BodyCity Council
MeetingRegular Meeting
Date📅 October 13, 2026

UnGovr Transcript

iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.
  1. PendingQueued for transcription.
  2. AIYou are hereAuto-transcribed and summarized; not yet human-verified.
  3. VerifiedReviewed and corrected by a person.

0:11 – 0:1914 turns

Pledge of Allegianceceremonial · click to expand · ≈9s recited, not transcribed
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed1:01

I pledge allegiance

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:06

to the flag of the United States of America,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:14

and to the republic for which it stands.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:27

Thank you.

Agenda Discussionitems moved / continued / pulled, click to expand
UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:28

Moving on to number four, approval

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:34

of

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:37

the agenda.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:38

We

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:39

got a motion and second?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:57

All in favor? Aye. Motion passes unanimously, thank you.

Moving on to item number five presentations 5A Economic Development Collaborative. Welcome.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed2:10

Thank you. Good evening, Mayor Mendez, Mayor Pro Tem, Council Members, staff. Bruce Stenslieth Economic Development Collaborative, we're thrilled to be here. I'm with three of my colleagues, Alondra Gaitan, Vicky Meraz who will come up and speak with me in a moment and Stephanie Gonzalez as well so we're thrilled to be here. All of them have deep roots and experience education and work experience in the Santa Clara River Valley so we come well represented Let's see if I can handle the simple technology here. I'm going to do a brief overview of who and what is the EDC in just a couple of minutes. Alondra and Vicki will come up and tell you a little more detail about specific services. We are passionate about providing services to business in your town and throughout the valley, and things that we can do in collaboration to make sure we're contributing to thriving economy quality jobs.

So just background on us, we're a private non-profit public partnership established in 1996 Our governing board is a mix of private sector leadership, education and other civic leaders. And very significantly each of the ten cities in the county and the County of Ventura. I appreciate Mayor Mendez's participation on our board and currently Councilmember Rodriguez really appreciate the support and participation.

As a nonprofit organization, a public-private partnership we're very much organized around doing everything that we can in collaboration. So we recognize that as a nonprofit there's only certain things we can do for business but we can do a lot when we have the participation of your team and really want to say or shout out To your assistant city manager, Manny and staff Angel Garcia and others who have been very involved and very supportive. And of course the City Manager. You see up there our mission vision and values were very much organized around the notion of being service driven, very specifically I said collaborative and responsive.

One quick point on that by making it clear that we're a non-profit, a 501c3. We're not an advocacy organization. We work with chambers of commerce and others so if you're looking for political change or advocacy around legislative or issues on How business is governed by regulations and taxation, that's for others. Our role is to figure out how in working in depth with the business owner and their team what we can do to improve their profitability, their opportunity to maximize job creation and so on. You also see here our notion of service commitment For a quick background on the way we're organized, we think there are three levers that we can push or pull to try and influence an economy or a community of opportunities such as Fillmore One.

We can work to retain and grow existing business space. That's the most effective thing that we can do. Businesses are already established. Work with them, identify what their barriers to growth and expansion or improving their competitiveness and we've got a team that can do that in Alondra Vicki will tell you more. Two, we can work with you to attract business to our region and we try to do that on a strengths-based basis. That is the notion of coming to our region because of the quality of life, the quality of our workforce, the quality of our efficiency in operations. In your case moving business to application to permit and building out and doing business And we can also most specifically work on entrepreneurship, that is what we do with business to help business create new jobs and opportunities.

With that I will stop and turn it over to Alondra who will comment on our Small Business Development Center. Thank you.

PresenterAlondra GaytanStrategic Relations for the Economic Development CollaborativeProposedself-stated6:00

Good evening Mayor, City Council members and city staff. My name is Alondra Gaytan and I am the Director of Strategic Relations for the Economic Development Collaborative. And today I'm going to highlight two of our programs. One of them is our Small Business Development Center. We have roughly around 40 business advisors who do one-on-one business technical assistance Each one is a subject matter expert, so some of them can help with marketing, with business start-up, permitting, licensing, anything around accounting, bookkeeping etc., eCommerce. And so each of our subject matter experts also has a very wide knowledge in various industries. So we have folks who have expertise in manufacturing, high-tech innovation, agriculture, anything in the bioscience.

We have a large group of business advisors who can help businesses and entrepreneurs here in the City of Fillmore. The other initiative that I would like to highlight is our early childhood education initiatives. So we have a very strong partnership with First 5 Ventura County, Child Development Resources and Ventura County Office of Education. And this partnership we work together to support and help the community needs in making sure that we We promote and provide quality and affordable childcare in our communities here in Ventura County. Not only do we focus on what the community needs are, but we're also serving the business side of it. So you know, we support the in-home family childcare businesses as well as the centers to help them with their business model.

Child care businesses are a lot different than the retail, hospitality business. So we have a cohort of business advisors who can help walk them through their business model to help them with that model of child care business. And we also support the Isabella project which is a pilot program that is taking That is happening in Santa Paula, and so we're really thrilled with these partnerships and we're thrilled that we are able to provide these services in Ventura County.

And to close, I really want to emphasize that EDC is a partner and a resource for the City of Fillmore. As you know we do have some alumni here from Fillmore High School so we understand the community's needs. We understand the businesses' needs and we wanna make sure that we're bringing our services and delivering quality services in both English and Spanish to Ventura, to the city of Fillmore. So thank you.

And I will hand it off to my colleague Vicky.

PresenterVicky MoraesEconomic Development CollaborativeProposedself-stated8:50

Good evening Mayor, City Council and staff. My name is Vicky Moraes and I'm the Loan Program Assistant with the Economic Development Collaborative. I'm here to provide some information about our loan program. We pride ourselves in being a community lender. We help businesses obtain access to capital. To be eligible these businesses need to be registered and operating in either Ventura County or Santa Barbara County. We help businesses that may not traditionally qualify for regular loans through a bank And we actually have a relationship with quite a few banks throughout the county that are regularly sending us referrals for assistance.

We've been running this loan program since 1998. We're here to support entrepreneurs that are looking to either start a business, expand or just grow in general. Some basic information about our loan program is that our loans range anywhere from $10,000 to $250,000. We offer competitive to low interest rates, and the term to repay the loan can go anywhere from four to seven years.

Seven years being the maximum. The funds can be used for a variety of things such as purchasing equipment, hiring employees, building improvements, debt refinancing, and just general working capital. So as Alondra mentioned with our Small Business Development Center, we have a team of advisors that can help these potential loan applicants out. And the benefit is that they can get assistance with preparing budgets, financial forecasting, financial planning.

and just help with the general application process. I hope this information has been helpful in letting local entrepreneurs about this resource, and we hope that we can continue to promote growth within the City of Fillmore. Bruce, over to you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed10:44

So just a couple of quick comments and we'll be out of your way. A couple other programs we run, we work very closely with the Workforce Development Board, the Community College, Cal State Channel Islands, Cal Lutheran to make sure that we're assessing workforce or businesses needs for a skilled workforce. We have programs that will provide subsidies for businesses who want to upscale their existing workforce to make sure they're staying current with new technologies, anything across the board. New machinery and manufacturing or just operational efficiency in any kind of operation. We also as you know work on we are the Ventura County Film Commission Juana Garcia and your staff has been a fantastic asset, making sure that we're connecting industry partners coming to the region

not transcribed≈14s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed11:28

efficiently come in do some filming spend some money and leave without creating a mess. And we're not a permit agency but we collaborate with you and we were thrilled for the city's participation in that I think lastly, we also work on a project we call the Broadband Consortium of the Pacific Coast. Trying to make sure that there is every kind of investment that we can make to close the digital divide. That is, we've learned that there are about 20-25% of Ventura County residents who are not connected meaningfully to the internet. Meaning they neither have or maybe no computer, no internet access. They may have one of those phones but you can't do your homework, you can't do business efficiently that way so we're dedicated to making sure that we're bringing the connectivity and the capacity for people to use the technology.

You can get in touch with us here or here, a Calendly link our phone number. We'd be thrilled for you to share that information. We'll get back to you immediately schedule as Alondra and Vicki mentioned with a professional business advisor Everything we do is confidential, no cost and we'll make sure that we're connecting you to the resources your businesses to the resources so the community thrives to the best of our collective ability. Happy to answer any questions

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed12:53

Yes, so I just wanted to thank you for all you do and I think the most important thing we can do is get your message out to more entrepreneurs and more businesses. Because frankly, I think that's that's the need right there if we can get you know the services you provide out to more businesses. I think they'll take advantage of it and everyone will benefit.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed13:14

Touche appreciate that. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed13:18

I do, thank you. Thank you Mr. Stensley and thank you everyone for the presentation it was really great informative. Absolutely agree and I just wanted to ask for our city manager process wise if people come in even just inquire not even quite to get a business license yet but just inquiring what are the steps? What do we do? Is it hopefully a regular thing that we're guiding them towards more resources like EDC

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed13:45

So EDC staff did provide flyers and we directed staff to include those on the business renewal process. Debra, was that completed? Did we include the fliers on the business renewal process? So yeah, that was a direction I had provided to staff and so like we still mail our renewal notices and so the flyers that were provided by staff were included there.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed14:15

Yeah, I'm interested in the discussion about the early childhood education. And I'm wondering with so many failing preschools and I was very involved in one of them that just could not especially competing with public schools and now provide you know the pre-k but there's other preschools that have not been successful. Could someone from that situation, that scenario get assistance in any direction for their

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed14:45

Yes, so in some instances we can make loans the funds that we have for lending to child care providers centers is really to expand capacity. But I hear you loud and clear it's really about stabilizing particularly the post COVID world and a number of challenges It is, as you know, a very challenging business model which is why we're so passionate about it. Providing assistance to operators to figure out making sure they're maximizing the subsidies from various state and other programs. Making sure that their doing the outreach to make sure they're not having any vacancies in their operation. But we appreciate the challenge and there's currently, not get too deep in the weeds but fantastically California is creating universal pre-kindergarten for four year olds but as families are able to put their kids into public school at age 4 is great or age 4 is great this also puts a pressure on home based and child care centers We're now trying to serve more infants and toddlers, which is a very challenging business model.

Higher staffing ratios but the data is I believe Council Member Rodriguez can tell you better than I can. Kids in communities that have access to early childhood quality early child education thrive and the communities do better short-term and long-term parents are able to work more effectively go to school confidently so I appreciate your question it's a challenging business model

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed16:16

I think there was the mention of small loans for maybe non-traditional or those who don't usually qualify. I was wondering if there was any more information that we can share with the public? What's an example of what that could possibly look like?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed16:31

Well, I'll take a shot and then you can help me out. What we really mean there is, we're not necessarily looking at a particular business model that isn't necessarily lendable. But businesses that are in early stage or for whatever reason are not competitive for securing a bank loan, a commercial credit loan. We're able to use our business advisors to do a more depth run and look at what is the financial projections moving forward, what kind of collateral they may have, what kind of capacity and experience. And then we'll take a higher risk in other words to lend to a business that might not otherwise qualify for commercial credit.

We do that not by being crazy in our risk management, but two things. One, we maintain a professional loan board of bankers who are frustrated sometimes they can't make loans through us. They'll be happy to help us figure out the strategy to get there and maybe even more to the point, we receive or were able to secure an 80% guarantee for most loans we make from the state of California So our ability to manage risk is mitigated by their backstop to a significant share of the loan. That's

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed17:45

great, okay thank you for that appreciate that. Thank

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed17:47

you so much good question.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed17:50

And then last but before I quit, you asked about access and your staff has been dynamite at making referrals to us as well. So when the team is out in the community talking to business there are agents on your behalf and our behalf sorry

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed18:09

Bruce, thank you so much for the presentation. I know you do great work. Just for the public, I know you mentioned early childhood education and film and other things that you mentioned but the services that you provide is for For anybody that wants to start or wants to expand their business, not specifically the ones that you mentioned, correct?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed18:30

Absolutely. I took a look we've served about 90 almost 100 firms over the last two and a half years in the city of Fillmore and the diversity across industry sector is pretty amazing in every kind of service organization every kind of restaurant and food service and retail and educational services so our passion really is not necessarily In the industry sector, we try to be open and as Alondra and Vicky mentioned, we have a core of advisors with experience across all aspects of doing business and of different industry sectors. We just want to help the business find a pathway to security, sustainability, resilience, profitability so they stay in business. They may grow but just to retain a business for us is a huge victory. Perfect thank you.

0:19 – 0:245 turns

PresenterAlondra GaytanStrategic Relations for the Economic Development CollaborativeProposedself-stated19:22

I would like to address your question as well in terms of the loans that we have available. One thing that I think is really important for us to point out is that businesses come and sometimes they've filed for bankruptcy, they've gotten divorced. All of these stories come through our door and so we want to make sure that It's a great opportunity for you to know and be able to communicate to the public that we look at the story. So we not only look at the financials, we also look at the story and we're able to make decisions based on what those two combinations together.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed20:03

Mayor, I just need to make an announcement. We're having technical issues with our platform for streaming on the website so we want to encourage the constituents that if they would like to stream the meeting to use our backup system which is Facebook or YouTube. We just confirmed with a DAB staff member and it's working and we're going to post something on social media right now as well. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 5Proposed20:29

Thank you Bruce. Thank you appreciate it.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed20:34

Moving on to item number 5B, Fillmore Town Theater 110th Anniversary. Welcome Sean. Hello.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed20:43

Let's see if I can get that off the screen. This was perfectly set up and now I'm going to screw it up. Okay, cool. So we had our 110th anniversary at the Fillmore Town Theater a week ago Saturday and John was there and spoke thank you very much for affirming the importance of the theater one of the programs that is most important to us of course, is the youth theater. And quite frankly it's one of the driving factors for me to actually purchase a theater in the first place because I was involved in youth theater with the Canyon Theater Guild in Santa Clarita.

So in the course of that 110th anniversary, I created a few videos and one of them has to do with the youth theater and I'm going to see if I can play it right now. Is there sound? Okay. There should be. The City Council meeting is being recorded. So this is our fourth year of doing the children's theater. We're doing Annie, we'll do two weekends. The kids are actually in the theater right now rehearsing. They've been rehearsing since the middle of August so I would encourage everybody to come out you know and to support it. One of the unique things about the theater that I wanted to make sure happened was we don't charge for the kids to actually be in the theater I would just like to make a comment. Sean, I think what you're doing is – and I meant every word I said when I was up there at the theatre.

not transcribed≈26s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

0:24 – 0:317 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed24:43

As we go through life, not everyone is the same obviously. We all have our different strengths and weaknesses and going through school of course, the stereotypical kid that wants to do all the academics and they're really into mathematics or really into English whatever, that is not every kid. And I think it's so important to provide an outlet for kids that have other interests. And I think that what you're doing with the theater is so critically important for those kids that need that other outlet because some kids are really into sports, some kids are really into academics but there are a lot of kids that are into band and the performing arts and what you're doing is just so important Looking at the whole spectrum of kids, and you're providing that piece of the puzzle to our community.

So I wanted to thank you for that.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 10Proposed25:39

Thank

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed25:39

you. All right. Thank you. Thank you.

Moving on to item number five C proclaiming October 2026 National Bullying Prevention Month And Councilmember Brogie will read the proclamation. Actually, that's me.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed25:58

Oh sorry. Sure I'll read the proclamation so proclaiming October 2026 National Bullying Prevention Month whereas bullying is unwanted aggressive behavior that involves a real or perceived power imbalance and is repeated or has a potential to be repeated over time causing emotional social or physical harm to another person or group and Whereas bullying can occur in neighborhoods, playgrounds, schools, extracurricular activities and other community settings as well as online through social media messaging gaming and other forms of technology. And whereas bullying affects children and adolescents across the United States can have lasting effects on their emotional and physical well-being and health academic achievement relationships and sense of safety and belonging.

And whereas children and adults And adolescents who experience bullying may face an increased risk of anxiety, depression, sleep difficulties, difficulty concentrating, decreased academic achievement, absenteeism and disengagement from school and community activities. And whereas children and adolescents who engage in bullying behavior may be at greater risk for other harmful behaviors and negative outcomes Demonstrating the importance of early intervention, positive relationships, accountability and prevention.

And whereas children and adolescents who witness bullying may experience fear, anxiety, helplessness and a diminished sense of safety while also having an important opportunity to make a positive difference by safely speaking up seeking help and supporting those who are targeted and Whereas, preventing bullying is a shared responsibility that requires the involvement of students, parents and caregivers, educators, schools, youth organizations, community leaders, businesses, faith-based organizations and residents working together to foster respectful, inclusive and safe environments for all.

Whereas National Bullying Prevention Month provides an opportunity to raise awareness, promote kindness and respect. Encourage safe and responsible behavior online and in person. And empower individuals and communities to take meaningful steps towards preventing bullying. Now therefore, Albert Mendez, Mayor of the City of Thelma, California does hereby proclaim that October 2026 As National Bullying Prevention Month in the city of Fillmore and encourage all residents, schools, students, parents and caregivers. Youth organizations, businesses faith based organizations and community groups to participate in awareness education and prevention activities that promote kindness respect inclusion and safety for all children and adolescents.

Witness thereof, I have hereunto set my hand and cause the official seal of the city of Fillmore to be affixed this 13th day of October 2026 signed Mayor Albert Mendez. Thank you Council Member Bernanke.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed29:22

Moving on to item 5D proclaiming October 2026 Breast Cancer Awareness Month and Council Member Brogie will read this proclamation.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed29:34

Proclaiming October 2026 National Breast Cancer Awareness Month, whereas 2026 marks 43rd year that National Breast Cancer Awareness Month has educated women and men about And whereas breast cancer impacts the lives of many Americans either directly or through the diagnosis of a family member or friend. There's been considerable progress in diagnosing this disease and improving treatments, yet eliminating breast cancer continues to be a major goal. While overall death rates are declining, breast cancer remains the second leading cause of cancer deaths among women. And whereas clinical breast cancers and mammograms are the most effective way to detect breast cancer at an early stage. The American Cancer Society, National Cancer Institute and the United States Preventive Services Task Force agree that regular mammograms can greatly reduce the risk of dying from breast cancer.

And whereas women and men can take additional steps to reduce their risk of breast cancer by not smoking, maintaining a healthy weight, eating a well-balanced diet, engaging in moderate or vigorous physical activity each day with vigorous activity three days a week and limiting alcohol consumption. And whereas it is important for all Americans to raise awareness of breast cancer by talking with family members and friends about the importance of prevention, screening and early detection. By educating ourselves and working together we will improve our ability to prevent, detect, treat and ultimately cure breast cancer. Now therefore Albert Mendez Mayor of the City of Fillmore California hereby proclaims October 26th as National Breast Cancer Awareness Month And encourages all women and men of Ventura County to learn more about the disease, be proactive in early attention practices and participate in building awareness all year long.

Signed by Mayor Albert Mendez.

0:31 – 0:374 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed31:24

Moving on to item 5E proclaiming October 2026 Fire Prevention Month And Council Member Christina Villasenor will read this proclamation.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed31:34

Okay, thank you Mayor. Proclaiming October 2026 Fire Prevention Month Whereas Fire Prevention Month provides an important opportunity to raise awareness about fire safety and to remind individuals, families, and communities that everyone plays a vital role in preventing fires and protecting lives and property. And whereas fires can occur unexpectedly and spread rapidly making fire prevention preparedness and early warning essential to protecting our homes businesses neighborhoods and community And whereas the City of Fillmore recognizes the importance of fire safety education and encourages all residents to take proactive steps to reduce the risk of fire, including practicing firesafe habits, maintaining smoke and carbon monoxide alarms, and identifying and correcting potential fire hazards.

And whereas every household should have a fire escape plan, identify multiple ways out of every room, establish a designated meeting place outside the home and practice the plan regularly with all members of the household. And whereas residents are encouraged to test smoke and carbon monoxide alarms regularly Keep heating and cooking areas clear of combustible materials.

Use electrical appliances safely, and never leave cooking unattended. And whereas wildfire preparedness is particularly important for communities throughout California Residents can help protect themselves and their property by maintaining defensible space, keeping vegetation and combustible materials away from structures, preparing emergency supplies, and staying informed about local fire conditions and evacuation information.

And whereas firefighters and first responders demonstrate extraordinary courage, professionalism and dedication in protecting our community and responding to fires, emergencies and natural disasters. Their service often performed under dangerous and challenging conditions is essential to the safety and well-being of our residents. And whereas Fire Prevention Month provides an opportunity for residents, schools, businesses, community organizations and local agencies to work together throughout the month to promote fire safety, preparedness and prevention throughout the City of Fillmore.

And whereas through education, preparation and responsible action we can reduce the risk of fires, protect lives and property and build a safer and more resilient community. Now therefore Albert Mendez the Mayor of the City of Fillmore California does hereby proclaim October 2026 as Fire Prevention Month in the City of Fillmore And encourages all residents, families, schools, businesses and community organizations to participate in fire prevention and safety activities. Review their emergency plans, practice fire escape procedures and take meaningful steps to prevent fires throughout the year.

In witness thereof I have here into the mayor has set his hand and caused the official seal of the city of Fillmore to be affixed this 13th day of October 2026

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed34:47

Item 5F, proclaiming October 2026 California Firefighter Appreciation Month. And Council Member Rodriguez will read this one.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed34:57

Proclaiming October 2026 California Firefighter Appreciation Month whereas the dedicated men and women of fire service selflessly risk their lives health and safety to protect the lives homes businesses and property Fillmore and surrounding communities. And whereas California firefighters routinely confront dangerous conditions, extreme wildfires, structure fires, medical emergencies, traffic collisions, hazardous materials incidents and other emergency situations with unwavering courage, compassion and professional excellence. And whereas firefighters serve our community not only during times of crisis but also Through fire prevention, public education, emergency preparedness, community outreach and other efforts that help keep our residents safe.

And whereas we recognize the profound sacrifice of firefighters who have lost their lives in the line of duty and honor their enduring memory courage and commitment to protecting others. Appreciation Month provides an opportunity for our community to express its deeply gratitude to active duty volunteers and retired firefighters, emergency personnel, and their families for their dedication, sacrifice, and continued service. And whereas the City of Fillmore recognizes that the strength of our fire service is reflected not only in the bravery of individual firefighters but also in the support of their family fellow first responders Dispatchers, emergency personnel and community members who stand behind them. And whereas the city of Fillmore encourages all residents to recognize the invaluable contribution of our firefighters and to express appreciation for those who stand ready to respond whenever their community needs them.

Now therefore Robert Mendez Mayor City of Fillmore California do early proclaimed the month of October 2026 as firefighter Appreciation Month in the City of Fillmore and urge all residents to join us in recognizing, honoring and thanking the brave men and women of the fire service who protect our community and serve our region with courage and distinction. And witness therefore to set as a hand and cause of this official seal of the City of Fillmore to be affixed with this 13th day of October 26.

0:37 – 0:458 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed37:33

Let me have the chief and guys come up so we can present these proclamation Cedar.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed37:47

Mr. Mayor, Council and staff we definitely appreciate this recognition. It's deeply appreciated. The men and women of the Fillmore Fire Department always have the community foremost in their mind and thank you for this recognition it's truly appreciated. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed38:16

Come on.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed38:25

Thank you guys so much for all your service. Members, where's the two? Okay.

not transcribed≈46s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed39:53

Thank you fellas. You guys are very well appreciated, thank you so much. Okay,

moving on to item number six public comments. Before we begin public comments just want to explain a little bit how this section works. Each speaker will have three minutes to address the council and under the Brown Act, the council is generally prohibited from discussing or acting on items that are not on tonight's agenda. This means that while we welcome and value your comments, council members will not be able to respond as follow up questions or engage in back-and-forth dialogue during this time.

We are listening carefully and your comments become part of the public record. If your comments relate to an item not on tonight's agenda, state law allows a brief response to clarify factual matters or refer the item to future consideration but no substantive discussion or decision can happen tonight. With that let's begin the public comments. Rito Murillo you have three minutes. Welcome to tonight's meeting.

CommentRito MurilloProposedself-stated41:03

Good evening to all. My name is Rito Murillo, I live in 818 Blaine where the asphalt got replaced and unfortunately since then every time when it rains water comes into my driveway. Before that I never had that problem. I've been living there for almost 40 years so I already complained like four times they listen to me they say they're gonna fix it but never have do anything Thank you so much.

not transcribed≈21s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 1Proposed42:09

Good evening, Mayor and members of City Council. I stand here tonight not just as a resident of Fillmore but as a veteran who swore an oath to support and defend the Constitution of the United States. When I served, I did so to protect the fundamental freedoms that make this country great including the right to live our lives free from constant government intrusion.

That is why it is deeply unsettling to watch the silent, unchecked expansion of flock safety cameras across the city. These are tools of mass surveillance logging the movements and daily life patterns of honest law-abiding citizens. I did not serve my country only to come home and have my daily movement's tracks catalogued and stored in a private corporation's database every time I drive through Fillmore.

If you want to know exactly where this passivity leads, you only have to look at what happened to our neighbors right here in Ventura County. We already know that an audit exposed how FLOC inadvertently opened up local data. Other cities in the county like Ventura, Camarillo, Moorpark and Oxnard had been forced to scramble audit and completely halt their programs after realizing local license plate data was queried hundreds of thousands of times by unauthorized out-of-state agencies.

And while departments across our county are confronting the reality that these private tech vendors cannot protect our data and respect state privacy laws, this council has maintained a troubling silence. The legal tides are turning and cities pushing these networks forward are now facing severe legal liabilities Just last year, the California Attorney General sued the City of El Cajon for systematically violating state privacy laws through illegal flock data sharing.

This month, the ACLU sued the city of San Diego to force the removal of flock cameras entirely. More importantly, the facade of constitutionality has shattered. In a historic decision, a U.S. District Court judge ruled that warrantless historical flock searches are unconstitutional, striking down evidence and explicitly condemning the technology has indiscriminate mass surveillance.

From federal civil rights lawsuits over wrongful stops to multi-thousand dollar public records judgments forcing cities to scrap their contracts, the legal and financial risks are clear. If you vote to expand this system, you're exposing Fillmore to the exact same litigation. As our elected leaders, you are the first line of defense in protecting our constitutional liberties.

Lack of concern in the face of these tracking systems is a failure of leadership. Public safety is vital, but it should never require an unconditional surrender of our privacy. I urge this Council to break its silence, demand absolute transparency and halt any further expansion of this surveillance network. One more sentence? of this surveillance network until the privacy and constitutional rights of Fillmore's residents can be fully and unconditionally guaranteed. Thank you for your time.

0:45 – 0:534 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed45:32

Comments, committee commission and board reports. And I will start. Today I attended the Air Pollution Control Board meeting. There were several items on the agenda but none of which were really worth noting so with that I'll pass it on to my next council member who would like to, Council Member Rodriguez?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed46:03

So, I attended the League of California Cities Conference out in Anaheim. And so I attended a lot of great workshops that just brought back a lot of information and some of this information I was able to share with some city staff but just to kind of give an idea of some of the workshops that I attended was tools for attracting and retraining businesses Money for finance, economic development, housing and infrastructure projects.

The usage of data and delivery effects services with limited resources. How to create community champions and lastly was a Revitalizing downtown without losing its old town soul. So there was, again really great information it was a few days most of the week from Tuesday to Friday and had a great time connecting with other fellow council members and other Local officials and city staff from throughout California.

And in terms of meetings, it's been pretty light for me. There was some rescheduling from some of the meetings that I attend and looking forward to attending those by the end of the month.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed47:28

Okay so I also attended the California League of Cities conference down in Anaheim, the 23rd through the 25th. I attended – I'm not going to go through all the different things that I attended but I would like to mention that It wasn't just the meetings that we attended or the sessions. As Mario said, there was also really good discussion on the sidelines and in particular I asked two different police chiefs about flock cameras Um, and their experience with it. And so you know for me it's a part of educating myself about flawed cameras hearing from police chiefs directly as well as hearing from um you know citizens as well. You know my whole thing is I want to understand the technology and understand what exactly uh the pros and cons are. Um you know I have my own personal feelings but you know when I'm educating myself I wanna make sure that I understand it from different perspectives.

So as I said, I met with the police chief from Santa Maria. He gave me his perspective on flat cameras as well as the police chief from Arroyo Grande so they gave me their perspective and I'm going to file that away and make sure that I understand that perspective from the law enforcement side but as I said, I've got my own personal feelings about it I'm not going to make any decisions until I have what I feel is a good understanding of the technology.

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed49:10

So along with my fellow council members and mayor, I also attended the League of Cities Conference in Anaheim. It's always a really great conference and a great way to see what other jurisdictions are doing. The league particularly gives out awards every year and it's basically best practices in everything from land use and zoning, housing community engagement, some really innovative things. So I really look forward to hearing what other cities are doing and it gets the motor going up here and it's always exciting to always go and come back more engaged. It's a great way again to connect with my fellow council members and the city manager, assistant city manager outside of this room in this meeting hall. That's really great.

So, I did not have a Ventura Regional Sanitation District meeting earlier this month. I will have one on Thursday so there's nothing particular to update there however regarding the hospital and Actions and communication that's happening there. The mayor and I are part of the newly formed Fillmore City Council ad hoc regarding the future of Santa Paula Hospital and health services in the Santa Clara Valley, and there is a particular group like you can call it a growing coalition or task force that has formed. It's called the Santa Clara Valley Hospital Task Force. It is something that is separate from the Blue Ribbon Task Force which I think what we'll continue to meet, that particular meeting is organized by the Ventura County Healthcare Agency.

Those meetings happen to take place up at Santa Paula Hospital. This coalition or task force is particularly geared towards Wanting a different outcome than what Ventura Hospital, the Ventura County Health Care Agency is proposing. And that is this task force's immediate objective is no gap in emergency services so just a reminder that three years from now come January 1st 2030 if things aren't changed the county will cease to operate Santa Paula But this task force is looking to keep emergency services in either the current hospital, maybe a form of a micro-hospital. Something that involves keeping an emergency room and some form of a small hospital in the Santa Clara Valley. That is the task.

And for there not to be a gap in services of that. So anyway, the group has just formed. We've had I think two meetings and it's a very complex issue and there are multiple layers of stakeholders but one thing that I think the group does agree on is one, the involvement of our local jurisdictions so they're very happy to hear that on our agenda today, on our consent agenda I believe is a resolution that the City Council here in Fillmore has put forward to what we believe we want to see in emergency and healthcare services in the Santa Clara Valley. The City of Santa Paula also is sending two of their council members as part of their ad hoc committee to this task force, as well as other community groups. So, there's multiple, like I said, sort of different prongs of information we're looking at.

But basically the gist of it is this group is really going to delve deep into the weeds of how we maintain these services here in the Valley. What could be the possible future and is the future that the county has aligned which is the closure of the hospital, can that be postponed? Is there a potential way for there to be a retrofitting of the hospital still? Seismic retrofitting.

Currently, the Santa Paula Hospital isn't a rural hospital by definition but apparently that might be a little gray area in some interpretations so there's probably about 5-10 really key questions that the group has discussed and we're going to set forth to answering those questions Thank you.

not transcribed≈20s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

0:54 – 0:595 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed54:02

I also attended the League of California Cities conference in Anaheim, and I think most of the council members here. We were all in attendance as well as some of our staff members. And definitely it's productive. I won't belabor much more than what any of the others have said so far. But I've attended the conference annually for a long time, and I walk away with information. It's always worthwhile. And the networking that goes on is just amazing. So that for me is half of it. So anyway, so I did that. We were there for three days.

Additionally, I attended the Ventura Council of Governments. I'm a member of that committee representing the city of Fillmore. And its representative, the Chair Council of Governments also known as VCOG is made up of different council members from all over the county. And the last meeting we had was, we had a presentation by our commander Eric Tennyson who is the Ventura County Sheriff Commander but he's also serving as the police chief for Thousand Oaks. He did a presentation on e-bikes, which was just amazing. And all cities are kind of struggling with what to do about the whole e-bike issue.

So he had a great presentation and speaking of VCOG, the next meeting, which is November 12th Eric Tennyson again will be speaking and this time he'll be addressing the whole issue of flock cameras. And he's been doing a very deep dive in communicating with other cities all over the state of California, and so he's going to present his opinion. These VCOG meetings are open to the public.

And the public has an opportunity to make statements just the way you do at City Council meetings. So if anyone wants to learn more about the FLOT cameras, I encourage you to attend that VCOG meeting on November 12th. It's at 3 o'clock p.m. in the Camarillo City Council Chambers. And again, as I said it's open to the public and public has an opportunity to make comments. Camarillo City Hall right?

And then I also attended the What was it what's the other one I said? I didn't attend the meeting, but in the previous ones we've been told they're the ones that are responsible for rebuilding the bridge, the train bridge. And they've been working on it you know for three years now and every time we get partially done as we all know the story then it gets flooded out again.

So I reported at a previous meeting That the bridge was to be completed by October 8th or 6th, which was last week. But I checked ahead of time before I was leaving town and I knew it's going to miss the meeting and found out that it's being pushed back sometime closer to the end of October. So but we're almost done. We're this close having that bridge completed and will have train operation in some capacity back into Fillmore again.

In addition to that, I do have my porch talk scheduled for tomorrow night. And again, for those of you who don't know, porch talk is a time just where I open up my porch or if there's a crowd we move to the patio or particularly hot or cold and then we move inside. But just to come and talk about issues that you have and concerns and things that you want to see our city doing moving forward.

And I encourage anyone to just reach out to me. You can reach me on Number 805-258-2661. And I'd be happy to give directions, there'll be signs on the street corners directing you to my house as well. So I'd love to have people show up for that tomorrow and again this is always the second and fourth Wednesday of the month. And then last but not least, I just wanted to make a comment with regard to our Fillmore Downtown Theater.

And I loved Sean's presentation earlier this evening. His heart for the youth and getting them involved in theater is just amazing to me. And I see the blood sweat and tears that he pours into that theater and I would just encourage the entire community to reach out attend these events they're amazing And I want to see this film work succeed, I think we all do up here. And I just think we need to really support that endeavor. So, um, I think that's all I have for now.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed58:55

Thank you. Council Member Guernica?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed58:57

Yeah so I was remiss in one item so tomorrow this had to do with Christina you reminded me about this so tomorrow morning is a rotary regular Rotary meeting we have it every Wednesday at 7am and tomorrow actually Supervisor Long is going to be the speaker at the Rotary meeting. And so of course, you know she'll be available there for Rotary members as well as any guests that appear to answer questions and of course some of the topics I'm sure will come up have to do with the hospital as well as possibly flock cameras. So if you're interested we would love to have you at the Rotary meeting and that's it. That's what I wanted to add in.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed59:41

Thank you so much. And where is Rotary meeting?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed59:43

We meet every Wednesday at 7 a.m. at El Pescador.

0:59 – 1:0518 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed59:49

Thank you. Moving on to item number eight, consent calendar. Governor, motion to approve the consent calendar?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:00:01

Mayor I have a, sorry let me get myself together here, on our consent calendar Let me just make sure I have the right item number here on consent. Is it 8D? Is that pop-up business? Okay, so I have a small amendment that I'd like to see before we adopt the consent calendar on item A. 8D, the adoption of the zoning ordinance regarding pop-up businesses. And the small amendment is that in the ordinance language it currently says that one of the requirements for pop-up businesses is they must have permanent accessibility to washing and toilet use but it says for the operator and for the patron sorry, it must be within 200 feet of a sink and water supply. And it says for the operator and for the patron so my amendment is to eliminate the patron and I say that because That would really limit a small pop-up business who wants to be a food operator and maybe just pop up within the Central Avenue corridor.

A patron will not have that public access to a washing sink or a toilet because the nearest one would be our ticketing booth, you know, the public film or restroom. So that's my amendment.

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:01:47

Can I

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:01:48

just address the legal procedure on that? So this is for second reading, so you would have to reintroduce the ordinance to do that. So you can either approve it now so that the rest of changes can go in effect 30 days from now and then staff can renotice it to come back to discuss that change But Brian might want to talk about this issue as well before you guys decide you want to make the

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:02:13

change. Legally, we can totally make that change. It doesn't need to be for the patrons. So it's adequate. Yeah, we can revise it and have it reprinted. Okay. Easy.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:02:23

It's not an issue to do but we just have to do it via that process.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:02:27

Oh yeah, we'll have to have a new public hearing. Okay. So we just approve it

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:02:30

as is

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:02:30

now? If you want to or you pull it and then it doesn't go into a file. Does this pull

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:02:37

item 8D then? Is that what was made in the motion?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:02:41

It was the second reading. No, I think that it's okay to go about it and like you said...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:02:49

So approve it tonight. Approve it tonight as is. But meanwhile we'll bring back a public hearing to tweak it.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:02:56

Sure yeah, we can do that so I will retract then my amendment and I'll make a motion then to accept the whole consent calendar as-is.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:03:05

Okay is there a second? Second. Okay all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Thank you. And thank you Tiffany for that clarification.

Moving on to item 9, new business advisory committee members nominating Ashley B Connolly for the Ventura County Air Pollution Control District Advisory Committee.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:03:32

Hello Mayor and Council, I am here to recommend that the City Council approves and adopts Resolution 26-4133 appointing Ashley B. Conley as the city representative for the Ventura County Air Pollution Control District Advisory Committee following review and recommendations of the City Ad Hoc Committee. This advisory committee occasionally takes up air-related issues and meets as necessary, usually one to three times a year.

The advisory committee is recommended is comprised of 20 members. Each county supervisor recommends two members for a four-year appointment, and each of the ten cities recommends each member to serve for a two or a four year term. The City of Fillmore has had a vacancy since 2024. Ashley Connelly If appointed as a member for this advisory committee, will start a four-year term beginning as of the date she is appointed. Do you have any questions? And Ashley Conley is here if you have any questions for her as well.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:04:55

Any questions for Ashley or for Hannah?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:04:58

Not a question, just a comment of thank you Ashley for stepping up and for submitting your application. And you do an incredible job on the Planning Commission and I think your attention to detail and really digging in deep to issues will be a real asset.

1:05 – 1:1817 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:05:15

Thank you Ashley

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:05:18

So given that, oh are you asking for a motion? Yes. Okay I will make that motion.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:05:23

Okay

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:05:23

we got a

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:05:24

motion, I will second that. Second all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Congratulations. Congrats. Would you like to say a few words?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 13Proposed1:05:42

Yeah, it's been a pleasure to be a planning commissioner here and meet more people and do what I can to bring the expertise that I do have to the role. And I'm looking forward to learning as much as I am to having an advisory role. I think that Fillmore could be particularly vulnerable to air pollution and I just want to be part of the solution to help reduce that vulnerability. Thank

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:06:18

you so much.

Moving on to Item 9B, 2026 Housing Project Approval Pathways under California Housing Law.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:06:50

The purpose of this presentation is just to go over the main housing laws that are in effect, that could affect the way the city processes and approves housing projects. A lot of these have been taking place and approved over the decades or so with quite a lot coming and a lot in state legislature now today that we're tracking. The housing laws have been, are basically intended to facilitate housing production by expanding the ministerial and buy right housing. And by the way this goes back to 1982 with Housing Accountability Act and it's subsequently been revised. One of the big ones was SB 35 which we can talk about.

It also, you know by facilitating housing and ministerial by right approving it has CEQA exemptions. CEQA is the California Environmental Quality Act that for a long time has been really the legal crux of how projects got delayed over the years. The way you always attack projects was to say that there's a significant environmental impact and the environmental impact reports could be argued You know, until the cows come home basically and that's how a lot of projects in California over the past several decades got stalled. So by having the CEQA exemptions it's fast-tracked a lot of projects.

Shorter timelines, city staff continues to shift its process for streamlining review for infill projects. Most of the projects we do in the city are, we kind of consider infill because we have our city urban restriction boundary and the area outside of that is the county and so we've kind of earmarked the lands that are inside the city for development. That's really where we're supposed to grow and as is most of the cities in Ventura County you stay within your urban restriction boundary and then the preservations tend to be on the outside. So we kind of call a lot of our projects infill.

So there's really two primary tracks that projects go down. One is discretionary and the other is ministerial. Ministerial is looked at basically as a staff approval, a lot of times it's called over-the-counter where you come in, it meets the standards and it's approved. Discretionary however is the types of projects that come through the Planning Commission or come to City Council wherein there's more of a subjective review that takes place It allows for exercising of judgment, and there could be more CEQA review depending on the location and other particular aspects of the project.

You might have to do more CEQUA analysis. The ministerial right process has now been expanded to multitudes of housing types. Types of housing projects that the state has targeted besides just general multifamily residential are accessory dwelling units. They've got provisions now for urban lot splits and duplexes, commercial to residential projects. Yes?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:09:49

I have a question.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:09:50

Sure.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:09:51

So have there been any projects in Fillmore that have been approved ministerially?

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:09:56

Yes sir. One you may have heard it's called Fillmore Terrace It's located over off Palm Avenue. That was approved ministerially just this year. It's a 50-unit apartment complex for low income housing and supportive housing. You now have ways to go from commercial to residential projects, which sometimes have zone changes and things like that, which is often very hard to get through a discretionary process.

Religious properties and school properties can be converted in a streamlined fashion, transit-oriented. Campus area housing and office to residential conversions are being targeted by state laws. And then in your staff report, we have a brief summary table that shows sort of a general description of how these trajectories occur. The typical process as I mentioned is the discretionary process which applies general plan and other types of standards There still is the Streamlining Act for determining a project to be complete, which is 30 days. So we always abide by that 30 day review period.

And then the ministerial by right still abides by the 30-day review period. SB 35 is one of the major ones that, as Albert mentioned, the projects would basically be fast tracked under SB 35 for the most part. It's due to sunset this year I believe but SB 423 will extend it out to 2036 and also add some other provisions for streamlining as well. AB 2011 is the conversion of commercial properties.

SB 9 allows you to split single family lots, build multiple houses. We have qualifying ADU and JADUs. We often bring back ADU update laws to you if we keep our ordinance updated. Adaptive reuse. SB 79 does not apply here. It doesn't apply in Ventura County because they don't have that type of mass transit. It's And we put our application online, we have exhaustive checklists in there so that there's a lot of guesswork is taken out of the application process. So if you follow the checklist, you follow the application, you should be complete.

But oftentimes that's not quite the case but we have almost everything you need on a plan on our checklist. So once you get through the completeness review process then or yeah, the completeness process then you go into an approval process which is about 60 days now based on the recent state laws. So again, those are ministerial and there's CEQA exemptions.

AB-130 for infill housing, like I said most of these we call infill so we are complying with AB-130 just by way of practice. SB-131 would apply if you maybe had a significant environmental impact that would trigger CEQAs in EIR but it's just one issue Then you don't have to do a full-blown study, you could just focus on the one issue and they call that the near miss.

So the underlying entitlement could be discretionary or ministerial depending on the environmental review but if you're studying one issue you lean it toward ministerial. And then there's other specialized statutory pathways AB 649, 893 those really aren't going to apply here as they affect college campus housing. AB 507 office residential adaptive reuse that could someone could take advantage of that one here.

SB 9 historic district changes and then you have the ADU and JADU law level of public review and secret review depends on the specific statute So when a project comes in, they would identify a law that they want to be processed under and we would make sure it meets that criteria. We haven't had too many projects. We've had maybe one SB9 come in the door that we're reviewing for a lot split We're in recent discussions with the developer who's talking about maybe, it's not on your list here, AB 2162 which is for supportive housing and there's a streamlined process with that.

But it's nothing too out of the ordinary. It's 30 day completeness review and then 60 days to approval. So there are some other projects in the works. We'll continue to keep you updated as they come through, but like I said if these process are processed on a ministerial level they won't come to you for a decision but we could talk about perhaps bringing a presentation like an informational session or workshop and that kind of thing just to make sure you're informed of what is coming in the pipeline So if we continue to shift and streamline for infill housing, meeting density bonus. So if you have a density bonus in your project, you are afforded streamlining. You're also allowed to get waivers of certain design guidelines if it's preventing the density from being constructed.

So we'll waive certain standards like height or setback parking and things like that. That's required under state law. We did approve objective standards. You might recall when we implemented one of the housing element programs was to rezone to RMH2 some areas down by the highway and we did an overlay, and with that you approved the objective standards so projects that come in the door a lot of the guesswork is taken out with the design but it also puts in some quality elements in there that we felt maintained Fillmore's character So there's quite a long list of objective standards in there.

And we have used those objective standards and shared those with developers, and we're getting some pretty good preliminary designs out of them, and none of the housing developers have said that there is anything in our objective standards preventing them from proceeding at the densities that they need so it seems to have been a good approval by adopting those standards. So we've got ahead of it a little bit, so we hopefully will get good quality projects even though they're ministerial.

We continue to administer the general plan and the housing element and the zoning regulations and building and safety and all those things that are going to make sure we keep people safe and do the most critical analysis we can to make sure that the project is best fit for the area. I'm happy to answer any questions Staff's recommendation is to receive and file this information regarding principal approval pathways that may apply to housing development under California law, and direct staff as you see fit.

For any further education we'd be more than happy to have workshops out in the public. Maybe we could do coffee with a planner although that sounds kind of boring but... We could definitely do that. But we do have some good projects, stuff is on the ground. Williams Homes is building a lot of good product. Seamill Family Homes that are selling rather fast and there's ADUs and JADUs built into the project.

not transcribed≈20s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:17:44

That was one that went through the planning commission.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:17:47

That actually went through planning commission? Yes. This picture of the one on the upper left is Mountain View which was built and then down in the lower right is the one Albert mentioned The mayor mentioned that's Fillmore Terrace. That one was approved ministerially, as I mentioned and they are looking to start construction in January of 27. Who

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:18:13

is the builder on that one?

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:18:14

It's People Self Help Housing.

1:18 – 1:2618 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed1:18:19

I just want to add something to the presentation, just for the constituents. From a ministerial perspective it's important for you know the public to be aware that the city generally cannot deny or redesign an otherwise qualifying project based on subjective concerns and so staff works closely with the City Attorney's Office to make sure that we are complying With the laws that are constantly changing from HCD.

And during January we typically receive a very lengthy memo from Tiffany's office, so thank you for doing that. And then we make sure that we're reviewing our internal processes to make sure that we're not going against what state law is requiring us to do so. There's that huge difference between like the subjective and the objective comments, and our hands are tied when it comes through the ministerial process. And I think that's important for the public to be aware of. The staff report does explain a little bit more in detail, and the plan is for us to share this information on the website so that the constituents can be educated on the different And for example of what you were just saying,

not transcribed≈21s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:19:55

When it was before the Planning Commission, the ministerial route wasn't available to them at the time. That bill didn't pass until after. So then they kind of went back to the drawing board.

not transcribed≈12s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:20:23

that they ended up with a decent, based on the photo anyway, a decent product, a decent complex compared to what they initially brought. So they still adhere to I think some of our requests and I'm thankful for that.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:20:39

That was an excellent case study.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:20:41

And that was part of my concern. I think I spoke with our city manager earlier and I think the work you did is Putting our subjective documents into our planning documents. What we look for in approving projects and I think I have total confidence that those documents are well written, whereas a builder comes in and they know what kind of product they need to put out in order for us to approve it.

Thank you

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:21:15

so much for your work. The Fillmore Terrace is a great example of one that didn't meet objective standards. It did meet the zoning. They had to do a zone change and change the densities and things like that. So under that, that was a discretionary decision, and so that was going through Planning Commission And we as staff had to recommend denial. It simply did not comply with the code. We recommended denial, it was 73 units I think at the time. A lot of excellent comments were made by the commission to improve the architecture of it. They went back to the drawing board, they studied Fillmore a little more, they looked around and saw that you know we like some daylight between the structures And they came back with a nice design. So we'll be happy to see it once it gets built, but the staff's hands were tied basically.

It had to be approved and met standards at that point. And we find that it works best to have a good relationship with the Housing and Community Development Department at the state. There's a good, happy medium where you stay in compliant with your housing laws and your housing element, and then you can still at the same time get good quality development. I find that developers do in fact want to do good quality projects if they know what you want, and if you can give them clearly what it is you want You're going to get more out of them, even if they're not required to. We do find that they are good to work with if you give them good information in the beginning.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:22:45

Putting out our objective criteria was so that it was not at all something that could just be someone's opinion. They were very measurable, objective criteria that anyone could look at and say yes we meet this or no we don't. And by building the Fillmore flavor into those objective criteria I think it really smoothed things out for that process.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:23:14

We may add some guidelines, maybe pictures tell a lot. So with each of those objective standards we might look at maybe adding some images to help in the interpretation as well and then some of those things are living breathing documents too you know it's you know we can always come back and make some changes if we find that on the ground something needs fixing.

You know we're not married or there's no reason to lock stuff in if a project can't get through

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:23:43

Brian, would you mind going back to the slide? Sure. Was it ZOA or I can't read my writing, 2826-03? Yeah that one thank you. So in looking at these a traditional discretionary review versus administerial so

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:24:06

sorry

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:24:07

yeah yes so I'm puzzled by How is it determined which development's going to fit into which category?

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:24:17

Well they'll come in, the developer will come in and present the project and identify which bill they see that they meet. And then we'll review it under that bill.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:24:30

I mean, in theory couldn't they come in and say we want to do this ministerially?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:24:37

I mean a lot of them are doing that now. They look at what benefits them and what they want to do, and then they pick which bill and then they design a project to meet that. And then we verify that they have...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:24:47

Yeah, I guess my concern is that if they're thinking about their cost, they're going to go the ministerial route. That's what they're going to request.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:24:58

I mean that's what most of the housing is nowadays throughout the state.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:25:02

And this goes back to what I've been talking about all the time where We have state government interfering with what local jurisdictions can and want to do. And so any of these mandates, that's what these bills are. Their mandates, we have to do things a certain way according to the way Sacramento wants us to do it. And I can go on about that all night long but that's something we need to watch for and I know we have legislators that are not too concerned about it.

But we need to pay attention to the bills that are coming down the pike.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:25:44

We're sensitive to the community's comments and what makes Fillmore, Fillmore. And the more that we can get objective standards that translate Fillmore then the better off we'll be so if you want to have another workshop and go over objective standards more, if you see things you like let us know. We can see how to make them measurable somehow. And keep Fillmore at the same time.

not transcribed≈13s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

1:26 – 1:3316 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:26:21

That

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:26:24

was my point Carrie, is what I was saying. By putting the objective standards in we can influence the projects that go through the ministerial review.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:26:35

And we did that when?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:26:36

We did that, gosh, a year ago. Do you remember? It was like a year ago.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:26:40

Yeah

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:26:41

because I remember the objective standards when we went through them it was trying to put into words kind of the Fillmore flavor and so that when people use any of those ministerial workarounds they still have to kind of jump through the hoop of meeting the objective standards So it's our, yes if they're going to convert let's say a church into a bunch of residential things they still have to comply to, it's got to look like Fillmore.

Or if they're gonna take an office building and convert it into a bunch of residential, you know, an apartment house or something, they still have to comply to the Fillmore flavor.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed1:27:28

As

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:27:29

long as we can translate the subjective criteria to measurable. Two things I'll mention quickly and then I'll move on, but once you comply and get your housing element adopted, you're no longer subject to something called builder's remedy. Some of the cities have been hit by that. Carpinteria is one. where all local standards are off the table so you could get a nine-story apartment project anywhere.

And I think Carpinteria is battling something like that right now, as is Santa Barbara City. So I'm hearing some of those stories. Yeah? They don't get their housing element certified in time. In time, there's deadlines.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:28:21

Remember we

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:28:22

need

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:28:22

to have a process. Yes. We were... So Carpinteria missed the deadline?

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:28:26

Yes.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 12Proposed1:28:27

Or chose not to. Some cities are choosing not to do everything that HCD is saying you have to do to have a certified housing element and then the result is that any developer can submit any project they want.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:28:39

By right. Mm-hmm.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:28:40

Wow.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:28:42

So, a couple of comments. Thank you Brian this is really helpful I know when I saw it on the agenda I said okay this is how we're going education route which I think is really important for us as council members and also for our larger community and I try to you know we get into the weeds with what the words and agencies but I try also just sort of bare bones it and say you know what is the community saying right now thinking right now from again What we hear from people we talk to or, you know, putting things on social media pages.

And I think one of the big questions is why? Like, you know, why do... Why is it by right? You know, why do we basically have to do what the state says and if a housing developer comes in and says they cross all ten boxes You know, why is it that the state's letting them do it? And I think it's just important to go back and say like where what are the roots of where the state is really coming, and I would say heavy-handed back to the cities.

And I'm just gonna put out there, I think that it does go back to you know per my internet Roots of crisis and local control. So even back to the 70s, housing began shrinking. CEQA, like you mentioned it's kind of been used as weaponization right? Like oh anything has got to have an environmental impact report so that really limited. And then you look at CEQA 80s, 90s, early 2000's a lot of exclusionary zoning. NIMBY stands for Not In My Backyard and basically a lot of local councils or developers would bring in ideas but they were met from the community saying that we are concerned about traffic School overcrowding. These are the same things we're hearing today, right? Traffic, school overcrowding, property values and frequently apartment complexes were voted down or low-income housings just didn't get through.

So I just kind of wanted to put some education out there. I almost look at it like what's that ride that sort of like a dragon ride where you go all in one area and it might be a slow build over years and years I'm not saying Fillmore in particular, but just cities all over California and the legislature has swung the pendulum back. And I think I agree with you Kerry, maybe too harshly or too much with the mandates, but that is how it's swung right now.

I wanted to share sort of a little bit, like peel the onion layer back. Why are we here? It doesn't change that we have to abide by what the state says but I think that there's ways to talk with the legislators, to follow the different bills that are coming down and maybe that pendulum has swung back really far and it's a bit of whiplash but There might be a way to get it back more towards the center, you know. And so I think continuing to advocate, to watch the bills, um, to see what's happening. I think in some communities there are definitely big boxes that are being dropped because there is not the communication that's happening. So I hand it off to you Brian and to the planning department, our commissioners, our planning commissioners.

And well for ministerial department right? For being that gatekeeper basically of the Fillmore flavor and really sticking to our objective design standards but Yeah, so we'll just have to monitor and keep track and do what we can in Fillmore. But we also have to make sure that we have the voices of folks who live here saying we have too much or we're overdoing it. Well, you know, we have to by the state but how can we make it something that You know, is good looking.

You know not too big that still you know is something that the community can be a part of the community and the community can sort of wrap itself around it. And many matches has been a great example. Central Station back 20-25 years you know I mean just seems like its always been there and I'm hopeful that Fillmore Terrace will blend into.

1:33 – 1:388 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:33:20

So just one quick comment. To me, I try to personalize as much as I can. When I bought my first house, I was in my mid-20s, late 20s and I think to myself Could one of my daughters, let's say right now, any of my daughters could they buy a house right now in California? Could they buy the house that I bought back in 1993-94? And the answer is definitely no.

The heavy-handedness that you're talking about, Kerry. I mean it's well meaning because I think what they're trying to do is – I don't know if you remember we went to that conference by the – I think it was put on by the Gold Coast Council of Governments up in Ventura and basically the economist said look It's not hard to solve the problem of housing and getting the housing prices down. It's been solved before, what you need to do is build more houses. Build more houses, prices will drop.

Again, heavy-handed. The state wants to build more housing so what are they doing? They're forcing you know communities not necessarily pointed at us but I know definitely there are communities that they don't want to build and so by the state forcing them to build they're trying to solve a problem of hey can my daughter buy a house? Can she and her husband, are they able to buy a house?

And to me that's what it's about And I agree with you. I don't think, you know all of the stuff that the state comes in they come in pretty heavy-handed but to me that's fundamentally what they're trying to solve is by building more houses they're trying to bring the price of housing down so you know and sometimes it looks ugly but we're trying to make it look as good as it can

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:35:15

I could add just one thing to what John said is that Creekside is putting product out there, they're selling really fast. At the same time we have Bridges selling homes at the higher end of the market segment. They sell a little slower pace because of the pricing. Williams Homes are selling a little bit faster because they're lower middle part of the market.

Single-story homes are down in the sixes and very close to the state mandated moderate income level. So there's a little bit of a price correction when you have enough supply out there, and you hit the right market segment for the first time home buyer. If you've had enough out there, you start to get natural organic correction which is really good for the local economy.

And once we reach our RENA numbers, which is enough billing permits to reach the RENA numbers then we can go back to traditional. More traditional review.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed1:36:12

I'm sorry for purposes of the constituents that are watching can you elaborate on what the RENA numbers are?

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:36:21

Well for the sixth cycle housing element there were 415 units, and that means that we had to provide on paper what we call upzoning to allow more units or higher density for the 415 units. We actually zoned for well beyond that with the RMH2 down along the highway. And once you're on paper that you've zoned up to that your housing element can get certified but actually meeting the numbers is issuing a building permit So not until you see the building permits. Sometimes you'll see a lot of projects in the pipeline and it looks like there's a lot of units moving through, and then if they don't proceed we stay below our arena numbers and then we're still processing things more on a ministerial level until we get there.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:37:13

Thank you. You got it? Do we need a motion on this? Okay, just resuming file. Thank you Brian. So then

moving on to item 9C public hearing on the consideration of zoning ordinance text amendment 26-03 ordinance 26-1003 amending Fillmore Municipal Code section 6.04.9610 definitions and finding of exemption from CEQA.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:37:50

Brian? Thank You Mayor So this is the data center, zoning text amendment. And you may have been hearing a little bit about this, there was one proposed at the Ventura County Fairgrounds recently and the board of the fairgrounds.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed1:38:12

I think you're skipping ahead, it's 9C. It's the kitchen.

1:38 – 1:5220 turns

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:38:23

All right. This is on Texas Amendment 2603, Ordinance 1003. So this is to define kitchen and wet bar in our ordinance. When you look at our ordinance it really comes down to what is considered a housing unit and a lot of those are defined by whether you have a kitchen or not so we define better what's a kitchen and what's a wet bar so that you can't have double kitchens where you're not allowed I'd like And so the enforcement becomes clear as to what's allowed for second units.

So, as I mentioned dwelling units if you look at the latter three there single family, two family and a dwelling unit it involves a count of kitchens. So we define better what a kitchen is so that Folks can differentiate between whether you have enough, whether you have a dwelling unit or not. So this adds the definition there and it's equipped with a sink in interior dimensions of 12 inches, has cooking appliance or other heating appliance, a refrigerator of more than four cubic feet capacity as opposed to a wet bar Which has no cooking appliance or other heating appliance, garbage disposal dishwasher electrical outlets in excess of 110 or 120 volts.

Gas bar sink interior dimensions are still 12 by 12 by 9 and plumbing is no greater than 1 and one-fourth inches in diameter So this came about through enforcement where A landlord had multiple tenants, multiple units inside what was really a single family home and then claimed that there was a wet bar not a kitchen but it really met the definition of a kitchen.

Planning Commission heard these ordinance changes and recommended unanimously approving it with a clarification that the 110 and 120 volt outlet could be interchangeable That's included in the ordinance that's in the staff report. It's exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act, it does not provide for any real new construction. Staff's recommendations are to conduct a hearing on Ordinance 26-1003 and Zoning Ordinance Amendment 2603, receive and consider all public testimony and evidence, and adopt Ordinance 26-10003 approving Zoning Ordinance Amendment 2603 amending Section 6.04.9610 of the definitions of the Fillmore Municipal Code and a finding of exemption from CEQA. Happy to answer any questions.

not transcribed≈13s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:41:20

Thank you. So, in your opinion is this going...this will prevent from what happened over on Kensington from ever happening again? Okay. Yeah. So I feel confident that our Planning Commission did their homework and did everything. I know they're very thorough so Thank you guys for doing that and thank you staff for your work on this matter. That was my concern, is this enough to prevent somebody else from coming in?

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:41:54

Yeah, we want to make sure that the residents are safe and sanitary and that families aren't being packed in where they don't have appropriate facilities to live in. And especially today when you have this ministerial approval of ADUs, just go get an ADU permit and then get it done right and get your inspections and make sure your outlets are not fire hazards. We do have a lot of structural fires in the city so...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:42:16

But at the same time it's not going to prevent somebody coming In

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:42:22

fact the definitions of ADU and JADU, they have kitchens. And so now we know what a kitchen is.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:42:33

Any other questions? No. Seeing no other questions I'll open the public hearing at this time and if there's anybody here from the public who wants to speak on this matter. Then I'll close the public hearing and I'll entertain a motion.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:42:48

Okay, Mayor I'll make the motion that the City Council adopt ordinance number 26-1003. An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Fillmore California amending Fillmore Municipal Code section 6.04.9610 to update the definition of a kitchen and the definition of a wet bar and finding of exemption from CEQA.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:43:13

Thank you we got a motion to second? I'll second. Okay motion second all in favor? Aye Any opposed? A motion passes unanimously. Thank you, Brian.

Moving on to item number nine D public hearing considering zoning amendment 26-04 ordinance number 26-1004 amending the Fillmore Municipal Code to clarify that computer data centers are not an allowed use in the city including in the city's business park and industrial zones and finding of exemption from CEQA.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:43:45

Okay, thank you Mayor. This is Zone Tax Amendment 2604 Ordinance 26-1004 regarding data centers. As I was mentioning you may have heard that there was one proposed at the Ventura County Fairgrounds recently and they denied it so... A lot of cities around the country are doing the same. They're getting ahead of it. The data centers have actually not been around for a very long time, but residents complain of humming noises and things like that. There's articles coming out about that. So we're getting ahead of it here as well. This is to change the zoning to prohibit them. It's in the industrial and business park areas. These are the parcel numbers listed here. Notices went out to each and every one of these property owners that this was changing The locations are shown there, circled in green.

It's a business park and the other manufacturing and industrial zones in the city which you can see is one of our more limited land use designations. The current municipal code has something called computer data which is allowed to be stored in these zones but that was written in 1994 as what they understood to be computer data at that time It could have been floppy disks.

So they didn't anticipate maybe the magnitude of the AI and the way that technology has gone, and the amount of space and power that's needed to run these things. So in 1994 you had about a 500 megabyte hard drive. And you did have these computer rooms as you see on the left. And then now what you have is more what you see on the right which is more of a massive scale They require a lot of power.

And like I said, neighbors are complaining about the low humming that's occurring at all times. They tend to be high-power eaters. They have 24 hour electrical cooling telecommunications utility infrastructure. It requires a lot of utility planning and capacity, long-term electrical liability, high qualities of recycled water. They generate aesthetic impacts, noise, vibration, heat emissions, hazardous materials.

And so we are amending the municipal code to prohibit these because largely because of the effects that we're seeing today and because our general plan and our specific plans don't account for this kind of thing. We did a CEQA environmental analysis for our general plan and for the Business Park Master Plan, and this is not what was anticipated. There was a recent California Bill 887 passed which causes greater environmental scrutiny for these types of projects so they wouldn't comply with our CEQA documentation as it exists today in any case.

So the purpose of the Manufacturing Industrial Zone is for employment concentrations and you can imagine that data centers don't have much of any employment Let's provide space for manufacturing industrial. It's avoiding overloading of utilities, and it's adjoining adjacent areas. It's avoiding excessive illumination, noise, odor, smoke, and unsightliness. And it's to promote high standards of planning, architecture, landscaping, and the application of development standards and guidelines for manufacturing and industrial.

And so that's the character of what that zone is supposed to provide, and we felt that data centers don't fit within that description. Same goes for Business Park. This is a description of the business park, similar along those lines focusing on future employment enhancing the commercial corridor provide a variety of light and medium industrial uses hopefully someday we get some research and development or some manufacturing or something in these zones but we don't want to have that be ruled out by having massive data centers So it's to clarify what was our 1994 understanding of data versus what is a modern data center and this is what the code will look like. It will change, minor change but a big impact in terms of the change so it strikes computer data and then it specifies that does not apply to data centers in terms of storage The code amendment adds these five new sections, so it's a whole new chapter basically that goes into the section.

The purpose is to prohibit data centers, to enhance welfare and safety of the residents, protect residents from heat, noise, vibration, emissions, hazardous materials, and minimize the impacts on electrical water and telecommunications infrastructure which hasn't been assessed for the capacity that would be needed And keep those areas available for future businesses and employment opportunities, and economic diversification tax revenue and community serving benefits would be preserved.

So the definition of a data center is quite long. In 20 years, they might laugh at this definition but this is what we have here. It's kind of a combination of what some other cities have used, what the State Energy Commission uses so we believe we've captured it all here as to what could be considered a data center. The Planning Commission added that sentence there that's underlined.

That change has been added And then this is the rest of it here, and it has what's considered an exemption. And the Planning Commission added that underlying text as well for what's exempt. And we determined that this is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act. It does not provide for any new development and actually recognizes that the CEQA document that was previously prepared would not account for data centers In any case, we determine it's exempt from CEQA review to have this ordinance amendment.

Staff recommends that City Council conduct a public hearing regarding Ordinance 26-1004, zoning ordinance amendment 26-04. Receive and consider all public testimony and evidence presented of the proposed amendment and approve the first reading to introduce Ordinance 26-1004 Approving Zoning Ordinance Amendment 2604. Amending Municipal Code to clarify that computer data centers are not an allowed use within the City of Fillmore, including within the Business Park, Industrial Zone Districts and a finding of exemption from CEQA. Happy to answer any questions.

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:50:42

Thank you Brian.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:50:43

Any questions?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:50:44

Go

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:50:45

ahead. So thank you for your presentation Brian. My question is How, I know water is impacted and that these data centers use quite a bit of water. And this may be in my head like how was the water used? How is it cooled? Just wondering if you know.

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role1:51:03

It's used for cooling through these things that they call loops. So I imagine it's just basically a housing that the cold water runs through John may know more about this.

not transcribed≈9s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:51:17

I can talk to it, so basically what they have is imagine a fan like a radiator so the water's contained in a loop that goes from the heat source which is computers and then it carries the water via pumps over to the outside air so they either directly cool like a radiator would in a vehicle Or they have what's called an evaporative cooler that would use the evaporation of water.

Those use a ton of water because you're continuously feeding water in evaporative cooling system, but in a closed loop system they wouldn't use as much water as just have it going continuously in a loop. So the open-loop systems are the ones that use a ton of water Okay all

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:52:00

right thank you I appreciate it. Just couldn't wrap my head around how water is being used here okay thank you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:52:06

Thank you. Any other questions? All right, seeing no other questions I open the public hearing if there's anybody here or online that wants to speak on this item.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:52:18

No one online.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:52:19

Okay then I'll close the public hearing and entertain a motion.

1:52 – 2:0020 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:52:27

I'd like to make a motion that we approve the first reading to introduce Ordinance 26-1004, approving ZOA 26-04, amending the Fillmore Municipal Code to clarify that computer data centers are not an allowed use within the City of Fillmore including within business park and industrial zoning districts, and finding an exemption from CEQA.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:52:52

Thank you. Have we got a motion second? Motion second. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously, thank you.

Moving on to item 9E, formation of community facilities district number 7 Creekside.

CommentDebra CavaleroProposedself-stated1:53:23

All right. So good evening, Council Members. My name is Debra Cavalero, Finance Director. The City staff recommends that the City Council adopt the three Resolutions 26-4136, 27 and 28 presenting the staff report associated with the formation of the City of Fillmore Community Facilities District No. 7 Creekside. The resolutions are to complete the formation of the CFD, deem it necessary to incur bonded indebtedness due finance the acquisition and construction of authorized public facilities and other eligible costs, and hold a land election within the CFD to approve the levy of special taxes, the initial appropriation limits, and the bonded indebtedness limit. In addition, staff recommends the introduction and first reading of Ordinance No.

26-1005, levying the special taxes within the CFD. If all is approved this evening, the second reading will be held on October 27th, 2026. Prior to tonight's meeting, the City received a late submission of the CFD No. 7 report which has been provided to the City Council and is available upon request. I do have here Mike Medve who is the Will Dan Financial Services. He is here tonight and he is available to discuss the report if requested.

On October 25, 2026 the City Council adopted resolutions declaring its intention to form the CFD and incur up to $10 million of bond indebtedness for the CFD, all pursuant to the Mellow Roofs Community Facilities Act of 1982. And the CFD goals and policies of the city. A public notice was published on October 1st, 2026 in the Fillmore Gazette for the public hearing to be held this evening.

The proposed CFD were responsible for all the financial transaction expenses and any bonds that are issued will be the responsibility of the CFD not the City The City of Fillmore will oversee the financial arrangements of this, but will not be responsible for any of the expenses. This item meets the City Council goals for infrastructure and this is the end of my presentation and I will be available for any questions upon during the public hearing.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed1:56:13

A quick question, Deborah. So this is very similar to what we've done with the other developments as well right? This is nothing unusual for them to form a CFD for the development. Okay that was my question thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:56:32

So this is a time and place for holding of a public hearing on the formation of City of Fillmore Community Facilities District No. 7, Creekside. I now declare the hearing open and does the city clerk have any proof of publication or notice of hearing?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:56:45

Proof of publication is on files at the city clerk's office. It shows that the notice was published in a timely manner

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:56:54

Who will be presenting the staff report?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:57:00

We also have Annette Luck, Bond Council from Alisher and Weiner? Is that how you pronounce it? And Adam Pope, Municipal Advisor of Columbia Capital Management via Zoom for any questions.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:57:20

Have there been any written protests filed with the City Clerk against formations of the district or the services of the special tax?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed1:57:28

The City Clerk's Office has not received any written protest.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:57:34

Is there anyone present who wishes to address the Council on this matter, or online? If so please state your name and address and please limit your remarks to three minutes. No? Okay. Does any member of the City Council have any comments or questions? If there are no further persons wishing to speak on this item, I hereby close the public hearing and we present the following resolutions for adoption.

Resolution number 26-4136, a resolution of the City Council of the city of Fillmore determining the validity of prior proceedings establishing community facilities district number seven Creekside of the city of Fillmore authorizing the levy of a special tax within said district. Establishing an appropriations limit within said district. Establishing an appropriations limit Approving an acquisition and funding agreement, and taking certain other actions relating to said district.

Resolution number 26-4137, a resolution of the City Council of the city of Fillmore acting in its capacity as the legislative body of Community Facilities District No. 7 Creekside of the city of Fillmore determining the necessity to incur bonded indebtedness in an amount not to exceed $10 million within said district and calling a special election within said district.

And now we're going to motion. If you

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed1:59:13

could get a

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:59:14

motion? Yeah, can I get a motion on this item? So moved. I got a motion and a second.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed1:59:21

Second.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:59:21

OK, all in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:59:30

Mayor, I do have a question. Is there a third resolution?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:59:35

There is. OK. Oh, it's coming

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed1:59:37

up. Got

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed1:59:38

it. Sorry. Thank you. We now proceed with the final actions for the Community Facilities District. I'll present the next resolution. Resolution number 26-4138, a resolution of the City Council of the city of Fillmore acting in its capacity as the legislative body of the Community Facilities District Number 7 Creekside of the city of Fillmore declaring the results of a special election relating to the levy of a special tax therein, the issuance of bonded indebtedness and establishment of an appropriations limit.

2:00 – 2:068 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 15Proposed2:00:21

Excuse me, Mr Mayor. Can I make a comment? I'm your attorney for this matter. The clerk is supposed to open the ballot before you declare the results of the election so... Do you have the ballot with you? You want to open it and let us know whether it's marked yes or no?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 4Proposed2:01:04

The results are for, they're yes.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:01:08

Thank you we may now proceed with the final actions for the Community Facilities District and this time I'll present Resolutions for adoption. Resolution number 26-4138, a resolution of the City Council of the city of Fillmore acting in its capacity as the legislative body of Community Facilities District No. 7 Creekside of the city of Fillmore declaring the results of a special election relating to the levy of a special tax therein, the issuance of bonded indebtedness and the establishment of an appropriations limit.

May I have a motion please? So moved. Okay, I got a motion and second. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously thank you. As one last item of business, is there a motion to introduce, waive the reading and schedule a second reading and consideration of adoption of ordinance number 26-1005 levying special tax within CFD number 7 Creekside. Ordinance number 26-1005 and an ordinance of the City of May I entertain a motion, please? We have a motion and a second. All in favor? Any opposed?

not transcribed≈16s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:02:52

This concludes the matters relating to the City of Fillmore Community Facilities District No. 7 Creekside at this time.

not transcribed≈15s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
CommentRito MurilloProposedself-stated2:03:25

Moving

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:03:29

on to item 9F. Adoption of plan specification and cost estimate for project specification number 25-11, police station restrooms renovations project and authorization to advertise for construction bids

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed2:03:43

Thank you Mr. Mayor, good evening. Staff has recommended the City Council adopt the plans and specifications and engineers cost estimate for the police station restroom renovation project at 524 Sesbee Avenue and authorize staff to advertise the project for competitive construction bids The project will renovate the restrooms in each of the two locker rooms to address the current building code requirements and reoccurring plumbing issues.

The design plans were prepared by T&D Studios, which were completed on August 28th, 2026 and subsequently approved by the City's Building & Safety and Fire Department. The engineer's cost estimate for construction costs is $325,000. Although the project was not included in the adopted fiscal year 26-27 budget, sufficient funds are available in Development Impact Fee Fund 410, Public Facilities Police and General Fund 101.

Staff will present a recommended funding allocation and budget breakdown when construction bids are presented to the City Council for contract award consideration on December 8th. That is December 8th meeting. The proposed schedule anticipates advertising for bids on October 22nd, 2026. Opening bids on November 19th Awarding again at the construction contract at the December 8th City Council meeting and completing the construction between February and April 2027.

The project supports the City Council's strategic priority for upgrading public infrastructure and its core value of investing in reliable, modern systems that promote public safety, accessibility and quality of life. That concludes my report. I'd be happy to answer any questions.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:06:02

Thank you. Joe, any questions?

2:06 – 2:1123 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:06:06

So just to clarify, so it's not just the bathrooms, it's the bathrooms and locker rooms is that correct?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed2:06:12

It's the restrooms within the locker rooms. So, the female locker room is somewhat smaller in size and to meet ADA codes some of that locker room will undergo some significant changes, new lockers because of it. The male locker room is a little bit different. It has bigger footprint. We have enough space to work within The existing footprint of the restrooms within that locker room without affecting too much of the locker room itself.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:06:48

So in my kind of reading between lines here, so did we have to affect the footprint of the building and is that why?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed2:06:55

No. We're

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:06:55

working all within the focus.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 16Proposed2:06:57

Yes.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:06:58

Okay. Thank you. That was my question.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:07:01

Thank you. Any other questions?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:07:04

Sorry, I was going to make a comment that I was impressed that we have the lease agreement from 1987 for the police station and I'm sure it's just going to be much appreciated by our sheriff and staff there of this upgrade.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:07:21

That's it. Can I entertain a motion? Motion

UnidentifiedCity ManagerProposed · by role2:07:26

seconded.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:07:29

All in favor? Any opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Thank you, Joe. Thank you. All

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:07:35

right. Moving on to item 10 city manager verbal

not transcribed≈8s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen
UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:07:40

report.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:07:52

Thank you, Mayor. Just reminding the community that we have the Trunk or Treat event coming in a couple weeks. It's scheduled on Wednesday, October 28th on downtown Central Avenue. We have a sensory-friendly hour between 5 and 6 p.m., which allows a quieter, less crowded environment for those children who might not be too well in larger crowds And then the general event starts at 6pm. The registration deadline is on October 22nd, so we encourage you to register and come have some fun with the city staff and the community. So far I believe we have already 19 vehicles registered, so we are anticipating that the event may be a bit larger than last year.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:08:46

So speaking of the large event, we had a large event last year and a really big crowd and we're anticipating larger this year. Some recommendations that I remember that came right after our last track retreat was can we expand it either up a little bit on Central Avenue or down? I think it was just contained between Maine and Sespe and it was pretty crowded.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:09:07

So once we have the closure of like the registration deadline on the 22nd, staff is already contemplating that and will probably go up. I don't think we'll go down so we'll just go above CESB, yes. Thank you for reminding us in that feedback but we'll definitely make sure to account for that. But we're excited that we'll have a much larger event this year. Also, we already published it I believe so, a press release and also just information for the community to let them know that the Arundo cleanup will begin effective October 19th. We want to thank the Ventura Regional Fire Safe Council and Fire Chief Carolla and the fire staff for working closely with them, and also Public Works and our PIO for putting out the information.

This will contain two phases so the first phase will be The area that's closest to Sespe Creek and the Santa Clara River, and that's anticipated to begin on October 19th. And they will be conducted simultaneously, and they're also expected to take several days. Please follow the rules if you see that a pathway is closed do not violate and try to jump it. There's a reason why the path has been closed There will be chemicals being used in the area also to eliminate the Arundo and it's a very elaborated process. And for more information, please check the website for additional details as well. And then for the final comment I'm going to pass it over to Manny to provide an update on the ERF grant. Yes?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:10:56

So I actually got a question from a constituent on the Arundell specifically and my comment, or I guess my response to them was well you know we don't have complete control over the entire property where the Arundo exists but I believe we're going to do something for the city-owned property. Is that correct?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:11:14

It's along the bike path primarily and it's closest to the bike path area. It's not gonna be the entire Arundo area and the Santa Clara River. It's also areas that the city does not own. So it's just closest to the bike path.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:11:31

Okay, got it. Great,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:11:32

thank you. Sorry, just another point of clarification on that. We had talked about that it was going to be above the water lines, right? Above the flood

CommentDebra CavaleroProposedself-stated2:11:41

line.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:11:45

Maybe Chief can bring you into it. And what day was it again?

2:11 – 2:1718 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:11:54

October 19th.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:11:56

So I think everybody has the correct impression it is above the flood stage, anything above the flood stage we can't go below that per a lot of the restrictions we have on fish and wildlife. But that is, I think you were asking, it is primarily along the bike path. But it does include some area outside of the city. It's joint with the county and the little tiny area there, Gas Way, often times referred to as Sunken City. That'll encompass all of that will be eliminated also. There's a large patch that's close to some of the river street apartments there and their swimming pool, that's all going to be targeted as well as along the highway 126 I'm sorry Highway 23 Santa Clara Bridge approach on all that next to it everything again above the high flood stage

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:13:01

Is that under the bridge, is that above the flood?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:13:05

Under the bridge for about 15 feet underneath the bridge.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed2:13:13

I'm still confused.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:13:14

Sure.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed2:13:15

When you say, what's the term used in floods?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:13:18

Yeah high flood stage.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 8Proposed2:13:20

Okay so you're saying the Arundell is not actually being removed it's just being cut down lower?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:13:26

No, so the Arundo is actually going to be cut and then it's gonna have herbicide applied so it won't grow back. But that's everything above the flood stage. So there's a lot of Arundo that's been established for years and years where the Santa Clara River never touches it. So that's basically the areas we're talking about. So if you, for the exact location, if you're leaving Fillmore going to Moorpark before you enter the actual bridge everything off to the left or to the east that's pretty much gonna be all eliminated. There's quite a few large stands of Arundo in there.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:14:19

I'm just out of curiosity, have we put any notices out to people? Because I know we had constituents come and address the council before saying that hey, the Arendo's a problem and there's fire etc., etc. I'm wondering if we had noticed

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:14:34

anything. So we just published something on social media in a press release also and I believe it's already linked on the website too. Awesome,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 11Proposed2:14:42

great thank you. So just for clarification The timing has always been when the threat of any exposure to any of the nesting birds has gone away. So it was identified as early October before we could get started, so that's where we're at now. And one more question,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:15:04

are we going to post anything along the bike path?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:15:07

So Public Works is working closely with the contractor and that's why I made the comment. If you see that the bike path is closed please understand that it's because of the Arundell removal and they're working on getting that area cleaned up.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:15:22

Thank you. Thank You Chief. Hey nice catch doesn't he? I was just going

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:15:35

to have Manny give a quick report on the year of grant.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed2:15:41

I'll make it quick. Okay, so really good news for both our ERF grants. So we've got 10 clients that are enrolled in a rapid rehousing program in shelter. Ten in the rapid rehousing and so they're completely out of the encampment. Three are in emergency shelter, so a total of 13. And one of those 13 has been placed into housing, permanent housing will be... They've been approved to move a permanent supportive housing unit, so that'll happen in the next month or so.

So that's through the coordinated entry system through the county continuum of care. So just super pleased about the progress of the program. In addition to that We're going to be starting a thorough encampment cleanup and that will start actually tomorrow. A group of us, the case management team, the encampment clean up team, the HLU team will be going out to the various encampments sites and marking the abandoned encampments for for removal, and so they'll have more than approximately five days. It's a 72-hour minimum notice but the HLU team and their experience, they do that on a Wednesday so that also gives anyone that's there until the weekend to leave. And there hasn't been anybody since we've been down there in September that was down in that area.

So you know this, we don't anticipate forcing anybody out of their encampment That's fantastic news and I don't know, Mayor was it you and Mario that went to that

not transcribed≈11s of audible speech the AI couldn’t make out▸ listen

2:17 – 3:1319 turns

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:17:36

It was Manny that went to it. Okay, do you want to talk a little bit about this solution versus the one we heard about? I don't know if he

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed2:17:45

should or not. I won't mention the city but yeah so at the League of California Cities you know you're gonna get some really good workshops where you're gonna learn a whole lot and then you're gonna get some workshops and you know with content like gosh out of that Just to get right to it, they featured a city, Southern California City that wanted to share how they were addressing their homeless encampment situation.

Essentially what they did was they made the encampments areas, they passed an anti-camping ordinance which we have as well. But their program did not feature any type of rapid rehousing or any type of proactive work to try to place the individuals into an emergency shelter or housing situation. It was pretty much, you can't be here, you gotta go somewhere else kind of scenario.

You know, someone like me and us, the council members that want to learn more about how other cities are addressing those situations and learn. That unfortunately was not much for us to learn there so maybe perhaps the city of Fillmore next year will be one of the cities that can present on our program. I think we

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:18:59

should.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed2:19:04

I have a question regarding like the increased numbers. What was done differently? I know it's been like an uphill battle, you know connecting our folks down at the riverbed to services and I think we had one and then they kind of jumped off but That's amazing, but I would like to hear what you did differently. What the

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed2:19:23

team

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 9Proposed2:19:23

did differently?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed2:19:24

There was a key change in staff that was part of the issue. It was also the time needed to gain the trust and respect The case managers, also the Rapid Rehousing Program. That was something that took a couple of months to develop during the program so there was a combination of elements that were worked on but it all came together pretty quickly in the month of August once it got word to the community that hey look Not only is the program ready, we have the funds to place you in a sheltering situation.

But also I think the impending threat of the storms kind of really was a little worrisome given especially where the encampments are located. So I think that helped kind of create the perfect storm to get things moving so... Thank

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 6Proposed2:20:22

you. That's a great, really positive update. I wanted to ask when you gave some numbers, you said 10 enrolled in the program? What does that entail for those ten? What are they doing right now and what have they received?

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed2:20:37

So Rapid Rehousing, you know they're in the Rapid Rehousing program so they had to complete an application packet and then placed into a emergency shelter situation where there was financial or rent required to be paid for their placement. And so 10 individuals signed up for that program and are receiving Rapid Rehousing funds to pay for their or to fund their housing.

The three that are in emergency shelter are in a shelter such as the Harvard shelter.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:21:10

Okay,

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 14Proposed2:21:11

thank you. Thanks for clarifying.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:21:13

Thank you so much.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:21:17

That's it. Thank you.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:21:19

One last question, Erica. Has there been any update on potholes recently? If not that's okay

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:21:26

just maybe in the

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:21:27

future...

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 7Proposed2:21:28

So I think staff has been working on other priorities as we get closer to the rainy season then we can start the reports again.

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 3Proposed2:21:40

Okay great thank you so much

UnidentifiedUnidentified speaker 2Proposed2:21:42

Moving on to closed session. City Council will meet on two items, one conference with the real property negotiator. City Council will conduct a closed session pursuant to government code section 54956.8 to enable city council to consider negotiations and give directions to its negotiators regarding that certain real property. Conference with legal counsel anticipated litigation, the City Council will conduct a closed session pursuant to government code section 54956-9.9D2 because there is a significant exposure to litigation in two cases.

Council is back in session. We met in closed session on three items and no reportable action. I will now adjourn this meeting to our next regular scheduled meeting at 630 p.m. on Tuesday, October 27th. Thank you and have a good night.