UnGovr Transcript
iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.0:00 – 0:348 turns
Hi,
good evening everyone. I just want to call the meeting to order for the Oxnard City Council for Tuesday January 6th 2026 Madam Clerk, may we have the roll call and posting of the agenda please?
Roll call — called by City Clerk
Show transcript
The agenda for this meeting was posted in the kiosk at City Hall, the Oxford Public Library, the city administrative offices and on the city's website on Tuesday December 23rd 2025 thank you Thank You madam clerk
Prior to closed session, we will take public comments on the closed session agenda. Can the city attorney please provide a statement prior to closed session?
Thank you mayor. The City Council will recess to a closed session pursuant to government code section 54956.9 subdivision D1 to confer with its attorneys. The matter being discussed is Cerda versus County of Ventura et al.
Thank You Mr. Fisher. Madam Clerk do we have any speakers for Public comments prior to closed session.
And Mayor and Council Members, we do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for closed session. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Clerk. The City Council will now recess to closed session at 5 p.m. We will begin with an appointment item followed by a regular council meeting. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Clerk. The City Council has just emerged from closed session. I'm going to ask our city attorney for any announcements to make.
0:34 – 1:044 turns
Thank you, Mayor. There are no announcements out of closed session.
Thank you Mr. Fisher. We'll move to the appointment item.
The next item is... It's the appointment item from the Housing Authority. The subject entails a department workshop Good morning, everyone. Welcome to the City Council housing and community development department presentations. The recommendation is that the City Council receive and file an update report from the housing director and the community development director concerning information related to functions, priorities, challenges and anticipated future needs.
I see Ms. Brenda Lopez is here, our housing director along with Mr. Jeff We will move right into the presentation.
accompanied by our entire management team that is nervously sitting here in the public third to last seating rows, in case there's any specific questions that they can help answer to give a better overview of the programs and services that we offer to their community. So I'll go ahead and get started as we mentioned, we're gonna be providing an overview of the housing department and the various divisions.
So first start off, just with the overall setup of our housing department. We have a total of seven divisions and in this seven divisions we have exactly 68 employees. Something that is a little bit unique to the City of Oxnard is that our local housing authority is actually embedded or part of the Housing Department That is not unique across the United States, but at least here locally most housing authorities are a standalone if you will. But in our case which is very helpful we are part of our housing department and so both departments have work together but they do have separate budgets. So in the case of the Housing Authority, the programs are funded directly by the Department of Housing and Urban Development which we call HUD for short and the housing authority has a budget of about 40 million and again these funds come from HUD.
Under the Housing Authority we have the Housing Choice Voucher Division Better known as Section 8, and then also Public Housing. Both divisions focus on providing subsidized housing assistance to families. And we'll go into a little bit of detail well into the presentation. Then we also have our Rent Stabilization, Grants Management, Economic Development, Affordable Housing, and our Homeless Services Division.
So first off with the Section 8 Division, again part of the Housing Authority programs. Through this division we provide subsidized housing assistance to low-income families. We currently have approximately 1587 apartment units, single family residence condos in this program and we're housing about 3,695 individuals. We release approximately $30 million in housing assistance payments on behalf of the clients so tenants pay 30% in rent of their monthly gross income. These programs or programs under this program focus on helping the extremely low to very low-income families What that means is that their income levels are at 50% or under of the area median income level for the County of Ventura.
Some of the programs that are managed through the Section 8 include what they call specialty, or special purpose vouchers and here I won't go into too much detail but we have the emergency housing choice voucher homeless set aside. We have a VASH program which stands for Veteran Affairs Supported Program mainstream and family unification. On these programs the clients get a voucher, they look for a unit of their choice in the city of Oxnard and they're able to rent there where there's also what's called a project-based voucher program little bit different in that the voucher is tied to a specific unit so if a client gets what's called a project based voucher they are required to rent a unit wherever that voucher was awarded to And the functions that our staff play in this department, we have a couple.
So in the section 8 division specifically, we administer all of the waiting lists for the housing authority. Our staff is responsible for verifying the families are eligible for assistance. All units are in the program must be inspected at least once every two years and we do have an in-house inspector and outside inspector that helps us with this role And then our staff has to do what we call as case management basically means that we recertify the families on an annual basis.
If there's any changes during the year, we also re-verify eligibility. We verify if there's any change to their portion of the rent. And if not, then we recertify it on an annual basis. Again that's for the Section 8 program. I did want to give a very simple example. If you have a family of four, the maximum income that you can make on an annual basis for this program will be approximately a little bit under $75,000. So it kind of gives you an idea of how the families are doing financially.
Then the other program that we have under the Housing Authority is what we call as public housing. Now, public housing is a little bit different in that the Housing Authority operates and manages these units. So here, the Housing Authority staff serves as a landlord if you will or for lack of better word. We have a total of 523 units in our program. These vary from studios all the way to five bedroom units, and we are currently housing 1,412 individuals in this program.
The income limit here is still considered low but it goes up to what they call 80% of the area medium income. So the example that I provided previously family of four could be making close to 120,000 and still be eligible for this program. We also have a couple of units, we have specifically 17 apartment units that are owned by the Housing Authority. The difference here between public housing and non-public housing is just the funding source so the units are still rented only to low income families they are just being subsidized through other programs such as the Community Development Block Grant or some other federal state agency that might have awarded us the funds.
Staff in this division, similar to Section 8, must verify eligibility, collect documentation, admit families but here again we do function as a landlord so we do take care of any repairs that are needed to the property. We also enforce lease if there's any lease violations. We need to make sure they cure those violations And if not, then unfortunately we have to take the next steps.
Our public housing does have a capital fund division. Capital Fund Division staff is responsible for applying for a grant so that we can continue to improve our properties through the capital fund grant. funded by HUD as well. We also have a maintenance team, our maintenance team is responsible to respond to work orders and to maintain our properties and last but not least our public housing staff they're responsible for what I deferred to as case management which again is working with the families make sure they're eligible and also to make sure that we process any changes in their income that might affect their portion of the rent And our staff here too ensures, again ongoing compliance. And we are also responsible for inspecting our units just like in Section 8 except here the Department of Housing and Urban Development does do inspections.
They come independently and they inspect our properties. We got to make sure that they are in good standing if they're not that impacts our ability for future program participation and also it impacts how often we get audited. I'm not going to go into too much detail on the next slides, but these are just our sites. Our 523 units are located amongst 11 different sites in the city of Oxnard. We have units all the way out to Cuesta del Mar and in the northern end more by Othia Court. Most of our sites are either maybe 10 or 12 units except for the larger ones which in this case and the image on the screen will be Squires and Trevino which has I think like 102 units but other than that they're smaller projects And again, on this next slide just a couple more images.
These are a little bit outdated in the painting most of them have been painted since then the pictures were taken but again here our larger sites would be Palm Vista and Juanita and Felicia Court those three sites have at least 100 units. The other ones again are a little bit on a smaller scale Under the Housing Authority, we also have a different program. We don't consider it a division but we felt it was important to highlight it. It's our Resident Services Initiative Program which is operated and based out of the multi-service center at 1500 Camino del Sol.
Camino del Sol or the 1500 building is owned by the City of Oxnard, but the housing authority staff operate the building. So here we work with non-profit or organizations that offer services to the community at this point in time. We for example have New Dawn Counseling, we have CDR Catalyst which provide child care and early education services to low income families We have Future Leaders of America, and then we also have the extension of the public library which we call the Colonia Public Library Extension. On site our resident services initiatives also offer access to a computer lab and we also apply to a ROS grant. ROS stands for Resident Opportunity Self-Sufficiency Grant. Basically it's funding that we receive so that we can have a coordinator on site The coordinator coordinates with various agencies to bring programs not just to La Colonia neighborhood, they're open to all the community.
But basically things such as workshops on obtaining your citizenship, getting your GED, job fairs. We also put together a food share once a month we have food share distribution and we also bring other services such as helping with financial aid applications for students We have a mural project that takes place in back of this building. And again, all of this is through this ROS program. The coordinator I'll go into the next slide as well but the coordinator also works with our financial self-sufficiency coordinator for the FSS program. This slide I'll spend just a couple minutes on it was a question that was brought before us by council in the past and that was if we could share a little bit more information about the financial self-sufficiency program The FSS program for short is offered to our public housing and our Section 8 Program participants, so it is limited to them.
Right now we are at what they consider capacity. We have 126 households participating. The way this program works, it's an escrow account savings account. So basically when a family improves their self-sufficiency if their income increases, their rent increases that increase in rent instead of being put back into operating budget, we put it aside for the family in an interest-bearing account and we continue to hold it there. Once the family graduates from the program then we release the funds back to them. This is a typically a five year program. Families can improve their self-sufficiency various many many many tools. It could be improving your credit score so that you're not subject to predatory lending. It could be consolidating your credit card debt or It could be learning about homebuyer or homebuyer education so you could purchase your first home.
So again, financial self-sufficiency means different things to our families. So success is measured depending on their goals. Once again they participate for about five years. We did pull back our data just to try to see if we can get a little bit of statistics. So we went back to 2010 Since then, we've had 96 participants that completed the entire program. We dispersed a little bit under 1.6 million to those families and out of the 96 families that graduated, a total of eight did purchase their first home I personally met one of the participants, they did move out of state but they did purchase a home free and clear. Right now with the economy that is obviously going to be a little bit harder but that is a goal that the family can set for themselves.
Both are the Ross and the FSS coordinator also co-lead a PCC committee. The PCC committee is a program coordinating committee we have 50 agencies participating in the county We come together once a quarter where we talk about the various programs for low-income families, and we share best practices again so that we can help and meet our families where they're at. So that's a little bit about that FSS program.
And now we'll move over into the services provided by our Homeless Services Division. Our Homeless Services Division has two staff members, again we say small but mighty group and some of our efforts include encampment response efforts. Again this comes back to a grant that we received close to four million from the state where we were able to work with community partners and be able to respond to the encampments on McWane and Fifth Street We did two things. One was to come in and assist individuals where they were at to get them emergency services, and then for those that were able and willing to work with us to become ready to be housed we also then set them up in non-congregate shelter. You've heard about it as programs or as developments have come to fruition.
We've been transferring them out We had a total of 44 participants go through this program and they have all been successfully placed at either Casa de Carmen, Central Terrace or Casa Aliento. So we're very excited to have seen families be able to get back on their feet. In addition our Homeless Services team also does street outreach via two efforts twice a month. We go out there again with community partners We work with the Oxnard Police Department liaison to determine what areas maybe they've seen a little bit more individuals gathering around. We try to come to them and encourage them to seek services and connect them to services. We also participate in the one-stop clinic at The Salvation Army that's once a week, and that's walk-in so anybody who needs help is welcome to stop by and get services whether it's connecting them to health benefits or a food pantry or emergency housing.
And then also our homeless services program coordinator is responsible for the fall weather shelter. So we usually notify all of our community that this shelter is in place, we notify individuals how to seek for help. We activate the shelter whenever it's gonna get below 40 degrees Fahrenheit or when we're expecting a lot of rain. So last week I believe you guys heard us announcing we're activating our shelters second activation Usually we activate two to three times depending on how the weather does. So again, Homeless Services Division is in charge of that effort and then of course we help any community or any individuals from the community who come in and seek assistance related to emergency housing Just a quick highlight for our homeless services team, we also serve as the lead contact for the City of Oxnard.
We work along the continuum of care for Ventura County in the point account and just a little highlight that we always like to share is that in 2025, we did see a decrease in the number of unhoused individuals for City of Oxnard 15%. And this is the second year that we've seen a decrease. And obviously, that's not just our division but it is thanks to all of the efforts and all the programs that we have brought forward to the community to help house individuals who are unhoused.
And I'll move on to our Grants Management Division. Grants Management Division is in charge of administering the entitlement grants that the City of Voxnard receives on an annual basis. We receive three major grants, which are the Community Development Block Grant or CDBG. We receive HOME and then ESG as well. These programs are all focused in different areas. CDBG usually we fund public services or programs that improve the quality of social services available to the community Through HOME, we usually work with developers to be able to help them bridge any financial gaps when new developments are coming online for affordable housing projects. And then ESG really focuses on programs that are geared at addressing or preventing homelessness.
Our grants division is responsible for monitoring the grants. We also accept applications from internal and external organizations, we review the applications, we make funding recommendations, we are responsible for monitoring any agreements and then responding back to the HCD which is the entity that monitors these grants on how we're doing and if we're not able to perform why we're not performing. And again, that's the Grants Management Team.
And then our Rent Stabilization Division is responsible for enforcing and monitoring our ordinances that were put in place. The most recent one would be the Anti-Harassment, but the Just Cause Evictions and Tenant Protection Ordinance which we refer to as Just Cause for short. We also monitor the Rent Stabilization Ordinance. What we do here is we take calls or walk ins from the general public questions from landlords or tenants about their rights and whether or not a proposed change in term or rent is within the ordinance that is here in the City of Oxnard. We'll review the information provided if we identify that there's violations to our ordinance, we will work alongside our city attorney's office to determine if there are violations. If there are, then we issue citations to the landlords under the rent stabilization ordinance.
There our focus is to ensure that rent increases if a property is not exempt do not exceed four percent and if somebody has been asked to relocate that they've been provided their relocation benefits. If this has not taken place, we do contact the landlord and we don't issue a citation. Our first step is to encourage them to Work with the family, obviously reduce the rent and if the family already paid an origin rent that they get reimbursed for any origin rent paid. And here just on the graph on average right now in 2025 we did see an increase in calls and walk-ins please keep in mind not all of these become a case this could be general in nature but at the end of the day we do our best to either assist them or connect them with services but we had over 2 000 calls and walk-ins related to our rent stabilization or Just Cause Ordinance.
We also are monitoring or will be monitoring our anti-harassment ordinance. This one, this ordinance was just passed at the tail end of last year so we are working on recruiting the staff that was approved by City Council to help us manage this enforcement. So far we still are under recruitment for the investigator that will be working for the Housing Department and on our city attorney's office they have already brought somebody onboard that will be dedicated to assisting us to respond to anti harassment And then last but not least, our team also monitors the mobile home rent solicitation ordinance. This applies to about 20 mobile parks in the city of Oxnard where we basically monitor rent increases and we also facilitate any appeals on if there's a dispute on the amount of rent increase for rent space.
Our affordable housing division, economic division. Here we do a couple of things for our economic development team. Our team was dormant at least in the housing department for about a year while we recruited a staff member so our manager just came on board and our supportive staff. So in 2026 we will be revamping our efforts on assisting businesses to launch grow or start their business here in the city of Oxnard And then on our affordable housing division or team, we have a couple of responsibilities. One is the loan servicing and monitoring of units and affordable development projects that received some sort of either assistance from a funding perspective or perhaps a density bonus so our team will monitor ensure that they're in compliance with any covenants or deeds or restrictions on the property.
We currently have 642 units. These are owned in the community by Oxnard residents where they received some sort of assistance. This could have been to rehabilitate their property or down payment assistance, so we're responsible for monitoring those up to 30 years depending on when they got their loan. And then we have 3,603 apartment units that we're monitoring which are all under 47 developments in the city of Oxnard. And again here we ensure that any restrictions are being abided by by the developer Just wanted to share a couple of projects that the affordable housing team assisted with via funding and helping them identify sources of funds for any gaps in their finances. In addition to that, all of these projects have project-based vouchers tied to them.
How does that help us? Twofold it obviously helps the developer to be able to bridge the financial gap but for us in the community it makes units available for our low-income families. Sometimes even if you get a Section 8 voucher, it doesn't guarantee that you're going to find an apartment or you know that it's either that the landlord will be willing to bring down the rents or maybe that you have enough of a security deposit to be able to rent so whenever units have a project based voucher tied to them it helps us because then the family usually has to jump through less hurdles to be able to secure an apartment. And so here we just have, um, we have our Ormond Beach Villas, Central Terrace, Casa Aliento and Dolores Huerta in Casa de Carmen.
So all of these projects came online and all of them have project-based vouchers. I just wanted to put a little shameless plug here. The Choice Grant is not a division, it is actually a grant that the City of Oxnard and the Housing Authority applied for. The Choice Grant is an initiative from HUD and what we're seeking to do is to come up with a transformation plan that will revitalize Five of our neighborhoods here in the City of Oxnard, which include La Colonia, Fremont South, Wilson, Hubson Park East and five points Northeast. What we're doing is we're assessing what resources are in the community where the community needs. We're having focus task meetings. We'r working with our various divisions in the city of Oxnard and our goal is to come up with a proposed transformation plan and we would like to apply for the choice implementation grant in a year So right now we're in a two-year cycle, if you will.
We did receive $500,000 for this work so that we can put together the plan and be able to submit it to HUD hopefully at the end of next year. And of course all of this is subject to funding. To wrap up my presentation, we just wanted to highlight a couple of challenges and some requests for your ongoing support as we come before you to propose recommendations or your support in programs. I think just with any other division, we obviously are on standby for changes in federal regulations that depending on what they are, are going to have a significant impact on our families. I think at the forefront most of us are familiar with the mixed status family Basically what that means is that the government might be changing which families are eligible for assistance.
At this point in time we don't know, we don't have an answer so we're on standby but depending on what at the end of the day is passed by our administration it could have a significant impact on our families And also we have an act that's called the Housing Opportunity Through Modernization Act, HOPMA for short. It's a change in our laws and policies that govern public housing section eight. This has been on the books for probably almost a decade. And every year we get a different implementation date. So what that means for our staff is the challenge of the administrative burden of running our program under two policies. So right now, we have what we call the pre-HOTMA, the post HOTMA and so our staff has to make sure that when they're reviewing eligibility and our clients that they're applying the rules that are in place and not the ones that are going to come in the future.
So again, just a little bit of a challenge. We also, of course, have the uncertainty of funding as I mentioned. The Housing Authority is primarily funded by the Department of Housing and Urban Development. The funding goes away. That jeopardizes Section 8 public housing and any housing authority-owned properties. Our entitlement grants are also state funded. So if that funding goes away, that would impact how much funding we have available to provide or to facilitate for our community partners so that they can bring services to their community. Increased cost obviously as rents go up, our Section 8 program is not able to assist as many families as our per unit cost increases. In addition, if or until such time that the Department of Health and Urban Development passes a budget Sometimes if it looks like a housing authority will not have sufficient budget they'll be placed on what's called shortfall status.
What that means is basically we can't admit more families into our program, we're on standby but unfortunately that could negatively impact our next year's allocation as your prior year allocation is taken into consideration so that's a challenge that we're navigating through and of course when we're looking at assisting our low-income families in becoming first time homebuyers as an example Layering the down payment assistance necessary for them to be able to afford a unit has become very difficult as these units would have to be deeply affordable in order for them to be sustainable by our families. As always, demand will always exceed supply on our affordable housing units and I think just like with any other departments we've had a couple of vacancies and whenever there's a vacancy we obviously want to make sure that we bring the best candidate on board that could take time And in that time, it could create a backlog.
In addition, a lot of our housing specialists have to have very specific, a very specific niche skill set and that could take one to two years to fill the vacancy. So again, these are just challenges that we were seeing across. And then some of our ongoing needs, we do ask for your continued support with our conversion program. This is called the Rental Assistance Demonstration Program or RAD. You'll hear us coming through the year and proposing strategies on how we're going to reposition the public housing program under the Housing Authority. The reason we want to do that is because if we reposition, we can set up a platform where we're generating the necessary revenue to be able to cover the deferred maintenance on our properties. So again, we ask for your continuous support on this in addition to the continuous support for rent stabilization division I mentioned this division specifically because we are working on a fee study and while we get the fee study up and running and we can generate that revenue We do ask for the sustained levels of funding so that we can have our dedicated staff and we can continue to respond to the community.
In the meantime, the choice grant as I mentioned here if you get invited to a meeting or for your input, we greatly appreciate your continuous support and of course if we have opportunities to assign project-based vouchers to developments, we strongly recommend that opportunity because again it increases inventory for our families And then last but not least, to please continue funding our efforts on addressing or programs that will address the needs of our own house population. Whether it's mitigating efforts or our response. Okay? And with that I'll open up for any questions.
1:04 – 1:1320 turns
Mayor.
Thank you.
Mayor?
Go
ahead. Thank you. First of all, I'd like to...I want to compliment you. Very responsive and I want to share with the City Council a recent incident That I that where you were involved we had a disabled resident in my neighborhood With two small children who were section 8 recipients And they were at risk of being displaced or they were being displaced from their apartment just before Christmas because there was a sewage was backing up into her shower. So there was no way that she could live under those circumstances and she reached out to me for support, and I knew the right person for me to reach out to was Brenda Lopez. And you were definitely on top of it. You had support from your staff, I believe Alba Marshall as I recall? Yes. Alba. And I believe you also brought in Code Compliance Manager Andrew Dixon who's in the audience here And my understanding is I think that there was a citation and, I guess, yellow tag, I think for the particular apartment.
So I was really happy that you facilitated a lot of that. You've got a good team that's working with it for you. And just as an aside, I also want to acknowledge Attorney Barbara Macri-Ortiz because you reached out to her And she actually came to the defense of this person drafting a demand letter to the apartment managers. So that's why I wanted to start off with just simply saying, you know, very impressed.
I do have a question about the self-sufficiency program. Wanted kind better understand that. So what happens to the money if the participants never graduate from the program? They've got all this money is going into savings it's There for their purposes like there are any interest maybe they're paying taxes on me. I don't know but what happens if Somebody dies, somebody just can't go forward. What happens?
So twofold usually our coordinator will meet at least on a monthly basis with the participants to try to get ahead of them not meeting their goals. We do afford the opportunity that let's just say as an example you wanted to get your bachelor's that's not possible maybe you want to get your associates we can modify those goals through meeting and, you know, through the five-year time frame. But let's just say a family cannot complete that's called a forfeiture of the program we close it out those funds go back into a forfeiture FSS account and there are made available four programs that will benefit the rest of the families so basically goes back into the pool of funding available for us to then bring more services to those families that do remain on the program does not go back to the family
I see. And do they have any concerns about that? When they're participating in the program, are they concerned that hey what if I don't make it? I paid all this money and I'm now in worse shape than when I started?
There could be, I think from my end the perspective that I would offer is that when a family's income goes up their portion of the rent goes up right and that funding goes back to the housing authority for operations. So if somebody doesn't participate in the program their funding goes back to operations here there's this little carrot if you will to incentivize them to try to improve but if not basically we're putting the funds back where they go back to operations so Kind of the families treated like any other person who did not participate.
And I would very much appreciate if you would take the time to introduce some members of your staff when they're here and they're doing good work for you, and I'd like them to
Sure, you're seeing me smile because they're very shy and they were hoping I wouldn't call. I promised that wouldn't call them up but we'll start here with Alba our rent stabilization team. You can raise your hand she's our supervisor for rent stabilization. Susana public housing supervisor. Freddie our superintendent for our capital improvements public health units. Lorraine our brand new grants manager Michael, our Homeless Services Manager. And then Alex, right? Raise your hand. Alex is our Housing Programs Manager. Leti is our Section 8 Program Supervisor. Rhonda is our Finance Officer for the Housing Authority and Elsa is our Affordable Housing Manager and right next to her are our new Economic Development Manager. That's our team.
Thank you very much. Thank you. That's all I have today.
Thank you, Councilmember. Go ahead, Councilwoman.
Yes, I had a question specifically about the economic development. I know you said you just hired somebody so it might be a preliminary question but what kind of programmings are we offering for folks who wanted to help their business launch grow and succeed in our community?
Most definitely. So right now we kind of like I mentioned, we've been a little bit dormant but we did start already our workshop so we are partnering with EDC and not just EDC but sometimes with WEAVE. So with different businesses or not businesses, with different organizations that help businesses. So we're leveraging our partnership but again we just started so usually what we want to do is bring In addition to helping facilitate connecting to the right departments in the city, we're also bringing any workshops that will help them improve their business. So depending... To give an example, we got mentioned that maybe something like in the financial QuickBooks or some sort of a software that they will find that helpful so we're doing this through workshops but we just had our first three and we're looking forward to growing this.
We are also looking into finding opportunities to work on improving Education and connecting or increasing the education for our community, our youth. So we have a lot of programs that we're looking at and look forward to initiating and getting back up and running.
Okay great. And when you say we, you're talking women's economic development
program? Economic development and then also our partners because we don't do it ourselves. We leverage our partnerships.
So like through non-profit partnerships and all that okay so shameless plug But it'd be great to connect maybe with the local community college to see if there's any internship opportunities or possibilities for strengthening that. Please don't feel pressured, I was just thinking out loud.
Thank you. Go ahead Councilwoman.
Thank you Director Lopez for your presentation and for the work that your staff does. I've had the opportunity to participate in the Backpack outreach as well, backpack medicine outreach and have joined our Oxnard PD on the homeless liaison aspect. So definitely I've seen firsthand just the impacts of that work and just curious, I know one of the slides highlighted the emergency housing vouchers and I'm curious if there's any impacts on funding for those and just logistically the number So
the emergency housing voucher program, that program was made available by HUD when COVID happened as a way for us to be able to respond quickly to individuals who were either losing their job, losing their homes or they were already unhoused. So in a way to prevent individuals from congregating and spreading the virus. The EHB program was supposed to be funded for several more years, but in the later part of last year we were notified that HUD no longer intends to fund the program. So as soon as we receive this information our understanding is we are funded through around August-September of next year. That could change. That's a difficult thing right now that anything can change. But we are funded through most of this year. So we are funded through either August, September of this year depending on our per unit cost.
As of right now our plan is to continue working with the continuum of care. They've stepped in very quickly to say let's see what programs are available And second to this, I'll be coming before you in about a month or two with our proposed PHA plans for the Housing Authority. One of the items is a preference for the EHB families to be able to be absorbed into the Section 8 program so that we can avoid terminating them from the program. So there's a couple of things that we're doing in-house to address this potential... It sounds like they're going to terminate the funding again Thank you for sharing. I think the last thing I wanted to highlight really appreciated the work that happened regarding
1:13 – 1:1813 turns
The anti-harassment ordinance. And I know the recruitment, as you mentioned is underway and just curious for the next report if we can kind of get a sense of numbers similar to the chart that you provided for the rent stabilization. And also just curious if as a part of that process, as we think about onboarding, if there will be an outreach in education mechanism? I oftentimes hear from community members They're just not aware of a lot of the ordinances that we pass and how do we get that information out so that people know where they can come and who they can call for support.
Thank you for the question, and yes most definitely now that we have our staff in place. We've also been recreating the rent civilization team but our plan is to do more concentrated efforts on marketing and doing more community outreach on these services. Right now what we do kind of what our council member started mentioned As soon as we're notified of any potential relocations or tagging of properties, we immediately have staff go on site to provide education about the various programs that we have in place. But we also want to be obviously proactively letting the rest of the community know so that is definitely on our to-do list for this coming year.
Great thank you.
Any other
questions at all? Go ahead Mr. Peralta.
Thank you very much for the report and the time Your staff's put into this a couple of questions on slide 3 you had there is a title wait list administration. Can you tell us how many wait lists are there for the various products that we have in housing authority?
Thank you for the question. We have a total of 11 waitlists that we're managing out of the eleven, four of them are actually housed if you will by the housing authority what that means is that we administer, we open, we close and we issue vouchers or we assign them to a unit And then on the other six waiting lists, we also administer but it's a little bit different. And then on those six waiting lists they're what they call referral based. So for example for what we call the VASH program for veterans, the VA is responsible for referring us the clients and we established a waiting list Thank you. Along the same lines, can you give us a rough idea low to high how many people are on these various wait lists?
So in the four that we are, for lack of a better word, directly responsible for. So think of like your Section 8, your Ormond Beach Villas, Public Housing and Las Cortes. We have a little bit under 1500 applicants but also keep in mind some applicants have been waiting since 2013 and the other ones since 2019. So we usually try our best, a new best practice that we've been enforcing is not to open our waiting list until we know that we're about maybe two years away from being able to provide assistance. But they do have lengthy waits. On the other six waiting lists I really don't have a number because those are tied to referrals and are based on unit turnover.
That's extremely important information for the public and the council here. I'm just assuming if you can help me out The city of Oxnard is not unique probably to that size of a wait list. Other large communities throughout the nation would probably have wait lists if they have a housing program?
Absolutely, not unique. I don't know of any jurisdiction so far that doesn't have an extensive wait time. I don't know many that have their wait lists open. That's the other challenge but yes absolutely. I'm pretty sure across the nation a lot of us have extensive wait lists.
Thank you. On slide number 11, there's a discussion about the various HUD housing and urban development programs and the things that they're involved with. Does housing and urban development provide audits on these various programs with some regularity?
Absolutely. All of the programs are subject to audits and it just really depends, kind of as I mentioned depending on how your program is performing that's how often they will come and audit you but yes we can be audited at any point by any of our entities that grant us funding.
And one last question again thank you very much for taking time to answer The individual that you showed the pictures and they were, the individuals able to get purchase a house. Are there requirements if those individuals are in a situation to purchase a house? It has to be purchased within the city of Oxnard or can they carry that to some other community?
Thank you very much. And again, thank you to your staff.
1:18 – 1:4111 turns
It's a part of our community that a lot of the public has no idea what's involved. When you hear the numbers of people that you're supporting, taking care of and the number of people that are waiting to get involved it's a big chunk of our community that's impacted by this. Thank you.
Thank You Mr. Perlow for those questions. Go ahead Councilor.
Thank you Mayor and along with what Councilmember Perrello mentioned this is just going to be my only comment was thank you, Miss Lopez and to your staff who are here. It's not lost on me I'd imagine on many in this room as well that the amount of work that you have in front And it's very important work. I would imagine each of your managers there would probably be open to even doubling or tripling the size of staff they have, and still trying to meet the demand for work that we have here.
But knowing that programs shift, programs change, administrations at the federal level come and go, even with funding changes or funding reductions, there is not a proportional reduction in need in our community There's still a families who have the need there still the need for housing. They're still these unmet needs for our own house population and the works there, the need is there regardless and so I just want to thank all of you for all of your work and the staff that you oversee as well.
I know that as I mentioned it's plenty of work to go around but we work with what we have and it's much appreciated and this is a great overview to see just the amount of work you're able to accomplish given the resources and I hope federal changes, we can see what we can continue to do with that. So thank you.
I was just wondering if you could just elucidate a little further on the Resident Initiatives Program and the number of people with services, and just provide more detail on what that is.
On the Resident Initiatives Program, as Ahad mentioned, we have twofold. We do have a ROSS Services Coordinator so we do have a staff member that is dedicated to putting programs together. These programs vary. We also look for other funding opportunities. I don't have the number of individuals assisted because, for example, a job fair is open to the entire community. Even though we will really try to focus our marketing there locally so people can come right over. We're right in the middle of the Colonia public housing site. We do open it. We communicate to our 50 partners, hey, we have this job fair. Can you come and participate? So I don'y have the numbers but we also even do other events for the community. We do national night out.
You know candy handout during Halloween if they celebrate. Toy drives, so we do do various efforts and again We don't really collect how many people but as far as case management that program does require that we have at least 50 families on an annual basis that are participating alongside our ROS services coordinator And this is more connecting them to services So not necessarily on a five-year plan or escrow savings account But more of showing that we've connected them to whatever resources they needed. So we do have to show outcomes for the fund, for the grant but I wouldn't have the numbers on that.
That's okay and it was just so our public can hear because I'm certainly a staunch supporter of the relationship we have with our housing authority. And I echo what the council member said about your leadership and I think it was the greatest appointment we made through Alex in appointing you. I think the way you're leading that department is wonderful. I see a lot of familiar faces with Freddie And others that are Susan and I see are back there, but I think you got the right people doing that kind of a job. Certainly I think we get that providing assistance for housing to our community is such an important role in all the positive outcomes that come from offering housing to our most in need with educational outcomes and health, or resourcing appropriately certain neighborhoods.
And that's where my question with the resident is just bringing people together. So I just compliment you and your staff for all that you do for our community. So thank you. This was a very well put together presentation. Thank you very much.
Thank you. Appreciate
it. If there are no other questions? Madam Clerk, are there any public speakers on this presentation?
Mayor and council members, we do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for this item. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Oh, sure. And just for those that are arriving, we're going to... Our intent is it was to start at 6 o'clock. We may just go a little bit over. So if you'd just bear with us, we have a presentation from our director for community services that's going to be here presenting. Go ahead, Mr. Pingeli.
Good evening, Mayor Pro Tem Council. Jeff Pingeli serve as the Director of Community Development. I'm gonna do a recap as briefly as I can of our presentation. It's posted online. This is an overview of the Community Development Department as part of the workshop series here If I can get the slide back. And I'll do a quick recap and I'll touch on a few things, and I have many of my management staff here as well to answer any follow-up questions you may have.
Our department briefly is filled by 70 full time employees in the three divisions of building and engineering planning and code compliance, you can see there. Real briefly, building and engineering is unique to our city where it's a traditional building department and land development engineering combined under the one-stop shop model. We also have in our planning division we have both current planning and long range planning and sustainability that team also handles the cannabis program.
And we have our code compliance division Again, supporting quality of life and the other divisions support quality of life, economic development, infrastructure and natural resources. And yes, those are consistent across all divisions. How we serve the community? We'll touch briefly on each of the major functions in divisions, long range planning and sustainability does a lot of work more behind the scenes. Most people think of our department as permitting dealing with entitlement CEQA inspections, et cetera. And we do that and we'll talk about that but our long range planning team looks forward and deals with projects like the climate action adaptation plan, the local coastal program, general plan update, housing element update, commercial cannabis business program.
And I inadvertently left off this list a very important project to the city, the Ormond Beach restoration and access program. Our sustainability teams spends a lot of staff time working on that A couple of projects to touch on. The South Oxnard Connect, it's a grant funded development of a transit oriented specific plan specifically in South Oxnard that the sustainability team worked hard to pull together that grant and to tailor it to fit this specific neighborhood.
The local coastal program I mentioned before, that's a three-year work effort and it is a subset of the general plan update but it's a big work effort. A lot of community outreach and we'll have more back in front of Council on that later this year. I mentioned the Climate Action and Adaptation Plan, again for the community's awareness that was adopted by Council in 2022.
And that's to be consistent with state laws regarding greenhouse gas emissions of course. One of the components of that is the EV charging program and we have just released, I believe this week, an RFP for an EV charging vendor Based on a franchise agreement model, and we'll be bringing that back in front of council when a vendor is selected. And I mentioned the commercial cannabis business program.
And again, that's been in operation since 2022. And just the business tax revenue from that has been about $5.5 million today. Code compliance, again how we serve the community. They deal with quality of life issues, substandard housing, unpermitted construction, short-term rentals, graffiti, illegal dumping all those things that can bring down a quality of life in a neighborhood and other parts of the city even our commercial industrial districts.
This is a photo of a substandard housing condition obviously from Oxnard. Current planning, building and engineering talking about how we serve the community. These divisions work together and enact state laws and ensure that construction is compliant to our city codes and standards. I mentioned land development engineering being a part of building in engineering but the planning department together with us and having the fire department next door to us provides a true one stop shop model. We moved into our current facility around 2008 and we were scattered in different parts of the city It's been a very efficient collaborative work environment.
As mentioned, we work with fire housing public works and other city departments as well as outside agencies to ensure the construction is safe energy efficient and that we process permits in a timely and efficient manner. There's obviously the Casa de Carmen project and the 101 logistics stream project on the right there. Just for some rough metrics, in 2025 we had over 10,000 walk-in customers we served. Another 2,600 served online. Over 25,000 building inspections.
Currently we have over 16, approximately 1600 housing units under construction and another 1800 in the permitting process. Regardless of the size of the project whether it's an ADU or a patio cover or a hotel or a large project our goal is to treat all of our customers with respect and serve them each efficiently. Another function within the building and engineering division is floodplain administration, maintaining compliance with FEMA standards. Maintaining the city's CRS rating to help reduce or prevent flood losses and access discounted flood rates to residents of the city.
You'll see the photo on the left in Oxnard Shores from the more modern homes built up on concrete piles to avoid wave impact flood damage And the photo on the right is the floodgate being built as part of the SCR3 levee project on Ventura Road. As far as progress goes, this is one metric and the back story is that post COVID there was a lot of staff departures and a lot of backlog that had built up and so if you look at the left side of the graph It's a little hard to see here. Around the fall of 2022, we started receiving additional funding from Council. We are very grateful for that funding and we've applied it aggressively, increased our staffing, increased our consultants, got all of our contracts with our consultants in order. And as you can see the steep drop of the blue curve as our backlog dropped from 470, 479 A manageable number now, you can see the red trend line that continues to decline over time.
Just before the holidays it was about 219. Anything between 200 and 300 is manageable. It's about the amount of workload we can process in one month's time. Additionally as far as progress goes, we've had what we now call the Permit Fast Track Program We've had that in effect for, we're guessing over 28 years. I've been with the city 26 and it predates me. This is a for business oriented permits whether it's a commercial or industrial business.
This is a plan check in one hour program by an appointment. It's been tremendously successful There are no extra fees, there are no prequalifications, no forms, no insurance. It's just whatever you would normally submit for a permit package for a tenant improvement, for example. And it can be in heavy industrial facility, it could be Procter & Gamble, it doesn't matter. If it's something that's a smaller project that we can reasonably look at in one hour, we'll take a shot at it. If it's larger than that, we'll still take a look and provide feedback in a one-hour info only session but again, that's been going for about 28 years We've added a residential component to that in January of 2025, the Residential Fast Track Program. That was designed to provide some relief to the increasing number of residential projects particularly accessory dwelling units ADUs and again that's a plan check in one hour by an appointment No additional fees or paperwork is required.
That program is about 85% consistently full, the business related one is about 70-75% full consistently so we have a little more room so we want to get the word out Other options include the Permit Simplicity Act Measure F program. It has been implemented diligently and continues to be implemented, however there's not been a lot of interest in that. We've offered eight training registration sessions as indicated in the table. We've had some interest but nobody has followed through and become an actual applicant to the program.
Housing production, great segue after that great presentation by our housing department. We issue permits for all the housing construction in the city whether the city is a partner in that or it's a market rate development where if it's accommodation of the above right now we have approximately 6,000 units on the horizon and about 1,600 of those are under construction and you can see a breakdown there Those that are proposed, those are under construction and plan check.
Some approved specific plans and a proposed specific plan totaling a little over 6,000 units on the horizon. Another item to highlight in terms of progress is the EPL software program enterprise permitting and licensing. We've been working on that since 2024 This will enable digital plan reviews, an online portal for customers to find real-time data on their inspections and plan checks, enhanced reporting for better real time management of department performance. And I couldn't resist putting a photo on the right of our existing green screen that we love. It's bulletproof but it does not meet any of the current technology standards and we're looking forward to this and we're very grateful for the funding council has provided for that.
One more quick shot on the right of our paper world that we're still in. That's one corner of our plan room. As I mentioned in the presentation, some larger projects and individual role plans can weigh 50 to 70 pounds. They need to bring in six sets for each of the three to five submittals for a large project so it's a lot of tonnage coming across our desks each year. The image on the left is a simple portal for submitting online. It's going to be miraculous.
So quick segue to challenges, the EPL implementation. The software implementation is in itself a challenge. It's a challenge we're happy to take on and I commend staff for the tremendous work they're doing keeping the gears turning while spending a tremendous amount of time working on this software implementation. Currently we're scheduled to go live. This is tentative. Don't publish it but it's tentative March 27th of this year And we expect there to be some about six months of both customers and staff getting used to it and working out the kinks. We will, of course, have training plenty of training of our staff beforehand but you can't know all the details until you're running it live.
And I do want to commend our finance director in our IT director for their support and help through this project Another challenge is increasing workload. The unpermitted food vendor phenomenon is something that has impacted city residents and we have been enforcing it through what we've called the HERO program, hazard elimination and reduction operations. The fire department has taken the lead on this. This is the enforcement of the fire codes And with help from Oxnard, a lot of assistance from the Oxnard Police Department and a lot of support from the city attorney's office.
We do after hours operations to remove this fire and safety risk from our residents. These are predominantly vendors from outside of this area and these operations pose a fire safety and health risk. The food they're bringing is uncertified it's not Health Department approved there's no knowledge of where it came from When it expired and there's almost never any refrigeration or ice or anything like that, they're just pulling this meat out of the back of a van literally in black trash bags and serving it to our residents.
We do collaborate with Ventura County Environmental Health on these operations as much as possible. We have a lot of rapport with them, they can't come out every time because they're dealing with this countywide but they have been a great resource so we're addressing the fire risk and when possible Ventura County Environmental Health does join us. Some of the challenges that residents may not be aware of is that our state has decriminalized unpermitted vending through those laws mentioned there, SB 946 and 972.
That significantly reduced our city and other cities' ability to mitigate this hazard to our residents. In 2025 again enforcing it through the fire codes we conducted about 50 after hours operations to mitigate this and protect our residents Oxnard is currently the only city in Ventura County actively addressing this health and safety and fire risk to our residents.
Another challenge is state housing laws since 2020, over 100 laws have been passed with good intent in most cases to increase housing production however they've gone into nearly every aspect of permitting and I've listed a few of them there it's just a challenge for us to keep up with them to adjust our processes where necessary, to be compliant. And in some cases they're quite challenging such as requiring the implementation of an online permitting system.
We had to pass an exemption through council to give us a three-year extension because we were working on it. That's not a quick and easy fix and that's very costly for cities to do. CEQA processing how things are processed and exemptions for CEQA Timelines, ministerial approvals and allowance for housing development in commercial zones post entitlement deadlines. Project density increases etc. It's just a myriad of patchwork of laws that aren't cohesive they are trying to do a good thing but they're hitting nearly every angle of how we operate and it's tough to keep up with that We did create a new position for a housing planner specifically to help us address those issues a year ago.
The increasing workload is another challenge I wanted to touch on, the proliferation of ADU permit applications as you can see in the table it has been rising considerably since about 2019-2020 ADU permit processing currently occupies about 40% of our plan check and permit processing workload. That's a new workload that did not exist prior to 2020. And as you've heard from other departments, recruiting is a significant challenge especially for the higher level positions both in engineering and planning.
Several positions have taken, as you've heard from other departments 18-24 months and some remain unfilled I did make a mistake here. We have seven vacancies out of seven, not six. We didn't recently lose one. I just miscounted. But the good news is by way of comparison there was a point in time where we had only three of 11 current planning positions filled. Now that's reversed. We have only three vacancies out of 11 and at another point in time we had only one out of four of our building plan check engineering positions filled and currently those are all filled But recruiting is a challenge. We're utilizing recruiting firms who are working with HR to look at salary ranges to make sure we're competitive, especially with other local cities.
Over the next three years, the overall challenge is how to implement our new permitting software while we're very busy and to keep the gears turning and not impact our customers. That's one of the big challenges Continuing to address changes in workload as mentioned the increasing number of ADU projects, ever-changing state laws and also the unpermitted food vendor activity.
I will say on the unpermitted food vendor activity when we started with the fire department and police department in our after hours operations under the hero program There were about 35 regular setups around town. Quickly, within a few months and at a steady state since then there's about three regulars that set up. And again they're predominantly almost universally from out of town.
And we'll continue to work closely with HR in filling those vacancies and particularly for those challenging higher level positions The other part of that is make sure we retain our existing employees. So, we make a lot of effort to hire good quality staff that can not only work with the public but work with each other internally as well and we try to be as supportive of them as we can.
That concludes this presentation and again I'm here along with many of our management staff to answer any questions you may have.
1:41 – 1:467 turns
Any council members have any questions of staff on this item? Go ahead, Mr. Perlow.
Comments. Thank you very much for the presentation. First off at the very beginning slides I give you credit for putting on their vacancies in red letters but we didn't get a chance to spend a lot of time there. We're trying to pick up the pace. I very much appreciate the fact that you're trying to fill all these slots because I'm going to give you one that's an uncomfortable question but I get it all the time You mentioned the term that you operate and you try to be timely and efficient in a timely and efficient manner. And I continually get people regurgitating, I want to use it wordy again, regurgitating the same stories that somebody has a problem getting something done, getting something taken care of. Can you give us an example of situations where there are delays based on the people returning the paperwork to you or taking the time to get back to you, where it's not your department or your staffs problem or fault?
Yes, Council Member Perrello. Happy to answer that question and first of all I want to say if we make a mistake, we don't want to make excuses. We want to know about it and we want to try to make things right for that specific project In many cases, however there's a lack of communication between the design team that's actually submitting the plans to us. They are the applicant and the project owner or the property owner so usually there's let's just say it's easy to blame the city without other information and usually when we get all the parties together The owner, the person preparing the plans and our staff. And we explain what's been going on, how many times it's gone back and forth that maybe that owner wasn't aware of or how long it took between submittals.
That's when the light bulb goes on and they realize we're here working with them to solve the process. You've heard claims of hundreds of days of a project being delayed when it's not in our possession. We can only just wait for the project to come back in and treat it efficiently when it gets in but we cannot go compel people to manage their own contractors, vendors, consultants, architects. We have to the projects have to be submitted back to us however like I said if we make a mistake we want to know about it and we'll see what we can do to shortcut things on the next cycle and make them whole on the project in total
Thank you very much and thank you for taking the time to explain that to the public. Unfortunately, a lot of people don't get that message no matter how many times they're told. I want to thank the code enforcement. They mentioned the safety, the food vendors. We could show possibly pictures of the damage in the extensive burns that were done to a person with the food vending because of accidents and unprohibited actions taking place In the past there has been mention about specific as you mentioned several times tonight The people running these things are from out of the area Basically, it's a big business. They have biz sites in this city Ventura and other places raking in over six figures on these situations We're doing the best we can but a compliment You're the only city this is the only city that's taking an action to do that stuff.
It's a Credit to you, to the council and management for supporting you in doing that. Thank you very much.
Credit to Code Compliance, the Fire Department and Police Department. Yes, thank you. That's all I have.
Thank you Council Member. Any other questions? I'm just excited that we're moving to be that much more efficient with implementation here hopefully. I know you said don't stay until March 27th but we're going in that direction so And I know that I see a couple of your staff members here. I've been excellent when there's been issue that have been brought up.
They've been very attentive and responsive to members of our community, and I think people quickly realize that we're here to be great partners. And you've got a huge department in code compliance. Thank you for taking those operations on with police and fire looking ahead to take the initiative to protect members of our community. So just I'm thankful for the efforts. Thank you.
Go ahead.
Thank you. I wanted to follow up on that as well and thank your team, Mr. Pengele. They're a great team. I've had the privilege to work with each of them in a different capacity or in different projects over the last couple years. And I just thank them for the work that they do because similar way said for housing there's a lot of work and only a few people to do it at this level that your team here who is here tonight knows the conversations we've had I want to thank all of you for your work and always being willing step up and see how we can be solutions oriented in addressing the issues
1:46 – 1:529 turns
Yes, I also want to take an opportunity. I know that I had a conversation especially during the holiday season Candy Cane Lane and code enforcement like there was a lot going on So I just I know Andy's in the audience And maybe he could share a little bit about shine light on some of the issues that were brought up I know that there's health concerns that their safety concerns and I know code compliance was trying to do their job and go out there. I know next year will do better But I would like to just shine some light because I know that you all get the heat of a lot of things and there's a lot of progress happening. And I see a lot of the work happening here, but I would really like to address that because a lot with something blowing up or just fire out of control.
So can you just share a little bit? I know there was, you alluded to something in terms of the state of California laws changing and really limiting our ability to do much so we'll do better but I wanted to see if we could have a little bit of information for the general public who's concerned about that.
I'd be happy to have Andy speak on that. I do want to add that at that same time we had an irregular event that occurs at Our Lady of Guadalupe Church in Colonia and the year prior vendors overran that event, they took up every parking space surrounding it there was over 50 vendors this year we pre-planned and we deployed a lot of staff code compliance police And I believe fire as well deployed there in advance with a plan of action and it was a tremendous success.
That was going on at the same time as some of the Candy Cane Lane, but I'll let Andy explain further.
Thank you
Good evening members of the council Andrew Dixon co-compliance manager Yes, we did have issues with some of the out-of-town hot dog vendors coming in trying to overrun our candy cane Christmas tree lane We were out several nights in the initial weeks leading up to it. There was an incident involving some community activists that basically was threatening to our staff, and I made the determination that in the spirit of the holidays with the threats that were made the tone of it, of what they had promised to do. It was not the best thing to have our staff out there and subjected to the abuse.
We also were out on the Day of the Virgin at Guadalupe Church. It was a great success. Saturday night, December 20th we did have one of these out-of-town vendors, unpermitted food operators up on Vineyard. They were storing a propane tank under their grill And as gases heat up, they expand the pressure release and the tank blew up causing a large fire on Vineyard Avenue right in front of our buyer at the market.
So myself and staff responded from home on the eve of Christmas week so we were out there a lot and unfortunately hindsight 2020 we will learn. We have learned and we will do better As Director Pingeli stated, Guadalupe Church last year 50 vendors. This year the church sold out and it was an overwhelming success generating you know the profits for our community for our church that serves our community.
Okay thank you very much and I think like the main takeaway is also is like I just wanted to shine some light on that.
Madam Clerk, I know there's... Yes, go
ahead. I just want to take this opportunity to once again thank Mr. Dixon. You run a really good shop there. You've got some good people. One thing I really appreciate about you is that you don't wield the citation first. Usually you're trying to get to work with the person and say hey this is not in compliance with the rules, you need to change this. A recent example I remember was that A gentleman who I think had some sort of like plumbing or tech business or something where he was putting signs on our, in places where they shouldn't, on poles and so forth. And you know, you took the initiative to actually talk to the person, explain what the rules were and then he promptly self-corrected. So I'm glad that you used that approach and you only escalate when you need to.
So thank you.
Thank you. Yeah, we embrace the compliance aspect of the job. We are not... Yes, we are code enforcement but voluntary compliance is our goal and that's what we always strive. Educating a new business owner on how to do things correctly as opposed to just citing him $200 for every sign that he had placed on every single light post in the
town. I'm very appreciative of your project. Obviously, I hope you'll continue that.
1:52 – 2:0312 turns
Thanks for that wonderful presentation. Madam Clerk, beyond this speaker card are there any other public speakers in person or online?
Mayor and Council Members, that's the only speaker, Alicia Purcell for this item.
Thank you.
So in spite of reports of progress, it still takes way too long in this city to get a permit. It is a frequent complaint from residents not just one. Many many people in the building industry have told us they just won't take jobs at Oxnard because it's just too difficult The permit process nearly drove Amazon away from opening in Oxnard. And I saw the emails, it's not speculation only after an online journal publicly shamed over the way that it was being handled did things take a turn and look what we got as a result because Amazon opened here look at the revenues that the city has gained by cooperating.
The Ventura County Grand Jury even issued a report of their finding in 2024 about Oxnard not complying with state mandated timelines, so you know the fact that it got worse around COVID and is somewhat improved from that level doesn't necessarily mean that the system works well That's the reason that we qualified the Permit Simplicity Program for the ballot and voters adopted it.
Even before we collected signatures for that program, we took the draft language to the city manager and we gave him an opportunity to say you know hey if voters were to adopt a measure like this would be better if you made this change But instead, Mr. Nguyen told us that he knew there was a problem but he was going to fix it himself. He didn't want anything to do with it. He opposed our measure. He told us he would use all his resources to fight it and that's what he did.
Other than Erin, council members are generally unaware of how it's been going. Even after voters adopted it, it took a long time for anything to happen towards implementation. Website was not easy to find. It was difficult for an interested person to even sign up for the training. People would have to actively monitor the webpage weekly because without notice boom they'd open a registration window for a few days and if you missed it too bad chance is gone Then when there was a one month registration window, the registration form is deactivated. You couldn't actually complete it.
We are informed by people who inquire about the program they have been at times incorrectly told they're not eligible or they've been actively discouraged and frustrated out of using the program so they quit trying. In spite of whatever rebuttals will be made, it's not been implemented in good faith and the chart in the slide is just evidence of the city manager's efforts to thwart the program. Thank you.
Thank You Ms. Porcel.
Mr. Mayor we're gonna respond so first I'd like to give Director Pangili an opportunity just to talk about some of the glitches in the program and what they've done and then I'll talk about a broader context
Go ahead, Mr. Pingeli. And also Madam Clerk I think the timer was glitching there somewhat. Go ahead, Mr. Pingeli.
Thank you Mayor. Just to rebut some of those comments The program has been implemented. Nobody has been dissuaded from applying. I'm the one that's implemented it. I've managed the website when we were notified one time that the forum wasn't taking applications, we turned the forum back on and extended it for another month or... And in fact, it's on continuously now. The applicants that were interested, I contacted each one of them Those that failed to respond after my attempts to contact them dropped off the list. Nobody was dissuaded. In fact, I had conversations with people late this calendar year 2025 who seemed to be interested, a fish on the line potentially and I had extensive conversations with them.
One of the big detriments this year is that the program mandates Renew your certification every time the codes change and they're changing effectively at this calendar year. So we might have a few applicants, but again when people look at the merits of the program it doesn't help them. It reverses the order of plan check versus permits. It doesn't save them any significant time. It doesn't save them money.
It's a 12-page document of regulations that calls itself Permit Simplicity, where you have a laundry list of forms and requirements where you could just submit an application and go through the process. I can talk about again our turnaround times are comparable to Thousand Oaks in Ventura The unnamed persons that are saying that things are not working well, come and have a conversation with me. I deal with the customers on a daily basis. Let's have a real conversation.
You know bad news travels around the world three times before good news crosses the street is the old saying so if you hear a complaint maybe it's valid maybe it's a third hand we'd like to know about it but The fact, the statement that Amazon went away because our permit process is just unacceptable. I lived the Amazon project both versions and that's not what happened.
I could give a more detailed explanation at another time but that's very frustrating so I'll leave it at that.
Thank you. Alex were going to say something? Yeah, I
just want to add to this wonderful revisionist history I can guarantee you, I have never once said to anyone, I'll use all my resources to fight something. What I probably said was it's a stupid idea and I still believe that. Now, a shortcut is not always the solution to a complex problem so let's fix this context window here so that we can have an actual shared understanding Now the Amazon thing was fascinating, but Mr. Pangilli's correct, had nothing to do with permitting, right?
A lot of that did precede my time, but I did reach out to Amazon and we were able to get them back to the table and the outcome is what it is. But enough of this revisionist history and quoting people out of thin air. Just deal with the facts as they are. One other thing Speaking of a context window Because and it's not just Oxnard this This department in every city especially when it comes to regulations and permitting and co-compliance Always gets blamed for everything, but let me let me just share with you That the primary reasons that we do these things are not to frustrate our residents or businesses Primarily. It's about safety When you look at the Christchurch earthquake 2011, 100,000 buildings damaged. 10,000 of those buildings had to be demolished.
Imagine something like that here but what happened in Christchurch afterwards? They looked towards our building codes to figure things out for a better future. Last year the high-rise fire in Hong Kong A lot of deaths. What did they do immediately? They started arresting people, including engineers and building officials who didn't do their due diligence in approving permits.
Now that came out rather rapidly so I don't know what the outcomes of that are and what really happened. I'm not sure we would find out on our end of the globe The New Year's Eve fire recently, this New Year's Eve in Switzerland. What's the headline story today? No inspections. So just remember this is about safety. We do the best we can but it's all wrapped around safety.
Thank you.
Thank you Alex. Any other comments? Mr. Parlow go ahead.
I'd like to address something. When I made my first comments with respect The presentation that was just made by Mr.. Pingeli and now after we've had a member of the public speak I know that member of the public Was introduced by her husband a sitting councilmember as recently passing the bar making an attorney And I know that. I don't have the ability to retape and go back and listen to exactly what she said quote exactly what she said, but she used the term We have heard We have been informed That's called hearsay, and I did say the first time that I mentioned the comments. That I continue, and I've said it twice, hear regurgitated comments with respect to our city not doing a good job with the code enforcement.
Permits, timelines, everything else. The most recent time was at the Christmas tree lighting. I heard somebody in the audience right now telling me about the problems that they're having and everyone else is having the same problem. Well when you see the numbers that are put up on the board about construction going on in this city, it must not be everyone else is having the same problem In some communities, it's not what you know. It's who you know. If some people don't want to work in the City of Oxnard or do business in the City of Oxnard because they can't get something specially done for them, I wish them well some other city.
I don't want something that you know somebody so you get a special favour. Usually special favours come with considerations and the considerations are that somebody gets shortchanged and the person that gets shortchanged is a member of the public And this whole process of the repeated statements that are made, we have heard, we understand businesses don't want to operate in Oxnard. When you have facts and evidence something that someone should learn in law school I think the first day it's important bring the facts and evidence otherwise someone will come to us like I am come to an opinion that there's a degree of untruth in what you're saying.
Thank you very much Mayor.
2:04 – 2:097 turns
There are no other questions or comments? Oh, yeah. Go ahead, Mayor Pro Tem.
Thank you. I'll just be brief on this. Just taking this all in and I'll just say I've been following Measure F since getting on the council and I appreciate Mr. Pingeli keeping me updated when I ask for each session and how many inquiries there were and how many applications there were. And you saw on the board earlier or on the table Zero applications in all of the eight sessions that have occurred since implementation.
So, the voters may have approved it but it appears to me that professionals have rejected it. I don't know what else to say because on February 13th 2023 the Moving Oxnard Forward blog sent out a blog post and probably emailed untold number of professionals as well about the Permit Simplicity Program about Measure F. If you look at the table and the public documents for this meeting, the February 2023 session had 28 inquiries far more than any others I'd imagine those are people who received a blog post or an email and there were still zero applications so does that mean 28 people were somehow dissuaded from applying or told they weren't eligible? Does that mean those 28 people who unnamed people who said oh I was told I wasn't eligible if they were told like, oh no that's incorrect you're eligible.
They still chose not to come back and still have not applied I mean i'll just say candidly it's okay to fail this thing if it's failed it's all right to admit that we get lessons in failure being a failing at something is okay I think everybody on this dais everybody's room has failed at something before there's nothing wrong with that humbling experience we learn from it and move forward so What shows me that this program is not working, is the fact that professionals have viewed it, have inquired, zero have gone forward with it. And I could just as easily sit up here and say, I've spoken to professionals who said, I would never do something like that. That makes zero sense for me as a professional to participate in that program.
So anyhow, those are my comments. I appreciate the opportunity to speak on this.
Thank you Mayor. We'll go to Mr. Mayor. You mind if I just go to a couple of speakers and we'll go back to you, Council Member?
That's all
right. We'll take Mr. Greg Runyon and Mr. Stein, you'll follow Mr. Runyon, and then Victor, and after Victor, we have Angela Waco.
Good evening, council. No Gatorade, no bananas today so hopefully I'll stay awake. The I know you are, I appreciate it. I'll probably slip on it on the peel the I wasn't going to say anything and I came a little late but I get what we start arguing about permits and we start arguing about the technicalities and things like that. I actually got up because I wanted to point out as you guys were complimenting Andy and I've known Andy a long time, his sister was part of the Special Olympics group. We bowled together.
He helped me in cleaning up a church property we had when we were trying to help some homeless folks and one of the individuals was vile to him, said some things that were completely and totally inappropriate And I went and I told Andy, I said, I'm so sorry. And he said, Greg, when you're trying to help people that need help, you need to remember that they need help.
I think sometimes when we talk about technicalities and things and we begin to look for gotcha moments, we forget to thank the people that are working through gotcha moments It would have been very easy for Andy to say, you know what? Forget it. We're not going to give you any extra time. We're not going to do this. You need to do this because this guy disrespected me and this guy did that. He didn't play politics.
He didn't play personalities. He did it the right way. And when you see something like that, it's kind of sad in a way because we were at kind of a high point And then it came crashing down. So I'd like to see us get up to that high point of, I'm not an engineer. I don't know about permits. I'm not a construction guy. But I do know how to treat people. And my fear is that there's people that may not want to come to Oxnard because they don't like the people.
Not the permits. They don't like the way the people are doing things. And I hope and I pray that we can look to people and thank them when they do a good job, and thank them for the example. So Andy, I've told you before but thank you so much. Thank you.
Thanks Pastor. Mr. Lerstein?
2:09 – 2:169 turns
Good evening, Mr. Mayor. Good evening, Mr. Stein. I'm with City Council, staff and the general public. My name is Larry Stein. I've been an activist for 30-plus years. And one of the things that bothers me is the fact that we have specific plans. The city makes sure that we do not complete the specific plans. We can take a look at the specific plan from Northeast Community Village That specific plan called for a fire station when 50% of the house would be built out.
This specific plan called for a park to be built. Again, residents bought 2,500 plus homes in that specific plan. They paid development fees. Where's the park after 25 years? Where is the fire station after 25 years? Well, after all the homes were built by 2012, the city decided in 2018 not to build a fire station because we don't need it according to the Fire Department.
We still have 2,500 plus homes advanced Construction going on and a specific plan to call at the time that people bought their homes for our fire station and park. Community development is responsible for specific plans, the city manager and city attorney are responsible for making sure the specific plans get completed. To get completed, we have a current assistant manager indicating that we have enough water for 10,000 new housing structures as part of the general plan. Where are the wells?
The wells that were supposed to be built from the 2010 water bonds had not been built. Where's the water going to come from for 10, 000 new homes? Oh, we're going to get by conserving water. Well, that's not what was said when the bonds were sold. We have a community development project We have the wells that were supposed to be built in 2010. We are still not working on 5th Street after five years!
Where's the planning that follows up on specific plans? We have the Till Club specific plan. That has a great deal of attributes to it, but we also have a field next to it where the air may be toxic. The air may be toxic because of lead next to the airport in the fuel planes. But who is testing the air? Oh, not the city, not the county. Nobody tests the air because you don't know if the air is safe or not.
When it was brought up in the specific plan hearings last April, staff said we've looked into that. That's all they said, we've looked into that. Why don't we look at the specific plans and how we're processing specific plans? Thank you very much for your time.
Thank you Mr. Stein. Victor. And following Mr. Ojeda is Angela Wickel.
Hello City Council. My name is Victor Ojeda, long-time resident in the city of Oxnard. And I wanted to make some comments on the city permit side and whatnot. I commend them and they're doing a good job and they're getting better year after year. And glad to hear that you guys are going digital now because most cities in the state of California are there now. We're always for whatever reason lacking one step behind. And we're playing damage control kind of trying to play catch up with the world.
One of the things I know, I have heard. I deal with a lot of businesses doing consulting work. I also work with Modern Beauty Academy here at local business in the downtown area and one of the things that when I go in there some of the friends that do construction, some of the people who are out in the world trying to get permits I do hear it's you know takes a year and a half for them to get something approved for whatever reason it might be. I know it's case by case. I'm not saying you guys aren't not doing Your job, but I guess we can always get better. And it's more just a comment to make let's find more of a solution than a problem.
Um, I know that sometimes I've heard from some of them and it's obviously yes, but it's just something to put out there in the world and for everybody to know that sometimes they come out and they bring their plans and they're like how much is it going to be? Oh, I don't know. I have to look over the plans. It's like, I mean, there should be some type of more structure on this is a fee for this if you add on this, add on that Kind of move forward from there. As I said, I know it's case-by-case scenarios but I do say you guys are doing a better job year for year. I know I recently had some issues with some permits trying to get hey, I need this permit not through the planning side more on the city business side. Well wait, I got to go talk to Alberto or Roberto and then they should have whoever is in front should be trained a little bit better maybe Thank you.
The lack of education, of knowing like the simplicity act that they were talking about. I had never heard of it maybe I just was unaware or not putting my attention but they haven't really voiced it out to the world as clearly. Just little things we can get better at nothing like I said nothing to say oh they're not doing their good job but let's just try to make this city better and Mr. Perala I know you said, you know, I don't care whoever doesn't want to work here or come here and whatnot. I feel that Oxnard should be a city to kind of be more inviting to let's work together and let's make it grow. We are the biggest city in this county.
Thanks Victor.
I am not against people coming here but I'm against people expecting special treatment if they come here. Apologize
Mayor.
And I
apologize but just the deliverance
of the message? Yeah thanks Victor. This is the time we take to listen to public comment. But thanks for your comments, Victor. Angela Whitecomb?
2:16 – 2:266 turns
I wasn't going to speak because I was waiting for one of you guys to ask the question, why are we still taking paper plans? You talk about the weight and the size. We live in a digital age. I'm a contractor. I do everything through PDFs and a large screen. And you can take it apart. You can zoom in. And you can send them one time. And you can have them now. And it's not going to cost any money to reprint them. It's going to save the environment. So I just don't understand.
Why we are still taking paper plans. I think the city should say no you have to send them to me digitally and then you don't lose them, and you don't have to pay for so much. I live on Christmas tree lane, I was part of getting the TUP where my husband was which means I was part of it. It was the most stressful Christmas I've ever had living on Christmas tree lane, dealing with the vendors and the amount of residents. I'm also the chair for Wilson and the residents that live on that street they're very frustrated when I really fear that they're not going to light up next year unless we come up with a solution to this problem. And I understand that VC Defensa came out and they wanted to protect the vendors, I did put in a call to them to work with them with the workaround because they didn't want to work with the city and I understand the fear that was coming from code enforcement in the heightened political environment that were in But we need to come up with workable solutions.
And so I really look forward to working with the city. I can tell you that the amount of toilet paper and trash that we went in through, my husband was personally pushing the trash down because we didn't have the trash collection as much as we needed because of the amount of vendors that were selling things that produced trash. And the amount of toilet paper that I personally bought to keep up with the need because food and drink, you know. We're people right? And we try to provide these clean safe spaces but as a neighborhood we're going to need more support next year and if we want to keep this tradition alive and it's lovely to the community I look forward to working with you guys in coming up with solutions And I can say that I did work with you guys, with the local permitting department.
And I had to get a re-roofing project done and it all went great except for the one day that the inspector didn't show up to the house and I waited for him all day. He said that the paper wasn't there and I could guarantee you That it was, so I don't know what to do with that. So I could understand the public's frustration and maybe what they need is we need a little quick survey. I don't know you might have it but something to help fix that thank you.
Thanks Angela Madam Clerk, are there any other speakers in person or online?
Mayor and council members that concludes our speakers in person and virtually for this item. Thank you. Thank you. Council Member?
Yeah sure so perhaps the city manager doesn't remember this but Alicia and I our very first meeting with him which was in late 2018 He made very clear to me and her that he would fight this measure with everything he had. That was both of our recollections, and sometimes memories dim, and maybe I'll get the benefit of the doubt to the city manager that maybe he doesn't remember anymore, but my wife and I certainly do.
Regarding the number of applicants being indicators as to whether the program is even appealing I'll tell you this, back in February of 2023 or just prior to that we recruited folks to actually apply and we got 28 of them to actually make inquiries. I was copied on the emails requesting the information so I saw the responses from staff and just for further background It was kind of a dumb luck that we recruited these people the time we did, because it wasn't clear that there was going to be a class. It wasn't stated when the next class was going to be.
What happened was that the class was announced only a week ahead of time just before holiday weekend so that people would only have four days to apply. Nonetheless, we got 28 people to apply at that point and they were being told by an email That the prerequisite for taking the permit simplicity class was that you first had to take the permit simplicity class.
It was a circular requirement and I spoke to the city attorney's office he finally agreed that I was right, I have that in writing. And what I'm told is that there was an effort to follow up with these people let them know but not really sure how well that went. I'm just simply saying that to say that no applicants means the program's not a success is just false when it's not possible to even apply or know when the class is going to happen.
Now, to the credit of the department now, I'm happy to say that they are opening up the ability to apply ahead of time. I think that's a good move. A recent inquirer who was interested in becoming an applicant was told that he shouldn't even bother taking the class, most recently because the building code is being updated. So I will see if he is able to be part of the program when it next comes up, I assume in April.
But I just wanted to correct the record and the understanding. I mean, I've lived this. So, I know there's been problems When I first ran for City Council, people were telling me this. That's the reason why we came up with permit simplicity and by the way if there was anything that we didn't like that you know that city staff didn't like about permit simplicity, we specifically added a provision that the City Council has the ability to modify this law it doesn't have to go back to the voters to even do it as long as it promotes Purposes that the initiative stated So those are just my comments. I just wanted to correct the record. Thank you.
Thank You councilman Sower and I'll just I'll just conclude By stating that You know, I personally Want to modernize this city and I'm just as I sit here and I think Angela you mentioned Why are we taking paper? Mr. Pinkley mentioned that we're shooting for a March 27th and We are getting there. As you know, I certainly and I think this council does too in our city. We support entrepreneurs, businesses because if they're successful we are successful as a city and as a community. We're all successful so we want to see them succeed but that's not to say we can cut corners. We want to be as efficient with us understanding that the protocols and codes are in place to protect all of us so we have to abide by them but that's also not to say that there potentially hasn't been some errors along the way But I can tell you that at least my personal experience in dealing with our department, or Mr.
Pangilli and others is that they're open and receptive to having those kind of robust discussions to get better and be more efficient because ultimately no one's in the business here to not be successful. We all want to be successful and wanna offer the best possible service we can to our community so I'm confident that we're gonna continue to strive to be as efficient as we can and as service-oriented as we can to our businesses, because we want them to succeed. Because then we succeed as a city, as a community. So I'm confident that we are moving in the right direction.
So there's no other public comment and no other questions or comments by our council. This is only a receiving file item? Yes, Council Member.
Just one comment for the council members that were not here This happened before I was on the council, but Mr. Stein brought up an issue he's 100% correct specifically about a Northeast specific plan in a fire station. I was a member of the public in the audience and I kept hearing that, kept hearing that Why, why, why? The response was the fire department chief at the time made the determination since the homes would have indoor sprinklers there would not be the need for a fire station in that development. But they would postpone the fire station as the city developed more towards east. Currently apparently there is something in Sakyoka Farm so Mr. Stein is 100% right on a fire station it was supposed to be in an area but there was a determination by the fire people in place that because the homes are equipped with indoor sprinklers, there was no need for that.
That was reported at the council before I got on council.
2:26 – 2:3315 turns
Thanks for that clarification now Council Member. Okay. Thanks for your patience by the way. Good evening everyone just want to call now formally the meeting to order For the alternate City Council for Tuesday, January 6th 2026. Madam Clerk, we have the roll call and posting of the agenda please.
The agenda for this meeting was posted at the kiosk at City Hall,
the Oxnard
Public Library, the city administrative offices and on the city's website
I know we have Keon and his family here for the Pledge of Allegiance. And for that, I'm going to turn it over to Councilwoman Basuah to make the formal introduction and then we'll go into the Pledge of Allegiance.
Thank you Mayor. I didn't know I was going to do that but I had the opportunity to reach out to a local high school and I chose Santa Clara High School. It's very dear to my heart so without any further ado, I will turn it over
Thank you. I invite everybody to please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance.
And Mayor, when we're done with the pledge can we take a moment of silence? Tomorrow is the anniversary of the number of people that were burned to death in the fires down south and today is the anniversary of the despicable thing that happened in the nation's capital and all the people that were pardoned by our President.
Thank you very much for that Council Member. Reminding us of the January 6th insurrection that happened and what happened there. So we'll take a moment, I'm sorry let's get right after it okay?
Sounds good. Please place your right hand over your heart ready to begin.
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all you may be seated
Thank you very much, everyone. Thank you. Okay, Keon, go
ahead.
Thank you.
Good evening Mayor McArthur, City Council members, staff and everyone present in the gallery. My name is Keon Villa and I am a senior at Santa Clara High School. I would like to begin by expressing my gratitude for, towards city council and Santa Clara High School for granting me this honor to speak here today and share my story and impact on this community.
As the youngest of three children, I constantly found myself having to prove myself to others. To provide some context, my older brother and older sister were very successful in high school graduating valedictorian receiving recognition in sports and were involved in various school organizations They then went on to be successful in adulthood, my brother becoming a commissioned officer in the Navy graduating from the United States Naval Academy.
My sister becoming a doctor of pharmacy graduating from University California San Francisco and it's safe to say that they set the bar pretty high and encouraged me to surpass their expectations which I am eternally grateful for Now, I have had many people tell me that everything I've achieved up to this point was a result of my sibling's legacy. But what they did not realize or witness was the amount of work, preparation and most challenging, the pressure I was under.
This pressure was not brought on by anyone other than myself. I never in my entire life wanted to be better than my siblings. I just wanted to create something unique, something meaningful to me So I sought to do and try everything that my siblings did, and more. To produce a legacy I can call my own. As soon as I started high school, I joined two varsity sports and almost all the clubs and organizations on campus while striving for academic excellence with the Arizona State University dual enrollment program my school offers.
But this is where I made my biggest mistake. In the dense fog of navigating high school and creating my own legacy I found myself overloading my schedule and creating this pressure, which ultimately made me lose sight of what my true goal was. Finding something meaningful to me. Now as I approached my senior year, something hit me. Taking on the roles of Santa Clara student body president, my junior and senior year, class president freshman and sophomore year, team captain of varsity sports President of Student Ambassadors and various other leadership positions on campus all had one thing in common, serving something bigger than myself.
In all these achievements I always found myself helping the school, the people within or the community as a whole spending countless hours giving back to the community. In those times where I was burnt out and exhausted I still found the energy To simply ask anyone if they needed help, whether they were on or off campus. Because I knew I had the support of my parents, school and the community.
And it was in those moments of aid where I felt the pressure melt away. In addition, I found other students who are willing to help those in need and shared the common goal with me. Knowing that there are others who share the same passion with me assures me that our community is in good hands and the future is bright. It turns out that, in the end, this pressure was solely my own doing and it was my parents, siblings, Santa Clara High School, and the community of Oxnard who helped me persevere.
With that being said I have come to the conclusion that I am best suited to help and be of service. My plans for the future are to hopefully attend the United States Air Force, Naval, Army or Merchant Marine Academy where I can develop my leadership, resilience and dedication to serve this world. My dream is to become a pilot in any of these branches and use my leadership and experience to create positive change in the world.
Thank you for your time and have a blessed night.
2:33 – 2:3812 turns
Ian, do you want to introduce who's here with you?
Of course. Please. Front row I have my dad Ben, my mom Michelle, my sister Kirsten and my principal Ms. Palmazano. And in the back I see we do have some teachers from the school Miss Ramsey and Mr. Ramirez
You had an opportunity to see a little bit of how our city government works. Waiting a little bit, so thank you for your patience but...
Of
course. But this is the highlight for us is having young people like yourselves come up and it just really showcases for our entire community just the amount of talent we have here in this city that are coming Growing up here, being part of our educational system here. And so we're just so happy that you have an entire community behind you whether you realize it or not. That's what the function of this is for us to get behind and be supportive and support your principal and your educators that are all here rallying for you. I mean you're the next generation and things don't happen by accident. So certainly the credit to your parents obviously they've got Man, the right recipe because they're producing.
My gosh, I mean it's just impressive so thank you for the work that you've done and we have a certificate for you up here if you want to come up when your family can come up and take some photos okay? Yes absolutely. I'm
sorry, I was going to do a few things. You know I just want to thank you one thing about you know I'm a big proponent of Catholic education for those of you that don't know extremely rooted in my faith and in who I am. But one of the biggest things that we teach in Catholic education, which I'm sure your principal can attest to is that we teach to serve others and that we are here to serve. And I think that you are a great testament of that.
And congratulations to your parents because it starts with them. And then they put a lot of sacrifice to send you where they sent you and to the teachers there also They're there because they love what they do. And they don't do it because of the money, because I'm very much aware that it's not much. But I just loved who you've become here in the city of Oxnard and you said it. It's the community that has put you there and I'm just so thankful and I am so happy to hear that there is more students. You said you found students there within That just think that way of you. So I congratulate your teachers, your parents and I could not be more prouder of you and your school and I'm just so happy to have you in your community now. The only thing that I ask is that you come back to Oxnard after you go.
I asked that you come back to Oxford and you become a great member of our society and that you give back to what this community has given to you.
Of course.
Are they able to text me the speech that we wrote? I'd like to publish that if you wouldn't mind. What's your number? Keon, this is for you. Where's your principal? Is your principal up here? Oh there she is! Do you want to say a few words or anything about this great student here? Yeah, let's take a picture.
Here we go. And hold. No blinking on three. One, two, three. No blinking on three. One, two, three. Let's roll in one camera.
Good evening,
everyone. Just a few words. We are just so proud as you know
of Kean.
2:38 – 2:477 turns
and his whole family. They are a legacy family, and it's just a testament of how our students are at Santa Clara High School. And also a testament of having teachers here and our counselor here to see this moment with Kian, and we're really proud of you. So I know you're going to graduate soon so best of luck to you. We have a mission at Santa Clara High School Have that mission to and just hearing you about service. I'm just so proud, so good luck for your future.
Congratulations. Thank you very much.
And we have a couple of ceremonial items. We're gonna start with Sir Optimist, if Lori and Debbie can come up?
Okay as our recipients make their way up here I'm going to go ahead and go over the proclamation here. This is the Sir Optimist Stop Human Trafficking Awareness Day And whereas January 17th, 2026 is the 19th annual Suroptimist Stop Human Trafficking and Sexual Slavery Community Awareness event in Ventura County hosted by Comunidad Regional Suroptimists of Oxnard, Camarillo, Fillmore, Ventura and Channel Islands Clubs to take place at Columbus Hall. And whereas this Suroptimist mission is to raise community awareness provide education and to honor and uplift women and girls who have struggled through hardships disparity and in some cases human trafficking And whereas January is known as the month of Human Trafficking Awareness Month, it is now time that individuals at home, workplaces, churches and schools should educate themselves and learn to identify the signs of trafficking.
And whereas every 30 seconds another person becomes a victim of human trafficking through force, fraud or coercion. Trafficking primarily involves exploitation for the purposes of prostitution, slavery, involuntary servitude and compelling victims to commit commercial sex acts. Approximately 75% of all human trafficking victims are trafficked for sexual exploitation while 18% for labor exploitation And whereas the Global Slavery Index estimates 40 million women and children are living as modern day slaves, forced labor and sex trafficking is a $150 billion worldwide industry.
And the fastest growing criminal enterprise. And whereas Seroptimists are investing in the program, Seroptimist Live Your Dream Which helps recipients with financial support to continue their education and gain independence. 50% of these women are survivors of trafficking, domestic violence and sexual assault. And whereas Sir Optimus International of Oxnard, Camarillo, Fillmore, Ventura and Channel Islands Clubs support the Federation, Sir Optimist International of America These programs to promote awareness, advocacy and action. And that all seroptimist clubs are in a global position to educate everyone especially women that have the right to live free from violence and exploitation. Now therefore our Mayor Louis A MacArthur, Mayor of the City of Oxnard does hereby proclaim January 17th 2026 as the 19th Annual Seroptimists Stop Human Trafficking and Sexual Slavery Community Awareness Event.
Thank you.
Here we are again. This is the 19th year that we have put on this program. I wanted to just introduce a couple of other Soroptimist members with me, our President Lori, our President-elect Noemi and you know most of you all know this is our past president Denise Morehouse so Why do we keep doing this? Why do we keep coming year after year, putting on this program? Well if those words and those statistics don't scare you they should.
Because the community, you're talking about safety out here earlier. We need to make our communities safe for everyone and there could be somebody right now sitting in the privacy of their bedroom on a computer And there's a trafficker out there lurking to get her or him. And they could be on websites that you're very familiar with, Facebook, Twitter, TikTok, WhatsApp, all of those that we kind of know and the kids know a lot more than we do. They go on these gaming apps and that's where the traffickers You know, go out finding young kids that are vulnerable.
And so we put on these programs every year to they're free of charge to the community if any of you have young children or grandchildren you babysit You have nieces and nephews. You need to come out and get yourself educated, and become aware of what's going on because it's not just something that's happening over there. The face of a trafficker is not like it used to be. They're not driving around in dark alleys and vans trying to get people off the street. They're sitting in a room just like this, not like this but with the computer and they're looking for people to pray on.
And unfortunately it happens and so you need to really spread the word about January 17th I've got some flyers here so please help yourself and come out do the walk with us and we have two speakers one of them is a survivor advocate, and the other one is a professional FBI special agent. So she's going to be giving us a lot of information. So please come out and we thank you for recognizing the work that we do. And President Lori, do you have a few words to say?
Well, I just want to congratulate Debbie and her committee for all the hard work that they've done over 19 years of making this a truly monumental awareness project. But if you get a little chance and you're driving on the 101 freeway take a look up at that auto center drive area because we have signage on the 101 freeway one of the most trafficked zones in California maybe the West Coast So please take the time to either come and see us, for women in the audience maybe you want to find out what a seroptimist is or does.
Please we can always reach out to you but come to the event this on January 17th at the Knights of Columbus Hall in Ventura and join us and see what you will leave a changed person. Thank you.
2:47 – 2:524 turns
Thank you, Mayor. And I appreciate the opportunity to read the proclamation for this evening and I appreciate all of you being here and Noemi is also one of my appointees for previous commission work as well. Thank you for all of your work But each year when this comes to us, there's something that is very important and impactful to me personally and professionally. And early in my career working with youth as I always have throughout my career I did engage with young people who were victims of trafficking, and it's something that has stuck with me all these years later. And oftentimes many are put in that position by people they thought they could trust adults whom they thought they could trust. It's not as you mentioned somebody driving around You know, windowless van looking for someone.
This is oftentimes someone who already knows that young person or engages with them in some way gains trust and then puts them in that position and it's difficult to get out of. So thank you for all of that. And as you mentioned as well Let's not pretend this is not something that doesn't happen in Ventura County or in Oxnard. The 101 Corridor, as many of these experts can tell you, is a main corridor for this. It happens in our backyard. It's not something that happens only in the metropolitan areas or Northern California and Central Valley. It is absolutely happening in our community. So thank you for the work that you do.
Thank you Mayor for the extra time.
Yeah, and I just want to conclude before we take that photo. Just really quick to thank Debbie, Lori, Noemi, and also Chief Morehouse for their initiative. I certainly know the issue well. So does Chief Morehouse having both of us worked in our victim unit involving child sexual abuse, elder abuse, et cetera. And we certainly know as community members the vulnerable population we have here in this city And so we know well that this happened. So I just thank you personally for the initiative that you take and for the amount of volunteer work that you do in doing this work, so thank you for that.
We're not going to blink downward. Thank you,
thank you.
We have one last proclamation. And Dr. Stewart, I see he's here and Ms. Montgomery If you both want to come up for this proclamation. And this proclamation is for Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day, And as Ms. Montgomery and Dr. Vincent Stewart make their way up here, we certainly know what Dr. King has done for our country through his peaceful demonstrations that led to the passage of our Civil Rights Act, also the passage of our Voting Rights Act that we've all benefited from in this country.
But for the proclamation, Council Member, would you mind reading it? Absolutely. Thank you.
2:52 – 2:587 turns
It's a proclamation of Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day for January 19th, 2026 whereas Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr worked to reaffirm the ideals of freedom, dignity and opportunity for all races and peoples Helping our nation recognize the importance of upholding America's founding principles of equality and justice for all. And whereas Dr. King served as a voice of conscience for our nation, and his words and actions continue to inspire courage, humility, and compassion. His enduring contributions to America remind us and countless others around the world that people should not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character And whereas January 19th, 2026 has been set aside as a national holiday to pay tribute to Dr.
King and the theme of this year's commemoration is A Living Legacy, Cultivating Compassion and Justice in Ventura County. And whereas the 40th annual Ventura County Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. birthday celebration will be held on Monday, January 19, 2026 at 9 a.m., at the Oxnard Performing Arts Center, and will feature youth speakers, scripture readings, and gospel music selections by the MLK Celebration Choir. That sounds fun.
And now therefore, Lewis MacArthur, Mayor of the City of Oxnard does hereby proclaim January 19th, 2026 as Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day. in the city of Oxnard and encourage all residents to recognize the lasting truth of his words and his legacy, and to renew our commitment to the principles of justice, equality, opportunity, and optimism that Dr. King espoused and exemplified and participated in the Freedom March and prayer starting at Plaza Park on January 19th 2026 at 8 a.m., followed by a program at the Oxnard Performing Arts Center. In witness thereof, the mayor hereby sets his hand and causes the great seal of the city of Oxnard to be affixed this 6th day of January 2026. Thank you so much.
Good evening.
I'm
Loretta Ayers Montgomery, Chairperson of the Martin Luther King Committee of Ventura County and I have some wonderful people with me today. We're going to pass the mic and ask them to give their names and their positions or what they do within the committee. Hi
my name is Haiti Gayton. I've been with the committee for about eight years now lead with the refreshments we do have refreshments at the end the program and we invite everyone over to have some coffee, sit down, enjoy our vendors. We do have vendors also and that's what we do.
Hello, my name is Vincent Stewart and I've been on the committee for 25 years now. And I'm responsible for the park. So you come over to Performing Arts Center at 730, park the car, jump on a van and join us for a program that's in the park, Plaza Park. And then from there, we will march back down Fifth Street to the Performing Arts Center. So while we're at the park, we have elected officials that give speeches related to Martin Luther King and the ideals that he believed in.
And it's a great time. Have a big crowd. I think we had like 500 or 600 last time. So come on out and support that, 730 Performing Arts Center. Grab the van and then join us for our program that starts at 8.
We also have one additional member with us. He's one of our youth who's volunteered for several years. He's back taking pictures I think. Oh he's over here on the wall. Isaac Gaten. Well, we invite you all to come and celebrate with us for our 40th annual celebration right here in Oxnard and throughout Ventura County. I've been on the committee for that number of years. I'm a little tired because, you know, volunteering is a lot of work, you know? But we really would like to see you all. Our mayor will be there. We know and I hope some other friends will be there as well. And you can join us in the Freedom March. Excuse me, Freedom March. The main thing we'd like for you to come to the celebration. We'll actually be in the theater so we're going to fill that theatre The 1600 seats, we want to share with your friends and family to come out and be a day of service on behalf and with us for Dr.
Martin Luther King. We thank you for allowing us to come here this evening and we definitely appreciate this beautiful proclamation and we look forward to serving another year as well. Yes. It's photo time.
2:58 – 3:0510 turns
Thank you.
You're welcome.
Thank you. Okay.
Mr. Mayor, I guess a point of personal privilege. We have people who are freezing in here. I see the city clerk is chilly. My wife is all bundled up. She's just turned it up. Thank you so much. Five six, Mr. Mayor.
Go ahead. Yes, before these representatives for the Martin Luther King Day leave I'd like the public to understand the council and anybody watching this on television. The leader of this nation President Trump has removed the insignias of people of color from national parks symbols military organizations. This is something we should never forget this should have never happened but it is happening as we're here if you sit and do nothing this could continue You need to get involved. I'm not talking violence, you need to get involved.
What is going on now should never stand. Thank
you. Thanks Montgomery and Dr. Vincent Stewart thank you for all the volunteer work
We'll move to the next item on the agenda. This is for public comments, for items not on the agenda. Madam Clerk do we have any on-call speakers before we move to the in person callers?
Sorry mayor and council members we do not have any virtual speakers for items not on the agenda thank you.
Thank you And just as a reminder for those watching at home, if you want to speak, you can call in and press star 9 to raise your hand. We'll go to Carolyn Amolan as our first speaker followed by Ms. Angela Whitecomb and Josh Tellez.
All right, good evening. We're going to kind of tag team on this but Happy New Year Mayor MacArthur, Mayor Pro Tem Turan City Council members and city staff I'm Carolyn Marina Mullen, the Executive Director of the Oxnard Performing Arts Center Corporation. It's a mouthful so we go by OPAC. I'm also here with Gary Blum our Chair Emeritus for the non-profit as well as Angela Whitecomb with the Downtown Oxnard Improvement Association and Daniel Cabrera with VisitOxnard. And we're here with some really exciting news! To announce that Downtown Oxnard has been officially designated a cultural district by the State of California and the California Arts Council. This is huge there were 74 applications 10 finalists, Oxnard was one of those 10.
I can't underscore how important this is. We're the only one in Ventura County, the only one in the Tri-County area so this is a big deal. We're with Balboa Park, Little Tokyo, some other big wigs Just very, very excited. So that's why we're here. I want to say that OPAC was proud to serve as the lead applicant but we worked closely with DOIA, VisitOxnard, the City of Oxnard and community stakeholders.
This designation did not happen overnight. This was decades of work by city staff, by non-profits, by our stakeholders in downtown All in an effort to make arts and culture a driver of community vitality. We especially want to thank Deputy City Manager Katie Casey for all her help during the application process on the day of the visit from the state, Mayor MacArthur for your leadership.
I know it gave you a lot of homework that day. And Council Member Gabriela Rodriguez for showing up and being so instrumental during their visit. Your engagement absolutely made this possible. And so we'll definitely keep you posted on ongoings, because this is just getting started. We were all kind of flabbergasted when we found out in December that we were awarded.
So congrats to you all. Congrats to Oxnard. This moment is ours. Thank you.
3:05 – 3:117 turns
So good evening. I'm Angela Whitecomb, in case you all forgot from the five minutes ago. I am chair of the Downtown Oxnard Improvement Association. DOIA is a proud equal partner in this effort together with OPAC VisitOxnard and the city and our creative community. I can't underscore how important our creative community is. We've worked to integrate the arts and culture into downtown Oxnard's revitalization. This designation recognizes the collective efforts and reinforces the creativity that is essential to Oxnards identity and economic vitality. This designation gives us new new tools to build on that work and strengthen downtown Oxnard for residents, artists and visitors alike. From the Mystery Shop to Open Door Studios to the Mariachi Inuketch, the CFF Dance Studio and Chapter 30 Artist Studios there's so much happening in downtown and I couldn't be prouder.
Thank you.
And hi, good evening. I'm Daniel and I'm the Digital and Multicultural Marketing Manager with VisitOxnard. And VisitOXNARD has been an active supporter of this process and a committed collaborator through DOIA's placemaking committee. We see this designation as a powerful opportunity to elevate downtown Oxnard's cultural assets from its legendary music scene and historic landmarks to its growing creative economy as a destination for both residents and visitors The California Cultural District designation allows us to align cultural tourism with community values, supporting local artists and businesses while sharing Oxnard's authentic story with a broader audience.
We look forward to continuing this partnership to ensure that the Cultural District delivers lasting benefits for the community and the local economy. Thank you.
Kevin, you want to come up? OK. That's fine. Yeah. It's Kevin Brannon and Josh Tejas.
Good evening City Council my name is Joshua Tejas I am a paid intern with Real Guppy Outdoors And I currently go to Channel Islands High School. And the reason I got the internship in the first place was thanks to a program at my school, which was Upward Bound Channel Islands. And we're just here to invite you to the Blue Carpet premiere that will be at the Channel Islands Maritime Museum to feature our new show Coastal Critters. Thank you.
Thank you Josh.
Hey, what up? Community Kev with Rogue Guppy Outdoors. Yes just want to echo it I wanted to bring one of our paid interns down to show that we are doing our economic development part of our program at Rogue Guppy Outdoors besides just taking kids and families fishing And this is the premiere of our new TV show previously Spoke with the mayor about the PEG funding to see about the educational funding. I'm sorry the educational television What is it? Public Education and Government. And we have education, and it's public. So we're already on CAPS Television in Santa Barbara, and we just launched a Roehlinger's Fish and Show on Pursuit Network which is streaming on Any Dish network. So just seeing if we could kind of circle back around that PEG support that we spoke about at your office a few months back.
But then again also you should have flyers up there for this blue carpet premiere of Coastal Critters. It's kind of like a PBS style. Again, talking about art and STEAM. We put the A in Angler and we put the A in Art. And they just talked about the award that Oxnard got for art and culture that we do. And also again career development and multimedia that is growing right now. So you get a chance to see that. We have puppets coming in and it's an art collaboration so the music that's in the background of these shows are composed artists that you get to meet. So you get to meet the film artists, you get to meet the composers and they're gonna be on this blue carpet at the China Islands Maritime Museum in the China Islands Harbor. So anyhow, let's see I wrote a bunch of scribbles over here but I think I kind of covered it all but yeah just wanted to invite you to that you know to check it out it's kind of like a little mini film festival we'll have what is that refreshments you have little goldfish crackers and little gummy worms right?
And part of the program with the paid internship is a partnership with the Port of Wainimi. So they're a big sponsor of this too, as far as economic development goes we get two paid interns for the next two years per semester except for I think we're going to keep Josh for like two semesters because he's solid but then if you guys heard of their GTL program global training and logistics they get to pick a student from that as well that comes in as a paid intern. Right now we have five interns, and that's another partnership we've gone this year with Oxnard Union High School District. And then we have three different schools participating in our program now. Channel Islands, Rio Mesa and Oxnard, and we're looking to expand that with Ashley which is the student rep for VCOE.
So again you get a chance to come out and see all this cool stuff they were doing. Again I went to Oxnards College to be a filmmaker. I inherited a non-profit and went that direction But my heart is in art and this positive television show is for families, right? And you have like the word of the day. You know, like confidence or effort instead of letters that you would see on Sesame Street. So we kind of copied some of that style for a nostalgic feeling but you got me like Mr. Rogers meets Steve Irwin, The Crocodile Hunter also highlighting Oxnard and the tourism that we do have in our backyard on some of these programs. And the last thing is we do have a new children's workbook called Seabirds that one of the students will be premiering that day as well.
So come on out, enjoy some refreshments and watch it and see what you guys think. The date is February 6th. That's a Friday night so you get to mingle from five to six and then six to 730 is the time of the event. So again this is like getting a little mini film Canes Festival so we're gonna do it that way And I hope to see you guys out there, and then hopefully we can again review this PEG funding or PEG support and get our show back on local television here. Thank you.
Thanks, Kevin. Thanks, Josh. Thank you. Pastor Greg Wrengen followed by Ron?
3:11 – 3:174 turns
Good evening again, Mayor and Council. I won't take up too much of your time. I'm going to say a little bit of what I said earlier. New year, new hope and I hope that all of us can do our best to focus on the people and the problems Not let our focus get distracted on what's not being done. I actually spent a great deal of the last month talking with Chief Benitez about, not so much about pointing out what the problems are but how can we help the people who have the problems?
Because I think there's a lot of other things that go on in Oxnard besides immigration And homelessness, you know we saw human trafficking. Families are devastated. Fentanyl families are devastated. Whether or not shoplifting families are devastated. You know there's a lot more things now that are going to be crimes that weren't with Prop 36 passing and I just really hope that in 2026 we're able to do more than just be that person who points out, well this is a problem. This is a problem. This is a problem. This is a problem. Let's do this and fix it. You know let's try to help people like the Bible talks of somebody's hungry you feed them if they're naked you clothe them and I think that Oxnard Needs to get back to that. You know, years ago we had a slogan.
Remember the slogan was the city that cares? Well, a city can't care unless people care and it's important that we get back to that thing of what can we do. Government can't solve a problem. Government can create them. People solve them and its people working In step with government, I really mean this. Government shouldn't lead people. People should lead government and if we want folks to follow us, we need to make sure that we're leading them in a direction that we're helping people. So in 2026, I hope our focus remains on helping people not pointing out problems but fixing them. Thank you.
Thanks Pastor. Ron? And then, Ron you'll be followed by Dan Pineda. Go ahead, Ron.
Good evening Mayor McArthur, Mayor Pro Tem Turan and council members. My name is Ronald Aruejo and while not speaking on behalf of them I wanted to note and give context to the remainder of my public comments that I'm currently the chair of the Planning Commission, the chair of the Measure O Citizen Oversight Committee, and the chair of the East Village Neighborhood Council.
201,000 the number of people living in Oxnard. Eight, the number of appointments from Oxnard that only you Mayor McArthur can make to active citizen advisory groups. Zero, the number of people you have selected to serve on the CAG. It has been 14 months since you mayor were elected 13 months since you were sworn in and nine months since the first round of CAG appointments were being approved by this council. These CAG appointments are not a surprise When the first round of selectees were coming up for approval last April, that should have been the optimal time to start appointing. When over this summer or fall that you receive through an annual presentation or written communication from the current or immediate past chairs at a Community Relations Commission Cultural Arts Commission, Parks, Recreation and Community Services Commission, Planning Commission and Measure O Citizen Oversight Committee.
That would have been a late but needed start to select future members. Vacancies on the Measure O committee of which you as the Mayor can appoint three have left the committee on the cusp of not making quorum if just one member is absent which happened at the last meeting since five are needed on the nine-member committee and only six having been duly appointed.
With the Planning Commission, there have been major changes in CEQA which staff provided a thorough presentation on how that will impact our decision making. Which would have been great for the seventh member to have. Moreover I had wanted to provide a series of parliamentary mini sessions to help the members in that and whatever bodies they may serve on in the future. Of which I postponed until the end of the year in the hopes that the seventh member would have since been appointed.
Past or current council members have worked speedily to try to fill in the appointees that they are allowed. I remember former Mayor Pro Tem McDonald asking the public on Facebook for who has interest in an unfilled acquisition. Councilman Starr was able to select two people for the Planning Commission within the span of just three months. Council Member Perez recently asked the community through social media who wanted to serve on the Parks, Recreation and Community Services Commission for the District 6 vacancy.
Actions speak louder than words and unfortunately Mr. Mayor you have done neither. Your election was more than a year ago and it has been way past time to make these appointments And to the rest of council, if the mayor does not appoint a full slate to fill all of his vacancies by the first February meeting I'm kindly asking you to send your alternate applicants to the CAGS and I'll be making a public records request to see who actually does this by the end of the month.
I look forward to your appointments Mayor being agendized by next month. Thank you.
Thanks Ron. Mr. Dan Epineda? Then Dan will be followed by Mr. Larry Stein.
3:18 – 3:247 turns
My name is Dan Pinedo. I live in the Rio Lindo neighborhood. I want to thank Councilman Starr for his prompt response to the signs, commercial signs on public property. Thank you. As a member of the Rio Lindo neighborhood, I have some concerns regarding the median on Bahia Drive. The origin of the traffic median on Mejia Drive stems from Rio Lindo residents concerned about the potential hazards by the increased traffic in the neighborhood streets.
Prior to the Harborside, Sycamore Place and commercial development, Rio Lindo residents requested that a safety medium be installed at east exit of the shopping center as a deterrent to keeping motorists from entering the neighborhood. As part of the development agreement, the medium was a COP condition of approval imposed on the developer by the Oxnard City Council at that time.
Existing conditions and problems. The median exists in its original state. Motorists exit the commercial shopping center onto Bahia Drive must make a right turn and then must make a right turn onto Gonzales Road West to their destinations. It is no longer permissible to make a U-turn from Gonzales Road towards East Gonzales Road due to the proximity to the railroad and frequent train accidents, train related accidents at Gonzales and Oxnard Boulevard.
Rio Lindo residents visiting the shopping center are inconvenienced by having to drive extra minutes to get back into the neighborhood, into Rio Lindo neighborhood through St. Mary's Drive as a trade-off for that safety. Due to the increased traffic accidents on St. Mary's Drive have occurred more often. Traffic has increased over the years. Something needs to be done Cars do drive into the neighborhood against traffic on Bahia Drive. I have personally experienced a wrong-way driver and had to reverse myself to let that driver go through.
What's going to happen when the lot south of Gonzales Road is developed? An increase in traffic. Some residents want the medium removed, but I will not support any change that will put our city in a position of liability. It is my understanding that to remove or modify the median, it will require several. I wish for additional time Mayor to finish off. Mr. Pineda if you have something
written you can submit it to us.
Okay. The concerns are this.
No but that's, I'm sorry you're out of time Mr. Pineda. Out of time? Yeah okay thank you.
I have submitted so you have the text. Thank you sir.
Thank you. Mr Stein
Good evening, Mr. Mayor and City Council staff. I submitted an application to serve on the Parks and Recreation Committee last July. I submitted the application both to you Mr. Mayor and Ms. Perez, Council President Perez. That response has been unanswered. That position has not been filled. It's my understanding the City Council wants the public to participate in activities, particularly participate in these citizen action groups.
So why is it that members of City Council don't want to fill the positions if the City Council wants community activists? I'm dying! Well not quite yet but soon enough. But there are other people who have want the opportunities to be an activist. I'd like to be able to share my opinions and ideas to other people by serving on CAG, especially Parks and Recreation Committee CAG might be fruitful to other members.
I've been following parks and recreation activities for 30 plus years. College Parks has not been built or has not been finished. Residents pay developer fees develop sports park It's After 30 years, College Park hasn't been finished. After 30 years, Sports Park hasn't been finished. After 30 years Campus Park has not been finished so where's the money? People pay developer fees.
The fees went to the developers who paid fees to the city develop their infrastructures but the infrastructure have not been completed. Specific plans designed 30 years ago specific plans called for a park at the corner of Gonzales and Oxnard Boulevard. Explicit plans called for funds, and people paid funds to have a fire station built. At the turn of the century, you like that phrase? Turn of the century we had 50% build-out in East and West Village but no fire station despite their requirement to build a fire station at 50% build-out. In 2012 we had 100% build out at the East and West Village plants No fire station. In 2018, to correct Councilman Ferreira, in 2018 the Fire Chief said well we don't need a fire station at this area but developers have repaid their fees 12 years or 8 years ago.
Please complete the parks and plans that were permitted. Thank you.
3:24 – 3:3011 turns
And of course, we'll go to the virtual caller ending in 3259-3259.
Virtual speaker ending in 3259 you have three please press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Hi this is Deirdre Frank I'm calling to wish you all a very Merry Christmas tomorrow January 7 is Orthodox Christmas. I was raised as a Ukrainian Orthodox religion, and so tomorrow is our Christmas. We've had our holy days over the last 12 days and I don't know if you appreciate that there are cultures in your city beyond what we always talk about You even have a Ukrainian Orthodox Church on Woolley Road at Five Points.
Did any of you know that? I'm sure they're going to be celebrating a beautiful Christmas mass tomorrow, and I think some recognition should be made through the other cultures that we have within our city. So that was the point of my calling, but since I heard Mr. Pinedo speaking about some traffic design issues, Mr. Pinedo please send your report to me as a personal injury lawyer. I would love to put that in my file so that when I have a major crash or death Accident that happens at that location, I can win and recover something for the poor victim. That shouldn't have been a victim.
Merry Christmas everyone. Thank you.
Thank you. We'll go to the next virtual caller ending 4018-4018
Caller ending in 4018, please press star 6 to unmute and you have three minutes starting now. Hi
can you hear me?
Yes
Okay good evening and forgive my voice I'm one of the ones suffering with that terrible flu going around. My name is Doug Portello, I'm a long-term resident of Oxnard. I am the president of a local charity community renew alliance. I'd like to touch on a couple topics uh one is about the Quimby reserve fund projects it seems that of the $9 or $10 million to remain as Quimby Fund reserves that weren't spent when the developments were made. There's very little movement on seeing those monies go toward improvement of the parks. There's over 20 communities that have reserve funds and there's less than a handful that actually have capital improvement projects on paper, so there are some on paper but it's not what is required by the state from the Quimby Act and I think the residents and perhaps the new members of council need to understand that the Quimby Act allows for these funds for improvements of neighborhoods when the developments are made.
And so some of the neighborhoods like mine and Cabrillo are nearly 40 years ago that the neighborhood was developed, we have Cabrillo Park but some of the money was left over. When I was chair of the Neighborhood Council in 22 and 23, I became aware of these reserve funds and started making every effort and due diligence to move forward a project for our park And so thus far, there's been nothing done. So the current chair has also moved forward in communication with the city about moving that project forward. I don't understand why some of these Quimby projects don't even make the CIP list but I think more movement needs to be made. Now in terms of state law those funds, the cities only have five years to utilize those funds or return those funds to the property owners.
So I think it behooves Oxnard to make every possible effort to actually get an actual project moving forward with plans and all the necessary documentation that shows it's just not a piece of paper that's put on a shelf, but it's an actual project to move forward or those funds need to be returned to the property owners. That's the law and I believe that's what needs to be followed. Now, I'd like to touch on homelessness there's point in time counts that's a valuable snapshot of our homeless population but it's significantly underestimating the true scale and scope of homelessness by a single night method It's not the fault of the county or any other entities that are doing this, but there's reasons why it is.
Thank you. I hope you feel better thank you we'll
go to was at
the last virtual
3:30 – 3:4019 turns
Excuse me, Mayor. We have another virtual speaker ending in 1622. Please press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
And Mayor while the clerk unmutes the speaker I note that if this is the last speaker we have just about two minutes left in our 30-minute set aside period for this so I would Seeing no other speakers here and seeing no others with their hands raised, I wouldn't say that this would be our last speaker of the
evening. We have one more
member. Can we have
Mr. Ojeda?
Okay so we had another card come in then.
Yeah so just a virtual one and then Victor I think you're the last one.
Hi, this is Larry Barbarin. If there's any time left in my three minutes I'd like to give that to Mr Dan Penao great hearing his voice again to take up the remainder of my time if that's okay. I want to say Happy New Year to everybody and happy epiphany officially today, King's Day. And I want to thank Miss Frank as a reminder of Happy Orthodox Christmas for tomorrow to our brothers and sisters in the Orthodox Christian churches there.
Talked to the Abel Magana, all those involved with the downtown on that recognition. We have to watch just not to rain on any plate but we also the same data I read about that recognition was a day after Christmas and on Christmas there was a shooting on A Street and I hope that victim seems young man is doing well now. We had to keep our guard up even as we, you know, have good things as well. The Councilman Perlow mentioned about the names. I hadn't heard about that. I did some research while it was, since he said that.
And I think he might be referring, if you could flesh that out. There was names for instance at the USA Today and Stars and Stripes mentioned that were taken out due to DEI concerns touting the race and gender of veterans at Arlington for instance. And with President Trump, like any politician or anybody you got to call balls and strikes. So this is the same man who also funded permanently the historically black colleges and universities in the first term and protected a lot of people of color from a lot of arrests And, you know, appointed African-American head secretary and so forth. So I think it was more to tout their accomplishments, these veterans, for instance at Arlington and less focus on race in general because we've gotten so extreme on that above all other things a lot of times.
But I wouldn't have done that. You know, I think probably better just to keep those pages up on the website, for instance. I want to just mention briefly too that kind of in contrast with Mayor Pro Tem mentioned last month, Washington Examiner reported that The DHS has said that Homeland Security, it's reported that seven out of 10 people have been arrested that were illegal who did originally the crime of coming over illegally, federal misdemeanor. Seven out of the ten of them have criminal charges or been convicted since then other crimes and three of the ten could be from other had crimes committed in other countries.
So they are still focusing, and they should do on those who committed violent crimes after
the end of the year. Thank you. We're out of time. Thank you so much. And then Victor if you want to come up? Thank you. Yeah, Victor's the last speaker.
Hi good evening council members. You know and I want to first and foremost congratulate I want to thank you guys for supporting the city of Oxnard and the downtown, getting that California cultural district. And hopefully with that we can maybe get the Carnegie Museum back up and getting a couple more things for the kids. I remember as a kid growing up here, I had fond moments going there in the Gold Winds Children's Museum as well. I have a daughter now, she is eight years old, and I would like to have her have the same opportunities that I had as a child You know, mention what the pastor had mentioned before as far as being the city that cares. Which is what helped us grow into the city that we're now. And I'm hoping that, you know, we can get back to that.
I know, you know, Gabriella Basuah, she had a meeting with my mom at one point and gave her peace of mind. So that union, that carriage part starts with you guys. You know? And each and every one of you touch your community in your district and in your section. And you guys push forward for the city to move on. And as myself, you know, being a community member I'd like to also offer myself because I do hear that there's issues with not having enough people to go on the committee, then I'll join a committee or maybe two. And I implore that whoever is watching at home could do your part as a community member as well and not just let the council members force it all on them.
Sir Mayor, I know you've just been in this for 13 months. We all as a community union can come together and not push people away but more so let's help each other out to make the city work better You know, which is ultimately what we should all want. Now that the fact of you know you guys get the part of my language, the bad part of the stick then you know it sucks but at the same time you guys do a good part whether it's Micaela or whether it's Mr. Peralta or whether it's Pro Mayor Teran even Governor Rodriguez.
It's let's just keep pushing for a better Oxnard. You know, and Mr. Aaron Starr you yourself all the unusual I've loved what you've done with your community and continue to push forward with a lot of the members in that district. And you know, I you guys have my support for whatever you guys can need or will need whether it's an oversight committee or any of that nature and I congratulate you guys once again, no my applause to you guys off. All right. Thank you.
Thank you. Madam Clerk, just to confirm that concludes the last speaker?
Mayor and council members yes. That concludes our speakers in person and virtually for items not on the agenda thank you.
Thank you we will next
move to item H this is a report of the city manager Mr. Nguyen.
Thank You mr. mayor so it is a new year and it is January 6th it's been mentioned before tonight but I've been advised not to make any commentary about January 6 so I will not The one thing I'd pass along is that this Friday, our governor is expected to release his budget proposal for the upcoming year. So many eyes will be on that. It's very important for all sectors of the California community to be attentive Given the deficit that the state's been Banting about and again, it's it will be his initial proposal. So the next four months I'm sure there'll be a lot of back-and-forth but just want to pass that along It is expected this Friday. Thank you
Thank You mr. Wynn
The next item on the agenda is out of my This is the report from our City Council members and we'll start with you councilman
Thank you, Mayor, for the recognition. Happy holidays to everybody that celebrated and happy New Year as well. I had a lot of time to be out in the community in the month of December and really reflect on what goals I have for this upcoming new year. And as a part of that, I think one of the biggest Initiatives that I've championed early on is really wanting to make sure That not only do we consider the current generation of leaders But also preparing the next generation of leaders and so my goal this year is to meet with all of the schools within my district to really ensure that they know who their representatives are. I know a lot of our family members are Have many things that are on their plate. So meeting them where they are, which is oftentimes in the schools or out in community PTA meetings is something that I look forward to doing so this Thursday, I'll actually be at Blackstock's schools meeting with parents and families to really understand the needs and concerns of the community there and really look forward Thank you.
To have many volunteers. I know for some of the distributions we had in December, we had Oxnard girls flag football come out. We've had people even outside of Oxnard come out to really ensure that there's that community investment and volunteerism so really excited I wanted to share that in light of some of that work tomorrow, we are going to be welcoming our first cohort for the voices of Oxnard youth and really excited to get that off the ground with Mayor Pro Tem and really do the great work. So that's my report and handing it back to you mayor.
Thank You Councilwoman.
3:40 – 3:466 turns
Thank you very much. Again, as others have said, Happy New Year. Hope you had a good holiday season. Something that is not often talked about we as council members and I'm sure it goes out to large numbers of the public. You get a daily crime report. I want to thank the police department for the number of people under the influence that took off the roads. Each one of those cases is potential fatality Possibly for the person in the car or an innocent person that happens to meet them.
As was mentioned by Mr. Pinedo on that particular street, people come out of there to make a fast delivery of a pizza and they go the wrong way down the street and hope that nobody meets them head-on. And when that happens, the person that is going in the right direction has no opportunity to do anything other than to back up. It's a real problem. It's impossible not to make some mention of what's happened nationally with Venezuela.
I don't agree, and that's enough said on my part. I wish the best for this nation. I hope that the legislative, the executive, and the judicial branch of the federal government get their heads out of the sand and start looking out for the best possible for the city of Oxnard, the state of California, and the nation as a whole.
Thank you Mr. Peralta. Mayor Pro Tem.
Thank you, Mayor. I have a couple quick items here. So in my notes, I have a couple of neighborhood council meetings but in District 2 we have Carriage Square on January 15th at 6 45 p.m.. That'll be at Kern School, so anyone who lives in the Carriage Square neighborhood is welcome to attend. They are public meetings though, so if the agenda has some items that catch your eye you're welcome to attend as a member of the public. I encourage people to subscribe to the weekly packet and they can see all the neighborhood council meetings and the city meetings that are published every week at the end of the week.
I was able to volunteer as a tour guide for the Holly Trolley Tour over the holidays, and that was a great experience. I appreciate the opportunity to do so. And went through Christmas Tree Lane and there were a number of houses that were on the notes that we would talk about but otherwise they gave the tour guides kind of the freedom put their own flavor on it, and I appreciate that freedom because I got some great feedback. And it was a lot of fun for me so...I had a tough audience my last tour that I did because my grandmother, my grandfather, my mom and my aunt and uncle were right in the front row looking at me the entire time. So that was the toughest out of all of them but they were a friendly audience still.
So thank you again to all of the residents and the downtowners and Gary Blum, and everybody who put their time and effort into all of the festivities that happened over the holidays. And that was going to be my last note. I'm just going to say that in response to citing DHS themselves when it comes to statistics or information they're putting out, I'm looking at the numbers just right now from December 14th, 2025 their own numbers and shows here there are thousands more people in detainment by DHS who have no criminal record versus those who do.
And yet in the same breath DHS will say that they're going for the worst of the worst. The worst at what? So I'm just saying, just keep those things in mind. And let's also remember that this is a department that has shown time and again that they have no problem lying to the public. I will use the word lying not misinterpreting the facts, not getting it wrong and having to revisit they have lied. to the public. Locally, they lied about a community member focusing on and chasing and ramming into their vehicle when dash cam footage showed otherwise so and then nothing then they said nothing so let's Let's take what they say with a huge grain of salt. I'll bring some salt with you if you need some, some with me to share with you all if you need that but when they're sharing statistics we need to look at all sides of that and look at it factually.
So appreciate the extra time on that. Thank you Mayor.
Absolutely thank you Mayor Pro Tem. Councilwoman?
Thank you mayor. I first of all want to wish everybody a happy new year Also, I know there were comments in regards to the CAGs and the mayor. But the mayor, I know has been at least appointed is in the process of appointing somebody. So I do know that so I just wanted to make sure that the public does know that you are currently in the process of doing that. Somebody just did a background today for that.
And last, I want to wish my brother Jesus Chui A happy birthday. He was born January 6th, I know it's you know something that we don't want to talk about but it's also Dia de los Reyes in our culture so in a religious so I want to wish him a happy happy birthday love him very much and thank you for everything he does.
That's beautiful thank you.
3:46 – 3:513 turns
First of all Happy Holidays. It's been a joyous season. I attended some events. I attended a toy giveaway at the Colonia Gymnasium on December 17th, and there were a number of sponsors there both inside the city and outside the city that were helping out with that. And I think that was great. On that same night actually, I attended the Rose Park Neighborhood Council, or rather the Rose Park Neighborhood Holiday Potluck, and I know that the mayor was there. I believe Burprella was also there.
I attended the holiday Posada in La Colonia on the 19th. And one of my most enjoyable experiences was on December 24, when Abel Velasquez Sr. actually invited me to adopt a senior event at the Vistas at Oxnard Senior Living Center which is over on Gonzales near Williams. Abel was wonderful. He played, he dressed up as Santa Claus. He's a hysterically great Santa Claus and he was accompanied by a bunch of elves and I don't know who all of them were but apparently I got recruited to be an elf that day and that was fun.
I got to meet with some folks that Mayor Yu and I met with, I think it was A couple folks. One was Father Labonte and also Elira Crutcher, which I'm sad to report that she passed away a couple months ago and she was just such a wonderful person. I think she was 96. She had a great life and she had her faculties to the very end. And she's been a bedrock of the community, and you're familiar with her family.
So she'll be missed. And upcoming, I've got the Ventura Council Governments meeting on January 8th which I'll attend as an alternate. And on January 14th will be the East Village Neighborhood Council meeting which I will be attending. And that's everything. Thank you.
Yes, I know that I shared some of the issues that came up during the holiday season at Christmas Tree Lane. So I apologize for my misspeaking earlier and I just want to thank city staff again for going out there even after hours and just doing our best and every day we learn and every day we grow. I also attended some of the other events that were shared specifically at Casa Lopez. I know that we did like a tamale distribution on the 22nd for about 700 folks who came through I'm a kid who can, did a distribution of toy drive and that was amazing.
A lot of holiday cheer and Merry Christmas to those who celebrate tomorrow so I just want to recognize that there are a lot of different communities and as inclusive as we try to be please let us do better. Thank you for that. So I'm a kid who can we helped bring joyous memories or just you know celebrate the holidays For 265 families, and I know I don't want to see your thunder mayor But I know young quicks at Winnipeg High School also had their amazing distribution for our youngsters so even are my college students as I remember he used to do that for us while we were in high school last but not least I had the opportunity to go on tour along with Mayor Pro Tem Teran and Of the navigation center, and they are doing amazing work a hundred and ten beds.
I'm glad that it opened before the Atmospheric River and in the rains So I just I'm very grateful for everybody making that happen behind the scenes and the units that are up for rent so there's a lot of great things happening there and Last but not least in my last comments from the last meeting that we had I had mentioned some of the The traffic flow, and I know we're going to talk about it so I won't get in detail in terms of, you know, Kamala Elementary School. I did have a trustee Rose Gonzalez reach out to me just to see how we could strengthen our relationship. I am sharing the report that was put together by our public works and the initiative that we'll be talking about later today.
So I look forward to some type of partnership or at least making sure that the work that's been put together from our engineering team and folks just working on a plan Don't go unnoticed. So I really do appreciate folks listening to these reports and following up because that allows us to become that bridge when possible, so I think that's it for right now but thank you all and again happy holidays. I know many of us are missing cutting the Rosca de Reyes but we're happy to be here today.
Thank You Councilwoman and Mayor Pro Tem go ahead.
3:51 – 3:596 turns
Thank you Mayor. Just a quick item that I did leave off, I'd be remiss if I didn't congratulate our Senator Monique Limon who was just sworn in as Senate President for 10-4. our state legislature. And so congratulations to Senator Limon and she's been a great partner, I think with the city of Oxnard and I feel fortunate to be able to work with her. And I'm sure many of us who've had the opportunity do so would say so as well. And so I just wanted to acknowledge that and I will second what Councilwoman Basuah mentioned at a recent meeting, I did see on your desk you did have the binder for the applications for the CAGS. So I know the work has been happening.
Thank you for pointing that out. I appreciate that and look, I just want to speak about the obvious. We had a very challenging time. Many of us who are long term Members of this community recognize that this last year has been the most difficult, I think politically that we've seen. At least in our generation right and so it's been extremely difficult for many of us here to navigate.
I know for me is trying to walk a straight line go this one's like go this way it's been difficult right so that's where I think leadership comes in where we are true to who we are, true to our character, true for what we stand for. And I think you've seen many of us that are here. You know this job is a lot of volunteer work right? We do it because we genuinely sincerely care about community and trying to make it better and so a lot of the passionate conversations held here as well as some of the speakers that come up is, I get it. It's because equally we all want the same thing. We want our community to be better but I can tell you when we speak about actions, I personally have started this whole year meeting business owners very strategically going door-to-door meeting our business owners just connecting with them or homeowners.
That's why some of you follow me on social media realize how busy I am because I very purposefully and very intentionally go out there and interact with people But in those interactions, you get homework out of it. People are asking for something or wanting you to look into something and that's what we do. And I tell you at a meeting with our executive leadership team, we've got a great, great staff that is committed to making this city better.
And if you see the amount of work that they do, you can understand from their perspective how tirelessly they work to make our city better. That's not to say that we can't always do more because certainly that's the input we get and I tell you when We're bringing issues forward. They recognize it, like yes you know what maybe we erred here or there was a misstep here but let's correct it. Let's have those robust conversations and let's intentionally work to do better. And I can tell you those things are happening and that's why I'm such a believer in our democracy because we are conduits to your voice what it is that's important to you It's certainly important to us and we convey that to our executive leadership team, to make those things happen for us and they're doing it.
They're absolutely doing it. And so I'm just thrilled that we have who we have here on board from Pink Gilly to our city manager, city attorney and everybody else because when you bring issues is like not on the defensive but let's recognize it. Let's try to move on or let's have a good conversation about it and we move forward because ultimately it's evolution. We want to keep pushing, pushing So my commitment to you for this next year is I will continue to meet with all our departments. I will try very intentionally to make all of our neighborhood council meetings that are present, to go out there and just hear and present to our community as well as continue my relationships with the schools because I am a proponent of our youth because they're ultimately our next generation and for them to get connected with our local government And as you know, my principal thing for me is modernizing and beautifying our city.
And I've talked about that extensively from maintaining our green spaces to pushing more infrastructure in our roads and our inspectors. Just look at our city after the rain that we received. Our inspectors are doing a great job in going out there. Look at all the major streets that have been resurfaced. You don't see a lot of flooding It's just, it goes to show the care that has been done in doing what we're doing. Right?
I got the report about how many trees we had fallen during the storm and the winds too in our city being the biggest city in this whole region. Two trees and that's a remarkable work that we're doing. And I think it's also because of trimming, the pruning of our trees and maintenance work ahead of time And as a consequence, you saw what we saw. Very minimal. And that translates to a better quality of life and making sure nobody gets injured because of these hazards that our climate presents.
And so that's the action that you're seeing and that we're all enjoying because ultimately, that's what local government can do is enhance the quality of life for all of us. And that is for us to do that, to set those policies in place All of us, all of our quality of life. So as your mayor out here I'm just committed to continuing those efforts and hearing directly from the public what should be priority in having those conversations with our executive leadership team to make sure that we implement those priorities that are a priority for our public. And just lastly, I was on the radio this morning and I've been on radio leading up to the holidays Asking, pleading with our community to please take care of this city. The way we are taking care of our city here with modernizing and beautifying our city presenting it better just like as soon as you walk out of here you'll see our palms are beautifully cut.
You saw what we're doing here in front of our library the police department And I know I misspoke on a video where I said we were bringing in artificial turf. I just, I misspoke there but there's no artificial grass coming in. I'm not a proponent of that but that's not happening at all. But it's just beautiful and now let's, I challenge all of us to make sure that we also take care of it from our wayfinding signs, our gateway signs. Just picking up after ourselves and you know Victor, you see me out there in the soccer fields picking trash after everybody plays Right, because I believe in actions. I believe in us doing our part by taking care of our city not tagging it just enhancing and making a better for all of us This is all of our house right just like the police department has police cars that are clean It's I think for anybody coming in or living this city.
I think If it presents well if you've got Police cars if you've got our city trucks or fire trucks our city buildings which is essentially as your your is yours. It's ours If it presents well, that is showcases that this is a city that absolutely cares and takes pride in our city. And I ask all of you here and also that are watching to please help us take care of the city so that it's beautiful for all of us to enjoy because that's how we're going to get just joy living here but also that And so we all benefit as a result of us collectively taking care of it. So that's my ask of all of us, thank you. And with that I think that concludes unless anybody else has any other comments to make?
If not then we'll go to
the next item on the agenda and
the next item is the review of our info consent agenda And at this point, is there a particular item that you want to remove or want further discussion on? Council Member Stone go ahead.
Yeah just briefly for L1 and L6.
Okay one in six.
4:00 – 4:0621 turns
And if we want to vote on the other items I believe that only number four is one where it's no action required so Vote on the remainder.
If you move, I'll second
that. I'll make that motion to vote on the non-action rather ones that require action that are not one in six.
So it would be two, three...
Two, three, five, seven and eight.
Are there any public comments on any of the agenda items?
Mayor and council members, we do not have any public speakers for the information and consent agenda. Thank you. Both in person and virtually. Thank you.
Thank you Madam Clerk. We have a first and second to approve the other items with exception of item four which is just a receiving file item.
Councilmember Perallo? Yes. Councilwoman Bettis? Yes. Councilwoman Rodriguez? Aye. Councilman Starr? Yes, Councilwoman Basuah? Yes Mayor Pro Tem Teran? Yes Mayor McArthur?
Yes
and this motion carries seven to zero thank you
Thank You madam clerk And we will start with the first item you pulled um Council Member Starr this is L1
Most I just wanted this to be a separate vote because I intend to abstain on it okay I have currently having There's currently litigation involved with contribution limits. And I think as you probably know, I'm philosophically opposed to them because I think they're a violation of the First Amendment. But I understand that my view is maybe the minority view here and that's the only reason why I wanted this polled so I can vote separately to abstain.
Just for those watching that are not following on the written item, L1 is from the City Clerk Department. The subject entails campaign contribution and loan limit adjustment. The recommended action is that the city council adopt a resolution adjusting campaign contribution limits and loan limits set forth on sections 2-443 and 2-444 of the Oxnard City Code. This item did not originate in committee.
Is there any further discussion on this? Mayor Bortelli.
All right, thank you mayor. And thank you, Madam Clerk for the update on this and just so that the public is clear on it since it's pulled as an agenda item or pulled from the consent calendar for discussion. There are contribution limits that the voters enacted in the 2020 election And it initially was at $500. It was also written into that initiative that there would be every two years evaluation to look at the CPI and if it needs to be adjusted, and in this case we were adjusting it again.
And so for those running for the Office of City Council and those running for Mayor, City Clerk, and City Treasurer, this would apply to them at different levels because councils by district and mayor, clerk and treasurer are at large. So the details on that are in the staff report if anyone wants to see it. I will share that prior to being on council, I was absolutely a proponent of reining in the amount of money that is going into elections at all levels Local, county, state, federal.
Folks go watch a video about Citizens United if you want to get some information about the federal level but looking at local elections when we especially looking at a district-based election 33,000 and 35,000 residents and then a fraction of that being number voters 18,000 22,000 depending on the district but I'm a firm believer that people who live and interact and engage in their community, and what's happening in their community, the money involved in their election should be irrelevant.
And this was originally started as $500 max contribution per individual, and then it was $1,000 from committees or from PACS. Even at that level, I remember putting a comment in back in 2020 saying we should also have spending or expenditure limits where there's a limit on the amount a candidate can spend on their candidacy and their election. And at the time, the county of Ventura had something similar and many other jurisdictions have that.
And I just truly believe that Money should be irrelevant when it comes to running for local office. At this level, somebody who is truly out there doing the work is going door-to-door, is talking to voters. That's not some lower form of running for office. That's the way to run for office. So to say that someone has to resort to doing that because of contribution limits, I disagree fully with that ideology.
So I just want to put out there to the public watching and those coming into this election year that I fully support this and yes we are increasing it because of CPI and that's the way the voters enacted it and I'm fine with that But even absent this, I would have personally put limits on myself. Even absent these limits because I truly believe that someone with actual community support and actual community engagement doesn't need this in order to get elected. You don't need $75,000, $100,000 to get elected. You just need to do good work for the community. So those are my comments. Thank you Mayor.
Thank you Mayor Pro Tem. Are there pros or cons on this side? If not is there a motion on the table?
I'll move the recommended action to adopt this.
I'll second.
Great. Madam Clerk, call for the
vote. Councilwoman Perez? Yes. Councilwoman Rodriguez? Aye. Councilman Starr?
Abstain.
Roll-call vote Passed 3–0 move the recommended action to adopt this. I'll second. Great. Madam Clerk, call for the vote. Councilwoman Perez? Yes. Councilwoman Rodrigu · 1 under review
Show transcript
4:06 – 4:1721 turns
And the motion carries 6-0-1 with council member Starr abstaining thank you
Thank you, Madam Clerk. We'll move to L6. This is from the Public Works Department. The subject agreement with Premier Property Preservation LLC for custodial services at the John C. Zaragoza Oxnard Transit Center, otherwise known as OTC. The recommended actions that the City Council approve and authorize the Mayor to execute in agreement with Premier Property Preservation LLC for a term of one year from February 1st, 2026 to January 31st, with an option for four consecutive one-year periods, ending January 31st, 2031.
For a total contract not to exceed amount of 700,000 for custodial services at the John C. Zaragoza Oxnard Transit Center. The Public Works and Transportation Committee approved this item 2-0 on December 9th, 2025. And our director Michael Wolfe is here to answer any questions we may have. Council Member Starr go ahead.
Yeah mine is just a request so I'm was reviewing the prior agreement's schedule of compensation at the end of the staff report for these custodial services. I can see that the monthly cost is dropping from $11,386 per month to $10,480 which is a good thing. What I'd like to see in a future report is that such comparisons are prominently mentioned in the report summary itself because I think people should know when we're actually making improvements Also know when we're not making improvements, but that's all I'm requesting is just a little bit more prominence on that. But otherwise people could dig through the entire report and ultimately figure it out. But let's show ourselves off when we can.
Because I know in reading the report, I hear what you're saying. In reading the report, when he went out for bidding, I saw the numbers on there which is great work. But I hear what you're saying. Any other comments pros or cons? Go ahead Mr. Perlow.
Thank you very much. I appreciate the staff report since this item has been pulled off the agenda and there's questions and asked, I had not intended to but I am going in now. With respect to the history of the Transportation Center, when there were times when human waste would be outside of the building when people would come to work. Is this going to be handled differently because we do have a bid as the council member mentioned? It's lower than in the past. Is there an extra cost when human waste is involved and has to be handled different than a custodian?
I know that the downtown improvement with the human waste issue it's handled much differently We can't just flush it down to the drains and send it down the street. So is there some extra cost involved or unforeseen potentially?
Good evening Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, Council Members Michael Wolff, Director of Public Works. What you're talking about is some of the contracts that we have for biohazards that are in like the parking structure and the right-of-way and those were handled differently than just regular street sweeping things like that. The contract here is for janitorial services, which does include the handling of biohazards.
We have as-needed services and so when those things are above and beyond what they typically have to do then it may fall into the as needed services and not their normal routine services that they would do either on a daily or weekly or quarterly basis. So the question's a little bit has two parts to it one is that part of their routine process is to clean up The restrooms that may or may not include biological waste. The other part of it, if it's not part of the routine then it would be extra cost for those things and so there's two parts to that question.
Okay thank you very much for the clarification I appreciate it.
Thank You Mr. Perlow any other questions? I'll
move the recommended action if he's not.
Wonderful. I'll second
it.
Wonderful Madam Clerk call for the vote
I'm sorry, Mary. It was moved by Mayor Pro Tem Teran and seconded by... Thank you. Councilwoman Rodriguez? Aye. Councilman Starr?
Yes.
Roll-call vote Passed 3–0 Moved by Gabe Teran moved by Mayor Pro Tem Teran and seconded by... Thank you. Councilwoman Rodriguez? Aye. Councilman Starr? Yes. Councilwoman Basuah? Yes · 1 under review
Show transcript
And this motion carries 7-0 thank you
We'll now move to the next item on the agenda. This is Item N1 from Public Works, Subject Safe Routes to School SRTS Report. The recommendations of the City Council receiving and file the city's safe routes to school report. The Public Works and Transportation Committee approved this item 2-0 back on December 9th 2025 to forward the item to the full City Council to review and receive and file it. Director Michael Wolfe is here along with members of his staff Jose and Morgan to answer any questions we may have of them. We'll start with Council Member Starr, go
ahead. Yeah just a couple questions so I'm looking at page 266 of our PDF and let's see if i got this. I think I got the right page here it says in compliance with the California ATP grant a student Travel survey was distributed to schools to gather pre-project and post project pedestrian and bicycle student travel tallies. During phase one a total of 13 of 26 schools provide responses reflecting a 50 percent response rate which is a reasonable outcome for a survey this kind, and then it says post program data from phase two schools will be collected analyzed reported in fall of 2025 so I'm just wondering is there going to be some update that will Say what the analysis shows.
Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, council members. My name is Jose Rivera from the Traffic Engineering Division. To answer your question, Council Member Starr, the post surveys are still in the process to be collected. We've been having challenges getting the responses from schools but we're still working on it.
Okay so we'll get eventually and I can see how this city constructed infrastructure changes like extending a sidewalk and traffic calming measures. I can see how that can improve safety. I'm concerned the recommendations in this report that require action by the school districts, the operations and program aspects will just wind up on our shelf somewhere never be implemented. And there is why I am concerned about this when I look at page 265 walk to school day the SRTS project team conducted Walk to school day events in October 2022, 2023 and 2024. Interested schools were provided with flyer and banner templates to encourage student participation. And then it says this in 2023 no even mentioned 2022 because I guess the number is zero but in 2023 two schools participated reported back And in 2024, two schools also participated and reported back following the event.
So out of 51 schools very little interest from the school districts. And I just would love to know do you have any thoughts on what we can do to inspire the school districts to implement the operations and program aspects of this large report?
I don't want to speak for the school about what their workload is and what their concentration is on. I'm going to guess, having been a product of the school district a long time ago that their focus is on other things sometimes. But I would say that it is we want the administration from the school district to take this information and be part of their educational component Part of their parent teacher association interactions. I know that Jose can talk about some of the things that he has seen or has heard from school districts where they put this in to the parent-teacher packages that go out on Sunday for the next week.
So we are seeing and hearing and finding that the school district is utilizing this information in its intent, part of that is then what's the followup of that? And so there was a separation between the city And I would think it'd be interesting conversation as an elected official if you wanted to have it with a school board member. We've talked about this and say, hey the city's given you some interesting information how are you guys going to use it?
And maybe the school board members can talk about it at the school board. We got to be very careful about a fine line between our recommendations and our potentially overreach in terms of what our responsibilities are or liabilities are And so I would say that we'd be cautious from a staffing standpoint of Pushing the issue too far other than making recommendations Absolutely,
thanks. That makes a lot of sense There's one thing that I think we should look at to improve safety That's not really mentioned here now Maybe it's something that the police department can look at but I I'm referring to vehicle code 28 15 and Basically It's not in the report, but basically it makes it possible to. Well let me just I'll just read it to you says any person who shall disregard any traffic signal or direction given by a non-student school crossing guard appointed pursuant to this other section are authorized by a city police department any board of supervisors county blah blah when the guard is wearing The official insignia of a school crossing guard. And when in the course of the guards duties, the guard is protecting any person crossing a street or highway in this vicinity of a school, or while returning thereafter to a place of safety shall be guilty of an infraction subject to the penalties provided in this other section.
So what I'm wondering is, is it possible for us to empower school crossing guards kind of initiate the process where they can document, maybe with a camera or something like that, somebody who's going past a crosswalk without stopping when they ought to. And at that point, of course, have maybe law enforcement at that point receive the report and issue a citation. I don't know if that's something that's possible but if it can be done, I think maybe it's another tool to add to the toolbox.
4:17 – 4:3317 turns
Yeah, I'm not so sure council member said that our public works director can answer that question. And
that's why I said this is probably a matter for the police department or city attorney's
office. Just to circle back, I had to sit down with Director Wolf and his staff on this particular item and I committed to Director Wolf that I would personally go speak with the elected officials at the school districts And also have sit-down meetings with the superintendent's office and just provide them this report. And just urge them to share that with parents and the principals, and so forth. But I think the benefit of having this report too gives us the foundation to go after grants and so forth because we've got the data Essentially the information we need to showcase where certain schools may need some infrastructure enhancements for commuter safety, pedestrian safety and so forth. So this is a great tool that we have to work with.
And so I told our director that I would commit to going out there and speaking with the trustees as well as the superintendent's office.
Mayor, I really do appreciate you doing that. So thank you for taking that on. I think it's very important, well with the safety of our children.
Absolutely.
Thank you, Mayor. And similar conversation I had with Mr. Wolf and his team on this. And I think that there's an important component to this that we all in the public need to recognize as well that our traffic engineering staff and our public works staff have gone and done some physical changes around these schools to enhance safety and to do some traffic calming but Those physical things alone are only part of the equation and the city's only part of the equation. I believe that good collaborative partnerships with the school administration and between the school administration and parents and families of those schools is where those three being involved, is where we'll actually see effectiveness. Because any one of those groups doing it on their own is only going to have limited effectiveness but all three of them is where you're really going to hit the sweet spot in that Venn diagram of having effective change happening within these around the schools and I will just use one school in District 2 as an example They did receive some of the little islands.
I apologize, I forget the technical name for them but around each crosswalk and then they received a lighted crossing beacon as well and that and they actually from the recommendations of engineering a crosswalk was moved to another part of the rear entrance for this school and that has made a major difference But as I shared at committee as well, prior to all this work happening there was an issue with parents who were double parking or parking in red zones or parking in a way that they're blocking visibility of the crossing guard at the crosswalk. And so the school and parents taking it upon themselves to put their own cones out there to block other parents from parking in the red zone is what made the difference.
And the school had cones, they just needed to put them out. And for whatever reason in the city of Oxnard people will respect a cone. They won't park there if there's a cone there and so putting them out before school bringing them in and then before school let out putting them back out that kept people from parking in that red zone Increasing safety and unfortunately at this school. There was a student who was hit by a car in that crosswalk And they believe it was two school years ago, and they were you know very very minor injuries But it still happened and so the administration staff parents and the city we all have a role in this I think there's opportunity in these conversations to see what we can all do to pitch in on this and last thing for councilmember star and then Mr..
Wolf we have three folks up here who worked in education on some level. And I will say that even just the surveys, there's a concept of survey fatigue within education and they have to do all these surveys for any number of things. Sometimes they're required by grants that they have to do X amount of response rate for a survey or there's these surveys by the PTA or surveys for any number of reasons and it's another thing that they have to do but the programming and operational side is Within education, there is a pretty universal staffing shortage for classified and certificated staff members.
So even if they want to have crossing guards out at every exit and entrance of the school, oftentimes an administrator has to make the decision do I have a safety person watching the gate to make sure nobody comes in or do I have a crossing guard? And it's one or the other just from physical bodies they have with the availability for that type of work So I think that's where we can talk about with crossing guard programs through PD or parent volunteers or school staff who are able to, are willing to work to do that extra duty. They could do that too but it's not an impossible unsolvable issue here. We all have a role in it so anyways that's my comments thank you.
You know we've got the, no thank you Mayor Pro Tem we've got the three E's and For traffic safety, engineering education and enforcement. I think Michael Wolfe would say we have five. We recognize the three. But it's hard to predict driver behavior for example. How do you change that? But I think the schools in my experience as a policeman they've been great partners here recently with taking on the crossing guard responsibility themselves, and also encouraging parents to also volunteer to help with traffic safety. And we recognize it's just that in the morning during a drop-off and then pickup, right? It's just...and I think our streets were not necessarily meant for that even though I think we have tried our darndest. And so it's just we have to constantly, I think, preach Education part of it right.
I think the engineering can only do so much now It's the education part of it is making sure that we can hopefully encourage good driving behavior By my parents and then the enforcement should be the last thing Which you consider, but that's also an element to it But if it's a job, but I think this report will give us the opportunity go after aggressive go after some grant funding That'll help us as a city Any other comments, pros or cons for the Senate? No.
I just want to thank them for the heavy lift because I see just the evaluation, the assessment and everything that you are recommending. I really appreciate how much work has been put into this and like I did say Rose Gonzalez already reached out and I'm glad to make a warm handoff or participate as needed. But I'm glad to see that there's an interest, and she was excited about this report. So I can't speak for her but at least our previous engagement was positive.
Yeah so thank you for that.
Thank you very much for the presentation. I did have the opportunity to speak as I'm sure every council member did with the Public Works staff. I appreciate it just a suggestion to council members if you want more buy-in Whatever school districts are in your district, you could get the schools that are in your district and you could get a hold of the local neighborhood councils that are addressed. That's one strong body that has an interest because most neighborhood councils have people on board that have kids and they're looking out for their kids.
One thing that I need to state If we're going to look for grants or we're going to look for putting money into crossing guards, I want the school districts to go 50-50 on this. I don't want the city to do the job of the schools. I'll go 50 50 but I'm not going to pay all the bills for a school district. The other issue is it's ever since I've moved into residential area and traveling throughout the City of Oxnard It's not the erratic driver driving through a school zone. It's not the commercial truck, it's not the drunk driver. It's the mom and dads dropping their kids off at school that are the most dangerous thing near schools at pickup and drop-off time. It is insane what goes on. The school in my neighborhood, Rio Del Norte, they ran over the principal's foot and broke his foot.
He's trying to slow people down. It is insane. And when we do have enforcement at the beginning of the year When it gets exciting, I am all for not giving warnings. You give citations when people do things they get a citation and the word gets out very fast nobody likes paying a fine but I don't know how else you teach the public because they seem to forget it the next opening year day of school they're gonna start all over again but I think the neighborhood councils are something we could take advantage of.
Thank you Council Member. Yes, go ahead Mayor Pro Tem. Absolutely.
I'll just second what Council Member Perrello said that the Carriage neighborhood has given great feedback and the school has taken that and worked with them to ensure that parking habits and driving habits of the parents during pickup and drop-off you know were addressed and so absolutely correct on that with the neighborhoods and we all have schools within our districts nothing stops us from going and talking to those principals and having sit down meetings with them And with the school board trustees as well.
Trustee Gonzalez is a great partner as well, she's been very engaging and approachable and easy to work with so last question if I can Mayor. I believe there was legislation that started that is kind of a graduated legislation that would allow through local ordinance lowering of speed limits in school zones between now and 2030 or 31 I believe Is that about correct? So not to go off the agenda item here, but it does pertain to what we're talking about with school safety. If there's any little brief information you can give us on that.
Sure I think you were looking at my notes from earlier this morning because Morgan and I were talking about that earlier today so yes there is a new law that by code in 2031 will produce Basically a prima facie or a default speed limit in the school zone for 20 miles an hour. So we are talking about how that looks in terms of rollout, obviously there's an enforcement component to that that needs to be discussed as well. There's a cost component to that so you can and we don't know right now all the logistics behind it in terms of do we need to have an action item from the council to do it in advance of 2031? So we're looking into all those things I will say though I don't want to pass up this opportunity because of the information and knowledge that we have in public works.
Speed limits are set a certain way, and there's lots of studies out there from the Federal Highways Association FHWA that talks about just putting up a lesser speed limit does not typically result in lower speeds. And so this is While this is a new law that will be in effect 2031, whether or not it actually is fruitful is a different question. And whether or not there's how that gets enforced as even a bigger question but there are lots of studies out there by just putting up a random speed limit that's lower than the traditional way you set it doesn't usually result in
reduction in speed. Understood thank you for that and last thing I'll say Mayor there's plenty of studies too to show I've been to other states where the speed limit in And the enforcement is on it where people, they go the 20 miles per hour because they don't want to get caught going 22 in that zone because it is pretty stiff. So anyway thank you for answering that Mr. Wolfe. Thank
you. Absolutely. Thank you Mayor Pro Tem. Any other comments? If not this there's no action. I won't take any public comment though. Thank you mayor. I'm so sorry Mr. Wynne yes go ahead.
Just a little history for this again to broaden the context Obviously it behooves all of us to do everything we can to improve safety, especially around schools. But there's statewide history here. So this has nothing to do with Oxnard. But when a school goes to create a school they don't go through the local jurisdictions for planning and anything. It all goes I believe is it called the State Department of Architecture? Yeah.
So there's minimal, minimal coordination with local jurisdictions about road design and all that. Very minimal. So we speaking abstractly about all local jurisdictions don't have the opportunity to have a discussion about how we would like to see a safer pickup drop-off zone and understandably Every school wants to maximize their real estate for things within their fence line.
The result over the decades has been these safety problems have been pushed out into the public right away, so everyone scrambles to try to make things safer and improvement and make improvements but it all goes back to there's no coordination. The school plans go to Sacramento They get approved there. We don't have enough... And again, it's not Oxnard. It's just the way things have evolved and local jurisdictions don't have the opportunity to say, hey, can you build a pickup and drop-off zone there?
Right, so that it gets the traffic out of the road. And it's particularly difficult and problematic in neighborhoods with narrow roads. So there's some history to this here. So everything we try to do now to make it safer is always going to be not enough and mostly imperfect solutions. Thank you.
Thank you for that clarity and insight. Madam Clerk, are there any public speakers on this item?
4:33 – 4:332 turns
Mayor and council members we do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for this item thank you.
Thank you no actions required this is only a file-and-receive item and yeah yeah thank you Councilmember Starr and if there's no objection nothing else on the agenda we are adjourned thank everyone