UnGovr Transcript
iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.0:01 – 0:1128 turns
Amen or in the spirit of many traditions may it be so.
Thank you. Councilor Arnauz would you lead us to the Pledge of Allegiance? Right
hand over your heart ready begin.
I
pledge allegiance to the flag of
the United States
Thank you Council Member Ornelas. Madam Clerk, could you please do a roll call?
Roll call — called by Unidentified speaker 6
Show transcript
And we have Vice-Mayor Crosswhite is absent this evening.
Thank you very much. Our Attorney Monica Custillo, do you have a closed session report?
Yes Mayor, this evening Council recessed into closed session to discuss item 4A on the special meeting agenda. Conference of Legal Counsel anticipated litigation significant exposure to litigation pursuant to government code 54956.92 and E1 regarding two potential cases there are no reportable actions taken. This concludes my report.
Thank you very much We have some translation equipment. Also, we have one person who is going to speak in Spanish. We'll have a translator come out. Right now, we have public comment and so each person will come up and we'll have three minutes if you do have one entry or request for two-to-seed time. And unless anybody has a problem they're not going to speak but they'll seed their time to one person. So that person will have nine minutes instead of three people speaking.
Mr. Mayor, if I could just point out in accordance with your rules of conduct that is not a suggestion that's allowed although any aspect of running the meeting is at the mayor's discretion unless the city attorney has other guidance but that's a practice that your policies don't allow or don't support I should say
That's correct. I agree with the city manager.
So what is your
recommendation? That you allow each speaker to speak for three minutes and that you... I'm very sorry, I was not following the conversation
The purpose is that theoretically somebody could show up with a representation of 10 others and speak for half an hour. And it would be out of concert with kind of the orderly flow of a meeting.
Okay, understood. Mr. Melgar, apparently we're being advised that instead of two people ceding their time to give you nine minutes that you get three minutes and then of course if you have other comments that the other two people who submitted speaker cards could follow up on, that would be desirable.
Point of inquiry real quick? Sure Is there discretion for this to be allowed Or are we imposing rules that haven't been applied in the past and we're trying to figure it out? I mean, we only have one speaker. Should we not allow that to happen? Does it specifically say or is it may, wording may recommendation but at the end of the day could be the mayor's discretion for us? Mayor's
discretion. It is the mayor's discretion to
ultimately it's the discretion of the mayor as the presiding officer over the meeting okay council majority has adopted guidelines to help with orderly development and flow of your meetings. And I would Encourage you to consider the purpose and value of that but of course it's it's at the mayor's discretion
Sure, and as I stated before I was prepared to allow this to happen seed time And I could see in those circumstances where there has been times where you have 30 people in the room? And they limit it to two minutes versus three minutes so accordingly Like for example other others Councils and meetings, they go for hour two because they let everybody speak. So we don't have that this evening and so if I had a prerogative then then I will allow Mr. Malgar to use the time ceded by two other speakers.
Thank you mister.
You're very welcome. Okay thank you and thank you for legal and I understand the ramifications if we have a room full of people or 15 speaker cards in one person ties it for 45 minutes
Right. So it's the purpose of economy, it's up to the presiding officer, the mayor in this case, to manage that.
And you know we have a light agenda so if it were a very full agenda we might reconsider that. So again okay thank for your time and thank you for your advice Councilor. Okay so speakers are going to be Nancy Grass followed by Atul Rashid. Welcome.
Good evening, Mayor Juarez and council members and staff. My name is Dr. Nancy Grass. I own a building and two businesses on main street with my wife and we are deeply interested in invested in the success and vitality of our downtown. I want to begin by saying that I truly appreciate the individuals serving on the PBIT committee as well as the city's economic development director.
It's clear that there's a genuine commitment to supporting our downtown from all involved. That said, I'd like to share a concern from the perspective of somebody who's on the ground. Over the past few years there has been limited visible progress on some of the PBID initiatives particularly the Commercial Facade Improvement Program which I believe in strongly.
We applied for a facade improvement grant in February 25 and are grateful to have finally been approved however more than a year later we have yet to receive funding Or see the program fully implemented. Delays like this make it very difficult for small businesses and property owners to plan and invest. For example, the front of our game store is in dire need of paint and our antique doors are needing serious repair.
These are important improvements and they wouldn't benefit just us but the look and feel of all of downtown Main Street. But we can't move forward with simply the hope of getting reimbursed. We applied because this was presented to us as a partnership, and we're relying on that partnership to move ahead. I share this not as a criticism of the people involved but as a concern about the system supporting them. And in fact, I don't see this is a personnel problem at all. I see it as a system problem.
For the PBID to succeed, the City must provide clear and updated policies, streamlined procedures and the support needed by both the PBID and the Economic Development Director to turn these good ideas into timely action. There's real potential here. But without timely execution, even the best ideas cannot deliver the impact our downtown deserves. I urge the city to take the steps necessary to help this and other programs move forward and I thank you for your time and consideration.
Thank you Nancy Grassley. We have followed Atul Rashid followed by Jose Malgar and as stated Malgar will have his time ceded.
Hi my name is Atul Ranshad from the Santa Paula Inn And thank you Mr. Mayor, council members. As far as the PPIT concerns it's like there's too many restrictions about how to get it done and it's not done in a timely manner so that makes it kind of very difficult to actually say we're going to help you when it's held back That's my thing on that, so I'm like just going ahead and taking care of the things that need to do to improve the facade on my own.
In terms of, my big problem right here now is that I'm losing a lot of business because of the noise that's really loud from Anicider on Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday. Even like in the evening and then they're playing really loud music. The police, when we talked to the city about it, they said about a decibel That's about what you call it. Either thing, but no one's come there to actually use it.
This trash all over because they don't have it. They don't apparently they don't need a trash enclosure so all the trash comes from my side which is not good and then you have a lot of disorderly behavior and so when customers come to my place they don't want to come back That affects business, so that's not good. And police come by and they don't do anything either.
So that's my big thing there. And even on Sunday mornings there was meditation at the church and this loud music, obnoxiously loud music going on. So it disturbs not only the immediate business in the area but that music is heard all the way up the hills. So if there's something that can be done about that, that would be highly appreciated. Thank you.
0:11 – 0:202 turns
Okay, next we have Jose Malgar. But Madam Clerk if you could either reset the time after three minutes or if you can set it for nine minutes and the people ceding their time are Kathy Godinez and Gilbert Moreno.
Good evening Mayor Juarez, council members and city staff. My name is Jose Luis Melgar. I have been a Santa Paula resident for the last 36 years and a business owner for the last 20 years. I have had the privilege of serving the community as a member of the Property and Business Improvement District or PBIT Board for short. We're a group of business owners that contribute to a common fund to improve the downtown area I have also served as a Measure T oversight committee member since it was established back in 2016 until late last year. I have served many years as a board member and chair of the Santa Paula Chamber of Commerce.
I am here tonight not just as a business owner but someone who has invested time, money and trust into this city. When the idea of PIVOT was proposed in 2019, it was a difficult task to get approved I asked business owners, many already struggling to take on an additional financial burden based on their building size. But through hard work advocacy it was supported and eventually was implemented. Why? Because we were told it will be a game changer for downtown Santa Paula because we believe in the vision and because we trusted the city to follow through.
Since then, my two businesses have contributed approximately $30,000 into this program. This doesn't take into account the contributions from all other businesses. Back in December of 2021, this council approved a $50,000 grant for the American Rescue Plan Act Fund to pivot aiming into improving our downtown area. This moment mattered. It created hope for business owners who were trying to reinvest in their properties and into the city, but then the process stalled. 2000 came and went. 2023 passed. 2024 passed. Four years with no application, no program rollout, and no clear communication.
Finally, in March of 2025 applications were released for a grant that will pay up to 80% of the business improvements costs. I submitted my application the very next day not because I have just learned about the program but because I had been waiting and following that since 2021 from 2021 to 2025. I followed that consistently with community and economic development director James Mason and city manager Dan Singer After submitting, I continued following up through dozens of emails and I will be happy to send you all those emails. Dozens of them.
Meetings and in-person conversations. Each time, I was told the same thing. It's reprocessed, be patient Jose. As the months went on and frustration grew through the lack of following up from the city staff, I reached out to members of this council and two different city mayors. That's how long this goes back. Every time I spoke to each one of you, you acknowledged the problem and the issue and assured me it will be addressed.
I appreciated that because I was taking your time but the outcome never changed. In December of last year, I met in person with James Mason. He came to my studio. He apologized for the delay and told me I will receive my first check for the improvements a week later so I could begin painting my buildings. That did not happen. Instead after waiting for over three months on March 9th, I was told something difficult to understand. He texted me that morning saying that he had lost my paperwork that I needed to submit again After nearly a year and two, three weeks I've been told the application was progressing. About to be approved about to receive the check and then I had to resubmit that means they never had the application they never had the paperwork so I have to ask how can an application being processed in the city staff did not notice?
I was once again told I will receive a check by the end of the week Then, just last Thursday I learned for the first time that the painters working on my project by California law were required to pay $52 an hour to be able to work in my buildings. That requirement nearly doubled the original cost of the project that has been submitted in March had already increased by $5,000 just for the time being waiting for it.
I negotiated back to $3,000. And now after more than four years, we're being told we'll figure it out. We're going to make it move forward from this which bring us back to where we started. To put this into perspective, back in 2016 I took the JCPenney building 13,000 square feet under one roof for a renovation. The project was very complicated included planning commission review and a conditional use permit an extensive seismic retrofit fire sprinkler system for over 20,000 square feet multiple inspections construction from application to receiving the certificate of occupancy the entire process was completed in less than one year Today, we're dealing with painting a building in a grant.
It has taken over four years to reach uncertainty today. So the question is what changed? From my perspective the answer is accountability and strong leadership. This was a time there was a time in Santa Paula where leadership acted with urgency when decisions were made follow-through was suspected and promises were kept Whether those decisions were popular or not, things move all forward.
Today, the urgency is absent and that should be a very huge concern to each one of us in this room. The experience has had a personal impact on me. It is one of the reasons I stepped away from PIVOTS and that's also why I resigned Measure T oversight committee after its implementation back in 2016 These were not easy decisions for me to take because I believe in public engagement, in my anticipation. But participation only works when there's responsiveness on the other side.
I understand that the city operates under a tight budget. Tell me about operating with tight budgets when Gilbert and I were the only staff for all our events? I understand all that but I would have seen suggested a bigger issue It's not funding. The bigger issue is time management, organization and follow through because when resources are limited leadership matters even more.
Strong leadership requires discipline in time management, smart allocation of resources, awareness of liability exposure and we all know how we're doing with that. Accountability and clear strategic plan. Without those things, limited resources start being a challenge and start becoming an excuse. I have to call it short because we're running out of time. What confidence can the public have when their concerns are not addressed? After reaching out to four council members, two different city mayors, you told me that things were moving forward And you relay the information. And things never change to this day.
And trust is fundamental for public service, a profession that each member of staff chose as their career. One thing that stands out to me is just not a delay but the absence of accountability. Not even a meaningful acknowledgement that this process failed because if there's no recognition of the problem There's no reason to believe it will be corrected. Public service is not a favor to the community, it's your responsibility.
When people interact with the city they're just asking for special favors. They're asking for the city to do its job what we're paying them to do. Nothing more, nothing less. Public servants are held to the highest of standards, professionalism, integrity, reliability, communication because they're entrusted with something very important, the public's trust and the public's money.
When that trust begins to erode, confidence in the system follows and when that happens it only reflects not only on staff but on this city council as well. Because accountability should come from the top. And for a long time, I stayed quiet hoping and praying for change. I trusted the process. I went along with the process. I believe things will eventually change but they didn't.
We, the people of Santa Paula and taxpayers deserve better.
0:21 – 0:258 turns
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Melgar and also Kathy Godinez and Gilbert for ceding the time. Next we'll have Efren Covarrubias followed by Ima Alvarez.
Efren Covarrubias. Hi there everybody. I hope you guys will understand my English but I'm in business here in downtown for more than 35 years And I think I've been paying big quantity taxes. And I'm trying to work for the city, growing with my merchants. I got four tenants plus my business so we got a full retail commercial business and The reason that I'm here is because I'm completely disappointed for the extra taxes you guys included in my property.
For something that, I don't know where my money was and somebody come to visit me and says they got a program to make a nice downtown The program was to improve the fascia on the business. And I submitted all kinds of applications, and I just contact with personnel for one time or two and never happens. And then this town has big taxes that I'm being paid And I got five business here.
And then, I'm not agree with the extra taxes that I've been paying. I would like to know where is my money goes? Thank you.
Thank you Mr. Covarrubias and the tax you're talking is at the PBID? Is that about the PBID, Private Business Improvement District? Yes. Okay thank you. Next we have Ima Alvarez. Do we have a translator?
My name is Irma, and I've been here in Santa Paula for 27 years in business. And in this 27 years, I've not seen any changes, any progress. Everything is still the same. Not only me, all of us, what are you planning to do to help Santa Paula grow or do something That we can progress because it's still the same since then I know all this time. That's it.
All right, thank you Inma Alvarez. That's in our public comment unless there is any others? Okay at this point the council may briefly respond to public comment and ask for questions or clarification Council members The other action we can take only on public comment is we may direct the City Manager to report to City Council on any item at a later meeting.
Oh, do you want to speak sir? No, you didn't come out. Yes thank you. Just state your name and afterwards if you could fill out a card please.
How's it going? My name is Pedro Duran. I'm a business owner here as well, 949 The Barbershop but I didn't come for that. I came because we did...I'm part of the ASO thing and we took it pretty far top four in United States unfortunately we didn't have the money to make the tournament not just Santa Paula it was the whole organization in general But I would like to have some acknowledgement from the city, maybe in the next parade. Have my boys, I don't have to be there but at least for them because this has never been done in the history out of I think it was 120,000 teams this age and we're number one, 15 players.
And I'm very proud of these boys. I never did it as a player, I almost did but things happen when our best players got injured at that time. It's beautiful doing it as a coach and all I'm asking for if that's possible, that would be really appreciated.
Well thank you very much. That's been on social media so if you could give your information to our city clerk we'll see about some kind of city recognition.
Yeah, if you have your contact info...
0:26 – 0:4810 turns
Thank you very much and what an accomplishment.
I have a follow up question. Go ahead, Councilman Chavez. This has been going on for awhile now to have folks come through the podium and share their frustrations it really takes them To the boiling point that they have to do that. And so I want to acknowledge the courage it takes to go before the whole city and share your concerns, and invite anybody who has those concerns to know that This is the people's house and that microphone is for you to speak. So this shouldn't be, should be always welcoming to anybody in our city who wants to speak so I do want to make that comment but I do want to ask what now?
Mr. Mayor what can we expect as council members for follow up because as council members we We've worked through our committees, we've asked for updates. And we're at a point now where there needs to be specific follow-up and we need some action. So what is going to happen from this point on? Because we have a lot of concerns regarding PBIT and it's been bubbling over time. And Council Member Cornejo has shared these frustrations.
And we're at the breaking point where we need to do something. So what is that going to look like? I'm asking for leadership. Thank you. Did you have a comment, Council Member Hernandez?
I just wanted to echo on what Council Member Chavez said And how much it took for those that came to speak today. I know that I always try to, you know, figure things out one way or another until there is no other way and so this mic is an opportunity for that and I thank you for coming. And I would have the same question. When I worked for the chamber, I would go to P-BID things or have conversations with John Marquez About what it was and I remember when the concept had been presented to us as chamber staff. And what it was supposed to do for downtown and the improvements that were going to happen, and then I remember that there was some disagreements on what the big first big project was going to be but I mean I can hear the frustration, and I understand it if it's about just painting your building and getting a grant.
There has to be something done to fix whatever the process is or if there is no process then let's make that happen. And as a council, I would hope that we're able to get some sort of response so that we can keep that transparency. We talk about having with the community on how it is that we do things here in Santa Paula and how our business owners who pay those taxes can understand where their money's going like one of our speakers said.
Thank you.
Thank you Okay So leadership, you know there's a lot of components to the PBID right? You have the business owners that own the property. You have the PBID board and then they work in conjunction with our city staff and economic development director. It's not agendized so we don't have the luxury of having any discussion because that'll quickly turn into debate but somewhere in there there is a problem, a breakdown in communication, a break down in process. And so what we need to do is figure out how we're going to fix it And how we fix that is we try to bring those people together.
We're a governing board that makes policy, but our city manager hires all these folks and so I believe that first responsibility should fall on Mr. Singer to take to heart all these comments that were made tonight And try to get to the root of the problem and work with our staff to figure out how to fix it. And not just with our staff, it's going to mean reaching out to every one of these people that are part of the PBIT or downtown merchants and find out what concern they have because if there's these many people here tonight, there's probably several others that have the same concerns But they just can't come or are afraid to be in speaking public So that would be my direction is to if the council agrees just to give the direction of city manager To follow up and to report sooner than later Anything that you can report on how we're gonna fix this Okay, all right.
Thank you all right, and thank you very much again for all those speakers that came in tonight Okay, we are now moving on to a Presentations, our first presentation seven will be by the police department and that'll be our Police Chief Don Eggler.
Good evening, Mayor and Council and our viewing audience tonight. I'm glad to appear tonight to report on the progress of the Police Department and we're going to just cover a few main areas today. We're going to review our annual crime statistics for year 2025. I'll provide you with staffing update for sworn and civilian staff, talk about our upcoming recruitments Our community engagement that we've been doing and also our employee development within our agency.
First I'd like to go over our crime statistics, and I'm pleased to report that our total Group A offenses which are the crimes against persons, crimes against property, and crimes against society overall are down 15%. Our crimes against persons is down 1.4%. Now our crimes against persons include murder, manslaughter, non-consensual sex offenses, assaults, kidnappings, consensual sex offences and human trafficking.
Within that category are non-consensual sex offenses are down 8%. Our crimes against property, which includes burglary, robbery, theft, motor vehicle theft, arson, fraud offenses, embezzlement, extortion and stolen property offenses. That is down significantly. The number of crimes reported in 2025 was 381 under this category In 2024, there were 500. So it's a significant drop and I will add to that this past year 2025 we had 3,000 less calls for service overall compared to year 2024 Our crimes against society, which includes narcotics violations, pornography, prostitution, weapons law violations and animal cruelty.
That is also down, that's down 6.75%. So overall, I'm happy to report that our men and women of the police department take the law enforcement component very seriously. And we continue to be proactive in the community with not only our first line response but also our investigative services. Before I
move on to the next section if anybody, if any of the council has questions about crime stats, I can answer questions or if you have a comment. Very good. We'll move on to sworn and civilian staffing. Just report a status for all of you, we currently although we have people in background or currently on field training until they're off field training and they've completed background and completed field training, we have four officer vacancies two of those are on field training currently. We have one beginning field training on April the 6th We have two lateral entry applicants in background currently and one of those candidates is an overhire.
For civilian vacancies, our property room technician has been selected and the start date for that employee is April 6th. Our administrative analyst applicant is currently in background as well as our part-time cadet currently in background. I know the community is aware of our animal services, our new Animal Control Officer and how we're operating. So I just wanted to do a brief report on since the month of November, so November, December, January, February and March these are statistics. We have taken in 64 strays dogs out of those 64 47 have been reunited with their owners The Humane Society has accepted 13 of those remaining.
We had one medical situation with one animal that had to be euthanized, and we have had three rescues. And I'm proud to report that our Animal Control Officer has reached out far and wide to find any other options for us to find a home for an animal absent reunification. And he's reached out to Valley Oaks SPCA up in Visalia, they were able to rescue one of our animals.
We also rescued two more to the Legacy of Love 805 in Ventura and we appreciate those organizations for their care concern and taking care of animals who have come into our control. We also had one dog that we had an issue capturing because it was loose near the cemetery area. And our animal control officer reached out to Dog Days Search and Rescue, and they assisted with capture of this dog who was ultimately accepted by the Humane Society.
Any questions by the Council on our Animal Services component? I just wanted to cover this before we move forward.
I have a quick question. Yes. I know that the animals that are rescued are held here, what with this intense heat that's happening? What happens if you were to pick up an animal because I mean we're having to make changes at home for our pets to not have them in the heat so is there a change in the way that you handle if you were to rescue an animal when we're having this intense heat
Yes, so we have to when we collect a stray animal week we house them. We have two places to house them either outdoors in the shade which we have plenty of that available. We have a large kennel outside that can has a lot enough space for a dog in the shade all day with food and water and is covered And then we also have several other kennels. For example, in the cold weather we put those kennels inside our Sally Port area and the dogs stay cared for in a comfortable temperature so they're not cold. And the same is for when the heat is turned up, so outside. So when we get a hot weather like we have this heat wave, we will actually put the kennels inside and house them where they have cooler air and they're provided water and are taken out several times a day for walks.
I have seen the walks but I was just wondering about this intense heat we're having. Thank you.
Thank You councilmember All right, on to our police volunteers. This is another component we're continuing to expand and grow over time. I'm happy to report that we have one reserve officer in background for us. Our law enforcement explorers are always an available option to assist us with traffic control at special events and other volunteer events to provide services to the community As you know earlier this year on Martin Luther King weekend, they were awarded a first-place Recognition at the Chandler tactical competition super proud of them I was there with them and it was really exciting and these young men and women or have bright futures ahead We've added two police volunteers. We have a animal services support person to assist our Animal Control officer in case There are Significant number of dogs and kennels that need to be taken on walks or assisted with food and water.
We have that convenience now for us as we move forward in our animal services, and we also have added a volunteer to support our equipment acquisition and technology. And this volunteer has a specialty in those areas and will provide very good support for us. So we're happy with that. And we also have been out in the community developing our young men and women. I was approached by the Community College District over at Ventura College, and they asked if we would accept an intern, and we always do. We take them from Santa Paula High, but this particular intern was from Santa Paula, and we accepted him with open arms.
We appreciate the opportunity in developing our young men and women for potential careers in this field. We have two recruitments that will be coming soon. Around July we will start our police sergeant recruitment and after that recruitment is complete, we will start our senior police officer recruitment. We do have vacancies in both those areas and we will attempt to fill those vacancies with this testing.
Our community engagement has just been phenomenal with our staff, both our volunteers and our civilian and sworn staff. To round out the end of the year we served Thanksgiving meals to those in need. We delivered toys and food supplies to those in need on behalf of The Rotary who does an amazing job during Christmas and their event We had a recent neighborhood watch meeting in the Oaks community, which was well attended. I counted over 50-55 people attended and they showed some great concerns not only for their own for their community where they live in but these residents also brought up very good topics about overall police services and we were glad to provide feedback for them.
Both of my commanders were there. I was there. We had an officer and also a dispatcher there to answer questions During and after the meeting, so we're very glad to continue that. And our volunteers who coordinate the neighborhood watch meetings were indebted to for keeping the communication lines open with our community. We also have provided education on pedal assist bicycles and e-bikes. We conducted a public service announcement as well as press release, and more information over the city internet sites to continue to provide input and information for safety reasons out there.
We recently participated a couple of weeks ago in Read Across America, amazing kids in our community at our schools. I went to McEvitt and read to the kids there and it was just amazing the attention they give and their desire to learn to continue to read. It was very inspiring and we all left our civilians and our sworn staff left the schools with really touched by the heart of all their outgoing efforts and the teachers and educators doing their work, so we appreciate that. March 5th we presented our first parent student awareness forum with the school district.
We narrowed it down to three important topics. Parent roles and best practices, the dangers of vaping, and mental health crises. We had over 50 to 55 parents and students attend this. We had community-based organizations, and also governmental agencies who support the community from the county. And it was very well received. McDonald's supported with a free meal for the dinner for the evening. And it was well attended, and we plan to continue this forum with some more topics in the first semester of the next school year.
Our emergency services coordinator has been busy conducting Spanish Community Emergency Response Team graduations for the most recent class. And just, I always like to share pictures just to share with you what the men and women of the police department do. We're out there serving the community. We're out there our officers actually have one of our officers presented the public service announcement for our e-bikes and pedal assist bicycles in Spanish he appeared on the camera and did a great job And on New Year's Eve, I assisted our patrol team including our dispatchers by working the shift with them overnight. And it was so enlightening and helpful for me to be out there with them and to show our support from our management to be out there with them during the evening hours.
So we had a great time and everybody was safe. It was well received. For our employee development and recognition, I always like to not only talk about our achievements but what are the things that we're actually doing inside the department internally with our employees. How are we engaging with our own employees? And I'm always glad that we have our commanders who help schedule meetings. These are connections, connectivity issues, challenges we address and resolve issues So we had during this period of time over the last few months, we had one sworn and civilian supervisor meeting. We had a dispatcher meeting with all of our dispatchers and dispatch supervisor Mark 43 who's our records management system and computer-aided dispatch new technology we have.
They've revisited us for a little mini summit to work with us to continue to develop our system and work out a couple of challenges that since we've had it online. This staff, Mark 43 works well with us they're very complimentary about Our ability to want to work with them and our staff members are very approachable for them to improve the system as we move forward.
We've also expanded our homeless liaison officers. We had a supervisor who was working handling the liaison duties, but we expanded our efforts by adding four other officers in a collateral duty capacity to better assist with the unhoused and those Decisions were made based on issues that have come up in the city, either on Main Street or at the shelter where we want to provide more services and referrals and help our backpack medicine and all their other social services. So we see this as a good asset to continue to provide services for our unhoused and find programs that also address the concerns of residents and business owners in the community.
We also rounded out the end of the year with our police station employee luncheon. This was done and presented to all of our employees complimentary, and also the community development personnel because we finished our first phase one construction project at the police station which was requiring a lot of patience by all of us. We were displaced out of the station for awhile and This is one of my favorite slides.
The city nominates our city employees throughout the year and nominate employees of the quarter. And at the end of the beginning of the next year, the employee of the year, and I'm so proud of our employees not only for those who achieve employee of the quarter. But I'm proud of employees at all over the city who nominate their own colleagues, which is an amazing feat that they all do. And they contribute to the success of all of our organization and all our departments.
So records technician Yolanda Garcia was selected as employee of the quarter. We're so proud of her in her work and customer service she provides in our records bureau. Our community service officer Hernan Navarrete was selected as Field Employee of the Year And Officer Robbie Mann was selected recently as Crisis Intervention Team or CIT officer of the year for his empathetic and caring support in working with those who have either developmental disabilities, mental health crisis and whatnot. We're very proud of our employees who continue to get nominated and selected for these amazing achievements. And it shows the dedication and loyalty, not just of the police department employees but all employees throughout the city and much appreciated.
And to round out some of the training we've been participating in over the last few months, this is training that has been provided to our civilian staff, our sworn staff, our management, our commanders. We have a commander who's currently taking a course in executive development. We want to mentor all of our ranks. Other operational trainings such as high risk stops, narcotics training giving the officers updated tools to be able to do their job effectively and deter crime or reduce crime by their actions. We also again sent several of our employees, our sworn staff to promotional preparation. Our priority here is to keep our employees here and we want our employees who stay here to promote here and so that's our contribution and our vision just to keep our employees and have them promote within the system here.
And with that I thank you for your time and I'd be happy to take any comments or questions
0:48 – 1:0438 turns
Thank you, Chief. Councilman, questions for the chief?
I have a
question. Chavez?
Chief can you tell us the status on the Chief's Advisory Committee and when do we expect that?
Yeah so this week we're actually launching our application process so we'll be sending that out and those will be distributed and people can turn those in so that will be going out later this week.
And then too you had a training site on there Could you share anything specific about training tied to addressing some of the deficiencies in the audit?
Yes, so I'll back up on the slide for a second. Prior to this reporting period we had also sent our detectives through additional training. Homicide school for the supervisor of the unit and also some other forensic interviewing training for sexual assault victims that are younger in age or underage. So that was the last reporting period. That was taken care of last.
This past reporting period, there has not been any additional training that is needed at this time. So we're getting them back to their caseload and they'll continue to develop those skills. If there is a skill set that they need to acquire, they let us know and then we look for another course that they could develop a skill set in such as advanced search warrants or Some other advanced law enforcement training, but the basic core training that is mandated by The Commission on Peace Officers the standards and training they have met all those mandates And that was a priority for us and that was already done several months ago
Thank you
Just one question and I'm not sure if it is for you chief or for city manager Seeing that you're allocating PD staff time towards homeless issues. Do you know when the point-in-time count comes out for homeless? Last year, I don't remember when it came out we were at 107 in the city about half of whom are housed at Spirit. Do we know when that count comes out?
Thank you Council Member for that question. I attend the Regional Homeless Task Force monthly and they are still, I attended that meeting a bit, I think it was a week-and-a-half ago and so they said they're close to finalizing that count and they indicated the numbers are probably going to be a little bit lower than even the last count. So I don't have the specific numbers but there should be rolling out with those numbers soon.
Okay, if we could get a report when it does come out that's really helpful for us to know who we need to care for in that situation.
I might just point out that usually the preliminary numbers are released first before the final report and those numbers are usually given to us by the end of March so I would expect probably within the next few weeks And we can certainly share that. The report itself, which is much more comprehensive, isn't usually available until like May I would say.
Just to make sure that we get that, I would really appreciate that. Thank you.
Thank you Council Member
Grinnell.
Just a question. Council Member Chavez asked about the trainings. All of the officers that went to the trainings, they all completed the trainings they went to?
Yes, all of the training, they have all successfully completed the training.
Okay, and then I don't know if in other presentations or in another meeting we have addressed this or shared it with the public. We've moved to officers handling the animals that are picked up here in this space because of the shift that happened with Spark. Is that why officers are now picking them up?
No, we have not changed anything about our approach to picking up stray animals. We have picked up stray animals when SPARC was in...when they were operating in conjunction with us by agreement and then when the agreement was just continued, we still continue our same path of how we deal with stray animals and our response to that so there's There's no change in how we handle stray animals. We have had kennels before, we have more kennels now because we believe that there is a potential we could have a few more animals here for a little bit longer period of time in some instances and that has happened but we have taken care of that and cared for those animals some even with medical issues that we sought medical treatment and immediately And got those animals well enough to either be provided to rescues or to be accepted by a humane society.
And is our animal, I don't want to get his title wrong, the officer that's assigned to the animals? Is he the only one that goes out to pick up the animals or are other officers out seeing animals and putting in a call for him to come out? How does that work?
Thank you councilmember for that question. He works Monday through Friday, so outside of his hours if there is a stray animal that is reported we respond to those. We don't put that off until the next day when he comes into work our officers Take those animals and they know how to put the animals in the kennels that we have. They know that every shift to be required to feed, get water and also walk those animals as well. So they have duties as well when the animal control officer is in his off time. And so we wanna make sure we're not compromising any of the services of the animal control officer or response times to deal with strays.
Okay,
thank you. Just to your point to add to that because you were trying to mention a point in regards to the officers playing a role and there has been times when that happens but it's been, there's been gaps between the time we lost John, previous animal control person of the new one so there's been times when they had to step up to that role. That's correct. Because I think you were trying to get to that point.
Yeah. And I would also point out that I think the big shift is that with Spark closing their doors The public often became accustomed to that being the local shelter. So there was probably a lot of activity we didn't even always know about, where somebody might find a stray in their front yard, look around not be able to know where it goes and they would just drop it off at Spark.
And
that's why I was asking because one time my dog got out and I was working downtown, but there was filming happening. And I got a call that she'd gotten out and the first place I thought to call was Spark. I would have never thought to call PD to see if my dog had been picked up. So I'm asking because now I have two dogs. But I wanted to make sure The public knows, you know if their animal is gone or missing. It's the non-emergency number maybe that they would call or where would they call to see if PD has picked up their animal?
Thank you for bringing that point up. So they can call our business line 24 hours a day, 7 days a week at 805-525-4474 and when we get these strays in we immediately post the pictures on all of our social media from Ring to Nextdoor to Twitter, Facebook, Instagram everywhere And that's how we're able to get that high percentage of reunification. Because as soon as someone reports it, we'll go pick up the stray dog safely and then we work immediately to try and reunite. We can reunite by posting on the internet. We can analyze and assess the microchip on the animal if they have one and that has helped reunite as well. So I commend not just our animal control officer but all of our staff, our officers who are out there who are very responsive in trying to safely collect the strays and also provide a reunification if possible.
Thank you Council Member Nellis. Chief just a couple questions. I think most of us and a lot of residents in the community get alerted when immigration enforcement actions are happening we have not gotten any in a while is it your understanding experience that that is not occurring? in our city or surrounding areas.
We've been working, and I say we all the law enforcement agencies and the chiefs around the tri-counties have worked or met with Homeland Security people to try and tell them that professional courtesy and otherwise is that when they come into town that they notify us that they're here and notify us when they leave. And so after we had that meeting, which was recently probably about one month ago.
We've had one visit where they actually called us and notified us they were in town. Now I'm not sure if they've been here since then but some of the discussion we had has prompted them to hopefully be more responsive to us and more mindful about the sensitivities in all of our communities going on with this. Emphasized the need for them to be communicative to us in those instances where they're in town.
Thank you chief for reaching out to them and making that clear. Second, we haven't had a motor officer in a while with the increase in traffic. Do you foresee in the near distant future a motor officer? Thank
you Mayor as we continue to reach our staffing, full staffing allocations. When that happens we have a traffic management plan to assign a traffic officer or a traffic motor officer as our traffic investigator to handle our management plan We have currently an application of a Office of Traffic Safety grant to request equipment to establish a motorcycle program. And so we're working forward to do that and we're hoping to hear back from OTS very soon.
Thank you, and finally have you been given any timeline of when The gates for the security around the complex here is slated? I was
told recently within 45 days that there would be a vendor out to work on and complete the wiring and electronic. They also have to install screens on all of the gates for safety reasons so someone won't get stuck as the gate's open and closed, so that's another facet they're going to have to work on and complete. Very good.
Thank you very much Chief for that. We're going to move on now to City Council reports. If we could start off with Councilmember
Moranellis. I don't think...I'm gonna forget that I did something, but I don't think I have anything to report.
All right. Councilmember Chavez, anything noteworthy besides your written report?
Aside from my written report, I'm not going to provide an update at the moment.
Okay very good.
Thank you, Mayor. I have a number of things I've noted to mention. Since our last meeting, I did attend as the liaison for City, the Senior Advisory Committee. On March 7th, I attended the opening day for Little League at Harding Park. It's a very, very touching opening ceremony because tributes by Jeanette Haragy Ray Frutos, and others that we've lost in the city that were a big part of the baseball family and our city.
On March 11th I attended the PBID board meeting. I would like to expand on that just a little bit since that's a topic for this evening. I would like to mention for public knowledge that over the last year PBID did lose the Chamber of Commerce representative so we do have a new representative as well And we have our fellows program working with them. That, along with the new contract with the chamber is putting us on track.
I do still note a lot of frustration has been exhibited here tonight with the speed at which government works and it's very frustrating for everyone to see that so Really do encourage city to do everything possible to make things happen with those tax dollars. They are in debates at this time. about their budget because they have, it's a good amount of money but it's a limited amount to make the most of the funds to improve the downtown district. And part of that is when our police department lost so many officers one year, the PBID has been paying for security three to four days a week in the evenings To help augment the security and the security presence downtown.
So I think they're reevaluating that at this time, and that's public meeting public knowledge too because of the fact that the PD is staffing up and the chief did speak to the PD and we're They're just trying to find their place as to how to allocate those funds. The other things that they are doing, which is a benefit from those taxes, is paying for the City Corps program, which is Handle Through Parks and Rec, which is extremely successful and has been providing a lot of an increased numbers of those working in the city core program of cleaning up the streets, all the trash cans and On the alcoves and that sort of thing so that should at least see improvement on that. They've also been paying for street, for sidewalk washing and are considering Purchasing or working with the city to purchase a unit in order to keep that going and have not have to contract that service out so once and they are training the City Corps young people to Operate that equipment.
So it would be in-house our equipment and available to do much more with that So I think there's some good things to come there is still a lot of frustration I have to say with the speed at which we work and anything that the city can do to make that work for our The people in our downtown district obviously needs to be done. On March 12th, I attended the Ventura County of Governments meeting as a representative for the city and I was elected vice chair, and I will be chair next year likely.
March 14th,I attended the premier party of the art museum for the Cornelis Bottke and Father, son artists that are just amazing. Historically have been jewels of our city in the arts. And it was a lovely and super well attended event at the art museum. Staff was there as well, I saw the mayor there as well. And today this morning along with Mayor Juarez and city manager and other staff as well we attended a presentation on the hospital that was presented by the Ventura County Taxpayers Association and it was held out at Lima Nera. We're keeping that topic in the forefront also, because it's so crucial with the timing on that.
1:04 – 1:1218 turns
I just wanted to say, it's not related to council but it's related to our students in the district. I served as a judge for the migrant regional speech and debate, I don't know what to call it, competition that took place and we had some of our students place so I'm just really proud and want to give them a shout out We have Angel Daniel Molinero placed second for a prepared speech in Spanish.
Jocelyn Molinero-Luguin, I got to hear her. She had a prepared speech in Spanish and she placed second. I'll just name the others as I go through here. Brianna Murillo, Angel Daniel Molinero again placed. Jocelyn Molinero-Luguin again And I don't want to miss any names. I was really excited to see students there, Jesus Manuel Ortiz Moreno, Guadalupe Rocha, Gabriela Ramirez and Liliana Ramirez.
And then we also had our students... They placed more than once but are in debate. The debate team winners were Our Isbell Middle School placed first for middle school and high schools in Spanish, Santa Paula High placed second. Middle school English, Isbell placed second. And for high school English, Santa Paula High School took first. So I just want to give a shout out to our students who prepared and put a lot of work and effort into their speeches and prepared for the debate along with their coaches and their parents that went and were proud to see them receive recognition.
And yeah, students is My favorite, I think. I've shared that before but I just wanted to acknowledge that and that's it. I don't have anything else.
Very good. Thank you Council Member Nellis. Okay, I'll follow up with...I'm sure the city manager will add a little bit but on the 9th we started our second course of the Santa Paula Leadership Academy at the Glen Tavern and Dr. Mears was there as well as the fellows and Mr. Singer and myself and I was asked to talk a little about the early history of Santa Paula Also as Council Member Arnella said, hearing the youth speak is just phenomenal. And I was at the Youth of the Year in Buellton on the 11th where the Tri-Counties from the Boys and Girls Clubs get together and there were nine students from each of the areas and the speeches they gave were just unbelievable in preparation and in passion. And it's great to hear that and I can't remember who the winner was but I apologize for that.
There was a happy history hour at the Aviation Museum speaker was Peggy Kelly talked about I'm sorry, the 98th anniversary of the St. Francis Dam. Also as Council Member Cornelius said we attended the hospital discussion by the Ventura County Taxpayer Association and they have some great ideas but it's going to take a combined effort of the Board of Supervisors and other entities that might get involved and we're hoping that not if it happens but when it happens, but we will see.
Today we had a closed session and I also attended the opening at the Botky Art Exhibit the other day and also I just want to remind folks Saturday the 28th will be our annual Easter egg hunt at Tea Park. I don't recall what time it is, but I remember Okay anyway all right so that's my report Thank You mr. Singer I apologize last meeting and I didn't call on you And so if you want to catch up on both that'd be great. Thank you
Well, I was gonna at that time report a few road closures But those have come and gone although I was going to also announce that we've been awarded for the fifth year in a row, Tree City USA designation. That doesn't come without a significant investment in our urban forestry and so know that that's going to be celebrated on Arbor Day this coming month of April I think. I too was at the meeting this morning it was very enlightening and helpful at the Historical Society presentation about the St. Francis Dam last Thursday and the art opening on Saturday, and on this past Friday we held our management retreat had some very helpful and robust discussions with our managers about our organization and our culture.
And finally Just want to point out that on Monday, for the benefit of the council, the mayor and I will be traveling to Washington DC to meet with representatives and hopefully lobby for assistance and talk about what's important to Santa Paula. And to keep expenses down, the mayor and I are sharing a room because rooms in D.C. are just outrageous so...
Thank you. Can you just expand a little bit on the Leadership Academy?
Yeah, so we kicked off our second ever Leadership Academy. Thank you for mentioning that this last Monday. Again the group met this week we had 20 people that registered although the attendance has been around 13 or 14. And we go into week three this next week with our finance department. Participants are going to get to do tours, meet with all of our departments, learn about civics and government and just what makes the city run and tick.
And hopefully come out of it much better for it. Interestingly, it's a very diverse group and we have newer residents. We have some non-residents. We have people who are engaged and involved in commissions and in the city in some way and others who are absolute newbies to it and really great diverse group. They got to do a mock council meeting This last Monday sit here at the dais.
It was very humorous, we brought to them a serious discussion about cannabis which is actually quite timely and we had all these speakers which were of course participants that were advocating pro or con on the topic and so that was really enjoyable.
Thank you. And I was there when one of the participants said the story of his son, they were sitting there and the son was watching the water go down he goes dad where does that go? And he goes, I'm going to find out because they're gonna take me to the wastewater treatment plant. He was very excited about that. All right thank you that's the city manager report we're gonna move on to the consent calendar these are items that if any council member wishes to pull or at least ask questions on.
I'd like to make a motion to approve consent items 10 A B and C and I'd like to pull D
If we could do one that's amended, we have a red line on 10C I believe it is. Or is it D? 10D.
Did everybody get a chance to see the red line version on Exhibit A that was handed to us?
Yeah, that's actually what I'm pulling.
Okay.
Alright
so you're going to pull that one and I just have a question on the GAD, geographic Yeah, basically I've had a question from a resident that lives on the hill of who do they contact. And so reading through the report they have a GAD manager but then when I was speaking to the city manager he said our first point of contact should be the public works director. But in reality who should those people call when they have a concern or problem with the geologic hazard abatement district?
Yeah, if concerns or complaints come up they should contact our public works department.
Okay.
We wouldn't want them working directly with the administrators because that's billable time and it may be things that we can resolve before going to the administrators.
Very good. Okay so was there a motion? There was a motion for A, B and C.
Second.
Roll-call vote Moved by Pedro Chavez · Seconded by Canelo
Show transcript
1:13 – 1:2345 turns
Aye.
Anyone opposed? Okay that passes thank you we'll move on to 10d the city recognition and Do you have a question on
there? Yeah I'm actually proposing a revision the way it reads currently says recognitions of Certificates of Recognition and or Appreciation and City Memorabilia are issued on behalf of the City Council as a whole I'd like to Adjust or amend or actually replace and presented by the mayor and take out the not by any individual council member. Because a recognition is presented by the mayor on behalf of the council, so it's more positive instead of punitive to make a statement against a council member.
So it's issued on behalf of the City Council as a whole and presented by the mayor instead of singling out any individual council member
I'm fine. I would say mayor or presiding officer, because if the mayor is not there, there's a reason for being able to present it.
And if I recall, I believe that's kind of the direction we had last time was the mayor gives it on behalf of the council. Yeah, no, that'd be fine. But I like the fact of a... Or presiding officer
just in
case, yeah.
In case the mayor is not here.
Everyone okay with that? Can we amend that?
Yes, you may just make your motion to include the amendment.
Motion to amend item exhibit A to B as amended.
Okay it's been moved by Councilman Chavez. Is there a second?
I'll second.
Okay, thank you. Seconded by Councilmember Ornelas. Any discussion? Okay seeing none all in favor say
aye.
Aye. Anyone opposed?
Point of order. I think he said a motion to amend but he didn't make the motion to approve.
Correct.
Motion to approve the amended language
To include after whole presented by the mayor or presenting officer. An exhibit A to B.
All right, so okay so first withdrawn and but thank you for catching that comes from her canal. Okay, so it's been moved again to For this language in the amendment and seconded all any discussion. Okay, all in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay it passes thank you very much we will now move on to action item 11 a second read an adoption of ordinance to regulate successive rent increase applications.
All right so...
That's my item Mr. Mayor.
Thank
you waiting for The slide
clicker.
Tonight this item is to consider a second reading and adoption of an ordinance that will regulate successive rent increase applications that council introduced at the last meeting. That ordinance generally prohibits apart from submitting a rent increase application less than 12 months after decision on a substantially similar, after a substantially similar application was made.
The exception to this is when there is a material change in circumstances within that 12 month period since the last decision that would affect park owners entitlement to adjust and reasonable return. At the last meeting, council asked whether excluding significant increases to property taxes from this material change in circumstances exception might have unintended consequences.
And to answer this it'll be helpful to look at the city's ordinance as a whole And how it affords a park owner an opportunity to obtain a fair return. So I've mentioned this before, but to comply with California law, rent control ordinances must have a way for parks to seek a fair return on their property or it is invalid and our ordinance as a whole checks this box.
So under our ordinance, a park can apply for rent increase to ensure that it's earning the same net operating income it did during the base year that is defined in our ordinance. And that's adjusted by according to our ordinance, a 75% CPI change. The base year is generally the date before rent control went into effect so you're starting at market rates. So NOI or net operating income means the gross revenue minus operating expenses.
And in that calculation of what maintaining a net property income fair return is, are property taxes. Property taxes and assessments are part of the definition of operating expenses that must be considered when an application is for the commission in deciding a fair return. This is consistent with case law that requires Our commission to make a reasonable evaluation of financial data that is offered to show evidence of their operating expenses.
Therefore, operating expenses must be considered when there's a fair return determination in front of the Commission. That does not affect what we're doing this evening proposing for amendments does not affect that overall formula for calculating fair return. So property taxes will be included when a park applies for that maintenance of an operating income fair return.
But what this amendment would do is it pauses for 12 months, in very limited circumstances when there's been a prior application. And then a park seeks to apply again within 12 months with a substantially similar application. So during that 12-month period, property taxes will be excluded and so this still allows them after those 12 months to obtain that fair return.
And California law allows for a not significant delay in a fair return. So if there's temporary delay to a fair return, that is permissible as long as they eventually get it. And so I wanted to propose in your ordinance additional language to make this clear and I'll put up This slide just kind of illustrates the process of what would happen if this ordinance went into effect focused on property taxes.
So say the park applies January 1st, that's their first application. They are denied their fair return and during that decision their property taxes are considered among their operating expenses Then they try to apply in July 1st application 2, but under this new ordinance amendment that would be prohibited. So it's essentially the same as application one and they want to include a higher. They want to make fit that exception to the 12 month prohibition by saying we have High property tax increase. Well, they're not allowed to do that until January 1st when they can bring their application with that higher property tax increase.
So this evening, I'm just suggesting that we add the additional language that's underlined to stress that and clarify that increases to operating expenses due to regulatory increases in property tax including increases resulting from a change or transfer of ownership shall be considered an application submitted 12 months after the prior application. And so we will We're going to retain the language introduced at the last meeting, but then add this last sentence.
Just for clarity for the public why is it that we know why but the it's highlighted in blue?
Yeah.
Yes. What was your question correct?
So the text that is not underlined and read is what staff introduced at the last meeting and the text that is in blue is what council asked to be amended And that concludes my presentation.
All right, questions from our attorney? For our attorney? Go ahead Council Member Cornell.
More comment I just want to thank you for clarifying that issue. That was something that we weren't sure really where it stood since it was brought up to us that evening and so doing that research and adding that verbiage I appreciate it very much.
Agreed.
Thank you.
Motion to approve.
Just one question, and that is the way it's read in the staff report. It says consider second reading an adoption or does this consider review and waiving of the second reading?
So what you would have to incorporate these changes You're gonna have to reintroduce The ordinance with these with this new amendment so we this will be returning to council for a first reading
okay So no need for a motion or
anything.
Motion to approve the amendment.
Motion to reintroduce the
ordinance
with amendments.
So motion to reintroduce Ordinance Number 1353 as amended.
And I will second it.
Roll-call vote Passed Moved by Pedro Chavez · Seconded by Nellis
Show transcript
1:23 – 1:3315 turns
Thank you,
Monica. OK we're going to
move on to the next item. A utility box project. This is Item 11B and it's going to be presented by our intern Nicole Aspera. Thank you.
Good evening, Mayor and members of the City Council. My name is Nicole Aspita and I'm an intern here at the City Manager's Office. Before you tonight is Agenda Item 11B, a staff report presenting proposed criteria and program requirements for the City of Santa Paula's Utility Box Art Project. This item is brought forward in coordination with the Santa Paula Arte & Cultura Collective and is intended to establish a clear framework for implementing public art on city-owned utility boxes.
The purpose of this item is to provide Council with an opportunity to review and consider adoption of guidelines that address key components of the program Including eligible infrastructure, design standards, application procedures, installation protocols and maintenance responsibilities. This criteria are designed to ensure that the project enhances the city's visual environment while maintaining public safety, protecting infrastructure and aligning the community standards. In developing these criteria and requirements, staff researched similar programs in neighborhood cities to help inform best practices and ensure a well-structured and effective program tailored to Santa Paula. This effort directly supports the city's two year 2025 to 2027 strategic plan specifically within the arts culture and environment focus area by advancing priorities related to expanding public art opportunities Strengthening community identity and fostering partnerships with local arts organizations.
Staff is recommending that the City Council adopt by motion the proposed criteria and program requirements to help guide the implementation of the Utility Box Art Project. At this time, I would like to introduce representatives from the Santa Paula Arte & Cultura Collective to present their proposed Utility Box Art Program. Thank you.
Good evening and welcome.
Sorry, I didn't hear
you. Good evening and welcome.
Thank you. Hi. OK. So he's stealing the show already.
Great. Show and tell.
Mayor, city council members, staff, and viewers, my name is Dr. Maria Munguia Wellman. And good evening. I'm Lynn Oken. And this is our former mayor and council person, Andy Sobel. There you go. OK, so let's start. Let's see what we can put up here. OK, and we're going to let you know what we're up to. And hopefully you'll understand everything but hopefully have some questions too. And Andy is just so happy. You want to show them the others?
Oh, it's on both
sides.
Inspired by beautiful Santa Paula. That's right. Okay, the Utility Box Art Proposal. This program is a city art showcase for Santa Paula individual artists, groups of artists, students, schools and community organizations to transform designated street utility boxes into public works of art. SPAC, the Santa Paula Arts... I never know if it's and or e So this is just an overview. This program will be year-round, there will be a rollout campaign to get the word out. Interested participants from Santa Paula will find a list of available utility boxes, dimensions, application process and further information on the SPAC website.
And submit application packets to SPAC. A SPAC committee will review applications for approval and suitability. All finished boxes will be photographed and displayed in a gallery on the SPAC website. We're in the process of getting that together. The utility boxes, the City of Santa Paula has provided a list of utility boxes that will serve as the initial installments. Southern California Edison has indicated that they are open to having their boxes painted Neighborhoods under HOAs may need special agreements, but we're just letting you know that.
This is a list of the current boxes that are available by street. There will be templates such as the following. Each participant will paint an entire utility box. That is all sides top and sides because they're different shapes and sizes So this is just one of the dimensions. I know Andy's in the process of getting dimensions for all the boxes that were listed prior to this.
Guidelines, so the program's open to artists groups from Santa Paula. Applicants and sponsors can request a specific location. Applications will be available on the website along with all necessary information. One utility box per applicant And the design should be visually engaging. So these are additional guidelines. The artwork may not contain advertising, religious arts, sexual content, negative imagery or convey political partisanship.
Artists will follow installation guidelines. Art will remain on the utility box for seven years and after that it will be re-added to the list of available boxes. The installation. The City of Santa Paula has agreed to do the preparation of the utility boxes, which includes cleanup and priming. Artists will follow detailed installation guidelines provided after approval such as artists or artists will pick a window to paint the boxes that is at least three days after any precipitation.
Artist or artists will be required to use high quality exterior acrylic paint kind of like what we used here SPAC will apply UV coating and non-sacrificial anti-graffiti coating, and each utility box will have a QR code that connects to the SPAC website that will have a picture of the artwork along with the name of the piece, the name of the artist or group, the name of the sponsor, the SPAC logo, and paint and supplies donors.
Some more maintenance on the boxes will be evaluated continuously If there is a degradation, artists will be notified and have the option to fix it to make any kind of repairs. There has only been one instance where public artwork has been defaced and that's good news. It is expected that there will be little to no need to perform any graffiti removal. Given that the city has materials and expertise, SPAC proposes that city staff will perform graffiti removal if necessary This decision can be revisited if it becomes a cost, staff time burden to the city.
Funding, so typical costs to a sponsor for an art installation of five colors, five quarts of appropriate exterior acrylic paint would run roughly $100. Paintbrushes, rollers, etc., anything else that's needed we're thinking $100. The total cost estimate with incidentals to the sponsor will be $250. The cost of SPAC is for a hand-held paint sprayer, which is about $50. $50 to $100 a gallon for UV and graffiti coating, which covers four boxes. So for 20 boxes, $250 to $500.
The goal is that there are no costs to the artists. That's really important to us. SPAC will provide a starter list of businesses, individuals and organizations that want to sponsor some of the art. Each participant can also find a sponsor on their own if they are up to doing that which I think would be part of the fun process. A business individual or organization can seek out artists to sponsor.
Local hardware stores have agreed to participate in the program. I think Franks has already agreed. We're going to check out Ace. A panel of SPAC artists will ensure submissions meet the guidelines, they will confirm that the design fits the box dimensions and uses the five sides or more if there are sub boxes in an aesthetic manner kind of like this you know kind of wrapping around things like that The selectors will not be judging or commenting on the design. However, they will provide suggestions if there are any obvious flaws in the submission that any artist or artist group makes.
SPAC will work to highlight each installation. A photo will be added to the website which is in process right now. We're really excited about that. Social and print media will be engaged and some kind of community events will be planned around each of the boxes. Thank you. Did you want to add anything? I think just wait for questions. Okay, Andy?
Questions from Council? I don't have any questions but I just think this is wonderful progress to be able to have all of our cities so thank you for your leadership and for your time in making this possible.
We've been meeting for what about a year right yeah we've been meeting for about a year
1:33 – 1:4024 turns
Have you looked at other cities doing the same or are you kind of modeling it after some of them? Just for that idea. I think it's wonderful, but
we've actually looked around the country when we're traveling anywhere We're always taking pictures But clearly Ventura has got a great program going and they've been very supportive in helping us with some questions that we had Can't wait to see.
Thank you. Yeah it's a model, it's been modeled in so many cities and such a successful project just bringing more color and enlivenment also the county is putting a project together so we have tagged one of the boxes that's on the west side of Santa Paula to be doing through the county as well.
Yeah through their public works department We saw it on the website or came up on their Ventura newsletter. There was one box on Briggs and Telegraph.
I just want to say that I'm excited. And the project that I think I've seen firsthand being done is the collection at River Park, all of their boxes are painted and It happens to be a good friend of mine who did the artwork, so when Andy shared with me that this project was coming up I thought of him. So hopefully he could come and do a box here. He's actually the artist that did the mural over at the community center but I'm excited to see more art.
I'd love to see if some of the youth I used to work with here in town would be willing to take on a box. Is there any like What am I trying? I can't think of the word. Exceptions or limitations on the design, do they have to fall under a certain list of things that are, I mean obviously appropriate but I mean are there things that would not be allowed or is it like an application process and it goes through you all and then you approve it? How does that work?
Yeah go ahead. Thank you. So there are no artistic guidelines. Some cities actually do themes and we had a conversation about that. That decided not to. So it's completely up to the artists, groups of artists which is really exciting so then we'll get a big variety and just to be clear you know it's not impossible that a second grade class decides to do a box so they make it a big theme of the class to do the whole process, do the markup, the design, the application, find a sponsor, do the work, do the painting So it can be anything. So that means we'll be surprised by a lot of the art that we might see, hopefully. And again, it will be a big variety and we don't know what it's going to look like.
I'm really excited to see it. I don't know if I was just so excited I missed it but is the application process... Will there be a rollout for that? Where will that be available for people? Where could we find it?
Right so we don't have the exact date yet but it will be sometime late next month or in May. Next month is we'll come in for proclamation for the California Art and culture, creativity. But then we will have but we're gonna have a bigger rollout because we're gonna have to get the word out to everybody so you'll know about it and we'll come in making a public comment here to get that out there and then contact all the sorts of different groups and stuff like that
And how many boxes is there again?
There's 20 or 21, depending. And then I'm not sure how many SCE boxes. And then also this is our first kind of art endeavor in terms of this public art process but we will be expanding it to paint Santa Paula or Santa Paula paints so other surfaces that aren't utility boxes, you will be looking at that too. So hopefully we're just ton of color in the
next few years. That's wonderful. Thank you all for your work on this so far.
I have a question, Mr. Mayor. You know we have a lot of civic organizations in town and I just want to make sure that those organizations because they're working for the common good of the community that they're not considered an advertisement as that.
Right so it went by quickly but the guidelines are quite short so they can't be advertisements, can't be political discussions sexual religious or antagonistic in any way And it turns out other cities have that one sentence and it's worked fine.
But a Rotary Club could do a Service Above South, for instance, theme to share the value of service?
Sure.
That would not be considered an advertisement right?
Well I couldn't say rotary for example.
Okay.
Right so it wouldn't be clear but yeah if the Rotary Club wanted to sponsor something find an artist and do something that somehow is representative. Or sore optimist or yeah.
And I will point to the prohibited content that's in the guidelines we're suggesting the council adopt. That's on page 120 of your packet, and I'll just read it really quickly. Designs may not contain advertising or commercial promotion political campaign messaging or partisan content, religious proselytizing. That's a mouthful. Sexual or explicit imagery, hate speech or discriminatory imagery, or negative or offensive imagery.
Some of that is, of course, a bit subjective. I think we'll be able to trust the resident committee and the art and culture collective to use their best discretion about that
I think you found your volunteer sandwich board advertiser. Do
we know who
the artist that painted
this?
1:40 – 1:4724 turns
I must say that my husband was stuck with what we couldn't finish because we all had to go to meetings. But it was the four of us, but yeah. I just want to thank Andy for leading this committee. I feel that I would be remiss if I didn't mention our great appreciation for the time that Augustine was on our committee, and we miss him dearly.
Thank you.
Get in the middle. Thank you.
And Mr. Mayor, while the council's considering the possible adoption of the criteria that we've laid out I just want to point one thing out. The notion of us having this is so that it can be applied universally not only for this project. So as Mr. Sobel was saying if they want to expand it or another group like our art center came forward and said oh we've got an idea we'll now have some criteria assuming you adopt it that will help guide that and keep it, you know, fairly safe.
I want to give kudos where they're deserved. Nicole was instrumental in putting this together and obviously researching other cities in the county in developing it so it's not really new criteria but it is new to us and we appreciate her work on it.
All right. All right. Motion to approve the utility box R project criteria requirements Being implemented in coordination and partnership with the Santa Paula Arte & Cultura Collective.
All right, second
Roll-call vote Moved by Pedro Chavez · Seconded by Leslie Cornejo
Show transcript
Good evening Mayor and City Council. Pleasure to be up here in front of you guys again to reintroduce myself. My name is Fabian Castellon. I'm an accountant here with our city's finance department. Today I'll be presenting agenda item 11c, transfer of unclaimed funds to the general fund. To begin, I wanted to give some background on the laws that give us authority to reclaim funds as well as define this term that you may be unfamiliar with.
Cheatment is the process by which unclaimed properties transferred to a government entity after a period of dormancy. The California Government Code sections noted above outline the procedures that must be taken in order to legally reclaim checks that have sat uncashed or dormant for over three years and I'll go over these procedures in the next slide. The first requirement is that unclaimed funds must have remained under city control for at least three years.
These were found by running an outstanding check register and filtering for any checks older than three years. The second requirement is to notify possible claimants, to give them the opportunity to file a claim on funds that the city is holding. This was done via a newspaper ad in the Santa Paula Times which was ran on two consecutive weeks starting on January 28th 2026 Claimants are given 45 days to file that deadline just passed on March 14th, 2026 this past Saturday.
After the 45 days have passed but no later than 60 days from the initial posting council may authorize transfer of the unclaimed monies to the general fund via resolution To give some insight as to the numbers involved, when the newspaper publication was posted there was a total of just over $62,000 in outstanding checks. A total of 24 claims were submitted.
However one claim was denied due to an administrative error that resulted in an approved claim total of approximately $24,500. This left a total more than $34,000 in unclaimed funds which could be sheeted through Resolution 7608. Oh sorry forgot to switch the slide my bad. Staff recommends that Council adopts Resolution 7608, allowing for the $34,590.84 of unclaimed funds be transferred to the General Fund.
While this item is not a goal or objective of the Council's two-year strategic plan, unclaimed funds will help supplement the General Fund with additional revenue to fund current and future projects. And I don't believe it was mentioned in the agenda, but there is an updated resolution as well as the exhibit. And that was due to a claim that was made between the creation of the staff report and the meeting today.
And with that, that concludes my presentation. I just wanted to open up the floor in case council has any questions for us.
All right. Thank you, Mr. Castillo. Anyone have any questions? Go ahead, Councilor Fernandez.
Normally a check has a lifespan, right? So do the banks have a 90-day now or what's our policy with terms of cashing checks?
I believe they automatically stale after 90 days but they can if say someone were to go to cash it and it bounces we can reissue so long as we can prove that they haven't cashed it before
And then, sorry. There's a lot of checks in here.
The last time we did this was back in 2019 so it's been quite awhile.
Is it tied to addresses? Do you think it's tied to addresses potentially people moving or what would... That's awfully a lot of checks for people not to catch.
Is the only requirement to do public notice in the newspaper or do they actually try to send letters or knock on doors?
I believe the only requirement is the public notification through the newspaper according to the ordinances noted on the presentation.
This is governed by state statute, the process is and you'll see from the list some of these checks date back to 2014 this is something we could have theoretically And the
plan is going forward that we will be doing it at the end of every fiscal year. That's what we should have been doing and what we will be doing going forward. Cool.
All right, well thank you for your work on this and staff.
Motion to adopt resolution 7608 as cheating monies to the city's general fund pursuant to government code 50053.
Including the amendment amount?
As
amended.
Yes, as amended. Okay.
I'll second.
Roll-call vote Moved by Pedro Chavez · Seconded by Gabby Ornelas
Show transcript
1:48 – 1:5213 turns
Yes.
Aye. Aye? Aye. Anyone opposed? Okay, passes thank you very much.
Thank you.
And now we
move on to item number 11 or I'm sorry 12 future agenda items and I think Mr. City Manager I think we have at least one.
We do. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, Council Member Chavez has submitted a request for council's consideration and let him briefly explain that.
Sure, it's pretty simple. You know we've gone through substantial growth in recent years and we have more coming. I'd like to ask that the mayor and connect with the city manager to potentially host a workshop to give us a vision of population growth and potentially impacts on roads and impacts on traffic as we're growing were starting to see things bottleneck.
And I think it'd be good to have like a larger vision over how that's all going to play out in like within 10 years, because that's when the all this expected population growth and it also ties into public safety. So I think it'd be great to hear from the police department, the community development department, the Public Works Department, because we want to have a big vision about What we expect and so I'm asking that the mayor consider putting an item on the agenda to do a workshop or study session. To kind of take that on, and wanted to get everyone's support on that.
How does the rest of the council feel?
I agree on a study session rather than regular agenda item, especially if you're going to have all the departments presenting or giving their input. It's kind of a lift because it can be a general opinion or it can be a very studied engineered response so that's what will have to be thought out as far as how you'd present it with staff but I think it's a good idea. There's a lot of issues coming up these days that we're hearing about.
And just to add to that, I keep looking at this wall I feel like we need to map out, okay this is when this is going to happen. This is when this is going to happen. How is that gonna create traffic flow or safety issues? Or even raise concerns about adding additional police officers for different parts of our city that are growing so I think it'd be great to have a bigger conversation on vision for the city between now and the next ten years what's gonna look like.
Well that also brings up the question well today at With the taxpayers of Ventura County Taxpayer Association, they discussed about Laminar Group working with the Caltrans. with the intersection out there. So we actually have a bigger concern and that's trying to include, you know, the state highway which goes through our city 126 or Highway 150. We can include them as well which again brings the subject of future traffic congestion once the bridge is finished because they're supposed to be improvements at 12th in Santa Paula and 10th in Santa Paula and we have all this work going on but it just seems like if there's gonna be future improvements You know, shouldn't somebody be talking with those developers that are going to do the future improvements?
Because it seems like they're repairing things but then is that going to change or they you know throwing good money after bad. So yeah I agree so we should and I think sooner than later Mr. Singer if we can just because these houses are going up and they're gonna be filled with people and cars and everything else so if we could work on that that'd be great
I would just point out you've got some pretty heavy calendars these next two to three months with study sessions and workshops on previous requests. So, I think this is a great idea and I agree we should make it multifaceted. June or July would be as soon as we could get to it unless the council's preference is that we postpone some of the study sessions that are anticipated on no smoking, or e-bikes, or a couple of other topics that we have coming up.
I think summer would be ideal.
Well just remember historically and even in our calendar July and August there's only one Council meeting per month so... Thank you very much.