UnGovr Transcript
iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.0:18 – 0:2829 turns
Roll call, called by Unidentified speaker 2
Show transcript
So this morning's moment of inspiration, we're
moving on to agenda item number four. I'd like to ask Anthony Linquada to kind of make his way toward the podium. Anthony good morning. This morning we have our moment of inspiration slash moment of perspiration because all the hard work that goes into our community and we're recognizing MANA, Conejo Valley Food Bank Manna began in 1971 when local residents came together around a simple belief that no one in the Conejo should go hungry. So please Anthony, thank you for being here this morning. Thank you for letting us recognize Marina and I'll turn it over to you.
I want to thank Ventura County Board of Supervisors for having me here today and allowing me a few minutes to go ahead and speak on behalf of Manna and behalf of food insecurity in Ventura County and specifically in the Conejo Valley As Supervisor Gural had stated, we were founded in 1971 on the belief that no one should go hungry in the Conejo Valley. And since 1971, we've been working extremely hard to go ahead and address that.
Last year, we served over 13,000 individuals just in the Conejo Valley. This year, we're gonna probably serve closer to 18,000 just in that area. And it's only gonna get worse. With the support of the community, we are able to go ahead and meet those needs. This year, we should probably go ahead and distribute roughly almost half a million pounds of food to those that need it in our area.
So with your continued support and the continued support of the community, we will be able to go ahead and meet that need. And I want to thank you all for having us here today.
Yeah, thank you, Anthony. And there's a short video I believe he brought with you?
I
did. We'd like to see that.
The Conejo Valley is 1,900 square miles of beautiful land and some of the most idyllic weather found anywhere in the world. As the fourth most affluent city of its size in the country it homes enough amenities to feed the lifestyles of the wealthy and influential. As an idyllic setting to live work and raise a family there's an ongoing hardship that is rarely brought to light and that is hunger
There remains a staggering number of hard-working residents who live amidst the incredible wealth of the Conejo Valley, yet struggle to make ends meet. In fact there are over 15,000 families who cannot provide their family with three meals a day.
Manna Conejo Valley Food Bank was founded in 1971 by a group of people who felt strongly that no person should ever go hungry in our community. Volunteers work alongside a team of board members, staff and a special needs workforce to make sure Manna's mission is carried out with dignity and compassion. For 50 years Manna's Food Bank has been a well-regarded model of success for hunger relief by providing food assistance to our local neighbors in need
However, MANA is supported entirely through private donations of food and funding. More than 96% of the food MANA collects and distributes each year is donated by organizations and individuals from around the Conejo Valley who want to put an end to hunger in our community.
With an eye towards the future and a desire to meet growing needs overseas, MANA's on a path to improve its operations in order to serve the growing population among us. Healthy food choices and access to resources can end a personal crisis and prevent homelessness.
Seniors, working moms, college students returning veterans and others. MANA will be here. MANA's mission is to provide dignity to those at a time when they need it most.
Won't you join us in making sure that all of our neighbors are able to enjoy the benefits of living this beautiful valley that we call home? Follow our social media and begin your call-to-action today I hope you can and I trust you will
Thank you. Thank you, Anthony. Let's give a round of applause for everything. Appreciate you being here and allowing us to recognize the great work you're doing in the community food insecurity is something that affects every corner of Ventura County and we appreciate your hard work So let's now
move on to agenda item number five that's the Agenda Review and Levine Act Disclosures. Levine Act Disclosures by any member of the Board of Supervisors? No, I'm hearing none and head shaking so we'll move on to Dr. Johnson would you walk us through please the Agenda Review
I'd be happy to. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Good morning Supervisors, staff and all in attendance today. The agenda review for October 6th 2026 is as follows. Item 11 Board of Supervisors recommendation of Supervisor Garrell to approve appointments and reappointments to the local planning council of Ventura County revised board letter has been submitted. Item 15 county executive office receiving filed list of ceremonial proclamations to be presented outside of a Board of Supervisors meeting in the months of September and October 2026. A proclamation recognizing Childhood Cancer Awareness Month and a revised Exhibit A have been submitted. Item 27, Resource Management Agency Environmental Health April 14, 2026 direction to the Environmental Health Division to review and modernize policies governing community events temporary food facilities mobile food facilities.
And event organizer permitting criteria request to hear this item as part of the regular agenda and one public comment letter has been submitted. Item 30 Sheriff's Office approval of the waiver of County of Ventura Administrative Policy Manual policy Item. 38 resource management agency and public works Division 13 of the Ventura County Ordinance Code regarding abatement of public nuisances and administrative penalties. One public comment letter has been submitted. Thank you, Mr. Chair. That concludes agenda review.
Yeah, thank you Dr. Johnson.
Agenda Discussionitems moved / continued / pulled, click to expand
Any questions on the agenda review? Any modifications? Seeing none, the clerk perhaps can frame the motion.
you. Thank you very much all right now we've got the consent agenda items 9 through 30 are there any
Roll-call vote Passed Moved by Janice S. Parvin · Seconded by Matt LaVere approve the agenda as modified has been
Show transcript
public comments on any of the agenda items for the
Thank you, there are no requests to speak for consent.
Okay thank you Supervisor Long.
Thank you I would like to have 27 pulled so that we can hear it
in
the regular agenda time frame.
Okay so there's a request to pull 27 any other requests by members of the board on the consent? Hearing none, I guess the motion would be here all approve all items on the consent other than 27 which should be pulled to the regular agenda and 30 has already been pulled. So that is so moved.
Roll-call vote Passed Moved by Janice S. Parvin · Seconded by Vianey Lopez approve items 9 through 26 28 and 29 has been
Show transcript
All right thank you. Minutes, minutes of the meeting meetings previous meetings any motion? Thank you everybody.
Item 7 motion to approve has been moved by Supervisor Parvin seconded by Supervisor Lopez please vote that passes unanimously thank
you all right we're cooking we're gonna
move on to agenda item number eight that's general public comments. Madam Clerk are there any general public comments?
Thank You Checker we currently have six speakers in our queue And just as a reminder to members of the public who wish to address the board today with public comment on any agenda item, please visit VenturaCounty.gov forward slash VOS comment for participation information and instructions. For in-person public comment please check in with the deputy clerk at the entrance of the boardroom If you wish to make comments, you must be in the boardroom or if you're participating remotely. You must be connected to the meeting via zoom or telephone before the close of the public comment period for that agenda item request to make public comments on any agenda item will be accepted until the public comment period for each agenda item is complete. For remote participants, please accept a prompt to be promoted and unmute your mic when it's your turn to speak.
And for all public comments the in-person speaker present in the boardroom will be called upon first followed by remote participants at the discretion of the chair general public comment regarding county related matters that are not listed on the agenda but are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board may be moved to the end of the meeting And our first speaker today is joining us in person, he's going to be Rick Cortez followed by Everett Woody and an anonymous member of the public. So Rick Cortez if you proceed to the podium you will have three minutes to give your comment.
Rick Cortez? Okay not seeing Rick Cortes do we have an Everett Woody? Everett Woody. Not seeing Everett Woody. So we have an anonymous member of the public who would like to address the board and then that will be followed by Tracy Cortez and Tim Taunton so we'll have our anonymous member of the public please come to the podium. And I believe she'll be using a voice translating device
0:28 – 0:369 turns
I appreciate County Board of Supervisors supported resolving setback matters according to Section 8106-5.11. Planning Division ought to comply with regulations regarding setback, however Jennifer Trunk borrow other reasons still requiring me to reapply for permits for the two previously approved covered porches. My two porches were legally constructed built in 1954.
With the residential bewheeling records dated July 9th, 1954 there were many records indicate that two enclosed porches are legally existed. Pursuant to Ventura County non-coastal zoning ordinance section 8111 minus 1.1.1 B4 permits may not be issued when a violation exists on the property Unless the zoning clearance is necessary for the abatement of the existing violation.
Department of Building and Planning Services issued a permit on July 1980, authorizing the construction of a bathroom addition at the property. The front porch and the side porch enclosed as part of the dwelling footprint is shown on the property site plans. At that time there were no violations exists on the property. This demonstrates that the two porches were legally constructed in 1954, otherwise the permit would not have been issued.
During September 2013 to June 2015 Planning Division and Building and Safety Division required me to demolish all unpermitted historic structures following the completion of the demolition. Inspected my property and confirmed all my property complied with regulations and met all requirements of Ventura County Government. There is a letter dated June 2015, confirmed that the property have obtained all permitted with no violations otherwise the violation cases would not have been closed.
On September 12, 2013 Planning Department and Building & Safety Department approved the restoration of the front porch to a covered porch. A handwritten annotation, Convert Back To Covered Porch directly constitute crucial evidence confirming that the porch had legally existed since 1954. There was a permitted description of work Demolition of Unpermitted 319SF Porch Conversion to Bedroom and Bathroom, returned to back-to-covered porch.
There is an over the counter standard plot plan, combination permit documents that legalize the bathroom including the existing covered front porch. There is a drawing represents the final revised plans for the property's demolition during September 2013 to June 2015 This drawing was received by Planning Department and Building and Safety Department on December 4th, 2014.
The drawing includes the two porches. If Jennifer trunk objects to permits issued by various departments she must file an appeal to county board.
Thank you for your comment.
Thank you. You can submit that in electronic format to the Board of Supervisors and to RMA thank
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you, okay so our next speaker is going to be Tracy Cortez followed by Tim Totten and then Eric Christian. So Tracy Cortes I see that um you've been promoted. You need to unmute your mic
Good morning Supervisors, my name is Tracy Cortez. The Planning Department's handling of ADU law has failed this board in two fundamental ways. The first procedurally, Ventura County began adopting ADU ordinances in 2017 however prior to 2023 HCD has no record of ever receiving an ADU ordinance for the required review. For six years the county imposed its local ADU rules on property owners without review by the state agency charged with determining compliance.
When the county submitted its adopted 2023 ordinance HCD reviewed it and formally identified 10 areas of non-compliance with state ADU law. The county corrected only 5 of those 10 items and claimed HCD concurrent. In June 2024 the county proceeded with a successor ordinance in which HCD just a month ago found 9 nine areas of non-compliance some involving the same issues HCD had previously identified. This is not one technical mistake it's a pattern and the county cannot say it wasn't warned Our documented history contains 24 separate notices and communications from us, our architect and our lawyers concerning these ADU problems as far back as 2020. We notified Franco Rosengren, Dave Ward, Kim Pearlhart, Ruchida Kodakia, Winston Wright, Rob Mullane, County Executive Staff, the Planning Commission and the Board of Supervisors.
County Council reviewed and put their stamp on these ordinances as well. We submitted applications letters legal citations HCD guidance HCD findings and exhibits We repeatedly asked for the legal authority supporting the county's interpretation. And in January 2023 HCD itself intervened in our case reviewed every basis the county had given for denying our ADU found every one of them non-compliant with state law and told the county that each issue required modification of its ordinance yet seven days later planning disregarded HCD's direction and presented the ordinance to you for approval without making those corrections. Today, the county website still says tell the public that and I quote in January 2025 HCD staff confirmed that the county's 2024 ADU ordinance for non coastal areas is in compliance with state ADU law.
This is not true. There are so many troubling parts to our experience first none of the staff seems willing to reconsider a position once made when provided with facts second there is no one to appeal to in a sincere manner We might get two or three minutes in open forum but what complicated issue can really be expressed in three minutes. Ventura County desperately needs a dedicated ombudsman. Thank you.
And thank you for your comment Tracey. Our next speaker is going to be Tim Totten followed by Eric Christensen and then we'll go back to some of our in-person participants. But Tim Totten I see that you've been promoted if you press the star 6 button you'll be able to unmute your mic and give your comment.
Yeah I'd just like to reiterate my objection to both the Axon Enterprise contracts which include the drone cameras, street light cameras and such and FLOC. And also in conjunction with the other item that's on the agenda I'll speak to later which is what I believe to be a consolidation of government power Those two things taken in light of our exit from COVID and how government performed during.
0:36 – 0:4715 turns
Hey Tim we're losing your audio.
By the way and I lobbied and protested for them to be open Because that's freedom. And what I saw from Ventura County Board of Supervisors was very upsetting, and to see them along with the sheriff looking to consolidate power and surveil people of Ventura should be alarming to everybody. It's so funny that serendipity which is the happy coincidence of things. I was wondering what I was gonna say today public comments It was this wonderful little parable that came up from a Chinese, or Taoist book.
And it says, A frog in a well cannot disgust the ocean because he is limited by the size of his well. And when I'm out talking and trying to drum up support against these things, I often wonder why people don't have the same view as I do. And I think I'm thankfully not a frog stuck in a well, and I can see beyond it. And I don't think enough people do. And I just wish more people were tuned in to the things that go on quietly at the Board of Supervisors and in our local government.
Thank you for your comments. Our next speaker is going to be Eric Christensen followed by Rick Cortez and then Eric Everett Woody. Eric Christensen, Christian I see that you've been promoted and you have your hand up if you unmute your mic you'll be able to give your comment.
Hello can you hear me?
Yes we can please proceed
Thank you, my name is Eric Kristen. I'm the executive director of the Coalition for Fair Employment and Construction. We are a 28 year old statewide organization that was formed by union and non-union construction firms solely to oppose discriminatory and wasteful project labor agreements like the one that you've included on your pilot project Fire Station 29 which just to remind you is still not open.
We look forward to seeing the results of that with regards to costs and local hire numbers when the job is finally completed Two days ago I sent you Lopez and Sons, one of the owners of Lopez and Sons located right up the road from you. One of the largest general contractors in the state minority-owned contractor explaining how project labor agreements openly discriminate against the 90% of the California construction workforce that's nonunion and how it steals money from workers and causes cost increases or such as in your case projects not to be built on time This shouldn't be a surprise to anybody. We warned you when we were fighting PLAs in Ventura County for more than 15 years, and only when you recently put it on this pilot project did you finally succumb to big labor special interest pressure.
But we warned you what PLAs would do. They never come in on time. They never come in on budget and they can't meet local hire needs because 90% of the California construction workforce chooses to wake up on a daily basis and work in a union-free environment instead of allowing the market to work. You've allowed big labor special interests to work We showed you what happened at Los Angeles Community College District, whose PLA was such a disaster. There was a seven-part series run in the LA Times pointing to the lack of quality of work and the money that was stolen and the projects that weren't done on time. More recently, Prop HHH which was a affordable housing bond quote unquote had a PLA placed on it on that billion dollar bond. The medium price of every home that's being built is over a million dollars because 40% was added to the construction of these projects thanks to the PLA and half of them are being built that were planned, only half because they don't have the money for the rest.
That's what project labor agreements do if a dysfunctional incompetently run corrupt city like Los Angeles is who you wish to emulate PLAs are great for you. But if Ventura wants to represent Ventura workers, Ventura apprentices and Ventura contractors as well as Ventura County taxpayers project labor agreements have no place as far Station 29 continues to prove every day. Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your comment Eric. Our next speaker is going to be Rick Cortez followed by Everett Woody and Joseph Dubinsky. Rick Cortez I see that you are on Zoom please unmute your mic and proceed with your comment.
Can you hear me now.
We can please proceed
in the musical Hamilton Lin-Manuel Miranda wrote a song entitled The Room Where It Happens Here are some lines the room where it happened no one really knows how the game is played the art of the trade how the sausage gets made we just assume it happens but no one else is in the room when it happens for six and a half years the Cortez's have told RMA that its administrative California 80 law was incorrect We have said it in applications and in letters and in meetings. Our architect has said our attorneys and consultants have said that we have raised the issue with planning staff planning leadership RMA leadership Planning Commission on the board again and again we are told in one form or another that Ventura County was correct and we were incorrect As you know, California's HCD is the state authority that reviews ADU ordinance for consistency with state law.
On August 26th 2026 HCD issued its formal findings on Ventura County's ADU ordinance HCD's conclusion, the Ventura County Ordinance does not comply with ADU state law. HCD found inconsistency with state law. This means that the Cortezes have been correct for six and a half years and the planning department is incorrect. Distressingly they've been enforcing their poorly contrived notions on the public despite being warned for six and a half years and they have blocked citizens' rights.
This means that all the meetings committee outreach presentations, the planning commission hearing to vote. The Board of Supervisors meeting a vote brochures and the website are all incorrect. So going back to Mr Miranda song. Who is in the room when it happened? When our three ADU submittal packages were denied, when all of our projects approval processes were sandbagged with purposeful nonsense. Who's in the room when the decision was made to reinterpret ADU state law, correct valuable county resources to produce a confusing and incorrect model? Who is in the room when they impose their opinions and beliefs onto the board by curating the information that this board receives?
The people in that room know the Board of Supervisors and Planning Commission are only as good as the information given to them. The people in that room know that the real policymakers may be the real policy makers by mixing some facts with strong perspective, the conclusions advice and suggestions they develop are not neutral. The people in that room have power that is achieved by weaponizing some words while omitting others.
In our experience they've even added words to create a sense of reasonableness So comfortable with this template that took on a power much greater than themselves, the state of California. And now they know what it feels like not to be in the room when it happens. The board must hire a third party ombudsman or consultant who is impartial to the facts because for six and a half years our right to improve our property under law has been held hostage by the planning department.
So what is this board going to do about it?
Thank you for your comment. Our next speaker is going to be Everett Woody, followed by Joseph Dubczynski. So Everett, are you here? Thank you.
Good morning members of the board. My name is Everett Woody with Angelique DiCobolo Architects and Planners. I'm here today to discuss the Billy Wack Ranch project. The project started as a code enforcement case back in, I would say March of 2019. And we submitted the project in June of 2019. Anyone who has ever taken a new project to the planning department or the planning desk understands one thing. The very first thing that the planners do is they look up the permit history on the property. Very first thing.
For our property, there was no permit history. So what we did is we provided staff with a comprehensive project historical report outlining all the uses of all the buildings over 100 years and that was accepted by planning. It was also accepted by multiple people in the room where we reviewed that report with cultural heritage, with planning and zoning, with building and safety and so forth, and everybody agreed okay the project was allowed to move forward. We even had a staff recommendation to approve the project at the cultural historic board hearing.
Six months later we were, the project was denied for lack of permit history which was known on day one And we just asked the simple question, if the lack of permits history disqualified this project. Why did the county allow it to proceed in the first place? And that's an important distinction over $1 million was spent repairing one of those buildings on the premise that we could proceed with the project and that all the uses were approved and understood when we submitted them.
And why did the county accept the property history report documenting approximately 100 years of building uses if that evidence was not going to be recognized? During multiple planning commission hearing during one Planning Commission hearing and one BOS hearing here in this room, Staff made us look like we had no direction with our applications because we just kept spitting applications out using the state law to find one pathway for our project.
And each time, we asked staff as they denied each project what is your citation? We gave them citations And they never responded to any of our citations. Hey, if you have a different interpretation, tell us what that interpretation is. We're happy to listen but we never received any of that. Anyway, after reading the report from HCD a lot of those comments that HCD made to staff in that letter were the foundations of our submittals.
Thank you very much. Our next speaker is going
to be Joseph
Dovzinski Jr.
0:47 – 1:024 turns
Good morning, my name is Joseph Dubczynski Jr. I am a resident of Camarillo. I'm also the 805 UndocuFund Rapid Response Organizer for Ventura County. Yesterday, a surge has begun within the 805 area code starting with 17 kidnappings yesterday in Santa Maria. 11 different vehicles were out this morning in Ventura County and we've been tracking those. As of the 4th, that brings us to 2,822 abductions within the 805 Area Code. 1,304 of which are in Ventura County.
These incidents have included an incident in Moorpark off Walnut Canyon where ICE decided to liquidate an entire house and make everybody watch him as they took two people into custody and then told them to go back inside. This included a series of car accidents on Patricia and Simi Valley in which two parked cars were hit and two moving cars were hit by ICE agents.
And frankly all the activity that's happening over in the Ventura County Government Center jail lobby, whether that's SB 54 transfers happening behind the gates or somehow the ICE agents know to the minute when they can go into the lobby and grab somebody who is undocumented. We really have to ask ourselves how is that possible? This search is going to be much like last year and it's going to be awful. So we're asking everybody if you can get involved, please do so if you see any ice activity that's out there, please call the hotlines. You can call 805 undocufund at 805-870-8855 and you can call VC defense at 805 296 1119 unlike local law enforcement. We will get a rapid responder out there verify if it's ice and alert the community as needed How safe do you think people think they are coming here to the Ventura County Government Center?
This is a question that we've been trying to answer over the last three weeks. We catch ICE vehicles lurking within the lots here on a regular basis. I-Lot is where a Silver Ford Explorer likes to hang out, H-LOT is where a black Chevy Tahoe likes to hang out and multiple other vehicles love to hang out on Tillian Hill and also in D&E Lots. This shouldn't be the case. The state found a very good reason not to allow ice to use their lots for state property because they know it creates an unsafe environment. I am asking, I am in fact begging the county to do something just as we asked a year ago for you to limit the activity and the access of ice So once again a surge is starting.
17 people in Santa Maria yesterday, probably many more coming and a lot of activity today. We're still catching up on the 10 reports that we've had today and I'll be back on October 20th with the truth act form and for this supervisors meeting and will be expecting answers. Thank you very much.
Thank you for your comment. Chair Gorrell, that concludes the public comment for this item thank you.
Thank You Madam Clerk for those who spoke today and particularly those that were cut short in their remarks you're welcome to submit any documents to the Board of Supervisors and we'll read them and I appreciate that so thank you. I'm gonna now move back to Item 27 that was pulled from the consent agenda and that's a receiving file report by RMA Charles Gankel available?
Good morning. Good morning Supervisor Garrell, board members, Dr. Sylvette Johnson I'm Charles Genkel and the county's Environmental Health Division Director. I am director of the Environmental Health Division that does a variety of programs throughout the county one of our largest programs is our consumer food protection program and probably one of the most challenging programs we have as far as expediting permitting is our community events program so thank you for pulling this item from the agenda And give me the opportunity to speak on this today. I think I'm glad to be before you to present what we've changed and what we're doing moving forward back in April, your board directed me to evaluate certain permitting conditions that were associated with a prior direction that was issued in 2013 by the previous board.
Things have changed obviously technology has changed. We've had the opportunity to go over a decade plus of of community events that we've evaluated and processed. And so it's given us an opportunity to make some obvious changes to our program. So Okay, so the first thing that was brought to our attention related to this policy was focusing on how we evaluated events within our county.
Initially in 2013, we thought we would go through a process of pre-screening applications and using nonprofit status and and public location as a pre-screening to prequalify events as a community event. This time around we are taking that off the table and we're solely focusing on the community event definition that's in the health and safety code And that sole discretion will be within our division. And primarily the community event definition in the Health and Safety Code focuses on what is civic, political, public or educational in nature.
And of course it includes any other event that I would deem considered a public event. The nonprofit status is completely removed, whether you're for profit or nonprofit. That doesn't matter we're going to solely focus on this definition. In addition, we do have some prequalifiers that we wanted to put up front with the community. You know any event that we prior approved as a community event is still considered an event. The majority of the events that we receive annually are repeat events so if it's a new event that's coming in we would have to evaluate it based on the definitions merit. We do see however that any grand opening store giveaway or any other event I have solely bolded and underlined there because that wasn't part of your board letter, but I wanted to speak to the intent of this.
So any other event that is solely designed to increase celebrate or promote for a more for profit commercial business is not a community event. We wanted just to distinguish that because we feel very strongly If you're coming in and you're solely for that purpose of a benefit of the business, that really isn't the community event. However we did provide an on ramp. And so just like before when we would bring this to the attention of a local official whether it's city or county, we would allow for some form of notification that they would deem that event a community event.
With the prior process, we required a resolution or proclamation from a board and that became cumbersome. And we recognize that was cumbersome for us too is a process that we really didn't appreciate so we made it a little bit easier. We developed an attestation form or to allow a public official to just email us to confirm that they indeed feel like that event is a community event and we would go ahead and process it as such. We feel like that's an easier process, it would allow this board if they want to approve an event they just fill out the attestation email to us and it wouldn't have to go to the board and be heard at a regular meeting.
Implementation time frame for this upon boards approval soon as that's approved we can get started on that process and I think that was a great change Modernizing and streamlining the permit process by transitioning from paper-based applications to online platform. This one's a little more challenging for me, we are currently going through in our division a database transition and this is why I mentioned that we do a variety of other programs within the county that database transitions gonna be for not only our food program but our recreational health program or hazmat program And it's a significant, if you've gone through that process, it's a significant lift. And so we are working through that process right now. It does come with the portal system.
That portal system, we are hoping to have a better exchange with the public and the business operators in our community. And with that, like our other programs, we're hoping for electronic plan submittal to go forward with this program. Now I have to preface that by saying we're not sure how that's going to apply or work. So we want to do a pilot study with smaller events possibly one to five temporary food facilities at each event with with that process. I think it's really important to just consider the idea if we don't go forward with these changes.
If we take on, let's say an event like the Strawberry Festival that might be too cumbersome administratively so our focus is to try a pilot see if that works. We have received feedback from local businesses and other operators that have expressed a desire to continue to submit the full package to our counter without doing this electronically. So we want to maintain that front counter service as we move forward.
As far as time frames to implement that, we are estimating that we would go live effective December 2026. That depends on our software vendor and how well we coordinate with them potentially could move into the first quarter of next year as well. The electronic submittal for the pilot project will start estimated probably April of 2027. Develop the enhanced standardized education and training requirements. So one thing we've done as we're in the process of developing video, we have our first two videos that are in production right now. One is called what is a community event and what to expect during an inspection?
Our goal right here is to go through The current training material which is usually a three hour training course throw it into training videos and other resources so that the community can easily have access to that information. Identify certain key elements like hey I'm just an organizer so I just want to learn about how what the organizers role is. A food facility that prepares food. I want to know exactly what my requirements are, so we'll be evaluating those as well as your typical risk factors associated with foodborne illness and operation of a stand.
Our estimated completion time frame for that would be spring of 2027 Evaluate and return recommendations to allow for mobile food facilities to be licensed and to be licensed. And so the key here is that we've had a lot of requests to allow other mobile food facility permits That are coming from other counties to operate and within our community events here in Ventura County. And so we developed a process that would allow for, let's say Los Angeles or Santa Barbara County food vendors to come in provided they have an existing permit.
We would go ahead and confirm that they have a permit, request a copy of the most current inspection report record to verify that there's no outstanding conditions or issues. And we would go ahead and issue a temporary permit for the community event that they're operating at. I think that's a welcome change other jurisdictions that we communicate with San Diego LA County, they have a process in place for this and we're happy to make that change as well.
That could be effective this January 1st. We need to update our fee schedules within the board and so by the time we get our fee schedules updated, we'll have a target date of this January 1st to immediately start allowing mobile food facilities from other counties to participate within our county. Part of this change allowed us to reevaluate You know, the process since we're eliminating the nonprofit status from the community event here and we're focused on training. What we wanted to do was look at our fee schedule and over the years we every year we usually waive about eighty five thousand dollars in fees associated with community events. And this is tied to people who have nonprofit status.
So what we did with the training enhancements And the change to not reviewing nonprofit status. We've eliminated the requirement for nonprofits to go through the training process, and I think that's a welcoming changes another hurdle that they had to get through to go through the process of becoming a nonprofit and getting a permit and getting a fee waiver. So what we're proposing this round is to eliminate the fee waiver status for nonprofit organizations And now offer just a 25% discount. The fee table up there represents the discount associated with the various fees within our programs, so you have a temporary food facility.
You'll see type ones and type two temporary food facilities that type one is typically someone that would prepare a lot of food at an event they would Require additional resources like handwashing, utensil washing and a type two TFF is someone who would probably have pre-packaged non potentially hazardous foods or foods that don't spoil and little easier to evaluate.
The new fee categories on the bottom it speaks to the temporary mobile food facility permit that we would be issuing for those facilities that will be coming in from another county Moving forward with the recommendations. We just ask that you receive and file this report, rescind the May 14th 2013 board letter on the criteria associated with community events and authorize us to go ahead and permit the changes as we move forward. And then we can return to your board with the revision to update the 25% fee discount.
1:02 – 1:1219 turns
Thank you any questions from the board.
Yes, I have some questions appreciate it thank you first of all when you stated in the first slide it was about business open you know ribbon cuttings and that kind of thing and having to have a permit for those are usually hosted by a chamber which is a 5013 C does that then state that it is a nonprofit that is running that event for a business opening welcoming them into the community I figured I have to ask because we're creating policy and I want to make sure we are straightforward.
Yeah, so we're going to be reviewing those applications based on the merit of the health and safety code definition. So the fee discount that we're proposing the 25% yeah you have to be a 5013 C. You have to verify we have to verify that there are 5 0 1 3 3 C and they could get that 25% discount. I guess to answer your question is we really do focus on that. If you've had a situation where we've looked at prior events, we look at the type of event, is it community based? Is educational-based civic importance?
We'll evaluate it based on that merit.
Okay and how long does this evaluation take? What we're used to having done, I want to set expectations.
Well I think the expectation moving forward is probably going to ask more questions up front you know what's your event? What's the title of the event? Why is it a civic political education importance that was actually what we did prior to 2013 but when went to the board at that point they wanted we wanted to provide some pre-screening elements so since we're no longer prescreening based on the nonprofit status were now solely looking That evaluation so we probably will ask questions up front like you know what is your the intent of your event.
You know why is it a civic political or educational importance.
And I understand that. I'm trying to understand the calls that we get from our office in regards to, oh my gosh, we forgot. We have to do this form right now and our events tomorrow. Can we get a resolution? Can we get things moving? And so it's a new person because maybe some volunteer didn't do this job last year and they're doing it this year and they just got told that they have to do a permit and that their event might get canceled.
I appreciate that comment. I know
that the idea.
Yeah, well it's a very common thing especially for you know someone that comes in someone else may have submitted the paperwork prior year for that same event and so they're new to it so we really try and guide them through that process. We do ask that we the applications are submitted 30 days 30 days in advance. And so we receive that information, it allows us to process those applications work with the organizer to ensure that they have all the paperwork, the fees are paid and that we can approve their event.
Now if there's a situation where There is a delay. We can certainly work with the operator, you know once it gets into two weeks prior to the event it gets very challenging for us to expedite those process those permits we process about 200 events annually and we have one person that processes those and those events are solely those events that have a temporary food facility associated. It doesn't include all the mobile food facilities That like you have mobile food facility events only which we don't inspect, but we still review.
And lastly I'll just add that we have about probably over a thousand permits that we issue annually for this program so.
Okay because when you showed I really appreciated the fee schedule and if you can go back to that for a second. Sure. Oops. Sorry, but I think it's important to just show it. Many times these values feel very nominal when you're talking about an event, but if you're $250 for a ribbon cutting of an event that you're trying to put on to just get people to come to the event, it's like oh maybe we don't need to do it And so I'm trying not to squash our nonprofits in what they're doing. And so is trying to figure out like, Is this even reasonable?
Before we waive the fee, I understand that as taxpayer dollars and that there's a process and everything. So I wanted to look through this and say okay, My thought 25% where do we get that? So we're just giving you a 25% discount versus a 50% discount or a 75 right now. We're at 100 and so I wanted to get an understanding of that because now we're setting expectations of you have to submit permits 30 days in advance You have all these things so I'm if someone comes to me and goes Kelly we're scratching we just got cuts tons of funding and we're just hoping that the county could waive this permit fee. Why are you now charging us? I need to make sure that there's value to that, and I'd love to have that explanation.
Sure. The there's a there's a few things so obviously that I mentioned the portal system earlier, the electronic portal system that does cost money to develop. We're enhancing our training with the training videos that does take staffing along with the electronic plan check that does require additional administrative staff to do that. So we're anticipating putting more staff to process those applications We've from our experience, especially with electronic plan submittal throughout all of our programs. We think okay there is a convenience there especially for the community or the business that wants to submit that application.
It tends to be more cumbersome on our end so that additional administrative staff would likely be needed under that circumstance. So the last thing that we're trying to encourage because You know, it's important for us to be out in the community. We're hoping that that could increase our inspection our awareness out doing inspections at some of these community events in the past nonprofits have been at a lower priority primarily because they had a training requirement. They were mandated to go through this training process now that they're no longer required to go through that training process You'll see us out there doing inspections at some of those nonprofit organizations. The 25% was a number we came up with based on those changes that we would have, but again, we've been operating with a full fee waiver for decades now so wanted to bring this to the attention of the board.
Our program is mandated to be fee offset as well, so that becomes challenging to meet that without charging.
So this would be kicked off in January of 2027 is what I heard. And how will those that have submitted or received fee waived be notified of these changes?
Right, well our plan is obviously to update our website as number one if this is approved by your board today we would update our website with the changes we anticipate We do have all the contact information from all our event organizers. Not only are we going to bring that 25% fee waiver to everybody's attention, but all the changes that are associated with what I represented in this board meeting so We will be reaching out to the organizers and having a scheduled meeting and presentation for those organizers and vendors.
In addition, we currently have monthly training that's associated with these events that we continue to do. And that'll also be presented during that online or that monthly training to community.
Okay, I appreciate it. Thank you very much. I just think it's really important that we're transparent on this. Our nonprofits are getting squashed even more but yet the county is getting squashed anymore. I can't say I can't cut one area and not cut another area we have to have fairness but I really do think that people need to understand where this is coming from and why we're talking about it so I appreciate it being pulled from the consent calendar.
Thank you.
Supervisor Parvin. I want to thank your department for bringing this back to us, you responded to every question that we had when we brought it forward having a permit myself. I have gone through the whole process my staff some of my staff members have too and that's why we realize what a difference it's going to make for people. It's gonna be much more streamlined exactly what our goal is And I'm looking forward to the implementation.
So thank you very much and to all the people in your department, and I'm sure with the new software there will be a lot of hair pulling. But it's a good move on our part, and I think it's good for our future and for our nonprofits. So thank you very much.
Appreciate the support. Thank you.
Madam Clerk are there any speaker cards on this?
I think you're correct. There are no requests to speak.
Okay, thank you. If there are no other questions is there a motion to adopt or adopt the recommendations?
Roll-call vote Passed Moved by Kelly Long · Seconded by Vianey Lopez approve staff recommended actions as
Show transcript
1:13 – 1:214 turns
you.
Thank you. I'm sorry we're running a little bit behind this morning and I appreciate everyone's patience but we're going to go to time certain 9 AM agenda items starting with number 31 which is a presentation by Supervisor Lopez if you're ready. We can proceed.
Thank you, Chair. Happy to kick off today's proclamations with recognizing the second Monday of October as Indigenous Peoples Day in Ventura County and as we all know the Chumash are the first residents stewards and original caretakers of the Ventura County region And today I have the great honor of presenting this proclamation to Dana Barrios, who has dedicated over a decade of hands-on experience supporting Native communities across California Spearheading critical grassroots initiatives focused on suicide prevention, domestic violence, behavioral health and critical resource access. So I'm not going to go into detail of what she has done. I'd rather give her the opportunity to share about her work and her contributions to our community as we recognize Indigenous Peoples Day this year.
Thank you Haku, good morning. I first want to thank the Board of Supervisors and specifically Supervisor Lopez for this recognition today. These are the moments that caused me to pause and reflect on the work that I've done where most days I just put one foot in front of the other and keep going. I don't often stop to think about how far I've come For those that knew me when I was younger, they probably wouldn't recognize the person standing here today.
I grew up on the avenue with my mom and my teens and early 20s were difficult for me. I struggled with addiction for many years and went to a continuation school And there was a time I wasn't sure I would graduate from high school, let alone get my master's degree. But here we are more than 20 years later and I'm standing before you accepting the proclamation.
But I didn't get here alone. Sometimes people call me self-made but I consider myself community made Yes, there was probably some sheer stubbornness involved but I am here because people believed in me. They supported me, taught me, challenged me and gave me the opportunities to grow. And when we talk about California Native People the idea of community is incredibly important Here in Ventura County we are standing on Chumash homelands, lands of our people have lived on for over 13,000 years.
Long before there was a Ventura County State of California or the United States, our ancestors were already here. They built communities, governed themselves, traded across vast distances, cared for the land and sea and traveled between the mainland and our island in our wooden plank tamals. Then beginning in 1769 everything began to change. The Spanish mission system is often taught through images of these beautiful buildings and bells agriculture and conversion but for California native people the reality was devastating it was genocide Native people were removed from their villages and brought into a system where their movement, labor, family life, culture and religious practices were controlled.
People were subjected to forced labor and physical punishment while disease and living conditions contributed to catastrophic loss of life. Across California upwards of 70,000 Native people died during the mission era. Children were especially vulnerable among the Chumash some estimates suggest that by the end of the mission period approximately 900 out of every 1,000 children born within the missions died before reaching the age of 8 and that history happened right here Mission San Buenaventura was established in 1782 in the heart of Chumash Territory. During the mission era, approximately 3,875 people were baptized there while approximately 3150 burials were also recorded there.
Those numbers represent mothers and fathers, children, elders, knowledge keepers, language speakers entire families and communities experiencing enormous loss only within a few generations. And still Chumash people survived. We often talk about historical and intergenerational trauma. It is the understanding that when a community experiences generations of violence, family separation, loss of land and suppression of language and culture the impacts do not simply disappear when those policies end they carry forward across generations affecting families and communities But I think it is equally important to talk about intergenerational strength. Our ancestors didn't only pass down trauma, they passed down survival. They passed down culture, knowledge, humor, responsibility, love and the determination to keep going.
And if you look around this room today, you will see some of the people carrying that work forward every single day. Our local tribal TANF program led by Magdalena Rodriguez and Sierra Gambala supports Native families throughout Ventura County through services cultural activities and opportunities to reconnect with community and culture. You have Alan Salazar who has spent decades teaching children throughout this entire county, who our people are through storytelling. And he helped guide us in bringing tamols or plank canoes back to the community and just a plug we're building the first female woman's tamol that has been built here since prior to the mission system so keep an eye out for that one.
You have strong Native women like Eleanor Fishburne, Julie Tumamite Stensley who advocate every single day for our people and they have been for over three decades. It's important that you know who we are. It's important to understand our history because it explains why we fight so hard to keep our workers alive and our communities intact, and the work is becoming harder. The cost of living is driving many of our people away from our homelands. Families struggle to afford rent and put food on the table. Our communities continue to experience fear and instability as immigration enforcement impacts Brown families throughout this county.
And after thousands upon thousands of years, we are still fighting to be seen. We should not have to fight this hard yet we do every single day. So I accept this proclamation today and I hope Indigenous Peoples Day can be more than a moment of recognition. I hope it can be a commitment. A commitment to building meaningful relationships with the Chumash people whose homelands you serve.
A commitment to protecting our cultural resources, our sacred places, our ancestors and the lands and waters to which our people have maintained relationships with since time immemorial. And please remember us beyond Indigenous Peoples Day Native American Heritage Month Invite us into the rooms where decisions are being made. Hire Native people, contract with Native organizations, support our youth and build genuine relationships with the people who have cared for this land for tens of thousands of years because acknowledgement is important but acknowledgement should lead to relationship. Relationship should lead to action and action should lead to change I began today by telling you that I am not self-made, but I'm community made.
Everything I have accomplished is because a community wrapped around me believed that I was worth investing in and gave me the opportunity to become the person standing before you today. Imagine what becomes possible when we make the same investment in our native communities Our history is not only a story of what was taken from us, it's the story of what survived. We survived, our culture survived, our community survived and we are still here. Thank you.
1:21 – 1:336 turns
Thank you, Dana for providing those wonderful words and the reminder that as we are in the present, as we look towards the future it is important to recognize and remember the history and how we can continue to do better in our community. So thank you for establishing that relationship for the work that you do throughout our entire community to continue to build on that so with that chair we have a proclamation if we can step down and do a photo and please invite anyone else to join you your family and anyone else who is with you here
All right, thank you Supervisor Lopez. Thank you Dana and everyone who came for being so patient we're going to
move to agenda item number 32 presentation by Supervisor Long
Thank you very much. It's been a privilege to be bringing this back to us every year and today we are recognizing October 26, 2026 as Breast Cancer Awareness Month for Ventura County. It is a time to raise awareness, encourage early detection and support those who live through the impact of breast cancer. And I just want to say being on the Ventura County Medical Oversight And really, our support of mammograms and how important prevention is. Not waiting till the end but preventing things is just so important. And so this year also marks the 42nd year of National Breast Care Awareness Month and while significant progress still is being made early detection remains crucial and regular mammograms is an important tool to detect breast cancer at an earlier more treatable stage.
And I would like to welcome Betsy Watson and Carnell Smith, organizers of the Ventura County Breast Cancer Walk along with Dr. Watabe was going to be here but she's sick and she's our chief medical officer of Ventura County Medical Center but we are very fortunate to have Dr. Danielle Gable our CEO of VCMC and Santa Paula Hospital here as well So I just want to say that their work reflects the importance of bringing our community together to support patients, survivors, families, caregivers.
These are our moms, our daughters, our aunts, our friends. And through the awareness, education, early detection and community support we can ensure that everyone affected by breast cancer feels seen, supported and connected. And remind our community that no one has to face this journey alone. So first off we have Betsy and Carnell thank you let's start with you guys.
Well, thank you so much members of the board and for Supervisor Long for having us here today. We really appreciate it. My name is Betsy Watson and this is Sharnell Smith and we are both breast cancer survivors and founders of the Ventura Breast Cancer Walk. I have a PowerPoint let me get myself organized here. We're grateful to be here during Breast Cancer Awareness Month just as you spoke to the prevention, the continued support that people need going through this families caregivers. It's not just the people that are going through their journey it's also the people that are there supporting them and so we really wanted to bring together the community and so last year I'm going to actually before I get ahead of myself, I had to have notes so that I wouldn't get ahead of myself.
Because it really is about detection and so I found a stat the stats seemed a little bit low to me but it does come from a state website around Ventura County numbers. What came to my attention a couple years ago is that men are also impacted by breast cancer. My sister-in-law's dad passed away from breast cancer, and I had never even known that was something. It makes sense when you think about it, but it's not something that is really talked about. And so, I wanted to make sure that we are also bringing that together and that's part of our walk purpose as well is just that awareness, and it's not just about women, it's about everybody, and that anybody can be involved in having breast cancer.
All right, so our story. So I am a lifelong social worker and so community work and connection is what I'm all about how we can connect people to resources and Sharnell have known and I have known each other for a lot of years through triathlon the gosh I met like in 2012 and we reconnected through my breast cancer journey And then I've also been a support for her as she goes through her journey, as well. And so last summer she mentioned to me that she's always wanted to have a walk. She is part of Aloha Steakhouse in Ventura and also very much part of the community. And so I have volunteered at a lot of events in my life and I said, well let's just do it. I called her the next day and said let's do it! And so in three months we put together our walk And had some amazing resources and the community really came together to support us.
So, what we were able to accomplish last year is we had shockingly, we were hoping 50 people would show up and we had almost 500 people come to our event which was amazing. We are purpose for our event is to give money directly back to Ventura County residents and so we had four recipients last year, and we were able to give each of them $2500 after our walk. And we also had a bunch of gift cards in different things that we had received from the community. So we had a beautiful luncheon couple weeks after the walk was held and brought them together and just really celebrated their journey and got to hear more about The money that they were using for what they were going through. We also had eight vendors come, we had 10 sponsors that helped us make our event happen.
I also want to add, too, that my family and my friends always really enjoy when I have great ideas because they end up coming along on the journey with me and fly across the country to be here to support us. And so that's going to happen again this year. So it's just an amazing thing we've been able to do. So this year is our second annual walk and it's on Sunday, October 18th. You can see some details up here what the check-in we have the mayor of Ventura is coming another city council members coming.
We also have the bagpipes are going to come Charnel son as part of the fire department so they come and open up the ceremony. So it's gonna be a lot of fun And really with my biggest, well my goal is the community piece bringing people together but also this year I've really focused on who our vendors are. We have an amazing group of vendors that are coming to support community memorial hospitals coming they have a cancer center Public health is coming.
We have a bunch of different, I'm going to show I think in a minute here on one of the slides our other vendors but we have a lot of resources that are coming that people can talk to while they're there and just want to bring all that together and allow people a space to have some of these conversations. And also, as we learned last year just the connection and people had fun at the walk. We just heard so many amazing stories and Sharnell actually did the walk with people last year and was kind of the cheerleader and just walked with people and talked with people.
It was really neat to hear what everybody's going through, right? So... Got ahead of myself here. So, today we're asking the board and really our entire Ventura County community to do four simple things. Recognize, attend, share and support. Recognize October as Breast Cancer Awareness Month. Join us on October 18th. Help us share information about The Walk and the breast cancer resources available in our community. And continue to standing with the patients, survivors, caregivers and families whose lives have been touched by this disease.
Support can look different for everyone. Sometimes it's financial. Sometimes it's connecting someone with a resource. Sometimes it's checking on a friend who's going through treatment. I had cancer during COVID and so I wasn't around any be able to be around anybody. I had friends that would come sit out in the hallway of my apartment and we would have get togethers and that meant the world to me because I was even more isolated going through And also.
And I will say if I can go back, I was so excited to have Oxnard PD come with their pink car last year that was like one of my big things that I wanted. I've worked with Oxnard PD in my social work career a lot and so it was great to have them there and bring their bring their car with them. And once again, we have our partners that we really want to thank. Paradise Chevrolet and Ventura is our presenting premier sponsor this year and has just been super supportive of what we're doing and really jumped in and said whatever we can do to support you they want to do. And then you can see some of our other vendors and community partners that are going to be there with us this year. So thank you very much for this year's Breast Cancer Awareness Proclamation.
We're very honored to be here and I appreciate you all.
Thank you very much. And I share this with Supervisor LaVere, it is in his district. But the reason why I wanted to bring this great organization together is there are so many organizations that are in Ventura County supporting and celebrating women and men who have survived and who have gone through this. And I think it's so important. I have I have flamingos on my yard right now for rolling for pink because I got flocked Good morning, everybody. Thank you, Supervisors. Thank you, Supervisor Long and
1:33 – 1:372 turns
Dr. Johnson, I'm thrilled to be here to talk about our new Breast Center. I will show the slides in a second but I had prepared a couple words at the last minute when Dr. Watabe wasn't able to make it and I'm really here to represent the incredible work that she and our hospital team have done to get the breast center up and running. My name is Danielle Gable. I am the CEO of VCMC in Santa Paula Hospital.
Before I led this organization, I started my career as a registered nurse at the bedside. I cared for women through some of the hardest and most hopeful moments of their lives. Many were facing breast cancer diagnoses. I've walked alongside patients and I've walked alongside friends through biopsies treatment and survival. And that experience shapes how I lead the hospitals every day.
I'm also here as a patient, I'm a previvor. For those of you who don't know what that is, I have the BRCA1 gene that increases the risk of breast cancer from 13 to 72%. For women like me early mammograms are so critical. Here's what makes breast cancer different from so many other cancers. It's the most common malignancy affecting women, but caught early it's also one of the most treatable.
Early detection saves lives and that depends on every woman regardless of income, language or zip code having real access to screening. That's what equity in health care means to us it means the women of Ventura County get the same shot at early detection no matter who they are or where they are from That's why I'm excited to introduce our new Breast Health Center. We have expanded access, advanced care and a healthier community built around a few key upgrades.
We now have state-of-the-art imaging with better detection, including for in dense breast tissue. Expanded hours so that our mammogram screenings fit into busy caregiving filled lives and we have smarter scheduling. We're actively rolling out new technology to cut wait times and make booking easier and that work is ongoing today. We also have dedicated new spaces for waiting consultation and ultrasound care All of this reflects our mission, caring for the women who care for everyone else. In my years as a nurse and now as the CEO I've seen it again and again. Women show up for their families, their jobs, their communities and they put themselves last. Our commitment as an organization is to make screening as easy and comfortable as possible so this community gets the early detection that saves lives.
I'll just show the slides really briefly. You can see Supervisor Lopez here when we did our ribbon cutting over at our brand new Breast Center a couple months ago, you can go to the next slide. Oh, I can go to the next slide huh? I knew that too. All right so here's just a picture of our new mammogram. I've talked about all of the expanded hours and the streamlined scheduling And here are some screenshots. You can see on the bottom right is our brand new waiting room and up on the top is what that beautiful hallway by our new Breast Center looks like. So with that, I want to close with gratitude. Thank you to the Healthcare Foundation for Ventura County, to Gold Coast Health Plan and to everyone at VCMC who banded together to make this center possible.
It's one more step towards serving our community. Thank you.
Thank you very much. So with that, if you could all join me down for photos I'd like to have everyone come in.
1:39 – 1:449 turns
All right thank you we're going to take agenda item number 33.
Yes and thank you very much our next item is a proclamation recognizing October 4th through 10th as National 4-H Week in Ventura County. 4-h is a nationally recognized program and it has given generations of young people life skills they can use for the rest of their lives. These are skills learning by doing and nothing shows that better than a young person raising an animal.
On a personal note, I love watching our young people take on the big responsibility of raising and caring for their beautiful animals in every year at the fair auction it is a treat to see their hard work pay off. But 4-H is about so much more than just the animals, I have to say. It's where kids learn responsibility, leadership and how to speak up and work with others.
They carry these lessons with them along after the program and a lot of leaders in our community have their start in 4-h and that says a lot about the program. So join us for the podium is Melissa Guillen And for a youth advisor with the University of California Cooperative Extension. And she's introducing our 4-H students who will be speaking with us today and proud to say that we do have some children of supervisors are in 4-h and so forth, so please go ahead.
Hi, good morning members of the board. Thank you so much for supporting this proclamation recognizing National 4-H Week. This year we are so excited to focus on expanding college and career readiness opportunities for our youth in the county We piloted a Teens as Teachers program where some of our own 4-H teens taught social emotional learning, yoga and mindfulness to kindergartners in the county.
We're also excited to expand 4-h learning opportunities through partnerships with YMCA, with Boys and Girls or Girl Scouts and Monica Ross School And also being able to host some youth at our Hanson Agricultural Research Extension Facility, basically a research farm in Camarillo. And yeah just thank you so much for the support. You know 4-H Youth Development Program is delivered locally through UC Cooperative Extension. So just want to extend our gratitude as well to the county and to the board for your continued support to be able to allow us to offer 4-h here.
And I'm very, very excited for you all to hear from some of our youth members. I'd like to invite Austin and Elizabeth up to speak with you as well as Matisse and Evelyn. Thank you so much.
And right before they come up, so Austin and Elizabeth are from Bardsdale 4-H. Matisse is from Santa Rosa Valley 4-h and Evelyn is from Loma Vista 4- H and a 4- h teen teacher. So just to give you some highlights. Hi!
Hi my name's Elizabeth Melania I'm from Barsdale 4- County Fair and I took care of them every day. I woke up at 5 a.m. and fed them water and food and...
Did you play with them? Mm-hmm. You did?
Thank you, that's all I'm gonna say. Great job!
Okay Austin.
Hello my name is Austin Lander. My favorite thing about 4-H is raising my rabbit Ben. I learned how to take care of an animal. I feed and water him. I clean his litter box and spend time with him at Fairbairn Place second overall. He is a very fun 4-H project and I want to share something with you guys and I won second place and I won a plaque. Wow!
1:44 – 1:489 turns
Great job,
Austin.
Hi my name is Matisse I'm nine years old this is my third year in the Santa Rosa Valley 4-H club. I'm here today to talk about my experience in 4-h where it's taken me and how it's changed my life for those of you who don't know 4- h is a youth leadership club with all sorts of projects and opportunities. A few of the projects I do are geology zoology fiber arts avian bowl and cake decorating 4-H has given me opportunities such as State Presentation Day, a big contest where I get to present my topic to a panel of adults. It has taken me to Riverside and Orange Counties and Fresno for our Avian Bowl Trivia competition where my team competed against other members of all different ages from all over California. This year I will be a representative of 4-h County and help come up with ideas for all of the clubs in the future 4- H may even present me for a college scholarship.
Some of the things 4-H has taught me are leadership, confidence and other things like sewing, clipping goat nails and how to write a speech. 4-h has definitely changed my life by giving me these experiences new confidence and helped me learn life skills this is what has brought me here today this is another incredible opportunity I would not have had without 4- h I'm thrilled that I've gotten this chance to speak with you thank you
Hello, my name is Evelyn Wally and I'm in my second year as president of the Loma Vista 4-H Club in Ventura. This is my ninth year in 4-h and my time in the program has taught me many important skills even though I haven't raised an animal. The Teens As Teachers Program which I participated in last year gave me strategies for teaching social emotional learning to younger kids but also for implementing those teachings in my own life Presentation day, an annual 4-H public speaking event with county regional and state levels helped me to grow into a more confident public speaker. I used to struggle to get up in front of a classroom to say a few words much less give a prepared speech in front of entire administrators but the practice in the safe encouraging learning environment fostered by 4-h leaders gave me the chance to become more comfortable in front of an audience leading to opportunities like this and a platinum award at State Field Day Our club is also committed to community service, learning about local nonprofits and contributing to their efforts to help the community.
Some examples of our community partners are the Elks Lodge and the Humane Society. Since 4-H is also a state program we learn about civic engagement opportunities around the state and across the country. Thank you for the time and support of 4-h that has made these opportunities possible.
There's a couple slides. Can you forward them so that we can all see
those?
Sorry, it was just staying and I was yes. I just thought this is fabulous representation. This is actually Matisse
right here. That's an outfit that she had made. That was a 4-H skit at presentation day pirate themed And then that is Evelyn teaching yoga to kindergartners at the YMCA. Those are some of our teen teachers this year. That was when they completed their training and up there.
Thank you very much. And just such a great way to teach leadership, so thank you. If that's okay we have everyone come up and we'll take a picture and we have a resolution.
1:49 – 1:546 turns
All right. Well, that was fun. We're going to
move on to agenda number 34 and as presentation by Supervisor Parvin.
It's domestic violence awareness month And I'd like to say good morning and I want to bring forward a number of people that are here with us this morning. Our district attorney, Eric Nazarenko. We also have Eric Sternad. You weren't on my list but I see you in the audience so I don't know if you're coming up. We also have Dr. Caroline Pujitel-Sutton, Executive Director Laura Morales, Health Services Manager and Lorena Siquieros.
Transitional Housing Supervisor. So we are honored today to recognize Domestic Violence Awareness Month. It's observed every October to raise awareness, honor survivors, remember those we've lost and reaffirm our commitment to preventing abuse and supporting those affected by it. And I know our DA could talk forever on this topic so with that I'm going to let you take it away.
Yeah. Thank you very much Supervisor Parman, Chair Corral, members of the Board of Supervisors, Dr. Johnson, thank you for once again recognizing these survivors and victims of domestic violence through this proclamation. This is a bit of a landmark this October because it marks the first time After the opening of serenity house, our domestic violence shelter at the Family Justice Center that we're having this so it's quite an honor to be joined by the people alongside me, Eric stern ad with interface. Dr. Caroline Prigetale-Sutton with the Coalition for Family Harmony. I also have some very important people with my staff, Chief Deputy over our Victim Assistance Services Brett Nybecker, the Chief Deputy over Domestic Violence and Sexual Assault Aaron Meister and of course the outstanding victim advocates from all these organizations if you are here can you please stand?
Speaking of the Serenity House and our domestic violence shelter, it's my pleasure to introduce Yasmeen Rodriguez one of our outstanding victim advocates.
Good morning, Chair and members of the Board of Supervisors. My name is Yasmin Rodriguez. I'm one of the supervisors at the Family Justice Center. I am honored today to receive the proclamation alongside the DA's office in recognizing Domestic Violence Awareness Month. At the Family Justice Center we assist survivors every day. Recently we supported a survivor in accessing safety and shelter through the Serenity House. While staying there, the Ventura County Foundation assisted with basic needs and financial assistance to help her get back on her feet. With the help of our community partners she was able to secure transitional housing through The Coalition and her journey is just a very powerful reminder that everything is possible when our community comes together.
We're grateful for the partnerships and for the continued expansion in our family justice centers throughout Thousand Oaks and Oxnard. More to come for that. This will allow us to reach more survivors throughout Ventura County. Thank you for your continued support for survivors in our community, and I'm going to welcome Dr. Caroline Bridgetel-Sutton.
Good morning, and thank you so much for having us this morning to recognize October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. Thank you to the board chair and to all of the supervisors for having us here. I also want to thank our partners from the district attorney's office and Family Justice Center and Interface Children and Family Services, as well as our partners in law enforcement and other community members, as everyone joins together to help survivors in this county.
I am here today with two of our housing service managers that oversee our portfolio of housing from our original Harmony House in Ventura to our indigenous shelter and now our Serenity House at the FJC, as well as our transitional housing program. They'll give you a very small glimpse into what we do all year to reach thousands of survivors of domestic violence and help them with not only crucial safety measures such as housing and counseling, but also being able to make decisions and find safety for the rest of their life. So I'd like to invite up Laura Morales, who is our housing service manager for our Harmony House and also our indigenous shelter.
1:54 – 2:034 turns
Buenos dias, soy Laura Morales to the Ventura County Board of Supervisors. Thank you for providing this space today to recognize October 2026 as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. Every year we reaffirm our commitment to fight domestic violence while the battle continues. We are incredibly fortunate to stand alongside dedicated advocates, leaders and community partners. We know we cannot do this work alone True lasting change requires the collective will of our entire community, and Domestic Violence Awareness Month is an opportunity to do so. To understand the scope of the dedication we look to numbers. Our advocates work 24 hours a day seven days a week. Because of the round-the-clock commitment, our shelters assisted over 40 survivors and their children.
Together we provided 1,381 bed nights to families from every corner of Ventura County. That number represents more than just a bed. It represents nights of safety, warmth, comfort and freedom from fear. Furthermore, our 24-hour emergency crisis line answered over 600 calls connecting individuals in crisis with a trained advocate ready to offer immediate shelter and resources.
Behind every one of these numbers is a life change and a family protected. To share more about the vital hands on work everyday Lorena will share more with you.
Hi, everyone. My name is Lorena Cegados and I am the Housing Pathway Manager at the Domestic Violence Shelter located at the Family Justice Center. I would like to share a story representing the impact of the important work we do. About three months ago, a survivor came to the Family Justice Center after leaving her abusive relationship. She had been unhoused with her partner for nearly a year and her relationship with her Relationship had created distance between her and her family.
When she left her abuser, he stalked her. He found her at a restaurant and attacked her at the parking lot. He attacked her physically and stole her phone which she was trying to use to call 911. The police referred her to the Family Justice Center for safety and support. She was connected to the Serenity House where one of our shelter specialists supported her and connected her to the services she needed including therapy.
From there, our transitional housing program was able to help her secure her own apartment. Today she is safe housed and continues to receive therapy and support through our team. Our shelter staff continues to check in with her and support her to rebuild her life. Her story is a reminder that our work doesn't end when, when a survivor leaves the abusive relationship it's about providing a pathway from crisis to safety to stability I would like to thank Interface and the Family Justice Center for continuing support and collaborating with us in the incredible work they do every day for survivors.
And a very special thank you to all our advocates who work day in and day out to provide support, compassion, and guidance to survivors when they need it the most. Thank you.
Good morning Chair Garrell and members of the board, Dr. Johnson I'd like to welcome next Nicole Gonzalez-Seitz with Interface Children Family Services to make some brief remarks as well thank you.
Good morning Chair Garrell, Dr. Johnson, members of the board on behalf of Interface Children and Family Services I'd like to extend our appreciation for the opportunity to be here this morning alongside our partners to raise awareness of this important issue and to honor the survivors advocates partners and community members who continue to work toward a Ventura County where everyone can feel safe in their homes For over 50 years, Interface has been a safe refuge for survivors of domestic violence. Offering support around the clock from our 24-7 crisis hotline, our emergency shelter, crisis intervention, providing safety planning, advocacy, counseling and connection to resources.
At the same time, we recognize the importance of preventing violence from happening in the first place. Through our teen dating violence prevention and middle school prevention programs, community outreach and awareness efforts, we work to equip our community with knowledge and tools to build healthy, violence-free relationships. We know that no one agency can do this alone.
Supporting those impacted by domestic violence requires strong partnerships across the community with law enforcement, the courts, victim service partners like the Family Justice Centers, Coalition for Family Harmony, our healthcare providers, schools, social service agencies and many many more We all play an important role in supporting individuals and preventing violence.
Collaboration also means listening to those with lived experience, and making sure their voices help shape the work that we do because behind every statistic a person who may have spent years being told that's what's happened to them is their fault. A person who may have been isolated from their friends and family A parent trying to protect their children. A young person trying to make sense of what they've experienced, and a survivor who has found the courage to seek help and begin rebuilding their lives.
Their voices matter. Representing those voices here today this morning are advocates from Interface's DV program who have brought with them a part of our Clothesline project which is being displayed at Interface's various locations throughout the month. The Clothesline Project gives survivors and those impacted by violence an opportunity to express their experiences through something as simple and as powerful as a piece of clothing.
Each piece tells a story, some reflect pain and loss others represent courage healing hope and resilience when we see these pieces I hope we remember that domestic violence is an issue that affects far too many. It affects our families, it affects our neighbors, it affects our coworkers and our communities. And these voices deserve to be heard. While October gives us an opportunity to shine a light on domestic violence, our responsibility does not end when the month does.
We need to continue creating safe pathways for survivors to seek help. We need to invest in prevention and early intervention programming. We need to continue strengthening partnerships across our county. And we need to continue listening to survivors, not only hearing their stories but allowing their experiences to shape and inform how we respond. At Interface, we're grateful to be a part of this community and to work alongside so many dedicated partners who share that commitment.
This month as we stand together with survivors I hope we remember that awareness is only the beginning what matters is what we do with that awareness how we show up how we collaborate How we respond and how we make sure that survivors know that they are not alone. Thank you for recognizing October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month, for supporting the work being done throughout Ventura County and for standing with survivors.
2:03 – 2:096 turns
Just one comment I would make Thursday evening, we will be having an art installation here at the Hall of Administration recognizing Domestic Violence Awareness Month. We certainly invite all of you to attend that. We'll have artwork some murals that were painted at Serenity House, the Family Justice Center. We're going to be talking about some of the work that we've done over the last couple of weeks. There's a number of pieces in there that are just beautiful that will be featured as well as artwork from our camp hope kiddos as
Thank you. Thank you so much. Yeah,
I believe trigger L has a comment just briefly What time do you know what time that is Thursday on Thursday? Okay 535 30 thank you very much. It's great. I just want to Say that each of you are our pillars in this community that hold up a framework of support That I've seen nowhere else in the state or nation. I would I don't think it's comparable what other Communities are doing, I think we're so far ahead in the effort and the most difficult work is to breaking those cycles of violence in families and in communities. That's a really move-the-mountain difficult part. The arrest and prosecution might be described as the easy part it's that things that come later and each of you in your individual ways in the district attorney's office and in our CBOs and our FJCs and our community are all coming together to provide an amazing network.
Again, I've never seen the likeness of it anywhere and it's so impressive because you truly are helping and saving lives in so many ways. So just want to say thank you to each of you individually and collectively for doing such great work. And in particular, I take a point of privilege as the chair. And I do want to point out Mr. Sternet is preparing to retire soon and this may be the last time we're able to share this proclamation, this resolution with him. And I just want to say with 20 years of commitment as one of these pillars that holds up an amazing foundation for our community, we just want to say thank you for your decades of service and everything you do.
Thank you all for the great work and we'll come down and give your proclamation.
All right that was good, thank you. We're going to
move on to item number 35 and it's a presentation for the fire prevention week in Ventura County I'd like to ask our fire folks to start making their way to the podium if we can particularly Assistant Fire Marshal Rod Torres and So we all know that there's no such thing as fire season anymore, right? It's year round. It's a year-round threat to you around challenge your own responsibility and this week is a reminder to all of us so we can be proactive to protect our families in our property from safe charging of lithium ion batteries to basic home safety and the home Harding right special thank you to our Fire Department and for their outstanding work in education prevention community outreach throughout the year Fire safety starts before an emergency with all of us doing our part to be prepared and here to talk about that is Mr.
Torres, thank you sir.
2:09 – 2:141 turns
Good morning board members. Thank you, I couldn't agree with you more on behalf of the Ventura County Fire Department thank you for the opportunity to recognize fire prevention week 2026. For more than a century the National Fire Protection Association, the NFPA has sponsored Fire Prevention Week as a national effort to educate the public about fire and life safety This year's theme is charge into fire safety, safe charging is a superpower.
The campaign focuses on something that has become a part of nearly every household and workplace in Ventura County. That is the lithium ion battery. There are many there are many of our personal devices such as our cell phones laptops they're also used to power toys e-bikes e-scooters and portable tools Some of us here today may have driven into work in a lithium-ion battery powered vehicle.
So why does this campaign matter? Well, lithium ion batteries are extremely effective because they can store a lot of energy in a very small space but if a battery is damaged improperly manufactured or charged incorrectly it can overheat catch fire and even explode A battery failure can rapidly progress from overheating to creating a very hazardous environment that produces explosive gases and intense fire conditions.
Fire service research and training personnel recently demonstrated this potential hazard of a fully charged 40 amp hour volt lawnmower battery during the controlled test, the battery was intentionally overheated placed into thermal runway and the resulting explosion blew a garage door off its hinges 10 feet away. That should give you some perspective of the amount of energy contained in something as common as a lawnmower battery.
The good news is that NFPA has identified some very simple things we can all do to reduce the risk. Use the right charger, use the cord and charger that came with the device or one that is approved by the manufacturer Charge on a hard, flat surface. Not on a bed. Not on a couch. Not under the pillow. Soft surfaces can trap the heat and restrict airflow. And if it's fully charged, unplug it. Don't leave devices charging overnight.
Know the warning signs of a failing battery. Batteries become unusually hot, they swell, they leak, they smell. Some of them will make strange noises, popping and hissing sounds. Just simply stop using that battery. Think the bigger the battery, the bigger the risk. And for e-bikes and scooters and power tools which use these larger batteries charge them outside whenever possible and keep them away from your exits.
The Ventura County Fire Department takes lithium ion battery safety seriously. This emergent technology has created unique operational response issues for our firefighters. Lithium ion battery incidents expose both our firefighters and the public to these hazardous atmospheres, intense fire conditions and the risk of explosions. We continue to train and refine operational tactics when responding to these electrical vehicle fires and other lithium-ion battery fires.
But as important as our emergency response is, preventing an emergency is better than having to respond to one. That is why we are taking Fire Prevention Week directly into our communities. Our fire prevention staff, volunteers and firefighters will be participating in multiple community outreach events throughout the county. We look forward to meeting the residents face-to-face answering their questions sharing simple information that they can take home and put into practice immediately.
Technology continues to change and the hazards we encounter change with it. During this fire prevention week, we are asking the residents of Ventura County to help us. To help us by taking a few minutes to look and see how it is that they're charging their own devices in their homes. Check the charger, check where you're charging, know the warning signs of a failing battery, and simply talk about battery safety with your family.
Because when it comes to lithium ion batteries, safe charging really is a superpower. Lastly I would like to extend a special thank you to our fire prevention professionals, volunteers and firefighters who helped carry the mission forward into the communities we serve not just this week but year round. And on behalf of the Ventura County Fire Department thank you board for your continued support for our fire prevention community and education efforts. Thank you.
Thank you.
2:14 – 2:315 turns
Thank you for everything that you do and the department does, we'd like to come down and take a photograph with you. All right, well that was fun series of proclamations and we're gonna do 36 now and invite up our Director of Office of Emergency Services Patrick Maynard. This is a receive-and-file report on the county's preparations for a possible strong storm season aka El Nino.
Dr. Johnson did you want to kick it off or we'd hand it over Mister. I hadn't
planned to kick it off but
okay
so thank you. Chair corral as we all know their predictions of a serious El Nino season coming up. So we have been partnering and working with our office of emergency services director Patrick Maynard Our fire chief, our PWA director, our office. And this presentation today is to bring to your board and the public what's been happening behind the scenes as well as what the community can do to prepare themselves for this coming season. So I'm going to kick it off to Director Maynard who has been really leading this. We are appreciative of his efforts. He has a lot of experience because we've had a lot of disasters here in our county unfortunately But we're thankful for him leaning in and being willing to be the face as we move forward preparing for El Nino.
Thank you, Director.
Thank you. Good morning chair grill members of the board and doctor Johnson, thanks for that nice opening just before we jump into this. This is a team effort and we are so lucky to live in work in a county where our county departments or cities are public safety community all can work together. We've done this as was alluded to Too many times, but with that in mind we're pretty good at it at this point and that good comes from good cooperation. So I just really want to thank all the agencies that have worked together through the planning process as we continue to go through this.
So the first thing I want to address with a board this morning is the governor's state of emergency or emergency proclamation that was issued back on September 22nd. I'm sure by now everyone has seen that emergency proclamation that was issued when it kind of talk about why that was issued and really where that leaves us as a county in terms of needing an emergency proclamation So when the governor did do that state of emergency, he included 18 plus or minus points within that proclamation. Many of those orders directed other state departments to take certain preventative action to prepare for what could be a busy winter season.
I think one of the most impactful items that was included in those 18 were really directing a couple of state agencies, in particular the Coastal Commission also CalEPA to expedite permit processing. So I think that's one of the really important things that the governor did take preventative action on to expedite any type of emergency work that constituents and the community could potentially be proposing One of the other things that that proclamation did was really just best position the state to expedite any kind of procurement that needs to transpire. As you can imagine, the Department of Water Resources is procuring a lot of supplies for flood fighting they do need to be able to waive the bidding process where appropriate and that is again one of the other elements of that emergency proclamation.
Where does that leave us though in Ventura County with respect to that emergency proclamation? Here locally, we like to believe that those emergency proclamations should be reserved for actual or reasonably imminent emergencies involving significant threats to life property and critical infrastructure. And I'm happy to say we're not there yet. Not to say we won't be having a different conversation later on in the winter But as of today we believe we are well equipped with the tools, with the cooperation that we have not asked to bring an item before your board for consideration quite yet.
Again when we're looking to issue a local emergency proclamation we're doing that because We have issues with resource shortfalls. We're looking for some type of extraordinary authority that we don't have on a day-to-day basis, perhaps were trying to align ourselves with the requirements necessary to secure state or federal assistance. Any one of those things would be reasons that we would come before your board and ask for you Either approve or ratify an emergency proclamation. And again, I'm thankful to say we're just not at that point yet. We as a county have been able to do plenty of work to plan prepare and really get again ready for what could be a very busy winter season.
So with that in mind, under the direction or at the direction of Dr. Johnson, the county put together several winter preparedness task force groups that have all been meeting on a pretty regular basis to prepare the county for this winter. Those task force groups include a response task force, facilities and infrastructure task force, a mass care and shelter task force, a public information task force in finance and recovery. Those task force groups again are really working not just within the county but in some cases beyond the county which we'll highlight shortly to plan and prepare for this winter.
Personally, I've had the opportunity to be a part of the response task force. And when we were looking at things to share with you today, I think one of the things that is often on our mind is the burn areas. So I wanted to take a moment to highlight some of the discussion that our response task forces had with respect to the burn areas. We go back to the mountain fire we've been concerned with post-fire debris flow potential and I'm happy to report that after a combined meeting with California geological survey. The city of Camarillo several folks from Ventura County public works and we've all collectively decided that the area has made it good enough recovery to reduce the or retire We're going to talk a little bit about what we've seen so far in terms of the debris flow thresholds that we had in place.
So what that means you know we reduce the level of monitoring that we have for the mountain fire burn area, we are not as concerned with it. It does entail a complete departure from monitoring it we will continue to monitor that The vegetation recovery and the soil type that we're in a much better place today, two years following that fire than we were back in 2024 as we were dealing with rain back then.
The other recent burn area and hopefully the only other burn area we have to be concerned with this fire season if we get through it unscathed is the Sandy Fire Burn Area from this past year. And similarly, we've met with a number of agencies, including several representatives from the city of Simi Valley. And ultimately, we've come up with some debris flow thresholds that we will be looking for this winter and that's point zero six inches an hour of rain. That's pretty commonly observed in a post fire condition. It's about half of what we understand is normal. In terms of something capable of causing a debris flow countywide, an inch and hour of rainfall at any location has the ability to generate a debris flow regardless of its post fire condition.
With the Sandy Fire burn area we know that again about .60 inches an hour could cause a debris flow. What that means for us and what that means for the residents is we will need to monitor that area very closely, monitor those forecasts. Again a joint effort between both the County Office of Emergency Services and also the City of Simi Valley. And if appropriate issue evacuation warnings, evacuation orders for residents if need be.
Some of our other areas of concern, I don't know if the public work structure would classify it the same way but Matilija Canyon probably Ventura County's most expensive roadway. That area continues to be a very challenging area we have seen a lot of damage occur the last five plus years some very significant damage in 2023-2024 During some pretty significant rain that area continues to be a challenge for us and a point of vulnerability. So I know Mister Shack loose from the public works agency will be highlighting some of their efforts for that roadway, but it is one that we are monitoring closely and most importantly were talking about some contingency plans in the event that we lose access which we commonly do in that area.
Another area of concern for us is Camp Chafee or the Foster Park area. I'm sure we've all seen the photos, we've received the emails you know there's a lot of challenging situations up there. There's a lot of great work underway that's actually already been completed by the Public Works Agency again which will be highlighted. All that being said we still need to continue to monitor that area and it is a problem area especially as Lake Casitas is very near reaching capacity. And as that lake reaches capacity, it does spill natural occurrence but it does spill water into Coyote Creek that passes through Camp Chaffee so we will be watching that area closely for both of these areas. It's likely we will embark on some collective outreach efforts to residents in that area and in the past we've had the opportunity in places like Lock and Cheetah to go door-to-door and actually make contact with residents and it's likely that we'll be doing the same for both of these communities as plans progress Again, partnerships through joint effort between the fire department, Todd Road Jail, the Sheriff's Office, the county OES logistics team.
They all worked together this last week to build upwards of 50 pallets of sandbags an incredible amount of work we couldn't do that without the fire department and their hand crew they were able to respond out and do that Those sandbags were pre-positioned this past week at a number of fire stations. We also dropped sandbags at Lock and Cheetah and at Camp Chaffee, so those have already been placed in the community and as they're used we'll continue to deploy those sandbags. We have quite a bit of supplies in stock and available.
The challenge is getting them out there it's very difficult to transport these piles of sandbags We are prepared to do that and if we do run out of materials, we can quickly pivot to the Department of Water Resources who has a lot of materials available. Actually some pre-positioned right here in Ventura County. In addition to the things I've already highlighted, there's a lot of preparedness work going on with respect to the emergency operations center. A lot of different training just various types of operational coordination with the 10 cities we're looking at a lot We've been able to test and leverage over the years and just trying to figure out how we can do things better. So a lot of that work continues to be underway, of course resource readiness goes without saying in monitoring these forecasts it's very challenging.
We don't know what El Nino will bring this year I mean we very likely will have a significant winter it could also not be a whole lot of anything so we really want to take this opportunity to prepare But also at the same time, remind our residents of the opportunity to just do all hazards preparedness. Whether it's for rain floods fires take this opportunity to pause and ensure that your family is ready for you know any type of disaster situation I just want to highlight some of the work that the Sheriff's Office continues to do with water protection as well as backpack medicine. They're constantly out in the community looking at our waterways, they're contacting our unhoused population letting them know again it's kind of hard to send a message to leave today as it's 100 plus degrees out but just warning them that the winter is likely to be busy More importantly they're making note of where these encampments are so down the road if need be.
They can go out and contact them ahead of the rain it's not uncommon ahead of a big storm for our homeless lays on unit to get out in the field and actually make contact with people doesn't mean that they'll be you know leaving but we at least like to make contact make them aware of what other options they have for shelter. If time permits, we also use the helicopter in the PA on the helicopter to make those notifications as well This is some really great progress here, and I don't want to steal the thunder of the Human Services Agency. But our Mass Care and Shelter Task Force from the human or led by the Human Services Agency has been working with all 10 cities in Ventura County to really ensure that as cities they have some type of sheltering capability, that they're equipped with equipment, that they have the training that they need.
And I'm happy to report that we're at a point of comfort doesn't mean that we have the capacity or ability to house every Ventura County resident Boy, I wish we could attain that goal. But we have at least a decent start on being able to provide shelter in every community. In addition to that, the EMS agency has done some work there prepared to respond to any of these shelters with some specially equipped trailers that can serve individuals with access or functional needs.
And you know, I think as best as we can be, we're prepared to activate shelters in every community again. Partnerships are so important here. Partnerships not just with public agencies but with our non-profits people like the American Red Cross, Salvation Army they're all amazing. One last thing I would like to highlight which to me is going to be very impactful if you recall these last couple years we've been challenged with a variety of issues in the Ventura River some repetitious water rescues fire department may talk about that.
The City of Ventura has worked to expand their foul weather sheltering program so typically if certain criteria is met The city would make through River Community Church several motel rooms available. That just wasn't enough though, so the city's been able to establish a contract with the armory in Ventura and we'll look to activate that armory and make that available again under certain conditions. So it won't be available as maybe you recall in the past where it's just a seasonal thing but if we do meet certain rainfall thresholds the armory will become available for sheltering additional individuals And again, much more capacity there upwards of 120 beds if we reach that threshold.
So that concludes my report. There's a lot of other people to present but I'm happy to answer any questions before I hand it over to the fire department.
2:31 – 2:4213 turns
I just wanted to ask question for him. Thank you. I was on a Sigma working group yesterday and they stated that just as of Friday there was more information coming from the governor's office on the emergency declaration. Did you have any information on that?
We took part in or participated in a meeting yesterday from Cal OES, you know really no new news. Really what Cal OES did underscore is no financial assistance has been authorized as of now so no California Disaster Assistance Act funding, no FEMA funding has been made available to us yet and I think that's you know key thing that we really need to think about here is that we are challenged with a lot of preparedness and spending that is before us now with really no recourse for reimbursement at this point. So I think departments, cities everyone's doing what they can to get ready but keeping costs commensurate to you know what could potentially be a busy season.
Well one thing I did hear was the flood protection and flood permitting. So just as a heads up to be aware they might be doing that to help us with some of the creeks in trying to dredge through so that the flows don't take out more land but just let us know thank you.
We'll keep an eye out, thank you for that.
Yeah it's Supervisor LaVere
Thank you, Chair. I wanted to kind of follow up on Supervisor Long's question because in the past just some of our challenges has been getting the permits from CDFW to do stream bed work especially proactively And I had a call with the Coastal Commission leadership on Friday talking about coastal protection and coastal permitting. And I know the Coastal Commission is taking the stance that they're going to be a lot more flexible, a lot more open to do some of this proactive work which they normally wouldn't permit. But because of the governor's declaration, they're allowing this to happen. And I wonder if CDFW if we can maybe get in touch with them and say are you going to be amenable to this real flexibility? To allow us to do this proactive work too.
Because I know it's been a challenge in the past.
Yeah that's a great point Supervisor LeVayre and I think one of the things that agencies like CDFW are looking at or you know where can they expedite the process how can they improve the process so I know several of these agencies were challenged With coming back in 30 days and trying to come up with a game plan, what can we do to expedite some of these things?
Obviously very complicated but we can certainly stay in contact with them and report back on any big changes.
And with Supervisor LaVere, I really appreciate that because we've heard based on the storms from 23 and 25 that funding might not be there as much as we would prefer. And so to get this dredged in to get some control on the natural creeks because I don't want them cemented. So how do we keep with the environment and the landowners? Hopefully they'll come up with some good ideas and that we can activate those. Thank you.
That would be nice. I'm going to take the opportunity to ask a question here as well. Our utilities, it's mentioned in your PowerPoint but related to Edison in particular that I haven't been impressed with their coordination collaboration and communication during emergencies and where are we with them vis-a-vis our integration in our EOC and operational coordination. If you could just talk to that.
Sure, thank you Chair Guerrero for the question. I'm actually happy to report on this that SCE was one of the first to kind of lean forward and host a forum even ahead of Cal OES believe it or not and try to bring together the response community and kinda hear what people are doing and then share their commitment to monitoring weather and getting power back on when they safely can do so as quickly as possible. I feel at a pretty good point of comfort, at least at this juncture that SCE will be present in our EOC when we ask them to. I feel like our level of coordination, at least leading into the winter is in a good place and I think on their end they've done what they can, at least given the circumstances, to prepare as best as possible so feeling pretty confident there probably more confident with respect to the rain than I do with PSPS as we've all experienced but I think we're in a pretty decent spot with
Yeah, well it's good to hear. Thank you and I do think Ian coming on board to represent Edison locally he's been very forward-leaning and engaged and helpful so thank you if there are no other questions we'll proceed with fire
all right i'd like to invite up assistant chief correction deputy chief chuck sherry from the fire department to give the fire department update
Thought I got a demotion there real quick. Good morning, Chair Gorel, members of the board, CEO Dr. Johnson. My name is Chuck Sherry. I'm your deputy fire chief and just tagging on to what Patrick said regarding partnerships and collaboration. I am so proud to work for a county that is leaning forward on this and this is not going to catch us off guard. We will we will not be prepared for this. This slide is an example of the level of collaboration and the way that your fire department's culture is lean in and basically look for ways to assist in any way that we can As already been mentioned, we have a lot of numbers flying around regarding the possibility of this event and what it might bring.
We know that it's gonna bring something, we're just not sure what. But the problem in the meantime is that our live fuel moistures are at 58%, which is below the critical level of 60%. So we know that we're either gonna get rain first or we're gonna get wind first. If we get wind first, do we have susceptibility to potential more burn scars? If we get rain first your fire department stands nimble and ready to react and change hats very quickly to adjust to a flood fighting and mud and debris stance.
As Patrick mentioned, we're trying to study our enemy in the sense that we are familiar with our history. We are aware of our problem areas and we are really operating from a when then standpoint. We are not operating if but when these areas get cut off, when we have challenges with access, when we stand to have isolated areas how are we going to respond? And so we were going through all of our operational plans looking at these areas as well as others to say Are there creative ways, are there additional resources that we need to pre-position? Do we need a student body left and shift resources towards certain area? Do we need to set up area command? I'll speak more about that. But these are on our radar as we continue to look for decision triggers evacuation coordination with Patrick and his team, as well as just monitoring forecasting.
Sandbags. So any given day of the year we have sandbags at 24 of our 34 fire stations this year, we are adding 10 temporary sand pits to the additional stations that don't currently have them so we will have emergency sand and sandbags at all 34 of our fire stations. And we actively monitor this and we resupply as needed. And I'll say this from a public awareness standpoint, I've been at many fire stations at times when members of the public have shown up and they've said, I'm here to get my sandbags. And we've said great like what's the problem? Like what is there something we can help you with? Is there do you need any assistance?
No, I just hear to get them the news that I needed sandbags And so what I would suggest is sandbags are best utilized for the diversion of moving water, for the protection of certain areas that could potentially lead to erosion or runoff. That's the utilization of sandbags. We stand ready to assist our public with installing those with filling those and resupplying them as needed but just because the news says it's raining does not necessarily mean everybody needs sandbags. So I'll just say that As we stand today, we are actually upstaffed for this heat event.
And unfortunately as we've all referenced, we are in the practice of doing this. We're in the practice of working with the National Weather System of monitoring forecasts eight days out, we get to 72 hours out, 48 hours out. We have a process in place that leads to a trigger of us to upstaff into our emergency plans. We have mud and debris flow plans, we have flooding plans, we have ocean rescue plans, We have swift water plans. All of these resources we are prepared to in state should the need arise and what this allows us to do is I kind of referred to earlier is.
We have the ability to staff extra chief officer extra command officers to put in place of these threatened areas where we could actually pivot if we needed to into an area command system which means basically we are going to allow that person in a geographical area to triage the needs of resources and move freely within that range to really provide the most assistance based on the highest need at that time.
This is actually the first event that we're going into where we have equipped all of our chief officers with Starlinks on their vehicles. We are feeling very strongly about our contingencies for connectivity, as well as just redundancy in our ability to communicate our needs across the county. Our Flood Fighting Tasks Force are actually the other hat that our Wildland Division wears. So as I mentioned, these individuals stand ready today to fight a brush fire but at the flip of a switch we can pivot them into a flood fighting task force which allows us to use proven leadership, a giant workforce of very strong individuals that have skills with saws and heavy equipment and power tools to help with sandbag construction, debris removal.
They can help with downed trees. We can put them into modules with leadership where we'll take a hand crew will have a heavy equipment operator under the direction of an area commander. And we've really found that recipe to be successful in assisting where we have our highest needs. We also then allow our swift water teams and our ocean rescue teams to remain available for the life hazard where those threats exist.
And we understand and are in partnership with the county regarding the need for continuity of operations, we're looking at all of our facilities right now I mentioned the Starling capability, we take extra measures to ensure that our generators or fire stations all of our facilities Stand ready should we be isolated, should we have cutoffs of supplies. We have redundant communication systems in place and we just ensure that 365, 24 hours a day your fire department stands ready in partnership with the rest of the county.
The goal to maintain all over these abilities year round regardless of what shows up so with that I'm available to answer any specific fire department questions
2:42 – 2:5312 turns
Quick question. So as far as the burn scarred areas, are you setting up the meetings with the communities just for that particular community? The ones that have the burn scars or are you just doing an overall community event within a city?
So we certainly emphasize the burn areas in terms of our communication notifications public outreach. We are highlighting those areas as a special case this year in collaboration with the task the PIO Task Force. Okay, so we are doing that as well as general County messaging. So
great.
Thank you. Thank you supervisor Lopez.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you for the information and I'm aware that you all have been coordinating with our local cities, the other fire departments but can you speak a little bit more to what that looks like? Sure
yeah so we do have a strong partnership with our regional partners And this year, one of the things that we have done proactively as we have reached out to the cities early and often regarding the involvement of their other entities within their city like their public works departments there heavy equipment departments. We know that we have some areas that are recurring problems within the cities.
So, we are getting ahead of those to make sure that we have the resources from the cities present and the proactive work being done in terms of clearing out drains and storm channels and all those things. We have taken much more of a proactive approach on that this year than what has occurred in the past.
Thank you
All right, thank you. We can keep going
okay with that
I'd like to
introduce Mister Strack loose.
Good morning chair grow members of the board CEO doctor Johnson my name is Greg struck loose and thank you for recognizing the support that public works provides to our community during times of need into our fellow emergency responders. Public works is charged with maintaining essential infrastructure These services include transportation, water, sewer, integrated waste management and watershed protection.
Now this isn't really all that we do but I'm going to focus on these particular areas as I deliver this presentation So what does the average rainy season look like? It's tough to tell now because out of the last five years there have been four declared flood or storm disasters, which I think has skewed the curve. But on the average coastal and valley areas can see anywhere from 10 to 17 inches of rainfall and the mountains can see up to 33 inches of rainfall during an average year.
When that rain falls, it falls within our three major watersheds. Santa Clara, Cayugas Creek and Ventura River. That rainfall feeds our natural creeks, our rivers and as well as the engineered systems designed to collect and convey that stormwater. The ability for natural flowways and man-made systems to move stormwater really depends on the storm event itself.
Rainfall intensity and duration are critical factors in determining impacts to natural flow ways and engineered systems. With that said, Ventura County's public works infrastructure includes 542 miles of roadway, 158 bridges through mountains and valleys, rural and urban areas. It includes four independent potable water systems in six sewer districts made up of hundreds of miles pipe traversing through areas and numerous tanks and pumps And while there are 750 miles of red line channels that convey stormwater throughout the county, only 27% of those channels have an engineered component that Watershed Protection maintains.
The remaining 73% of those channels are on privately owned property and mostly natural. Being a resident, sorry being a resilient county requires exceptional maintenance and all of our infrastructure in our public works team has delivered on that exceptional maintenance. As you think about Ventura County's unique topography and geology, you think about vulnerabilities.
You get a sense of where some of those vulnerabilities are. Steep winding mountainous roads and roads adjacent to creeks and rivers, some of which Patrick have named. The same vulnerabilities are true for infrastructure and property along creeks and rivers that move large volumes of water. Your public work staff are aware of these areas and watch them closely during storms, even pre-positioning heavy equipment nearby to address storm issues immediately.
I'm trying to go backwards. Your Sheriff and Fire Chief set the bar extremely high when it comes to readiness and responsiveness. Your Public Works Agency follows that lead and ensures that our staff trains equally hard, and spends time working together on disaster simulations. The public works portion of the county's emergency plan is up to date and our duty officer is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Public Works operates several pieces of heavy equipment such as motor graders loaders skid steers and dump trucks that are all critical to day-to-day work but particularly during emergencies.
While our partners at GSA Fleet Services keep the county's equipment operating, it's important to know that Public Works has the ability to temporarily expand its fleet through contracts with private companies and not just for equipment but for construction services as well. I wanted to touch upon some of the additional El Nino focus given by our Public Works Agency.
Earlier this year when the weather forecast began to indicate a strong El Nino condition, Public Works accelerated maintenance of our roads, bridges and watershed facilities by authorizing overtime to staff. This overtime allocation enabled Public Works to catch up on some of the deferred maintenance and better prepare Ventura County and the community for the rainy season.
Going one step beyond, Public Works teams were asked to find ways to improve resiliency of our infrastructure by strengthening it with different materials or engineering solutions to greater standards particularly when this can be done at cost effectively Examples include larger boulders along slopes and bridge foundations for greater protection from rushing waters, raising the elevation of road segments near waterways.
Public Works has been strengthening selected areas that are known to be more vulnerable, prioritizing critical infrastructure of heavily used areas serving large populations. And all this work is being thoroughly documented Because we know that the level of detail needed to prove storm damage during a disaster to FEMA and other regulatory agencies for financial reimbursements.
We definitely understand the complicated process of that financial reimbursement process. Last but not least, the Public Works engineering teams have been designing shovel-ready solutions for some of our most vulnerable facilities that may become damaged by upcoming storms. So we'll be ready with designs to go in and fix things. Before leaving this slide though I do need to give my sincere gratitude to the public works staff who've been working so hard over the last few months getting ready for the season ahead You've heard some of the preparedness actions the agency has taken in light of El Nino forecast. I wanted to also share some of the collaborative efforts with federal, state and local agencies as well as neighborhood associations and private property owners.
Prior to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife Directors, Megan Hartel's recent notice regarding local agencies reminding local agencies of the more helpful provisions by which emergency work may occur. Public Works met with CDFW staff to discuss the work efforts leading up to the season Public Works also met with Caltrans to discuss the state's facilities within Ventura County, particularly the vulnerable locations. And by October 21st, the governor's recent declaration requires Caltrans to submit a prioritized list of projects that would mitigate risks associated with vulnerable state roads and bridges.
Public Works has asked to receive a copy of that list for Caltrans District 7. For many years, Ventura County Public Works Directors have met monthly to discuss a wide array of public works issues. And in the next few days, Public Works is hosting a meeting with the city's Public Works Directors at our new Emergency Operations Center. There we'll discuss preparations for the upcoming rainy season and review emergency contact information and mutual aid agreements.
Here you see some photographs of work that we've been done. This is just a small glimpse of some of the stormwater conveyance channel clearings that we've done. Our debris basins, we have 58 debris basins and in the past few months, we've been able to remove 235,946 cubic yards of material. Granted Lower Santa Paula Creek is on track to have material removed by the end of this year.
Some of the areas that Patrick mentioned, including old Telegraph Road Bridge. You see reinforcement there and those are four-ton boulders not two ton boulders. You see Santa Rosa Bridge if prior to our work there you could a tall person could walk under the bridge and touch the top of the bridge which is a problem because any debris flowing under that bridge could impact the bridge and damage it so what we did is we went in under the bridge and excavated some material to create a greater clear way for waters to flow. And Matila Road, you see a project there where we've actually elevated the road to bring it more resiliency because that segment of the road is up against a creek so but there are still other areas in Matilija Road that were still deeply concerned about.
2:54 – 3:0017 turns
I just want to bring to people's attention the old telegraph road public works has been doing a fabulous job of fixing it than 2023 in 2025. However, what you note is that the rocks keep getting removed so We'd love to get it cemented. I would suggest however others do not agree one, I think it's cost and regulation is that true? I bring this to it because I'm concerned of what it's going to look like by January and what the next steps are so I'm trying to get ahead of the curve on this and is there anything else that we can do besides putting rocks there
Yeah, these are larger rocks. Four ton as I mentioned. We would like to grout this area but the California Fish and Wildlife do have some objection to that because it does impact flow in environment and wildlife to a certain degree. I think there may be some opportunity to pursue that a little bit more particularly during this time not that we could get that work done this year but to pursue for future years.
Well, and I bring that up because I do know there was some findings from the VCTC with the bridge that was fixed in Habitat. I think there's some good information that was found there. And then also, I think with the emergency decorations that we've had my office myself, I would really like us to be looking at what to do there because it is taxpayer dollars in which is keep putting in more money towards these rocks that keep going downstream And I think we need to cement the issue to fix it. And then that helps everyone, environmental landowners everybody so thank you. Thank you
The picture on the left shows our team with City of Simi Valley staff reviewing the Sandy Fire burn area. There's been excellent coordination on that point, I'll talk a little bit more about that later and then the Peach Hill Wash was an emergency that we brought to your board in recent weeks that we've recently completed now where we have a sewer main under that slope. We've rebuilt the slope and reinforced it.
Our flood warning system is one of the country's best. And in terms of preparedness for county staff, but also individuals in the community, this ability to get to this website and see live data and then projections of what flows will be through our channels is an incredible asset. We've actually installed another monitoring station up by the Sandy Fire burn area to help monitor that area a little bit more closely.
But this is a huge resource for Ventura County and all of its residents. With here, I feel I'm more prepared to more than prepared to answer any questions before handing it off to Natalie.
Any other questions? Supervisor Lopez.
Thank you, Chair. Just just a comment Mr. Strakoulos there wanted to commend you for the segment on KCLU about the work that's being done. That was a nice little clip to show the preparedness right I think we're all getting questions about is the county doing work and the work is being done right it may not be as visible so I appreciated you know that being an opportunity to share with the public that the county has been proactive
Thank you for that. And the staff who interviewed during that interview were really quite impressive and not the work that they were doing but in how the questions are being answered, they are ready.
All
right, Supervisor
Parvin? Just a question about staffing. I've read an email from someone yesterday that mentioned that you still need additional staff in Public Works. You have any comments on that?
Well, we're preparing with the staff that we have. And we've actually allocated overtime to folks to enable us to better prepare for what's coming. You know that question is more around budget I think. I'm more concerned about not having enough funding to do the work that we want to do and getting reimbursed by FEMA so that we can recover properly. So so funding is probably the top of my list.
I think our staff are working so well And we've freed up some more hours for them to work
Okay, thank you
Mr. Chuck loose quick question for you it may be too far out in advance to be a current concern but at one point General services and public works were concerned about not having the ability to possess and have pool vehicles that were non-EV because they were found to be ultimately subject to EV mandates by CARB. And it was a concern that during an emergency like this where EV is not practical, That there may be limitations on our ability at public works to respond to that like we could with fire and law enforcement.
On the horizon?
No, my compliments to GSA Fleet Services for the program that they've installed to try and address the carb issue by looking at the fleet vehicles that are pickup trucks and smaller vehicles because the larger heavy equipment will be very difficult to achieve. We're not quite sure that that equipment has been proven in terms of electric or hydrogen powered but we're fine for now I think in the future that is a concern
Yeah, thank you. Okay any other questions by the board? Any public comment on this agenda item?
Natalie Hernandez.
Oh yeah I'm sorry Natalie please.
3:00 – 3:094 turns
Good morning, Chair Garrell, Supervisor, CEO Dr. Johnson. I'm Natalie Hernandez. I am the Public Information Officer for the County of Ventura and as you've heard this morning there's been a great deal of preparation that's going on with our county agencies and I'm here to talk to you about how we're informing the community on ways they can get prepared and then also understand the efforts that the county is taking on itself So public information in general is a task force that we have taking place, which is really a joint effort across agencies. So we have agencies that are working ahead to update on preparedness information just ahead of what the winter season may bring us and give tips and tricks on what to do should we see a strong El Nino season.
So really there are four key areas that I want to focus on just to talk about what our approaches are where we're talking about doing a multi-channel approach, which means that we're meeting residents wherever they're receiving information. We're ensuring that the messaging that we're sharing is bilingual in English and Spanish so we're meeting all residents in our community with that critical information on preparedness or should it become necessary emergency information?
We have local and state coordination, which means that we're partnering with our cities. And then we're staying in contact with those who are at the state level like Cal OES. And then we're going to make sure that we have print and digital resources available should people be connected on social media or they want to see print items such as our Ready, Set, Go booklets. So really a strong call-to-action that we have during this season. And what we're really focusing on is getting prepared so we want people to really sign up for VC Alert.
So I just want to talk to you a little bit about our approach on this and really how we're trying to encourage residents to think about getting prepared. It is really hot out there today, and it's hard for people to think that this is something that they need to look ahead to. But this is why it's the perfect time for them to do it. It's sunny and good weather, and it's an opportunity for people to take advantage of that good weather and get prepared for when we know that those storms may come.
So what we are looking for in our grand theme over all of the messaging that we're sharing over the next couple of months is that we really want people to think prepare today, be storm ready tomorrow. And there's some key areas that we're going to focus on in terms of the messaging that we share in our print and digital materials that we put out. Really making those calls to action for registering for emergency alerts, helping people understand the difference between warnings and orders so that they're ready when they see those come during what may be our fire season or even our winter impact season.
And then recognizing what hazards might be in their community so that they're prepared and ready to recognize them should they receive those alerts. We really want people also to focus on home readiness and family readiness, so taking the time to prepare your homes and properties, building emergency go bags or making emergency stake hits Should you be told that it's safer to stay home than it is to evacuate, because that does happen in flood situations. And then making sure that people know that we have a ready set go booklet that comes from our partners in the fire department which has really great information about ways to get prepared for all hazards.
We want people to understand sandbag resources, which we've talked about today. Flooding resources and flooding safety. We have a great guide from our public works agency that talks about debris flow and erosion and how people can deal with that around their homes. And then one of the things that we really want to share throughout these next few months is highlighting our county at work. Because as much as we're asking people to get ready, we want to also show them the hard work that we're doing behind the scenes so it inspires them to be working together. So their government is working for them and they are getting ready on their own as well.
So I'm going to talk to you a little bit about campaign timeline so you can know what to expect and why we're going to share this information. September was preparedness month, which was a great start for us and we've shared some information about how to get connected to VC alert and how to prepare your go bag. October really is going to continue on with that theme where we're going to talk about how to get ready.
Again, building those plans having emergency kits and getting familiar with ready set go. Also this month I'm really excited to say that we're gonna launch a partner toolkit and these are resources that we're gonna share with our city partners so we have really strong great communicators at all of our 10 cities and they're gonna get this resource so they understand what the county is going to be messaging about they can share those messages too or they can just continue on to have a similar cadence to the information that we'r putting out November is going to focus on how to protect your home. Again, the sandbag resources, knowing your zone. Are you in a flood zone? Are you in an area that has significant hazards that you should be aware of?
We're going to guide people to understand that. December we're going to talk about knowing flood risks, educate people on flood map information driving tips and then January and March is when we may see ourselves head into a season that's impacted by storms We still don't know what El Nino might bring us, but what you'll see us talk about is there's a combination of preparedness information that will be shared throughout those months. But then we'll also make sure that we integrate safety messages as necessary.
Should we enter into an incident? Those will be amplified across our county channels. And just want to let you know that every month we're going to be doing that call-to-action to sign up for VC Alert. Also, and doing those features on your county at work which can be our Public Works Agency, it might be our Agriculture Department, it will be our Sheriff's Office, etc., just so people continue to see that we're active in the work that we're working on.
So our communications in action, as I mentioned, our partner toolkit is something that's going to be really great for us because it's going to have those ready-to-share posts and graphics for our local agencies. And they're going to be bilingual available in English and Spanish but what I think it really provides as value add is that it extends our reach. So the county has a fairly, really good reach across all of our social channels and some of our agencies are really massive connection with people across social media.
But as we're working together with our city partners that means that our reach goes even farther and they're hearing from trusted voices in their community that even if they're not connected to the county, they're connected to their local jurisdictions. Our approach is to try to do multi-level channels across all of our communications and so that means that we're gonna reach out to our media outlets in the community Share across social media. Send information out in our digital newsletter, which is great because we have a hundred thousand people who are signed up and receive it.
We have print materials. We're going to produce videos, which some of them have already come out. And then we already know that there's some community meetings that have taken place. And so here on the side you see an example of what we shared earlier last month about Is Your Go Bag Ready? I just want to do a quick spotlight on some of our other departments too, who are also doing some great messaging and talking about the updates and the information that they're sharing with their audiences. And so our Harbor Department is actively preparing for El Nino and doing monitoring of Hobie and Kitty Beach. Really good at thinking about what king tide impacts might be and they're communicating with residents about the plans that are coming forward for the dredging project with Army Corps of Engineers and they have a community meeting It's planned for October 21st.
Our Department of Agricultural and Weeds and Measures is also messaging to their growers in the community, really putting out information about how to get ready, connecting them with resources for a disaster preparedness workshop. And then plans in progress are to connect people with the AgPASS flood class and then also stand bag resources. So those are just two of the examples of those who haven't come up here and spoken today, but are doing some really great work.
And finally, just to wrap up that I want to talk about how we really want to encourage residents to stay informed. And these are messages that we're going to share throughout the season. Rareness information it's really key that people visit ready.venturacounty.gov this is the landing site and web page for everything where we want people to learn about how they build their go bags, how they create those stay kits, how they get connected to flood information and resources that they might need.
VC alert, again we really want people to be connected to that. They can go to readyventuracounty.gov sign up to the address that they want to receive alerts about and they'll get that information throughout the season so there'd be evacuation warnings orders or other impacts in the area where they're living or working and then they received that important information from our sheriff's office Should we enter into significant storm impacts? I just want to remind people that emergency incidents are housed on VCEmergency.com so this is the main landing page so should we land in an emergency incident where we have significant You know, it could be a fire. It could be a flood. It could be storm issues.
This is where we'll have that information. And then when we're in an incident our Sheriff's Office and Fire Department very often are in unified command so there are official channels that we then amplify across our county channels as well. So should you have any questions I'm happy to take them.
Thank you Mrs. Hernandez. Ag pass flood class can you elaborate on that?
I will have to defer to our Agricultural Commissioner. She can give you the details on that.
All right, thank you.
3:09 – 3:2024 turns
Good morning Chair Guerrero. Good morning. Members of the Board, CEO Johnson. My name is Corinne Bell for the record. I'm your Agricultural Commissioner and so we have been for the last several years conducting with Sheriff's Office of OES and County Fire the Ag Pass which allows And so with all of the different natural disasters we face. We thought that Particularly this year, it would be prudent to add a portion of that class to be on flooding specific dangers. And so I've spoken to Chief Gardner and we're already working on adding that element to our next class that we hope to host between now and December.
Okay, thank you. Can
I ask a
question
since Corinne's here? Hi Corinne! Just in fact of El Nino coming up we also have extended high heat is this hitting our ag hard is there anything that our board needs to be knowing or the agriculture industry in regards to that just concerned with the high heat and then getting ice cold in production and all of that
Yeah, so definitely when there is significant damage to our agriculture we are collecting that data. The thresholds for disaster aid is pretty significant and it's very industry specific so it's like 40% of an entire industry needs to be that information and providing that rationale if if one of these disasters hit and not something we do consistently so as I'm speaking to this current heat wave.
You know, one of the important things to do particularly for when you know in advance and that's kind of the theme of today is disaster preparedness is you can put irrigation on some of these fields in advance of these heat waves. And so I think that as long as power is available and pumps are available people can do that. And so far we've not gotten any significant reports of damage yet. So
appreciate it. Thank you.
Any other questions? Supervisor Parvin.
Question more for Natalie, I think. The question is she was just mentioning training for the ag industry and then fire was mentioning they have courses too right? So how are how can we get that communication and know when the dates are of these different trainings and events because I have egg in my district to Some of us have more or less, some have more fear of flooding that could happen. But how do we as a board get that information if somebody's interested?
So our office
has all these different websites and different sites to go to. I just want to have concise information.
Yeah, and the approach that we really have and the intention that we have is to make sure that we're not sending people to too many different websites. Right? And so really trying to intentionally make sure that Ready Ventura County is the location that we go to but related to your question what we can do is really could combine all of those calendars and we can share them with you. The other thing is that in that county newsletter that we have We can put these important classes and these important dates that people need to keep in mind and send it out.
But what we'll just, we'll make sure that we share all of that and that we make it an easy place for it to live so it can be on the website, it can be shared directly with you via email or however your office wants to communicate with us. And then we can also just make sure that we're sharing it consistently through our regular channels. Sounds good thanks.
Supervisor Lopez?
Yes, thank you, Chair. I really appreciate the presentation in terms of following up on the communications and action with the partner toolkit. Is that something that can also be shared with non-profit organizations? Just thinking of those trusted organizations, my cop, right? Radio Indígena reaching some of those additional communities through these toolkits which is one to verify how we're working with organizations
So we're starting right now with our city partners, but these are things that we can share with our community partners as well. Right? We can send that out. We have a list of these organizations that we can share to because I'll just share them with your offices because I know all of you have social media channels that you want to share that message with and will make sure that they get these resources and they understand the calendar in the cadence of what the county is messaging on. Great. Thank you.
Yeah, thank you. I'll just mention, I think the public information piece is so critical right now because interestingly, I've seen more so than ever before a really heightened sense of fear around fire and flood and we had... And there's also A lot of misinformation out there. We've had a town hall not too long ago at Leisure Village and it was you know, maybe it's because of chat GPT or just access to information. A lot of people were very they came armed with information that I'm not sure was accurate including you know somebody saying what are you going to do when The big rains start on October 15th. They actually knew the date that these rains were going to start, so I think people are educating themselves in different areas that might not be accurate and so this public information piece is key and to Supervisor Lopez's and Parvin's point as much as we can do to help get the word out ourselves through our community-based organizations Through the county family, you know please lean on us and let us know how we can how we can help out with that.
Are there any other questions? Yeah Supervisor LaVere.
Thank you Chair and I first I just really appreciate you Dr. Johnson bringing this in allowing us to have this public discussion And I think you and I have talked about it. It's we're kind of walking this tightrope in that we don't want to scare people because we don't know what's coming, but we also don't want to get caught flat-footed like Chief Sherry. You go by Chuck too right? Yeah okay. Chief Sherry.
You know it's so and I think it's really important the public knows that we as a county are taking these proactive steps to prepare and I just I know in my district Public Works has already been out scouring channels, waterways doing a lot of preventative work. I know a lot of our different agencies are doing similar work and so it's really important for the public to know that we won't get caught flat-footed that we are preparing for whatever comes. And so thank you Dr. Johnson and thank you everyone for sharing with the public all the work you're doing.
Yeah ditto. Are there any public comments on this?
Thank You Chair Gorrell there are no requests to speak for this item
OK, thanks. Over to Supervisor Lopez.
Yes. Thank you, Chair. Just wanted to see if I could ask Director Tripp to share a little bit more about the harbor work and the coastal communities there, Silver Strand and Hollywood Beach. I know there's work being done and the questions are again, I think all of us are hearing right? But if you can share a little bit more about what the department is doing, I think it's really great work.
Sure, thank you. Good morning Chair Gorel and honorable members of the board and Dr. Johnson. Yeah yeah the horror department's hard at work getting ready for these upcoming storms. The first thing that we're doing is we're documenting the condition of all of our facilities in case something is damaged. We want to be able to have that information for FEMA. The next thing that we're doing is we've hired a company to survey our beaches. The harbor department uh we control the beaches a mile north and a mile south south of the harbor and so what we want to do is basically to establish a baseline We want to know how wide those beaches are, what the elevation are where the beach crest elevations are. And so we can use that information with a coastal engineer to determine if we do need to take any preemptive moves like for instance, building berms there.
And we're also just going to use it as a baseline so we can watch as the storms come in how the erosion occurs and get an idea if we need to act based on that. Something very fortunate that's happening this year is the Army Corps of Engineers is returning again to do the beach dredging that they do every other year And so they'll be moving 1.5 million cubic yards of sand from Hollywood Beach on to Port Hueneme but the reason that this is good news is because the dredger who will be operating there, they'll be there from November until the end of February and they have heavy equipment that can be used for things like building berms if we needed to But they also have the suction dredger, which is a very powerful piece of equipment where if we do see one beach in particular getting eroded badly, we can direct sand to that specific area.
So I'm very glad to have them out there during this time. Something we do during every storm season, but that we're doing especially now is we're monitoring the forecast and we're monitoring the height of the tides. So when storms do come in, we'll be ready for it. And we're already working with our PIO and the county PIO to develop information that we're going to send out to the residents and boaters when a storm does come what they should do with their boat, for instance making sure it's secured properly, making sure all the hatches are closed so the boats don't sink And in addition to that, when the storms actually come, the Harbor Patrol boats don't stay at the docks. We're underway in the harbor looking for boaters in duress, looking for boats that have broken free and we also have pumps on our boats so when we come across boats that weren't properly secured and they're sinking, we can get on there and pump the water out of them and secure them as necessary.
So we are getting ready for that. And lastly, you know we're working with the other county departments and with the city of Oxnard in the city of Port Hueneme to make sure that when these were prepared for these storms and that when they do come. You know, we work together to deal with them.
Thank you so much Mr. Turp really appreciate and I'll echo the comments of that have the chair has shared just with everyone the work that is happening. So thank
you. Well with that is there a motion to receive and file? Moved by Janice Parvin.
Roll-call vote Moved by Janice S. Parvin · Seconded by Vianey Lopez Resubmit a File
Show transcript
3:20 – 3:2720 turns
vote.
Sorry about that. That passes unanimously thank you
Thank you everybody. Again, appreciate everyone's patience today as we're a little bit behind but it looks like we're
moving to item number 37. This is a time certain public hearing. It's the second public hearing regarding the adoption of an ordinance repealing and reenacting Chapter 3 Public Emergency. I am going to open the public hearing and ask Mr. Maynard to present.
Hi, good morning again Chair Garrell members of the board and Dr. Johnson again this item was brought before your board on September 22nd it's an effort to modernize our emergency powers ordinance today again the second public hearing which you've already opened and we'd ask that she receive public testimony and if appropriate adopt the attached ordinance which is Exhibit 1 of this board letter repealing and reenacting Chapter 3 Division 5 of the Ventura County Ordinance Code
thank you are there any public comments on this agenda item?
Thank you, Chair Groh. We do currently have one speaker for this item who's joining us today via telephone on Zoom. His name is Tim Totten. I'll have our IT promote Tim Totten so he can give his public comment.
Thank
you. Hi Mr. Totten, I see that you've been promoted. You'll need to press the star six so you can unmute your mic. Hello Mr. Totten please unmute your mic so you can give your public comment.
Thank you sorry about that I was halfway through thank you it is so uncomfortable to be the Paul to your righteous acknowledgement and celebrations of our good citizens and some of the good work our agencies can do But alas, this innocuous sounding ordinance change will consolidate government law enforcement powers during local state and national states of emergency. And we'll certainly remove the citizen mandated participants in the Ventura County Disaster Council and replace it with a quote invitation of feedback.
I would like to remind you all that government information is not necessarily the truth or the final word on a matter. I again suggest codifying a Citizen Oversight Committee with legal power and funding to hold accountable abuses of power like the free citizens of Ventura County experienced during COVID. Mandated masks, penalties for not vaccinating businesses being sued by then-Ventura County Board of Supervisors Chair Linda Parks to shut down.
Absent codifying such a diverse public role in the Disaster Council please delay approval of item 37 or additional public outreach The stand of mine today is another atheist protesting for Godspeak Church's ability to meet during the COVID lockdown moment. It doesn't matter why I'm on the same corner as others, as much as I am on the same corner fighting a just fight. I am as right today as I was back then when Bruce Boyer graciously and correctly told me that day at Godspeak we share American values.
American values does not include mass surveillance of American citizens and consolidation of government powers, excluding we the people during times of emergency period. During my number eight public comment today I paraphrase this Tao parable a frog in a well cannot discuss the ocean because he is limited by the size of his well A summer insect cannot discuss ice because it knows only its own season. A narrow-minded scholar cannot discuss the Tao because he is constrained by his teachings.
Now you have come out of your banks and seen the great ocean, you now know your own inferiority so now it is possible to discuss great principles with you. I search for other frogs perched atop their wells who gaze toward the ocean waves and can I get a rivet?
Thank you for your comment Mr. Totten. Chair Geraldo concludes the public comment for this item.
All right are there any questions by staff? Supervisor Lopez
Yes, thank you Chair. Thank you Mr. Maynard for spending the entire morning with us. Just to recap what we're doing would you mind just explaining what happens now in transitioning from the council or reassigning the council to the Board of Supervisors? What happens with everyone who has been involved and what their role is continuing or moving forward?
Thank you, Supervisor Lopez for the question. So our intent is to continue the discussion having a body that is designated by the board makes that very difficult to maintain a large roster and keep that active and current and meet Brown Act requirements again we plan to continue those conversations we haven't continued them nothing will change there I think the difference is just keeping a Brown Act body around and maintaining a roster that's been designated by the board aside from that no big change
Got it. So technically that list of people would still be convening, it wouldn't be under any Brown Act meeting notice requirements anything like that?
You are absolutely correct we will continue to meet with all of the partners especially the NGOs and again the need to meet is on a as-needed basis so generally revolves around plan updates or emergency operations plan which will come before your board in the next couple months and our local hazard mitigation plan but that work will continue as it has
And with again bringing that responsibility, the role to the Board of Supervisors. Is it the approval of the plans that would come in a planned anticipated notice or would there be a need for the board to meet on a special notice special meeting emergency notice? Just wanting to better understand what our role is, because you know I respect and recognize the work that all of you do. First responders everyone involved in emergency response and what that means now for the board to take on that role in this process and the work that you all do.
Yeah, so thank you again for that question. There's a lot that we do in a hurry but planning especially our emergency operations plan and our local hazard mitigation plan are not things we do in a hurry. In fact the local hazard mitigation plan which we're working on right now is about a one-and-a-half year process it's It includes several community meetings, one that's coming up here in November. In the city of Camarillo our emergency operations plan goes through a very similar process not quite as often.
One of the changes that we are adding into this ordinance in fact with respect to our emergency operations plan is that we update it on a regular basis. We want to continue the community feedback we will always post these plans online. We will always host some type of either in person or online town hall to see community feedback and we're always happy to answer any questions again at the end of those, you know planning processes. We will always bring these items before the board there will always be an opportunity for public comment and feedback. There's no reason to rush any of that part of the process.
Thank you.
All right, thank you. If there's no other questions I am going to close the public hearing and turn it back to the board for motion deliberation first and second.
Roll-call vote Moved by Janice S. Parvin · Seconded by Matt LaVere approve staff recommendations has been
Show transcript
3:28 – 3:335 turns
all right
and that passes unanimously Thank
You Thank you very much. We're going to now
move to agenda item number 38 it's a public hearing this is a public hearing regarding adoption of the county Ventura County ordinance repealing and reenacting division 13 of the ordinance regarding abatement of public nuisances I'm gonna open the public hearing and turn this over to Mr. Mullane how are you sir thank you for your patience
Thank you chair and good morning supervisors. Dr. Johnson, Mr. Berg. I'm Rob Mullane with the Resource Management Agency and before you today for first reading in our first public hearing is a update to our Public Nuisance Abatement Ordinance We have this coming to the board as a joint presentation or joint board letter from Public Works Agency and the Resource Management Agency. And we've been working very closely with County Council over the last several months to bring an ordinance forward that really embodies the need to have more effective enforcement provisions for both public works and for code compliance It streamlines the process. It gets at areas that have been very difficult to achieve a resolution with the tools that we have at our disposal now, and some of those tools are very severely limited as you'll hear from some of the other speakers at this item.
We often find ourselves in a situation because of the ineffectiveness of our existing enforcement measures where people are either impatient for violation to be addressed. It's not being dressed in a timely fashion, it takes months to get through the appeal process as we have it now, or we're in a situation where the enforcement actions that we can take are so ineffective that the violation doesn't get resolved for in some cases several years or even decades because the only action that we can take currently on some and for some of these cases is to record a notice of non-compliance on a property. And that really only gets, that really only has an impact when there's either a need to refinance the property or if the property is changing hands, being sold.
I found our staff in the position and probably some of you supervisors have heard from your constituents where there's an obvious violation that may be impacting a neighbor next door very severely and we tell them well we can record a notice of noncompliance on the property and that's all we can do That is not good governance, that is not being responsive to our rules and regulations. And unfortunately what we have to tell the neighbor that's being impacted by the violation is well unfortunately it's all the county can do but you're welcome to take your neighbor to court and file a lawsuit against your neighbors so again that is something we would like to be able to address and that's why that's one of the main motivations for taking this ordinance forward The other members that will be speaking today from Greg Strockolous' team, Anastasia Seams will be speaking on behalf of Public Works and then Jonathan Wood our Code Compliance Director will be taking the presentation once I'm done with my introductory remarks.
Again, as we often say before the board and with our applicants, even with the violators, our goal is compliance. Compliance is the goal. Our goal is not to be unreasonably It's punitive, it's to bring about compliance and we have a lot of flexibility in how we go about that now but we need more effective endorsement tools and that's what this ordinance brings forward. You did get a correspondence from the Ventura County Farm Bureau and it does raise a number of concerns and has a few specific requests I would say that we keep in mind and you'll hear more from the other speakers that we are, in addition to bringing this ordinance forward, we are also going to be putting into place our own internal policies for how we go about different compliance efforts.
And there's a lot of flexibility in those policies to again emphasize that compliance is a goal not being overly punitive We have measures in here that are really geared towards very serious violations. They're geared towards repeat violators, violators that are intransigent or recalcitrant and are thumbing their nose at the county's regulations knowing that our current enforcement methods are just not very effective so That's just some introductory remarks and I want to turn it over to Jonathan Wood next. And oh, let me, I'm sorry, I want to say one more thing. So this is a first reading if there were changes from the board directed we would like to have some specifics on that so that we can continue on with the second reading which is scheduled in two weeks.
The but I would say that a lot of the feedback that we've received from this letter you may hear other public testimony. We will be able to build those into our internal administrative policies and again, I think our practice has been to be very flexible with looking again at the goal of getting compliance. Compliance is our goal, not to be overly heavy handed.
But there are some cases where we do need better tools and that's what this ordinance would bring forward to the county staff. So with that I'm going to turn it over to Jonathan Wood our Code Compliance Director.
3:33 – 3:4614 turns
Good morning Chair, members of the Board and Dr. Johnson my name is Jonathan Wood Code Compliance Director for the County of Ventura. The county's public nuisance abatement ordinance is not new it was initiated or initially adopted in 1968 and was last revised in 1997 a lot has changed in nearly 30 years including state laws and tools available to address public nuisances The proposed ordinance modernizes and streamlines the county's existing process while maintaining our primary focus on education and voluntary compliance. It also updates provisions of the current ordinance that are no longer consistent with state law.
When code compliance confirms a violation, the property owner is provided with a notice of violation explaining the violation what is required to correct it and the next steps in the enforcement process. Our focus is education and voluntary compliance. When voluntary compliance is not achieved, a notice of non-compliance can be recorded against the property and administrative citations may be issued to encourage compliance. Under the current ordinance however our administrative enforcement options become very limited after those steps have been taken.
As a result, these are cases where a violation remains unresolved for years. In some instances compliance is not ultimately achieved until the property changes ownership because of the recorded notice of non-compliance that can mean a public nuisance remains unresolved for years or potentially decades. The proposed ordinance provides the county with additional administrative tools to achieve timely compliance while preserving due process for property owners.
One of the most significant changes is a streamlined hearing process that addresses both liability and the appropriate remedy, which may include an order to abate the imposition of administrative penalties or both. Under state law, that hearing may be conducted in one of two ways. The first is before a county hearing officer who renders a final administrative decision. The second is before a three-person ad hoc hearing body which makes findings of fact and a proposed decision that may then be considered and adopted by your board based on the record of that hearing. Both options are authorized by state law and proposed under this ordinance.
The proposed ordinance also increases the maximum administrative penalty from 1,000 to up to 10,000 per violation per day. I want to emphasize up to $10,000. The ordinance does not establish a standard 10, 000 per day penalty rather it establishes a maximum amount and requires penalties to be proportional to the violation reasonably necessary to obtain compliance and evenly handedly applied A penalty approaching the 10,000 maximum would be reserved for the most serious and warranted circumstances.
Ultimately, the proposed ordinance gives the county a modern legally compliant and more effective process for addressing public nuisances while continuing to prioritize voluntary compliance in providing property owners with due process while recovering the cost of abatement and enforcement including attorney's fees. For the rest of the presentation I will turn it over to Anastasia from Public Works.
Good morning Chair Garrell, members of the board and Dr. Johnson my name is Anastasia Symes I'm the Director of Engineering Services in the Public Works Agency. The current Administrative Enforcement Authority doesn't apply to all of the violations that occur in the county and that staff needs to respond to specifically we have some ordinances that are though we have listed here but As examples is if there's work that occurs in a redline channel or if there is grading or work occurring in a floodplain. In those cases currently we will be able to send a notice, request an inspection and follow up with the property owner that is performing the violation If there isn't voluntary compliance then unfortunately what we're able to do is record a notice of non-compliance and wait for the violation to be corrected.
This could take months, it could take years sometimes decades like what was discussed earlier so with this proposed ordinance we are creating a one due process hearing on both the liability and the remedy which is in order to abate and the imposition of penalties That allows us for situations in which there isn't voluntary compliance where we've exhausted all of our other options that we are then able to actually issue a notice to abate and assess those penalties, to try to get to a point where there is compliance with the code and bringing about that compliance with that violation.
And so that is, it creates an intermediary step between what we have now and going to litigation which are currently our options. So that's the purpose of the proposal for these other situations in which we don't have kind of a hearing process like there is for code enforcement. And so that brings us to the reason why there's two recommendations in the board letter. One is for the Board of Supervisors for County Ventura related to the nuisance ordinance and the public hearing for that. The other is related to, for the board as a, for the Ventura County Watershed Protection District, so that the nuisance ordinance is incorporated in an ordinance for the watershed protection districts.
And with that, we are all available for questions. So thank you.
Thank you. Appreciate the presentation. Any questions from Supervisor LaVere?
Thank you, Chair. I appreciate you bringing this to us. I'm sure my colleagues have had similar frustrations with problem property owners where I think county staff is trying their best to get compliance with different violations and we're kind of very hamstrung with what we're able to do to get that kind of final compliance And one of the issues that we've come up with is, or that we've seen is that there's no ability beyond filing the notice of violation.
But now we're gonna be able to file these not only the increased penalties but also liens right? Is that something we'll be able to do now and also if we do see a lien issued are we going to be able to foreclose on that lien judicially For the worst for the worst of the worst to just completely ignore County County attempts to seek voluntary compliance.
Yeah, thank you chair girl. Supervisor live your Jeff Barnes chief assistant County Council. You're correct that the ordinance provides a path to place lanes which will go on the property tax rules and so Basically recouping the county's abatement costs. Well, it is definitely a process and my understanding is the county won't directly be able to foreclose based on our lien but it will be on the tax roll and so it'll be more effective way of the county basically recouping its cost through the tax roll process
So rather than having to file a lawsuit to foreclose on the lien, that the lien would be recovered through the property tax assessments?
Exactly. Yeah, that's right because like you said otherwise the county would have to go to Superior Court, file a lawsuit, it would take a year or two get a judgment and then we would have a judgment lien basically and so we'll have the ability to do that administratively now.
So there but now so I guess yeah before there was no avenue to collect these penalties. Now this is going to give us that avenue to collect penalties.
Correct and I just want to emphasize again because we can't say it enough times that this ordinance in this process will be reserved for the egregious cases where all other means of obtaining compliance fail And including even before sending out the first notice of abatement, staff always makes informal efforts to obtain compliance. It's not like they just send out the notice blind and then hammer from there.
All those reasonable methods of obtaining compliance have failed. It is an egregious case and this is a tool to go down that path.
Yeah, you're right Mr. Barnes I've been really impressed with our code and public works teams in terms of their efforts to try to seek voluntary compliance. I found in my experience very professional courteous attempts trying to work with people to come into compliance. My concern is like you said sometimes there's going to be an egregious actor that I wanted to make sure we had avenues open to us that didn't have before.
And I guess just in terms of another policy point and practical points without this tool. And basically under the status quo, what's happening is staff spends a lot of time for we've heard for years or for decades addressing these violation cases that money comes out of the general fund. And so basically everyone's paying for it. And so this will provide a means So we think that's an important policy consideration right. Thank you. Thank you chair to thank in the past we've had issues with a tenant on a property versus the landowner so Yeah, so under the current our current non-coastal zoning ordinance and I'm assuming it would be the same here. Like the short answer is there would be flexibility in terms of who is a responsible party but where I'm going with this is at the end of the day legally the property owner is ultimately responsible for the actions of the tenant.
The primary responsibility under our zoning ordinances The permittee and so if there's a land use permit then it's that the permit to the permit holder. If it's a tenant, landlord tenant type situation that might be different. And so again there needs to be flexibility but If the tenant doesn't have a land use permit, then the property owner would be primarily responsible. But the way this nuisance abatement ordinance is worded, it provides the county the flexibility to determine who is a responsible party and basically says that everyone involved can be made responsible because every situation could be different.
And then what happens if I hypothetically that the tenant then got caught just as bankruptcy. And then it gets rolled on to the property owner? I'm trying to understand.
Exactly, at the end of the day the property owner is responsible because the property owner has a legal relationship with their tenant or their permittee and so the property owner is responsible for achieving compliance and if they don't and if the county has to deal with it and incur costs And penalties and like we said worst case scenario for the property owner and again, it's 99 times out of 100. It wouldn't come to this but the County could obtain a lien put it on the properties tax rolls to recoup the county's costs from the property owner.
Okay. So then once it once the violation is triggered that it what how many days does it go before? It's triggered that says we have to have a hearing
3:46 – 3:5113 turns
The recipient of the notice to abate has the opportunity to appeal. Let's see, and I believe it's a 30-day period to file an appeal.
Okay so once they file an appeal does their daily accruing of fees stop? I'm trying to get as quickly as just to get it fixed. So so the sooner they appeal and and get a hearing and pay the fees or is it lined out? I just wanted to make sure are they can they recruiting fees until it gets to the hearing? And they have no control of when that hearing is,
I believe the fees don't start to accrue until they've had the appeal hearing
Okay.
And then the amount of the penalty is fixed during that hearing.
Okay, and then in the letter from Farm Bureau it's talking about the hearing structure does not provide independent review and the ordinance displaces existing appeal rights. Could you comment on that?
Of course, yeah. So the ordinance does provide for independent review either you know as I think Mr. Mullane described a hearing officer or hearing board and so we disagree with you know the fact there is no independent review. The other point that was raised in which is a good one is And maybe this is only part of the point is what happens if the appeal concerns a permit condition or zoning ordinance provision that is ambiguous or might you know implicate policy concerns.
If that's the situation then staff I'm going to go through the process that exists now which would be appealable to Basically giving the alleged violator the right to decide which path to take would be and we saw with this with that with the Camarillo event venue case. The violator would then have the authority basically to decide which process, which path to go down and you know as we've heard the zoning ordinance path that goes through the Planning Commission and Board takes Many, many months to get to a point where a violation is confirmed. And in that time the violation continues with no repercussions to the violator. And so I would not support basically even suggesting that the violator has the authority to decide which violations get appealed to the Planning Commission and Board but that staff will have every opportunity I think it's really important to make sure that you know the zoning ordinance is.
Appropriately, you know go down the right path and if it may not like I said if it's really a tricky. Ambiguous provision that has policy implications then the violation could be routed through the zoning ordinance and taken to your board
okay so then the independent review
It's a third party and that it's individuals who have had no involvement with basically enforcing the violation. And so they could be county staff, but they're not involved. They're different than the prosecutor if you will.
Okay thank you and then the cost for going into the appeal? How is that correlated or how is that computed?
Yeah, so that's the same as we do now. It's no different. It will be it's basically a fee based on the reasonable costs of providing the appeal hearing and so the county cannot charge more than those reasonable costs and so it's a matter of computing how many stop hours that takes or if it's an independent hearing officer that we're going to hire through the state which is also another option and what are the costs of that and passing along those reasonable cost to the to the alleged violator.
Thank you I appreciate it sounds very thought out and that's why was asking the questions on to get an understanding as to how it would roll so I appreciate it very much
course. Okay, thanks let's hear from public comments.
3:51 – 4:028 turns
Thank you, Chair Gorrell. We currently have two speakers signed up for this item. Our first speaker is going to be Jane Farkas followed by Louise Lampara. Jane please proceed to the podium and give three minutes to give your comment.
Good afternoon, Chair Gorel, honorable supervisors. Dr. Johnson, Jane Farkas, JLNR Consulting. I started my land use consulting firm about three years ago and what started out as an idea of permitting new projects has turned into a firm that spends 90% of its time working on code compliance cases. I'm concerned about how this new ordinance is written and what it will do to the small businesses, homeowners, small agriculture, and the elderly. These are the people I'm helping The language in this new ordinance doesn't discriminate between historic bad actors and the common citizen who may not understand the permitting process or who may not have received the notices of violation from code, which happens more frequently than you would expect due to address inconsistencies.
For example, I met a client about two weeks ago in the RMA lobby. I'm going to call him Bill for this discussion. He was facing hundreds of thousands of dollars in penalties and fines associated with the property he inherited. Code had been sending notices of violations for this property to the wrong address Thankfully, I was able to negotiate a settlement agreement with Director Wood who has been incredible and open to negotiations and discussions. But how many other bills in the county have been fined under these same circumstances?
And then, and there are others that we can talk about. You know people who have slipped through the cracks and I'm happy to share with them with you at a later time. If this ordinance is focused on certain bad actors then it needs to be described as such not a blanket ordinance that affects every business every property owner in the county. I understand that RMA and Public Works want to update that may Thank you for your comment. Our next speaker is going to be Louise Lampara.
Good morning Chair Gorel, Supervisors Louise Lampera, Farm Bureau of Ventura County. I think we actually agree on the intended use of this ordinance. Staff describes it as an extraordinary enforcement tool for urgent threats for recalcitrant parties and for cases where the county has to front the cost of abatement. And I've heard reassurances from staff based on how the county has handled such cases in the past But there's a fundamental problem with that logic.
You're being asked to adopt this ordinance today because staff says the county currently doesn't have the enforcement tools it needs, so the fact that the county is asserting that it hasn't misused powers that it never had in the past is not an indication as to how such powers will be used in the future. The language in the ordinance itself doesn't limit this authority to the circumstances everyone in this room says it's intended for. It's broadly written, broadly applicable and relies almost exclusively on staff discretion and interpretation to ensure that it's applied judiciously and as staff today says it's intended Well, this board knows better than probably anyone in this county how difficult it is to correct an administrative process once staff discretion and interpretation have drifted somewhere they were never intended to go.
You're trying to correct that now in your three-year effort for permit reform and to streamline county processes. Unintended consequences from county ordinances and policies are something that I stand at this podium and tell you about over, and over, and over again. Impacts to real farmers, real property owners, and real businesses from ordinances being applied and interpreted the way they were never intended to be.
So my request is simple. Before the adoption on October 20th, direct staff to write the intended limits that they've expressed to you today into the ordinance itself. The three circumstances staff described a tolling provision so penalties do not accrue while a property owner is waiting on the county and an independent hearing officer opinion because County staff is not independent Good intentions are not enough.
If we agree on the intended limits of this authority that this ordinance should only be applied to as Supervisor LaVere said, the worst of the worst of the worst then let's put that in the ordinance. Thank you.
Thank you for your comment Chair Garrell that concludes a public comment for this item thank you
all right thank you any Let's bring it back to the board. Any questions of staff before I close a public hearing? All right, I'm going to close the public hearing then and bring it back for deliberations or motion. Any questions? I mean we're done with questions any concerns? I do want to just say that this additional language did not come from staff. I think came from the Board I think it came from the board directing the staff to come back with these greater tools.
The greater tools were made necessary, and I recognize that these are very significant and really powerful tools that need to be exercised with great caution and care. The tools are necessary, unfortunately because we do have bad actors who understand that our most powerful tool to date has just been fines. And those fines can easily be incorporated into a business model whereby those fines are simply paid and then folded into the cost of doing business in a fraudulent manner against county codes.
It's been most clear to me and most visible to me recently because of the surge in use of residential property for commercial purposes, And in places where the residential area is very congested and it's very clear that residents in and around the commercial operation don't support it, and are very vocal, and are very frustrated with the county's inability to act.
And when we do ask our team to act their greatest authority at this point, their greatest tool at this point is just merely a fine. And again those fines are then simply included in the cost of doing business for these individuals who are who are acting out. I wish it was a way to describe historic bad actors that was kind of brought up as a term a few times here, maybe there's a way to articulate that through the procedural context that RMA suggests that they will develop internally I do think the most powerful to hear here is the most important.
The next step, I think, is to identify the most expeditious a way for an appeal so that if there is an error like was suggested with the The mailing address or if there is an inappropriate use of this powerful tool for whatever purposes either because it was done erroneously or because it was done through some vindictive process. That there be a swift method to appeal that with as much as possible and independent approach Before somebody has to go through the more lengthy process and appeal it to the full Board of Supervisors.
So I understand the concerns that are brought forward about the county adopting for itself these really powerful, powerful tools that can really usurp private property rights in many ways But I think that this is really born out of just feeling incapable of acting in some of the recent egregious kind of, and again historic bad actor contexts. So that's why I'm supporting moving this along at this point. I do hope that we continue to receive input for those individuals who feel like they're maybe affected by this and I do think that an ordinance could evolve over time, for sure as we learn and utilize it but I think it's enormously important that we adopt something more than we have now and this is what we're acting on now Anything else Board?
Supervisor Partman.
I just wanted to follow up on the Firm Bureau, they did ask a question about the amount of money could it be capped is that something is that too defined to put in within this document and you
want to leave it open? I'm going to open the public hearing again sorry to ask a question have received
The question about the amount of the penalty and so this is getting into the weeds a little bit but in terms of civil penalties. One provision says $10,000 per day you know per violation or such greater amount as authorized by law. That kind of open-ended provision applies if the county goes to court and so there's civil I'm going to talk a little bit about what we're doing here. So the first thing that we're doing is we're looking at litigation when we're abating a nuisance, but then if you drop down into the next subsection it's actually capped it for and this is where it's administrative. If it's at the county level, I should say nothing's obvious, but in my mind that obviously wouldn't be the default. So there actually is a cap if it's administrative we just left it open when we're going to court because That could be a very serious situation and the county could be eligible for seeking greater penalties in that scenario
4:02 – 4:159 turns
Since you reopened the public hearing I guess one question I had is, are you seeking direction from us when the appeals been discussed whether to move forward with the three person hearing body or the single hearing officer? Or is that something that you want both of those.
We are not the ordinance allows for either those options to be taken and I do want to address the appeal. Options because as Mister Barnes pointed out one of our options for if there is a case where it was zoning interpretation. So we would have the option on a zoning interpretation to bring it through the existing appeal process now at the Planning Commission.
and then appealable to the Board of Supervisors. The two options that we're putting forth in the public nuisance ordinance are either this three-person hearing board, which then—that's not the end of the road. They actually present a report to the Board of Supervisors that the Board of Supervisors then says yes, we agree or no, we do not agree. But there's not a second public hearing before the Board of Supervisors. So that's one option that we get it's not just county staff making a decision in a vacuum, it's something that is then delivered to the board for final action and then as far as independent That's the hearing officer. The hearing officer is not a county staff person we don't have that they don't have that office in house right now, we would be going out and Jeff correct me if I'm wrong to it.
A service that would provide like an administrative law judge staff person that would be able to decide on that and that's a final decision that does not get appealed to the board but that isn't independent review it so there are there's lots of flexibility for different appeal provisions and it's going to depend on the situation. A lot of times we do not want a long lengthy appeal process, especially if there is a nuisance happening and neighbors are getting affected that's when we would probably prefer to go to a hearing officer and just have it, you know, not have to get on the planning commission agenda, not have to get on the board agenda And just go that route, but it does allow us for those options.
And I think our preference would be the hearing officer for cases where we really feel like time is of the essence that we need to finalize this and not have it drawn out for months and months and months.
And I just want to say I appreciate the chair's comments. That's exactly kind of how I feel about this ordinance today so thank you
And if there's no other questions, I'm going to once again close the public hearing bring it back for motion or action.
Roll-call vote Moved by Jeff Gorell · Seconded by Matt LaVere approve staff recommended actions has been
Show transcript
Yes
All right, that passes unanimously and I will read the title of the ordinances into record. The first ordinance for the County of Ventura is an Ordinance of the County of Ventura State of California Repealing and Reenacting Division 13 of the Ventura County Ordinance Code in its entirety regarding abatement of public nuisances and administrative penalties And the second ordinance for the Watershed Protection District is titled an Ordinance of the Ventura County Watershed Protection District regarding abatement of public nuisances and administrative penalties. Thank you.
Thank you. That's it, I think we're good. We are now going to do agenda item 39 on a regular agenda that is receiving file presentation on the 101 Improvement Program
Good afternoon Chair Garrell, members of the Board, CEO Dr. Johnson. For the record Anita Balin Director for Roads and Transportation with the Public Works Agency. As a daily... The item before you is presentation on the 101 Improvement Program as a daily commuter on 101 from Thousand Oaks to Ventura and back I feel the pain of sitting in traffic on a daily basis twice a day Ventura County Transportation Commission is the lead sponsor for this program and project. And I'd like to invite Amanda Fagan, the Planning Director from VCTC to give the presentation. Thank you.
Good afternoon, Chair Guerrero and members of the board and Dr. Johnson. Thank you for this opportunity to speak with you this afternoon on what is arguably one of the most significant transportation projects in our county in a generation. We have reached an important milestone in this project, so I know that many if not all of you have seen this presentation more than once.
So I'll be giving an abbreviated version today. The U.S. 101 Improvement Project Study Area extends from Moorpark Road in the City of Thousand Oaks through the cities of Camarillo and Oxnard to State Route 33 in the city of Ventura. Of course, U. S. 101 is the major coastal route that connects northern central and southern parts of our state Regionally, it connects Ventura County with our neighboring counties of Los Angeles and Santa Barbara.
And serves as both a regional connection and a main street connecting our communities with one another and serving as a critical link in a resilient transportation system. Over half of Ventura County's jobs and residences are located within the three-mile corridor along US 101. The 101 has long been identified as the highway network's greatest area of need, with aging infrastructure, no continuous alternate routes, peak period speeds forecast to drop and travel times to increase, and constraining person and goods movement.
In collaboration with Caltrans and our local partners, VCTC has taken a regional multimodal approach to finding solutions to congestion on the 101 and to planning for the future of our transportation system. At each step along the way, VCTC has actively engaged local stakeholders including the county and the public. Within the project area, US 101 consists primarily of three general purpose lanes or regular lanes in each direction.
Auxiliary lanes are located in certain select locations, primarily in Thousand Oaks. There are no existing HOV lanes located within Ventura County. The defined purpose of this project is to improve traffic conditions by improving trip reliability, achieving regional HOV connectivity, supporting regional prosperity and improving the efficiency of our public transit system.
The overarching project need is to improve trip reliability and traffic operations. A wide range of alternatives were considered for this project, ranging from a no-build alternative to several HOV lane configurations, a reversible lane, elevated transitway, general purpose lanes and a combination of lane configurations. After careful evaluation of these evaluations compared with the purpose and need for the project, three alternatives were ultimately approved by the project development team for further study. The no-build alternative, one HOV express bus lane with auxiliary lanes and one HOV express bus lane with auxiliary lanes and design variations.
So last week we, oh I'm sorry. Excuse me. I was one slide ahead of myself. So last week we achieved an important milestone in the project and that is the beginning of public circulation. Following the public circulation phase of the project, we will select a preferred alternative and develop early action phasing strategies and then adopt a final environmental impact report and environmental assessment So public circulation began of the draft environmental impact report and environmental assessment began on September 30th, and we will hold public hearings in November.
The total estimated construction cost of the alternatives for Alternative 2, it's $1.8 billion and Alternative 3, $2.2 billion. As you can imagine with the numbers that high, the construction will be phased over approximately a 20-year period. We do currently have about $218 million programmed for construction to begin in 2031. That funding consists of Surface Transportation Block Grant and Surface Transportation Improvement Plant or STIP program funding that has been saved by VCTC since about 2013.
Potential early action projects will be determined based on cost effectiveness to provide the highest level of benefits with the least costs. So we will be holding public hearings in November, one in each of the corridor cities beginning on November 4th. We'll also hold a virtual public hearing on Saturday, November 14th to accommodate folks who can't attend a weekday meeting.
So the public circulation period will continue through December 7th. The draft environmental document is now available on our website at OurFuture101.org Public comments are due by Monday, December 7th Comments may be submitted to Caltrans. Of course, all of this information for submitting public comments is available on the Our Future 101 website. We are using our existing social media and webpage resources to provide updates and share information about the public circulation.
Postcards have also been delivered to all residences and businesses within one mile of the project corridor. So approximately 75,000 of our friends and neighbors received notices either last week or early this week of the availability of the environmental document for public review. The social media Instagram pages handle is Our Future 101 And again, the website is our future one oh one dot org.
So with that I'd like to say thank you for this time. Thank you to the county staff who've participated in the project development team all of these years. This environmental document and phase of planning has been underway since twenty eighteen so this is a long time in the coming but again thank you for your time and we look forward to Friday's commission meeting.
4:15 – 4:3018 turns
Yeah well thank you for this and appreciate the presentation and for your patience today.
Oh, thank you so much.
All right is there a motion to receive and file or is
that?
Roll-call vote Passed Moved by Matt LaVere · Seconded by Jeff Gorell receive on file
Show transcript
you very much See you on Friday. We're gonna take up item 42 that's just the correspondence agenda is there a motion to adopt?
Item number 42, motion to receive and file moved by Supervisor LaVere seconded by Supervisor Grell all in favor please say aye. Aye. Any opposed or abstentions? Hearing none that passes unanimously thank you.
All right thank you we're gonna now move to County Board comments and CEOs agenda item 40 Madam CEO
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So three quick things I want to put out a reminder for this Saturday at the Museum of Ventura County our library is hosting the One County One Book it's Lisa C.'s Daughters of the Sun and Moon and the author will be there for discussion. It'll be at 10am so we encourage anyone who's interested to be there. Second as a reminder as we're going through excessive heat many of our county libraries serve as cooling centers so you can go to library.venturacounty.gov And you'll see cooling centers, you can press on it and you'll see the different libraries that are available as cooling centers during regular hours. They also have hydration stations so if you need to get out of the heat we want you to be safe and that is a good place to go.
And then lastly, our Harbor Department. They have a lot of cool events coming up on this Sunday they have the ponies by the sea car show from 10am to 3pm and then on October 24th there have their pumpkin paddle at 10am and their parade of frights in the evening starting I believe at six o'clock Thank You mr. Chair that concludes my remarks
thank you don't just turn over to supervisor Lopez
Thank you, Chair. I want to start off by thanking a few people starting with two weeks ago held a community meeting for the beach residents focused on short term rentals. So I want to thank Rob Mullane, Jonathan Wood, Dean Fanoof and Mark Pacheco who attended and presented. It was a really good conversation and appreciate staff presenting on the short term rental or Ordinance and talking about the enforcement actions, taking into consideration some of the feedback from residents about the process and how to better communicate with staff.
And thank you to Supervisor LeVere who was also there listening in the back will continue to gather feedback and work with our made to discuss some potential improvements for the future. And second, I wanted to thank Environmental Health Department staff. Charles Ginkle, Carrie Svoboda and Imunu received some concerns about mosquitoes. I think we've all been victims of the mosquitoes.
And just appreciate the information they shared, some messaging to share with some residents specifically around the Cal State Channel Islands campus. They've been really hit over there. So I appreciate that work. Some of the events that I attended recently, I think alongside some of you, Supervisor Long and Supervisor Parvin. The Ventura County Sheriff's Basic Academy class graduation really great event. Great to see more members join our local law enforcement agencies And later that evening, I attended the West Ventura County Business Alliance Military Appreciation Awards. I presented some certificates on behalf of the board to a number of honorees. I also attended the Hands Across The Sand community event hosted by Seafrogs Sierra Club and Surfrider to raise awareness in opposition to increased offshore oil and gas drilling off the Ventura County coast And I know there's a number of other events that I won't go down the list of, but I want to end with a number of names that I've submitted requesting we adjourn in memory of.
But I want to call out one specific Audelio Martinez who passed away on August 17th at the young age of 60. He was born on May 29th in Guanajuato Mexico Out of necessity, at 14 years old he left his home country with his older brother and came to the U.S. in search of a better opportunity. He started working in the oil fields in Texas and eventually made his way to California where he worked in various crops and eventually landed in raspberries working every job possible.
In 1989 he became a mediero which is a sharecropper and in 1995 alongside his brother Renato he became an independent grower This kind of boldness and drive embodied much of who Audelio was, emblematic of the American dream. He was undocumented and through the Reagan amnesty he built the American dream with his own hands. He was a visionary driven by a deep sense of fairness in everything he did. He led with humility passion and integrity. He was old school If he said he was going to do something, he did it because he had given his word. He always returned a phone call or text and carried a deep sense of obligation in everything he did. He often told his daughters that if they were going to do something they had to do it right and give it their all.
He had a kind but strong character with the deep sense of doing the right thing even when it came at his own expense. He is, leaves behind his wife Maria Luna and his daughters Patty and Sarita that some of us may know with an extended family that included the employees of Mars Farms many of whom worked alongside him for most of their lives and became family in every sense of the word. So I send my deep condolences to the Martinez family and all those who knew him And for those who didn't know him. He was very humble very quiet and it was the response to his passing I was very telling of who he was as a person and member of our community, especially in agriculture. Thank you chair. Thank you
supervisor apartment
Thank you. We participated in the Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce Legislative Advocacy Forum, and I was guest speaker at the Women's Information Network meeting in Simi Valley. The topic was finding your voice so had a lot of fun with that one. I attended the Ventura County Sheriff's Office Basic Academy graduation with my colleagues, where three officers from Simi Valley Police Department graduated and Officer Guadalupe Guzman who received the F. Morton Pittman Memorial Award that exemplifies dedication, integrity and work ethic. There were 42 total graduates. It was pretty great, pretty special.
We attended the banana festival, lots of bananas Came home with lots of bananas. I met the new district manager of the Rancho Simi Recreation and Parks District, Steve Wright. I believe you met him as well?
Yeah.
Interviewed candidates for El Rancho Simi Public Cemetery Board. Believe it or not, people are applying for that position especially during Halloween season. Met with the fire chief, participated in a film meeting with the city of Simi Valley, Simi Valley Chamber of Commerce and Film Industry Professionals. Congratulations to Lisa Greenlinger of Garden Grove Elementary for receiving Simi Valley Teacher of the Month.
This past weekend, my staff and I were tortured by participating in the Moorpark Country Days Parade and Street Fair followed by the following day, the Moorpark Mammoth Run 5K-10K. Needless to say we're lively this week. Lastly, I'd like to adjourn this meeting in memory of the individuals that provided the clerk at the board However, I'd like to recognize a dear friend that passed Joe Casella. Joe was a longtime owner of Pacific Building Materials in Simi Valley. He is not only a respected local businessman but also someone who believed in giving back to the community. He's kind of like the father to a lot of people I know.
If they lost their father he kind of adopted them. But he was on the Boys and Girls Club board with me, and I got to know him really well. And yes, he's got such great heart. I know his hard work and generosity and commitment to Simi Valley has left a lasting impression on the many who had the privilege of knowing him. I'm glad I was one of them. Our thoughts and condolences are with his family and friends and employees and all those who knew him appreciate it. Thank you. Condolences
Supervisor Long.
Thank you very much. Since last meeting, it kind of merges. So I might as well just say since the last meeting not you know when. I attended the rural counties representative California's annual meeting in Santa Barbara. It was key to go there. I'm on the Sigma subcommittee for CSAC and working with rural counties in regards to water and Sigma regulations is really important.
Also as a California 211 board member, it's really important that we have our rural counties actually have 211 numbers as a dial-up. We have several that don't have them and making sure we have that connection is really key. We really do need to advocate for access to food healthcare security and it's just as simple as putting 211 to be able to call. So I was up there representing and also for CSAC. Also, we had the grand reopening and ribbon cutting of the New Hall Mansion in Piru. This historical landmark has been a Heritage Valley treasure throughout the centuries and new owners Kenny and Betty Lou Wiseman. Also thank you for your service for the PNC has been preserving this beautiful building as a wedding and event more Venue, sorry twisted there.
They honored its history through bringing new energy to local economies so congratulations to the Wiseman's also really proud of the criminal justice team. Congratulations for the last training center Academy class 2026-1 it was a wonderful event to go to. Also attended the banana festival did you know that we import over 5 million bananas? Five million bananas, that's a lot of bananas a day.
But what it represents is our local economy, our labor, our businesses that use the port. We're not only importing in but we're exporting and I just want to say thank you to that partnership with the Port of Waimea. Also, we had our California State University Channel Islands dinner President's Dinner and key speakers just really appreciate the partnership with our education.
They just had a site committee retreat and we were talking about how do we link the port? How do we link our Navy base and our bio centers are bioengineering bio areas to the college to make it more impactful for those who are graduating that they can have jobs coming out into markets. Also, I was fortunate to go to the El Castillo's Family Services. They hosted their 36th annual Latino Leadership Award. I want to really say congratulations to Claudia Bautista, Omar Zapata and the Mission Produce. They were among those that received awards that night And then it was mentioned earlier, but the Interface Children's Family Services Hope and Light Gala. Thank you to Eric Sternard for his work through so much we had speakers on domestic violence and homelessness he's been over 20 years.
In that such a passion so it was nice to be there for him. And then also I have those two adjourn in memory and those lists, thank you for your service Thomas Giggler also Jennifer Churchill, she was the founding teacher at Mount Cross. Lutheran Church Child Development Center. She was also wife to Randy Churchill, and if you ever knew him year and a half ago he passed away but he was such a great civic leader.
The two of them just accomplished so much for the city of Camarillo and beyond with Boys & Girls Club and so forth. So I just wanted to say thank you and condolences to their families. Thank you that's
it. Thank You Supervisor LaVere
Thank you chair. I want to start by thanking 3 people, 3 groups actually the boys and girls club of Ventura, the Ventura County Sheriff's Office and EJ Harrison because we had our Saticoy cleanup last Friday and we do it try to get several times a year in partnership with the boys and girls club but it's always great to see our sheriff's deputies out there cleaning up with the community. EJ Harrison donating a lot of the barrels It was a very successful day. I want to thank my staff for organizing it, but just a great day and then last weekend I was able to attend the annual California Fallen Firefighter Memorial in Sacramento this year of Ventura County.
Added two names to the wall. We added a captain Jeff Maurer and engineer Tommy Monadeo both who passed way too young due to Workplace related cancers, and we added their name to the wall this year it was a strong turnout from not only some of our firefighters but also a lot of work the executive staff chief Gardner Chief Sherry were up there and A very powerful ceremony. If you haven't been, I would invite all of you to attend in future years.
But it was an honor to join our fire department this weekend up in Sacramento. And then lastly, I want to let the community know that in partnership with the Oak View Women's Club and Salvation Army will be hosting our monthly food share distribution at the Oak View Park and Resource Center this Friday, October 8th from 1 to 2 p.m.. And again, I want to thank the Women's Club and Salvation Army for helping us make that happen. And then lastly, I'd ask that we adjourn in honor of those names provided to the clerk and I want to mention the veterans that we have recently lost may include Clarence Deripiza who was a Navy veteran Norman Plott another Navy veteran John Perry Senior who is a Marine Corps veteran Charles Davis Who was a Navy veteran who actually just celebrated his 100th birthday last month.
And then lastly, Modesto Hurtado who was an Army veteran so thinking about all of them their families and recognizing their service to our country. Thank you.
4:30 – 4:323 turns
Excuse me, I'm just going to do one item and then we can adjourn into closed session. But I just want to talk about this last weekend a shout out to Santa Rosa Valley for an amazing fall festival with the Municipal Advisory Council and my staff our county parks everybody came together to put together this third annual festival. And even though it was 100 degrees out there in the Santa Rosa Valley We were able to have a great event. We were able to raise a lot of good money for the Stepping Stones equestrian program for youth and I was the chief auctioneer for the pie auction, and I even made a pie with my wife. It was a pecan pumpkin pie I think we raised close to $5,000 for Stepping Stones. Great organization, great event and yes it was a little warm but everyone had a great time so congratulations to that community.
I would ask that my colleagues adjourn with me in honor of those who passed and have been submitted to the clerk. And with that we can adjourn to closed session. Madam County Council.
Thank you chair, we will now go into closed session on items 43 through 45 as indicated on the agenda. There will be no reportable announcements so your board can adjourn out of closed session thank you.
Great thank you everyone