BodyCity Council
MeetingRegular Meeting
Date📅 January 28, 2026

UnGovr Transcript

iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.
  1. PendingQueued for transcription.
  2. AIYou are hereAuto-transcribed and summarized; not yet human-verified.
  3. VerifiedReviewed and corrected by a person.

0:01 – 0:022 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:34

We will call this special meeting of the January 28th, 2026 City Council to order. Let the record reflect that all council members that were present earlier except for Council Member Tremblay are here and we have a closed session item. Madam City Attorney?

UnidentifiedCity ClerkProposed · by role1:54

Yes, thank you Mayor and Council. We have one item on the agenda pursuant to government code section 54956.9 D1 and it's the OPV coalition matter versus Fox Canyon and if there's any reportable action I can make that report.

Pledge of Allegiance — led by Santangeloceremonial · click to expand · ≈85s recited, not transcribed
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:11

Thank you very much we will recess until 5 p.m. to close session

0:31 – 0:376 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed31:27

Good evening. I'd like to call to order the regular meeting of the Camarillo City Council, the Camarillo Sanitation District, the CLB, the SA, the IDA, the EPFA and the CCIC for January 28th, 2026. I'm going to ask council member Santangelo to lead us in the pledge.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed31:49

Please stand. Hand over heart. Ready? Begin.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed32:13

Thank you, Susan. Are there any changes to the agenda? I'd like to also comment that all of the members of the council are present except for Mr. Tremblay who is on his way here from another meeting. At this time we will make a presentation to Ventura County Food Share but i'm going to read it from the dais and then invite you up here Last October, the City Council approved a $70,000 allocation to Food Sheriff Ventura County specifically for food assistance to Camarillo residents, CSU Channel Island students, Somos Ranch residents with no distinction made in terms of immigration status.

The City of Camarillo prioritizes collaboration with trusted community partners that deliver measurable local impact. FoodShare of Ventura County is one such partner, with strong connections to local agencies, grocery stores, volunteers and food pantries serving the city of Camarillo and its surrounding areas. Ventura County FoodShare serves more than 250,000 residents each year It works to support approximately 7,800 residents through 13 local pantries here in Camarillo.

Providing food assistance and it reaches people efficiently and with dignity. Food Shares coordinated approach allows resources to be used responsibly and kept focused on local needs. This partnership was demonstrated during the emergency food collection at City Hall this past December When community donations were quickly delivered to residents who needed them most.

On behalf of the City of Camarillo and the entire Council, we would like to thank Food Chair Ventura County for your continued work in supporting our residents and strengthening our community. Now if you'd be so kind as to meet me up here I'd appreciate that. I'm sure Jennifer will have something to say. Can you hear me now? Once again, thank you FoodShare for everything you do not just in Camarillo and the surrounding area but throughout the entire county.

I would urge anyone that has not visited FoodShares facilities to set up a tour it's amazing the number of volunteers they have and the tons of food that get processed probably almost daily so thank you very much and on behalf of the city I know you already got the real check but we'd like to have you Get the fake check, so. Monica, I'll let you have the first question. Oh, I was going to let Jennifer do

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed35:40

it. Thank you Mayor Tennyson this is absolutely incredible council. I just absolutely adore you as a resident of the City of Camarillo this is extra meaningful. As Mayor Tennyson mentioned FoodShare feeds 250,000 Ventura County residents on an annual basis just under 8 000 of those here in the city of Camarillo so this is really meaningful to those residents that we're serving right here in our local community And FoodShare can take the dollar that much further. So for every dollar donated to FoodShare, we can buy $5 worth of food. So this is a significant investment in making sure that Ventura County and the city of Camarillo is fed all year round. On behalf of my CEO, my COO, our board of directors just a huge thank you to the city for making this happen.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed36:24

Thank you any council member comments? Vice Mayor.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed36:31

Just a super big thank you. I know how hard you work and especially executive directors, so much work happening behind the scenes all of staff and i've had the opportunity to tour motivating so many volunteers it's amazing just the entire project and the love that goes into doing everything so on behalf of the city we're just I mean I know when when we had that motion come to the city and we expanded the funding that went from 50 to 70, and expanded the service not only to Camarillo but to the residents impacted by immigration enforcement.

Expanding that to Somos Ranch farm workers and to the CSUCI students just I think it was the right move so thank you for providing and doing that hard work really appreciate it.

0:37 – 0:446 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed37:25

I'm just gonna add on Councilmember Tremblay is not here but he would say ditto.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed37:35

Ditto. I want to thank all of your efforts and everybody out here that makes it happen, you know we all know food insecurity is a major issue and it affects all of us in a lot of different ways here so You're one organization that's doing more than your part, if not totally your part in trying to alleviate some of that. And I can reasonably with certainty say that all of the residents in Camarillo are very supportive of what you do and you will continue to do that so I'm really happy we could do a little small part with us and try to make The job tiny, tiny bit easier but keep up the good work. It really it doesn't go unnoticed and is very much needed.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed38:54

Okay, I'm going to exercise the mayor's prerogative and take something out of order. Vice Mayor Martinez Bravo has a request to adjourn in the memory of a local resident so if you want to start Martita.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed39:09

Thank You mayor Yes, we typically do this at the end of a meeting but what I am requesting is to adjourn in honor of Hayden Fisher Miller and we're going to learn more about who he was. And Mr David Tennyson actually also served in the military as did Hayden and Hayden's family is actually here today and we wanted to honor him today in this way. So David, if you can begin speaking about him and then I will follow.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed39:56

that voluntarily put on the uniform of the United States Armed Forces. We have had an all-volunteer force since the early 70s, so that means every young man and every young woman or even some old ones with gray hair that you see wearing a uniform volunteered to put themselves in harm way for all of us. So tremendous respect to the family, tremendous respect to Hayden for his volunteerism by joining the military Hayden is the beloved and beautiful son of Calvin and Laura Racey Miller. He grew up in Camarillo.

He ended up hiking with friends, made films, traveled to Ecuador, the Galapagos, Thailand, Vietnam, Europe. on end yearly trips to Big Bear. He was offered several scholarships and decided to attend Indiana University earned a degree in criminal justice before he joined, and again I say joined not conscripted but joined the United States Army After boot camp, he completed Officer Candidate School then Infantry School at Fort Moore, Georgia becoming a First Lieutenant. He went on to Ranger School and earned the esteemed and coveted Ranger Tab.

During this time he forged a lasting friendship and bond with fellow officer Tom Hurst. They served together at Fort Bragg, Fort Moore and later at Fort Bliss, Texas. Hayden became a platoon leader and also worked logistics.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed41:31

After completing his Army service, Hayden made the brave choice to support the people of Ukraine in their fight against aggression. On October 9th he gave his life in that service. Hayden was a beautiful soul level-headed, kind, generous and funny. He loved his family deeply. He was a devoted younger brother to Calvin and shared a close bond with his cousins Alex, Becca and Nick who felt like another brother.

He spent summers working at the family business Cal Coast Plumbing where his presence brought joy to every job site Laura will cherish her memories of trips to Wyoming, Montana and Utah with Hayden. CJ will cherish the many fishing trips with Hayden, Grandpa Cal and friends to Alaska, Panama, Mexico and Florida. Hayden loved animals especially dogs and after volunteering at the Camarillo Animal Shelter he adopted his loyal pug Gus.

In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to the Camarillo Animal Shelter. We believe this would have made him very happy. Hayden is survived by his parents Calvin Miller and Laura Miller, his brother Calvin Miller, his grandfather Calvin Miller Jr., his grandmother Sharon Meade Rassi, his aunt Lisa Johnston Johnny, his cousins Alexander Smith, Rebecca Smith Scott Cameron, Nick Bounce and Kelly Meade. He was preceded in death by his beloved Papa Charles Rassi.

And I also extend my condolences to the family. I think as a mother The most terrifying thing that I could imagine is losing a child. And unfortunately, the parents are living that terror and that nightmare now. And I share my grief with you. I'm so sorry he's no longer here. Do know that through his relationships and the love that he had for humanity, he continues to live on here in the city and throughout the world.

I thank him for his bravery, for promoting justice in every step of the way, and for even giving up his life for that. May God bless you, every single one of you, the families who is here, and I will continue to keep you in my prayers. Thank you.

0:44 – 0:519 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed44:30

Thank you very much. We come to the time for general public comments for items not on the agenda, Madam Clerk?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed44:45

Yes, currently at this time I show that we have nine speakers and i'm just going to read a little bit about the general public comment rules. Per City Council policy 1.05 each speaker is limited three minutes. The city council received general public comment for a maximum of 20 minutes which typically allows for up to seven speakers Speakers who sign up during the 20-minute public comment period that are not heard within that time will be given an opportunity to speak following the completion of action on all other agenda items.

The City Council may not take action on matters raised during general public comment but may briefly respond, seek clarification or refer matters to staff as permitted by Government Code Section 54954.3 Your time will be displayed with a video on the displays up here And when your time is up, the microphone will be muted and then

we'll move on to the next speaker. So I'm gonna call up the first person and indicate who does second two, the second third people will be. So our first person is going to be Patty Braga and after Patty will be Joseph Dubinsky and Clea Talley so Patty if you want to come on up.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed45:59

Welcome

PresenterPatti BragaVentura County Leadership AcademyProposedself-stated46:00

Thank you. Thank you, Mayor Tennyson, Camarillo City Council members. My name is Patti Braga and I have the pleasure of serving as the Executive Director of Ventura County Leadership Academy. VCLA's mission is to connect people and issues to strengthen our county. We do that by bringing together a diverse network of leaders from the business, education, nonprofit, and public sectors.

Over a nine month program, we hear from subject matter experts on the complex issues impacting our community. We build relationships and understanding between cohorts and throughout our vast alumni network, many of them in this room so that we can all work together across all industries in all areas of the county to make our community the best it can be. We are now in our 31st year and we have over 890 alumni I wanted to take a moment and share with you our 23rd Annual Journey to Leadership Award Honorees for 2026.

This year's honorees include our Business Leader of the Year, Nick Deitch, Principal Architect at RRM Design Group. Our educational leader of the year is Dr. Cynthia Herrera, Vice Chancellor for Institutional Effectiveness with the Ventura County Community College District. Our not-for-profit leader of the year is Robin Britt, Executive Director for Community Conscience.

Our public sector leader of the year is Mark Stadler, Senior Program Administrator for the Crisis Intervention Training program with the Ventura County Sheriff's Office. And our alumna of the year is Danielle Borgia, President and CEO of the Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce. This is your formal invitation to join us at The Luncheon on Thursday April 30th beginning at 1130 hosted right here in Camarillo.

You can learn more by visiting our website or please feel free to reach out to me with any questions. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed48:04

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed48:05

Okay next person is Joseph.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed48:12

Welcome.

CommentJoseph Duszynski JrProposedself-stated48:13

Good evening, my name is Joseph Duszynski Jr., I'm a resident of Camarillo and I spend my mornings outside of Cortez Circle tracking raid activity. I missed y'all last time, I was too busy training over 250 people in Santa Barbara to get involved with this effort because other people can't or won't For statistics, in the 805 Tri-County area 1,534 people at least have been abducted by ICE. 817 of those are from Ventura County and 444 have been taken within Camarillo that's over 50% of the Ventura County total Imagine my surprise this week when I opened up the VC Star and saw an op-ed from Mayor Tennyson saying the same things that we've been saying for months, which is nothing new actually. Ventura County has been experiencing harassment, doxing, instigation, brutality, rammed with cars, flashbang tear gassed, and murder by ICE within our community I guess it took a couple of people being gunned down in Minneapolis to actually start waking up to what's going on.

So, I'm glad you're here. I'm glad you're seeing that brutality that this lawless administration has started to have and I hope you'll do more as a city council to protect us. The only thing I didn't agree with is why people are having trouble trusting law enforcement with ICE. It's not just ICE's actions that are making it hard to trust because law enforcement has remained neutral while ICE has continued its reign of terror throughout the county, because law enforcement officers won't investigate the many claims that we have brought to city council and county boards within Ventura County Because the sheriff spoke at a memorial for Charlie Kirk who hated immigrants and willingly collaborates with, and the sheriff willingly collaborates with ICE.

And has spent months passing along their lies without investigation while downplaying their actions as just guys doing a job. Because when we report crimes by ICE to local law enforcement they don't actually show up or do any investigation but when ICE reports a crime three units show up to question our volunteers outside of Cortez Circle Because when I provide photographic evidence and precise details of law breaking happening with the county, Ventura County Sheriff's Department and the Camarillo Police Department will not respond. I am still waiting for a call back from Deputy Borden As such, words and opinions without actions are meaningless. And as such I want you to really reconsider the Immigrants' Takeholders Committee we've been trying to get established within Camarillo as part of the City Council here.

The same way Oxnard has, the same way Santa Paula has, the same way Moorpark is now getting going and the same thing that Fillmore after last night's city council meeting is considering. If you don't want to be a part of this discussion in supporting the undocumented community, that's fine. We can't wait for you guys to actually do something or take action outside of food going to FoodShare for everyone not just the undocumented community. So if you don´t wanna be a part of this conversation we're going to start an immigration stakeholders roundtable within Camarillo and we'll work around you guys and we'll figure out how we can support this community because y'all aren't doing it thank you

0:51 – 0:576 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed51:15

Okay, our next person is Clea Talley. After Clea will be Spencer Ritchie and after Spencer will be Bev Dransfeldt.

CommentClea TalleyProposedself-stated51:24

Hello my name's Clea Talley and I'm here today to ask the City Council to vote to terminate the contract with FLOC and cover any cameras currently deployed within the city until they can be removed If the council does not want to discuss further on the issue today, I request an open public hearing be scheduled similar to what was held in Santa Cruz on January 13th which would allow true public commentary and transparency on this taxpayer funded and unapproved liability.

Several flock cameras are easily found online with publicly accessible live feeds with 30 days searchable footage. No login required, these are open IP addresses. These new cameras that have been installed in Camarillo are located next to our public schools and private schools with the playgrounds clearly visible in the camera feed. This is in violation of our privacy laws and exposes our children to the internet in terms of what they can be accessible. Flock cameras pose an unacceptable risk to our community privacy, safety, and civil liberties. Flock cameras and automated license plate readers are used by California police and in cooperation with ICE and federal agents to clearly conduct unconstitutional immigration enforcement activities across state lines in violation of California's privacy laws.

They have been used by law enforcement officers to track people, vulnerable people with health care issues with the idea of charging them with the crime. To track ex-romantic partners and to stalk people for personal reasons. Recent audits of data have confirmed as well as national reporting that have shown that information is not just Accessible by police departments nationwide, but Homeland Security and other agencies. We are quickly becoming a mass surveillance nation. Is this what we really want? Independent research has uncovered dozens of serious security vulnerabilities that have allowed access to live feeds, unencrypted data, no security whatsoever. And by the way, the recent current terms and conditions by Flock Safety have now said that the data in those camera systems belongs to them in perpetuity.

So I would ask these cameras be covered as soon as possible and the contracts terminated, and that you hold a public hearing as soon as possible. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed54:19

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed54:19

Okay Spencer, and after Spencer is Bev Dransfeld and then Nicole Radden.

CommentSpencer RitchieProposedself-stated54:38

Hello, I'm Spencer Ritchie. I have quite a few things to say. So the first thing is that For some reason on your sign up the public comment thing out in the front there was an option to sign up to public comment on the on the food chairs check presentation I notice and I signed up to do that to comment He skipped public comment on that over so I don't know why that was an option if that was your plan.

And then the second thing, I am seconding the whole you need to get rid of the flock all per cameras because Again, why are you feeding us to ICE police departments across the whole country and bad actors from every single stripe on a silver platter? Because again that's what these Flock Alper cameras do because literally anyone everyone can look at their footage from the past 30 days And then, and also I've noticed you still make a huge point of being physically responsible.

Renting 25, a whopping 25 Alper cameras when Oxnard, a city that is multiple times our size only has 19? That is not physically responsible on your part. And then going into what I actually submitted in my written public comment this afternoon Nobody was pointing at Get Your Heads to rent a whopping 25 Flock Opera Cameras to cover a town that is a fraction of the size of the neighboring city with only 19 Flock Opera Cameras.

Multiple people have told you That you know, you can prove by looking it up online with at, you know, reliable sources that, you know flock all per camera footage is accessible by ice. And it's there. It's a huge, you know the like notably that and your not at least Commissioning studies to look at the possibility of the state switching from contracting with the openly collaboration as VCSO for law enforcement and instead going to its own in-house PD that does not collaborate with ICE. And, you know, not doing even the slightest steps that you can against ICE. That is tacit approval of ICE.

That is tacitly agreeing with what ICE is doing. You are all a bunch of traitors who like ICE. Thank you, have a nice day.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed57:39

Okay next we have Bev Dransveld and after Bev is Nicole Radden and after Nicole is Bob Garcia

0:57 – 1:047 turns

UnidentifiedCity ClerkProposed · by role57:47

Good evening again council members. I think it's important to express gratitude where gratitude is due so Mayor Tennyson, I do want to thank you for your comments in the op-ed. It's an important stance and it's important for people to hear that from you as well I also want to express gratitude for the funding that did go to FoodShare. And with that being said, I do find it interesting that you know the immigration standpoint is brought up in these statements up here publicly. I don't feel and I can be corrected on this that it's available you know that's not in the press release sort of thing so The reason why this was pushed forward was for advocacy from 805, UndocuFund and many other volunteers that are supporting the immigrant community.

And I bring that up because it's a significant investment in our community And it could have been an even more significant investment. And Mayor Tennyson, Councilmember Tremblay I appreciate you taking the time after one of the meetings to explain to me that with VCCF it was because a policy that it was considered a pass-through I think that is something that could have also been explained to understand that and that's also something that could have been changed prior to if that was such a concern. So even the $50,000 that was originally proposed could have gone even further than the $70,000 to make it $100,000 and as we know every dollar that is spent is five dollars you know so again just when we're talking about fiscal responsibility Again, we're not asking for a million dollars.

All I'm asking for, all we're asking for is an immigration stakeholders meeting. This goes back to some of the goals and objectives that were presented earlier today. When it looks at trust which Vice Mayor Dr. Martinez Bravo brought up that has eroded. And it's happened on every single level of local government, every layer of government from local to national.

So building that trust, we're looking at forums. This is an opportunity again this discussion of three minutes at a time every couple of weeks I do want to touch on the public comment portion now that it's 20 minutes I'm not sure if that's previous policy that wasn't Before, I'm seeing a nod from Mayor Tennyson. Again being very forthcoming about that because right now it seems like it's retaliation of the number of public comments that are coming. I appreciated that former mayor Kildee allowed everyone to speak and I understand if it goes towards afterwards but I know with Oxnard City Council often what they do is move to extend that time so I hope that the council also does that in practice if that

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:00:52

Okay, now we have Nicole Radden and after Nicole Radden is Bob Garcia and Blanca O.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:00:59

Madam Clerk I'd just like to recognize that Councilmember Tremblay is now present.

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated1:01:06

For the record thank you Mr. Mayor. I sit on the Fox Canyon Groundwater Management Agency Board of Directors We had a lengthy quasi-adjudicatory hearing this afternoon that concluded at 4.47 p.m., so I apologize for being late, but that's why I'm late. Thank you.

CommentNicole RadinProposedself-stated1:01:25

Good evening, Mayor Tennyson and members of the council. My name is Nicole Radin and I am a Camarillo resident. I've come again today to voice my continued concern about the immigration enforcement that's happening in our community and to ask that City Council take decisive and immediate action. I want to use my voice to remind our leaders that the issue of immigration is still critically important and very urgent.

The people of our city are being deeply affected by this issue. Earlier this week, a friend reached out to me. She and her family live overseas and run a social enterprise business in a developing nation. She reached out to me because she was unsure whether or not it was safe for her family to come home. because she has darker skin than I do. She said, from this side of the world it looks pretty intense. Honestly, I'm a bit scared to come home.

Scared to come home? Home here, to Camarillo. It was difficult to answer her. I tried to answer candidly. Yes, the political climate and immigration enforcement is intense and scary It's not just happening in big cities, but it's happening here as well. The numbers that I have are actually outdated just because I pulled them the other day. It's now over 700 people have been taken from Ventura County and over 440 of those were taken in Camarillo.

But I was also able to share with my friend that there are pockets of hopefulness in community members that are taking action working to protect our neighbors, people stepping up in our city to care for one another People from my church recently banded together. We're able to help provide diapers for a local family where both parents were taken and three toddlers were left behind.

While I was able to share about community members taking action, I did not have much to point to from the leadership of our city. Nothing to point to her that is from the officials in charge that say we as your City Council want you to feel safe. We want we here's what we have to say about what's going on or here's what we're going to do. I do appreciate very much that there is a web page with immigration resources on the city of Camarillo's website, but it's critically out of date and it is very insufficient facing regarding the gravity and the urgency of the ongoing crisis.

I am going to keep on working to make sure that people feel safe at home here, in the small ways that I know how and in my small sphere of influence. And I hope that our council will join me and my friends. Thank you. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:04:14

Okay, on the list I have Bob Garcia, Blanca O., and Sidharth is the last one I have signed up.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:04:22

So three more? Correct. We will complete those three before we go into the regular agenda.

1:04 – 1:103 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed1:04:32

Unfortunately, I'm here to talk about people who've been lost in military service. I wasn't aware of what was happening tonight but that's my topic you all know that I've been here before about this. I believe I came here in October of 2023 and made some requests and in over two-and-a-half years I just now been able to get four more names that I found Vietnam of casualties of war, Camarillo residents that were killed.

Those names should be added I believe in February to the plaques so that will make the total of 40 names of Camarillo residents who died in the service of our country. One of the holds up is every time I try and do something like this they say well it has to go through the American Legion I brought this stuff, this is where I get my information that I've gathered. It doesn't have anything to do with the American Legion. I'm doing it on my own and that's why I'm asking you guys, and I've asked this before, that you establish a Citizens Advisory Committee volunteer for Veterans Affairs and let under your guidance come up with proposals that affect veterans.

And I think that will make things a lot easier because there's a big delay when they say, oh we have to wait for the American Legion. Well they don't know. Information is here not over there. So that's my main proposal is that you establish a Veterans Advisory Committee all made up of volunteers. They don't have to be veterans but that would be helpful Another issue, and I've made several proposals like changing the name of Constitution Park to Veterans Memorial Park.

I went to one committee meeting and two of the council members said they weren't in favor of that. Well there's five of you. Is that how it works? Two guys get to make the decision? I don't know what the policy and procedure is on that. I've made some other proposals about letting veterans buy those memorial bricks like they're doing at the Pleasant Valley Historical Society and put them up around the memorial out here.

That's a no-cost thing for the city as far as I can tell, and the last thing I'm asking from you guys is I'm also dealing with Assemblyman Bennett and Irwin's office, trying to get one of those freeway signs like we have for Deputy Kuchenko here at Lewis Road for Camarillo's only unaccounted-for missing in action service member, Victor Corona who has been missing in action since July 23rd of 1952, Camarillo resident.

And I'm running really into the same kind of roadblocks dealing with the state that As

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:07:40

an

CommentNicole RaddenProposed · by introduction1:07:42

Oxnard native, I just want to point out that we have a beautiful memorial in Plaza Park. So I think it could be done here as well. Let's stop lying to ourselves. This is not about immigration enforcement. If it were, the math would make sense. Minnesota has an estimated 95,000 undocumented residents while Texas has over 2 million and Florida has 1.6 million yet enforcement resources are being funneled into blue states, states that did not vote for Donald Trump. That is not coincidence. That a strategy.

We are told this is about the worst of the worst, but the facts say otherwise. Roughly 93 percent of those detained have no violent criminal record. If cartel leaders were really being arrested, the footage would be everywhere. Instead what we see are ordinary people taken, families shattered and communities terrorized. So let's say the quiet part out loud—this is not public safety. This is political targeting.

And when anyone dares to point that out, they're gaslit. We're told no this is just enforcing the law. Is it? Then why are state police deployments paired with political pressure like demands involving voter rolls? That has nothing to do with immigration and everything to do with power. We're also told to take Donald Trump seriously when he tells us who he is. But when someone openly sells and wears Trump 2028 merchandise, when democratic norms are mocked instead of defended at what point do we believe him?

Democracy doesn't disappear overnight it's dismantled piece by piece while people in positions of authority look away. And real people are paying for that silence. Renee Nicole Good, Alex Pretty and a small child Liam Canejo Ramos. These are not talking points, these are lies forever altered or lost under policies that treat human beings as collateral damage.

Then we see federal agencies themselves promoting language like one homeland, one people, one heritage. We are not stupid, we know exactly what that language comes from. It is not neutral, it is not accidental and it is a rhetoric of exclusion and white supremacy repackaged and stamped with a government seal. This is not about undocumented people. It is about consolidating power, silencing opposition and testing how far institutions will bend before they break.

So the question before this council is very simple. Will you continue to play neutral while democracy is eroded in real time? Or will you name what is happening and stand on the side of civil rights due process and humanity? It is a pretty good time to start believing your eyes and ears.

1:10 – 1:158 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:10:47

Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:10:47

OK, our last speaker. Yes?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:11:04

Mr. Mayor, Council, fellow citizens My name as you seem to have so much trouble with it is Siddharth Mehrotra and by now you know me And by now you know I agree I agree with the family of Hayden Miller No parent should be forced to bury their child I agree with Joseph This matter has gone on too long and our response is too late. I agree with Ms. Talley and Ms. Ricci, we have not done due diligence.

I agree with Bev Drumsfeldt and Blanca in all they have said. I agree with all this and I hope you do too. Indeed, I've come to believe we all must I have come to believe in these things more than, and perhaps, I've ever believed in anything in my adult life. For the past 25 years we have suffered this oppression, this mad search, this tearing of ourselves apart in search of a non-existent threat of a totally fictitious danger to people who stand no danger at all.

The time has come Time has come instead to heal ourselves, to stop what is destroying ourselves and do what will knit us back together. And what will knit us back together has been named already to free the prisoners, disarm those who captured them and streamline the immigration process so people don't have to wait and be punished for it. Thank you. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:13:06

Okay, we will move on to Council staff and intergovernmental reports. Our first report is a library update and I know Mandy's here. Mandy the microphone is yours.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:13:26

Good evening, Mayor David Tennyson and library trustees. I am excited to announce a new modern feature in the library which is a 12 bay laptop dispenser located on the library's second floor. This dispenser allows patrons to check out a laptop to use anywhere inside a library building and provides greater flexibility for library patrons. The dispenser is self-service and patrons can check out a laptop for up to three hours a day.

When the library, when the patrons complete their computer session, the laptop is returned to dispenser where it's charged and prepared for the next patron to use. This service is available for all patrons 18 years and older and have a valid Camarillo Public Library card. In relation to technology, the library will redesign the existing tech lab in the second floor into a new meeting space that we are branding as The Workspace.

The Workspace allows small groups of up to 15 people to book a private meeting space for their business and educational needs. This space will include technology upgrades such as a smart board for virtual meetings and offer modular furniture for room flexibility. We hope to launch The Workspace later this spring and foresee this being a popular service with the public.

Our library staff will market this accordingly once we have all the equipment and furniture in place. The laptop dispenser in the workspace support the City of Camarillo's strategic plan by ensuring the city's technology and facilities promote efficient operations and public engagement. And that concludes my presentation, I'm happy to address any questions.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:14:58

Any questions for Mandy? Thank you very much.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:15:13

I harken back, I think it was about 2008-2009 the library was actually constructed and somewhere in that neighborhood. And boy it really looks good and I think it's really great that you're continuing updating it to reflect what you know the consumer and or you know the residents and the people's needs are so if you could pass that along to your staff too. I'm happy to thank you. I really always enjoy going there so well used

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:15:44

Anybody else? Thank you, Mandy. Next I would like to invite Oxnard College Dr. Roberto Gonzalez president to the microphone sir

1:16 – 1:222 turns

PresenterRoberto GonzalezOxnard CollegeProposedself-stated1:16:01

Good evening buenas noches Mayor Tennyson, Council Members. Thank you for having us. I'm Roberto Gonzalez, President of Oxnard College. Like many of you and many of the families we serve in Camarillo, I am a proud son of immigrant parents who came to this country from Michoacán, Mexico to provide for their families a better life. I am the first in my family to go to college. I started my college career at my local community college And the guidance and support that I received there really helped to set the stage and laid the foundation for my future academic and career success.

My purpose is to help youth and adults in our community, and help them discover their calling just as I was helped define mine. My wife and I are proud to have chosen Camarillo as our home, where we are excited to be raising our two young daughters in the city. From the moment we arrived, we found the city to be very family friendly, just people oriented and so we're so happy to be here.

This evening I'm joined by Mara Malch, Vice President of Business at Admin Services, and James Schuelke, our Director of Outreach & Marketing. This year, Oxnard College is celebrating our 50th anniversary. As you may know the college was established thanks to families of Oxnard and Ventura County advocating for equitable access to higher education and today some 50 years later we are proud to have served generations of Camarillo families from fire departments to city halls schools and businesses to hospitals and clinics laboratories and non-profits Oxnard College graduates are on the front lines serving our communities every day.

We honor our shared past and tonight we hope to give you a sense of where Oxnard College stands today and where we're heading as we forge the next half century of service. In terms of the PowerPoint, Oxnard College is an institution of excellence with recent statewide and national recognition for our work serving students. Oxnard College was recently ranked ninth in the nation among two-year Hispanic serving institutions by the Washington Monthly College Rankings, which prioritizes advancing social mobility equity and student opportunity. Oxnard College was also ranked amongst the top 10 community colleges in California for return on investment by the College Futures Foundation. And both in 2023 and 2025, the prestigious Aspen Institute named us among the nation's top 150 community colleges out of 1200.

Recently, we received a recognition by the Carnegie Foundation for our community engagement work. Only 277 institutions nationwide receive this designation honoring colleges and universities that demonstrate a commitment to working alongside other communities. These distinctions underscore Oxnard College's commitment to providing affordable high quality education that leads directly to economic mobility.

We are proud to offer high quality academic programs. This fall, we launched our first bachelor's degree program in dental hygiene. We also assist students to transfer to four-year universities by offering 36 transfer programs. Our top five transfer degrees are business administration, biology, psychology, anthropology and elementary teacher education. Oxnard College also offers about 20 career education programs. The top five programs are business management, early childhood studies, dental hygiene, computer networking information technology and culinary arts. And next I'd like to introduce our Vice President of Business and Admin Services Mara March to come present.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed1:20:02

Good evening. As a resident number person on campus, I got assigned all the number slides so bear with me but we wanted to give you an overview of our demographics in the 2024-25 academic year we saw a reasonable growth of about nine and a half percent serving just over 12,000 students on campus. Our enrollment is a little bit heavier on the female side over the males which is a trend in higher education overall When we look at our ethnicity, our students are predominantly Hispanic with about 72% being Hispanic followed by the next largest group of about 16% white and 6% Asians. And then the remainder being a mix of various ethnicities. So we have a very multicultural campus with a broad representation of the communities that we serve.

Additionally, if you look at the age breakdown of our students, our largest group is that traditional college-bound age. But we do have a strong representation of the 17 or younger with our dual enrollment students and then also strong representation of adult learners from our CTE programs as well as our PACE and our ESL programs which we'll discuss a little bit later.

Again, we have seen a nice growth in our dual enrollment programs at about 6.5%. As a proud Camarillo graduate, Camarillo High graduate, we service Camarillo High School as well as Rancho Campaña and Rio Mesa that service your students here in the city of Camarilo as well as a number of other high schools within our service area. Additionally, we have some targeted programs for non-traditional students and adult learners. Our PACE program which is our Program for Accelerated College Education is focused on working adults to assist them in getting degrees for transfer as well as professional certificates to advance their employment opportunities and improve their income status. And then additionally, we offer ESL programs English learners, and we've seen additional growth in those programs as well.

So with our PACE program growing 9% over the past year and our ESL growing 35% over the prior year. So when we look at those targeted programs, of that 9.5% overall growth, those programs contribute about 6% of our overall growth and so it's important to know that we have diverse programs on campus and that we tailor our services in our programs to meet the needs of the community in which we serve. And with that I'm going to turn it back over to President Gonzales Oh, I forgot this one. I apologize.

We've also had an increase in the completion rate so whether it's our associate degrees for transfer or professional certificates we've seen a modest growth of almost 2% in that area as well from the prior year

1:23 – 1:2810 turns

PresenterRoberto GonzalezOxnard CollegeProposedself-stated1:23:02

Oxnard College also offers excellent student services including specialized support for specific student populations, including our Veterans Resource Center which supports our veteran students. In terms of financial aid we distributed about 32 million dollars in aid last year to help students pay for their education We have many external partners including the United States Navy, Port of Wainimi, County of Ventura and LIUNA.

We partnered with the Navy and the port to create a logistics certificate to help meet industry demand. The Port of Wainimi recently awarded Oxnard College with scholarships funding to support our students in the logistics program and then recently we partnered with LIUNA to offer their laborers training school on campus. The program starting later this year will train community members for jobs in construction.

Oxnard College, the college with the heart is proud of our 50 years of service to our community and our contributions to the workforce and economic vitality of Ventura County. Here's to 50 more years of service thank you so much for your time and attention.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:24:10

Thank you any comments from Council? I know Vice Mayor Martinez Bravo has her hand up without looking

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:24:18

I do. Thank you so much. First and foremost, thank you for the great work that is happening at Oxnard College. When I was elected shortly after I came on, Dr. Oscar Cobian and Dr. Luis Gonzalez invited me for a tour of Oxnard College to begin that partnership And I truly enjoyed it. But in addition to that, I think it's the fact that they thought about inviting a council member to the campus to provide and initiate that relationship I thought was extremely meaningful.

I know that they are two doctoral level individuals who Our residents of the city of Camarillo, and I was pretty saddened to hear that they are no longer with Oxnard College. And so my question to you is how are you prioritizing local talent? And what are you doing to retain excellent workers and leaders such as Mr. Oscar and Luis Both doctoral level Latinos, which are highly in demand.

PresenterRoberto GonzalezOxnard CollegeProposedself-stated1:25:42

No, thank you for the question. You know as I've been at the college for about a year and a half one of the big things that I've spent time doing is really getting to know the culture of the institution and getting to know how we engage with our community. And so one of the big takeaways is that we're a small college but we're the college with the heart. And everything that we do we want to make sure that we're supporting our professionals helping them grow and move forward in their career And also looking for new talent and making sure we prioritize local talent. So right now, we're going through the searches for interim positions and then very shortly will go out for the permanent position. So right now although it doesn't look like it I'm three people so I am the Vice President of Student Services, the Vice President of Academic Affairs The president so just been working with everybody on the team at the college to help kind of keep the boat afloat until we get some temporary people to help out.

Hopefully, some local talent and then also as we recruit for the permanent hopefully some local talents to your point so

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:26:48

yeah no thank you I mean I think just the fact that they are Camarillo residents and were able to bring that perspective was extremely meaningful to me. But I know this is, I sit on the site authority board of CSUCI as well. I know things take time but yeah definitely continue to prioritize local and important talent here.

PresenterRoberto GonzalezOxnard CollegeProposedself-stated1:27:15

Absolutely

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:27:16

thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:27:17

Anybody else? Mr. Kildee.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:27:19

Yeah, I want to thank you for being here. I'm actually a graduate of community college back in the day. Awesome. But it's great, great college that you have over there. My current dental hygienist is a proud graduate of your program. She does a great job and I know you have a whole bunch of other really good programs over there so I want to go over there sometime and take another tour. I haven't done it in a while but I'd like to do that We're here to help and wish you continued success. 50 years, it's amazing I can remember the first year so yeah that's really great congratulations. I know we're going to have 50 probably a whole lot more really good years too so keep up your good work and I wish you nothing but future success and thanks for coming here makes a difference we really appreciate it thank you thank you for having us

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:28:12

council member Santangelo anything

1:28 – 1:4512 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:28:20

Thank you so much for being here. It's really, it's appreciated that you've taken time out of your evening to show us a little bit more about your school and all that you do. So thank you for all that you do for the community. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:28:34

Go ahead Mr. Tremblay.

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated1:28:35

Thank You Mr. Mayor. Thank you for your presentation. I also think that it's significant and it speaks very well of Oxnard College that you now have a bachelor's program in dental hygiene. You know, I know that Moorpark has been moving in that direction or it already is in that direction with other subject matter areas. Not sure about Ventura College yet but I think that speaks very well of our community college district and of Oxnard College in particular so I congratulate you on that. And if there's, if I left any other academic areas out, I'm sorry, I just saw that one on the slide.

So thank you. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:29:15

Well, Dr. Gonzalez, thank you for you and having some of your staff present this evening. I would sing you happy birthday, but I don't have a singing quality voice. My wife has outlawed singing except at church on Sunday morning. So there's people that drown me out. But happy birthday. Congratulations to Oxnard College and all of your alumni that have passed through those doors and keep up the good work. Thank you. Thank you.

Now we shall go to council comments. Who would like to go first? Mr. Kildee.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:29:59

Okay, meetings attended January 15th VRSD today I attended the investment committee with Martita. And January 24th, Saturday, I did attend. I got there a little bit late but I did attend. Steve Bennett had an open house in Camarillo. Thank you, sir. Who'd like to go next?

not transcribed≈10s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:30:48

I'll let you correct the record Councilmember Santangelo.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:30:51

Okay, I'll go next. Okay on January 15th I attended a CPA board meeting also on January 15th we had the CPA executive committee meeting. On January 21st I attended LAFCO. On January 28 that was earlier today I attended the investment committee And then I attended the CPA Finance Committee. And that's it for meetings attendance. I did want to explain, I handed out to all of you a little two page black and white.

And these are talking points for the Board of Directors but I figured you could all use them. CPA instigated an interim rate change because The PCIA fee for Southern California Edison went up, so CPA lowered rates so that we could keep ourselves competitive. Let's see if the board had not taken action the new PCIA fees would have increased monthly electricity bills by an average of 9 to 13% for most residential customers.

Rates for communities that started in CPA service in 2025 were also lowered, CPA rates remain competitive with SCE and CPA's lean power option remains less expensive than SCE's base rate. So if you have any questions you can ask me hopefully this helps explain things a little bit. And that's all I have.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:32:26

Thank you. Susan, I owe you an apology. I had back-to-back meetings this morning with both of you and I apologize. Actually investment committee meeting was Susan. It's starting to look a lot like me. Was that memorable right? Yeah sorry about

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:32:41

that. Vice Mayor you're up.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:32:42

Thank you and Council Member Kildee, I think you just missed me too much in the investment meeting but we did have a following meeting after that.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:32:52

Thank you i'll get it right

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:32:54

Yeah, January 15th I attended the Economic Development Collaborative Annual Board Meeting. City staff attended and there was a wonderful panel on the film industry to help support the economic development throughout the county actually so it was a very very interesting panel. January 26th meeting or January excuse me January 26th we had a meeting with Adolfo Camarillo High School staff and also with city staff to discuss some traffic concerns so that's going to be some ongoing efforts there.

And then in terms of the comment that was made about our veterans, I am all for supporting or looking into other ways to honor our veterans. I know we do have also a beautiful memorial here in the city at Constitution Park, but I'm definitely open to other possibilities. So I'm happy to speak with a gentleman who was here, I think he may have left or to you know just discuss that.

Additionally um I do want to say I do have some comments and Rachel City Attorney please stop me if this is in any way going out uh you know that would be I wanted to share on December 4th of 2025 of last year, I accompanied a farm worker to the ICE office in Camarillo. She was told that everything was fine and that all she had to do was go to the Camarillo office and have her monitor removed.

Well, as it turned out, that's not what happened when I showed up to the office they detained her and would not even give me that information. I managed to get that information from them. In addition, her vehicle was there and it was going to be towed so I had to request like authorization by giving my ID to to get her car keys so that we could move it. Immediately, I contacted UFW who came and helped me. I was extremely shaken up by the entire experience. You can just imagine what it's like for the people who are living it.

And I know that we see this and many more horrors that are happening throughout our country. But when you're there, whether you're recording or living it, it's very, very different and I was just extremely shaken up by the entire situation. On that same day, I know UndocuFund was there on the side. They had no idea what was going on because we serve very different functions.

And so at least in that moment So, I don't do through my organizations. I don't do rapid response. I don''t follow ICE What we do is we provide direct service to farm workers in need And that is not to criticize one level of work versus another, but the reason I am saying this is because all of us have a role to play. And it doesn't mean that if you're not doing one thing that it's not as important as somebody who's doing something else.

I have farm workers who are calling me from detention I have sat there and literally prayed with farm workers who are calling me as they weep. I have sat there from farm workers who call me and guide them through meditation because they're literally having a panic attack on the other end. There are organizations who are working on family preparation plans. And none of this is something that we provide publicly, but it is work that is happening behind the scenes and sometimes the work that is happening behind the scenes is obviously just as important.

And I understand the frustration. I understand the anger. I have photos of my passports on my phones I have made plans to make copies and leave one with City Hall and another with a chief of police because the concern is, because of the work that I do and because of my color of my skin, I am a target. And as the only woman of color on this dais, yes, I do believe I and my family and many people of color in this country know what that terror is like.

And as we move forward, I think we're experiencing something that we never have in this country before. At least in the most recent years. We don't need to look at Nazi Germany because the Nazis borrowed the playbook from the United States In terms of the mistreatment of slaves, people that were brought here against their will. We have indigenous people who are being taken during these times. Indigenous people of this land who are being detained.

So it is extremely, extremely troubling. As I mentioned, I do believe that every single one of us has a role to play. And I also think it's important to provide grace if there are people who voted for this but are now realizing you know maybe this isn't the right thing let's provide some grace because at the end of the day we do need to move forward. We do need to have a country And we are all here passionate because we do love this country. If you did not care, we would not be here.

And so I think we are all doing the best that we can. At three o'clock, we had our goals and objectives meeting. And one of the goals that I brought forth within public safety was to try to establish a strategic plan for, to increase public trust because we know that this has been, trust has been under attack between law enforcement and the community because of these recent actions.

So, do know there is work happening. We're not perfect. I am happy to always meet with folks to see what you have in mind and... You know, I think I'd like to also thank Mayor Tennyson for your op-ed on the VC Star The reality is that no matter what policy we bring forth, it always has to be done with humanity. And that is the part that I think is lacking currently with the current tactics that are being utilized under this administration.

I did share a social media post and I shared it after mass on Sunday. And so, I would like to share it with you as well in both English and Spanish. This is a moral crisis. We are living under a deadly federal administration. Human and civil rights are being stripped away. Violence is being used against US citizens. I condemn it. Children are being gassed, used as bait and traumatized.

Indigenous people, US veterans and other citizens are being detained. People of color including police officers are being held at gunpoint. This is no longer political. This is about right and wrong. Psychological warfare is being waged against the American people. Truth is being distorted. The American people are being gaslit. Fear is being weaponized, but justice does not disappear when it is denied.

I stand with the American people. I stand with those protecting our communities and defending the God-given dignity of every human life, faith leaders, medical associations, U.S. veterans, NLPOA, National Latino Peace Officers Association, and peace officers, nonprofits, and all who refuse to stay silent. May Alex Pretty rest in peace. May justice rise, I pray for his family and loved ones. And on this Sunday, I offer my holy communion for the repose of his soul and for eternal life.

Ahora voy a repetir este mensaje en español. Este es una crisis moral. Estamos viviendo bajo una administración federal letal. Se están arrebatando los derechos humanos y civiles. Se está usando la violencia contra los ciudadanos estadounidenses. Lo condeno. Niños están siendo gaseados, usando como carnada y traumatizados. Pueblos indígenas, veteranos de Estados Unidos y otros ciudadanos están siendo detenidos.

Personas de color Incluyendo agentes de policía están siendo retenidos a punto de pistola. Esto ya no es político, se trata de lo que es correcto y de lo que no es correcto. Se está librando una guerra psicológica contra el pueblo. La verdad está siendo distorsionada al pueblo estadounidense Se le está manipulando y confundiendo. El miedo se está utilizando como arma, pero la justicia no desaparece solo porque se le niegue.

Estoy con el pueblo estadounidense. Estoy con quienes protegen nuestras comunidades y defienden la dignidad otorgada por Dios a cada vida humana Líderes religiosos, asociaciones médicas, veteranos de Estados Unidos. La NLPOA y los oficiales de paz. Organizaciones sin fines de lucro y todos los que niegan a guardar silencio. Que Alex Pretty descanse en paz. Que la justicia prevalezca.

Rezo por su familia y sus seres queridos. That is all that I have. Thank you, Mr Tremblay.

1:45 – 1:562 turns

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated1:45:44

Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This will be pretty short for meetings attended since January 12th. I attended the California Association of Sanitation Agencies conference between January 13 to 16 and today a lengthy Fox Canyon Groundwater Management Agency board meeting at the CASA conference and I have programs that all distribute to all the members of the council later There were excellent presentations on federal deregulation and permitting reform, and in particular on agency funding and project financing opportunities. We all know that we have an extremely significant public works project ahead of us in the next couple years in terms of our water recovery facility, so the lengthy presentation was opportune.

The second thing is that the Camarillo Senior Resource Guide just came out. I think the cover page was signed by our mayor, but I want to thank publicly Kathy Gluckert and Bruce Margolis who spent an untold number of hours in putting this together with the Camarillo Council on Aging. It's a very welcome resource guide and I really appreciate their efforts. And that's it.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:47:10

Thank you, Mr Mayor. Thank you. On the 14th through the 16th, I too attended CASA and I'll just say ditto to Mr. Tremblay's comments. You wouldn't necessarily think discussing sanitation agencies is that exciting but it was very germane to what Camarillo is looking at over the next several years with our sanitation plant, with our water reclamation plant. Yeah, Water Resource Facility. On the 15th I had a VCOG Admin Committee meeting.

On January 23rd the City Selection Committee which is mayors from all 10 cities in the county where we proudly and unanimously elected Mr. Trembley to continue in his role as a city representative on Fox Canyon so congratulations Mr. Trembley! And then on Saturday, I attended the community coffee with Assemblymember Bennett and there were some good discussions.

With that, I am going to announce a 10-minute recess and we will reconvene in exactly 10 minutes. Council meeting and we will begin with the consent calendar items D through P. Madam Clerk any public comments on the consent calendar?

1:56 – 2:0918 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:56:47

I do actually have somebody that signed up for consent calendar but I believe they're out in the foyer and it's Spencer Ritchie.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:56:58

Can they hear us out there?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:57:05

We can't see her on the screen.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:57:07

All right, we will move on. Are there any questions from Council on the consent calendar?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:57:13

I'm happy to move consent.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:57:15

I'll second. Got a motion and a second. Madam Clerk? Yes, I gotta hit the right button.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:57:38

I'm happy to take Susan's and Kevin's vote.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:57:44

Are you voting yes or no? Okay, I'm leaving up the

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:57:46

screen for the mayor to announce

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed1:57:47

the vote. That passes 5-0 thank you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:58:04

Now we will move on to item Q, a discussion item. And before we turn it over to Lisette I just want to make a quick preparatory comment. This was presented to Council last month and there were several questions about it so it came back to the Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Committee. We're working with staff. We refined it and fine-tuned it a little bit. So with that Lisette please take over.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed1:58:35

Thank you, Mayor, City Council and members of the public. I'm pleased to be here once again to introduce this item and also to introduce Colleen Murphy with Lassar Development Consultants. And she's going to walk us through the revised version of our Homelessness Strategic Plan Draft. And then also waiting in the wings we have Senior Deputy Jason Havelka who will be available to answer any questions that council may have following the presentation. And so now I'll welcome Colleen forward and we'll begin the presentation. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:59:07

Thank you, Colleen.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:59:17

Good evening. Mr. Mayor, council members thank you again for the opportunity to present a revised City of Camarillo homelessness draft strategic plan for your consideration tonight. We greatly appreciate your feedback on the plan back in early November and tonight I'm pleased to share how we've integrated this feedback in alignment with the city's priorities Before I provide a summary of the plan's revisions, I wanted to share that the plan's phase-based structure remains the same. Phase 1 continues to be focused on creating the right conditions for success. That includes the potential for pursuing applicable funding opportunities, reducing barriers to housing development and expanding staff capacity to strengthen the city's response.

This phase also emphasizes the opportunity for strengthening partnerships, working closely with the county, the continuum of care and the housing authority to align efforts and avoid duplication. And finally this phase recommends prioritizing transparency and public engagement. That includes the opportunity to create tools like dashboards, continuing community outreach and providing regular updates to council so progress remains visible and measurable.

With phase one's groundwork laid, phase two seeks to focus on implementation including delivering the housing and services needed to reduce homelessness. Phase two outlines suggested activities for the next three years and looks to develop additional permanent housing solutions add new affordable and supportive units and expand interim options such as motel-based shelter It also includes a suggested prevention strategy to help keep people housed through rental assistance, shared housing and other local supports. Along with flexible funds that can help remove smaller barriers to housing. And finally it includes the proposition for workforce development recognizing that long-term housing stability is tied to income and opportunity.

This plan is also still grounded in a proposed measurable outcome, and this core outcome seeks to secure a two-thirds reduction in Camarillo residents experiencing homelessness by year five through sustained increases in housing placements for those experiencing homelessness and a strong prevention effort to better stabilize inflows. This proposed outcome is grounded in current baseline data and supported by our detailed modeling that demonstrates how maintaining steady rehousing rates while managing inflow increases through prevention can achieve the stated goal.

With that grounding, I'd like to shift on how we revise the plan in line with Council and Public Safety Committee's helpful feedback. One can categorize the plan revisions in these seven categories. Number one, clarifying the aspirational nature of this plan. Number two, sharing how this plan integrates with the general plan and housing element. Number three, focusing funding strategies on external resources, external sources. Number four, highlighting the importance of aligning potential organizational changes with the city's budget processes. Number five, linking programming to funding availability and feasibility. Number six, providing augmented language around trauma-informed care. And seven, clarifying the difference between goals 5.1 and 5.3 that focus on community education and community access to resources respectively.

So for number one, a comprehensive note to reader section was added at the beginning of the plan to explicitly establish it as a guiding framework that provides direction versus mandates. This section clarifies that strategies represent informed recommendations rather than requirements, that timelines serve as logical guideposts rather than deadlines and that the plan does not supersede existing city policy or council direction It also adds that the city may adjust plan actions based on circumstances, reinforcing the flexible adaptable nature of the plans framework.

So for number two, we strengthen language to include explicit connections to the city's ongoing general plan update and adopted housing element. The opening sections now clearly state that the plan aligns with and builds upon existing planning documents and that recommendations may be revisited and incorporated into future funding planning cycles only when consistent with broader city priorities and statutory requirements.

Goal two, which addresses barriers to affordable housing has been revised with particular attention to land use and zoning recommendations. Timelines note that review will occur in alignment with housing element programs and that comprehensive zoning updates will be analyzed as part of the general plan update process with implementation contingent on consistency with that comprehensive planning effort. So moving on to number three, the plans funding section shifts emphasis towards external funding opportunities focusing on how Camarillo can maximize state funding, federal funding and regional funding sources. The potential opportunities for local revenue sources that the city may consider if external funding proves insufficient is still available as an appendix.

For number four, recommendations regarding organizational structure and staffing have been revised to tie any potential changes to the city's established annual budget development process. New language emphasizes that the city will assess the need for additional positions including their scope timing and funding sources through the comprehensive budget study that occurs as part of the normal fiscal planning Additional context has been provided to explain the potential benefits of these proposed organizational changes.

Moving on to number five, recommendations for specific program implementation. Particularly those that involved master leasing arrangements and permits for housing development have been revised to include explicit conditional language tied to funding availability. Action steps now consistently reference the need to secure grant funding before launching programs and include language directing feasibility assessments rather than immediate implementation. Additional considerations note, notes have been incorporated to acknowledge program costs, coordination requirements and the need for strategic implementation based on available resources. This ensures that the program recommendations are understood as opportunities to pursue when conditions are favorable rather than immediate mandates.

Number six, this section addresses the engagement challenges and was augmented so as to provide a more detailed trauma-informed perspective. The revised content acknowledges that engagement challenges are real and complex and while explaining how behaviors that may appear as resistant often reflect trauma responses, safety concerns or program design mismatches rather than unwillingness to accept help. The added content emphasizes that trust building, consistent engagement and person-centered program design are proven to lead to better outcomes. And finally for number seven we refined goals 5.1 and 5.3 to ensure that the plan's language clarifies that 5. 1 is focused on general educational opportunities to engage Camarillo residents on the causes of homelessness and housing crises and Camarillo's response to these crises Next slide.

City staff, the Project HOPE team, county and regional partners, lived experience advisors, service providers and residents who all contributed to this process that has led us here today. We appreciate everyone's feedback and inputs to this plan and I thank you.

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:08:31

Thank you Colleen any questions from council?

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated2:08:35

No questions just comments

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:08:38

okay well we'll do that afterwards madam clerk any public speakers on this issue. On item Q, the draft Camarillo homelessness strategic plan.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:08:50

Yes I do have two people who signed up to speak on this item. I have Spencer Ritchie and after Spencer is Jacob Anglin. So Spencer if you want to come on up?

2:09 – 2:156 turns

CommentSpencer RitchieProposedself-stated2:09:20

All right, hello this evening again. I'm Spencer Ritchie. So yeah, I would say that you're the homelessness, the draft of the Homelessness Strategic Plan sounds pretty good. Pretty sound stuff. My question for you as like, I guess an addendum to it is actually two questions. So one actually three questions. Um, so one, um, I, you know, as you might have heard from among all the horrible news coming out of Minnesota is that is that I think four homeless, unhoused indigenous people were actually picked up by ICE and have been detained by ICE. You know, despite you know being indigenous American, I think more specifically Sioux. And So there's been a backlash about that.

Does the city have anywhere, have any plans for, you know, if ice, you know, targets any of our local unhoused homeless people? And then this leads with this, what the, yeah, this is related to my second concern about this too. As you hopefully may have heard as well in general, both Trump and RFK Jr. have suggested that institutions or as RFK Jr likes to call them wellness farms be brought back And in fact, in Utah currently there is a

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:11:38

huge

CommentSpencer RitchieProposedself-stated2:11:38

giant...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:11:39

Spencer I'm going to interrupt you. Please address the issues to the item on this agenda. This is our strategic homeless plan. Okay next Madam Clerk?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:11:55

Yes Jacob come forward.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed2:12:04

Mayor Tennyson, council members, staff. I appreciate the work that you're doing on this. I want to thank you for that. I can see how thorough you do desire to be to make sure that this is holistic change that you're going after and so i'm praying for you all in this aspect and so a couple things I just want to recommend from that holistic picture You mentioned it beautifully that there's sometimes there's a level of trauma that is prohibiting people and that's not just sound counseling that gets through. And so as you're looking for partnerships of who to engage with, I would encourage you to find people that can effectually pray for that level of freedom for people of past trauma things in their family that have happened. So there's emotional wholeness and ways of thinking so people can get broken free of maybe any cycles that they've had in their lives.

So, that's one component as you're looking for partnerships is people that can effectually bring that. Secondly there's two other facets when it comes to the land use and affordable housing. I don't know if you've already engaged with, but I would encourage you to reach out to the Housing Trust Fund Ventura County and housing trust fund that the land trust Ventura County they're already working with the state in getting grants and doing affordable housing in the region so they could be a good resource not only for feedback and strategy planning but we're willing there's maybe strategic partnerships to be developed in that.

And lastly my other encouragement and recommendation Around that land use, because you're looking how do we create funding through this or the sustainability for even the people's income and staying in those types of places. I think there may be a potential for overlap and on another time i'd like to talk about the sustainability development plan but what does it look like on certain land use where it's available to actually incorporate on the places where there's affordable housing for garden scapes, regenerative agriculture. For that type of thing to not only be there but then the people that are staying there to be trained and equipped on how to steward that level because it'll do a couple things. It will one provide food for them right away so you're talking about another level of expense that somebody in that situation is already having to work through And then two, there's also a level of resource for local markets.

A lot of our agriculture here which has been booming is very much exported and global but what about our local community? So what does that look like to have a multifaceted approach in some of those affordable housing and land use places where people are being trained up in those areas can implement that, have other income that comes from it and then that could also be scaled for other types of trade that they're learning on site so Overall, we can talk about that another time with sustainability in the sustainable plan but not just thinking how do we get as many houses as possible in one location. How do we also think holistically in that approach? So I just wanted to offer those encouragements and recommendations as you continue to go forward and glad to follow up within you at another time so God bless.

2:15 – 2:2113 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:15:07

Okay now it's time for council discussion and comments Mr. Tremblay Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated2:15:16

I want to thank staff, our consultant. I want to thank the Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Committee for the extensive revisions to the prior draft plan, for their hard work on the plan. The revisions are excellent. And they are responsive to the requests that I previously made at some length, at a prior council meeting. I really appreciate all of the work that staff and our consultant has done, the committee has done.

I support adoption of the plan. I want to thank you all for your patience As I was leaving my prior meeting, coming late to this meeting. In the plan, I hope I read that correctly. I'm not sure if I saw one was to correct a misspelling in at least one of the areas and I Apologize, I don't remember the exact did anybody else see that email? Yes, if you see that email

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed2:16:25

yes It was to update I donno it was to update the organization's name on pages 106 and 125 to the Autism Society of Ventura County

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated2:16:35

And I think that would be really appropriate. So I certainly support that revision and then secondly, uh, to remove the term aspirational from the cover page, which I'm fine with. I think it's covered at some length in the forward, which I really appreciate has been done. Um, and, and with that, um, thank you Mr. Mayor. And again, I really appreciate all the hard work on this. I think it's a more from my standpoint far more improved and something we can be very proud of, and I'd be happy to make a motion when the time is right to approve it.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:17:11

Any other comments? No? Susan did you have something?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:17:20

Okay, I wanted to voice my appreciation for the work done on this plan originally and on all of the revisions because I think you did a really good job. I actually went back and listened to the November meeting again because I wanted to be refreshed on how that discussion went and I think he did a really good job of addressing some of the concerns I really like the addition of the trauma-informed care.

I'm a nurse, I work in psychiatric nursing and psychiatric medicine. And so we're addressing and realizing that addressing the trauma for some of these folks is so important. So I really appreciate that addition. I appreciate that we've clearly spelled out that this is aspirational. I am glad you are okay with Changing the title if that's okay. I was wondering if we almost went too far to the other side but um, but I'm okay with that.

But I agree with changing the name of it yeah and that's all I have. Thank you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:18:34

Vice Mayor.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed2:18:36

The two comments that I was going to make have already been touched upon. That was the name, updating the Autism Society of Ventura County and then I was also in agreement with changing the aspirational piece actually. And other than that, I really wanted to thank staff Our consultants, wonderful work. I'm glad we're here, I'm glad we're moving forward. Thank you to Project HOPE and everybody who's doing the work on the ground serving this very vulnerable population. Thank you Mayor Tennyson for collaborating with me and for even meeting after we were already on different committees. So with that being said yeah I'm happy to support it as is as well.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:19:27

Mr. Kildee? Yeah, I agree with everything that's said here. This is a top 10 issue nationwide it might even be a top 5 issue. It breaks my heart to see anybody that's homeless here We're spending a lot of money, we're spending a lot of resources to see if we can't help this problem. I hope in my lifetime that I'll see it eradicated, it probably won't but I've seen it jump exponentially in my lifetime too and that troubles me. What I would ask, I appreciate all the changes on that, I think I'm really proud of our city Potentially our council, if we adopt this that we do have a plan now. We spent a lot of time and a lot of effort on this but I would also ask that the council gets periodic updates on how it is going what is working and perhaps even more importantly what is not working and also what could be happening in the future There's not any one reason why folks are homeless, and there's not one solution to it either.

So we have to be open-minded on any changes that could be brought forward in the future too. But other than that I support the hard work The committee did. Committee worked extremely hard. Staff, Lissette and your staff and everyone else that had a hand in this you worked extremely hard in this but it's a very important document and I will support it.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:21:11

Mr. Tremblay the floor is yours.

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated2:21:15

I'll move that the council adopt the Camarillo homelessness strategic plan.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:21:20

I'll second.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:21:21

We have a motion and a second. Madam Clerk please prepare us for the vote.

2:21 – 2:249 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:21:37

Yes. Yes.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:21:52

Yes. Yes, okay.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:21:54

Get it right.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:21:58

And that passes 5-0 thank you very much staff and Colleen. And with that, I'm going to ask the city attorney if there's any report from our earlier closed session.

UnidentifiedCity ClerkProposed · by role2:22:16

No but after we adjourn the regular meeting we will be returning back into closed session.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed2:22:21

Correct so as a reminder we're adjourning tonight's meeting in memory of Hayden Miller and we will reconvene back to our special meeting and continue our closed session

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed2:23:17

I think

Commentthank you MrProposedself-stated2:23:18

it's Carol.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:24:16

That was a nice tribute to him. I was gonna say something, but you were so eloquent.