott because really The amount that residents have to be able to stand up for themselves in this fight.

They feel like it's a David versus Goliath struggle, and they increasingly feel like That we're just at the beginning of an adjudication that will cost each residence tens of thousands of dollars to represent themselves legally. And so this is a hot topic, especially in the Kiyama Valley and because there's only hundreds of residents as opposed to thousands of residents in the township.

They have called upon people outside of Cuyama, Santa Barbara and the rest of the state to join them in their efforts. Mr Young?

not transcribed≈6s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:45 – 1:4910 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:45:49

Mr. Chair, so Ms. Jaffee referenced the groundwater threshold in the county's CEQA Thresholds Manual. That document is maintained by planning and I see Ms. Plowman has made her way into the room, so she may have a comment also. But the County Water Agency, I think, has provided technical support in the past as some of these Thresholds were updated and so we would be happy to do so in the future on county planning's Timeline as they make their way through various revisions in that document

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed1:46:25

Mr. Chair members of the board, so we're well aware of the Need to update some of those thresholds in our document and is something that we are looking at adding into our work program But they are outdated And we'll work with the water agency to do that.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:46:44

Supervisor Nelson.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:46:45

Yes, I think as we look at the thresholds, I mean there's some there's a changing legal landscape right? So those thresholds were put in place prior to adjudications and other and GSA's and I think that that's probably should be considered whether we need to be duplicative there You know, I think some of those things the idea behind it an adjudication Or the GSA's are a management Strategy that's more holistic That still recognizes property rights, but also at the same time the scarcity issue. So I think it's not one size that fits all which is the unfortunate part that public sometimes has a hard time understanding as what might be significant in one area may be insignificant in another and trying to make that work in a county as diverse as ours is always going to challenge so if we do go down that route I just want to make sure that we're taking consideration that we're not creating additional layers of of governance that are unnecessary or being taken care of by some other legal mechanism.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed1:47:45

Supervisor Nelson through the chair, it's a very good point how different the landscape is since the time we drafted those and so we will definitely need to be considering the GSAs and the management plans that are coming out of that and how they're going to work with our thresholds so that we can actually do the CEQA analysis that's required of us. So yes, we will be doing that.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:48:12

Okay, no more public comment. Lights are off. Is there-

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:48:19

I'd like to make a motion.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:48:22

Supervisor Hartman?

ElectedJoan HartmannSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.851:48:23

So I would move A through C, including direction to return with an indirect potable reuse study when that's done as a D item and return with the stormwater capture study for a refresher and with options that we can invest in for capture.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:48:47

I'll second and also just thank you for your efforts, continued funds for conservation. That's a great victory. There's still a lot of wasted water out there. Just sometimes ones that are harder than water leaking down the street. Grass types that use more water than other grass types throughout different landscaping choices. Options for areas have smaller grass footprints or no grass footprints and convert to other landscaping uses so highly encourage the work and hope that some of the success that has been seen in some agencies doing this can be spread throughout the county.

All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Opposed? It's unanimous. D3.

1:49 – 1:5316 turns

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role1:49:52

Chair Williams and members of the board, departmental item number three is from the planning and development department. It is a hearing to consider recommendations regarding an appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of their revision to permit condition number 38 MM Bio 16 Golden Eagle Permit Take. Take permit for Straus wind energy project case number 23 RVP 31. This project is located within the third and fourth districts as I previously announced, I would like to note for the record that we have received a request from the department to withdraw this item from today's agenda and approve their revised recommended actions to accept the withdrawal.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:50:29

I understand we need to take public comment on the withdrawal. Is there any public comment?

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role1:50:35

Chair Williams and members of the board, we do have one request to speak. We'll move to Gordon MacDonald via Zoom.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:50:48

Mr. McDonald?

UnidentifiedClerk of the BoardProposed · by role1:50:53

Gordon can you hear us? You've been unmuted on our end if you can try to unmute yourself on your end as well.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:51:15

Hello, can you hear me?

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:51:17

Yes we

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:51:18

can. Apologies I was speaking away there. I was just going to correct the record and advise that it's actually Gordon McDougall. I'm the CEO of BiVA. I didn't have any particular comment to say, but just wanted to thank the planning department and everybody involved for their patience with us with this and thank them for their efforts. And just make it clear that we obviously will be meeting all the obligations required of us.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:51:50

Thank you Mr McDougall.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:51:53

Yeah I'm just curious while Mr. McDougall is on the line, when will those start moving now that you guys have satisfied or at least have a solution to this

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:52:01

condition? We have a couple of minor things to get sorted and then we go into sort of live commissioning hopefully as early as this weekend and once we've sufficiently tested and commissioned everything we hope to be up and running during this month in full operation Thank you.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:52:24

Since you are not here in person I'll just tell you that everyone's eyes went up and you filled the room with some optimism.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:52:34

Well, I thank everybody for their support. I recognize it's been a long path getting there and we've got a number of things still to do but we were very keen to make sure that we are delivering our wind farm which the whole county of Santa Barbara can be proud of

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:52:55

And is there we need to take a vote on the withdrawal. Can I get a motion on the withdrawal.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:53:02

So moved second

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:53:04

all those in favor please say aye. Aye. Opposed. And I also want to thank staff for all their work on this and its previous approvals. Thank you We are going to recess to closed session. Can we have a preview of closed session?

1:53 – 2:244 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed1:53:28

Thank you Mr. Chair, members of the board. The board has one item for closed session it's existing litigation and it's the Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors sitting as the Board of Supervisors and also sitting as the Board of Directors for Santa Barbara County Flood Control and Water Conservation District. The case is City of Goleta versus Southern California Gas Company and the time estimate is 15 minutes

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:53:55

I'll give us a little more time than that. I know I'm normally so the half return in half an hour Oh 20

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:54:05

minutes

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.971:54:06

about 20 minutes We're reconvening from closed session. Can we have a report from closed session?

2:24 – 2:242 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed2:24:12

Thank you Mr. Chair, members of the board. The board met in closed session on one item of existing litigation City of Goleta versus Southern California Gas Company and the board took no reportable action.

ElectedBob NelsonSupervisorProposedvoiceprint 0.972:24:24

We are adjourned to Tuesday October 10th in Santa Maria