UnGovr Transcript
iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.0:01 – 0:5018 turns
Hi, good evening. Welcome to the City Council meeting for Tuesday, March 17th, 2026. Madam Clerk, may we have the roll call and posting of the agenda please?
Councilmember Perala?
Here.
Councilwoman Beres? Here. Councilman Starr?
Here.
Mayor Pro Tempteran? Here! Mayor McArthur?
Here
The agenda for this meeting was posted in the kiosk at City Hall, the Oxnard Public Library, the city administrative offices and on the city's website on Thursday March 5th and the amended agenda on Wednesday March 11th. Thank you.
Thank You Madam Clerk. Prior to closed session we will take public comments on the closed session agenda. Can the City Attorney Please provide a statement prior to closed session.
Thank you, Mayor. The City Council will recess to a closed session pursuant to government code section 54956.9 subdivision D1 to confer with its attorneys. The matter being discussed is Oxnard versus Port Hueneme Water Agency And so there are no comments.
Mayor and council members for the record, there are no public comments for closed session. Thank you. Thank
you, Madam
Clerk. Thank you
Mr. Fischer. Go
ahead.
I know she's not here but do we need to make a statement around Councilwoman Basuah recusing herself from this item? Thank you
So Councilwoman Basuah is not present at this time and will be recusing herself from this item because of a conflict of interest under Government Code Section 8-7 1-0-0. Thank you.
I appreciate the prompt, Mayor Pro Tem. Thank you Mr. Fisher. The City Council will now recess to closed session and at 5 p.m., we will begin with an appointment item followed by the regular scheduled council meeting. Thank you Good evening. The City Council has just emerged from closed session. I'll ask our city attorney, Mr. Fisher to make an announcement. Thank you, Mr. Fisher.
0:50 – 1:096 turns
Thank you Mayor. There are no reportable actions out of closed session this evening.
Thank you, Mr Fisher.
We will move to the next item on the agenda. I'm going to move over to Item D2 first. This is from United Water Conservation District Santa Felicia Dam safety project update The recommendations that the City Council one, receive and file an update regarding the United Water Conservation District Santa Felicia Safety Project. And two, authorize the mayor to sign the attached letter of support for the Santa Felicia Dam Safety Improvement Project. There's a live presentation by United Water Conservation District staff.
Mr. Wolf is here as well, our Director of Public Works that will make the introduction. Go ahead, Mr. Wolf.
Yeah, good afternoon Mayor and council members. Michael Wolfe, Director of Public Works We do have one of our important regional partners in the water industry here tonight to give a presentation, and we're pleased to have that. They're going to talk about a very unique and regional project I think is important to all folks in Ventura County. So we do have their assistant general manager Dr. Marion Brault will be giving the presentation today so here's Marion.
Welcome doctor thank you
Thank you. Thank you for the presentation, Mr. Wolff. I would like to acknowledge our directors, President Malhart and Director Huber being here supporting us and my senior engineer Adrian Kuras. Thank you for the opportunity to present Santa Felicia Dam Safety Improvement Project and the benefits that it provides to Ventura County. Before I go deep into the presentation on this particular project, I would like to briefly highlight the services that United Water provides to the county. So our service area spans from the northeastern part of the county all the way to the Pacific Ocean along the Santa Clara River covering about 340 square miles.
Our Santa Felicia Dam and Lake Piru provide 80,000 acre feet or over 26 billion gallons of storage for water conservation. The lake also allows us to import state water project via pyramid, which is a benefit for our water reliability and down on the Oxnard plain On the Oxnard Plain, our Freeman diversion allows us to divert surface water from Santa Clara River for recharge purposes through a number of recharge basins in Saticoy and El Rio.
We also provide service water directly to the PTP, Pumping Drought Pipeline and the Pleasant Valley Reservoirs for irrigation purposes. At the Rio Wellfield we produce drinking water that is conveyed through the OH pipeline and serves over 200,000 people including the majority of the residents in the city Oxnard. Lastly, I would like to also talk about a new project that we are currently designing the extraction barrier and brackish water treatment project that once it comes online it would effectively manage seawater intrusion and provide a new and reliable supply to our service area Moving on to the Santa Felicia Dam and Lake Piru Reservoir. This facility was the first one in the state of California dedicated for groundwater recharge and seawater intrusion management.
This is a very critical facility for our operation, and I would like to highlight some of their benefits. So earlier I mentioned that Lake Piru allows us to import state water project to our service area and since 1991 we have imported over 107,000 acre feet or 35 billion gallons of water. And the state water project import was aggressively intensified during the drought where the groundwater levels were very low and their drinking water quality was deteriorating.
On a side note, we also take advantage of the flood flow releases from Castaic Dam and between 2017 to 2025 We have brought over 100,000 acre feet or 33 billion gallons of water to our service area. So what do we do with the stored water? This is a clip of annual conservation releases that we usually conduct during the fall, during the late summer months. And what you see here is a release of 400 cubic feet per second flow to Lower Piru Creek.
On annual basis, over 26,000 acre feet or 8.5 billion gallons recharge the groundwater basins in the upper system including Pairoo, Fillmore and Santa Paula. And the releases provide diversion flows at Freeman Diversion as I mentioned. The diverted flows are used for groundwater recharge for direct surface water delivery to our agricultural customers and During the prolonged drought, it helps correct the drinking water quality.
In addition, the reservoir is critical to wildfire suppression or response to wildfires. And this clip shows the aircraft that directly taps into the reservoir extract water for canyon fire suppression. That actually happened last August 2025. Although the Santa Felicia Dam is well maintained and operate reliably, however the dam was built in 1955. It means that it is 70 years old and it has three main deficiencies.
The existing outlet works is not designed to respond to the regulatory mandated seismic loading of 7.2 magnitude. In case of a seismic failure, what happens is that the dam safety will be potentially compromised and it would result into downstream flooding. So through a number of analysis, we have determined that this existing outlet works need to be replaced with a new one. And I also want to draw your attention to the location of the site which is in a seismically active region and the site is about two miles away from the controlling San Cayetano fault and 20 miles south of San Andreas fault.
The second deficiency is related to reservoir siltation that has claimed about 20% of the original storage capacity. United tracks the sediments elevation around the intake tower and as of 2023, the sediment elevation is about 18 inches below the rim of the intake tower. What happens if sediment gets into the intake tower? It would compromise and perhaps halt our ability to release water in a controlled manner. Obviously, we want to avoid that.
Last deficiency is related to the existing spillway capacity to safely pass the regulatory mandated inflow design flood which is 220,000 cubic feet per second. improvements are needed to allow this regulatory requirement to be met. So let's say that there is a massive, very large storm event what happens is if we have kind of like a choke point the spillway walls and the dam will be overtopped and it could potentially lead to imminent failure of the dam The dam failure as the highest concern in the county is confirmed through the 2022 multi-jurisdictional hazard mitigation plan that was adopted by the county. And as you can see, there is a list of cities including the city of Oxnard that would be impacted by those potential dam failure events.
So for your consideration, what you see here is the flood inundation zone as a result of an IDF-induced dam failure. The blue areas here show 70,000 acres of land that will be impacted in case and potentially if the dam fails. And as you can see, the water is being spread over the Oxnard Plain and it impacts the majority of this area. To kind of like communicate the impact of a potential dam failure we have provided this animation and I'm hoping that I can run it.
Oh, unfortunately did not run quite. Yes. So here you can see how the flood waves arrives on the Oxnard Plain and I just want to briefly show you Camarillo Airport, Naval Base Ventura County Point Magoo, Naval Base Ventura County Port Hueneme, a portion of City of Ventura and the City of Oxnard will be impacted. And also notice all the communities along Santa Clara River Pairoo, Fillmore and Santa Paula will be severely impacted.
If there is any risk of dam failure, United will immediately activate Santa Felicia Dam Emergency Action Plan as required by the federal and state regulation for high hazard dams. And Santa Felicia Dam is in that category. By the states it is recognized as an extremely high hazard dam because of the population residing below the dam, that it is estimated about 400,000 people.
In order to be prepared, we offer and conduct several training seminars and exercises and we invite the emergency responders to participate in those trainings. And I'm happy to report that the City of Oxnard has proactively attended all of those trainings and I would like to thank the city for that. I think, sorry. So I have a rendering of the new outlet works.
The new outlet works will be located on the east side of the dam. What you see here is the intake control facility including a sloping intake with multiple ports that would allow us to draw water from the reservoir at different elevations to mitigate the sedimentation issue. Any active port is covered and protected by a fish screen that prevents fish and other species entering the system.
The intake control facility is connected through a tunnel to the downstream control facility, and this tunnel, that it is about 1,300 linear feet, houses a conduit for high flow releases and a low flow for lower flow releases. You see the downstream control facility here. It will house a hydropower generator. It's also equipped with an isolation valve vault that could cut off the water releases for any maintenance or emergency events. As far as this spillway is concerned in this area over here, the plan is to raise the dam crest by six and a half feet replace the slab on the spillway and install it at a deeper level to allow a higher pass-through capacity, and replace the under drain system.
So the design of this project is nearly complete and the project is approaching construction readiness. What we are envisioning is that the outlet works, the new outlet works will be constructed over five years followed by the spillway improvements that will be constructed over four years. So in total a nine-year construction period. So what does that mean to the city? Why do you need to even care about this project? What you see here is a side-by-side comparison of the flood zone prior to project implementation and post-project implementation. As you can see clearly, the impacted flooded areas is significantly reduced We've also done some estimates on the number of populations at risk, the estimated flooded areas and also the financial damages before and after the project implementation.
And across the board there is 80% reduction once the project is implemented for instance The financial damages before the implementation is over $8 billion. Once the project is implemented, that financial damage is reduced by over 80% to $1.6 billion. So the estimated construction cost for these two components is $314 million. Obviously, at this point everyone stops and say how are we going to pay for it?
United has no plan to support this project through rates. We understand that there is no rate that can support this project and therefore we have actively pursued grant fundings, federal state appropriations And in fact, we have established a grant task force in-house to pursue all the opportunities that would support this kind of project. However, we recognize that this project is a regional project. It's a public safety project and it impacts all the cities that were listed on that table that I showed earlier so we need support and our Executive management including our board members are actively interacting with legislators, with federal and state agencies to make sure that we can secure funding that can help move this project forward.
The most recent activities include a grant application that we submitted to FEMA requesting $17.4 million to support the outwards construction, and I also want to take a moment to thank the city for the letter of support that they provided along with all the letter of supports those were included in our application. Also, we have secured a $99 million low-interest loan from the EPA WIFIA program. And currently we are negotiating the construction loan agreement. However our preferred method to pay for this project is not necessarily a loan but an appropriation or grant funding.
We also know that we don't need the $340 million up front, so we have forecasted the expenditures over the nine years construction and we realize and recognize that a majority of the expenditure is needed in the first five years when we are constructing the Outlet Works system. I'm happy to report that through these efforts to make the local agencies and organizations and elected officials aware of this project, the Board of Supervisors adopted a resolution in November 2025 recognizing this project to be a critical regional priority. We are thankful for that.
Protecting lives and properties, this project will provide increased reliability of water deliveries to our service area which supports a population of over 400,000 people across the agricultural, municipal and industrial sectors including the City of Oxnard. And at this point, we respectfully request the city's support and advocacy to secure the funding to allow this project to move forward. And that concludes my presentation and I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.
1:09 – 1:1732 turns
Thank you doctor. Are there any questions? Go ahead Councilwoman.
Thank you so much for your presentation. I really love the overview in terms of the risks, how many estimated community members would be impacted should there be any kind of disaster and just out of curiosity, I also appreciate the emergency preparedness but the mitigation plan, how often is that updated? And I anticipate that there's also some form of communication or at least a group convened I can list a number of efforts.
Through annual meetings with the Neighborhood Council, we talk about the project, the progress that we have made and the successes that we have had to draw attention to this project. Also, we have tabletop exercises in collaboration with the Department of Water Resources Pyramid Dam because the two dams are basically just in the vicinity of each other. If anything happens, let's say a seismic loading, Pyramid Dam is impacted We go through those table top including the City of Oxnard, to sit in those exercises that actually takes a whole entire year. And we go through our EPA or emergency action plan to kind of like say okay what is the notification chart? Are the phone numbers are in order and we can clearly and quickly touch base with the ones who are responsible like the sheriff and so forth.
Hope that answered your question.
Thank you so much appreciate the responses
Okay, the mayor stepped away for a moment. Do we have additional questions from other council members? Council Member Starr. Thank you.
First of all I have a question about the slide where it was describing the insufficient spillway capacity. I was wondering if you can go back to that slide.
Do you want me to go upside to this slide?
So we'll have to ask Diego in the back to do that. So I'll go back there.
All right, so I'll ask some other questions in the meantime. Do we have any inkling of what the likelihood is of a calamity at any given year? Is this one in 100 chance in a given year or is it one in 50 chances or 10 chance? What are we talking about here?
The likelihood of receiving an inflow of 220,000 cubic feet per second is pretty remote. When we look at the history of the significant floods coming to the dam, we have observed 40,000 cubic feet per second in 2005 when the dam actually split. However, we understand that these are like really large inflows but because this is a We have a handout. Which number is it?
The 1955 bar and the 2013 bar. Is 1972 and 2006, were those... What are those? Are those flood events? What are we talking about here? What do those represent?
So the very first one, the original design that's I think clear that the dam was designed to pass to safely pass 109,000 cubic feet per second and it would allow five feet of freeboard from the top of this spillway wall to where the water level is. And then as we have kind of like gone through this exercise of what would be the reasonable pass-through flow, working with the regulators. We have now arrived at the 220,000 CFS that would allow us to maintain 2.5 feet of freeboard.
So do these two middle bars represent estimates in the past for
what
the required capacity should be?
The two bars show the progress in determining the inflow design.
So what does the 321,000 represent in 2006? What does that mean?
This one over here?
No right there yep that one
The tall bar, right?
Yep. What does that mean if I'm looking at that?
So I believe that was the one that DSOD Department of Water Resources Division of Safety of Dam has jurisdiction over our dam as well as the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission so when they looked at the watershed and Determined through a model what would be the flow coming into the dam, they had an estimate of about 300,000 cubic feet per second. We threw a number of analyses determined that this is not applicable to our site. This is not site specific. And therefore, through additional analysis we brought that inflow down to 220,000 CFS which we are currently designing the spillway improvements for.
So it's fair to say that this 220,000 figure is I guess more refined than what we had before?
Yes and more site specific.
Okay got it.
Thank
you. How long would this new dam last? Do we have any idea about that?
Well, the current dam is operating great. You know it is 70 years old and we expect that the improvements to the dam would last 70 years or more and we are hoping that the regulation doesn't change on us as we move forward. We have taken all the kind of like measures to address the three deficiencies that I explained And so that's the hope. So this is an investment that should last between 70 to 100 years.
Okay, and the original dam that was built somehow got funded I was curious do we have any history as to how the original dam was funded?
It was locally funded. Yes, there was no support from the state or the federal government. I'm sorry. And it cost $5 million to build it back in 1955. $5
million? OK. 314 million is a much, much bigger number than
that. Much, much bigger because of the very stringent regulatory What I'm trying to grasp
1:17 – 1:238 turns
The likelihood of damage, I guess when I'm looking at what we have as an $8.1 billion estimate today what the damages would be versus 1.6 so that's about a six and a half billion dollar difference so we'd be spending 314 million dollars to potentially Save six and a half billion someday. But I don't know if that's, like I said this is what would be helpful for me to better understand is do we think this is a one in 100 year event or 500 year event or what? Because what I have to look at with my financial analysis on is that there are other possible calamities out there that have nothing to do with dams that we could also invest in I'm not able to figure out right now is where I would rank this dam improvement versus other projects that are where we're spending money in order to prevent a calamity.
I'll give you an example of something we have recently, which I thought is Over on Rice and 5th Street, we're doing this really big $150 million or whatever it is now for that which... And we've had one loss of life there. Yes. And we're gonna spend 150 million dollars maybe to prevent one future loss of life in the future for somebody who can't figure out how not to drive on railroad tracks.
To me That was a waste of money compared to what you're proposing here. To me, I'd much rather have spent $314 million on a dam that affects all these people than the $150 million that we're spending on this interchange. Yes. I just wonder if the people that are actually funding the $150 million cost is there a reason why we can't have them do this?
Yes, great point. And if I may add, apart from the public safety aspects of the project there is a water reliability that this project provides. Also there is a regulatory aspect. We are working closely with Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. There is a project Anderson Dam up in Northern California it has similar kind of like issues What we are concerned about is that if we don't follow the schedule and build this project in a timely manner, the operation of the reservoir could potentially be restricted. Meaning that you cannot store water behind a dam, meaning that you cannot import state water project to our service area which is so vital. You know as you know our local supplies are at the mercy of the nature if we go through another lengthy drought well we would experience low groundwater tables you know like I said issues with drinking water quality and therefore it is very critical to save and protect the facility that it is currently operating and providing benefits to the region.
So I agree with you this is a money well spent because there are several kind of like aspects to this project.
So how solid is the 314 million dollar figure? I mean once again going back to this interchange, I think we originally thought it was gonna be I don't know was at 50 maybe 60 million dollars and now it's roughly tripled. You know how do we know that we're not gonna have A $314 million project suddenly becomes a billion dollars.
May I ask a question before you answer this? And I hate to interrupt you, but I just want to clarify. You just mentioned that you agree with Council Member Starr. So you agree that the project happening right now on Rose Avenue is a waste of taxpayer dollars? I'm sorry. No. OK. I don't.
I'm sorry. Thank you for the clarification.
I just want to make sure that we are I just want to make sure that you did not agree with the statement that was made.
Thank you for bringing that up. I do not, I'm not managing that project. I am not having any professional opinion about that project but I agreed to that $314 million investment in this project is money well spent. Thank you.
So and just just to clarify there's limited resources And I'm looking at just a comparative value of two projects. If I had the money to spend it on one but not the other, which one would I choose? And that's really the point that I was making because at the end of the day whenever we tax people to pay for these projects they're making sacrifices in other ways. In some ways that actually really limits their ability I think that's where I'm going.
1:23 – 1:3515 turns
Thank you very much for the time and effort that you put in, and the time you spent answering questions from council members. One minor suggestion, put numbers on each page so that when we have questions we can address it. I would make a suggestion. I don't know if you already have, and I suppose you probably have, but just a suggestion. You pitch every school district in the area that would be in a flood inundation area because I do recall One specific school district, the Rio School District didn't believe that something like this could happen. And I do appreciate this. It's an insurmountable amount of money but something has got to be done because I do agree, an individual was killed in a train crossing
and
it happened. But when you show over 100,000 people's lives at risk on something that could happen Thank you very much for presenting it. Hopefully some are watching. When they look at those inundation maps, those are wake-up calls, big time wake-up calls. My house is
in there. Thank you for your questions and the time. I appreciate it.
Mayor, may I make a comment? I know your board members are here, staff, and to you, I just want to acknowledge United Water and your comments today regarding doing your best not to pass this on to taxpayers I greatly appreciate all the effort that's being done in order to accomplish that, and I want to make sure that I just commend you for that effort. Thank you.
Thank you so much.
Thank you. Thank you, Doctor, very much for this wonderful presentation. Madam Clerk, are there any public speakers on this item?
Mayor and Council members, we do not have any public speakers for this appointment item. Thank you.
Thank You. I will now
move to Item D1. This is the presentation by Interface and Children Services and Gerardo Gonzalez
is here. So I'm sorry there is an action requested on item d2.
Oh, I apologize. Yes, I I'll make a motion to accept the recommended the recommendation to receive and file it and also to Support the letters the support the letter of support that they're asking for Thank You against my parole and a clerk call for the vote
Mayor and council members, if you can go ahead and cast your vote please. Thank you. And the motion carries six to zero. Thank you.
Thank you. Mr. Gonzalez we'll now move to you this is a presentation by Gerardo Gonzalez Community Information Associate Director for Interface 211 Ventura County, he will make this presentation. Go ahead Mr. Gonzalez.
Good evening mayor and council members thank you for having me here today my name is Gerardo Gonzalez I'm the Community Information Associate Director with Interface 2-1-1 and I'm here to share how 2- 1-1 has been supporting Oxnard residents throughout this past year For those who may be unfamiliar with our services, 211 operates as a program under Interface Children and Family Services. And we serve as a county-wide information and referral hub linking residents to over 2,000 health and human service resources.
Last year in 2025, we received over 18,000 calls and texts county wide while our website welcomed more than 25,000 visitors Each of these interactions represents someone finding their way to the services that they need. In 2026, we celebrate over 20 years of providing 211 services to the community. 211 is just one part of Interface's broader mission Interface runs 30 distinct programs spanning six core departments.
Our domestic violence and child abuse prevention, human trafficking prevention and intervention, justice services, mental health and trauma treatment, and youth crisis and homeless services. This broader network allows us to do more than simply refer. We can frequently link callers directly to other interface programs to suit their situation. 211 stands as the county's most extensive information and referral resource for residents seeking help. Our team assists callers in locating and accessing the services that they require, from housing to food programs, mental health support to legal services. We're available every day 24-7 understanding that urgent needs don't wait for convenient hours.
Accessibility is central to our mission. Residents can connect with us through three convenient methods by dialing 211, texting their zip code 2898211 or visiting our website at 211ventura.org Regardless of how someone makes contact they'll be connected to one of our trained community information navigators Now I'd like to share some specific data about how we served Oxnard residents in 2025.
So, we took a total of 5295 calls from Oxnard residents throughout the year which is the largest call volume that we received from any city in the county. Let me give you some context around this figure. A significant number of our Oxnard callers reach out to us more than once, so the actual count of unique individuals is lower than the 5,295 calls. What this shows us is that residents trust 211 enough to come back when they need additional support.
Someone might contact us initially about finding housing, and then call us again a few weeks later looking for job search help. And perhaps call us a third time when they need food assistance. We collect demographic information from every caller to help us understand community needs and trends which is why you're seeing the total call volume rather than a count of unique individuals.
Looking at the demographics of those that we served, 1,852 were first-time callers to 211. 713 were families with children under five years old. 124 callers indicated the person in need was pregnant and 381 were calls that pertained to someone who was at risk of losing their housing, and 754 calls pertained to someone who reported they were already currently experiencing homelessness. These numbers give us a snapshot of the challenges facing some of our Oxnard neighbors particularly around housing stability and economic hardship.
Behind each of these calls is a real person navigating a challenging situation. Let me share an example with you. Earlier this year, we received a call from an Oxnard resident, let's call her Lily, who found herself in a difficult situation. Her husband had just lost his job and she was let go from her position shortly after. They have two young children and suddenly they couldn't make rent They applied for Food Stamps CalFresh but had issues with the application and they were falling behind on their housing payments.
When Lily called 211, our navigator recognized she needed support across multiple fronts. We connected her to emergency rental assistance programs to help prevent eviction, enrolled her family in food pantries and CalFresh to ensure they had food, and linked her husband with employment services to help him get back to work as quickly as possible. Income support ranks as a second highest need in Oxnard. Families aren't just dealing with one challenge when someone loses a job, it creates a domino effect touching housing food security and overall family stability two-in-one is here to help families navigate all of those challenges at once When we look at the top categories of needs expressed by Oxnard Callers, housing ranked number one. No surprise there.
Second was income support and assistance reflecting the economic pressures many families face. Third was individual family and community support encompassing services like the Area Agency on Aging, case management, and services like holiday gifts and toys. This slide here shows how Oxnard compares to other cities in the county. As you can see, housing is a top need across every community.
This is a county-wide challenge and not unique to Oxnard. What distinguishes Oxnard is the prominence of income support as the second highest need, while some cities like Ventura which has a closer call volume see food and meals as their number two need. Oxnard residents are calling about economic stability, jobs, income assistance and financial support programs. This tells us something important about the specific economic pressures some of our Oxnards residents are facing And lastly.
Beyond linking residents to existing resources, we operate several specialized programs delivering direct services over the phone to residents through VITA, our Volunteer Income Tax Assistance Program. We offer appointments to no-cost tax preparation to qualifying community members, helping them claim maximum refunds and secure tax credits that they're entitled to. Our PSPS initiative supports the access and functional needs population in advance of public safety power shutoffs via case management care coordination and delivers real-time help during actual shutoffs, covering things like lodging, meals, transportation, portable backup batteries all at no cost to residents. And we do this in partnership with SCE, Southern California Edison. Ventura versus Hate assists those who've experienced hate incidents in filing reports and accessing the appropriate services that they require.
And through ECM, our Enhanced Care Management Program, our team delivers comprehensive case management to Gold Coast health plan members. Helping them address both their basic needs and health needs through coordinated care. These initiatives allow us to offer on-hand assistance over the phone to some of our most vulnerable residents. I appreciate your time this evening and thank you for your continued support of the work that we do here in Oxnard. If you or anyone you know ever needs assistance, remember 211 is here 24-7. You can reach us by calling 211, texting your zip code to 898211, or visiting our website at 211ventura.org. Thank you so much.
1:35 – 1:4016 turns
Thank you very much for the information and update on that for many. I'm happy to see that there are Oxnard residents who are taking advantage and accessing the services or service direction resources that 211 provides, so thank you to you and all of your team and all the folks who take the calls for that work. One question I have regarding the hate-based incidents if somebody wants to report that It sounds like the basic process could be they call 2-1-1 and they say, I experienced this. I don't know what to do next. Does that sound correct? Or is there other
guidance for folks on that? Yeah, that's correct. So this project is actually part of a broader Project which is known as California versus hate so there is a 1-800 hotline that our persons can call but then that then is routed to all any 2-1-1 in the state depending on where they're located and then the navigator will complete that initial report and if they agree to case management or that they'd like additional support And that's when we come in and then talk to them. And usually what happens is, we try to assess what their needs are, set a goal, and then help them through that process. It could take up to a year sometimes before the Civil Rights Department even reviews our report. So that's why this work is important.
Great, thank you for that information. And I really feel that the promotion of that program especially now that I know it's statewide is important so thank you for bringing it to us and I'm assuming that when there's tabling events and other outreach by interface the 211 general cards and numbers are out there but specific programs probably have their own brochures and media as well, is that right?
Yeah, we have that as well and then we also make sure that those are available at outreach events. And then it's 1-800-8NO-HATE so if someone has experienced a hate incident or a hate crime all they have to do is dial 1-800-8-NO-HATE and they'll be connected with someone at 211.
And I'm assuming multiple languages? Correct. Yes okay thank you for that and I hate to say it but in In the current climate in this day and age, this is a service that I'm glad is out there. And I hope that people everywhere know that that's available as one resource for them if they feel they've experienced some hate-based incident targeted towards them or someone close to them.
Can we get materials? I don't know if you brought any but left with the clerk or in the city hall across the street that we can have at our public facing facilities?
Yeah, absolutely. I didn't bring any today but I can connect with the city clerk and make sure you have those. Great. Thank you very much. Thank you Mayor.
Absolutely. Thanks Mr. Gonzalez. Go ahead Councilwoman.
Yeah thank you so much Mr. Gonzalez for coming out and sharing more with the community about 2-1-1 and the services provided. I'm just curious what the when folks contact 2- 1-1 what's typically the turnaround for a response for those that have reached out?
In terms of like wait times like how long it takes to connect So on average, it's around three minutes. It's usually slower in the evenings. It could be around a minute and a half. There are periods when it can be longer than that and that can depend if there is a disaster or if there is something impacting call volume but on average it's around three minutes at this time.
Great, thank you. And my last question is really I know here in Oxnard we have a large agricultural community many of our community members right now are being impacted by immigration enforcement and just curious what services resources are available or provided through 2-1-1 for this population?
That's great question so currently right now through our website 211now.com We have a comprehensive list of both local and statewide immigration resources that we share with all of our callers.
Thank you. Any other comments or questions for Mr. Gonzalez? Go ahead, Council Member.
Thank you very much for bringing us to the presentation for the City of Oxnard and this council member. I appreciate the work you're doing helping those who are least able to help themselves because everyone could be in that boat someday or other. Thank you. Thank you.
Madam Clerk, are there any public speakers for this presentation?
Mayor and council members, we do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for this appointment item. Thank you. Wonderful.
Thank you Mr. Gonzalez for bringing this to us. Good evening. This is only receiving file items so there's no action required At this point I'm just going to hit the gavel just to bring the meeting to order okay? Good evening everyone. Just want to call the meeting to order for the Oxnard City Council And for the Oxnard Housing Authority, for Tuesday March 17th, 2026. Madam Clerk may we have the roll call and posting of the agenda please?
Roll call — called by Unidentified speaker 2
Show transcript
1:40 – 1:474 turns
The agenda for this meeting was posted in the kiosk at City Hall, the Oxnard Public Library, the city administrative offices and on the city's website on Thursday March 5th. And the amended agenda on Wednesday March 11th. I do have two announcements The first announcement is pursuant to Government Code Section 5495.2, each member of the Housing Board of Commissioners present will receive $50 pay for convening this meeting with the exception of Commissioner Starr who has declined to receive compensation.
The second announcement is that we are removing from the agenda this evening item F1 and L9 from the agenda. Thank you very much. Mayor and council members, that was item F1 on the ceremonial calendar. On the information and consent agenda L9. Thank you.
You may be seated. Thank you.
Thank you everyone.
Good evening Mayor, good evening City Youth or the Council and good evening staff. I want to thank you guys for giving me the opportunity to speak today. As stated my name is Santino Enrique Frechado II and I am currently attending Pacifica High School So today I'm going to go into depth about my story and who I am. And I wanted to start off with something I wrote down, which was in 2013 when the sun was rising that day, I woke up and I began to cry. I was crying, and I had no one to soothe me.
No one reciprocated. And it took me a moment to realize that no one was going to come. And that morning I went out. And there sat my father. I saw him looking up at the sky, just contemplating and I asked him where's mom? And he said that night that my mother reunited with my true father in heaven. So that was a huge change and impact for me. And from that day on, I had this confusion on who I am as a true person, who I think or my belief in God is And I had this like hatred, I had this hatred for him. And it wasn't until I attended a youth group in Coastline and Ventura that changed my life.
In Romans 5, in Romans 5-3, I have it right here. Romans 5 3, it talks about not only so but we also glory in our sufferings because we know that suffering produces perseverance perseverance, character and character hope. And hope does not put us to shame because God's love is poured out into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who he has given to us." When I read that, and I don't know if anyone here is religious but I personally have a true relationship with Jesus.
And when I read that I came to the revelation that He saved my life. And I was so lost because that impact really changed me And from that day on, I had this new motivation to do good for my community, for those around me, for my family. And currently, I can say that I'm truly changed. I stay very active in my school now and in my community. I serve as a senior patrol leader for Troop 231 and Boy Scouts.
I am a star rank. I was just attending Channel Islands Vineyard and every Sunday since the day I was born, I've been helping there. So, I've accumulated over 500 hours of service through that and currently I'm vice president for two clubs, Cade and Bible Club City Youth. And all of these are to me they seem like so low compared to what the Almighty God has done for me.
It comes to that realization again, time and time again of how beautiful this is. I also have a job at Coffee Bean. I worked as a barista so anytime y'all want to come there, I'll view it. And again, I do track at Pacifica. I'm part of an academy called TECA. I am a TECA officer which is a higher up position where you guide others like your peers or those around you Every one of these experiences that I've had has really shaped who I want to be when I grow up and my future.
And my future personally is to, I wanted to go to a UC, I wanted to go all big colleges, I wanna be a hotshot yeah but now I put that into his hands for me and my goal is to truly give back to those around me. That's my goal is to serve humanity Just be a bigger part for other people. I want to be able to be the shoulder that people can come to, to help carry their burdens. That's my goal in my true life and I just want to say that I really appreciate you guys. Thank you guys so much for this and love y'all. God bless.
1:47 – 1:528 turns
Santino did anybody accompany you tonight?
Yeah, my older brother Diego Preciado.
You know we do this to start off on a positive note and if young people like yourself come here it takes courage to share what you just shared with us here today and to show the extraordinary students and youth we have in our community that are going places and are gonna shape the future of our region here so thank you Santino for coming here If there are no other comments or anything, I want to invite you to come up and we have a certificate for you. And if you want to invite your brother come up here as well and take some photographs.
Thank you.
Good to see you again.
We're going to
move to the next item on our agenda. The presentation of a proclamation designated March 2026 as Women's History Month. And for this proclamation that Councilwoman Basu is going to present, I'd like to call up Cheryl, the co-president of the League of Women Voters who will accept the proclamation. Ms. Collard? And for those in the audience here, this is a time when we celebrate the extraordinary contribution of women in our history and the present leaders in our region and our community and our country that are shaping industries, strengthening our families, supporting the core values of our society.
And just remarkable contributions that women make. Thank you so much.
Thank you Mayor. So the proclamation states, whereas women of every background have made history contributions to the growth and strengths of our nation in countless recorded and unrecorded ways and whereas women have played and continue to play a critical role in the economic cultural and social life of our nation and whereas women have played a unique role Through our history by providing the majority of the volunteer labor force and whereas women were particularly important in the establishment of our early charitable, philanthropic and cultural institution.
And whereas women have served our country courageously in the military, and whereas women have been leaders not only in securing their own right of suffrage and equal opportunity but also in the ambitious movement, the emancipation movement, the industrial labor movement, the civil rights movement, and other movements. Especially the peace movement which creates a more fair and just society for all.
And whereas, despite these contributions the role of women in history has been consistently overlooked and undervalued. In the literature teachings and study of history now therefore I Louise MacArthur the Mayor of the City of Oxnard do hereby proclaim March 26 at March 2026 as Women's History Month
1:52 – 1:585 turns
Thank you to the mayor and the council. Thank you, and to the city staff in the community. I'm Cheryl Collard. I am one of the co-presidents, and this evening I'm joined with another co-president Kathy Morgan. And this is always a very formal setting to be in City Council but I'd like to bring some lightness to the moment that I think you'll appreciate. So how many of you remember doing the tri boards for your science reports and all those sorts of things? Yes.
And this is historical. This has information, we've pulled this out of our own archives and I wanted to just bring some attention. Ventura County League of Women Voters was started in October 1958 As was reported in a letter to the editor in the Old Star Press, everybody had that newspaper coming at their front door. Carol Quinn was our first president in 1959.
The first activity of our league at that time was to create something called Facts for Voting, to help people understand what was going on with elections. Currently we offer things electronically now. We've moved a long way. You offer Vote 411 and Easy Voter Guide. It's also interesting there are some council candidates. One of the first things we did to look back at my notes in 1964 We had the Oxnard City Council Candidate Forum that was hosted by the League of Women Voters, and the press item says hot contest and cool candidates.
And at that time it featured all men who were running for office, no women. It was Mr. Soho, LaBacker, Goss, Pollack, and Davidson. Those candidate forums have now evolved. We use local cable stations over the years, we then went to Zoom during COVID and of course in Oxnard we've been at the lovely Pacific High School Auditorium really worked well for us. I also want to highlight on this board something of importance to Oxnard. In July of 2000, Roma Armbrust who was a league president and Gene Harris who was active on the City Parks and Recreation Commission were very active in promoting the protection of Ormond Beach. 25-26 years later it's still an issue.
And previously, the League had studied the position of the Ormond Power Plant and provided comments to the Public Utilities Commission in 1968. I was still in high school. It's a great history. So today, our mission is empowering voters and defending democracy. This is our current focus and I will just leave you with presently we are very involved in educating voters about the SAVE Act that in fact is probably before our U.S. Senate today And we also are concerned about the California Voter ID Initiative that you will see on your ballot.
So, we will be working on those items to educate voters and to empower our community. It is indeed a pleasure to be here this evening on behalf of what we know are many other women's groups in Ventura County but you honor us this evening with this. Thank you so much. Thank you.
Do you want to take a photo? Yeah, we'll take your photo.
Thank you so much.
In light of Women's History Month, I just wanted to express my
gratitude And thanks to the generations of women that have come before me, especially when we think about representation on bodies of government like this. The efforts of women whether it's in fields of science as architects, as labor employees in our community I know women do so much Thank you, Councilwoman. Any other comments?
1:58 – 2:0823 turns
I
do want to actually, if we're done with this item, I do want to ask a question. I think maybe the city attorney would be best for me to ask the question of. I just noticed that we have two items under H but they seem to have the same recommendation and I'm just wondering if perhaps it was really meant to be just one item?
Yeah, that may be a question for the
clerk. Mayor and council members For item H the report of the city manager those are actually two different items One is the City Manager's weekly update or and then the second one is to receive an update on the whistleblower program
So the recommendation under one, I guess would be
struck. And mayor and council members, I apologize on item H1 The recommendation is just to receive and file the city manager's update That that's a mistake on my part. So I apologize
and then I have a question about speaking May a public speaker who wants to comment on the City Manager report Make their comment after the city manager's report, or must they comment now before they even know what else the city manager might say?
Mayor and council members. Traditionally we will have the public speaker speak.
So Madam Clerk if I can interject here so the Council's procedures state as in item G it stated what the policy is Which is if it's a non-action item as city manager report item, as well as the council report items are. Unless there is an item with a listed action to it public comment is to be taken at the time that comments on items not on the agenda are taken and that stated in full in the description under Item G.
At some point, I'd love to see when that policy was adopted because it didn't used to be that way. And one day it just simply changed on the agendas. So I just don't recall the council ever adopting that change.
Thank you. Thank you, Council Member Sir.
The next item on the agenda is for public comments on those items not on the agenda and also for non Thank you, Madam Clerk. We'll go to the virtual speaker and then those in the audience. Thank you, Madam Clerk.
I'm going to be the first star 9 to speak on the women's history month. But since now I'm on public comment, I guess I'll talk about Women's History Month. You know, I'm 73 years old now. I was a child of the 60s and 70s, recipient of affirmative action in allowing me to get into law school. She wasn't able to get a credit card. She had to have permission from the husband to go on a loan.
We had no birth control, you know until 1971 and at that time health insurance whatever there was of health insurance didn't cover it so women were in a real tough spot there Education was the barrier. We couldn't get through, we couldn't get in. You look at the history of medical school, law school any of the higher education women had no access. We now let's talk about Title IX where the funding went to the men in college for sports scholarships but women who were achieving great things and Collegiate sports were not eligible for any funding. Those programs received nothing until the federal government finally put some equality there.
We now are looking at Donald Trump, you know what's coming next? And I want y'all to know because it's all over my lawyer listservs is coming after no fault divorce And what does that mean? That means that we go back to the days where you had to prove cause to get divorced from your abusive husband, instead of just being able to say he's a jerk and I don't want to be with him anymore.
Now you're going to have to prove but you need money to do that. There was a time that pregnancy by the way people was not considered a disability for the purpose of collecting state disability. State disability was if you're not able to work, you've worked and put into the state disability fund but pregnancy was not considered a disability so women who went out for their three months two months one month period of maternity leave got no benefits whatsoever it took an act of the state legislature to change that You need to be paying attention, especially
the young women. Thank you. Your time is up. And that's all I have to say.
Thank you
very much.
Thank you ma'am for your comments. We'll next go to Josie Mendez. Josie, you'll be followed by Pam and then Anjana. I'm
sorry, Josie. Go ahead. Sorry, good evening. My name is Josie Mendez. So I'm here to bring to your attention a concerning situation involving the Girls Youth Softball League that operates within our city park. During the previous season several parents respectfully requested a financial statement or report regarding league funds following these requests two parents were reportedly banned from the city park This response has raised serious concerns among families, among transparency and accountability.
Within the program intended to serve our community's youth. Additionally one parent was allegedly presented a letter said that it came from the city. I have it here. where she was told she had to sign or her daughter would not be allowed to participate in the league. This situation is troubling as it places undue pressure on our families and appears inconsistent, sorry nurse with the values of fairness and inclusion that our city promotes. Further a long time volunteer coach who has dedicated over 20 years to mentoring and supporting young athletes has been impacted by these actions. His wife has reportedly been banned from the park and has been told that if she attends games, his team will be forced to forfeit this not only affects the coach and his family but also fairly impacts the players on his team.
These actions are deeply troubling for several reasons potential Misuse of authority within the public park, lack of financial transparency and accountability, retaliation against parents seeking information, possible misrepresentation of official city documentation. Given that the league operates in a public space and serves youth in our community, I respectfully request the city investigates this matter. Specifically, I ask for clarification on whether the league has authority to ban individuals from public park property?
Whether the document presented to parents was officially issued or authorized by the city? What oversights exist regarding financial accountability for organizations using public facilities? What protection are in place to prevent retaliation against families and children? Our committee values fairness, transparency and the well-being of our youth. The current situation appears to undermine those principles and warrants immediate attention.
Thank you Ms. Mendez, thank you.
Mayor if I may, if it's possible if we can perhaps maybe get her contact information and address some of the questions that she's presented
Yeah, I see Mr. Harrison coming up here.
Yeah, I would appreciate if staff actually has a conversation with Ms. Mendez and see if we can come to some sort of resolution.
Thanks, Josie. Pam? Followed by Angela. Thank you, Pam.
2:08 – 2:144 turns
Good evening. My name is Pam Hogarth And I am the president of the Elite Theater Company and I'm here to speak on their behalf. I've brought some support tonight. Elite supporters please raise your hand. The elite is a community theater that was founded in the Pettit House in Heritage Square in 1994. Our goal is to be a theatrical organization that offers thought provoking innovative theater of substance and a voice and venue for a wide range of artists in Ventura County.
We are a completely volunteer organization, myself included. In our 34 years we have performed for over 300,000 theater goers and contributed significantly to the culture and economy of Oxnard. Almost all of Elite's cast, crew and administrators are Ventura County residents. And many of our productions have been written by local playwrights. Many of our shows were world premieres.
Now rather than take my three minutes to detail more of our contributions I have a document I can leave with you if I'm allowed to do that? Certainly. Over 20 years ago, we moved to the former Maritime Museum in Fisherman's Wharf which I'm sure you're all well aware is being redeveloped. Which means we need to move in July and we need to find a new home. I am here to ask the city's help and support in this endeavor.
I have had a meeting with the mayor. Thank you Mr. Mayor. He expressed his desire to keep us in Oxnard which is also our desire and asked the housing department to investigate any vacancies the city may have. Unfortunately, the city doesn't have any viable openings at this time. The elite would really prefer to stay in Oxnard as I said. In fact, the awarding of the California Arts District designation we would love to return to downtown and help grow the arts district.
Two options we'd like the city to consider if I may are the youth center building at OPAC which could make a great space for a small theater of 49 seats, plus a small performing arts space for such things as dance, exercise, black box theater and so forth. The other option of course, which I'm sure you hear a lot is including a small theater in the Carnegie Library building.
Of course any help that we can get would be much appreciated and so welcome. Thank you for your time and consideration
Thank you, Mr. Walker, thank you. And Angela DeSille, thank you. Good evening and thank you Mayor.
Thank you, Mr. Mayor and City Council members for allowing us to speak this evening. I'm going to try to not get emotional about this. My name is Angela DiCicco with over 50 years of experience in the theatre. I told you this was gonna happen! Over 50 years' experience as an actor, director, and producer it has been my honour for the last five years to serve The theater that has served the Oxnard community for over 30 years with all volunteer help.
Some of you may already know, as Pam mentioned, that we are losing our home due to the redevelopment of Fisherman's Wharf. We have had such an outpouring by patrons who have come to our theater and thanked us for presenting original works utilizing local playwrights Actors, directors, set designers, sound and lighting designers, stage managers and producers.
Those patrons have been saddened by the possibility of losing the elite theatre company in their community We at the Elite strive to present, not prevent, present professional work utilizing local talent. We love what we do and the shows and all the productions we present please assist us in continuing to entertain serve and educate our community right here in Oxnard.
They say it takes a village But we at the Elite Theatre Company have formed a family of artists. Please help keep us together by assisting us in finding a new home. Thank you for your time.
Thank you, Mr. Chico. Ms. Hilary Rushing followed by Jeanette.
2:14 – 2:196 turns
Hi, thank you for letting me speak. I am Hilary Rushing. I'm here in support of the Elite Theatre Company of Oxnard. I grew up with theatre dancing acting writing singing. When I turned 18, I got a chronic pain condition that put me on a hiatus for a long time. It was still my dream to get back to the arts someday. After years of disability, I enrolled back in Ventura College at BC.
Around that time, I remember vividly doing Google searches local theaters near me. I discovered the elite that way. I took myself to see Journey of the Skeletons in October of 22 and I fell in love with this space. I listen to my health very carefully, so I only audition for something when I know I'm ready. I auditioned for The Elite for the first time in fall of last year and I was cast as an actress in Women of the Night.
It was amazing! The play was written and directed by the remarkable Kimberly Dimery, a local playwright who has produced three of her original plays there. People ask me, what's your dream someday? And I respond immediately. I'm living it. This is my dream to work with this community and these women at the elite especially. This is my dream. I work in some film too, all because my friends have asked me. It's all about community and we are all creatives.
I bring this up only to mention that in 98 years of Oscar history, we just had the first woman ever to win the Oscar for Cinematography, a woman of color, Autumn Durald-Arcapow. Here she was born here at Oxnard. This is really inspiring to me. I was just bawling, I was crying. It's so happy. There is no better time to support the dreamers of this community.
The elite is very passionate about keeping their theater company in Oxnard. I want that for them and I want that too. I want them to have a space as magnificent as their home in the harbor and I want the elite to continue to be my dream theater to work with for the next 40 years. Thank you.
Thank You Hilary. Jeanette?
Good evening. I wanted to speak upon a superintendent from Oxnard Union High School District, and I hope he's watching at this point. Superintendent Thomas McCoy, after reading the paper of 51.6 tax in revenue, I'm glad that you are leaving as superintendent out of my 110 emails CC'd from me, you did not respond. On top of that all these students while you covered up for these two drunks on campus at the high schools Ted Lawrence and Ray Gonzalez as principal and assistant principal under your watch and my godson and other students that were rushed to St. John's Hospital and you did nothing under your command so You're a heartless coward, just like Trump.
This is called the class action suit. I said you are reckless and a menace to society. So with me being said, I know you set me up with those two police officers to have me walked off campus. I'm here to tell you that shame on you and what you did to other students and what you did to me and to other employees. Shame on you. I said, I know one thing. The Lord sees all and you could pretend to be ghost but I'm sure I will set a clear example of you, of your negligence and what you did to my family member Mr. McArthur, I didn't come up here to create any amongst more problems for you.
I know you wanted a meet. I'll be contacting your secretary to meet with you in private as well. There's a true meeting for all this and it should have never happened. So in regards to everybody and also the evidence that I provided the board earlier this month on the 2nd. I hope you read through it and it was really disturbing, and I hope that there's a change furthermore down the line after this because students matter Staff matters, teachers matter, councillors matter. Everything all aboard.
I thank you for letting me speak on my behalf and any questions from anybody? Thank
you Jeanette.
Okay, I'll be meeting with you soon. Thank you Mr. McCarty. Sounds good, thank you Jeanette
Next is Pedro Toscano followed by Mr. Steve Nash
2:20 – 2:253 turns
Hello. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of council. Thank you for giving me the time to inform the members of the public of our awareness campaign Tax Fraud Days of Action. The United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America in the Western States Regional Council of Carpenters Local 805 we run a yearly nationwide awareness campaign. This crisis doesn't just harm workers and honest contractors It affects every resident in our community. The state's Employment Development Department warns that underground economy employers illegally reduce spending on payroll taxes, workers compensation, social security and safety programs like OSHA giving them an unfair competitive advantage while placing workers at greater risk of unsafe conditions and wage theft These practices drain essential public resources.
When taxes go unpaid, our city loses funding for schools, emergency services, road repairs and affordable houses – services we rely on every day. As state agencies have emphasized the worst consequence is the erosion of tax fraud across California. Legitimate local contractors, those who follow labor laws, pay taxes, provide insurance and invest in skilled workers are being undercut by unscrupulous contractors who win bids simply by refusing to play by the rules.
This race to the bottom hurts not only workers but also every taxpayer and every business that strives to operate ethically. But the good news is we can fight back Our local government can play a crucial role. Cities that strengthen enforcement partnerships require verified payroll reporting on public projects and support state investigative efforts to dramatically improve compliance and protect public dollars. Today, I urge the council to prioritize stronger anti-fraud measures in the city contracting support, interagency enforcement And to ensure that taxpayers funded projects are built by law abiding contractors to invest in our workforce and our community.
Thank you for your leadership and commitment to protecting both workers and honest businesses in our city. Good evening, my name is Pedro Toscano with the Carpenters. Thank
you. Thank you Mr. Toscano. Thank you guys for coming. Mr. Steve Nash, followed by Mr. Doug Portello.
Good evening. I miss my old podium. Mayor McArthur, Mr. Nguyen, it is a very good thing for the city to engage in the repatriation of indigenous artifacts including human remains from the Carnegie Art Museum collection. I would suggest the City Council instructed staff and consultants to be historically accurate when writing or speaking about our cultural and tribal resources.
Case in point, while reading the EIR recirculated draft of the Avalon Project, I came upon the phrase that Chumash were heavily affected by the arrival of Europeans in section 4.4 Cultural and tribal cultural resources. Really? They were heavily affected? This is glossing over the actual history of European interaction with Chumash. They were forced off their land, into the missions, enslaved and forced to abandon their culture and way of life.
It was genocide plain and simple. I believe if you ask any tribal member they would agree with that assessment And ask Mary Ann Parra, especially. Your eyes will burn with her powerful words. Words matter. We must not lie about our history to suit our conscience or we are doomed to repeat it. The centuries-old genocide of our indigenous people, the enslavement and mass lynchings of African Americans, the forced internment of our Japanese brothers and sisters during World War II And the current situation involving ICE in their vile removal of the other all point to a craven ignorance of our oftentimes sordid history.
We can do better, we can be better but it starts with being honest with ourselves. You have the power and the authority to implement this simple change. Remember words matter. Thank you for your time.
2:25 – 2:3511 turns
Mr. Portello, followed by Sarah.
Good evening. I'll be speaking on item H regarding the whistleblower complaint. Mr. Perillo you like to yell at other people that facts and evidence matter but the council is operating in the dark without the facts and evidence kept in the dark by your own employee. I wonder do other city employees know that they can first drive home and take their 15-minute break, turning it into a 25-minute break including drive time there and drive time back. Mr. Nguyen's video accuses Aaron Starr of jumping to conclusions, making assumptions, making public allegations, and being disrespectful to staff. No, that is what Mr. Nguyen's video does and what Gabe Turan and Bert Perillo did at the February 17th 2026 City Council meeting jumping to conclusions about Aaron making public allegations against Aaron.
What does the city manager's behavior say to city employees who might be future whistleblowers? This video says that the city does not actually want to hear from whistleblowers that the city will bury problems and you'll better keep your mouth shut or you'll be demonized if Mr. Wynn is willing to smear a city council member for daring to point out to the council that was being misled, imagine what he would do to a employee whistleblower. Well we see what happened to Phil Molina at the February 17th Council meeting Gabe Turan and Bert Perillo shockingly seemed to think one purpose of the whistleblow program is to make sure if there is a problem the public never learns about it. They seem more interested in trying to make Aaron look bad than to determine whether the actual problem was addressed or solved.
Aaron told you that he had permission from the source to discuss the subject of the complaint. The policy says that he could even disclose the identity of the whistleblower if he had permission to do that, and you just desperately trying to twist this situation to falsely allege that Aaron did something wrong. When the city manager uses city resources To make misleading videos about a sitting council member, you've got a problem on your hands. We all know some of the city council members don't like Aaron so they took look the other way but what if you were that minority and the city manager did this to you?
I bet you'd think that was appropriate. All of this ruckus is to detract from the real point that the city council members were misled That's the core point of Mr. Nguyen's hope, that you will forget about all the noise. So this city council, this whistleblower program is something that really needs changing. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Portillo. Sir? Followed by Eduardo Huerta.
Good evening Mayor McArthur, City Council, city staff. Once again my name is Sarah Wilczewski I'm a resident of Oxnard and a volunteer with 805 UndocuFund This week again saw more brutality from ICE. And I came here every meeting to read off the statistics and make sure that they are entered into public record so the people impacted are not forgotten As of 1020 AM on March 16th, 805 and DocuFund has received reports of 1746 kidnappings in the 805 area code. 859 of which were in Ventura County and 149 people were kidnapped in Oxnard.
That is 1,746 people kidnapped and either held in horrible conditions in detention centers or sent to a country that they left for a reason. And in many cases may not have lived in for decades. It isn't just the 1,746 people who were kidnapped that are affected by this either. Their families, friends, coworkers, neighbors and community all experienced their loss And I wanted to take a moment to talk about what we do and what we offer to the community.
805 UndocuFund offers families impacted by ICE separation financial support, connection with mutual aid efforts whether that's setting up a GoFundMe or collecting food and other necessities. And we can try to locate their missing family members once they are in the system. We also offer family comfort and emotional support At least what we are able to offer.
To the community, we offer accompaniment for immigration appointments, any kind of legal appointments, doctor's appointments, that kind of thing. If your family has been impacted or you have been impacted, you can call 805-870-8855 or text us at that hotline. And VC Defensa offers similar support and you can reach them at 805-296-1119 If you want to get involved, we have regular trainings. Information is posted on our website at 805undocufund.org and on our social media.
In addition to patrolling and responding, we need operators to answer the phones, volunteers doing community outreach and helping with mutual aid and so many more. There's a role for everyone and we hope to see more people at our upcoming trainings. And I would like to also thank the Oxnard Police Department and the city for responding so quickly, and ending their contract with Flock.
Thank you.
Thank you, Sarah. Eduardo? Followed by Mr. Larry Stein.
Good afternoon. How are you guys?
Good afternoon.
Hey Alex, how are
you?
So just here really quick. I wrote something down really quick here. So I'm here to pretty much discuss a little bit about the interface. And there's a lot going on tonight with your agenda. It's very unfortunate that I only have three minutes, and if I was elected we wouldn't even be here tonight. How about that? Talking about splitting the work protecting our city from constitutional rights, human rights, civil rights, a lot of violations that I see today. What brought me here, what brought me to run for office is actually the same story of Jeanette Lopez.
When I first ran for office, I got myself involved with a lot of community members' students. And I sat down with Gabe Tran. We talked about mental health and crisis and family in crisis and how can I get help from the police department and my city council to help my family come out of a crisis? The crisis that I came in was internal crisis. And so from there when I ran for office, I built my support system going to church doing the adequate services and kind of guiding myself through the same services through agencies provided from the county And today what I'm hearing here is that there's a lack of support for our community.
Honestly, I don't mean to put Gabe on the spot but Gabe as a teacher as an educator when I came to you and talked to you about these issues what was the first step you took? You saw me as a threat now I'm sure you don't see your community as a threat or you don't see anybody you know I'm just trying to tell you that there's lot of families that are hurting you didn't take the right steps To prevent a lot of the issues that you're being confronted today, especially with Interface to Crisis Team. You don't let families live through experiences like right now we have 805 UndocuFund. We don't let families or immigrants live through immigration raids just to satisfy ourselves, to put ourselves behind the platform and say that we support our community.
We don't do that. And so I'm just trying to say that and then obviously we need to make sure that we are there standing for our students and obviously our farm workers as well. Without the right structure and support systems that families can get, can get lost. Especially with this new administration we have to avoid families becoming political pawns especially with this immigration crisis you know I hear people talking about Trump a lot honestly the responsibility that we have it was local it was City Council I don't think I think we should take some type of responsibility and sit down and talk about this.
We're talking about, I guess, networks and sources that we use to publicize our campaigns. You know, I fall in all that. And so you know, I honestly don't...I lost my mom through all of this and I don't think it's fair to say that our city is really there for families who are in crisis. I'm not saying well off but there's a lot of families in this community that really need help.
Thank you guys. God bless.
Thank you Mr. Huerta. We're about 30 minutes into our public speakers We have about five more speakers, so if it's okay we'll allow them to continue. Go ahead Mr. Stein. And then followed by Pastor Greg Runyon and Ronald.
2:35 – 2:413 turns
Good evening Mr. Mayor. Good evening. Members of City Council, staff, audience and the general public. My name is Larry Stein I've been an Oxnard activist for 30 plus years, and I follow many issues. I'm fortunate I get to pick my issues. City Council members cannot. They have to deal with all the issues. And one of the issues coming before us is consideration of what Measure O's going to be doing in next two years.
Measure O is set to expire in two years, and city manager is taking efforts to promote different issues why funding is needed What is sometimes not included is what funding is not needed for. So while the city manager talks about how funding is needed for the police department, fire department and general public safety, he seems to exclude the fact that there are usually 20 or 30 vacancies in the police department and anywhere between five to 12 vacancies in the fire department. Well if there's so many vacancies in these public safe departments why is measure O needed for these departments?
Many other areas get neglected. For example, neighborhood streets. We should be having a 10-year program to repair all our neighborhood streets but that's not being funded. We have an urban water master plan was adopted several years ago by City Council but staff is not recommending funding for the urban water master plan. I've talked about parks that need to be built. We have funding that was taken from homeowners, such as the people in the East Village and West Village. They paid development fees to have a park developed. Those paid fees to have a fire station developed. I don't think we need any more fire stations. I think we need more people trained in providing services And that's basically an advanced life support and basic life support.
This is a major call for our fire department, they handle 80% of their time spent responding to ABS and Advanced life support and basic life support calls. We should be staffing these positions. While we need firefighters, and we don't really need firefighters because they're insurance policies, but we have eight units of two engine companies and a ladder company. Perhaps you don't need eight units of engine companies and ladders. Perhaps three engine companies or one ladder would be sufficient for our city. Because 80% of calls are for ABS and ALS, basic life support and advanced life support services. We should be staffing those positions.
And perhaps other things could be looked at. We have advisory committees. They're called CAGs. Why does the City Council use CAGs to get advice? It's just a suggestion. We're in budget sessions now, and you're not using the CAGs for advice. Thank you very much for your time.
Followed by Ronald. And then... What's that?
Good evening, Mayor and Council. You know, Stephen Nash got up and he was talking about how important language is. And it is in all of us You know, need to be mindful of language. I think back and I'm watching our world and it seems like we're on a precipice of a lot of things. And if any of you are true students of history this isn't the first culture war we've ever gone through, it is.
Certainly we are not at a religious crossroad like the Crusades where Islam and Christianity are vying with one another but if you listen to certain people They talk about, they're so afraid of going over the edge and then they push us there. I hate to tell people this but I'm gonna say it very quickly. Genocide didn't begin with the Europeans. The Aztecs and the Mayans did it. Tribes have done it. People have done it. It is wrong, it is wrong, and it is wrong.
But it ain't done by one skin color. It's done by man's evil heart And that's what we need to address, is all of us looking in the mirror no matter the color of your skin and looking at your things. I admire Steve because he has a lot of courage and he's been very faithful to our community. I was watching the baseball game. I know, I hope some of you up there aren't but I was watching the World Baseball Classic. I wasn't playing video games this time. I was watching the game and USA's losing two to nothing which makes me a little mad and they're losing to Venezuela.
And do you know the Venezuelan people are in the crowd? And I guarantee you they don't have signs saying bad things about Trump They don't have bad things about Maduro. They don't have bad things about this. They're not about oil, they're not about that. They're out there cheering their heroes and they're doing it next to their American neighbors. That's what matters.
is that we figure out how to get along in the midst of all these crises, in the midst of all these things. We don't have to agree with one another to be kind to one another. We don't have to... Well let me say it this way when someone says oh I love you I just don't like you You can't love somebody unless you like them So we better figure out how to start liking people. And each of you has an opportunity to lead with respect and dignity, and I know you will, and encourage you to do it. Thank you.
2:41 – 2:489 turns
Good evening Mayor McArthur, Mayor Pro Tem Turan and Council Members. My name is Ronald Aruejo and while not speaking on behalf of them I wanted to note and give context to the remainder of my public comments that I'm currently the Chair of the Planning Commission. Several members of the Planning Commission consisting of myself, Vice-Chair Dr. Vincent Stewart who's actually Expresses regrets, he's at the Police Community Academy just across the street.
Commissioner Stephen Nash in his third term and Commissioner Henry Barsena just ending his first year had an opportunity to attend the League of California Cities Planning Commissioners Academy last week as you may or may not know this academy expands a commissioner's knowledge on a wide range of planning topics relevant to our role within the city with other commissioners and subject matter experts.
We greatly appreciate the budget that was prepared by the City Management, approved by the City Council and allocated by the Community Development Department to enable us to participate. I along with my fellow Commissioners believe it is vital that these training opportunities will be made possible for future Planning Commissioners in the future and at similar conferences for our fellow CAG members And those on city staff will be continuing and are adding to their training regimen.
We availed ourselves of all the training and knowledge that the Planning Commissioners Academy provided from a deep dive of the California Environmental Quality Act to getting a summary review of legislative updates impacting housing, to highlighting the best practices when it comes to being effective in decision making on the dais and everything in between. I'm absolutely sure that everything that we have learned will be to the benefit of the commission, the city, and the residents that we serve.
The four of us will be debriefing our fellow planning commissioners who are unable to go at a future Planning Commission meeting and we look forward to them, Commissioners Dr. Miguel Lopez and James Schuelke, and the seventh yet-to-be seated member to attending the academy next or in the following years. Again thank you for making room in the budget for learning and training so that we commissioners as decision makers on the Planning Commission can, quote, make sound land use decisions for a better Oxnard. Thank you for your support.
Wonderful.
Thank you.
Thank you for sharing. Thank you commissioners for being here. Thank You.
And just to add a couple of words my takeaway from the sessions especially the ones involving autonomous vehicles and artificial intelligence is that in a couple years you'll be able to appoint robot commissioners who actually understand housing law So that's a benefit, I think. Thank you.
Thank you. And thank you Mr. Nash for sending that letter in. I appreciate it. Arthur Munoz? Yes. Come on up, Mr. Munoz. Okay. And then Gerald Ruiz. Hello. Can I apologize, Madam Clerk is that one virtual caller? Yes, thank you. We'll go to him after Mr. Munoz.
Hello my name is Arthur Munoz My father grew up in Colonia and his name was Jesus Arturo MunoZ He was an Army Ranger Staff Sergeant who was killed in Vietnam in 1966. In 1990, when I was a 25-year-old man, I was wrongfully convicted of a crime in Ventura County. A girl had accused me of rape. The detective who's in charge of the investigation was named Ralph Nieves. Everybody knew him. He was a well respected detective. His report said that I was absolutely innocent However, in Ventura County they dropped the case because of his report. Then they refiled the case and lied to me about what he said so they suppressed my defense evidence. On that case alone I was sent to state prison for eight years of my life.
Okay? In 2000 rather on 11-30 of 2025 I was arrested I was taken to the Ventura County jail where I was held in On that day when I was arrested, three officers pulled their gun service revolvers on me and the Caucasian officer threatened to kill me with a gun. And it hadn't even been 30 days yet on a case that I'm innocent of. So they let me go without seeing a judge and today at the same park, the Oxnard police went over there and they harassed me again.
I'm not bothering anybody, I'm hanging out by myself but I think I'm going to have to search for an attorney in this matter because it's flagrant. I'm a child of the Lord God Almighty. Never was. But I wanted to share that and I wanted to let you know that on that arrest, the Oxnard police has been conspiring with the Ventura County sheriffs and they've been conspiring to murder me, to try to hide that conviction what occurred in 1990. And I would like to state for the purposes of the record, I'm a competent, cognizant, incoherent man by the grace of God Almighty
Thank you, Mr. Munoz. Thank you. JR Ruiz? I'm sorry we'll go to the virtual call and then JR. I apologize Madam Clerk. Sorry JR.
Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now
2:48 – 2:546 turns
Happy St. Patrick's Day, everybody! This is from Larry Barbarin and family. May we... Would the Lord help follow his example? He went back to the people who enslaved him to tell the good news. Now that's guts right there. Went back to the people who enslaved him to tell the good news. The gospel. One who Refer to the city manager's remarks at the INCO on the 4th, and I want to give him credit because he didn't just criticize the Republicans federal administration but also the massively Democrat-run state.
on budget cuts and all that. So at least it was fair in that way, but you mentioned things like the money for the homeless and all that. I think we have to do...I would urge our city to do a better job. I know usually they have lobbyists up there in Sacramento to do better job and just, you know, I'd go after them, the state, and the way they've been working last several years more than the feds because They wasted like $24 billion with a B dollars for the homeless. They can't even track it all the way and we had the ED fiasco where I think that was about $25 billion that was wasted, that a lot of criminals got ahold of.
That was federal COVID money and they lost a lot of that. And I think we get back to federalism, the federal government's doing things that we cannot do or local government cannot do in fighting making sure Iran doesn't have a nuclear bomb and ballistic missiles and such as part of the job all this stuff there's been a lot of criticism in the city of ice and all that but they're following the law Illegal immigration, it is illegal.
Again how they enforce it we need them to have wisdom on how they do that of course. I think mostly they have mostly but the and also too there were we have our tax dollars federally. We have a big deficit and debt trillions of dollars of debt And I think that the $36 trillion in debt and they're doing and mostly run by the not well-run but healthy box, the Medicare and Social Security. So I think we have to get back to federalism where we do what we can be responsible then you get help from your family from charities You know, local state and then federal. You know I think we've put too much responsibility on the feds to do every little thing in life and all the different problems and ask wait for that money to come back to us. We need to keep the tax dollars here but of course also get grants.
Thank
you your time
has taken a lot of our money so thank you.
Okay, so I was here to talk about what I talked to you guys at the beginning. I lived in a lot of other cities, and they don't get like a lot of stuff to do. There's nothing to do here but go to Walmart and go to church. And now I feel that since today we, I guess I got good bad timing you guys are talking about Women's Month. I want to give my mother who raised eight kids with my father always missing not one penny in federal or government services does she ever collect?
At her age, I was able to buy the biggest property in Oxnard and it was taken. So I wanted the mayor to see the face behind the crime. It's not really me, it's more about her. But anyway so also there were some items that were brought up and I want to remind the young ladies in the public that to realize that everybody especially women have worked really hard to get it the way it is. Don't take it for granted because people don't understand how hard It was back in the 70s for minorities or women. We couldn't even get credit cards or home loans and now that everything's good, they don't appreciate it so just I want to give homage to all the women and all the minority groups. Also the ladies over here, the artists that they want to do their committee, their art committee.
I think that the Carnegie Center would be a good connection for them to keep it Maybe connecting both we can make something work. I've always thought, I live in a city that's kind of like Paris France and every afternoon in the Pagoda they play classical music like Beethoven and all that. And I always thought, I wish Oxford would do something like that for the people you know? It's not just about bringing in commerce and doing stuff for the infrastructure but You know, like do stuff and maybe we can start working in that direction with the Carnegie Center and that organization. And maybe do stuff like City of Camarillo does it. City of Ventura does it. In summer they play mariachi by their by in front of the mission for the community like a couple times I mean every weekend I think so.
I think the city really should go more towards doing stuff for the people. Now the reason I wanted to talk to you guys was I noticed that on 5th Street they cleaned it all out got rid of the trucks but I want you also to consider We can fix that up like so that it can accommodate these people, so we can get them on a plan to get them. back into the mainstream.
I noticed one time, I passed by the Ormans, by Ventura, the canal and I noticed a campsite over there. I always said Oxnard needs a campsite. It said City of Oxnard so maybe that's an option for the city to get them on the program but also I want to add truckers because truckers bring in a lot of revenue and they haul a lot of our products. They leave a lot of taxes. We need to set that up for them because that's the hardest working people in America and you guys really need to think about that not just kick them out of there Thank you for your show.
Thank you, Mr. Ruiz. Thank you. Mayor Kruger is there an additional virtual caller?
Yes that is correct mayor. Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
2:55 – 3:0212 turns
Hello Mr. Mayor members of the City Council this is Manuel Herrera. Citizens for Better Oxnard. I'm calling regarding the city manager's video, regarding the whistleblower program. I'm a little confused because if the whole idea of a whistleblower program is so that a person can submit a complaint anonymously yet in this case, the person issuing the complaint went to air and star with the information then is it no longer considered an anonymous complaint?
And if so, why then didn't Starr just handle this internally rather than to grandstand at a committee meeting? Now don't get me wrong. If an employee is doing something wrong and according to Aaron Starr this person committed theft then by all means they need to be held accountable. You know kind of how we need to hold Phil Molina accountable for cheating the public By drawing a salary of $141,000 a year which is $5,000 every two weeks and only working an average of two hours a day.
Isn't that theft? And why isn't Aaron Starr up in arms about that? Why isn't Alicia Purcell, Aaron's wife upset about that? Is it because Molina wanted to make her his deputy treasurer and pay her a huge salary? Why isn't Eric Andres, you know the guy who calls himself an investigative watchdog? Why isn't he investigating Moina? Talk about corruption. So many questions so little answers but you know like the saying goes if you hand them the rope they will hang themselves.
So this is just more ammunition that we can use when the time comes to recall Aaron Starr. And while we're at it, let's just add Phil Molina to the mix. That Mr. Mayor are my comments.
Thank you Mr. Herrera for calling in. Madam Clerk does that conclude the speakers virtual and here in person?
Um mayor and council members yes that concludes our speakers for items not on the agenda in person and virtually thank you.
The next item on the agenda is Item H. This is a report of the city manager. Mr. Wynn?
No, we can go to the public speakers I suppose unless you guys want me to do this twice but no, we can do it once.
Yeah, we could take public speakers. We have four public speakers.
We will start with... I think it'd be more appropriate for the city manager to give his presentation, so if the speakers want to comment on it they may. Do
you have a preference Mr. Winnard? No we can go to the speakers. Yeah that's fine. If it's okay, well we'll go to Mr. Blair first followed by Mr. Portello. Did you want to speak on this item as well or was it the previous? I don't know if he got confused when you spoke earlier. Okay. Yes, go ahead.
If I may, in alignment with Mr. Bartello here was my understanding from hearing that the item H comments will be taken during items not on the agenda unless I heard incorrectly on that. Okay. Okay,
go ahead. Go ahead? Okay.
Good evening, mayor, councilmembers and staff. My name is Blair Brehm. I represent about 400 hard-working Oxnard employees for over a decade. Mr. Starr's name bandied about a little bit and I'm here because I have an issue with him, and that's that I don't feel he handled this whistleblower situation well at all. Not to take from an earlier speaker but yeah grandstanding there are better ways to handle it.
You make accusations against people that I represent. I'm going to be here. I want to show up because they take great offense to it The city does a fine job and has always done a fine job of dealing with these issues. I sat in the meetings, people have been disciplined and terminated for theft of time but there was no theft of time in this issue and it just was him being a mouthpiece to talk bad about people that I represent Reason to want to stop by if they're passing by the house, to use the bathroom. It saves resources, it saves gas, it saves wear and tear on the vehicles. It could be a trash truck driver picking up trash in his neighborhood and it's lunchtime or he missed lunch because he's working too hard and he didn't get to it yet and he was driving by his house.
Guess what? There's no policy that says he or she can't stop and grab a sandwich or use their own bathroom. None! And it's fine. And they shouldn't have to worry about now because you're making a big deal about something that was nothing, oh my God can I stop at all without worry of someone who's got nothing better to do? Somebody that got no life to just sit and worry about who's doing what next door? Pretty sad and pathetic in my opinion but no there's nothing to see here. And if there's anything to see here ask. You've got plenty of resources I would like to ask you to come out and say because you had intimate knowledge and then make an accusation that they are guilty without any due process.
That is not how it works at the city of Oxnard. If you've got any questions in the future, please go to them. Don't use the mouthpiece. Don't don't go down that road and make people look like they're doing something wrong when they're not because these people aren't going wrong but doing their jobs day in, day out, week in and week out and do a really good job.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you Mr. Brim. We'll go to Mr. Eric Andrist followed by Alicia Purcell
3:02 – 3:1210 turns
Alex gets a preference, really? Come on. Push play, Lulee! This is Eric Andrist, resident public advocate and producer of Oxnard Confidential. I'm here to correct the record on the City Manager's gaslighting Measure M video about the whistleblower program. First his video implies that Councilmember Starr made an allegation of theft against a city employee. He didn't! A whistleblower used the city's own hotline exactly as intended and Starr related. That is his job. Instead of respecting that, Alex Nguyen is once again trying to take down an elected official just like his failed vendetta against elected city treasurer Phil Molina that the courts slapped down.
Second, Alex brags that five employees were fired for theft. None through the whistleblower hotline as if that proves the system works. It proves the opposite. The hotline exists to protect whistleblowers from retaliation under California law. Bypassing it strips those protections and leaves employees exposed. Those five had zero protection. Alex is effectively arguing against his own whistleblower program because it leaves room if he wants more retaliation.
Alex says the complaint at issue had no merit. I downloaded all 13 whistleblower reports covering seven years and reviewed all 177 complaints. Not one has been substantiated, not one investigation completed, not one final report issued. Most were labeled non-fiscal and bounced back to the city to die. That's not oversight that's a shutdown machine. Fourth, Alex shrugs that his employee occasionally goes home for a lunch or restroom break. Fine if every city employee gets the same perk. If they don't then you've quietly granted a special privilege some workers enjoy and others don't. City employees listening do you get to go home for lunch and stroll back on the clock? Finally, did any of you vet the firm running Oxnard's whistleblower program?
Instead of licensed investigators, Oxnard hired a CPA firm. A firm that Los Angeles County sued for fraud and fired after a major embezzlement went undetected while they sent investigation information to the very client under scrutiny instead of the county that hired them. That's who you trusted with protecting whistleblowers here in Oxnard. That story's coming in my next Oxnard Confidential video this week. Bring popcorn. And Bert Pirello, this is what facts and evidence actually looks like. Did you personally research any of this or are you once again letting your beloved staff spoon-feed you what to think? That question goes to the rest of you. You promised voters courage. Instead I see a council minus one of you letting Alex Nguyen use this measure and presentation to run a personal vendetta Measure M was sold to bolster truth and transparency to the public, not as a cover for the city manager to attack whistleblowers and elected officials.
He works for you. He's paid an exorbitant salary to inform you, not brainwash you into defending his grudges.
Thank you.
Folks are dying.
Madam Clerk does that I'm sorry we have Alicia Purcell
Just real quickly before we continue, Mr. Partello had mentioned he didn't get a chance to do his item not in the agenda just because of the confusion here and I'm wondering if the council would be okay and the mayor if he's willing to wait till the end of the meeting to give that comment?
Absolutely. Doug what do you prefer? Do you want to do it now or after Alicia Purcell? Go ahead Ms. Purcell
So the city manager's video is an attack on the messenger, trying to distract from the message that he hopes people won't notice. The first sentence of Mr. Nguyen's video is not true. It claims quote at the January 27th 2026 Finance and Governance Committee during the report about the whistleblower program Councilman Aaron Starr alleged that a city employee had committed theft of wages.
No, the city received a whistleblower complaint asking the city to determine whether wage theft is occurring. The discussion started because the staff report gave no meaningful details but dismissively asserted that the complaint was either not fiscal or not city related. Because Aaron had knowledge of the details, he was pointing out that council members are being misinformed about the type of complaint received to decide whether that characterization is accurate one needs to know the general nature of the complaint. Aaron's overall point was that when you understand the complaint was questioning whether theft is occurring it is fiscal and it is city related Even in the video segment Mr. Nguyen chose, Aaron allowed for the possibility that quote maybe this is okay end quote undercutting the accusation in the videos opening sentence.
The video falsely pretends that the only evidence was a series of three to four year old photos I'm often present when constituents bring issues to Erin, so let's talk about something that neither the video or staff told you. And with permission, I will say that one of the videos was at 3 o'clock p.m. in a grocery store parking lot Another photo was 20 minutes later parked at the employee's home.
Besides some photos, the whistleblower submitted a list of recent and regular dates and times the vehicle was at the person's home including two sightings one hour and 25 minutes apart. The data points seemed to undermine the attempted explanations in the video. The whistleblower possesses photos matching the other dates and times, but handing over some of them would identify the source subjecting them to personal attacks like this video.
Under this program, the council must be able to depend on your staff to tell you the truth about the types of reports that have been submitted. And if the city manager's office is willing to mislead the council member over the nature of the complaint, why just blindly accept the assertion that the investigation revealed the complaint has no merit? Maybe there's a problem, maybe there's not.
Maybe the council needs to review all the whistleblower complaints in closed session so you can decide for yourselves whether any others have also been misrepresented about the type of complaint they are. Thank you.
Thank you, Ms. Purcell. Mr. Portiello followed by Eduardo Huerta.
Good evening again and thank you Gabe for allowing me the opportunity to speak on my non-agenda item and I apologize for the confusion. I wanted to speak about the homeless issue in Oxnard And I had a good conversation with the mayor concerning some of our folks that are considered mobile homeless. So in other words, they're living in their cars or living in their RVs and we have a section of three streets and South Oxnard Edison McWane and Arcturus. And this has been an area that's mostly all industry there. There's a lot of imported cars that come through there and that sort of businesses operate in that area. And we had a large homeless encampment on Halico it's reforming I talked to the mayor about my view of the homeless and my advocacy for them has to do with just very basic human needs.
So there's a lot of different opinions on the homeless and everything, but my take on it is it's by my work in Nicaragua for 20 years in the humanitarian realm. So it's about trash removal. It's about access to water. And it's about access to toilets. So I spoke with the mayor about that. I thought we had a great conversation And I'd like to advocate for the city to offer those homeless people that are mobile homeless in their RVs and it's increased. There's probably about 100 people there now because the county passed a law that they can't park out in the ag land. So once that happened you know they had to move from there. Well where did they go? So they went over here right. And I want to commend the city for changing their policy concerning picking up the trash And so there is a designated area at the end of McWane where they blocked it off with some K-rails.
And that's the designated spot. Some of the homeless didn't know I informed them, but I've actually been getting the homeless to clean up the trash in the general area and it's been remarkable. We nearly have all of Edison clean now. There's a lot of illegal dumping. Some of it is the homeless, but there's also people that come and they illegally dump their much like they dump in the ag land in North Oxnard where I live So there's a lot of illegal dumping. It's terrible because there's rats and there's disease that caused by living near trash. I think we all know that. And so whatever you feel about homeless, people don't want to live around trash and the homeless have actively worked with me to clean up that trash. Some of it is their own, some of its from outside dumping.
We nearly have Edison Clean I've been picking up the trash with the homeless, working with them, giving them tools, giving them bags and things. And they want their trash removed. They don't want to have all that trash around them. So if we could have porta-potties because they've got to go to the bathroom. They're humans. And with the way that they're going without access to public toys, they've been using the ag company's porta-potties. And naturally, they're not happy about that. They actually moved them. That's for the workers. But if we had porta-potties in a handwashing station If we had dumpsters there and then it wouldn't be such a mess and a health hazard. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Mr. Portillo. Thank you. Mr. Huerta?
3:12 – 3:2112 turns
Hey guys. First of all I've listened to a lot about this topic about whistleblowers. It's pretty unfortunate how that this city has those patterns Alex you know to target you but our city manager, you know it seems like a lot of our constituents come to you guys and ask you guys for help. And then you guys see what benefits me first, and then I will help. That's pretty what we see here and what we're starting to see, right? And so there's obviously repercussions coming back to you guys in regards to those choices. So what I'm trying to say is it's a reference to whistleblowers. You know, I think that they should get the respect that they need. Obviously they try to help you guys do your jobs better. It's all about public health and safety concerns that really are targeting our infrastructure fraud abuse, waste.
We just saw that today with was it yesterday? President Trump just signed an executive order with VP Vance on going after waste, fraud and abuse I thought about our county you know really really thought about our county you know and then also today We have, you know obviously our homeless population as well. We're doing so much for our homeless and now we're getting targeted about with Project Homekey fraud as well and obviously you guys know my connection with Emilio Ramirez when I first ran for office and so those are true facts and like I said we can't look the other way when people like me or they're really involved in your work come to you guys. You guys need to put your community first that's pretty much what I have to say and protect your whistleblowers because You know, obviously they are there for you guys.
Obviously to protect your rights, your positions and your paychecks. Thank you.
Thank you Mr. Wharton. Does that conclude Madam Clerk the public speakers on this item?
Excuse me Mayor and Council Members that concludes our speakers on this item thank you. Thank you. I'll refer now to you Alex
please.
Thank You Mr.
Mayor.
There's been a lot of historical references tonight so let me throw one more out there So most, if not all, historians in New England believe that the first ever St. Patrick's Day celebration took place on March 17th, 1737. So for those of you who genuinely celebrate St. Patrick's Day, happy St. Patrick's Day and for the rest of us who just like to go along for the ride, happy St. Patrick's Day.
I think it's important to address a lot of what's been stated, which is fine. We'll get to that. But for the purposes in the event that anyone's watching just Unified conversation, I think it's better if we just show the measure M presentation Because I think a lot of things have been said about that. So I think it's good if we just bring that up
Mr. Mayor object and here's the reason why We do not have reenactments.
We're not reenacting. I'm actually gonna comment on it what as it goes so Diego Can you please pull it up? So Part of what is important to state here, is that everyone has their right to come here to speak. And when you're on that side and at that microphone, you can express your opinion. You can make your allegations. You can raise your questions, anything you want But be reminded that, Diego press pause. Be reminded that no one's accountable for what they say there.
On this side it wasn't that long ago in this country that elected officials, politicians were held accountable for what they said but we live in an era now where you're not and that is what it is where we are in this country right now But here in between for all the executive staff and actually include our city clerk in this, we are held accountable for what we say.
And from that perspective words matter even more to us. So when things are stated that are wrong, that are incorrect, that are misinformation, disinformation or bashing staff I will, as the head of this organization speak up and clarify the record. So have no doubt that has happened and that will always happen. And any decent city manager would do that. So Diego play the tape and then I'll make some comments along the way.
And I hope this is easy for people to read along. So, this is obviously referencing that original City Council committee. And from our perspective, everyone who heard it took those as allegations which is fine if you have the facts to back them up. And the reason we made this video the way it is just so It's clear there is no interpretation on our part. And we make it clear that the whole video is actually
available. My understanding, this is a little bit off topic and I probably have to have the City Manager or the Assistant City Manager answer this question but my understanding is that from a presentation we received a number of months ago that we don't allow teleworking with the city of Oxnard. And I remember hearing that we've had difficulty recruiting people as a result. Is that still the case? Is that still our policy? So, I do not have any first-hand knowledge because
it's clearly the interest here is to play a gotcha game.
But I have intimate knowledge of the second. I had a whistleblower approach me and laid out what was going on. And I suggested to this person that, I'll say they, submit something through the whistleblower hotline here. The nature of this, so without identifying a department or an individual, the nature of this theft is a city employee who was taking a company vehicle home in the middle of the workday, spending hours at home on a regular basis.
And this person provided me with photographs that were time-stamped showing when this employee was at home and apparently had been storing up photos for several years And this person noted to me that the issue has been closed, and I verified that the incident number on here is the same incident number on this person's report. Basically it was closed and nothing happened.
And apparently still this person is going home in the middle of the workday. So to me, that is a theft. It is fiscal because we're paying somebody, and they're not actually doing the job. And I don't know what our next step is with something like this. Maybe this is something that gets brought into closed session to discuss. But we can't have an employee deciding on his own to just simply be at home during the middle of the afternoon Unless we've got an exemption for that person, when we say yeah you're able to work from home then maybe everything is okay.
But if we've never given that person permission to work at home I think this is a big problem so I guess I'm looking for direction on what to do next and by the way the individual whistleblower said to me that they would be willing to testify with a sworn declaration combined with the evidence of actual photographs with time, date stamps and locations. I think this is something that can legitimately be pursued and ought to be. And I don't know if my colleagues have a different opinion.
3:21 – 3:272 turns
Again, I hope this is something people can read along to. But we don't make the conclusions. It was investigated and here's a part that people seem to like the gloss over it. This employee works in the field. This is not someone who sits here at the desk. This person is out and about in our community Now, even if someone who works in the office, if they want to go home for lunch, they can do that. If they want to go home and use the bathroom, they can do that too on their lunch hour.
Thank you. So these are certainly the facts as we saw them. Now I'm going to ask our assistant city manager, Sastagard, to talk about the evidence in question here a little bit and then we can hold the discussion with the council.
Thank you Alex. Mayor, members of Council so I think Some of you heard me speak at the Finance and Governance Committee, and I did express my, whether you call it hesitation or frustration with this topic. I don't believe that the Whistleblower Program, well, the intent of it, the origins of it, or the positive effects of it are gathered by this taking place in a public forum. But here we are, and it was brought to our doorstep so This particular submission was submitted in two parts.
One late last year and one early this year. I've heard a lot of reference about photographs, and just to kind of contextualize this, I ran the Internal Affairs Unit for five years, conducted Probably 100 personnel investigations helped a lot of employees find success somewhere else, if you know what I mean. And so I take these things very seriously and there were three photographs submitted they were four years old that's not like good tangible evidence of something or something that we can track down. So it's easy to say that there were photographs, I have evidence, I have photographic evidence.
Three photographs of a vehicle four years ago, you know it could be evidence, it could not be evidence and so just wanted to bring that to your attention again. It was plainly stated at the Finance and Governance Committee That this is theft. It was plainly stated that wasn't misstated tonight it was it's on video and it was quoted so that's why we felt the need to address these things I want to there's one more Thing kind of out here in the ethos I want to share with all of you too. There seems to be a lot of talk about whistleblower retaliation and that the five people that were mentioned that were terminated they didn't have any protections.
The whistle program is just that nobody has any idea who submits a whistleblower submission So this idea that there would be retaliation or they're not protected, that's completely contrary to the entire program. So when people just throw these mantras out like retaliation and lack of protection it doesn't make any sense. It's not how a whistleblower program works so...
There's probably more that can be said. If there are any questions, I'm certainly here to answer anybody's questions about this.
3:27 – 3:3513 turns
Anybody have a question or comment?
I appreciate the fact that this has come to a head. I appreciate the fact that it's come with a response as a council member As a council member, it's extremely troubling when there are accusations made and there's no facts or evidence. We have an individual in the back filming. He's got every right in the world to do that and he can either write the will to make accusations but there comes a time when there's not a right.
And I will tell you that I did work in a union situation I'm extremely proud to be sitting here and watching a union individual go to bat for his employees. Where I worked, that didn't always happen but where I worked in that job you were on the road and when mother nature called there wasn't always a place to go and you tried to find a place somebody it would be little somebody to go back to their own home if they were near to use the restroom I don't know what kind of human being you are.
I've been in situations where people go on their pants to keep a job, not good. Those types of jobs should never exist but they do and people take them because it's the best they can get. When there is a situation in place as this city has a whistleblower program which I was instrumental in getting this thing in the City of Oxnard I'm grateful it's there and when people complain and claim that they read everything about them when it's identified It's financial or criminal, and when they are personal somebody complaining about say for example They don't like the color of the shirt. Somebody's got that's got nothing to do with this type of stuff but when a councilman makes a claim that it's a theft I Don't know the word slander counts in this case or even fits but it sure disrespects a lot of good public employees.
And Mr. Starr, I think you were wrong on that. But I am grateful that the city of Oxnard has enough to stand up and work to fight and keep the city employees that they have. One thing came out in this presentation, the number of people that have been terminated. There was another presentation by the police department some time ago When the individual was killed in Minnesota, and the police department explained how many people had been let go. That's something the city doesn't always talk about but I think it's something the public in this community should know about. This is not a bad operation.
We're very fortunate to be in this operation. And the various people that talk and brag about don't come a time, brag about the good works It's a pleasure to be here and I'm delighted to have the opportunity to speak on
behalf of councilmember or city treasurer. There is another side to these stories. Thank you. Particularly with the City of Los Angeles suing that company.
Sure, so we entered into a contract with them probably seven or eight years ago I can't answer that question. I would just provide the context that...I don't know what came of it those were allegations. I don't know what came of the lawsuit and if The city never did business with any company or vendor that's ever been involved in litigation. We wouldn't be involved with any companies on the planet, so...
Thanks Mr. Sonsgaard. Any other comments or questions? Go ahead.
Thank you Mayor. Just a quick item just to Statement I've heard from the video and then, I think from a few other people just regarding do other office employees get the privilege or the opportunity to go home during the day or go home for lunch? And the city manager did speak to that. But I mean, I'm thinking back the entirety of my career. I've always had jobs that afford you a duty-free lunch whether it's 30 minutes or an hour. And during that time, you're free to go and do Anything you need to do. Even when I worked at Hollywood Video, they'd let me go do whatever I wanted to do for the 30 minutes. Of course Hollywood Video was later involved in a class action lawsuit for cheating people on the clock and so I think I got like $70 or something out of that point being though that The City of Oxnard is no different.
We have to follow California laws when it comes to employees and employee breaks after X amount of time, there's also the different assignments as was mentioned where if you have someone who's at a desk all day they're afforded X number of breaks and X amount of lunchtime. Someone out in the field driving around is also afforded those breaks, and the person at the desk and the person at the wheel can take those breaks wherever they want to as long as they are taking those breaks in the prescribed amount of time and being back at their assignment as they're supposed to be.
So anyways I just wanted to point that out just an interesting point to make that well does everybody else get to go home for lunch? Well yeah if they have time if they live nearby That's the right for a duty-free lunch. So anyways, that's my only comment Mayor. Thank you.
Thank you Mayor Pro Tem. We will now
move to the next item on the agenda. Go ahead Council Member Starr. I'd like
to make a comment.
Go ahead.
So let me start off by saying that Ms. Purcell accurately conveyed the nature of the complaint and what the whistleblower told me. My concern with the staff report was it gave no Meaningful details on the complaint even the nature of it And just simply said it was deemed non city and non fiscal nature That to me I felt like I was misled by the report maybe that wasn't the intention, but that's what I felt I Felt like it was all being swept under the rug if there is an allegation of employee theft Then what I want to see in a report. Is that an allegation was made?
And later it was dismissed or found to be unwanted of support. The only reason why I brought it up is because I knew about this, I saw a staff report that made no mention whatsoever the nature of this complaint and having the details of that made me think you know what? I don't know if this whistleblower program is really Being treated like a sincere effort to allow whistleblowers to speak out and reveal what they believe are issues with the city.
And what I'm going to do is I'm going to encourage any future whistleblowers, you please contact me so that I know what's going on because the staff report clearly will not tell me what's going on So come to me, and that way when it does come to a staff report I can comment on that and say no this really was fiscal. This really was city related. When it said it was non-city related, non-fiscal related, that was just inaccurate.
It clearly was both. And that's all my comments thank you.
Thank you, Council Member Starr. We'll now
move to the next item on the agenda. This is Item I. This is a report of a City Council member. We'll start with Councilwoman Perez. Go ahead.
3:35 – 3:456 turns
Thank you Mayor for the recognition and I also wanted to thank our representative from 805 Ndaki Fund for coming out and sharing some of this data. Just to kind of jump ahead, this week I'm really excited I'll be meeting with the chair of the Agricultural Labor Relations Board not specifically talking about this concept here, the item that was just before us regarding wage theft but as we know many of our community members particularly agricultural workers are impacted by wage theft Just last month, in the month of February, a report was released indicating that the Labor Commissioner's Office helped secure $6 million in unpaid wages to farm workers on the Central Coast and really wanted to thank the organizations who led that effort.
Obviously, our community here is impacted by very exploitative working conditions. Many of them are still being impacted by not being able to take a bathroom break. This week we've experienced many impacts of heat illnesses in our community And workers are still out there working in these pretty hazardous conditions. And so definitely excited to have that conversation and really look at ways that we can uplift worker protections and safer working conditions, particularly for our community that is oftentimes overlooked and is a high representation in our community as well.
Some of the conversations I've also had, I want to thank CAWS for reaching out. I know many of our community members are still living in uninhabitable living conditions and have expressed the need for tenant rights. Why the anti-harassment ordinance was put in place. And so really looking forward to continuing the work there to ensure that our tenants know what their rights are and that there are protections in place to ensure that there are habitable living conditions. I've also had the opportunity to attend pretty much every neighbourhood council meeting, and I look forward to the Blackstock Neighbourhood Council meeting that's happening next Thursday March 25th at 6.15, and I'm looking forward to any other scheduled neighborhood councils that will be coming up if they don't happen to conflict with Tuesday night council meetings.
I also wanted to take the moment to just thank all of our principals at our elementary schools. I've had the chance to meet with quite a bit of them and was invited to participate in Sunkist Elementary's Read Across America to really uplift the importance of unity and to also inspire this current generation to know that they too can aspire for great things in this community.
The last thing I wanted to mention, similarly to some of the concepts I've talked about tonight particularly around stronger worker protections for our agricultural workers I definitely wanted to uplift and direct staff to investigate and bring forward what was mentioned by the Carpenters Union tonight, looking at ways that we can implement stronger anti-fraud measures among public projects in our community. And looking forward to circling back and hearing more on that. But that's my report and back to you Mayor.
Thank you Councilwoman. Commissioner Andrade did you have anything you wanted to comment on? Thank you. I have a couple of quick updates
here.
Great opportunity, and I think this is maybe the third or fourth year I've done this in a row. And got to speak to some sixth graders and seventh graders just about careers in public service and had a great little Q&A activity with them. So I appreciate the opportunity again to go this year. Also attended two activities in East Village, the East Village bulky item collection and I didn't actually stop and volunteer so I should make that clear but my grandfather had things that he wanted to get rid of.
Was happy to help the city with that. So I appreciate the coordination from our city staff and the East Village Neighborhood Council in having that be a great successful day, I did get to talk with Alexis who was there as well as Ronald and few other residents while I was there and the staff and it seemed like it was a good steady turnout Then after that, the East Village Neighborhood Council the following Monday.
And I appreciate the work of neighborhood council to put that together as well and Mayor was there and presented. Had my first attendance at the continuum of care that I was appointed to at last month's meeting and appreciate their work then diving right in. And so I'll be happy to provide updates to that as time goes on here if folks need that And thank you to Oxnard Fire, I saw the chief was here earlier. I was able to attend the promotion and recognition awards that they held at the Staybridge facility and thank you very much Chief and thank you your team for all their great work. Congratulations to those who've been promoted and the awards to those who just have demonstrated excellence in their positions as firefighters And just a couple last quick things here.
Councilor Perrello and I attended the Airport Authority, I know I don't typically update on things here unless it's pertinent but it was mentioned at our airport authority meeting that the vacant lot that is owned by the Department of Airports on Ventura Road which immediately across the street on the east side of Ventura Road from the runway there an RFP has been released for use of that land and there are a couple A couple uses that can go there. And it's obviously has to, it's height restricted because of landing planes. It can't be anything that's inhabitable by people. So some of the items that were mentioned things like solar panels or using this space by the port for parking vehicles coming being imported. So RFP went out for that and I just wanted to share that here.
There will be information coming from the Department of Airports on that And I did ask them to commit to speaking in the neighborhoods who live nearby as well. And lastly, back after the October 29th A Street raid by the Department of Homeland Security here in Oxnard, I had mentioned in a subsequent city council meeting that I filed A couple of complaints with the Department of Homeland Security, Office of Professional Responsibility and the Office of Inspector General.
I want to thank Congresswoman Julia Brownlee's office for helping with facilitating to ensure that they actually at least acknowledged receiving that and that was shortly after that incident in November I submitted the complaint we are on March 17th today I received word They acknowledged that they had received it and essentially they said, if information regarding this incident was received or reviewed by OPR consistent with its protocols as this matter pertains to specific employees no additional information can be shared in accordance with the Privacy Act of 1974. Thank you Congressional Liaison.
So even though I had set my expectations in a realistic level of anything coming from that, I do want to acknowledge again our Congresswoman's help in ensuring that they did acknowledge they received it because I wanted on the record the video I had and the descriptions of everything I saw that I believe were misconduct or unprofessional conduct by the Homeland Security agents.
And again, everything I said, I had video to back it up. And so at least that's now in their house on the record and at some point me being the optimist sometimes someday there may be some accountability for some people in some way for what we're seeing in our communities. So thank you mayor those are my comments.
Thank you Mayor Pro Tem. Councilwoman do you have anything?
Yes just besides Women's History Month, which we do have to acknowledge all our women leaders especially here in our county. I also want to acknowledge that on March, we have Brain Injury Awareness Month, which brings attention to brain injury including concussions and traumatic brain injuries, which is called TBI. I got to learn all about that when one of my daughter Playing soccer, got a concussion so it's I think every March she brings it to my attention and she says I need to buy her something.
So I told her no but I do make sure that you know her brain is functioning but I just want to bring that awareness because especially here in Oxnard we are huge soccer community and continuously we've got players you know I just want to take this opportunity
3:45 – 3:573 turns
So I attended the East Village Neighborhood Council meeting. It was well run and well attended. I think a lot of people were there because they wanted to see the mayor, and the mayor gave a presentation that was very well received, and I think I described him at the time as a ray of sunshine. And I really appreciate the public face that he presents for our city. I'm very glad that you are our mayor, and i think you do a good job of that. Thank you.
And I attended also the Eastside Little League opening ceremonies this last Saturday. Council Member Perrella was also there with me. Well, I'm very thankful by the way that I didn't throw the opening pitch because it would have been pretty embarrassing but they had somebody out there who was able to do it and did a great job. There is one gentleman that struck me and Council Member Perrella you'll remember this This gentleman, he was 81 years old and he was describing how he first played Little League 75 years ago at this particular park.
And that's just amazing. The guy was lucid, he was ambulatory, he was just what you want to see in somebody at that age who is in good health and still vigorous We've got some upcoming meetings of the Rio Lindo Neighborhood Council meeting on Thursday and La Colonia on Saturday. I intend to attend both. I would like to take this opportunity to actually acknowledge some really good work that was done.
So there's a gentleman by the name of Mark Burnett, he's the Director of Facilities for the Oxnard School District and I relayed to him Issues that people were having with the condition of the West Village Park and he took it upon himself to really take care of that. And he's done such an excellent job that park is completely restored. We have a joint use agreement with the school district and they're the ones that are responsible for actually doing the maintenance but we checked in. We had our parks and recreation department Basically, collaborating on restoring the baseball diamond there so it's just a beautiful park and I hope that all of our parks eventually look like that.
I wish the folks from the Elite Theatre were still here. I just wanted to bounce an idea out there. I don't know if my colleagues are familiar with dinner theatres where you actually eat at the location where you are watching the entertainment, but it seems to me there might be and I can't speak on their behalf of course, but it seems like there might be a opportunity for synergy right here in downtown And I don't know if anybody can lead me to the right person to talk to, but I'm thinking about the Casa Lopez Banquet Hall.
Right now that's a facility that they offer banquet facilities. They've got a really tiny, tiny stage not enough to handle the elite theater. But I wonder whether there might be a partnering opportunity between Elite Theater and the Casa Lopez Banquet Hall where if they were to get together and just build an adequate size stage, it might be to the benefit of Casa Lopez because they can get more people to attend and buy food.
And it will be good for the elite theatre as well because now they'll have a place to actually locate. Plus it brings them back downtown. It would be nice if we could bring more traffic to downtown. It'd be a perfect spot. I don't know if it would work for them or not, but I just kind of wanted to raise the idea and I hope that the folks at the Elite Theatre will consider pursuing that option and if there's any way that I can help, I would like to help.
Back when I used to live in Simi Valley, I was on the Simi Valley Cultural Arts Center Foundation Board And so the arts matter to me. And I think that it brings, you know, theater brings a sense of, I think vitality and life to community. So I hope that they can be successful at this and I hope they'll consider that option. And that's all I have to say, thank you.
Thank you. I plan to meet with the elite theater reps. I'll bring that idea up to them and coordinate with Casa Lopez. And I'll just conclude, try to make my statement here brief. First many of you know that I'm really committed to beautifying modernizing our city so I'm continuing with that effort constantly meeting with those that can do just that and I have a report that early this morning I met with the downtowners as well as those from the heritage Heritage Square, myself to try to collaborate in doing a nice festival on July 3rd along with a car show and it was great. I think they were very receptive to the collaboration because I think there's experts among all of us that can do something really nice in celebration of our 250th anniversary for our country and then just to make it a free event for our community Bring people in to downtown and just make it vibrant so that people have entertainment and something to enjoy.
And so I'm happy to report on that, and along those lines too working as you know we've got Cinco de Mayo celebration that's going to happen here in downtown as well. I know I mentioned before we got the Ceviche Festival that's coming up in August. So these are things to be excited about. I met with a collection to try to encourage them to have a watch party celebration of the World Cup that's coming. I think this is, for our generation it's an opportunity of a lifetime.
The World Cup is gonna be hosted by the U.S., Mexico and Canada so there's an opportunity for us to really push and that's what I'm pushing for watch parties as Councilwoman Visua mentioned we are, we have a generational fan base built right here in Oxnard. The majority of, we celebrated here the remarkable teams from the high schools that are just dominating in the sport. And so I'm really encouraging the collection to do a watch party, again bringing people in here for our local community but as well as tourism that will support the tenants that are there at the collection as well as offering something to our community members to enjoy. So I'm really pushing for that.
Also I'm glad that our planning commissioners were here highlighting the support they received for their training, and that's something I'm very supportive of. And we'll continue to advocate that the CAGs be well-supported so they can be as effective as possible. And I'm glad for the gracious invitation received from the East Village Neighborhood Council to present so that those who were in attendance had an opportunity to learn more about myself. It was the first time that I stopped by the East Village Neighborhood, so thank you for the gracious invitation and for allowing me the flexibility and time.
And Mr. Bortellaro, you mentioned The homeless situation, so I'm actively working to see how the city can be supportive with bathrooms and wash stations to supplement the efforts that are already being done by others in that community. And treat those homeless individuals with dignity and respect. And I know others talked about it here in celebration of March 2nd Read Across America. I'm an avid reader and I appreciate the invitations received I received from the various schools here in our city and I went to many to read, to promote literacy.
But often you know we talk about empathy for others and I think reading does just that it allows young people to get into the character of whatever is being said in their book into his or her mind and actually look at it from that perspective allows young people to see and really develop empathy for others through books. I'm a big fan of them, and I'm just thankful for the schools that invited me to go present. And I have others that I'm going to present throughout the month so I always welcome those opportunities. And last, I just want to give a compliment. I don't know who I'm giving a compliment to but it's to our city staff member. I was trying to reach actually Ms. Brenda Lopez's department at the Housing Authority and I called 385-8220 which I think is the ER extension And I'll tell you, the gentleman that answered the phone.
When I asked to connect with one of the housing authority individuals, he told me I had the wrong number. He said look, I don't know what extension you're looking for but let me give you this other extension and if you're not able to reach who you're looking for why don't you call me back and I'll research it to make sure I connect you with the right person. I only highlight that because that's the kind of service that we should be providing all members of our community. He had no idea who I was. And I know he didn't because my number is blocked And I just want to give whoever answered that phone at 385-8220 a commendation because that's exactly the kind of service everybody in our community should be receiving, trying to be helpful and having a service mindset and a solutions mindset.
So I'm very appreciative to that individual. And then with that, I will conclude. So thank you everyone for being so patient. We're at 825 and we're just now really getting to the core of our agenda. So thank you everyone for your patience If there's nothing else,
we'll move to the next item. This is from the City Clerk. The subject is the appointment of members to serve on the Citizens' Advisory Group, otherwise known as CAGS. The recommendation is that the Mayor with the approval of the City Council make the following appointments. One, to Measure O Citizens' Oversight Committee Alfonso Arroyo who is also the Neighborhood Council Chair at Rose Park.
Two, to the Mobile Home Park Rent Review Board Mr. Luis Armando Salazar Three to the Parks and Rec and Community Services Commission, Alfonso Arroyo. And four to the Planning Commission, Mr. Edgar Friday. Five to the Senior Services Commission, Maria Magdalena Tapia. And six to the Library Board. There is a number of them. This is Sahara Pena, Thomas Christian Nielsen, Michelle Robledo Conchola, Estela Casares and Emily Ramsey.
Thank you mayor and I see quite a few appointments here in front of us. I want to as always thank those folks for their willingness
3:57 – 4:0326 turns
Dedicate their time to their community and be on these advisory commissions to be able to vet a number of things that help to move this community forward and continue the operations of it. Just one question I have for you, Mayor, for the Planning Commission appointment for Mr. Freire. If you wouldn't mind just sharing a little bit about him and what brought him to your attention for appointment at Planning Commission?
You know and I see that Mr. Friday's out here in the audience he's been patiently waiting, and I think I got to know Edgar In my law enforcement profession met him many years ago He's a probation officer continues to be a probation officer And he is very civic minded. He is one of those persons that is very objective highly ethical he's also a business owner and He has a really keen eye for The development of our city, being environmentally conscious and also economically conscious.
But nonetheless he's committed. He very deliberately and very purposefully arranged his schedule around to go into work early in the morning to be up at 2 o'clock just so that he could be committed to being an active participant in our planning commission. He is already taking the opportunity to read our various zone guidelines Also, he obtained a book on Robert's Rules of Order just to be that prepared. And that's the kind of person that he is. So when I was looking around, I thought this is the kind of civic-minded visionary ethical and committed to serve exactly the kind of person that we are looking for to engage in time and to bring that enthusiasm motivation to the Planning Commission.
Okay. Thank you, Mayor.
Absolutely. And if anyone has any questions, if you're willing to come up Mr. Friday, if anyone should have any questions that I'm sure he's open to that as well.
Sure appreciate that and thank you. I just I know what the Planning Commission really taking on probably one of the heaviest loads of all the CAGs. I'd appreciate you sharing that information. And this is just a coincidence as well but we used to work together as well many years ago when he was in the education realm. And so just funny how there's another Oxnard moment there. Anyway, thank you very much for your willingness to be appointed to the Planning Commission after we come to the vote here. But thank you. Thank you Mayor.
Absolutely. Go ahead Mr. Pearl.
Yes.
Recently there was a applicant that felt that she was treated differently and I'm hoping that we can get the City Clerk to explain. There are a couple of agencies, Planning Commission and Mobile Home Rent That if a certain profession is not real estate, is not allowed in those boards. Can you clarify that? Or the city attorney's office?
Mayor and Council Members, on the Mobile Home Rent Review Board members cannot be associated with real estate or be a property owner in a mobile home. And for those reasons they are not qualified to serve on the Mobile Home Rent Review Board.
And in the real estate profession?
That is correct they cannot be any real estate agent
Thank you.
You're welcome.
At this point, I make the motion to approve with the council support the appointments.
I'll second.
We have a second by the Mayor Pro Tem and Council Member Starr.
And Mayor and Council Members we do have a speaker card for Larry Stein to speak on this item. Mr. Stein come on up thank you.
Good evening, Mr. Mayor. Good evening. Senate Council staff. I'd like to know how many positions are still open? Because it's my understanding there is at least one position of Parks and Recreation that's still open and I've applied for that position back in July. It's not heard as to whether all the positions on the calendar have been filled or not. I was just curious if we could get a report as to what positions are still open. Thank you very much for your time.
Thank you, Mr Stein. Are there no further speakers? Call for the
vote. Mayor and Council members, just for the record and for the public, the only vacancies that we have currently available, and they're actually in the background stage right now is for the Measure O oversight committee for the business liaison. And then we have one vacancy One vacancy for the mobile home rent review board, which we will we're doing some Advertising and hope to come back to council in early April with that appointment
Thank you. Thank
you And
madam clerk correct me if I'm wrong but I believe vacancies for any of the CAGs are typically posted here at the City Hall as well as available online is that correct?
Mayor Pro Tem and Council members, that is correct. That's also referred to as a MADI Act. If you just come out from the council chambers on your right-hand side there's a bulletin board and every time we make appointments we update that MADI list. We also make that available on our website so that the community is aware of the vacancies that we currently have. And we do have a virtual speaker still on this item.
Thank you, Madam Clerk.
Thank you. Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
4:03 – 4:1014 turns
Good evening Madam City Clerk and good evening Mayor and Mayor Rotem. Um, my name is Ronald and while I'm not speaking on behalf of them. I would just like to note that I am chair of the measure. It's an oversight committee and the chair of the planning commission. I think the mayor MacArthur for making his selections and look forward to working with members that were selected and if approved by the city council at our next meetings respectively. Thank you very much.
Thank you Mr. Albarco for your comments, thank you. Is there another virtual
caller Madam Clerk? Mayor and council members yes we have a virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now Mayor and council members, that individual has disconnected. So that concludes our speakers in person and virtually. Go for the vote? Mayor and Council Members if you can go ahead and cast your vote. Mayor Pro Tem, if we can get you to cast your vote.
I know it happened to me last
time. Thank you. This motion carries six to zero. Thank you.
Thank you Madam Clerk. Congratulations thank you.
Just like a quick comment that I had the pleasure of meeting our new planning commissioner at the I think it was at the Rose Park Potluck, if I'm not mistaken. And I remember that you own some laundromats and that you definitely watch the council meetings. So thank you very much for stepping up and volunteering.
Thank you. And as I mentioned, but Mr. Fred is local here. He's an English learner, just a remarkable individual in the sense that he goes and gives motivational Talks, but he also is a graduate of Oxnard College. Attended Juan E. Lee High School. Graduated from there as an alumni of Cal State Channel Islands and graduated from Cal State Northridge. So he has a long-term vision for our city.
Environmentally conscious but economically aware what we need. So again thank you for your willingness to participate in a very demanding position as the new commissioner. And thank you to Commissioner Arroyo. Thank you. We will now
move to the next item on the agenda. This is the Review of Information Consent Agenda. Are there any items any member wants to pull? Go ahead, Mayor Pro Tem.
Yes, Mayor I'm actually pulling one but I'm just going to recuse myself from Item 4. Just as they typically do this agreement with the County of Ventura just out of an abundance of caution due to the potential for a remote interest. Thank you.
Thank You Mayor Pro Tem
And Mayor and Council Members, just a reminder that we pulled item L9 from the agenda. So you will not be voting on that item. Thank you. Which one is that Madam Clerk? L9. Are
there any public speakers on the consent agenda? Just Mr. Stein? Correct. Okay. Mr. Stein?
Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the Senate Council, staff and general public. I'd like to address a concern of I-3 Community Development Project, the General Plan on Housing Urban Element Progress Report. One thing that housing needs is infrastructure. Infrastructure includes roads, streets, I mean roads, sewers and water. Several years ago, the city approved the Urban Water Master Plan.
That master plan is supposed to provide water for 10,000 housing units. The City Council's amendment presented a financial plan or budget provided for the water for the housing program. I don't want to sound like John Corston for those of you who don't remember John Corson. John Corson spoke on a regular basis for a number of years about an issue he had with the city taking his property and disposing of this property, so why bring issues up like the water plan of 2010? That almost sounds like John Corston.
The concern that I have is the city provided was supposed to approve housing I'm getting old, I'm sorry for getting old. But it's supposed to provide a water program to be the backbone of the water system back in 2010. That water program has not been developed yet after 15 years. The city approved the Urban Water Master Plan several years ago and the updates on the Urban Water Master Plan.
So I encourage the City Council when you look at the budget this year The fact that staff has not provided the funding for the urban water master plan to be fully developed, there's 14,000 acre feet of recycled water to go in an urban water master plan. That the city started approving the budget for the urban water master plan and asked staff why isn't there any funding for the urban water master plan? It's supposed to provide the housing and it's supposed to provide the water.
Those 10,000 housing units. By simply saying the water being generated because we're conserving water doesn't really address the issue of a new water source. We're supposed to build the wells because we passed the bonds 2010 to build those wells but the money was not spent to build the wells. They're still trying to build one well, one test well Thank you, Mr. Stein.
4:11 – 4:1837 turns
Mayor and Council Members, that actually concludes the speakers in person and virtually for the information and consent agenda. Thank you.
We'll take a vote, Madam Clerk with the exception of the ones outlined by the recipient file and then with the exception of LT which we'll take a separate vote on here after
this.
Thank you. Mayor and council members if you can go ahead and cast your vote please thank you.
Which motion are we voting on right now? L4 or...
I'm sorry?
Which one are we voting on first because we have several motions
Oh, I'm sorry. This motion is for the information and consent agenda. Item number three is a receive-and-file. Item L2 is for the housing authority. Do you want to restate the motion for which items you wanted to cast your vote?
I just wanted to make sure that if we're voting right now, that if we're going to vote on L4, that that's, that vote happens. It's my understanding. I just want it to be clear so that the mayor pro tem is.
Can you just make the motion again? I guess members start excluding L4 and LT which will take a separate vote on. And L9.
L9 was full wasn't it? Just a
second.
Mayor, just for the record, L9 was removed from the agenda. So no vote on that one. Okay. Thank you.
All right, so everything except for L2, L4 and L6 right now.
That's correct.
And obviously there is no L9. So
that's the
motion? So the motion is to approve staff's recommendations on all of those.
Okay if you can... Mayor and council members, if you can go ahead and cast your vote Okay, so this motion carries 6-0. Thank you.
I guess next if we can have the vote on L4 so that Mayor Pro Tem could recuse himself from that.
And I second the motion.
This one will...I will actually take a vote. Councilman Starr?
Yes.
Mayor Pro Tempteran.
I'm recusing myself, thank you.
Roll-call vote Passed 4–0 motion. This one will...I will actually take a vote. Councilman Starr? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempteran. I'm recusing myself, thank you. Oh, I'm sor · 2 under review
Show transcript
And this motion carries five with Mayor Pro Tempteran recusing himself on this item. Thank you. Thank you
I guess the final motion now will be to adopt, as the whole housing authority here, L2. So I'd make the motion that we adopt staff's recommendation for L2? Is
there a second? Second. Are there any comments or call for the vote, Madam Clerk on L2
Okay, Mayor and Council Members if you can go ahead and cast your vote. This would be for L2 for the Housing Authority Minutes. Mr. Andrade if you can... Thank you. Thank you. And this motion carries seven to zero thank you.
Madam Clerk, is the Commissioner able to be excused at this point or not just yet after the hearings? After the first public hearing
Mayor. Thank you.
We will now
move to the next item on the agenda. This is the time and place set for a public hearing on Item M1. This was from the Housing Department subject. A five-year public housing agency PHA plan annual PHA planning capital fund program Five-year action plan for low rent public housing. The recommendation that the Oxnard Housing Authority Board of Commissioners, one, hold a public hearing to receive comments concerning the second year of the five-year public housing agency PHA plan, the capital fund five-year action plan in the 2026 capital fund budget and two, adopt a resolution A approving the five-year public housing agency PHA Plan in the 2026 A, authorizing and directing the chair to execute the department of housing and urban development public housing agency certification compliance form certifying the housing authority's compliance with federal policies and procedures.
C, authorizing the housing authority to execute and submit all reports documents and all other certifications required to comply with policies and procedures at the Department of Housing and Urban Development regarding This item did not originate in Is here. We start with the city clerk's certification of publication of written communications, if any. Madam City
Clerk? Chair McArthur there was a legal notice for this public hearing published in Vila Newspaper on December 4th and also on February 19th. The city clerk's office has received no written communications on this item. Thank you.
Thank You madam clerk do any commissioners have an ex parte communications or other disclosures regarding this matter to state for the record
None.
None. No. Thank you. Members of the public were invited to sign up to speak on this item on the city's website, and a person who did not sign up may do so now by submitting a speaker card or following the instructions posted on the agenda for this meeting at the city's website oxnard.org backslash city hyphen meetings backslash. Housing Director Brenda Lopez posted a video presentation regarding this item and is available to answer any brief clarifying questions Council members may have before we take public testimony on this item. The commissioners will deliberate after the public hearing has been closed. Do any council members have any questions at this time?
We'll start with Council Member Perot, then Mayor Pro Tem. Go ahead. Go ahead, Council Member.
4:18 – 4:2510 turns
Thanks.
Okay, go ahead. I'm sorry, Mayor
Pro Tem, go ahead. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Council Member. Thank you Ms. Lopez, just with this being a public hearing and I know that these are items that come with some regularity to us would you mind just briefly giving us a synopsis of what's in front of us here just so the public has that for the record?
Yes, thank you. Brenda Lopez, Director for the Housing Department. The item before you is the proposed annual PHA plan which stands Public Housing Authority Plan for the City of Oxnard Housing Authority. Basically this plan is an annual plan that we submit every year that communicates to HUD, Department of Housing and Urban Development. I apologize. The upcoming goals that the Housing Authority is working towards. We also provide updates again on progress, any new activities we plan on undertaking, any significant changes to policies and the submission of this plan also serves as an application for capital funds This year we are proposing two significant changes to our policies. One revolves around the Emergency Housing Choice Voucher Program, or EHV.
This program was made available back in 2020-2021 to housing authorities to be able to respond to our unhoused community and the City of Oxnard received an allocation of 46 vouchers It was originally anticipated that funding will be available all the way through September of 2035. We were just notified this year, confirmed that the funding will end towards the tail end of this year. When it ends it varies by housing authorities because it depends on how many vouchers you have at that given point in time. Had published a recommendation on how to transition families into the housing choice voucher or Section 8 program, most commonly known. So that we avoid terminating the families from the program which will then result in them being unhoused.
This can be done via two things. One, we have to secure a regulatory waiver from the Department of Housing and Urban Development and it needs to be coupled with what's called a preference for the families to basically be expeditiously transitioned into the Section 8 program. The housing authority already secured the HUD waiver. It was approved The second part of this is adopting this preference so we can transition our families over to the Section 8 program and avoid terminating them. The second significant amendment to our policies is aligning our occupancy standards from the public housing program, these are units that are operated managed owned by a housing authority, to align with the Section 8 program. So we're basically trying to mirror those occupancy standards.
The main difference right now is that the public housing program Section 8 does not have that distinction. It's basically two persons per bedroom except for head of household, spouse and a minor under the age of three. So we are proposing to align the policies for both programs to be two persons per bedroom regardless of gender and again except for the head of household, co-head and a minor. And also this is not part of reasonable accommodations so reasonable accommodations are still there for families who need them.
The plan also talks about what activities do we plan to undertake in the coming year. We're not going to start new activities, these activities have been going on they're gonna continue for a couple of years one being our choice grant that we've come before you a couple of times this is a grant where we're working on creating a transformation plan that we hope to apply for the choice transformation plan when it becomes available. We will continue seeking funding opportunities to increase our allocation of project-based vouchers. These are vouchers that are tied to units versus to individuals. Housing authorities have a limit of 20%, an additional 10% if it's a special vulnerable population limit, so we want to continue pursuing those opportunities when they become available if they present themselves.
And last but not least, we also want to continue our conversion activities. These are activities where we're looking to reposition our public housing program into a Section 8 type of model so that we can increase operating revenue and we can improve our properties because there's quite a bit of deferred maintenance to those properties. As I originally mentioned, this PHA plan also serves as our application for capital funds. Capital funds can only be used to improve the 523 units in our portfolio. We usually put a submission of a little bit over $1 million each year. How much we ultimately get allocated to housing authority is decided later on this fiscal year. And what we do is we say, we're applying for $1.5 million. This year, we're hoping to focus on replacing furnace units in all of our scatter sites, approximately 100 units and then the remaining funds to be reserved for the Althea Court Project which refers to a loss of eight units that we had due to a fire at the Althea Court Project.
Proceeds from the insurance company are not going to be enough to rebuild those units so we would like to set aside some of those funds. And summary, that is the PHA plan gets submitted and needs to be approved by HUD. And then we follow comments that we receive from the community.
Thank you very much. And folks, she did that all off the top of her head too so... That was a great brief synopsis.
Council Member Perrello, go ahead.
Thank you very much. I wanted to ask specifically if we knew about grants but as Mayor Pro Tem brought up the explanation with little more information and you brought it up On page 826, we talk about eliminates consideration of a household member's gender. And I appreciate that when determining unit size but the next this is the second from the last paragraph on the bottom.
But the next part is and I apologize they didn't ask you this earlier to give you a heads up where it could go but when I saw this in Mayor Pro Tem's question The Oxnard Housing Authority will determine the unit size based on the following criteria. The initial bedroom will be allocated for the head of a household and spouse, and no more than one child under the age of three.
Is there a requirement now that the people that live their head of household must be married?
No. Because it says spouse? Yeah, it says spouse but we consider spouse our partner so basically they are in the same bedroom. We will allocate one bedroom to whomever discloses that they're in a partnership. So the family discloses their familial relation to the head of household.
So just with the way the federal government is and what they're pulling things out of their hat, the word spouse, we don't have to get it clarified better than...
You mean if we could clarify spouse in the policy? Yes, we can definitely do that.
4:26 – 4:3116 turns
When do you get updates? And I'm sure talking in the county, you talk to other housing authority. When do you get count updates with respect to the state or the federal government cutting back on any grants that we had expected? Do you share and how is that happening? I know we have another member of the council that's involved in that type of stuff but how do we get an update so we're not surprised?
Usually we get updates, we hear what is being proposed. So usually HUD does publish what the proposed allocations potential changes to Pro-Owns will be in the coming fiscal year but you we don't get a firm answer until an appropriation if it's passed so in this case for the EHB program that's the one that we definitely heard a firm answer from HUD saying It's coming to an end. We've given you your final award allocation. Go ahead and forecast how long you can assist those families, and here is some guidance on how it transitions. For this specific for the Housing Authority other than that so far we have not received any news that any other programs will be completely cut off from funding but there are going to be potential reductions in funding.
So I just mentioned for example the capital fund grant. We're asking for $1,057,000 They might give me $900,000 and what that means is I will need to select which project is a priority and which will need to be deferred. For the Section 8 program funding levels for us are staying about the same but also if there's increases in the rental market that affects how far I can get with my funding. So the short answer is they will hopefully notify us well in advance so we can determine how to proceed But right now it's changing.
All of the policies, we're waiting for a final answer on all of the policies.
Thank you very much for clarification and explanation. I appreciate it. Thank you Ms. Lopez.
Thank you.
Madam Clerk are there any speakers for this item? Chair McArthur yes, we have a virtual speaker. Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting
now. So Mayor are you opening the public hearing now?
Yeah let me just clarify Thank you, Mr. Fisher. I'll now open the public testimony portion of the public hearing. Speakers have three minutes to speak on this item. Madam Clerk, you just informed us we have a virtual speaker on this item. Thank you. Thank you Mr. Fisher.
Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you can start your three minutes.
Yes, good afternoon. How are you? This is Eduardo La Huerta. I was just in there with you guys. Hello Brenda pleasure to meet you. Just the housing need here in the City of Oxnard it's really really I'd say it's really bad I guess We really do need the support from the housing director. I think from our previous housing director Emilio Ramirez, really put our state into a really housing crisis especially after COVID. So all these grants are coming from the state programs that benefit obviously non-profits and those who provide housing is something that we need to look into especially families and private homeowners that are willing to help us fill in the gap of the crisis You know, a lot of residents are willing to help us fill in the gap in our housing crisis.
But their concern is service fees. What's going to happen to the property if they allow the city to use these grants for housing? And then who's going to fix these properties? Is a homeowner gonna provide Thank you, Mr. Huerta
Chair McArthur and committee members, that concludes our speakers in person and virtually for this item. Thank you.
Thank you Madam Clerk. If there are no additional speakers then we will close the public hearing. The public hearing is closed. I will entertain a motion to approve the recommended actions.
So moved. I'll second.
Call for the vote Madam Clerk?
Chair McArthur and commissioners, if you can go ahead and cast your vote. Thank you. Thank you. And this motion carries seven to zero. Thank you.
Thank you Madam Clerk. May we excuse the commissioner at this point?
Yes that is the appropriate time.
4:31 – 4:3921 turns
This time in place of set for a public hearing on item m2 from the housing department 9th amendment to the fiscal year 2020-2021 annual action plan for cares act funds substantial recommendation that the City Council one conducted public hearing regarding the ninth amendment to the fiscal year 2021 I'm sorry 2020 21 annual action plan Approve the ninth amendment to the fiscal year 2020-2021 annual action plan, substantial recommending use of a special allocation of community development block grants otherwise known as CDBG funds under the CARES Act for two new public service programs to prepare, prevent and respond to the ongoing effects of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Three, authorize the city manager or his designees to incorporate the amended CDBG funds under the CARES Act grant allocations into the fiscal year 2020-2021 annual action plan and authorize any necessary budget appropriations and corresponding revenue recognition in CDBG funding. Fund 201 for the project, four, authorize a city manager or his designees to execute the required documents for the submission of the amended fiscal year 2020-2021 annual action plan. Five, receive and file Any comments made during the 30-day public comment period or made in person at the public hearing with the amendment.
And six, authorize a city manager or his designees to execute agreements and sign all agreements Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. We have a number of items on the agenda for the implementation of the annual action plan amendment including subrecipient and interdepartmental agreements. This item did not originate in committee.
Mayor and Councilmembers, there was a legal notice for this public hearing published in Viva Newspaper on February the 12th. And the City Clerk's Office has received no written communications on this item. Thank you.
Thank You Madam Clerk. Do any council members have any ex parte communications or other disclosures regarding this matter to state for the record?
None.
Members of the public were invited to sign up to speak on this item on the city's website. And a person who did not sign up may do so now by submitting a speaker card or following instructions posted on the agenda for this meeting and at the city's website, Oxnard.org backslash city hyphen meetings backslash Lorraine Mendez, Grants and Compliance Manager posted a video presentation regarding this item and is available to answer any brief clarifying questions Councilmembers may have before we take public testimony on this item.
The council will deliberate after the public hearing has been closed. Do any council members have any questions at this time? We'll start with you, Councilmember Stoddard and Mayor Pro Tempore. Go
ahead. Thank You Ms. Lopez I'm wondering if you can share a little bit about the two programs that are outlined in the staff report
Yes, for this allocation I would, Brenda Lopez is director for the housing department. I do want to just state for the community that this allocation has to be it's very specific there's a statutory requirement where whichever program we propose to fund must directly prevent prepare respond to COVID-19 and its ongoing community impacts Through this amendment, we are proposing to fund two programs. One is the senior nutrition program which has a goal of addressing food insecurity or lack of food if you will for our elderly population and then secondly the stories to stay outreach program which is a literacy program that is going to focus on topics that will help reduce or target housing instability as a result of the pandemic These two programs are going to be headed by our cultural and community services department.
And they're actually here, and can provide more of the details of both programs.
Thank you. The overview was sufficient. Thank you.
Council Member Starr? So
just so I have my clarification, how did staff decide on the allocation? So you've got senior nutrition program is Almost $332,000 and stories to stay outreach program about 161,000. How did you decide on that ratio instead of something else?
So we contacted, we worked with our staff. We were obviously interning with their staff and also with our cultural and community services department. And we had them review what they're expecting fundings are gonna be, what are their project goals? And most importantly realistically how much can they actually expend by March 2nd of next year? If we don't spend the money it's gonna be recaptured so when we looked at our total allocation which is a little bit over 500,000, 577,000 We asked to see their budget, what are your goals, objectives and how much funding will you need to be able to either expand your program or in the case of the literacy program to get it up and running and be able to meet your goals in less than a year. So that's how we decided okay how much can we allocate to each program?
And were there other proposals that staff considered as well and you said hey we've looked at these five or six and these are the two we're supporting?
These are the only two we have. What was really difficult here was the statutory requirement that we need to make sure we're showing how we are responding to COVID. That's the challenge right now, a lot of organizations do receive funds to be able to respond from their programs and now that we're coming at the tail end We don't have applications where the recipient feels confident and is able to show that we are responding to COVID. So these were the only two that we actually reviewed.
Okay, and I guess maybe this is a question for the future maybe not for this report but it would be nice if a resident can somehow determine whether the money was effectively and efficiently spent? I don't know how many meals the senior nutrition program will I mean, we got our projection of what it will fund as opposed to what we actually deliver. And I'd like to see some sort of metrics in the future about that because I'd like to know if we're able to deliver a service quickly and at high quality and hopefully at a low cost per unit.
Most definitely, and to your point that the synopsis provided just gives us the locations and the goals. But the sub-recipients are required to submit quality reports where they demonstrate that they're moving towards their goals but we'll definitely take that recommendation of putting what their goals are.
Thank
you. Any other questions or comments? I'll now open up the public testimony portion of the public hearing. Speakers have three minutes to speak on this item. Madam Clerk, do we have any speakers on this
item? Mayor and Councilmembers, we do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for this public hearing. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Clerk. If there are no additional speakers then we will close the public hearing. The public hearing is closed. Does any council member wish to comment? If not, I'll entertain a motion to approve the recommended actions.
So moved.
Second. Call for the vote, Madam Clerk.
4:39 – 4:466 turns
Mayor and Council Members, if you can go ahead and cast your votes. Thank you. And this motion carries six to zero, thank you. Thank
you This is the time and place set for a public hearing on item m3 from the housing department Subject second amendment to the fiscal year 2025 26 annual action plan substantial Recommendation that the City Council one, conduct a public hearing regarding the second amendment to the fiscal year 2025-26 annual action plan substantial. Two, approve the second amendment to the fiscal year 2025-26 annual action plan substantial recommending use of community development block grants otherwise known as CDBG funds for public infrastructure improvements.
Three, authorize the city manager or his designees to incorporate The amended grant allocations into the fiscal year 2025-26 annual action plan and authorize any necessary budget appropriations and corresponding revenue recognition in CDBG funding, fund 201 for the project. Four, authorize a city manager or his designees to execute the required documents for the submission of the amended fiscal year 2025-2026 annual action plan.
Five, receive and file any comments made during the 30 day public comment period And made in person at the public hearing with the amendment. And six, authorize a city manager or his designees to execute all agreements for the implementation of the annual action plan amendment including sub-recipient and interdepartmental agreements. This item did not originate in committee.
Ms. Brenda Lopez our housing director is here. We start with the City Clerk's certification of publication of written communications of any. Madam Clerk?
Mayor and Councilmembers, there was a legal notice published in Viva Newspaper on February the 12th. And the City Clerk's Office has received no written communications on this public hearing. Thank you.
Thank you Madam Clerk. Do any council members have any ex parte communications or other disclosures regarding this matter to state for the record? None. Thank you. Members of the public were invited to sign up to speak on this item on the city's website, and a person who did not sign up may do so now by submitting a speaker card or following the instructions posted on the agenda for this meeting and at the city's website oxnard.org backslash city hyphen meetings backslash miss Lorraine Mendez grants compliance manager posted a video presentation regarding this item is available answer any brief clarifying questions concerning Council members may have before we take public testimony on this item.
The council will deliberate after the public hearing has been closed. Do any council members have any questions at this time? Mayor Pro Tem, we'll start with you. Thank you. Followed by Council Member Perrello and then Council Member Stark.
Thank you. Ms. Lopez for this one if you wouldn't mind sharing a little bit about the shovel ready project we have here and the reasoning behind the reallocation we have as part of this
Yes, I will try to briefly summarize it. So on this project what we did is we came before you in September of last year and we communicated that we had received a notification from Department of Housing Urban Development HUD for an informal meeting basically in that meeting it's an opportunity for staff to describe and provide a workout plan to HUD in which we indicate how we are going to meet what's called a timeliness expenditure requirement And which is summarized as we are not allowed to have more than one and a half times of our award allocation in our line of credit.
When this happens, if you receive this notice basically your allocation for that fiscal year is placed on hold. So our 2025-2026 award was placed on hold until we satisfied all of HUD's requirements. So this was in September. We came before you in October and we communicated this concern At that time we had about a million of unallocated funds. We recommended to funding a shovel ready project, which basically means that the recipient has completed work or is very familiar with CDBG requirements and they also have a project that will realistically expend those funds before this timeliness review is done. Timeliness review is done on May 2 for the City of Oxnard each year.
That allocation was approved, that was great. We submitted our workout plan to HUD and we were waiting to hear back. We finally heard back on January 26th of this year letting us know that they were satisfied with our submission and instead of a consultation they were gonna waive that requirement however we needed to complete mandatory training on timeliness expenditures and secondly we needed to submit a new workout plan so that they could consider releasing the 25-26 funding allocation As we review it and we prepare a workout plan, we knew that as long as we satisfied HUD's requirements they will also not only approve our workout plan but now release the 2526 funding allocation. which means more than likely, since we are delayed in getting this funding, we would not be able to expend the funds fast enough before May.
That's May 2nd is the key date. So when we reviewed all of the sub-recipient agreements, we met with everyone. We also looked at those who are supposed to receive 2526 funding to see how their projects were doing, try to determine can we expend the funds fast enough? We came to the conclusion that we have approximately $900,000 over that limit come May 2nd. So in reviewing and speaking with our sub-recipients we had to identify what can we do? What program could be shower ready and spend the funds but remember I don't have new funds or unallocated funds So one of our sub-recipients is our Public Works Department.
They were awarded a million dollars through this annual action plan for the CalGisler neighborhood repayment street resurfacing project. It has started but they will not be spending all $1,000,000 by May 2nd So keeping that in mind, we also checked progress on the La Colonia project. It's almost at the tail end. They still have expenses are eligible for CDBG funding and they will spend that money before May 2nd. So looking at that, we spoke with our public works director and we asked if they would be willing to work with us on this and if we could perhaps recommend reallocating $900,000 of the CalGISLR allocation over to the La Colonia project which is ready to expend the funds. Their budget gap, I know it wasn't a gap but we supplemented some of their difference between original and actual cost was about 3.5 million so we knew that they could welcome an additional allocation and that would help them prevent reprogramming funds in future phases in other neighborhoods So having that conversation, they are very confident that they can use the $900,000.
It's an eligible expense and they understand it then we're reallocating the funds that were given to the CalGIS program. So today before you were proposing that we give an additional $900,000 allocation to the La Colonia project so that we can meet our timeliness expenditure Okay, thank you very much. And I'll just
4:47 – 4:5515 turns
I know it's questions, but just want to give thanks to the collaborative effort between you and Public Works in finding a solution on that. So thank you.
Go ahead Councilwoman.
Thank you for the overview and just really appreciate the highlight specifically regarding Cal Giesler's neighborhood street improvement. I think that's just a good thing that the people in our community should be aware of Which I know it mentions here that it's meant to improve street sidewalks and the construction of ADA access ramps for persons with disabilities. And I guess maybe, you know, you shared that an aspect of the funding will now be allocated raise a couple of concerns for folks maybe in the Cal Geyser neighborhood. Can you kind of help reassure? And then also too, I know on page 18 it's, I think it's 1007 actually at the bottom it does highlight the location description and it includes the census tracts that would be included.
Do we happen to know what particular streets or should Should I take a deeper look at the census track number to kind of get that sense? Like where would be the best kind of direction to kind of let folks know what streets should be included for the Cal Geyser neighborhood.
And just to clarify, are we referring to the La Colonia or Cal Geyser? For Cal
Geyser,
yeah. Cal Geyser. I will defer to our Public Works Director on the streets and I'll get back to your question about the recording.
Yeah, good evening again. Michael Wolfe, Director of Public Works. I'll start off by saying we always like it when the housing director calls us because she brings money so... So I want to make sure it's clear that we're not proposing to stop or make any changes to the Kalka-Eastler neighborhood paving project. It will go forward as planned The timeliness of money is the issue here, so we have a construction project that's already going in the Colonia area and that can be spent faster than the money that was going to be spent in Calgeaser. So we're not proposing to make any changes to the design.
You asked about the specific streets and so there's a couple components there. There is probably a component that Brendan can answer which has to do with which streets define the housing tracts that are associated with CBG. Now inside of that, then the question is which streets are going to get paving? And I don't know the names of the streets off top my head. I wish I did but we have on our CIP webpage, we have all the locations of our upcoming streets. We have our five phase maps that we took to council. I want to say about a year ago give or take so I certainly can come back with those but nothing in tonight's proposing to change what The council has already seen those five phase paving plans.
And just for the public's awareness, I know this is an ongoing project for the Cal Giesler neighborhood. Is there a timeline that they should be aware of in terms of the project being completed?
Yeah, so again I don't have off the top of my head it's it is on our website. We typically bid those projects towards the beginning of the summer and then they get constructed starting late summer and then in the fall. The Cal Geyser is one of... It's the next phase of our neighborhood street paving projects and it has actually Cal Geyser a couple other It feels like hud is
Requiring staff to attend a mandatory community development block grant timeliness training webinar. I guess first of all, can you tell me what it is exactly that you learn in a CDBG Timeliness Training Webinar? Is that something that you've already... Staff's already participated in this webinar right?
And I owed one last answer to Ms. Perez about the funding for CalGISLR, they're part of our allocation for the next fiscal year so we will make them whole via the next allocation and then back to the question on the training. The training really focused on best practices and if you want me to summarize what I learned is we need to try our best to time when we're doing our funding allocations We are very lucky that one of the largest allocations is to our Public Works Department. And just as you saw right now, CalGisler is going to go they're starting they need a little bit of seed money right now but most of the funding is going to be utilized towards the tail end of this year Next slide, please.
We are doing more one-on-one monitoring with our subrecipients, and we are making those decisions. I cannot speak to other administration but we're making those decisions of it doesn't look like you're going to be able to spend your funds. Can we help you? Can we support you? And if not should we consider reprogramming these funds? And also when we come before you with our next annual action plan we also kept in mind that the Federal administration and the funding were in changing times, and in the past it was I'm pretty sure more flexibility on spending your funds drawing them down. Now that's not the case anymore, and so we are also being very cognizant that the sub-recipients need to demonstrate that experience.
Believe it or not yes it's money but Community Development Block Grant recipients and contracts have Quite a bit of regulations that they have to follow, that they have to include in all of their subcontracts. And once partners realize that it makes sometimes difficult maybe doesn't make sense for them for a small location so We learned to make sure we try to time our funding better. Can we get ahead of this? Yes, I think one of the hiccups was that a lot of organizations received additional funds whether it was through ARPA, whether it was COVID-19 and so this has been lingering and we're trying to get ahead of it but all those funding sources are almost done. So now we know that the recipients are going to really rely on this allocation
Is it your sense that other agencies with housing departments, is it typical for them to have this issue of timeliness?
Yes, at least last year and this year which is when I've been coming before you with our action plans absolutely. And I feel very confident that I feel that HUD is very satisfied with our responses and our workout plans and the draws that we are processing. And then you know we did have the HUD shutdown that didn't help us because in that delayed how soon we could get our funds for this next year.
Can you tell us a little bit more about the challenges that we're experiencing with timely deploying these funds? What can we do to make it so that this is easier in the future?
Honestly, I think one of the challenges is if a lot of your funding's tied up to projects. Sometimes our developers cannot control them. You know sometimes there's a construction delay, there's an increase in cost or financing or layering so I feel sometimes it's difficult even for our developers if we have some money Thank you so much.
4:55 – 5:0718 turns
Thank you, Ms. Lopez. I'll now open the public testimony portion of the public hearing. Speakers have three minutes to speak on this item. Madam Clerk do we have any speakers on this item?
Mayor and council members yes, we do have one virtual speaker. Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Yes, thank you. This is Eduardo Huerta again I'm just kind of taking this all in. So this explains why the lot around, I guess Amazon right? That explains why it's been sitting there for the past what six years without housing that we haven't really allocated or actually designed programs are actually you know user census to find the right appropriate housing to build there that would accommodate obviously our amazon workers and then we have what El Rio and Island Acres and obviously La Colonia in that area so um I mean it's really We're fortunate that we have a lot of empty lots, and we still have this problem is still working on other areas in our city. So just something to take into consideration. I mean, these are all low income saturated communities.
And after COVID, we have what four or five families living per home. And I think that's where Carmen Ramirez started with COVID is that when we were being attacked with our housing and that was the first thing they went after was our farm workers because they obviously you have five families per household. So this is something always to consider when we allocate housing or developments that we consider these families so we don't run into the issue that we're running in another future crisis like when it comes down to our housing.
Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Huerta.
Mayor and council members that actually concludes our speakers in person and virtually for this item. Thank you.
Thank you Madam Clerk. If there are no additional speakers then we will close the public hearing. The public hearing is closed. I will entertain a motion to approve the recommended actions.
I'll make the motion to approve.
I second. Thank You Councilwoman. Thank you Mayor Pro Tem. Call for the vote Madam Clerk?
Mayor and council members, if you can please cast your vote. Thank you. Mayor and council members, this motion passes six to zero. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you Ms. Lopez.
The next item on the agenda is Item N1 from Public Works Subject professional services agreement with Hazen and Sawyer for design and construction engineering services for the wastewater interstage pump station project. The recommendation that the City Council approve and authorize the mayor to one, execute an agreement with Hazen and Sawyer for a term of five years from March 17th, 2026 to March 16th, 2031 for a total amount not to exceed $2,912,479 for design and construction engineering services.
And two authorizing project budget appropriation in the amount of $1,924,079 from the Wastewater Fund 611 as well as the corresponding transfers in the Wastewater Capital Fund 612 for the Design and Construction Engineering Services for the Wastewater Interstage Pump Station Project, C2544. This item did not originate in committee as this is a capital improvement project specifically listed in the city's Capital Improvement Program budget which was previously approved by the City Council.
Michael Wolf, Public Works Director is here to answer any questions council members may have Before council member discussion, we will receive public comments. Speakers have three minutes to speak. Are there any public speakers on this item? Madam
Clerk? Mayor and council members, we do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for this item. Thank you. Thank
you. Do any council members have any questions of staff on the side? Yes.
So so I think I got this from the presentation rather than from the staff report that basically staff ranked proposals based on some criteria being company profile Assigned staff, project experience, project approach to understanding and level of effort. I was wondering if perhaps you can expand upon that a little bit as far as maybe give us a deeper dive on how the ranking works and the weighting?
Sure. Good evening again. Michael Wolfe, Director of Public Works. I'll talk in general then Jan Hauser our Wastewater Division Manager could talk specifics but In general, we're talking about professional services rather than low bid process. We're talking about evaluating the things that are listed in the staff report and normally what happens is when we send out the request for proposals, we indicate that these are the scoring criteria that we're going to use and each one of the criterion has usually a weighted value or maybe the total adds up to 100 where experience may be 25 points Other projects similar to ours may be 10 points. So that is already known before any firm submits their proposal to us, so it's clear about how we're going to evaluate the proposal.
They're pretty standard in terms of the... If you've read most of our staff reports which I'm sure you have, you've seen that those are pretty standard I would like to And staff, they'll independently review the proposals that were received based on that criteria. They'll put their score together and they submit those to our purchasing folks and then that becomes the aggregated score based on those individual scoring criteria aggregated for the individual person for the firm that they're scoring or firms in this case too.
So that's typically the process that goes to it. Then once that's done, once we've selected Most qualified for lack of a better summation of those terms, then we will understand what the price proposal is and then we can negotiate with the highest ranked firm. A proposal that fits within our understanding of what that scope of work should be. We'll have an estimate. We'll say hey maybe this design work is you know somewhere in the neighborhood two-and-a-half million dollars on their proposals at three. We may negotiate that down to two-and-a half million dollars if we can because we think it's two-in-half million dollars worth of work instead of three.
And so that process can go as well Come to the council and make a recommendation. And with that, I'll let Jan add anything specific. Did I do a good job with
that? Yeah. All right. We can go into more detail if you
want. I wouldn't mind actually hearing a little more detail if that would be OK.
Thank you. Good evening Mayor, Council members. My name is Jan Hauser. I'm the Wastewater Division Manager. So there's really four areas that we look at because again this is a qualification based selection It's a professional service. It's no different than hiring, let's say, a lawyer that you want a real estate lawyer. You're not going to hire a labor attorney, right? So it's like that. So it's a process we go through to ensure that whoever we hire is actually qualified to do what we're doing. It's very complicated process and you have to be knowledgeable. You have to know what you're doing. So the first thing we look at is the firm The next thing we look at is who they are see face-to-face and talk to, right? So we look really closely at resumes.
So we want to see similar projects on their resumes with clients similar to us in Southern California, Northern California or somewhere in California. So that's a very important aspect. Then the next thing we look at is similar projects, right? So then they give us projects that company has actually done. We limit it to 10 I've worked for companies and I've seen proposals where if you don't limit it, you might get 300 projects. We don't want that.
So they give a list of projects and they describe what they are and when they were done and how much they cost and all the technical data. And then we have them give us a matrix Which shows the people they've proposed with the projects they've proposed. We want to see a lot of check marks on that matrix so we can really tell that the people were hiring have actually worked on these projects, that the company is done. So that's the third section. The fourth section is their understanding of the project. We have a pre-proposal meeting. We invite these consultants to come in.
It's very difficult to explain all the nuances of a project in the scope of work, they're generally kind of generic so it's an opportunity for us to talk about some unique aspects of this and then they're required as part of their proposal to have an understanding, their understanding of what the project really is And then we also encourage them to give us ideas, better ways to do what we're proposing to do and some ideas. And so they do that. And then we also as part of that section a level of effort. So they, we don't ask for cost, we asked for hours for each task and each person how many hours? And then we have an idea in our mind what it is. So we have some rules of thumb right in our business So we kind of know what the construction is going to be.
Don't hold me to any, I'm not going to say any numbers. We're not gonna talk about that because these are real, you know, kind of high level estimates. So for instance for this kind of thing it's about 15% of what we believe the construction cost is so when we look at and we can determine how many hours that is. So we say is it reasonable? Are the amount of hours reasonable or not?
The three of us that did this independently go through this process and put grades to each one of those. And then we turn them in, and we see if we all are in agreement. And generally, we all get pretty close to agreeing on it. If it's close, we'll do interviews. In this case, it wasn't close. We didn't do interviews. We then looked at their fee. It was close to what we thought it would be, right? And so that's why we're here today recommending award of this contract.
5:07 – 5:127 turns
I just got a note from our city attorney's office via text. We've got to be careful about how far we go into detail about the deliberation process, so I think what we've provided so far is probably the depth that we can go without providing too much information about the process and we don't want to give away that deliberation process too far because this is a staff review process that needs to be protected from that.
Okay it's from the way you described it, it's my sense and you can tell me if I'm wrong on this It's my sense that there is a lot of diligence and effort that goes into the qualification process for whoever you ultimately select. It seems like a very involved process, it's not done on a whim.
I
agree with
that. Private sector putting proposals together, so this is something we've done for a long time. And reviewing them is also a process as well. One of the key things that Jen mentioned, the projects that we do are very technical in nature and very specific and we want somebody who's the expert at doing this. We just don't want somebody who's a licensed engineer. We want somebody who actually is an expert in doing this.
We go through this process such that we make sure we get the best technical person, people that we can because it's very important for us to make sure we have a good set of drawings. He's got to keep an operate 24 7 3 65 operating system out there right you can't just say hey nobody flush the toilets for the next 6 months right so that's important as well. So he not only has to go through that process from just an engineering technical standpoint they have to understand our operations and be able to put into their design plans how to keep our operations up and running. So there's a lot that goes into this.
And I don't know to what extent that you can answer this question Alaska. You can tell me if it's out of line but there were I guess there were two proposals that you considered and I heard you say that one of them wasn't even close. And if you can say, I do not want to know who the other firm is. I just want to know just as a generality here what we're... If you want to expand it a little bit that's fine to make it more generic But I'd like to know, where are you finding that competitors are failing in their process to convince you that they're the right pick?
I'm going to channel my inner city attorney's voice here and say maybe a bridge too far to discuss tonight. But I will say that once the action is done tonight we certainly can provide We certainly can provide an opportunity for the firms that don't get selected and debriefed with the purchasing department so they can go through that process as well, so they can understand how to get better next time or how it may be different. I'll let Jan speak to this one maybe just at the surface level but it's likely that, I don't want to say Jan said one was lower than the other, one was just far superior in that fashion right?
Not that the other one couldn't have done it, but I think the idea here is we want the best one to do it. And so I will say having reviewed a lot of these in my career, a lot of times Jan pointed out something that's super important is we want to understand not just what the company did, but the individual that's going to work on our project. We want to make sure That matches the projects that they're proposing in terms of similarity to ours. Because oftentimes it's like, oh yeah my company has done these six projects but actually nobody on their team that they're proposing actually worked on those projects right?
And so that's usually one of the places that I like to focus where I used to focus a lot when I did these evaluations a lot is saying We want to make sure that it's actually the people that did the work that are going to work for us as well. So I think that is one of the places that typically is a focus point and then the other one is understanding our projects, right? So we write in the RFP what the scope of work is but we're not Typically the technical experts in all the details. And so we're relying on those technical experts to say, oh and by the way make sure you consider this in the scope of work because I'm going to consider it as I'm writing my proposal like hey, I think you should also consider these three things. And that gives us a good understanding that they understand our project.
They understand our operations or they understand not just our operations but operations in general. And so a lot of times I spend a lot of time on the scope of work and their understanding of the scope of work so that what we're getting is exactly what we expected to get.
5:12 – 5:1311 turns
Thank you.
All right, thank you so much.
If there are no further questions or comments I'll entertain a motion at this time.
Do we need a motion to go past 10,
Mayor?
I'm just kidding. I'll make the motion.
Is there a second?
Second.
Madam Clerk, call for the vote.
Excuse me, Mayor and Council members if you can go ahead and cast your vote. Thank you and the motion carries six to zero thank you very much.
Mayor I would just like to say I appreciate the detailed responses we got on these questions that were Thank you very much.