UnGovr Transcript
iHow this transcript is madeUnGovr transcribes the official recording with automated speech-to-text, separates speakers by voice, and matches voices to the seated roster. Names and attributions are AI estimates and may contain errors.Verify any quote yourself: click anywhere in the transcript and the official video jumps to that exact moment, so you can check any quote against the recording.0:04 – 0:2018 turns
Hi, good evening. I just want to call the meeting to order for the Oxnard Council for Tuesday May 5th 2026. I would like to make it clear for the record of this meeting, and it should be reflected in the minutes that at least a portion of this City Council meeting is conducted pursuant to California Government Code Section 54953 parentheses B. In that Mayor Pro Tem Teran is participating remotely from the Holiday Inn Express in Visalia-Sequoia Gateway by IHG in accordance with the Brown Act.
The teleconference location has been identified on the agenda for this meeting. Madam Clerk, it would be appropriate at this time for you to conduct a roll call and posting of the agenda after which we will confirm certain matters for the record. Thank you.
Councilwoman Basuah? Here. Councilmember Peralo? Here. Councilwoman Perez? Here Councilwoman Rodriguez? Present. Councilman Starr?
Here
Mayor Pro Tempteran? Mayor McArthur?
Here.
The agenda for this meeting was posted in the kiosk at City Hall, the Oxnard Public Library, the city administrative offices and on the city's website on Thursday April 23rd. I would like to request that Mayor Pro Tem respond to the following questions. Mayor Pro Tem can you hear me well? Yes. Were you able to hear our proceedings Do you have a copy of the agenda for this meeting?
Yes.
Have you posted the agenda at the location where you are located?
Yes
Is your location reasonably accessible to the public such that any member of the public could participate in this teleconference from your location if he or she wished to do so?
Yes
is there any member of the public there with you?
No
Who would like, okay. Thank you. And then I would like to advise the mayor and the council members that any votes taken must be taken by roll call. Thank you.
The next item on the agenda is an appointment item scheduled for 530. I apologize, we ate a little bit into your time for six minutes so we'll add that at the end. This is from the Culture and Community Services Department. This subject entails Senior Services Commission annual report. The recommendation's that the City Council one receive the Senior Services Commission annual report and two present a proclamation designating the month of May 2025 as Older Americans Month And for that, I'd like to call up Senior Services Commission Chair Ms. Alice Sweetland who is already up who will make the presentation. Thank you, Ms. Sweetland.
Thank you. Make sure I can hear me
okay?
Mayor McArthur and City Council members it's a pleasure to be here again to tell you what we've been up to with senior services And we have a PowerPoint to present to you. Thank you for the opportunity to present this. Tonight, we'll highlight the program services goals and accomplishments. OK now I'm supposed to run this. Let's see how I do. Oh it's over here!
So we are so happy we now have seven commissioners. We have a full complement You can see each of the districts they're from, and they're sitting here on the front row. So we're just delighted. Should I introduce each one of them? Do you know them? Okay. We have Linda Calderon first and Lupe Reyes and Magdalena Good evening, everyone. Thank you for joining us tonight.
Okay, let me get organized here. We meet the second Tuesday of each month at the Jocelyn Lawn Bowls. Two months out of the year we go to other senior centers. We meet at South Oxnard Center one month and then we go to Laconia one month and we like get in there and see what the other centers look like. So according to census data, approximately 23.3% of Oxnard residents are age 55 and older. So almost a quarter of Oxnard is over 55. It's about 46,813 people.
This demographic is a significant and growing portion of our community often termed as the silver tsunami And the aging population continues to grow faster than the total population. These are all the baby boomers that, and that trend reflects the term silver tsunami based on current projections. Oxnard could have between 55 and 60 thousand residents, 55 and older by 2030. This growth highlights the importance of keeping senior services a priority while also expanding services programs and support systems for older adults. So we recently had a survey, and hopefully we came out on top as far as needs for our seniors.
So we have four Senior Centers. We have the Colonial Center The Wilson Senior Center, South Oxnard Senior Center and Palm Vista. Each center has an amazing staff who provide programming, social opportunities and access to services that support healthy aging. And our mantra is to age in place. We hope that we can provide services so that our seniors can age in their own homes, activities that will keep them invested in our community.
The activities that we offer are varied. We have pool, bingo, quilting and if you notice the Star Wars quilt here that's from our ladies at the South Oxnard Center they made that quilt just for today and I'm not sure about the baby blanket and the little cap is that from SOC 2? From Wilson They have a group of knitters and crocheters at the Wilson, so they're always doing something fun.
We have the Lotteria. We have our gardening that's right next to Lawn Bowls behind the senior center or Senior Services Office and we have seniors that grow their Produce there. That's my neighbor, Liz Garner, who is a really successful gardener. And then Pinnacle and just all sorts of games that they play. We hope that you will join us for lunch. Each of the commissioners is inviting their city council person to come to the Wilson Center and enjoy lunch. And you can see all this activity that's going on We have special events, the end of summer carnival and wellness fair which was lots of fun. I went to that well every year I go to it. The Dia de las Muertes which is at the Carnegie.
Well I don't know what's a Carnegie library? What's it called now Carnegie? Art museum. It'll always be the library to me. Mexican Independence Day Our Halloween dance and then the Christmas parade. And Gloria, Massey, Chenae and I got to ride in this vintage car. And it was just lots and lots of fun. So we have holiday party, Valentine's time party, luau party, Thanksgiving, and all our seniors dressed to the nines they just love the activities.
A lot of them don't have family around so this is their family We have excursions. We have a new van purchased for the cultural and community services, so we're able to send three vans on these excursions. The seniors pay their way but we provide the transportation. Memorable trips including the Santa Paula mural walking tour And then we have exercise programs. We have Zumba, yoga for health, wellness and we've started evening programs so some of the seniors that are still working they can come to the senior centers and participate in evening classes.
So a year of growth engagement enriching experiences for our senior community So, our RSVP program you're probably very familiar with is Retired Senior Volunteer Program. All these acronyms get so confusing but it's a national program and people volunteer as an RSVP member and they contribute to the community in many meaningful ways including visiting and assisting homebound seniors, tutoring and mentoring youth Councilman Torillo loves to hear about their contribution because if they were paid by the hour, it would be a great drain on the city's coffers.
Really happy that our RSVP program is so successful. And they have an annual luncheon, and that picture is last year we got Mayor McArthur to come and rub elbows with us. So we had lots of fun. They have 59 new volunteers in 2025, and they contributed over 45,562 hours which is a lot The volunteers lead bone builder programs, a walking group. As I said they support homebound seniors, tutor youth so we have a little intergenerational program going there.
It's just a win-win for the seniors and the community. So our Senior Nutrition Program is probably the highlight of Senior centers, they prepare the food at the Wilson Kitchen and it's the meals are designed by a dietician. So it's the proper amount of protein and vegetables and not too much salt whatever. And so we have congregate meals hot nutritious meals served from 1130 to 12 every day at three senior centers. So they serve at the Wilson, Palm Vista and the Colonial Center. We have to put the meals in a van and take it over to the other centers.
We also do home delivered meals for seniors that are home bound and they can't get out so they bring frozen meals and they can pop it in their microwave or whatever. And for that, adults that are 60 years of age and older, and the total meals for the homebound seniors is 44,144. That's both of them combined isn't it? Yeah, that's the congregate and the home delivered meals so if you know somebody who needs a meal congregate or home-delivered they can call the senior nutrition coordinator and we do that in conjunction with or cooperation with the Ventura County Area Agency on Aging.
So these are our partners, we get help from these different SCAN and Humana and the Palms of Bonaventure, Walgreens, Oxnard Fire Department Oxnard Police, Dignity Health. And they all do things for us for various events and we appreciate our partnership with them. So this is one of the highlights for me is celebrating seniors who turn 100 or older. And we've visited I don't know how many this past year but here's just an example Margaret Tatum, and you may know her daughters Daisy and Jeannie Tatum. And Margaret turned 100, oh it was the grandest celebration just...and then Maria, let's see Maria Consuelo blah blah blah she has about four different names. And she was turning 103 and we went to her house All her family was there, her four sons.
And then V.J. Nickelberry and he lives at Glenwood and we went to see V. J. Nickelberry and
0:20 – 0:262 turns
Uncle-
Pronounce that again? Anyway that was at Mercy House. Mercy Housing on 5th Street. And he didn't say a lot, but he was very, very happy. And then the last picture is Sally Varela. And when I went to her house, I said, is your mother home? She's the most youthful 100-year-old lady I've ever seen. So anyway, we have a lot of fun. As many commissioners as possible come. Councilman Turan has come, mayor McArthur has come to some of the celebrations. So we really celebrate our 100 year old seniors, recognizing them reminds us of the lasting contributions older adults make to Oxnard and most of them have grown up in Oxnard they've worked here Sally Varela used to work at Santa Cruz market and then she went to Mayfair market They're just wonderful people.
So, we have goals every year and we were in the technology education goal phase two this year. We've done research and created a list of independent living facilities in Oxnard for seniors and I'm turning that over to Our city manager and Brenda Lopez, so they can see what we offer. We have monthly senior health presentations and we try to improve the signage and accessibility of our senior centers and that's an ongoing goal because our parking lots are pretty rough for our handicapped seniors it makes it hard to get in and out We're working with Public Works to correct that.
And we also have to keep in mind our long-range goal of building a new senior center, and we visited that. We've talked about it, and then we took it off the agenda, but we're putting it back on. We're going to build this beautiful senior center. We have the spot on 5th Street. We have the architectural renderings, and hopefully with your support We will get the Senior Center built in my lifetime, I hope.
So this is our tech education it's called Cyber Seniors. And our instructor is Tristan, who is amazing and the most patient person in the world. And so he gets a group of seniors and they come with their iPads and their iPhones and their laptops and they all have questions and he can answer all of them. He's just amazing. So he's at the Wilson Center and the South Oxnard Center.
Yeah even TV remotes He knows it all. But the unfortunate thing, he only speaks English and Mandarin. He does not speak Spanish but he manages to communicate well. And these are the when I told you we did a survey these are the senior housings independent living senior houses in Oxnard and some of them aren't just for seniors but the veteran housing Dolores Huerta Gardens just opened, and Casa de Carmen just opened last week. And that's not just seniors but there are a lot of seniors that live there and a lot of seniors that live in Casa Aliente.
So okay our monthly health presentations we have a new group that comes love on a leash and they bring their dogs in and so Everybody loves dogs. They say when you pet a dog, your blood pressure just kind of drops. So caregivers in Oxnard receive guidance and senior services for key topics including stroke prevention, grief counseling, Alzheimer's awareness, mental health and diabetes education. St. John's does a wonderful job of sending nurses over to help with medical guidance and I told you we worked. So, we started with the Wilson Center and we have signs now so everybody knows because they drive down C Street and they didn't know that our senior center was there so now they can see the Senior Center at Wilson and will do similar to SOC or South Oxnard Center We are on social media.
We're on Facebook, we're on Instagram so check us out and we're on the Oxnard Recreation website. So if you want more information there is our phone number 385-8019. Our hours of operation for our senior services office is 8 a.m to 5 p.m and we have an email seniors at oxnard.org presentation. Do you have any questions?
0:26 – 0:3220 turns
I just wanted to quickly take the moment to thank all of the senior service commissioners for all the work that you do. I know I had a couple of folks come to my community meeting at Southwinds, so it was really great to kind of hear some feedback and get some input from community members there and just wanted to extend the invitation that I'd love to come by for a luncheon or if there's any kind of events that are happening, feel free to send them my way. And looking forward to continuing to see the work that you all are doing.
Everything we do is fun so plan on having fun when you come have lunch.
I recommend the Zumba class.
I don't know. That's hard work.
Go ahead, Councilwoman.
Yes. I just have a quick question. I know in one of your slides you shared that 368 local seniors making a difference. When you say there's 59 new volunteers doing 45,000 plus hours, how many is that total? So 59 new ones in 2025 because that's quite a lot. We have 368.
Sorry. 368 seniors who participate in RSVP.
Correct, so they participate and you have 59 new volunteers correct? Doing 45,000 plus hours which is amazing I'm just wondering what the total volunteer workforce is.
Good evening Mayor Pro Tem and council members to answer your question The RSVP program currently has a total of 368 registered volunteers. Of that, the new number is 59 that we've acquired in the last fiscal year, the last calendar year.
Well I just want to thank everybody for giving their time. I think it really matters you know today is actually my uncle's 90th birthday and yeah so um my dad is somewhere in the middle and he's 84 but I appreciate the work that it takes, the patience and the diligence. So I just think keep on moving and it all matters. Thank you all so much for the good work and thank you for the ladies stepping up to the commission to participate. And I also really appreciate how hard you're trying with the names. I know that somebody's name and their identity is very important. So thank you for your attempt and keep working on those names.
Thank you. And was remiss not to mention that the staff they do it all. do what we can, but we have a fabulous staff. We have Renee Raigstraw and Pam Morrison. And Terrell, you know Terrell? He's our
boss. I
thank all the volunteers, everybody that is involved. I've been to some of your events, it's been awhile, but I know when you have the luncheon for the volunteers it's tremendous. But I want to assure you, Ms. Wheatland, the Senior Center will get built in your life and my lifetime.
My lifetime?
No. I'm pretty old. There has been no act by this council to take anything away from Senior Center. It's still on board. The deadline and the date, I don't have yet but...
Okay well we're moving forward.
Is the Orcas group still up?
No, we had it disbanded because it was costing Thank you.
Yes, thank you very much. And thank you Miss Sweetland for the presentation as always very well represented by you and I think that's why they keep you on his chair because you just do such a big job and I have to wear a brag tag for that because you are district two resident and My continued appointee and I have to thank the late Supervisor Carmen Ramirez, former Mayor Pro Tem Carmen Ramirez for appointing you as well. You've done some amazing work so please do not sell yourself short on that. I also want to echo what my colleagues have said in thanking the commission for dedicating their time to really spearheading a lot of these efforts and highlighting the many efforts that are happening by so many volunteers and our staff who are working with them For any of my colleagues on the dais, if you have not yet had a chance to go to any of the senior centers or any of their events or activities I highly recommend it.
There's just so much great stuff that's going on. I know that we've mentioned a number of times in this council but Even just the socialization, the physical activity and also the emotional benefits, social-emotional benefits that our seniors get from participating in these things are immeasurable. And the way that they really are measured is in quality of life and the number of years that they spend with that quality of life. So I wanna just thank you all again for all of the work you do And I just did some quick math on it from what i see on the 45,562 volunteer hours. It looks like that's about the equivalent of almost 22 full-time positions and even if we paid those volunteers current minimum wage in the state of California that's almost $800,000 worth of volunteer work that's happening and I just want to thank you all because The work you do truly is exemplified by the good quality work that comes out of it and the services that our seniors receive.
So thank you to all the volunteers and thank you to our staff who coordinate it so I look forward to joining you all for lunch later this month.
Got it on my calendar yeah. The volunteer hour The independent sector estimates the value of a volunteer hour is $34.79 per hour, more than minimum wage. So based on that number of hours it would be about one and a half million dollars that is contributed as far as labor and time so pretty good.
0:33 – 0:3815 turns
Thank you, Ms. Sweetland and Maggie thank you for being part of this group now and all the volunteers I echo what the Mayor Pro Tem has said and I hope you don't mind Ms. Sweetland too I was at an event where I heard that many of you may not know but the Lion Inn Hospital I was born in
Long Beach
hospital and
now it's a historical monument.
It was a great celebration. They just celebrated 25th
I'm sorry the rest of you couldn't make it, but it's right there on 5th and H Street. It's a wonderful community for seniors and low-income families. I
love the historical aspect of it where they were able to preserve his office in some other areas there on this site. We have a proclamation for you, Ellis, and your team And I'll just read it, whereas the President of the United States and the Governor of California have officially proclaimed May as Older Americans Month in recognition of the many contributions made by our residents 55 years of age and older.
And whereas the Oxnard City Council wishes to celebrate those older adults who provide immeasurable contributions to our community. And whereas the Oxnard City Council encourages the city's Utilize and enjoy the services and programs offered by the city's senior services programs. And whereas these services and programs assist in allowing many older adults to remain independent in their own homes and communities while maintaining their dignity and self-determination, and whereas this year's theme, Champion Your Health highlights prevention, wellness, and personal responsibility as cornerstones of healthy aging, and whereas the City Council Oxnard commends the Senior Services Commission for its advocacy and its involvement with the seniors of our community in providing and enhancing the seniors services and programs.
And whereas older adults of Oxnard are recognized and acknowledged for their experience, their knowledge expertise and numerous contributions which enhance and enrich the quality of life offered to all residents of the city of Oxnard. We hereby proclaim May 2026 is Older Americans Month.
How are you? Good to see you.
And you're also a newly appointed, right? Yes.
Magdalena
Tapia. Magdalena, mucho gusto.
Mucho gusto. Nice to meet you. Hi. Gabby,
nice to meet you.
You all in the middle please. Thank you. I feel small. You feel
small? Happy Cinco de Mayo. Okay. Do we wait back? This one? Or this one, or this? Thank you.
0:38 – 0:4320 turns
Thank you.
Okay, you're going to have lunch with us? Yes!
Thank you so much. Oh, socorros!
Yeah, yeah.
Really? I don't see it. I think my family...
Gloria, thank
you so much for
all your efforts. I know we're in a long list of
people who are doing this. I want to recognize a lot of challenging students right now. Yeah, they're at the Capitoline and Montclair. It's good exercise.
Mayor.
Thank you so much. You know, just a lot of celebrities back then would make the drive from L.A. to come to Dr. Schwartz Hospital.
But what they did, they knocked on others' doors and decided maybe
that wasn't such a good idea.
Maybe that wasn't such a good idea? Yeah! I could do that! They used to, back in the day, they used to give them... Yeah, yeah! It was incredible.
Mayor and council members, just for the record there were no public comments for this item. Okay?
Thank you.
We're on page three.
Yeah.
Okay.
So I just want to call the meeting to order for the Oxnard City Council in this special meeting for the Oxnard Housing Authority for Tuesday, May 5th, 2026. I also would like to make it clear for the record of this meeting and it also should be reflected in the minutes that at least a portion of this city council meeting is conducted pursuant to California Government Code Section 54953B and that Mayor Pro Tem Gabe Teran is participating remotely from the Holiday Inn Express in Visalia.
In accordance with the Brown Act, the teleconference location has been identified on the agenda for this meeting. Madam Clerk it would be now appropriate for you to conduct a roll call and posting of the agenda after which we will confirm certain matters for the record.
Roll call — called by City Clerk
Show transcript
0:43 – 0:4913 turns
The agenda for this meeting was posted at the kiosk at City Hall, the Oxnard Public Library, the city administrative offices and on the city's website on Thursday April 23rd. I would like to request that Mayor Pro Tem respond to the following questions. Mayor Pro Tem can you hear me well?
Yes.
Were you able to hear our proceedings on this end up until now?
Yes
And do you have a copy of Have you posted the agenda at the location where you are located?
Yes.
Is your location reasonably accessible to the public such that any member of the public could participate in this teleconference from your location if he or she wished to do so? Yes, is there any member of the public there with you who would like to participate in the public comment portion of this meeting?
Not at this time no
I would like to advise the mayor and the council members that any votes must be taken by roll call. Thank you.
Thank you everyone.
Good evening, Mayor and members of the City Council and neighbors. My name is Alejandro Sandoval and I want to take Councilwoman Rodriguez and Oxnard College Trio Program for this incredible honor and opportunity to be here. Growing up in Oxnard, I learned early that our community is built on grit. My journey hasn't always been a straight line like many families here we've faced our shares of obstacles financial hurdles balancing work and school, or navigating the educational system.
But those challenges don't stop us. They become the fuel and they teach resilience that isn't just about surviving but looking towards the future not the past. Currently as an Oxnard College student I'm working towards my future in a medical field. I spent countless years in high school looking at careers in medicine becoming part of clubs and joining multiple sports, diving deeper into the sciences preparing for next steps in my academic career.
Whether that's in the future attending a Stanford lab at the School of Medicine this summer I carry the values of our city with me and the commitment to serve the relentless work ethic looking ahead towards my goal to transfer to university where I can continue my path towards becoming a cardiologist I want to take the skills that I've learned and eventually bring it, my expertise back to a community like ours.
Especially after I got to meet most of our amazing community through volunteering at countless hospitals and non-profit clinics or being part of a great program such as Trio Upper Bound where I met the trio team who mentored me into applying for colleges and for the academic rigor of college. In addition to always being a supportive and welcoming to any student.
Oxnard is not just where we are from, it's the foundation that makes us capable of going anywhere. Thank you for believing in my story and for everything you do to support students of this great city.
Just
a few words. So Alejandro is like first in his family to pursue higher education, he mentions the TRIO programs and that's for students who maybe don't have that solid pathway and my very first interaction with Alejandro I was at the transfer center working for the college and he was still a high school student trying to figure out how do I get to that end goal? And I just I really appreciate how he's always taking initiative and very perseverant and when not life doesn't turn out as we want it to just pivot and shift gears. So I know he's going to make it far, and I appreciate how much pride he has in being an Oxnard student. And wherever he goes, he'll make us proud.
0:49 – 0:599 turns
Wonderful. Alejandro, do you have any of your family members here or a teacher? Anybody?
Currently not the only person that I brought with me is my girlfriend Hannah. Is she supporting?
I'm going to tell his mom, by the way.
That's wonderful. It's always inspiring as you can see there's a lot of young people here today we're celebrating Challenge High School various programs at Challenge High School as well as Pacifica but I tell you many of us here on this council really are staunch supporters of youth. are definitely the future of our country and our community. You must be doing exceptional work if the councilwoman elected you to come here and be recognized, so great job, Alejandro.
We have a certificate for you if you and your girlfriend would want to come up and receive it, okay? And we'll take some photos for you.
Thank you.
He just shared with me that he just got selected to do an internship at Stanford, to do research at Stanford which is amazing. You should have said that! He'll make us very proud.
And I told his girlfriend that she selected well, right? He's going places. This next item, we're going to command the Pacifica Girls wrestling team of the girls here. Yeah, you hear? Maybe they're outside. We're going to start with the Pacifica Girls Wrestling Team which coach Jorge Bautista. First one's a wrestling team. We're going to do the wrestling team first, yeah.
And then right after the wrestling team we're going to be doing the Chattanooga High School mock trial team and for that we've got the Channels high school cheerleaders that are gonna cheer on all the various recipients. Right Ms. Ramos? We're gonna... Yes! Right yes. And as the wrestling team is making their way up Let me tell you about the girls wrestling team from Pacifica High School.
This year, 2026, the Pacifica Girls Wrestling Team won the CIF Southern Section 4 Division 3 Dual Meet Championship with a victory over Elsinore High School 47-36 This happened on February 5th, 2026. The Tritons showcased incredible determination and skill winning eight out of 14 matches with meaningful contributions from Saima Bazil and Anali Martinez helping them secure their second straight section title We also want to acknowledge Melody Hernandez, Samia Bazile and Cherie Anzures for their exceptional accomplishment as Channel League champions.
Additionally we extend our congratulations to CIF placers Cherie and Samia as well as CIF Eastern Division champion Ashley Magdaleno who achieved fourth place Cherie earned third place as the SSCIF Masters Tournament and Samia Bazile was a finalist. Both Cherie and Samia participated in the California State Meet with Samia finishing in fifth place, remarkable!
We are incredibly proud of the dedication, perseverance, and efforts of all these students. Their outstanding performances are testament to their hard work and the unwavering support of their coaching staff Led by head coach Joe Rodriguez and assisted by Kehlani, Wagstaff, Alex Lara, Javier Bautista and Cesar Gonzalez. So let's not mess around with them right all these wrestlers.
It really is you can see look at our council it is full of young students, young student athletes their parents we also going to acknowledge the challenge mock trial team their decathlon team We're just so proud of our students and where they're going. You know, Oxford is the 18th largest city in California and we have just remarkable students supported by parents who give tremendous sacrifices in the profound impacts that our educators and our academic leaders have on these young students. So really when Javier reached out to me and informed me about their win this year without hesitation, we certainly want recognize them, and I know that your principal from Pacifica High School is up here.
And I mean Pacifica is just you guys were dominating right in sports Chris? Just another one yeah my goodness that's just remarkable so without further ado let's give it a big round of applause for the Pacifica high school wrestling team And I'm going to turn it over to your principal if you want to say a few words and pass it to your coaching staff, if they want to say anything.
Thank you Mayor McArthur yes it does make us very proud as you look in this room you see a lot of students from our great city here of Oxnard. As another person I live reside here in Oxnard it makes me proud to call these young Students up here, they're a principal. I am very proud of our coaching staff but as I see, I also was an assistant principal at Channel Islands at one point so it's good to see Raiders up here as well and it's just amazing to see our students in the City of Oxnard making their city proud, making their schools proud, making their community proud I'm very proud of Pacifica High School. Yes, we've been accomplishing a lot over the last several years but to us it's not just about winning titles and championships in athletics, it's about giving back to the community.
It's about teaching our students here resilience but most of all Making an impact in the community because it's not just athletics, it's about academics and it's more about citizenship. Building relationships and this is just a testament of what our coaches do for our students and the importance of lifelong relationships like you and I have Mayor McArthur. And again, it feels really good to see the accomplishments of our amazing student-athletes up here and as we say at Pacifica, it's good to be a Triton.
Pass it right here to Bautista, he's one of our oldest coaches up here in the wrestling program.
I'll hand it over to Coach Joe Rodriguez right now. He's the girls' head coach, but the coaching staff works as a team. We work with the parents. They're a crucial part of our success for this year and last year. Last year, the boys won the TIF championship. This year was the girls' turn. We have the majority of the team coming back next year so we hope to be back here next year to be recognized again. It's...we set that standard high at Pacifica High School for all our athletics, for everything we do at Pacifica, so hopefully we'll be invited back next year and I'm going to pass it over to Head Coach Joe Rodriguez.
0:59 – 1:059 turns
All right, guys. Thank you guys very much for your support. I'd like to say that compared to last year's this team we didn't even wrestle any championships last year. For this year, I had a bunch of new kids, new girls. It was freshmen and sophomore heavy, a few juniors and a couple seniors. So this is a very young team looking forward to what we're going to do next year. I think it's going to be bigger and better. And I expect to kind of keep winning this year in and year out as long as they stick to the program and high school. Scholarships are everywhere for these girls so if you have a young girl, little sister somewhere that's ready to come out wrestling is a great opportunity not only for just academics and sports but for scholarship opportunities out there so again this is not the end this is just the beginning of us winning championships here and I look forward to the next few years thank you
So we're going to call the young ladies by name and then I think the mayor wants to hand you a certificate. Emily Gallegos. We have a certificate for assistant coach Javier Bautista, assistant coach Alex Lara Malaya Saipali. I'm not sure, Saipali? I'm sorry for the last name. Ayanna Silva. Isabella Trejo Dominguez. Kiara Vences. Gabriela Villega. Jacqueline Almanza.
Gabriela Cervantes. Anai Martinez. Natalie Juarez. Samaya Bazile. Isabella Martinez. Alessandria Venegas. Shari Ansouris. Eileen Ayala. We have a crowd, Aileen. Sarai Dominguez. Enani Gomez. Melody Hernandez. Ashley Magdaleno. Aaliyah Maestas. Citlaly Rojas. So, Assistant Coach Kalani Wagstaff. And Head Coach Joe Rodriguez.
Okay, cut. Count of three, no blinking. One, two, one, two, three, no blinks. One, two three, one, two three.
Right here with me guys.
All
right,
felicidades. Congratulations everybody!
Do you want to say the next one? Oh yeah, can you bring it
in? I'll read it out. So I apologize, but we missed a student. Alana Fregata you do not go unnoticed. Thank you so much for your hard work on the mat and off the mat.
1:05 – 1:118 turns
We will be sure to have your certificate ready for you at City Hall, so maybe we can pick it up or get it to one of your coaches. Thank you.
And if you would just bear with me before we get to Challis High School, we're going to call up Lillian. Also Tammy with the Ventura County Chapter of the Japanese American Citizens League if they're here. Also Dr. Yu with the Ventura County Chinese American Historical Society And also the Asian Pacific Islander American Association at California State University Channel Islands to accept.
We have proclamations proclaiming May 2026 as Asian-American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month, Asian-American and Pacific Islanders This month is to celebrate and pay tribute to the contributions of Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders to the American history, society into our culture which is prevalent here in the city of Oxnard. Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders have distinguished themselves as leading researchers in science, in medicine, in technology, innovative farmers and ranchers Distinguished lawyers, judges and government leaders in the arts, literature and sports as war heroes who defended our country from fascism and peacetime healthcare heroes.
And Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders comprise many ethnicities and languages and their many achievements embody the American experience. Today over 20 million Asian American and Pacific Islanders live in the United States And through their action, make America a more vibrant, prosperous and secure nation. The contributions of the Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders continue to enrich our culture here in our beautiful city of Oxnard.
It is my absolute honor as the mayor of this city to proclaim Asian American-Pacific Islander Heritage Month May 2026. Thank you. Hello everyone, my
name is Brandon Langford. I'm the director of housing and residential education at California State University Channel Islands and I serve as the staff co-chair for the Asian American Pacific Islander Association. I'll let my faculty co-chair introduce herself
Good evening, everyone. I'm Nancy Chen and I am the faculty co-chair of the Asian American and Pacific Islander Association at CSU Channel Islands.
We just want to thank everyone at the City of Oxnard for the proclamation. Dr. Lillian Tamai for nominating us and seeing the work that we do. We were founded on the campus in 2021 so we've been doing this work quite some time trying to recognize Asian American Pacific Islanders on campus and in the greater Ventura County area. It's a very vibrant community, so we hope you come out to our events. We just hosted our second annual AAPI Heritage Week that occurred on campus and we had at least over 800 folks in attendance It's a very big turnout, so we're hoping next year you'll join us. We do ours in April because our graduation is coming up. So we hope to see you out there and we just want to thank everyone at Cal State University Channel Islands for supporting us, all the faculty, everyone up here.
These are all of our executive officers that help run everything on the campus and they do amazing work. So thank you all so much.
Great, my name is Liliane Welty Tamai and I am Ventura County Japanese American Citizens League chapter as well as faculty at Cal State Chatham Islands.
I'm Betty Katsura and for about 25 years, I've been a member of the Japanese American Citizens League. And I work on the scholarship committee and we have a book club if you're ever interested. And so it's a great pleasure to be up here with Lily. She's a wonderful president for our organization. She's taken us very far. So thank you, Lily!
Hi, my name is Dr. George Yu. I'm the chair of the Ventura County Chinese American Historical Society. We were formed in 2000 to help to promote the history and also do research and also to educate the public about the history of Chinese Americans that have been here since the 1860s. Also, I am very proud that Bill Suhu was the very first native-born Asian American Especially Chinese Americans elected to mayor of Oxnard in 1966. So this year, this is 60th anniversary so it was a landmark achievement with only about 15-10 Asian or Chinese American voters. So everybody voted for him because he was the right person for the job
1:11 – 1:1912 turns
Hello, everyone. My name is Kimiki Rose. I'm a professor of psychology and also the treasurer for the AAPI Association at CSU Channel Islands.
Good evening, everyone. My name is Dr. Carolann Becerra. I am a professor in the biology department.
Hello, everyone. My name is Minda Tran and I am the Asian American Pacific Islander Association's student intern.
Good evening, everyone. My name is Dr. Kevin Hayakawa. I'm an assistant professor of physics at Cal State Channel Islands as well as our organization's academic senate representative and along with Dr. Becerra I co-chair our Asian American Pacific Islander Stolling Ceremony Task Force, and I just wanted to invite all of you to the special graduation event for our students of Asian American Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander descent. It'll be on the Cal State Channel Islands campus on Thursday May 21st from 6 to 8 p.m. in the Grand Salon on campus. You're more than welcome to join us.
Hi, good evening. My name is Dr. Hyunsook Yoon. I'm a professor of communication at Channel Island and I'm also serving as student activity coordinator of the AAPI Association on campus.
Thank you so much.
1, 2, 3.
Yeah, so
we'll just send them like that.
I forgot to mention something very important. Our organization, JACL, Japanese American Citizens League is responsible has taken on the responsibility of keeping the historic Japanese cemetery as tidy as we can and we have a cleanup every March and we try to advertise it if those of you out there would like to help us but I particularly want to give Lily credit Because this year, she really made it happen. We had a great turnout and she provided us with so much work.
I can't even express it because I wasn't prepared but she did a great job of making that happen and it's a yearly event. Thank you very much for giving me that chance.
I apologize. Next, we'd like to call up the Channel Islands High School mock trial team. They're here? Thank you. The Channel Islands mock trial team had an outstanding season after months of rigorous preparation The students dedicated themselves to refining arguments, enhancing presentations and preparing for challenges. In February 2026 they competed at the Ventura County Superior Courthouse against over 30 teams from across the county.
Their efforts yielded remarkable results. I don't want to mispronounce the name. Corelle Lubit won first in journalism. Aliyah Guzman won second in journalism, and Princess Gonzalez won second in art. These accomplishments qualified the team for the state competition in Oakland, California where they represented both Channels High School as well as the entire Ventura County.
Led by coach Monica Adrian, the Team Traveler Oakland competed against California's top programs and the achievement reflects their preparation resilience and dedication Importantly, Charles High School is the only Oxnard school to participate at the state level this year and the past three years highlighting the program's strength. They represented Charles High School with Raider pride making a significant milestone in the program's history so let's hear it up for the team Ms. Ramos, I'll turn it over to you and then your coaching staff that's okay.
Thank you so much for having us tonight. It is our great honor to be here. It's my great honor to serve as principal at Channel Islands High School. I get to be surrounded by phenomenal students. Tonight is one night of the many nights that I'm around these amazing Raiders. These students these three here and the one if you're in mock trial and you're out there will you stand up?
These students that have come to cheer on. It is a collective work that's led by Coach Monica Adrian, they all work so well together her leadership is phenomenal and what's wonderful is these students come with no knowledge no background and together they make this powerful team And I am so incredibly proud to share that Channel Islands High School is the only school in Oxnard that has represented the city of Oxnard for the last few years.
So we're really proud of that and that's South Oxnard, and we're so incredibly excited for our kids.
1:19 – 1:264 turns
Good evening, everyone. I'm Monica Adrian. I am privileged and honored to be called their coach for the last 21 years. I've been the mock trial coach and for the last maybe 15 years. I've been there criminology and law instructor in the morning. These young people get to school between seven six fifty and seven every day. during high school, some of them which I've had for four years.
And every year they've been a blessing to me. They're outstanding really not only in the classroom but outside with all their engagement with ASB and other clubs so it's really just a privilege for me to polish them up and showing them the principles of law what our constitution looks like what criminal law looks like many of them are gonna go on to practice law which is such a prideful thing for me to see because it's like Those were my students, they were my itty bitty 14 year olds that are now at Yale and Harvard and UCLA Law School and Stanford or whatnot. But I would be remiss if I didn't talk about a couple of my attorney coaches Barbara Macri-Ortiz which I don't see here today but she's been with us for the last five or six years and Attorney Elvia Garcia.
I've also been helped by the Honorable Michelle Castillo and the Honorable Romero so Wonderful things coming out of Channel Islands High School and I plan to continue our journey to bring up more championships back to home. So thank you everyone.
Yes, I have the privilege of calling out the names and the mayor will give them their certificate so we have coach Monica Adrian Osvaldo Gutierrez. Aida Santiago. Princess Gonzalez. Aliyah Guzman. All right, I think that's it for now.
One more here. 1, 2, 3. Thank you.
Now I'd like to call up the Channels High School Academic Decathlon team, if they're here. Come on up guys. We commend the Channells High School academic decathlon team for achieving an impressive third place overall finish in Ventura County and securing second place in Division 1 The team earned a total of 39 medals across the honors, scholastic and varsity divisions.
For the second consecutive year they were also honored with the Team Spirit Award which was voted on by the competing schools. Challenge High School has consistently ranked among the top three schools in Ventura County for four consecutive years, demonstrating sustained excellence in one of the county's most competitive academic programs. Each year the competition revolves around a specific theme This year the focus was Roaring Twenties.
Over the course of eight months, students engaged in rigorous preparation, completing seven objective assessments and three performance-based events including a prepared speech, an interview, and an essay. The team is guided by Ms. Caitlin Genchi Okay. A science educator who has served as the academic decathlon coach and advisor for nine years, she continues to inspire students to challenge themselves and to extend their limits and embody Raider pride with purpose just that you know we got a miss Ramos touch sounded these are our South Oxnard students in South Oxford incredible You know and I say you know, I graduated from Charles High School myself.
And I feel like you look at our city and I mentioned the City of Oxford is the 18th largest city You know, we are working a lot as a municipal government to really uplift the south end of our city which encompasses some of the most dense pockets of our community here in this city. And oftentimes there's struggling communities in certain sections but I tell you, you can see here back-to-back Chalmers High School, The Cheer Squad is coming up next and I think Monica mentioned it. The students that Ms. Ramos has, they're all going places. It goes to show you the tremendous dedication, passion and commitment that our educators, our leaders have to uplifting our students. And this is a reflection right here and this is happening in South Oxnard Children's High School.
So thank you and congratulations everyone. Thank you.
1:26 – 1:324 turns
Hi everyone. Something that I would like to highlight about this particular group, they're a phenomenal bunch of students there. They work hard. They work hard every day. They work hard all year and they keep working hard. They really are just a gem in our school but something that Our mayor highlighted, but I'm going to just add on to it is that these students in front of you and some that didn't make it to tonight's meeting.
These are all from Channel Islands High School. They beat students the last four years we have this team or obviously somehow graduated, Channel Islands High School academic decathlon has beat for the last four years schools throughout Ventura County. Channel Islands before was never in the top three, now we are the team in not only Oxnard but Ventura County. Only two schools have beat our school in academic decathlon and that's pretty triumphant if you consider our kids don't necessarily have the prep when they're in elementary, middle specifically for academic decathlon where some of our other sister schools across the county they do. So when they come to our school this is raw talent that they have and Coach Jinshi she really does an excellent job of honing in their skills and making them not only know but believe that they can So we're really proud of this group and our coach.
And I know you wanted to say a few words.
Hi, I'm Caitlyn Gingy. I've been honored to be their advisor for this club for the last nine years. Honestly, I really want to put all the acknowledgment to these guys. I just opened my classroom door. They actively even request our practice schedule. We set it based off what they would like. So this past year we were there until seven or eight for the last six to seven months.
We have been there on top of Getting there for a hour practice at seven in the morning. It's all their choice, so I've been lucky to be working with these guys. I do also want to give a little shout out because some of these kids it's not just one year. I have a few students who they come back every year by choice. For example Giovanni Sanchez this is his fourth year in academic decathlon.
And I have multiple students who are here for second year, third year. So our plan for next year is to keep getting better because every year since we have improved either in our scores, our medal count, our placement. Every year just improving and hopefully the really big trophy. Thank you again.
Thank you. And Councilwoman Rodriguez is going to help call up your names and we have certificates for you okay?
All right, bear with me if I don't get one right. Okay, Angel Mendoza not here today. Charles Neal Sales Irish Sabado Carlos Muñoz Giovanni Sanchez Alexis Rodriguez Elijah Zaragoza. Anali Rodriguez. Behind you. Ramon Solano. Jacob Rodriguez. Rodner Quiroz. We're going to have to help them. Kaislyn Senizal. Jose Garcia. Alex Armenta. Chloe Garlett. Jayden Arce.
Marlene Gonzalez. Yelizmar Basturto. Aileen Angel. Anthony Macias. Jose Iglesias. Aliyah Guzman. Osvaldo Gutierrez. Arion Allen Asahan. Sorry, Angel Chavapedi. Kaitlyn Ginchy. All right, thank you all so much! If there's any typos, let us know. We'll fix it. We want to get it right. It's your name. All right folks, I'm going to hand the microphone back.
1:32 – 1:374 turns
Dan, if you're right there is good? Okay. At least we're good. I can just have everyone squeeze and we'll take a photo.
Show me that certificate. There you go. One, two, three. Thank you. Thank you.
Okay. And if I can have the Channels High School cheer team come up, please. And as they're making their way up here let me just highlight their achievements The Chattanooga High School Cheer Team achieved an extraordinary milestone by winning back-to-back USA Spirit National Championships, an accomplishment that reflects the highest level of dedication, teamwork and performance.
Teams must qualify for the U.S. National Spirits Award through a varsity spirit regional competition and meet participation requirements, including summer camp attendance. Each year the national competition brings together hundreds of top performing teams from across the country making the level of competition extremely high Winning a national championship is a remarkable achievement. Earning this title two consecutive years is truly exceptional and speaks to the consistency, resilience and collective strength of these student-athletes.
Beyond their competitive success, the team represents Chattanooga's high school in the broader Oxnard community with pride bringing positive recognition and distinction through their accomplishments. This success is guided by dedicated coaches, Bobby Morales, Brianna Winbush and Mark Rocadon whose leadership commitment and support have played a vital role in the team's continued excellence.
The Channel Islands High School Cheer Team continued its success as a testament to the hard work of its athletes and coaches and their achievement stands as a meaningful example of excellence both on and off the mat. And it's just with great Just honor. As I mentioned, I'm a Channels High School graduate to just highlight the best that we have at Oxnard. We talked about South Island and you're doing it with greater pride and we're all just absolutely honored and we're all behind you right? The entire community is here behind you so I would like to just call upon the coaches if you guys would like to say some words yeah
I just want to say that what you think you know about cheerleading, you kind of have to strip your mind because not only do you see them on the sideline but they are working their butts off like Monday through Friday. They work hard four to five days a week. Not only are we teaching them how to be strong athletes mentally and physically But we're teaching them how to be young, respectable adults. And we prepare them for what's after high school. We teach them determination.
Nothing comes easy without hard work, motivation. We try to teach them more than just cheerleading and we try to give them life lessons. I'm extremely proud of this team. I am a graduate of Channel Islands as well and I was on the cheer team as well So seeing this team accomplish everything that I ever wanted for them is a dream come true and we're not done yet.
And last thing, I just want to say there's no such thing as perfection but cheerleaders get very close to it
1:38 – 1:436 turns
Going off of what Coach Bobby said, I just want to say how proud we are of these kids. They work very, very hard every day. They probably spend more time with us than they do their families so thank you to our parents for your continuous support and letting us spend time with your kids because it's a joy to us. Like Coach Bobby said, I also cheered at Channel Islands High School. It's very near and dear to our hearts so we do put a lot of time and energy Thank you, Mayor, for recognizing them because they do deserve this and we're proud of every single one of them. And I also would like to thank Miss Ramos. I don't know where she went but our principal... Oh there she is! She's a great principal. She puts a lot of time and energy into our kids and tells us every time she gets how much she loves us is a proud of them as well.
So thank you.
Mayor Pro Tem, did you want to comment on something?
Yes after all of the school officials or the students are done speaking I just had a quick comment to make.
Thank you Miss Ramos did you want to comment on that your team yeah
See, I was just saying this is where I wear heels so I can at least be the same height as our students. But again, I'm still incredibly honored of being the principal of this school. We have great students here and our students are great because the families and the guardians and those of you that take care of these kids bring them to us and we have the honor of caring for them while they're on campus This program, when I started as an assistant principal a long time ago we only had maybe eight cheerleaders. Maybe eight? And because of these two leaders they have grown this program not just in quantity but in quality and it's really hard to do that when you start from nothing So I'm really thankful that these student athletes have the honor to be able to work with these two individuals and Coach Rokodon.
Really, we started with eight and now we are at 50-68, and the program is stronger and stronger. And something I think that we shared that didn't highlight is our team only for the first time last year competed We, last year was the very first time we entered the national competition and these girls came in first. First time ever! And then the second time? First again! So...
I goes to really show the strength of South Oxnard, how amazing these students are. How they it doesn't matter where they're from, they are excelling. So these are student athletes, they have to qualify to be cheerleaders that means they are strong not just physically but mentally and they hold it together with such grace and I am so incredibly proud of every single one of them. So thank you for honoring them.
Look Miss Ramos, we have something very special for you. Seeing the recognition we're giving your entire school and I know that things don't happen by accident so it's to the remarkable leadership that you are instilling in your educators and the support that's unwavering to your students. So we want to just provide you with accommodation for Miss Marianne Ramos for her outstanding performance as a leader at Channels High School that has resulted and Challenge High School be recognized for their academic achievement and their academic decathlon team, their mock trial team. And now their cheer team we command that Challenge High School academic decathlon team for taking third place in Ventura County second division one and earning 39 medals across honors scholastic and varsity divisions they received a teen spirit award for the second consecutive year and have ranked among the top three schools in all of Ventura County for four years running This year's theme was Roaring Twenties, and the students spent eight months preparing for seven assessments in three events under Coach Katelyn.
And the mock trial team led by Coach Monica competed against over 30 teams at the Ventura County Courthouse earning individual awards and qualifying for the state competition in Oakland representing Ventura County. Charles High School is the only Oxnard school to compete in the state level this year, and in the past three years highlighting its strength. And now the cheer team winning back-to-back USA Spirit National Championships, a feat achieved through dedication and teamwork guided by coaches Bobby Morales, Brianna, and Mark. And it's just my honor to present that to you. Thank you.
1:43 – 1:507 turns
Okay, with that we'd like to honor Sofia Gutierrez. Jocelyn Barroso. Gabby Ontiveros. Jasmine Garza. Jocelyn Castro. Itzel Romero. Jasleen Colima Medrano. Jasmine Prado. Christina Perez. Peyton Grace Tuazon. Alina Lopez. Itzel Garcia. Dulce Linares. Aaliyah Hernandez. Andrea Robles. Ana Villarreal. Alina Maldonado. Maydeline Kabigting. Teresa Angeles. Vanessa Guerrero.
Natalia Pillado. Juliana Pillado. Sitlali Vasquez. Kayloni Salazar. Lily Mochel. Marley Estrada. Natalia Avelar Lopez. Julissa Reyes. Nevaeh Rodarte. And cheer coach Brianna Winbush. Cheer coach Bobby Morales.
Did we miss anybody? We're good? Awesome, thank you. Absolutely. Yeah. If you can't see the camera, you're
not in the picture. You can't see the camera with both eyes, you're not in the picture. Ready? 1, 2, 3. No blinking. 1,2,3. Thank you. 1-2-3 Yay! Thank you. Thank you so much.
Mayor Pro Tem, did you want to say a few words as the cheerleaders are going back to their seat?
Oh thank you mayor. I just wanted to say real quickly um i apologize to all of our recognition awardees tonight that i couldn't be there in person. I am traveling for my day job but i just want to reiterate what has been said about How proud you are making this community and how much you are accomplishing for yourself, for your fellow peers at school, for the school itself and for your community members and your family. So I hope you're very, very proud of yourselves and as always You know, I would be remiss if I didn't remind folks that communities like Oxnard absolutely need programs and opportunities for young people and adults who are willing to provide them with those opportunities. Because if you look at the tenets of resiliency theory If we have caring relationships, high expectations and opportunities for meaningful participation.
Those three components as part of the larger umbrella of resiliency young people who have adults and peers who offer them those three components have such a such a higher likelihood of success and overcoming adversity versus those who are not receiving that from important adults in their life or from peers. So thank you to our coaches, and to our administrators, and all those adults out there who are providing those components for young people. And I'll just say for our cheer team, you can see as Ms. Ramos had mentioned what it's grown to. And even from where I am on Zoom finding Ms. Ramos on that stage is like trying to find where's Waldemar? I didn't know she was there until the coach asked about it. So anyways, thank you all so much. Congratulations to all of you on a job well done.
Keep making us proud. You are doing amazing work.
Thank you for those beautiful comments Mayor Pro Tem. Thank you.
The next item on the agenda is for public comments for items not on the agenda and I'll refer to Our clerk, to see if there are any public speakers for items not on the agenda.
1:50 – 1:5712 turns
Madam
Clerk, are you able to confirm too if we have anybody online waiting to speak?
Mayor and Council members, yes we have two virtual speakers. Would you like to take them first?
We'll take maybe after the in-person and then we'll alternate to online. Okay. Ms. Mary French followed by the online caller. And after the virtual speaker Mr. Eric Andrus, you're after that speaker.
Good evening. My name is Mary Rainer French and I am here representing the Redwood Neighborhood Council and I would like to invite the city council members All the residents of Oxnard, especially South Oxnard to our neighborhood council meeting tomorrow evening 6 p.m at Our Savior's Lutheran Church at 905 Redwood Street. We will be having a candidate meet and greet evening so please come and join us there's going to be 12 candidates and two representatives from our area that will be on the ballot. So if you wish to meet these candidates, please come and join us.
Our Savior's Lutheran Church, 905 Redwood Street in South Oxnard. Thank you.
Can I say something? Absolutely go ahead Council Member Peralta. Mrs. French thank you very much for coming and sharing that and thank you also for representing your neighborhood and your executive board. Thank you.
Madam Chair, we'll go to the virtual caller. Follow up Mr. Eric Andrus.
Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Hello this is Deirdre Frank I'm so pleased for the recognition given Students of Oxnard, especially the academic recognition. But you know there are so many of them that I think these recognitions should perhaps be compiled and saved for a celebration like a big celebratory event held perhaps at the OPAC and we call it the Excellence Awards. You have them biannually or quarterly You can have sponsors for the event.
And you know, since this has become like a graduation ceremony where everyone is getting their diploma as they do the walk perhaps an event at the OPAC would serve this purpose better where everyone could have a greater opportunity to speak there'd be greater opportunity for photographs it can be live on YouTube, just like your City Council meeting. It can be recorded just like your City Council meeting and I think that would be better than taking up an hour of council's time when people are looking to take care of the city's business.
So although believe me, I was a mock trial coach. I know the effort involved. I appreciate the recognition for everybody But I think this has just become too much, especially since our meetings are compelled to be handled in the evenings when people have limited time. And it is a work night. Thank you.
Thank you for your comments, Ms. Frank. Thank you. Mr. Andrews?
Oddly, I agree with Deirdre on that. You earlier finished the Pledge of Allegiance, a pledge to the flag and I'd like to talk about the flag. On October 2022 Assistant City Attorney Jason Zaragoza sent a written reprimand to the manager of the Oxnard Performing Arts Center because she lowered the American flag to half staff to honor Supervisor Carmen Ramirez who had just passed away. Zaragoza told her the city must comply with national flag protocol that only the president or the governor could authorize lowering a flag for any other reason. I filed a public records request asking for the specific legal authority behind that claim, the statute, the ordinance, the written policy. The response produced nothing because there is nothing. The U.S.
Flag Code carries no penalties whatsoever. The American Legion, the organization that actually wrote the flag code explicitly says local officials can lower flags to honor community members A city employee was formally reprimanded because, based on a legal authority that simply does not exist. Either that or your overpaid public record advocate is withholding more records.
That's the City Attorney's Office which seems to think making things up to enforce their agenda is okay and I assure you it isn't. Now let's talk about the city manager. Alex Nguyen's employment contract requires him to adhere to the ICMA Code of Ethics The Professional Standard for City Managers Nationwide. That code requires city managers to respect the role of elected officials and refrain from working against them. There is documented evidence that Alex has done exactly that, worked against an elected member of this city council and against the elected city treasurer.
I contacted ICMA directly this week and they confirmed he is not registered with them He was almost 15 years ago, but his membership is no longer active. Yet his contract with Oxnard still requires ICMA ethics compliance. But that one professional body empowered to enforce that code has no jurisdiction over him as a nonmember. How convenient! A contract written and approved by your top-notch city attorney's office gave this council a way to keep him on the straight and narrow, and he's made sure that mechanism is not available to you.
Were you aware of that? His contract even includes a provision allowing him to ask you to pay for the membership. Does anyone remember asking him to pay for it? A city attorney's office that fabricates legal authority, a city manager bound to an ethics code that the council can't enforce who has used his position against the very elected officials he is supposed to serve. This council deserves better and so does the community. I'm working on holding everyone accountable in this city that you all want to blindly praise, even though the people often tell you differently. Will any of you actually work on making this city better? Or do you think you're doing enough already? Thank you.
Thank you Mr. Andrews. Madam Clerk we'll now go to the second virtual caller.
1:57 – 2:056 turns
Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Hi, this is Sarah Wilczewski. I am here tonight to give the update on ice activity here in Oxnard. I don't have updated numbers but we saw ice in South Oxnard five mornings this week between the 30th and the 3rd. We saw them Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday. And I also wanted to recognize that today is Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women in People's Awareness Day to recognize the disproportionate violence that is experienced by indigenous women, girls and diverse people.
Their stories matter and their lives matter. Thank you.
Thank you Sarah. We'll go to Jeanette Lopez followed by Mr. Art Mortel. Jeanette, you're first and then Mr. Mortel will follow you.
Good evening council members. On 4-29 of 2022, I made a report with Officer Garcia badge number 5434 for incident number 2230657 reporting to Administrator Junks at Pacifica High School Oxnard. I reported Ted Lawrence and I reported Ray Gonzalez Then after, Officer Garcia advised me to go to Ventura County District Attorney's Office and I reported the incident and turned in a letter and a copy of the police report with the same incident.
My question to the Police Department, and I just seen the Chief just walk in, why haven't these two drunks been arrested? for negligence on their actions. This is a federal offense, a class action suit and multiple cases with employees that came forward to report incidents like myself and was wrongfully terminated. Superintendent McDonnell McCoy you're my number one coward because I reported to you and to Karen Sherr and Cesar Morales and $68 million of money uncounted for, well you can times that times 3,400 students not including the staff, parents and everything else. So once again nothing was done and furthermore I know it's Cinco de Mayo weekend or the whole week and actually for today that's how I wanted to present for today Mr. McArthur you asked to see me I came into your office Is there any comments or anything from any of the council members that would like to address?
And going back to the evidence, I supplied pages of evidence in regards to these two people. I don't know why they're still employed with Oxnard Union High School District but my job as a godparent is to protect my godchildren and now I have 15. So all the way, all the way across from the top from Pepperdine all the way to the newborn two months. And with all due respect my duty is protecting them and MacArthur I don't know if you're how close you are to Mr. Romero's principal at Pacifica High School but Mighty Mouse with special powers he's not a very good liar And he was involved with my dismissal as well.
So I also wanted to put that in the note and also, I will be reporting to the council board meeting at Oxnard Union High School District because my voice matters. Thank you.
Thank you, Ms. Lopez. Mr. Martel?
Good evening. Recently, I met with Terrell Harrison and some of his associates including Pam Morrison and Jesse Tapia. I was asked to present one of my training programs to about 15 other staff which I did. After completing my program we confirmed March 6th to discuss scheduling my next training program for the rest of their staff and then to continue with the community of the work I do.
However, the day before our confirmed meeting, I received an email from Ashley Costello stating quote it's a careful review we regret to inform you that as of March 5th your volunteer application is no longer being considered. I then spoke with Ashley explained that was already volunteering and asked why my work was being canceled. I was told that the decision to cancel my work was made by the director Steve The following morning, I called Mr. Harrison's office and was told that our meeting for four in the afternoon was still confirmed.
I then mentioned Ashley's email and soon received an email from Terrell's office explaining yes they had to confirm our meeting. I'm sorry cancel our meeting. Over the next few weeks when in the area, I visited the Human Resources Department to meet with Steve but he was never available. I left my phone number each time and asked him to contact me but that never happened.
On March 24th, I emailed Steve with one request. A meeting to understand why my volunteer work was being discontinued. Having yet to hear from Steve, I am now here. I understand that the two primary objectives of the City of Oxnard are two words. Transparency and accountability. And I believe we cannot have accountability without transparency just as we cannot have justice without the truth.
So I'm appealing to those of you in a position of authority that at least one of you might meet with me. I'll leave my contact information below. And I'm thanking many of you, you know who I'm speaking about, many of you for having given me so much time in the past that we can at least have a conversation regarding transparency. I think for all the work I'm doing, I was in Santa Paula today teaching children critical thinking through chess I just finished recently 18 months at Ventura County Juvenile Hall, teaching critical thinking through chess every Friday afternoon for 18 months. I'll be with the Oxnard Portland Navy Boys and Girls Club tomorrow continuing my process that way. So I'm just curious what I'm doing all this work for.
Last year, Cal Lutheran University, Channel Islands University, Ventura College lecturing there four times to Pepperdine in Malibu. Why could not continue the work I've already begun with your people? I look forward, Alex. Look forward to being with one of you in the future to help me help your people. Thank you very much.
2:05 – 2:127 turns
Thank you Mr. Mortel.
Mayor, could a member of staff perhaps talk to Mr. Mortel before he leaves this evening just to see if we can clear this up?
Council Member, we have his, Mr. Mortel's contact information. We can follow-up with him. Gloria Massey. Thank you, Gloria. Followed by Mr. Larry Stein.
Good evening, Council. My name is Gloria Massey-Chinea and I'm wearing a different hat at this moment. The report that I'm going to share with you is documented by the people that are experts in statistics, science information of the topic and some of these sources are 2025 state of Ventura County region, Ventura County public health websites California websites and other government agencies.
Again, my name is Gloria Massey Chinea and I do have a master's degree in public health and I'm a certified health education specialist. So with open heart, I'm sharing this information with you. I'm so excited to see the amount of success that we saw. But let me share with some statistics. Public school enrollment from 2021-2022 we had 18,220 students 2024 we had 16,895 students the trends are going down. Ventura public school enrollment projections 2024 to 2025 was 122 810 2040 to 2041, it's 104, 934. The annual per pupil spending of Oxnard Unified School District from 2019 to 2020 was 12,974. 2023-2024 was 19,960. Ventura County school graduation and dropout rate is higher in minorities in minorities area. Now my basic concern, my husband's too concern is that the English percentage of student meeting or exceeding standards for 2024-2025 11th grade students has 54.1% proficient in the English language.
Some example Rio Mesa has 46%, Moinimi high 38, Oxnard high 48, Condor high 29%. Math percentage of students meeting or exceeding standards are Rio Mesa High School, 24%, Hueneme High 9%, Oxnard High 25%. Condor High is 5%. Ventura County teen birth rate is 9.5. Hispanics are in the higher in the teen pregnancy rate in Ventura County. Teen sexually transmitted disease rate in 2016, our county Thank you for sharing the data with us.
Pastor Greg Runyon. I'm sorry, it was you Mr. Stein and then followed by Pastor Greg Runyon. Go ahead Mr. Stein.
Good evening Mr. Mayor, members of City Council, staff General public. It seems that every year, the city passes a balanced budget. At least that's what the city tells us happens every year, a balanced budget. But include in that balanced budget something called unfunded liabilities. What is an unfunded liability? An unfunded liability is a liability the city has but has no money to pay for it.
A very common, well one of the more popular unfunded liabilities is pensions. So pensions are approved by City Council when they have contract negotiations. So pension is one of the largest unfunded liabilities the city has. Created by City Council when they pass the budgets and contracts our public officials. So this unfund liability is not going away The city manager decides to spend general fund money to decrease the unfunded liability.
Now, the city manager just improved the raises for everybody from 5% last year knowing full well that sales tax revenue is going to be dropped but the unfunded liability is still going up My question to you, how would City Council address the unfunded liabilities? And that's just pension plans. To me an unfunded liability is the water system because the City Council passed 2010 water bonds 15 years ago and they didn't build the wells. That's an unfunded liability.
Developers paid fees to the city to develop East Village and West Village. But the park was not built, the fire station was not built. That's an unfunded liability. The city made commitments to fix up seawalls. That's another unfunded liability because we don't have the money to fix up seawalls. So what are you going to drop? Headcount or otherwise when cell tax goes down and we have more unfunding liabilities.
I don't know what positions City Council is going to drop to pay for the unfunded liabilities. And when will the parks be built? Because we are promised, we were promised by city staff and they approved the Northeast Pacific Plan to build what's now known as Sports Park and build Fire Station 9. In 2019, the city said, we're not going to build Fire Station 9 because we don't have any fire concerns. We still have ALS and BLS needs that did not go away just because you didn't build a fire station. ALS and BLS went up Because more people moved in. Please consider how you're going to be addressing unfunded liabilities in a budget session. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Mr. Stein. Pastor O'Neill? And Pastor, you'll be followed by Alicia Purcell.
2:12 – 2:198 turns
If it's not yours I gave you a pen. Mayor and Council good evening. Want to invite everyone on Thursday 6 o'clock to the National Day of Prayer But I also want to share with you that I was encouraged and discouraged in that we posted this on Facebook and different places. And not once did I say that this was an event where we would praise Donald Trump, curse Donald Trump Praise Obama, curse Obama. Praise Mary MacArthur, curse Mary MacArthur. Praise Aaron Starr, curse Aaron Starr. Praise Bert Perillo. What we said was we're going to lift God up. I was called a Christo-fascist, a Christian nationalist. I was called a lot of names but I want to tell you the name I embrace is a follower of Jesus. I'll embrace that. I may not get it right But I will tell you this, I am not trying to follow my way because my way led me the wrong way.
And when I heard some of the statistics that Gloria was reading, I hope all of us are adult enough to realize what makes our country great is that none of us insists that my way is the right way And when you hear where 9% of young women between the ages, I think she said 15 and 19 something like that are having some kind of pregnancy. That's one out of 11. I'm not very good at math. I failed just about every math class I took but I can figure that out. That's about 1 in 11.
That is not okay. Because I'll tell you that God wants better for our young people. And there may be people that don't want to be taught and force God down their throat, but can I tell you what makes our country great? The idea of democracy, the idea of choice, the idea of being able to decide your destiny is because God gave you that right. So I encourage all of you to come whether you're a believer or not believe in Oxnard come out Be with us. I promise you, like I said before, there's not going to be any snakes. Nobody's pulling snakes out. Nobody is doing anything weird. What we're doing is lifting up God as we understand him in love and in honor. We want our community to be better and I pray that you all can come and celebrate with us.
Thank you.
Thank you Pastor. What are the times for the public?
What's that? Well, Lions Park at six to seven and it's a hard seven. We'll be out of there maybe even a little before.
Thanks, Pastor. Lions Park.
Too many questions, Bert.
Ms. Purcell. Followed by Ronald who is joining us virtually
At the last City Council meeting when Mr. Starb stained on a vote, the city attorney attempted to compel him to vote by citing to a policy in the council procedures manual and this policy says when present all council members are to vote unless prohibited by law or conflict of interest but Mr. Fisher ought to know that this policy is void as an An attempt by government to compel speech, which is a violation of the First Amendment. And the First Amendment applies in spite of any conflicting city policy.
But beyond that Mr. Fisher said nothing when at least four other current council members have abstained on votes when they were not prohibited from voting. He said nothing when Mr. Starr has abstained on previous occasions. So why now? Well, this selective attempt to enforce an unenforceable policy only came when Mr. Starr's critics are looking for things to complain about to fuel a recall attempt.
On social media Steve Nash who submitted to you some written comments on the subject tonight claimed that abstention should be censured and this is justification of her recall. But he called for no censures, no recalls when other council members did it. One of the responses on his post was from a relative of former Mayor Zaragoza feigning outrage over an abstention but I saw no such outrage when former Mayor Zaragosa abstained from vote though he was not required to abstain.
You know, there's some similar selective outrage if Mr. Starr interrupts another council member but no such outrage when Mr. Turan and Mr. Perrello interrupt Mr. Starr which they do. So with an attempt to qualify a recall underway, there's going to be plenty of critiques about anything that Mr. Starr does. He blinks too much. He doesn't blink enough. He claps wrong. Manuel Herrera recently criticized me on social media for having the audacity to attend City Council meetings gasp.
If he participates in debate, critics say he makes the meetings too long even if it's actually two hours of public comment on a hot topic that made the meeting run long. If he doesn't say much in debate, they run to social media and falsely accuse him of having slept through the meeting. Council members Perrello and Turan repeatedly criticize him for asking questions during the meeting saying you should have asked the question in advance so we don't waste meeting time on it but they ask questions during the meeting, questions they could have asked in advance. They just don't want Mr. Starr to participate.
So we're all used to this sort of thing during political campaigns, but it's wholly inappropriate for the city manager and city attorney's offices to insert themselves into these political activities as we have seen them do recently. Thank you.
Thank you Ms. Purcell. We'll go to Ron who is joining us virtually.
2:19 – 2:2810 turns
You have if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Good evening, Mayor McArthur, Mayor Pro Tem Turan, Council Members, staff and the public. My name is Ronald Aruejo, Vice Chair of the East Village Neighborhood Council and speaking on behalf of the Oxnard Inter-Neighborhood Council Organization's INCO Executive Board. We invite everyone to attend in person via Zoom or view the recording later of the Candidates Forum for four of the county candidate positions next Monday, May 11 at 6 p.m., in the Oxnard Council Chambers. Those four positions in which candidates are planning to participate in the Candidate Forum are for Treasurer Tax Collector, Clerk and Recorder, Auditor-Controller and Superintendent of Schools.
We are excited to be hosting this event in the largest city in the county that makes up just under a quarter of Ventura County's population. We encourage everyone to submit questions by this Sunday, May 10th to the link bit.ly slash 2026 Oxnard Candidate Forum Questions, no spaces, to have your concerns addressed on what you care about Please stay informed about these candidates and their positions as ballots are delivered to mailboxes this week.
Some or potentially all of these positions may not be on the November general election ballot if candidates receive more than 50 percent of the votes at the upcoming June primary election, but this may be your only chance to have your say. Again we look forward to providing Oxnard and all of Ventura County and opportunity to hear from your county-wide candidates in less than a week on Monday, May 11 at 6 p.m., here in the Oxnard Council Chambers. Thank you very much.
Thank you. Forgive me for just writing some notes now. We will go now to Martha Patron, please. And she requires a translator Thank you, Ms. Petro. You'll have six minutes with an interpreter. Thank you. You
need the microphone? This way we can talk to the mic and...
We don't need another microphone. Thank you Mayor.
Good evening, Mayor. My name is Marta and it says here honorable members of the Municipal Council City Administration and team that works with older adults This is just to give you my deep thanks and appreciation for honoring our families that are centenarians. Maria Marquez at the house of Maria Patron. On behalf of our entire family, We wish to express our deepest gratitude because of the extraordinary kindness, compassion and generosity that you have shown to my dear aunt during the celebration of her 100 years of life.
The acknowledgement you brought to her because she reached this important 100 years old became one of the most significant moments that our family has lived. Your visit to our humble home in Oxnard and the beautiful certificate you brought, the elegant flower vase and the flowers from the older adults of this city was just a beautiful gesture But we also saw meaningful expressions of unity, respect and love to one of your older residents.
My aunt was so deeply moved, so beautifully surprised And she felt so proud to be able to show you her health, her strength, her happiness because she accomplished this extraordinary goal. Because she felt valued, appreciated, acknowledged by her city Your presence and recognition reminded her, and all of us, that her life matters. That her 100 years of wisdom, perseverance, and legacy deserve to be celebrated.
As residents, we are very proud of this great city. Our family is incapable of expressing fully how meaningful this was to us and your dedication of honoring the elders that shows True leadership of this community, as well as passion and humanity and respect that is genuine. Thank you for taking the time to show how important this is. Thank you for your commitment in recognizing the life and contributions of the older adults at Oxnard.
And thank you for making our families feel so valued. We're deeply grateful to live in a city that honors It's elders with so much beauty and humanity. With true gratefulness and affection, Marta Patron.
Thank you. Thank you. So thank you.
I
know it's public comment but I think both Ms. Cheney and I are getting emotional up here. Thank you for your kind comments.
Thank you. Mayor and Council members, we have a virtual speaker. Okay. Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
2:28 – 2:337 turns
Yes hey good afternoon guys good afternoon council good afternoon mayor how are you first of all I just want We've been actually to speak today in Council, you know the support that our seniors need here in our community is pretty pretty transparent as far as their housing prices and the housing. The housing that is needed for them as well, you know and obviously the recreation activities that we need for them to keep them busy active proactive and obviously on their feet You know, obviously the infrastructure is looking good. All the regulations sidewalks you know they're able to now leave their homes walk independently and pretty much enjoy your city and then other thing too we just want to congratulate the city on all your infrastructure around our seniors and senior services you know congratulations on that.
We'll talk more on that issue and then also I wanted to just really quick recommend for you guys to not ignore Jeanette Lopez. Um, I know that we're in the middle of elections and you know obviously families that have concerns are very detrimental and harmful to campaigns so i think it's important that you guys don't ignore her. I guess her cry for help um I looked into it so it's you know she's valid on a lot of the issues so I think Mayor if he could take that consideration and uh help her It would be nice to know that Chief is in the audience as well, but I think that right now it's very important that family gets the attention they need. And I just want to say thank you to all council members for doing a great job in their city and we'll meet soon.
Thank you. God bless.
Thank you Mr. Huerta. Madam Clerk does that conclude the speakers for
this item? Mayor and Council Members yes, that concludes our speakers in person and virtually for items not on the agenda. Thank you.
We will next go to item H. This is a report of our city manager. Alex, go ahead.
Thank you Mr. Mayor. So three items tonight. Diego can you bring up the slides please? So first is should be the annual, here we go, the Annual Oxnard Police Department's Memorial Ceremony. This is the ceremony to honor Those who made the ultimate sacrifice in serving our community. We'll take place right next to the police station here on C Street. It's on Wednesday, a week from tomorrow May 13th 2026 it begins promptly at 1030 AM every year they start on time and Do not take too long to have this very, very important ceremony for the, not only for the department but for the entire community.
Next I'm going to ask Director Pangili to help me with this. It is apparently building safety month for 2026 and the theme is built to last. So Mr. Pangili, I'll hand it over to you.
Thank you Alex. Thank you Mayor, City Council, Jeff Bingeli, Community Development Director. Briefly, each May we celebrate Building Safety Month and as Alex indicated this year's theme is Built to Last. It serves to remind the public that the city of Oxnard is committed to the safety of our homes our buildings and infrastructure, not just in our everyday lives but in times of natural disaster. We wanna highlight the critical role our local code officials play including Oxnard staff in ensuring that Oxnard residents have code compliant and safe buildings where they live, work, play and worship.
That includes not just the seismic safety fire and life safety exiting but also things like energy efficiency and disabled access. We want to acknowledge the dedication of our engineers, our inspectors, our permit technicians, our support staff. And not just for the Building and Engineering Division of Community Development but we want to recognize our partners in the Oxnard Fire Department Fire Prevention Division.
We just want to take this opportunity to let the public know that our role is to use our training and our expertise to assist residents and businesses through the permitting and inspection process The state codes are complex, and they change every three years. We are your experts. We are your tour guide. Please rely on us for our expertise. We will walk you through the process. Thank you.
Thanks, Mr. Binggeli. All right. Thank you. And then finally another department who does their best to work on things and make them last is Public Works. So I have Director Wolf help with this. This is the annual Public Works open house It is scheduled to take place on Wednesday, May 20 of this year. It's going to be at Plaza Park this year beginning at 1 p.m., and going all the way through 7 p. m. You can see some of the photos there from recent Public Works open houses and Mr. Wolfe is online. Go ahead.
2:33 – 2:4816 turns
Yes, good evening Mayor and Council Members. Michael Wolfe, Director of Public Works. Thank you for allowing us to discuss this so we do have our annual open house as indicated by the City Manager. We are open to the public hours are displayed there. We're excited about this one, the last couple of years has been very popular. I know lots of folks come out and have a good time. They can see all the equipment that we have or most of the equipment they can interact with a lot of our staff members and participate in some fun activities so looking forward to everybody joining us.
Thank you.
And I'd just like to say it's amazing when you're out there and you notice that The kids are as fascinated by some of the interesting Public Works vehicles as they are about fire trucks and police cars. It's really a lot of fun, thank you.
Thank you Alex. I know I took my own kids last year to the Public Works open house and they absolutely love the trash trucks and everything else so we'll be taking them again this year.
The next item is Item I. This is a report from City Council. Members, I'll start with you, Councilwoman Perez. Thank you.
Thank you, Mayor. Just a quick report since our last meeting on Thursday. I just wanted to thank all the organizations that led May Day efforts including Harrington Elementary. I had the opportunity to attend their celebration on Friday night and then I also in the day attended EO Green my alma mater's junior highs career day definitely It was awesome to see all the opportunities. That's definitely not something that I had access to when I was there, but it's good to see the growth and just the exposure to different workforce pathways and educational opportunities. I also had the opportunity last Saturday to join Councilmember Rodriguez's meeting with Doug Partello regarding homelessness and really the need to ensure that our homeless individuals have access to the care and resources in our community.
Just two quick updates regarding neighbourhood council meetings, as mentioned in referencing the weekly packet Redwood Neighbourhood Council will be having their meeting tomorrow at 6 p.m., and then on Thursday May 7th at 6pm Southwinds will be meeting as well And that is my report.
Thank you, Councilwoman.
Mayor, I'd like to thank the people that spoke in public comment. Some of them need responses to their answers. I could give them now but it would end up in a debate and that wouldn't be good for the City of Oxnard. But I can tell you that one mentioned health. One of the things that there's been a tremendous issue in this city of challenging the City of Oxnard Council Had to do with support for pro-choice.
And one of the entities that I support, Planned Parenthood does more than just provide opportunities to abort a child. They provide a lot of information that it sounds like a lot of our young people should take advantage of tremendous amount of information. The comment by my fellow council members wife with respect Two council members questioning when a council member asks a question.
I have no problem with asking the question, I've done it myself as the speaker alluded, I've done it more than one occasion but I do my darndest not to ambush and the right word is ambush city staff by not giving them a heads up of what they're going to ask especially when they have to go back and forth pages Thank you, Mayor. First of all I'd like to wish everybody a happy Cinco de Mayo. Last week I had the opportunity to meet with Misty
at the district office. I also had the pleasure of attending Dia del Nino at Lemonwood School, it was a very well attended event and I really appreciated the invitation from the principal. Last but not least, I'd like to wish all our mothers a happy Mother's Day. We'll be celebrating on Sunday and none of us would be here without our mothers so Happy Mother's Day!
Thank you. Council Member Starr, do you want to go next?
Very short, just happy Cinco de Mayo, Happy Mother's Day. Not a whole lot to report since last Thursday so thank you.
Thank you. Council Member Rodriguez?
Yes similarly since we met on Thursday I attended the EO Green Career Day celebration that they have and the students were exposed to so many careers and I know we had Some city reps just exposing different possibilities, so I really appreciated that. I had office hours and I think we had maybe about eight different people come through so please if you have comments concerns or just want to get to know me Just as a human that'd be great So it's been great to see different council members drop by and Mayor Pro Tem drop by so thank y'all It's a great opportunity for us to just have a cup of coffee, break bread and talk about issues in the community.
So I think that's it for now.
Thank you Councilwoman. Mayor Pro Tem do you want to go next?
Sure, thank you mayor. Somehow we still end up with things even if we met last Thursday right? So I'll just echo. I also had the pleasure and the opportunity to attend the EO Green Career Day that was held at the EOGreen campus and it was very Very pleased that they had a great turnout of diverse occupations and career paths, including an employee of SEA which is our contracted street sleeping service. And we had a great conversation about The type of work they do, he actually had the vehicle outside and you can see how complex this vehicle is. And it makes sense that it does require quite a bit of skill and a classy license I believe in order to operate it so that was great that we had folks who have really good jobs like that were there as well as academic folks People representing our local government, and I was happy to be able to represent myself in my role as a council member and remind young people about the importance of voting and democracy.
And their constitutional rights regardless of their ability to vote, their eligibility to vote or even their citizenship status or what language they speak reminding them that they still have These innate rights that are afforded to them through the state of California's constitution and United States Constitution. So they were a great group, I loved working with all of them. I had all eighth graders the whole time I was there. That was that one and then I'm sure the mayor will mention it too so I'll leave it to him but I did have a chance to attend the first half of the Oxnard Premier Football Club their first home game of this past weekend, and it was great to see. And I just applaud Joe Garcia and all of the folks who are working to provide these young women with the opportunity to hone their skills and compete at that level.
So it was just great to see it, and it was really great to see the turnout and the home side, just how full it was of people there to spectate. So those are my comments, Mayor. I'll just say I always appreciate the speakers who take the time to speak to the local government anytime that we get a chance to have really good discourse that is paramount to this democracy and part of that as an elected leader also means to ensure that it's time well spent by the public and by the staff and by us as elected members So oftentimes that means ensuring that if I'm going to ask a question, that that question, if I ask it ahead of time or tell them hey, I'm curious about this. I would like to speak about this at the public meeting so that the public is fully aware of this versus me springing on them live at the meeting and they may not have all the information.
They need to look and go back. I've essentially cheated the public out of getting that information. So my opinion on that but thank you very much.
Thank you, Mayor Pro Tem. And as many of you know I really value connecting and partnering and collaborating with our individuals and community members. I often interact with folks in my office. I have an open door policy for individuals to come in and speak with me. I value various perspectives that can inform the decisions we make here. I was able to partner with our community for Dia del Nino at Lemonwood Elementary School and was able to take, with the help of friends, raspberries for Dia del Nino to give out to the kids and parents in attendance.
Also this weekend I went here to Plaza Park. I think it was a wonderful event at Cinco de Mayo celebrating Mexico's independence from France Also, at Oxnard College it was really nice to see Radio Laser partnering with SWATME Justice and the college to be able to have Cinco de Mayo celebration there at the college. Further reinforcing I know that the Chancellor was here last week as well as the Vice-Chancellor who's currently filling in as a president of Oxnard College and they spoke about their commitment Ensure that Oxnard College is a hub for community activity. And to testament, attestment to that was the Cinco de Mayo celebration that occurred there at the campus.
Yes, the better public? Oh I'm sorry yes thank you. The better problem from French, from the French government. I also had the opportunity to go this weekend and support a youth soccer program they had their finals at Del Sol Stadium to be able to partner with The organizers of that youth league and be able to present young athletes with their medals and trophies.
And the Mayor Pro Tem mentioned attending the women's game, it's their inaugural game that they play at Deaths Hole Stadium on Sunday evening at 6 p.m. against Montclair. It was the inaugural game of the Oxnard Premier Football Club that is playing in a National Development League So I was happy to go and support that team, and it's exciting to see that they're here. Also the Auction Warriors event at Auckland High School, it's a football youth club.
And then this morning or actually yesterday morning I went to hear the president of Cal State Channel Islands speak about the state of the university and she provided good Just a lot of good positive information, including the fact that they're experiencing an upward trend in their enrollment numbers in the various programs and now the university is offering.
Last night I went to, for the ribbon cutting for Herzog Wine. It's been open since the mid-80s. The rebranding, the reorganizing. I was able to have really deep conversations with the owners of the winery and just delighted to see that they are here in our city and the impact that they have And how many folks from out of town, specifically the Valley, Beverly Hills, West L.A., Hollywood come to our city to spend money to have fine dining and wine? And the number of employees that they have their Herzog Wine most from the City of Oxnard including their chef.
Also lastly this morning I attended the World Trade Forum at the Harbor to hear Those from Peru, the consulate from Peru, the consulate of Mexico to talk about the tremendous economic impact and the trade relations with those various countries. And the economic impact here to a region that they estimate to be about 2.3 billion into this region and the port, the number of employees that they have, Oxnard accounts for Just shy of 60% of those employees in their high-paying jobs. And they talked about the relationship with Oxnard College and also Cal State CI, Cal Lutheran specifically targeting the engineering and biotech sector.
That's all I have. So thank you very much everyone. We'll now go to
the next item on the agenda. It is from the city clerk The subject entails the appointment of members to serve on the city's Mobile Home Park Rent Review Board. The recommendation is that the mayor, with the approval of the City Council, appoint Yoki Okano and Cindy Bernice Segura as at-large members to the Mobile Home Park Rent Review Board. This item did not originate a committee and our clerk, Luna Lopez is here Thank you.
2:48 – 2:5316 turns
I'm very grateful that we're finding individuals to fill these slots, and I have no questions or comments. I know one of the individuals served on multiple CAGs If there are no questions or other addresses, I'd move the recommended action.
I think I have to move the recommended action But I'd be happy to accept your second Councillor Marparo. Are there no further questions or comments? Madam Clerk would call for the vote on this item
Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 move the recommended action But I'd be happy to accept your second Councillor Marparo. Are there no further questions or comments? Madam Cle · 2 under review
Show transcript
and this motion carries seven to zero thank you.
Thank You Madam Clerk
the next item on the agenda is the review of info consent item. Do any council members have any consent items they wish to discuss or pull? No? Are there any comments? Madam Clerk, any public speakers on the consent agenda?
And Mayor and Council Members we do not have any requests to speak on the information in consent in person or virtually. Thank you.
Thank you. Given that there are no speakers what's the pleasure of Council on this particular item? I'll move the recommended action. Thank you. Is there a second? Councilwoman Basuah seconded. Call for the vote, Madam Clerk.
Roll-call vote Passed 4–0 move the recommended action. Thank you. Is there a second? Councilwoman Basuah seconded. Call for the vote, Madam Clerk. Councilwoman Rodrig · 3 under review
Show transcript
and this motion carries 7 to 0, thank you.
Thank you. This is the time and place for a public hearing on item N1 from the Housing Department subject fiscal year 2026-27 annual action plan in citizen participation plan. The recommendation that the City Council 1 conduct a public hearing to receive comments to incorporate any recommended changes and approve the fiscal year 2026-27 annual action plan, otherwise referred to as AAP.
In the citizen participation plan, otherwise referred to as CPP, to be submitted to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development HUD, to authorize a city manager or their designee to incorporate the final grant allocations and approve the corresponding budget appropriations in corresponding revenue recognition Now subject to the $220,000 CPP limit and to make any future budgetary adjustments up to $220,000. And three, authorize the city manager or his designees to execute HUD agreements including certifications applications and pertinent documents for submission and sign all agreements for the implementation including sub-recipient and intra-departmental agreements This item did not originate in committee.
Brenda Lopez, Housing Director is here to answer any questions. We start with the city's certification of publication and written communications if any. Madam City
Clerk? Thank you Mayor and Council Members. Mayor just as a housekeeping item if we can just take a motion on the information and consent agenda for Item I-4 that's for the parking authority just so that we can officially adopt that item
I make a motion to move the item. Second by Council Member Perrello.
Roll-call vote Passed 7–0 move the item. Second by Council Member Perrello. Thank you,
Show transcript
and this motion carries seven to zero and now back to the public hearing mayor and council members there was a legal notice for this public hearing publish and be the newspaper on April 2nd and the city clerk's office has received no written communications on this item thank you
Thank you, Madam Clerk. Do any council members have any ex parte communications or other disclosures regarding this matter to state for the record?
No.
Thank you. Members of the public were invited to sign up to speak on this item on the city's website and a person who did not sign up may do so now by submitting a speaker card or following the instructions posted on the agenda for this meeting in at the city's website oxnard.org city meetings Lorraine Mendez, Grants and Compliance Manager posted a video presentation regarding this item and is available to answer any brief clarifying questions council members may have before we take public testimony on this item.
The Council will deliberate after the public hearing has been closed. Do any council members have any questions at this time? I'll now open the public testimony portion of the public hearing. Speakers have three minutes to speak on this item Madam Clerk, is Christine Rizk the only public speaker that signed up?
Mayor, yes. That is correct. Thank you.
2:53 – 3:006 turns
Hello! My name is Kirsten Rizik and I've come to provide my input as a community member of Oxnard and as an employee of Turning Point Foundation. Turning Point Foundation is a Ventura County non-profit providing shelter, housing and services to community members in Ventura County experiencing mental health challenges including those who are homeless. As both a resident of Oxnard and employee of Turning Point Foundation homelessness continues to be a high priority I have seen the City of Oxnard's efforts over the last few years pay off significantly. From the 2025 homeless point in time count to the 2026 point in time count, there was a 16% reduction in homelessness which I think we can celebrate and the year prior there was also about a 16 percent reduction in homelessness so the city's efforts are clearly paying off And I think that the recommended annual action plan this year, which also supports a variety of housing types and housing solutions along with supportive services will continue to decrease those numbers of homelessness in the city of Oxnard and continue those successes.
And so for this reason, I recommend the action plan as presented and commend the city on its efforts toward improving homelessness.
Thank you. Does that conclude the speakers on the public hearing?
Mayor and council members, yes. That concludes our speakers. We actually have a virtual speaker so we'll take that caller now. Thank you. Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Yes. Hey mayor how are you? So what a subject, homelessness. This is I mean what a mess that Emilio Ramirez left behind. I guess I lived in it at downtown Oxnard and obviously during COVID there was a lot of I guess homelessness around our seniors and there was I guess we still mask mandates and there's just a lot of controversy around uh homelessness farm workers and the answer housing crisis so It's nice to see that Christine Risk is actually putting more attention to our homeless situation. I'm not sure what type of relationship she had with Emilio Ramirez prior before COVID, but at the end it took a lot not only for local leaders but it took a lot for advocates to really put their minds into it and not only that it's not only our homeless It's not only our homelessness that has been affected, but it's also a mental health issue and crisis in our state.
And at the end, providing the adequate resources, providing the right voices is only going to secure the funding that is needed for housing and obviously Turning Point. I can speak more about Turning Point at the end. That explains the agenda today in the City Council meeting, but at the end I'll just keep that silent. But you know, the focus really is our community members Not ourselves and finding funding, finding the right resources. And at the same time upgrading our behavioral health systems, making sure that when our officers show up at homes they provide the right resources to support the right family members during the crisis. And at the end you know focus on our mental health crisis really because at the end it's costed our state I'm not going to go back to the past, but if you recall the governor this exact issue costs us about 230 or 60 million and it's taxpayers money.
And we're still trying to find a solution for it. But I just want to say that this is something that I'm very dedicated to. At the end, I support a lot of the staff at Casa del Carmen trying to work around obviously legislation and working with City Council and providing the right resources. Thank you guys appreciate it.
Next we're going to call up Pastor Greg Ryan.
I apologize, I didn't plan on saying something. When you think of an issue like this there are a couple things that are just honest. One not all homeless people are alike, not all the issues are alike There is no, I know we have a service that's called One Stop. There is no one stop. There is no one size fits all as a body. I hope that you all are honest enough to recognize Mayor McArthur was in law enforcement He knows, he can look at the effects that homelessness has. He has no idea what it's like to be homeless.
And sometimes we say things like that but the thing is you want to be able to help someone help themselves and I think For all of us, whether it's Turning Point or Casa de Vida or the Rescue Mission or the Housing Authority or the Oxnard City Council. Your job is not to save people. Your job is to give people the tools to save themselves. And so I think and I would hope that if you are committed to this that you do not try to shortchange it And I also will say this is not something that you can just look at the data.
You know, I was homeless at points in my life. I was homeless because of my drug addiction. I was homeless because of my choices. I was homeless because of my behaviors. It wasn't until I was much older that I decided that I needed to work on why I chose those behaviors You're not going to be able to force somebody to get help, but I do think it's paramount that you offer it and also that you ask the right questions. And sometimes the right question isn't what are you going to do with the dollar?
It's why should I give you the dollar? And some of us, we just have to take a step back and listen to reason and explanation. The last thing I want to tell you, King Klopman, a former officer used to say if you always do what you've always done, you're always going to get what you've always got. Let me say it to you in a different way. You cannot fix the mistakes of the past. You can fix the mistakes of the future by not committing the sins of the past. Thank you.
3:00 – 3:0712 turns
Thank you. Thank you.
There are no additional speakers and we will close the public hearing. The public hearing is now closed. I will now entertain a motion to approve the recommended actions.
The next item
on the agenda is Item N1 from
the
Public Works Department. Subject entails public project agreement, construction management services
Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the public. I would like to make a motion to approve the city council's service agreement amendment for campus park activation project. The recommendation is that the City Council approve and authorize a total of $16 million 4787263 in project funds for the campus park activation project to the mayor to execute We have a total of $1,268,814.
With urban habitat for a total not to exceed value of $13,956,9563 for the project. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the public. I have a motion for engineering inspection survey construction management and project management for the project for the mayor to execute an agreement with Philippine engineers in the amount of $1,000,780 Three consecutive one-year period extensions ending May 16th, 2031 for professional construction management, inspection materials testing, grant administration and public outreach services for the project.
Five, the mayor to execute a fourth amendment to agreement 82, sorry, A. Adam 8248 with Moore, Ayo Kofano, Goldsman Inc., in the amount of 10,700,000 for a new not-to-exceed amount of 1,299,652 and extend the term to December 31st, 2027 to perform landscape architecture and design construction support services for the Campus Park Activation Project. And six, a project budget appropriation of 299,727 from the Local Development Impact Fees Fund As a reminder, this item did not originate in committee as this is a capital improvement project specifically listed in the city's current capital improvement program budget which was previously approved by City Council.
And Michael Wolfe, our Public Works Director is here to answer any questions the staff may have. Before Councilmember discussion we'll take public comments. That's okay Mr. Wolfe. And we will start with Mr. Eric Endrist Madam Clerk, do we have any callers online?
Mayor yes we have one virtual speaker.
We'll take that caller right after Mr. Andrus. Go ahead Eric.
Your illustrious city attorney's office requires me to illegally be here to say please play the video. This is Eric Andrist at the Henry Levy House, Caddy Corner to Campus Park. At the last meeting, Alicia Purcell said this about the City Manager's budget survey.
When you get to the survey asking how to set the priorities, the answers have already been filled in for you. You're being told what the priorities are and you can rank them relative to each other but you can't add one to the ranking You know, there was a list about 10 subjects that were pre-populated. It asked the public just to rank those options. We only get to rank someone else's priorities that were given to us.
Tonight you're being asked to spend $16 million on a park designed by exactly that kind of process. I have the City's own grant application. In the first two workshops residents were shown staff prepared posters that already included a Pelota-Mixteca court In the next two workshops, residents were given pre-made stickers to place on maps. But those stickers were created by the staff based on staff made posters from the first two workshops.
Residents never generated the options themselves. The Mixteco Indígena Community Organizing Project was a formal planning partner before any resident ever walked through the door. Residents ranked what they were given. Staff chose options. That's a rigged survey and the grant application reveals why. It describes the goal as building, quote, California's first official Pelota-Mixteca court, close quote.
That wasn't something residents dreamed up. It was a distinction the city wanted to claim in a competitive grant application and the process was engineered to produce it. This park was originally promised to be completed in March of 2022, then March of 2024. Construction begins June of 2026, four years of delays and while we're talking about what this community actually wants Wilson Park just down the street is in disrepair I think it was Burt Perrella who called out that one park in Oxnard doesn't even have restrooms. But tonight we're voting to build a park full of lush landscaping while existing parks can't get basic maintenance. Maybe a real survey would have surfaced that priority too.
Don't call this the will of the people because the people were never really asked If this council truly wants to serve its constituents, conduct a real survey before spending this money. No pre-populated options, no staff chosen priorities. Thank you.
3:08 – 3:1710 turns
Thank you Mr. Andrews. We'll go to the virtual...
Mayor and Council Members that person has lowered their hand so thank you.
Mayor Pro Tem, did you want to say something?
Oh wait till we're done with the speakers mayor. Thank you.
Okay thank you. We'll take Angela Whitecomb followed by Aurelio Ocampo Jr.
Good evening I just wanted to start by saying that i am over the moon about this project and I'm really excited because I sat in those public meetings where people from the community came. There were three of them, I was part of the Parks and Recreation Commission then not chair just a member and I was also a member of Friends of Campus Park and still am. We fundraised for that meeting we brought things to the community, we invited the community to come. A ton of my neighbors came neighborhood outreach meeting and this was, you'll have to forgive me. I'll have to ask Mr. Andrus the date of when those meetings were. I don't remember but they were very open and transparent and very exciting and we brought in the ideas that we wanted from the community.
We did have members from the community that represented the Pelota-Mexteca athletics, and they were very eager to share the culture that was around this sport and how they looked forward to having an area where they could play that was an official field. And when they stated their case, the people that sat in that room that chose to come to those meetings, they were excited because it was something new and different for people who are outside of that community to experience. It's also just a big area of DG. It is kind of flat. So it has the opportunity to serve more than one purpose. As it being a lush native landscape, well there's a group called Friends of Campus Park and what they want to do is volunteer and bring in volunteers to support that landscaping and to keep it beautiful and to make it something unique to this city.
As a Parks Commissioner I am very well aware of the challenges that we face with our parks not having enough restrooms. You can hear me, I will speak about public restrooms all day long and you probably are gonna get really tired of me saying we need one downtown and in every park and then they should be open for everybody and they should probably be something that's pretty bulletproof and also very friendly and inviting to go into because nobody wants to take the three-year-old to something that you're scared to sit down on as a mom We spend our times in these places. Public green spaces are important, and our city deserves something that's beautiful and unique. And I applaud you for finding a way to make this happen, and I encourage you to look for more opportunities like this with all of our parks in the city.
Thank you.
Thank you Angela. Aurelio? Followed by Veronica Munoz
Good evening Mayor, City Council members and city staff. My name is Aurelio Campo and I'm here tonight representing the Friends of Campus Park in support of the city moving forward with the campus park and continued progress of this long awaited project for more than 15 years our organization that's stood beside the city of Oxnard helping shape the vision of Campus Park and what it could become from the very beginning Friends of Campus Park has been front and center in the conversations, workshops, planning meetings, outreach efforts and community engagement that helped guide this project in the direction it has taken today.
This park is not just another development project to us. It represents years of collaboration, persistence and belief in what this community deserves. Our group also played a significant role in supporting the city's efforts to secure more than $21 million in grant funding. That level of support did not happen overnight, it took partnerships advocacy volunteer work and shared commitment between community members and the city to make this possible.
Tonight we believe that time has come to move forward. We strongly support the selection of a construction firm so this project can finally move from planning into reality. The community has waited long enough time for this moment, and we are excited to see the vision begin taking physical shape. Friends of Campus Park also looks forward to continuing our partnership with the city in the months and years ahead. We are committed not only to supporting the construction process but also helping oversee manage maintain and program the park alongside the city and our community partners We also look forward to working with Police Activities League, also known as PAL.
A nonprofit organization that provides recreation and positive opportunities for youth and already has presence at Campus Park site. We believe partnerships like these are essential to creating a safe active and welcoming environment for young people and their families throughout our community. Our organizations core values center around education environmental stewardship, public safety, civic duty volunteerism and creating a welcoming experience for every resident and visitor who enters the park.
Over the coming months we will continue mobilizing volunteers and working with the many supporters and partners we have built relationships with throughout the years to help ensure the success of Campus Park. The project represents what can happen when the community stays committed to a shared vision We are proud of the work that has brought us to this point and we are excited for what happens next.
Thank you for your time and thank you for continuing to move Campus Park forward.
Thank you, thank you Aurelio. Veronica followed by Mr. Miguel Fernandez
Good evening, everyone. My name is Veronica Munoz. I'm here today both as a citizen born and raised here in Oxnard and also as a very recent member to the Friends of Campus Park. I would like to express my excitement and my support for a very long-awaited project which is the commencement of the construction of Campus Park. I am the last graduating class of Oxnard High School, 1995. And I opted to come back after college to live in this community. I live in the neighborhood just blocks away from Campus Park and I hope...I have the hope and the vision of enjoying this big beautiful nature-based park. Of course, I was hoping to see it a lot sooner rather than 20 years later, but here we are. And I'd like to thank the efforts of the Friends of Campus Park for so many years as well as that of many community members who contributed to the planning of it, city staff, contractors, developers that have put their vision to paper and hopefully we will soon begin to see a first phase of construction As a member of Friends of Campus Park, we hope to be an integral part of the park's growth and success.
We would like to see this become a place of beauty and inspiration for all of the Oxnard residents. I would really like to see my own children enjoy this park now as young adults. And as a side note to address the Mixteco area, having visited Oaxaca last fall I learned that Oaxaca is such a huge state. in Mexico with many diverse regions. And outside of Oaxaca, Oxnard has the largest population of Oaxacan people outside of Mexico. So I think it's a well-deserved area and component of the park.
Again we are so ready for this park and it is our hope that tonight you will support the first leg of this project by hiring the recommended contractor. Thank you.
3:17 – 3:2215 turns
Miguel Fernandez.
Thank you, Mr. Mayor and good evening to the Council too. It's been a long road to get to where we are right now. It is a very significant moment in time now for this project and for our community. I just want to give thanks to the Council, the mayor, staff for getting us to this point where we are now And I want to give the same thanks to the previous councils, the previous mayors and the previous staff members that helped shepherd this project to where it is now.
And particularly, I want to single out our grants writer Eric Hummel who's not just a grant writer he's a rainmaker And in a time of drought, he brings money for projects such as this. This is four separate grants that were specifically tied to this particular project. They're not just money that we could have gotten and attribute to some other project elsewhere. It's for this park, it's for the items in this park including Palo Alto Mixteca and if Palo Alto Mixteca was partly responsible for getting us some of that grant money, so be it.
We are a disadvantaged community that probably had a big role in helping us get some of this grant money. The grant money is going to this park, the park's gonna be beautiful and we're just very grateful at this point that this is where we're at right now. I urge you to say yes to all of those items, thank you.
Thank you Mr. Fernandez.
Mayor and council members, we do have a virtual speaker. Virtual speaker, if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now. Virtual speaker, if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
It's okay Madam Clerk we can always come back to that individual should they come back. Okay. All right. Mayor Pro Tem, do you want to go up next?
Hello? Mr.
Stein,
please
proceed.
Good
evening. I'm
somewhat concerned
Now, first of all, I'm happy that we're building Campus Park. That's a great thing. The fact that there's a well on it that's not working is a different issue. But the fact we have three regional parks, Campus Park, Sports Park and College Park. How come you're not using general fund money to build these parks but relying on grant money? These are committed liabilities because this doesn't let us save promises for taxpayers.
Taxpayers have built three regional parks, Fort Park, Campus Park and College Park. We're getting started on Campus Park. You've got to realize that Campus Park was only purchased because it was a low bidder on this property. The high bidder on this was Garcia-Martin. They paid more for this property, offered more for this property than the city did. The city got the property. It's great that we're building this park but it's taking so long! Why is it taking 20 years to build this park? The city bought the land in 1998, almost 20 years later and still they've been thinking about the park. When is that thing going to be built?
You had groundbreaking ceremonies but still not built. I'm somewhat concerned with the fact We're not focusing on the parks in general, but counting on grant money for the regional park. And that's the price being built for the 200 parks that need to be finished. Thank you very much for your time.
Thank you Mr. Stein. Mayor Pro Tem?
Yes thank you mayor. I did have a question from earlier if it's okay if I ask it.
3:22 – 3:3613 turns
Yeah go ahead.
Okay, thank you. I'm wondering if from our public works staff and i'm not sure who's there um i can't see the podium at this point uh can we just give a brief summary um not the 20 plus year summary uh just a quick summary of the campus park activation phase one versus phase two and phase three um and then the follow-up question to that because after we talk about the phases The winning bid and how that has allowed us to look at some other amenities that we might not. We might have had to do later in later phases. So I'm worried if we can just touch on those two questions.
Yeah, good evening mayor and mayor pro tem and council members Michael Wolfe director of public works so the first part of the question is about the phases that we have for Campus Park. So we do have in our capital project or CIP. Those ones, when Morgan and I got here a couple years back those were inherited projects but the idea there or understanding is that as they were as staff at the time was going after funding. They were looking at the different phases and trying to be able to go after funds in different sort of chunks if you will.
of the phases, including the activation has separate elements and then subsequent phases build on top of those elements as stated in the staff report. So there are certain elements in the activation phase, certain elements that were in phase two grant applications and certain elements that were in phase three grant applications. What has been done to date is there was a master plan for the entirety of the site. That master plan shows all the elements including all the phases. And then when we started the design or when Staff at the time hired a consultant to start the design. They also included other phases in there for the purpose of knowing that we're going to eventually bid those out and construct those.
What we're able to do now is because of Eric Hummel, they got all that money, the rainmaker, I'll have to call him that when I see him tomorrow. Because of all those, the fundings that we got, we were able to start incorporating some of the later phases into their current construction contract So the design package as it states, as it was bid out includes phases two and three. And it also includes I think Mayor Pro Tem's comment is additional or additive items that we included in the bid package that if bids came in lower than the grant grants amount, we could recommend awarding those.
Because the lowest bidder was lower than our current estimate and lower than the grants that were received, we're able to add those additive items. Not necessarily add the phases because those phases have specific elements that need to be funded so there'll be some elements that will be designed and constructed later but we're able to put back in or have in additive items that were bid out as such so that if the bids came in low enough, that we would recommend this. So I think that covers that one and sort of touches on Mayor Pro Tem's second comment or question which was the bid amounts and so good news is is that we have $21 million most of that majority of that is grant funding but we do have certain elements that could be funded by certain grants and elements that can't.
So we have to stick with that from a grant standpoint But we also have match requirements and so with the exception of I think one of the grants, the ones that have match requirements. So we still have to put in certain colors or other monies if you will. So we have some general fund money and we have diff money or development impact fees in this project for some of that for that very purpose. So I think that answers both your questions.
That does thank you very much Chancellor Wolf. And that was my only questions, Mayor. If I may since I have the floor, I'm going to go ahead and just make some comments here since we're done with the speakers. I want to thank all of the work that's happened on this and starting with staff certainly Mr Hummel has been mentioned already It cannot be overstated the incredible role that he has played in Campus Parks ability to have any funding at all, to be able to be realized if the council votes on it tonight to approve it.
So certainly Mr. Hummel and Ms. Jenny Yvanes, who is the project manager for this with our public works folks as well as Mr. Kessler and Mr. Wolfe and all of the other team members who have had a hand in this. And there are a number of community members, as was mentioned by a few speakers, who have been involved nearly every step of the way, some of them in earlier phases, some of them in later phases, some of them the entire time And they, I would say this is probably one of the number one questions i get as a council member overseeing district two. Is hey so what's up with the campus park? What's up with the old Oxnard High School? So it is a great feeling to hear people be so excited to see this now in front of this council tonight and for this decision to be in front of the council to award this bid award and so with that being said I was present as a parks and rec commissioner at the time for all of the workshops as well, and I was there.
And there were early on discussions around what types of things would we have here? This is part of the grant application development process. I'm not sure if the grant application was limited to a word count, but I'm sure it does not capture all of the discussion that happened there. Including the fact that there are amenities that were not included because the residents in attendance after the initial talks about what should the ideas be of amenities they had to vote on with a number of chips like what Things would you really like to see there and you only have so many chips to vote on and so many types of amenities to vote on. So there are things that were not included because even though everybody had talked about them, they didn't get as many votes as the other items.
You know, being there and seeing the public process. I am very proud of the work that our staff did and very appreciative of the many community members who came out over the course of the workshops to make this happen. And again you can only capture so much in application no matter how good of a writer Mr. Hummel is for our grants. So with that, I just want to thank again staff and community members and the Parks and Recreation Community Service Commission past and present for their work on this as well as Friends of Campus Park who spoke this evening as well. And have certainly the initiative and the desire to have a very pivotal role in Campus Park's success in the future as well.
And when the time comes, Mayor, I'm sure there may be other council members who wish to speak. But when the time comes, I am willing to make a motion on the recommended action. Thank you.
Thank you, Mayor Pro Tem. Any questions or comments by staff? I'm sorry, any Council Member? Council Member Starr, go ahead.
I'm in favor of this. I guess I'm trying to take in the criticism that we don't maintain our existing parks very well so I'm wondering Do we have any sort of thoughts as far as what it will cost to maintain the new park and where we might fund that?
So I believe the staff report. Yeah, so on page 198 of the agenda package is the information that you're seeking Council Member Starr We anticipate an additional operating maintenance cost of about a half million dollars for the new elements that would be part of Campus Park. Thank you, I see that now. Thank you. And that will be part of our operating budget that we utilize today.
I guess what I'm struggling with is I do know there's quite a few parks that are not as well maintained as they ought to be and I think it's great we're building parks. I just want to make sure we do a better job of maintaining them afterwards, so I'm not sure what we can do as a council to assist with that but that's something I think the public desires and I hope we can meet those needs in the future.
So one thing I will say, the specific part that was mentioned Wilson Park there is actually a couple of capital projects in the Capital Project Program about Wilson Park so those are getting funds associated with tenant improvements The playground I think was replaced at Wilson Park. So, I'm not sure why they're identifying Wilson Park because there's a lot of existing recently done and future capital projects going to be done at Wilson Park and then the other comment I think is restrooms and I will say that there are some... There's a lot of parks in the city of Oxnard that are neighborhood parks that shouldn't have restrooms for a variety of purposes and there's places, parks in Oxnard Unfortunately, sometimes we only keep them open for certain activities and events because of the unwanted activities and events that may occur with those.
We do clean the restrooms I believe it's twice a day once in the morning once in the afternoon or evening before they get closed. Parks maintenance is daily if not weekly and some services whether that's trash pickup whether that's mowing I think with the passage of Measure E, there has been a big change in terms of the types of services that were occurring at parks. And I wasn't here before but I hear the stories about how tall the weeds were at parks and after Measure E the ability to fund those services on a more routine basis is pretty evident. I think if you're truly honest with yourself and look back five years ago versus what you see today in parks it's sort of night and
day. Part of the challenge, and you've mentioned this to us before The vandalism that happens, whether it's by homeless people or who knows. It really makes it difficult to have nice things in the city when people are so willing to destroy them and it's very sad that we face that as a community today.
And we are trying to address that with the types of restrooms that we choose, whether that's the XLU and I think was brought up. I think Ms. Whitecomb brought up last week different types of restrooms that may be a little more vandal resistant. I don't think there's anything that's bulletproof and sometimes people just do it just because they want to do it rather than for other reasons they just wanna be bad actors
Mr. Warren, do you have a comment? Yes,
if I can jump in. Just a couple of comments to make some clarifications. So Friends of the Campus Park, they were one of the first groups to come in to see me when I got here. I don't know if they remember. They laid out very elaborate plans for Campus Park. I remember looking at it and chuckling because they had like 68 amenities, not enough acres But they explained it to me and I don't know if Ms. Whitcomb, you remember this but you're the first person to tell me about how long it had been there in vacant and that how you'd hoped that your kids would get a chance to enjoy it but they had already by the time you met with me they were already young adults.
But I do recall their passion and commitment to this space and I did make a commitment again I don''t know if y'all remember I did make a commitment at the ideation for the park and the design, and working with the landscape architects. And I think you've been through with them the entire process. With the question about...I think it was in Mr. Stein's comments about why did it take so long? Why did we not...? I don't know if he exactly said, why didn't we spend other money?
In, I think it was 2018 the voters of California approved what turned out to be Prop 68 which is a, I think it was a $4 billion bucket for a handful of items but local parks was one of the major categories. So whenever there are state grants available that where we're only competing with 482 other Cities unlike foundation grants where we would be competing also with the private sector We always pursue these funds first Because it's available. We'd be it'd be foolish not to So that's part of that process itself doesn't move as fast as everybody wants and then On the maintenance question we talked about this or I talked about this a little bit last Thursday with regard to Even when we rehab or build new things, we do have a problem with keeping it maintained.
And I just want to reiterate maintenance and the upkeeping of our public spaces is not a one-way street. It just can't continue to be like that. So I know one of the things we talked about, though I spoke with Campus Spark, friends of Campus Spark is for this park they would be the first this universal concept called Leave No Trace. And they've made a commitment to work on that with the community, and that's a very basic principle.
Don't leave anything that you brought into the park. Don't leave it. Take it with you. So...and I believe that they are committed to all of these ideals and that it will be successful. So thank you.
3:36 – 3:438 turns
Any other questions or comments? Council Member Perlon, go
ahead. I appreciate the speakers. This is a good example of marshalling your forces when you came in for your speakers but I would really like to thank Mr. Fernandez. You gave credit to the people in the past, past councils, past staff has been a long credit there's a lot of people that were involved in this nothing happens overnight The young lady mentioning, I think she's the last graduating class of Oxnard High School.
I remember going to Oxnard High School. I didn't go to that school but I remember going there for football games. They were the only lighted stadium around and I remember going there when they had the pool that they allowed the public to swim in swimming pool. It's also something that has come since they decided to knock the school down partially because of the airport Everything the airport is still there, and there are certain things that we can't do But this is a big movement forward mayor pro tem has made Suggestion that he'd make a motion. I would definitely second that but this is a big step for the city of Oxnard I remember when this property first came up for sale There was a big push because one of the property owner one of the one of the operations that wanted to buy it wanted to turn it into a cemetery and That's when the city got really involved And this is quite a while ago, but I do recall that in history matters.
This should be something of real showcase. That's all I got. But if the mayor is going to make an emotional statement?
Yeah. You know, I'm excited. I remember certainly playing football there, talking about soccer. I recall when I was the co-director of the Police Activities League scheduling teams to play at Campus Park Having a real deep conversation with Mayor Holden whose kids played in the soccer program that I put together. And actually, I drew out for him what I would envision Campus Park to look like.
Parks are vital for communities. They create an identity for neighborhoods. They're free accessible spaces for our young people, for families to enjoy and they have tremendous environmental benefits I've repeated here that I'm a staunch supporter of beautifying our city, and I think a park does just that. So I am too very supportive of it. I'm so glad that Veronica Yu, Ms. Wycombe, Miguel and Aurelio, many others participated to inform the decision that we will make up here because that's what municipal government should be is I think we should reach out and I'm ready to move this item forward when that comes.
Go ahead. I just want to make some comments. Thank you all so much for the hard work to align everything. I remember my office was at the old Dockstown High School with Future Leaders of America, a local nonprofit and our restrooms were far from the best but I remember Mayor Tim Flynn with plans of an amphitheater and what do y'all think? There's a lot of community input. I'm talking 2012 or so Proposal didn't have the funding it needed. It didn't have We had all these great ideas and possibilities, but it did not at the time Have the ability to launch so I just pulled up an article about from the VC star of November 2013 When the council then was trying to see if they could bring a part to life So the fact that we have this alignment the possible funding the community input makes me very very excited and grateful to folks who have Stuck with us for such a long time and you know this is our community, and I'm just so proud to see what the next chapter will be so.
I know there's a motion potentially in a second but I think I'm ready for the vote. I just wanted to mention that.
Yes, go ahead guess my
brother comment. The Santa Clara River Levy 3 was along drawn out thing and it was a tremendous lesson for me living close to that area. Just how important people are that can get grant funding? It's been identified tonight, Mr. Hummel is really good and I thank him very much. I thank people for bringing his name up and sharing that. That is something that we need to make sure that we either get him an apprentice or we get some of the people like him to help our city but the other part is today I had an opportunity to walk around the River Park Lakes and Mayor City Manager's comment as well stated.
The city cannot pick up all the trash It's up to the people. I have a very close friend that went to Cal State Northridge recreation major, and I remember at the time People wore t-shirts truck it in truck it out And they had a motto if you truck it in your truck it out basically if you carry the trash in You can carry it out because there's nothing better than to see a family of Whatever and wherever they are.
And they're giving the kids goodies that are in bags, and as they finish them, the bags are left behind, and it's like a trail. It's not that hard to pick it up. You truck it in, you truck it out. And I support this totally. Thank you Mr. Hummel for the work, and the city for giving him the opportunity to do that work.
I just want to make one final comment seeing Mr. Eric Andrus here, and I know how important it is for you Mr Andrus Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just create the identity for the neighborhood. So we should be very mindful of just maintaining it and maintaining good condition, picking up after ourselves but also enhancing our historic district because it's all here very centralized.
And that's a challenge for our community to make sure that we protect our green spaces and take care of it so it always looks well. And then we'll complement very well what the endeavors are from Mr. Andrews through now your nonprofit to really enhance our historic district and be a partner with many of us. I move the recommended item is...
Mayor and council members, we have two requests to speak virtually. I don't know if you want to take the call. Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now. Virtual speaker, if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
3:43 – 3:4914 turns
Hi this is Eduardo again I just want to say congratulations to staff and everybody working on this campus park actually was in a city council meeting when it first went through i think back in 2020. I know that's been a process and my only question was is that um I want to say about 33 million, I think from Prop 68. I think we got some money out of that and I was just wondering why we never got at least allocation with grass and at least kind of prepared for you know just future engagements like soccer events and you know just utilize the park instead of having it sit there empty without any action or infrastructure being put into it. Sorry about that guys. So anyway I was just wondering Just you know, it's good to see that we're moving along in the downtown area.
We cleaned up the mess now that we've actually got the department pulled away from our home situation so I think the community of Downtown Oxnard really deserves this park and obviously all the families around it and so I think personally it'd be a good benefit. Excuse me with actually bad reception here guys but thank you appreciate it
Thank you, Eduardo.
We'll move to the next online caller.
Virtual speaker if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Thank you this is Manuel Herrera creator of Citizens for Better Oxnard although I'm calling on behalf of myself just basically want to say I'm in full support of this project it's long long overdue And it's something that people want and it's something that people need. That area has been dormant for quite some time, so this would definitely help. So I'm in full support. I'm sure the council as a whole will make the right decision. And I don't know if it's just me but it seems like anytime there's a positive project that the people want and that it's going to benefit the people.
You always have the Star Clan calling in, speaking up against it. I don't know if it's because of their hatred for staff. I mean they're always especially Andres is always putting down staff and we know his history on always criticizing them even cussing them out But if he's going to do these little videos, he should at least get his facts straight before presenting the videos.
So but they always seem to be against any project that will benefit the people of Oxnard like Campus Park, like the Aquatic Center. These are things people want, these are things people deserve and the Stark Clan is always against them Especially the eighth council member, Alicia Purcell. So again all for this I trust the City Council will make the right decision and that's those are my comments Mr. Mayor.
Thank you Mr. Herrera. Does that conclude the speakers Madam Clerk?
Mayor and council members, yes. That concludes our speakers in person and virtually for this item.
Thank you. I move the recommendation. I think Councilwoman Rodriguez is in your district and you seconded it. Thank you. If there's no further comments or deliberation call for the vote Madam
Roll-call vote Passed 7–0 move the recommendation. I think Councilwoman Rodriguez is in your district and you seconded it. Thank you. If there's no further comments o
Show transcript
And this motion carries 7-0, thank you. Thank you. Okay
Angela, thank you
Veronica.
The next item on the agenda is Item N2. This one from the Public Works Department subject Channels Harbor Water Quality Implementation Plan Phase 1 Approval. The recommendation that the City Council direct staff to proceed with Phase 1 activities of the selected non-structural Structural and receiving water strategies is outlined in table 2. In this staff report, the Public Works and Transportation Committee approved this item 3-0 back on April 14th, 2026 to approve the staff recommendation with the direction of adding a pumping project to table 2 under the receiving water category and to forward For council approval.
Michael Wolf, Director of Public Works is here to answer any questions we may have with staff. Any questions for staff on Mr. Wolfe before we open it up for public comment? No specific? Okay. Madam Clerk are there any public speakers on this
item? Mayor and Council Members, We do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for this item. Thank you. Wonderful.
If there's no questions or comments, what's the pleasure of council on this item? Thank you. Call for the vote, Madam Clerk.
Roll-call vote Passed 4–0 · 3 under review
Show transcript
3:49 – 3:5413 turns
And this motion carries six to zero. Thank you.
Thank you, Lulie.
The next item on the agenda is Item N3 from the Housing Department subject home ARP loan agreement with I'm sorry for the Cypress Place at Garden City 2 apartments. It's a 59 unit affordable rental project that's located at 5482 Cypress Road in South Oxnard. The recommendation is that the City Council adopt a resolution approving and authorizing the city manager to execute 1,200,000 home ARP loan agreement and any and all related documents thereto with Cypress Place at Garden City 2. It will be for the development of a 59 affordable unit and one managers' unit rental housing project located at 5482 Cypress Road And known as the Cypress Place at Garden City to Apartments.
This item did not originate in committee and Brenda Lopez, our housing director is here to answer any questions we may have of staff. Any questions of Ms. Lopez before we open it up for public comment? Okay. Madam Clerk are there any speakers on this item? I see Mr. Stein's preparing his
speaker card. Yes, we have one speaker, Larry Stein. Go ahead Mr. Stein.
Good evening City Council Members, Mr. Mayor and the general public. There's something called a Water Neutrality Policy. It was approved I think in 2018 or thereabouts. So supposedly any new housing that comes up is supposed to be water neutral. So where is the water coming from for this project because we have not built the wells Thank you very much.
We have a motion by Councilwoman Perez and a second by Councilmember Peralo. Offer the vote, Madam Clerk.
Roll-call vote 3–0 motion by Councilwoman Perez and a second by Councilmember Peralo. Offer the vote, Madam Clerk. Councilwoman Basuah? Yes. Councilmember Pera · 4 under review
Show transcript
And this motion carries 7-0 thank you
Thank you The next item on the agenda is Item N4 Also from the Housing Department, subject entails loan agreements for Aspire Apartments and 87 Unit Affordable Rental Project in Pocket Park located at 536-538 Mita Street here just east of downtown. The recommendation that the City Council one adopt a resolution approving and authorizing the city manager to execute $1,200,000 home AARP loan agreement A $1 million home loan agreement and $689,659 CDBG loan agreement.
And any and all related documents there too with Aspire Apartments LLP for the development of an 87-unit affordable and one manager's unit rental housing project in Pocket Park located at 536 through 538 Meta Street and known as the Aspire Apartments and two Thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. I move to authorize the mayor to execute a first amendment to agreement number 326-00278 with M&S engineers Inc. to increase the not to exceed amount on the contract from $220,000 to $291,000 for labor compliance monitoring services. This item did not originate in committee.
Ms. Lopez is here to answer Madam Clerk, are there any public speakers on this item?
Mayor and council members we do not have any public speakers in person or virtually for this item. Thank you.
I just have one question Miss Lopez regarding the pocket park How do we how do we come to that decision of a pocket park and also are there any security concerns And were police consulting on this This pocket Park implementation
Good evening, Brenda Lopez, Director for the Housing Department. Mayor can you please repeat the first part of the question on the pocket park?
The pocket park or what actually formed the decision to put a pocket park and also if there are security concerns with the pocket Park and if police were consulted on the implementation of the pocket Park
I will probably invite my project manager Elsa Brown up to the podium just to clarify on the pocket park
3:54 – 4:0922 turns
Good evening members of council, Elsa Brown development manager. We do have the developer on the line as well to answer any questions but this project did go through the DAC process and I believe there is a representative from the police department when it received its entitlements. Thank
you. Were we going to call upon the consultant?
There might be a requirement just in terms of the space and the people, just to have some green space. But in general it's a good idea to have a little bit of green space. And I think pocket is because there's not enough land here to have a full-blown park.
Yeah. I'm just concerned about the security and the monitoring and whether that presents a security concern. I am certainly in favor of anything that's green and to enhance our city.
I did want to add to Alex's point that when the park-to-park was acquired, there is a restriction or requirement that a park be developed and maintained by many mansions. So they will be assisting us in full responsibility of maintenance and also monitoring.
OK, perfect. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Lopez. Madam Clerk, are there no public speakers on this item? What's the desire of Council on this item? Thank you, Councilwoman. Is there a second? Madam Clerk, I'll call for the vote.
Roll-call vote Passed 5–0 · 2 under review
Show transcript
And this motion carries 7-0 thank you
Thank you The next item on the agenda is Item N5 from Public Works Subject public project agreement with Toro Enterprises In agreement with Philippine Engineering for Arterial Street resurfacing. Oxnard Boulevard, 5th Street, Saviers Road and Ventura Road. Recommendations that the City Council approve and authorize one, a total of $10,922,971 in project funds for the Arterial Street resurfacing. Oxnard Boulevard, 5st Street, Saviers Road and Ventura Road to the Mayor to execute an agreement with Toro Enterprises In the amount of $9,102,475 for the project and a project contingency amount of $910,248 with total enterprises for a total not-to-exceed value of $10,000,012,723. Three, our project allocation amount of 910,241 for engineering inspection survey construction management and project management And four, the mayor to execute an agreement with Philippine Engineering in the amount of $741,634 for a term of one year from May 5th, 2026 through May 4th, 2027 for professional construction management services.
This item did not originate in committee as this is a capital improvement project specifically listed in the city's Capital Improvement Program budget which was previously approved by City Council Michael Wolfe, Public Works Director is here to answer any questions Councilmembers may have for him. Do any Councilmembers have any questions? If not we'll open it up for public comment and we'll start with you Mr. Stein.
Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the City Council, staff, public in the audience and public watching. This is a good project for arterial roads. We're taking care of several roads. The question I ask is if there's money for arterial Councillor Hutchison. And we're going to carry roads that have been attached maybe every four or five years. But neighbourhood streets, there's no money for our neighbourhood streets because the money has been spent elsewhere. We're not taking care of the neighbourhoods even though the neighbourhoods are paying for the taxes, they're paying the gasoline fees and our roads for our neighbourhoods are not being fixed.
One particular council member made an issue of neighbourhood streets not being repaired several years ago. And again, the fact that our neighbourhood streets Despite complaints from the neighbors, the number one complaint for the servant of our Survey conducted, survey number two was the streets. Our neighbourhood streets are not being maintained but we're managing to maintain our major arterial roads but neighbourhood streets should come along the lines. We're not budgeting on an annual basis for our neighbourhood streets sufficiently to take care of our neighbourhoods. We can always find money for Rose, we can always find money for Gonzales, we can always find money for Ventura Road but we can't seem to find money for our neighbourhood streets and take care of our neighbourhoods Thank you much for your time
Thank you, Mr. Stein. Any other questions or comments? I move the...
Mayor? Yes. I'm sorry, Mayor Pro Tem Theron would like to speak. I am sorry. Go ahead, Mayor Pro Tem.
Thank you Mayor, thank you Madam Clerk. Just a quick thing for the Public Works Director. Can we just speak briefly to the concept of preventative maintenance when it comes to our pavement and our PCI? And that's my only question, thank you.
Good evening again Mayor, Council Members Michael Wolff, Director of Public Works. The question is One of the process that we use for roads. So, we do have a payment condition index that we identify. We do inspections every year on a cycle of every third year. Identify payment condition index zero out of 100. A hundred being best, zero being worst and so when we look at streets regardless of the classification arterial collector residential alley We typically look at the payment condition index as a starting point. It's a good rule of thumb, kind of tells us where we're at in the life cycle of that street and we use that to, in addition to visual inspection, And so the preventative maintenance may be crack sealing or slurry seal or thin layer Some level of chip seal or cape seal.
Those are the maintenance, thin layer of maintenance may be the applicable solution for that street and then other streets that may have degraded to a point where those aren't gonna work. Those types of preventative maintenance activities aren't gonna work so now we're into the corrective maintenance activities which may be an inch or two or two-inch overlay or inch and a half overlay We're putting more asphalt on top, or in the case of I think it was Doris.
Maybe two years ago we had to completely remove the entirety of the structural segment of the asphalt and replace it with base or sub base space first course and wearing course so We take a look at streets based on their pavement condition index, we take a look at streets based on our field investigations and we identify either corrective or preventative maintenance.
Preventative maintenance is well I'll put it this way corrective maintenance is usually six to ten times more expensive than preventative maintenance. The city engineer says this all the time to me which is keep good streets good and so part of our Sort of mantra going forward for all of our projects, whether it's arterial, residential or alleys is to do some level of preventative maintenance.
Right now we're trying to do about 25% of it from a dollar standpoint, preventative and the rest of it corrective. You know that the ideal world is that we're doing the opposite of that where we're doing 75% preventative and 25% corrective. That's when you get there when you get the PCIs up in the upper 70s You know, in the 80s. So I think that answers the question that Mayor Pro Tem.
It does thank you Mr. Wolf and I know I said that was my only question one last quick thing regarding the network that's referenced there do we have some standard protocols or notification strategies will be using for residents nearest to the work when we have to do nighttime construction?
We do. So we have standard notifications that are required to go out a certain number of days in advance, whether that's through our team, the construction manager that we're hiring or the contractor that is in this it's written in our specifications in terms of when they're supposed to be notifying. We also typically put up changeable message signs in advance so that we can identify certain types of traffic control issues and sometimes we use those to identify night work as well.
a protocol for those types of activities. It also depends on whether or not we're talking about residential neighborhoods versus commercial neighborhoods. We try not to do night work as much as possible in residential neighborhoods, but sometimes we have to just because of the volume of traffic that occurs on some of these streets where just from a safety standpoint and the amount of work that we can get done at night far exceeds short-term impact of maybe some nighttime work.
I do want to just touch a little bit, hopefully that answers your question but I want to touch a little bit about the comments that were made. So if you look actually in our capital improvement program every year for the last four years since I've been here we put money into residential streets so I'm not sure if the public speaker just hasn't looked at the capital improvement program or chooses to ignore it In the last 12 months, we actually awarded two separate paving contracts for residential streets. One in Colonia and actually one I believe in the Public Speaker's neighborhood.
So we actually construct, or we have capital projects for arterials, residential and alleys separate because the types of methodologies that we use for repairs are sometimes different for those types of streets. And so from a bidding standpoint, from an economies-of-scale standpoint it's better typically for us to lump them into those classifications rather than do them together So the idea that somehow we only spend money on arterial streets is incorrect, is a false assumption. The idea that we maintain arterial streets every three or four or five years, whatever the frequency is, that's also an incorrect assumption and so I think that responds to those comments.
Thank you, I'm in support of this item For me, I just want to beautify this city and repair our streets. Add to the, I mean they don't just, you know, streets just don't move cars but they add to the identity of our city. They're great engines to boost our business community here that entices those to open up businesses, the livability factor And they just beautifully complement, beautiful streets compliment our green spaces. This shows our community pride of our city so I'm just thrilled to push this item forward.
Any other? Do you have a question or anything or comment? I
would just like to move the recommended action.
Wonderful. Or bring it to us
where you can second
that.
I'm sorry Mayor and Council Members we have a virtual speaker if you want to take that. Yeah absolutely. Thank you. Virtual speaker, if you can press star six to unmute and you have three minutes starting now.
Good evening Council. Hey, a question here I'm not sure we can answer my question does anybody really when you guys do these free repairs? I mean coming from infrastructure experience and having somebody that works for public works here at the county. Does any of our council members really check on the worker in their streets and really drive on their streets and see if um let's see what are there i guess what are the repairs needed? I only speak I mean I'm not trying to side with uh Stein here but at the end there is communities that haven't been touched for 20 years For example, district here was at Oxnard Shores. Right there on the street is not Harvard Boulevard but that street alongside the shore where all these houses are at normally they'll have during sandstorms still have that area covered with sand if there's flood or let's say high sea rise they'll have to see water kind of overflow into the streets so I mean You know, these are community members that are actually pretty involved in our City Council meetings.
Water quality and at the end you know these they feel pretty neglected from what I have my understanding on the last City Council meeting and then also you know the Sierra Park neighborhood you know i'm not sure if you guys pick and choose which street to repair or whatnot but it looks like a checkered box there's some streets that are fixed some streets that are not and so you know just it's always good to kind of just you know have council members drive down their Thank you Eduardo. Does that conclude our public speakers Madam Clerk?
4:09 – 4:1715 turns
Mayor and Council members, yes that concludes our speakers in person and virtually.
So at this point can I make a motion to the recommended action?
Second that but I'd like to make a comment as a council member. I do drive around the city of Oxnard There are streets that do need work, but I can tell you I don't drive around and check the work that Mr.. Wolf or the public works is doing Specifically when I come across and see them doing work throughout the city of Oxnard. I'm pretty impressed I'm impressed with the contractors that we hire And I'm impressed with the work that the public works staff does You mentioned specifically oxen our chores That is in my district, and there are some things in Oxnard Shores. And when 311 calls get made they are taken care of I can speak directly to that I Can also speak directly to specifically this is probably something a council member should not say about our district that he lives in And represents, we have some very active neighborhood councils that stand up and call in when things are going on.
Others do not. And the prioritization of the work that the city of Oxnard is doing with the funds that they have is impressive to me.
That's just my comments. Thank you. I'll just share, as soon as I drive around this city, I do stop Thank you, Mr. Chair. And just let them know that I'm personally appreciative. And same thing for our streets, I think our streets and our city is looking just that much better. I can tell you from driving around patrolling this city for 30 some years that I'm really delighted to see the way our city is presenting.
So Madam Clerk we have a first and a second? Correct.
Roll-call vote Passed 4–0 · 3 under review
Show transcript
and this motion carries 7 to 0 thank you.
Thank you at this time I'd like to make a motion to go past 10 o'clock. Second. Thank You Councilmember Perallo
Councilwoman Basuah? Yes. Councilmember Par- excuse me, Councilmember Peralta? Yes. Councilwoman Bettis? Yes Councilwoman Rodriguez? Aye. Council Member Starr? Yes Mayor Pro Tem Teran? Mayor McArthur?
Yes
And this motion to extend past 10 carries 7-0 thank you
We'll move to the next item on the agenda. This is Item N6 from the Public Works Department, subject public project agreement with American Nashville South Inc for Advanced Alley Maintenance Program Phase 1. The recommendation to the City Council approve and authorize one a total of $2,848,460 in project funds for the Advanced Alley Maintenance Program Phase 1 project This is an amendment to the For a total not to exceed value of $2,000,611.088 for the project.
Three, a project allocation amount of $237,372 for engineering inspections serving project management for the project and four, a project budget appropriation of $862,631 from Measure O Fund 104 available fund balance to the Advanced Alley Maintenance Project as well as the corresponding capital outlay fund Appropriation increase in the same amounts. This item did not originate a committee as this is a capital improvement project specifically listed in the city's Capital Improvement Program budget, which was previously approved by City Council.
Michael Wolf Public Works Director is here to answer any questions council may have of him. There are no clarifying questions. We'll start with public comment. Mr. Larry Stein coming up sir? Thank you.
Good evening, Mr. Mayor, good evening members of City Council, staff, public in the audience and public at large. One of the key factors you may want to notice in here is using measure all money. So what's going to happen three years from now if there's no measure all money? Where is the money going to come from to fix alleyways? Fixing an alleyway funding does not come from the gasoline tax.
It has to come from the general fund or donations. So how many alleyways are in great shape now? I know Lemonwood there, I don't recall seeing any alleys in great shape. Lemonwood's supposed to receive some road repairs on some of the streets in Lemonwood. I submitted a public record request about two years ago to see if certain streets had been fixed and they haven't done. There are no records!
When was the last time street improvements were made on certain streets in Lemonwood? I didn't ask for all the streets, I picked out four streets randomly. There's no record going back 20 years as to when these certain streets in Lemonwood were fixed or repaired and how many other neighborhoods are there? How many other neighborhoods have alleyways have not been touched?
We know that Wilson neighborhood has certain alleyways been fixed. We know what other neighborhoods are falling apart We've heard from staff saying that we look at these things periodically. Well, how are these alleyways in such bad shape if you look at them and fix them periodically? They don't get fixed! The citizens have not had the money or desire apparently to fix alleyways when they say they're going to fix them.
Promises are made to the citizens of Oxnard when we pay our taxes You're paying sales tax or paying local licensing fees, all sorts of taxes. Some of these monies are designed specifically for streets. In other cases they're general funds so we need to have a defined program by City Council for long-term projects that go beyond your two year terms And these commitments should be held by other city councils, because you got elected. Some of you got elected a year ago. Some of you have been elected for several years.
But to always make commitments to the public but when you leave office who follows up on those commitments? Staff changes their minds, City Council changes their minds. Staff turns over, City Council turns over. The commitments should stay constant. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you. Do
we have an online caller trying to
join? Mayor and council members, that concludes our speakers in person and virtually. Thank you. Any questions or comments? Go
ahead. I move the recommended action if there's no one else wants to speak.
Thank you. Is there a second?
Roll-call vote Passed 4–0 move the recommended action if there's no one else wants to speak. Thank you. Is there a second? Councilwoman Rodriguez? Aye. · 3 under review
Show transcript
4:17 – 4:2212 turns
and this motion carries 7 to 0, thank you.
Thank you we'll move to item n7 From the Public Works Department, subject agreement with Green Coast Landscape for grid pruning services. Recommendation that the City Council approve and authorize the mayor to execute an agreement with Green Coast Landscapes for an initial term of one year from May 20th, 2026 through May 19th, 2027 with an option for four consecutive one-year extensions ending May 19, 2031 in a total not to exceed amount of $6 million for grid pruning services.
The council meeting agenda for May 5th, 2026 will be posted prior to the April 28th, 2026 public works and transportation committee meeting therefore as of the drafting of the staff report, the committee outcome has not yet been determined. Appropriate Works Director Michael Wolfe is here to answer questions Council Members may have of him. And go ahead Mr. Wolfe we can clarify that Lorenzo
Yeah, just a promise to be the last one of our items tonight. I would want to make mention that we did post this before the committee met on this item and recommended it before to Council 3-0. So I wanted to make that mention tonight.
Thank you. Any questions or clarifying questions for Director Wolf? If not, I'll open up for public comment. Are there any public speakers on this item?
Mayor and council members, we do not have any requests to speak on this item in person or virtually. Thank you.
Thank you. I was just delighted when it came before the committee. As you know, I want to continue to see the city get more and more beautiful for just to entice businesses, home ownership, and just make our city vibrant and appealing. And I think this community all of us deserve a beautiful city so I love the way our city meetings are looking. I think Green Coast is doing a fantastic job. What's the desire of council members on this particular item?
I'll second.
Roll-call vote Passed 7–0
Show transcript
And this motion carries seven to zero thank you
Thank you. The next item on the agenda is Item N8. This is from the Community Development Department, subject Joint Use Agreement with Southern California Edison and Fifth Harbor Owner LLC. The recommendation that the City Council approve and authorize a mayor to execute the joint use agreement with Southern California Edison and Fifth Harbor Owner denoted as JUA 203-904-272 The joint user grant pertains to the relocation of the existing Southern California Edison transmission lines and related facilities from their existing location over a portion of the North Shore project, to the easterly line of Harbor Boulevard.
And adjacent to the project and extending to the southeast corner of Harbor Boulevard in West 5th Street. This item did not originate at committee. Jeff Pingille, Community Development Director is here Council members may have staff on this item. Madam Clerk, do we have any public speakers on this item?
Mayor and council members, we do not have any requests to speak on this item in person or virtually. Thank you. Thank you. Council Member Stahl, go ahead sir.
Yeah I do have a question. So I'm hearing that undergrounding power lines with SCE has been delayed in many cases. In some cases they're making, they're telling folks They can't underground for like seven, 10 years because they're so busy with the fire prone areas trying to protect those. And my concern would be how do we... I guess that first question is do we anticipate it's gonna be that long here as well?
And what do we do to make sure that the undergrounding takes place and not halt the project from going forward? Because I don't wanna see a project Delayed for years just because Southern California can't get it its act together or they have higher priorities So
the developer will be able to answer more specific question about the start time But it is my understanding that we well, we've had long-term negotiations with Southern California Edison They have agreed two terms which are laid out in the staff report and the work is beginning now as we speak so It will happen. It will not delay the project And if you want more information, the developer is ready to give a presentation or we can just answer any other questions you may have.
4:22 – 4:256 turns
Thank you. Any other questions or comments? Go ahead Council Member Perlman.
I had the opportunity to meet with city attorney's office and the three individuals here was very impressed. I think one thing that does not real clear in the staff report, and I said that I would ask this question you mentioned that you're going to pay for a bond. You're going to include a bond if there's an issue. Can you just explain how that is going to be handled so that we know?
We don't have a situation where somebody makes a promise and then it doesn't fall how he explained that you were That's the only question I have.
Well, I'm happy to talk about what the agreement requires. So the agreement requires that the developer pays for the cost of the undergrounding so they're going to be paying SCE. SCE will underground the lines along Harbor Boulevard between the Edison Canal and 5th Street and then during the following 10 years in the very unlikely event the city requests that the underground lines be moved The city is responsible for that cost, but the developer is posting either a bond or a lot of credit for $1.2 million to pay for that cost. So under no circumstances will the city be out-of-pocket and then after the 10 year period any relocation will be the obligation of SCE pursuant to our franchise agreement. Okay, that clarifies thank you.
That's all I got. Any other questions or comments? If not what's the pleasure of council? Thank you. We have a second from Council Member Peralo. There are no speakers on this item, Madam Clerk call for the
Roll-call vote Passed 7–0
Show transcript
And this motion carries 7-0 thank you
Thank you. And before we move to adjourning this meeting, I know at the last week's council meeting, Mr. Wynne, I asked for a report on Measure O to be brought to the full council. But hearing Mr. Stein, I'm wondering if we can't get a full report back in addition to what I asked for last week but just on our options and on our alternatives when Measure O sunsets Including up to putting Measure O back on the ballot to give our community a say in what happens when Measure O sunsets, including keeping Measure O that is the will of the public.
If we can get a full report on those alternatives. There being no further business on the agenda and without objection, we are adjourned. Thank you everyone.